A primordial tRNA modification required for the evolution of life?

Naturally-occurring modification restricts the anticodon domain conformational space of tRNA(Phe)

Post-transcriptional modifications contribute chemistry and structure to RNAs. Modifications of tRNA at nucleoside 37, 3'-adjacent to the anticodon, are particularly interesting because they facilitate codon recognition and negate translational frame-shifting. To assess if the functional contribution of a position 37-modified nucleoside defines a specific structure or restricts conformational flexibility, structures of the yeast tRNA(Phe) anticodon stem and loop (ASL(Phe)) with naturally occurring modified nucleosides differing only at position 37, ASL(Phe)-(Cm(32),Gm(34),m(5)C(40)), and ASL(Phe)-(Cm(32),Gm(34),m(1)G(37),m(5)C(40)), were determined by NMR spectroscopy and restrained molecular dynamics. The ASL structures had similarly resolved stems (RMSD approximately 0.6A) of five canonical base-pairs in standard A-form RNA. The "NOE walk" was evident on the 5' and 3' sides of the stems of both RNAs, and extended to the adjacent loop nucleosides. The NOESY cross-peaks involving U(33) H2' and characteristic of tRNA's anticodon domain U-turn were present but weak, whereas those involving the U(33) H1' proton were absent from the spectra of both ASLs. However, ASL(Phe)-(Cm(32),Gm(34),m(1)G(37),m(5)C(40)) exhibited the downfield shifted 31P resonance of U(33)pGm(34) indicative of U-turns; ASL(Phe)-(Cm(32),Gm(34),m(5)C(40)) did not. An unusual "backwards" NOE between Gm(34) and A(35) (Gm(34)/H8 to A(35)/H1') was observed in both molecules. The RNAs exhibited a protonated A(+)(38) resulting in the final structures having C(32).A(+)(38) intra-loop base-pairs, with that of ASL(Phe)-(Cm(32),Gm(34),m(1)G(37),m(5)C(40)) being especially well defined. A single family of low-energy structures of ASL(Phe)-(Cm(32),Gm(34), m(1)G(37),m(5)C(40)) (loop RMSD 0.98A) exhibited a significantly restricted conformational space for the anticodon loop in comparison to that of ASL(Phe)-(Cm(32),Gm(34),m(5)C(40)) (loop RMSD 2.58A). In addition, the ASL(Phe)-(Cm(32),Gm(34),m(1)G(37),m(5)C(40)) average structure had a greater degree of similarity to that of the yeast tRNA(Phe) crystal structure. A comparison of the resulting structures indicates that modification of position 37 affects the accuracy of decoding and the maintenance of the mRNA reading frame by restricting anticodon loop conformational space.

Novel methyltransferase for modified uridine residues at the wobble position of tRNA

We have identified a novel tRNA methyltransferase in Saccharomyces cerevisiae that we designate Trm9. This enzyme, the product of the YML014w gene, catalyzes the esterification of modified uridine nucleotides, resulting in the formation of 5-methylcarbonylmethyluridine in tRNA(Arg3) and 5-methylcarbonylmethyl-2-thiouridine in tRNA(Glu). In intact yeast cells, disruption of the TRM9 gene results in the complete loss of these modified wobble bases and increased sensitivity at 37 degrees C to paromomycin, a translational inhibitor. These results suggest a role for this potentially reversible methyl esterification reaction when cells are under stress.

tRNAHis maturation: an essential yeast protein catalyzes addition of a guanine nucleotide to the 5' end of tRNAHis

All tRNAHis molecules are unusual in having an extra 5' GMP residue (G(-1)) that, in eukaryotes, is added after transcription and RNase P cleavage. Incorporation of this G(-1) residue is a rare example of nucleotide addition occurring at an RNA 5' end in a normal phosphodiester linkage. We show here that the essential Saccharomyces cerevisiae ORF YGR024c (THG1) is responsible for this guanylyltransferase reaction. Thg1p was identified by survey of a genomic collection of yeast GST-ORF fusion proteins for addition of [alpha-32P]GTP to tRNAHis. End analysis confirms the presence of G(-1). Thg1p is required for tRNAHis guanylylation in vivo, because cells depleted of Thg1p lack G(-1) in their tRNAHis. His6-Thg1p purified from Escherichia coli catalyzes the guanylyltransferase step of G(-1) addition using a ppp-tRNAHis substrate, and appears to catalyze the activation step using p-tRNAHis and ATP. Thg1p is highlye conserved in eukaryotes, where G(-1) addition is necessary, and is not found in eubacteria, where G(-1) is genome-encoded. Thus, Thg1p is the first member of a new family of enzymes that can catalyze phosphodiester bond formation at the 5' end of RNAs, formally in a 3'-5' direction. Surprisingly, despite its varied activities, Thg1p contains no recognizable catalytic or functional domains.

