p53 accumulates but is functionally impaired when DNA synthesis is blocked

Growth arrest in G1 protects against oxygen-induced DNA damage and cell death

Although oxygen is required for normal aerobic respiration, hyperoxia (95% O(2)/5% CO(2)) damages DNA, inhibits proliferation in G1, S and G2 phases of the cell cycle, and induces necrosis. The current study examines whether growth arrest in G1 protects pulmonary epithelial cells from oxidative DNA damage and cell death. Mv1Lu pulmonary adenocarcinoma cells were chosen for studies because hyperoxia inhibits their proliferation in S and G2 phase, while they can be induced to arrest in G1 by altering culture conditions. Hyperoxia inhibited proliferation, increased intracellular redox, and rapidly reduced clonogenic survival. In contrast, Mv1Lu cells treated with transforming growth factor (TGF)-beta1, deprived of serum or grown to confluency, arrested and remained predominantly in G1 even during exposure. Growth arrest in G1 significantly enhanced clonogenic survival by 10-50-fold. Enhanced survival was not due to reduction in the intracellular redox-state of the cells, but instead was associated with reduced DNA strand breaks and p53 expression. Our findings suggest that the protective effects of G1 is mediated not simply by a reduction in intracellular ROS, but rather through an enhanced ability to limit or rapidly recognize and repair damaged DNA.

Wild-type p53 inhibits replication-associated homologous recombination

In mammalian cells homologous recombination is stimulated, when the replication fork stalls at DNA breaks or unrepaired lesions. The tumor suppressor p53 downregulates homologous recombination independently of its transcriptional transactivation function and has been linked to enzymes of DNA recombination and replication. To study recombination with respect to replication, we utilized a SV40 virus based assay, to follow the synchronous events after primate cell infection. gamma-ray treatment at different times after viral entry unveiled an increase of interchromosomal exchange frequencies, when the damage was introduced during DNA synthesis. Elevated recombination frequencies were fully suppressed by p53. With respect to the downregulation of spontaneous recombination, we noticed a requirement for active p53 molecules, when replication started. After a transient treatment with replication inhibitors, we observed inhibition of the drug induced recombination by p53, particularly for the elongation inhibitor aphidicolin. Consequently, we propose that p53 is a surveillance factor of homologous recombination at replication forks, when they stall as a consequence of endogenous or of exogenously introduced damage.

A novel p53 mutational hotspot in skin tumors from UV-irradiated Xpc mutant mice alters transactivation functions

A mutation in codon 122 of the mouse p53 gene resulting in a T to L amino acid substitution (T122-->L) is frequently associated with skin cancer in UV-irradiated mice that are both homozygous mutant for the nucleotide excision repair (NER) gene Xpc (Xpc(-/-)) and hemizygous mutant for the p53 gene. We investigated the functional consequences of the mouse T122-->L mutation when expressed either in mammalian cells or in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Similar to a non-functional allele, high expression of the T122-->L allele in p53(-/-) mouse embryo fibroblasts and human Saos-2 cells failed to suppress growth. However, the T122-->L mutant p53 showed wild-type transactivation levels with Bax and MDM2 promoters when expressed in either cell type and retained transactivation of the p21 and the c-Fos promoters in one cell line. Using a recently developed rheostatable p53 induction system in yeast we assessed the T122-->L transactivation capacity at low levels of protein expression using 12 different p53 response elements (REs). Compared to wild-type p53 the T122-->L protein manifested an unusual transactivation pattern comprising reduced and enhanced activity with specific REs. The high incidence of the T122-->L mutant allele in the Xpc(-/-) background suggests that both genetic and epigenetic conditions may facilitate the emergence of particular functional p53 mutations. Furthermore, the approach that we have taken also provides for the dissection of functions that may be retained in many p53 tumor alleles.

Association of p53 and MSH2 with recombinative repair complexes during S phase

Our previous recombination and biochemical analyses have led to the hypothesis that the tumor suppressor p53 monitors homologous recombination, a function which was previously attributed to the mismatch repair protein MSH2. Here, we show that a certain fraction of p53 is concentrated within discrete nuclear foci of cells synchronized in G1 phase, a pattern which becomes even more pronounced in S phase, especially after gamma-ray treatment. p53 foci show some colocalization with MSH2 within distinct foci during G1 phase, while dots formed by BRCA1 display an independent localization pattern. In S phase nuclei, p53 foci almost completely colocalize with MSH2 foci and associate with the recombination surveillance factor BRCA1 in irradiated S phase cells. These p53 and MSH2 foci also show significant overlaps with foci of the recombination enzymes Rad50 and Rad51, which for the first time unveiled recombination-related functions of p53 in replicating cells. During S phase, p53 and MSH2 are maximally active in binding to early recombination intermediates, and coexist within the same nuclear DNA-protein complexes. Our data suggest that p53 is linked similarly to homologous recombination as MSH2 and provide further evidence for the new concept of a dual role of p53 in the regulation of growth and repair.

Prolonged arrest of mammalian cells at the G1/S boundary results in permanent S phase stasis

Mammalian cells in culture normally enter a state of quiescence during G1 following suppression of cell cycle progression by senescence, contact inhibition or terminal differentiation signals. We find that mammalian fibroblasts enter cell cycle stasis at the onset of S phase upon release from prolonged arrest with the inhibitors of DNA replication, hydroxyurea or aphidicolin. During arrest typical S phase markers remain present, and G0/G1 inhibitory signals such as p21WAF1 and p27 are absent. Cell cycle stasis occurs in T-antigen transformed cells, indicating that p53 and pRB inhibitory circuits are not involved. While no DNA replication is evident in arrested cells, nuclei isolated from these cells retain measurable competence for in vitro replication. MCM proteins are required to license replication origins, and are put in place in nuclei in G1 and excluded from chromatin by the end of replication to prevent rereplication of the genome. Strikingly, MCM proteins are strongly depleted from chromatin during prolonged S phase arrest,and their loss may underlie the observed cell cycle arrest. S phase stasis may thus be a `trap' in which cells otherwise competent for S phase have lost a key component required for replication and thus can neither go forward nor retreat to G1 status.

mtCLIC/CLIC4, an organellular chloride channel protein, is increased by DNA damage and participates in the apoptotic response to p53

mtCLIC/CLIC4 (referred to here as mtCLIC) is a p53- and tumor necrosis factor alpha-regulated cytoplasmic and mitochondrial protein that belongs to the CLIC family of intracellular chloride channels. mtCLIC associates with the inner mitochondrial membrane. Dual regulation of mtCLIC by two stress response pathways suggested that this chloride channel protein might contribute to the cellular response to cytotoxic stimuli. DNA damage or overexpression of p53 upregulates mtCLIC and induces apoptosis. Overexpression of mtCLIC by transient transfection reduces mitochondrial membrane potential, releases cytochrome c into the cytoplasm, activates caspases, and induces apoptosis. mtCLIC is additive with Bax in inducing apoptosis without a physical association of the two proteins. Antisense mtCLIC prevents the increase in mtCLIC levels and reduces apoptosis induced by p53 but not apoptosis induced by Bax, suggesting that the two proapoptotic proteins function through independent pathways. Our studies indicate that mtCLIC, like Bax, Noxa, p53AIP1, and PUMA, participates in a stress-induced death pathway converging on mitochondria and should be considered a target for cancer therapy through genetic or pharmacologic approaches.

Regulation of apoptosis by p53 in UV-irradiated human epidermis, psoriatic plaques and senescent keratinocytes

The carcinogenic effects of sunlight in human epidermis may be thwarted by either: transient growth arrest and repair of DNA photodamage in keratinocytes (KCs); elimination of KCs with damaged DNA via apoptosis; or by stimulating a senescence switch whereby KCs become irreversibly growth arrested. Using normal human skin organ cultures and living epidermal equivalents, we demonstrate that in the proliferative basal layer, removal of KCs via apoptosis had a rapid onset (beginning within 2 h) following UV-light exposure generating progressively greater numbers of KCs with thymine dimers as the dose of UV-light was increased; involved induction of Apaf-1, activation of caspase-3, and was dependent on p53 activation as addition of a p53 chemical inhibitor blocked the apoptotic response. Suprabasal layer KCs underwent apoptosis at much later time points (>8 h). KCs in the basal layer repaired DNA damage more rapidly than KCs in suprabasal layers. Steady state levels of p53 increased in irradiated cells, and the increase was accompanied by phosphorylation of serine 9 and serine 15, but not serine 6 residues. By contrast, cultured KCs undergoing spontaneous replicative senescence were resistant to UV-induced apoptosis. Senescent KCs constitutively contained low levels of p53, which were neither increased nor phosphorylated or acetylated after UV-exposure and possessed minimal DNA binding activity, indicative of functional inactivation. Furthermore, treatment of senescent KCs with DNA damaging agent adriamycin did not result in activation of latent p53 or apoptosis. When KCs within psoriatic plaques were examined, they resembled senescent KCs in that they expressed p53, which was not phosphorylated or acetylated. Thus, UV-light induces DNA damage in human epidermal KCs triggering p53 activation, and subsequent apoptosis involving distinct cell layers and kinetics. However, the lack of p53 activation as seen in senescent KCs and psoriatic plaques, is associated with a relative resistance of KCs to UV-induced apoptosis. In conclusion, the sensitivity and resistance of KCs to apoptosis depends not only on the location within various layers of epidermis and levels of p53, but may also involve p53 activation via post-translational modifications.

Transcription-coupled and DNA damage-dependent ubiquitination of RNA polymerase II in vitro

Transcription-coupled repair (TCR) is essential for the rapid, preferential removal of DNA damage in active genes. The large subunit of RNA polymerase (Pol) II is ubiquitinated in cells after UV-irradiation or cisplatin treatment, which induces DNA damage preferentially repaired by TCR. Several human mutations, such as Cockayne syndrome complementation groups A and B, are defective in TCR and incapable of Pol II ubiquitination upon DNA damage. Here we demonstrate a correlation between ubiquitination of RNA Pol II and arrest of transcription in vitro. Ubiquitination of Pol II is significantly induced by alpha-amanitin, an amatoxin that blocks Pol II elongation and causes its degradation in cells. Pol II undergoes similar ubiquitination on DNA containing cisplatin adducts that arrest transcription. Stimulation of ubiquitination requires the addition of template DNA and does not occur in the presence of an antibody to the general transcription factor TFIIB, indicating the transcription dependence of the reaction. We propose that components of the reaction recognize elongating Pol II-DNA complexes arrested by alpha-amanitin or cisplatin lesions, triggering ubiquitination.

Involvement of mouse Rev3 in tolerance of endogenous and exogenous DNA damage

The Rev3 gene of Saccharomyces cerevisiae encodes the catalytic subunit of DNA polymerase zeta that is implicated in mutagenic translesion synthesis of damaged DNA. To investigate the function of its mouse homologue, we have generated mouse embryonic stem cells and mice carrying a targeted disruption of Rev3. Although some strain-dependent variation was observed, Rev3(-/-) embryos died around midgestation, displaying retarded growth in the absence of consistent developmental abnormalities. Rev3(-/-) cell lines could not be established, indicating a cell-autonomous requirement of Rev3 for long-term viability. Histochemical analysis of Rev3(-/-) embryos did not reveal aberrant replication or cellular proliferation but demonstrated massive apoptosis in all embryonic lineages. Although increased levels of p53 are detected in Rev3(-/-) embryos, the embryonic phenotype was not rescued by the absence of p53. A significant increase in double-stranded DNA breaks as well as chromatid and chromosome aberrations was observed in cells from Rev3(-/-) embryos. The inner cell mass of cultured Rev3(-/-) blastocysts dies of a delayed apoptotic response after exposure to a low dose of N-acetoxy-2-acetylaminofluorene. These combined data are compatible with a model in which, in the absence of polymerase zeta, double-stranded DNA breaks accumulate at sites of unreplicated DNA damage, eliciting a p53-independent apoptotic response. Together, these data are consistent with involvement of polymerase zeta in translesion synthesis of endogenously and exogenously induced DNA lesions.

Bloom's syndrome protein response to ultraviolet-C radiation and hydroxyurea-mediated DNA synthesis inhibition

Bloom's syndrome (BS) arises through mutations in both copies of the BLM gene that encodes a RecQ 3'-5' DNA helicase. BS patients are predisposed to developing all the cancers that affect the general population, and BS cells exhibit marked genetic instability. We showed recently that BLM protein contributes to the cellular response to ionizing radiation by acting as downstream ATM kinase effector. We now show that following UVC treatment, BLM-deficient cells exhibit a reduction in the number of replicative cells, a partial escape from the G2/M cell cycle checkpoint, and have an altered p21 response. Surprisingly, we found that hydroxyurea-treated BLM-deficient cells exhibit an intact S phase arrest, proper recovery from the S phase arrest, and intact p53 and p21 responses. We also show that the level of BLM falls sharply in response to UVC radiation. This UVC-induced reduction in BLM does not require a functional ATM gene and does not result from a subcellular compartment change. Finally, we demonstrate that exposure to UVC and hydroxyurea treatment both induce BLM phosphorylation via an ATM-independent pathway. These results are discussed in the light of their potential physiological significance with regard to the role of BLM in the cellular pathways activated by UVC radiation or HU-mediated inhibition of DNA synthesis.

Hypoxia links ATR and p53 through replication arrest

Previous studies have demonstrated that phosphorylation of human p53 on serine 15 contributes to protein stabilization after DNA damage and that this is mediated by the ATM family of kinases. However, cellular exposure to hypoxia does not induce any detectable level of DNA lesions compared to ionizing radiation, and the oxygen dependency of p53 protein accumulation differs from that of HIF-1, the hypoxia-inducible transcription factor. Here we show that, under severe hypoxic conditions, p53 protein accumulates only in S phase and this accumulation correlates with replication arrest. Inhibition of ATR kinase activity substantially reduces hypoxia-induced phosphorylation of p53 protein on serine 15 as well as p53 protein accumulation. Thus, hypoxia-induced cell growth arrest is tightly linked to an ATR-signaling pathway that is required for p53 modification and accumulation. These studies indicate that the ATR kinase plays an important role during tumor development in responding to hypoxia-induced replication arrest, and hypoxic conditions could select for the loss of key components of ATR-dependent checkpoint controls.

Homologous recombination induced by replication inhibition, is stimulated by expression of mutant p53

Cell cycle control, faithful DNA replication, repair and recombination are associated in a network of pathways controlling genome maintenance. In mammalian cells, inhibition of replication produces DNA breaks and induces RAD51-dependent recombination, in a late step. Here we examine whether the status of p53 affects this process in mouse L-cells containing a recombination substrate. We show that expression of the mutant (His175)p53 strongly stimulates recombination induced by aphidicolin, in a late step (kinetically related to the RAD51 step). Mutant p53 stimulates recombination induced by the replication elongation inhibitors (aphidicolin, hydroxyurea and Ara-C) but is without effect on recombination induced by the initiation inhibitors (mimosine and ciclopirox olamine). We compared the impact of several p53 mutations showing different effects on the G1 checkpoint and on recombination. We show that the mutant (Pro273)p53 protein, which does not alter the G1 checkpoint, strongly stimulates recombination induced by elongation inhibitors. These results show that p53 can act on recombination induced by replication arrest independently of its role in the G1 checkpoint. An action of p53 via the RAD51 pathway is discussed.

Why is p53 acetylated?

Recent studies suggest that acetylation of the p53 tumor suppressor protein is not important for its DNA binding activity, as was previously thought. We discuss here a number of theories as to how this modification may serve to regulate the protein's functions.

Mammalian G1- and S-phase checkpoints in response to DNA damage

The ability to preserve genomic integrity is a fundamental feature of life. Recent findings regarding the molecular basis of the cell-cycle checkpoint responses of mammalian cells to genotoxic stress have converged into a two-wave concept of the G1 checkpoint, and shed light on the so-far elusive intra-S-phase checkpoint. Rapidly operating cascades that target the Cdc25A phosphatase appear central in both the initiation wave of the G1 checkpoint (preceding the p53-mediated maintenance wave) and the transient intra-S-phase response. Multiple links between defects in the G1/S checkpoints, genomic instability and oncogenesis are emerging, as are new challenges and hopes raised by this knowledge.

Insights into cancer therapeutic design based on p53 and TRAIL receptor signaling

Knowledge of the emerging pathways of cell death downstream of the p53 tumor suppressor and the TRAIL death-inducing ligand is suggesting ways to improve therapeutic design in cancer. In contrast to its unique G1 cell cycle arresting mechanism that is maintained by p21(WAF1), there are signals transduced by p53 to multiple apoptotic effectors perhaps due to the importance of apoptosis in suppressing tumors. There is evidence for cytoplasmic as well as mitochondrial activation of caspases downstream of p53, although in some cell lineages the signal ultimately involves the mitochondria. The TRAIL signaling pathway appears promising for therapeutic development despite sharing some similarities with the toxic Fas and TNF pathways, in terms of effector molecules and downstream signals. One of the key findings is the tissue specificity of cell death responses, a feature that could be exploited in strategies to widen the therapeutic window of combination cancer therapies. Efforts continue to develop p53-targeted cancer therapy, and novel clues to enhance or block specific effectors may improve therapeutic design.