A yeast knockout strain to discriminate between active and inactive tRNA molecules

Here we report the construction of a yeast genetic screen designed to identify essential residues in tRNA(Arg). The system consists of a tRNA(Arg) knockout strain and a set of vectors designed to rescue and select for variants of tRNA(Arg). By plasmid shuffling we selected inactive tRNA mutants that were further analyzed by northern blotting. The mutational analysis focused on the tRNA D and anticodon loops that contact the aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase. The anticodon triplet was excluded from the analysis because of its role in decoding the Arg codons. Most of the inactivating mutations are residues involved in tertiary interactions. These mutations had dramatic effects on tRNA(Arg) abundance. Other inactivating mutations were located in the anticodon loop, where they did not affect transcription and aminoacylation but probably altered interaction with the translation machinery. No lethal effects were observed when residues 16, 20 and 38 were individually mutated, despite the fact that they are involved in sequence-specific interactions with the aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase. However, the steady-state levels of the aminoacylated forms of U20A and U20G were decreased by a factor of 3.5-fold in vivo. This suggests that, unlike in the Escherichia coli tRNA(Arg):ArgRS system where residue 20 (A) is a major identity element, in yeast this position is of limited consequence.

Crystal structure of tRNA(m1G37)methyltransferase: insights into tRNA recognition

tRNA(m(1)G37)methyltransferase (TrmD) catalyzes the transfer of a methyl group from S-adenosyl-L- methionine (AdoMet) to G(37) within a subset of bacterial tRNA species, which have a G residue at the 36th position. The modified guanosine is adjacent to and 3' of the anticodon and is essential for the maintenance of the correct reading frame during translation. Here we report four crystal structures of TrmD from Haemophilus influenzae, as binary complexes with either AdoMet or S-adenosyl-L-homocysteine (AdoHcy), as a ternary complex with AdoHcy and phosphate, and as an apo form. This first structure of TrmD indicates that it functions as a dimer. It also suggests the binding mode of G(36)G(37) in the active site of TrmD and the catalytic mechanism. The N-terminal domain has a trefoil knot, in which AdoMet or AdoHcy is bound in a novel, bent conformation. The C-terminal domain shows structural similarity to trp repressor. We propose a plausible model for the TrmD(2)-tRNA(2) complex, which provides insights into recognition of the general tRNA structure by TrmD.

Transfer RNA modifications that alter +1 frameshifting in general fail to affect -1 frameshifting

Using mutants (tgt, mnmA(asuE, trmU), mnmE(trmE), miaA, miaB, miaE, truA(hisT), truB) of either Escherichia coli or Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium and the trm5 mutant of Saccharomyces cerevisiae, we have analyzed the influence by the modified nucleosides Q34, mnm(5)s(2)U34, ms(2)io(6)A37, Psi39, Psi55, m(1)G37, and yW37 on -1 frameshifts errors at various heptameric sequences, at which at least one codon is decoded by tRNAs having these modified nucleosides. The frequency of -1 frameshifting was the same in congenic strains only differing in the allelic state of the various tRNA modification genes. In fact, in one case (deficiency of mnm(5)s(2)U34), we observed a reduced ability of the undermodified tRNA to make a -1 frameshift error. These results are in sharp contrast to earlier observations that tRNA modification prevents +1 frameshifting suggesting that the mechanisms by which -1 and +1 frameshift errors occur are different. Possible mechanisms explaining these results are discussed.

Identification of the yeast gene encoding the tRNA m1G methyltransferase responsible for modification at position 9

Methylation of tRNA at the N-1 position of guanosine to form m(1)G occurs widely in nature. It occurs at position 37 in tRNAs from all three kingdoms, and the methyltransferase that catalyzes this reaction is known from previous work of others to be critically important for cell growth in Escherichia coli and the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. m(1)G is also widely found at position 9 in eukaryotic tRNAs, but the corresponding methyltransferase was unknown. We have used a biochemical genomics approach with a collection of purified yeast GST-ORF fusion proteins to show that m(1)G(9) formation of yeast tRNA(Gly) is associated with ORF YOL093w, named TRM10. Extracts lacking Trm10p have undetectable levels of m(1)G(9) methyltransferase activity but retain normal m(1)G(37) methyltransferase activity. Yeast Trm10p purified from E. coli quantitatively modifies the G(9) position of tRNA(Gly) in an S-adenosylmethionine-dependent fashion. Trm10p is responsible in vivo for most if not all m(1)G(9) modification of tRNAs, based on two results: tRNA(Gly) purified from a trm10-Delta/trm10-Delta strain is lacking detectable m(1)G; and a primer extension block occurring at m(1)G(9) is removed in trm10-Delta/trm10-Delta-derived tRNAs for all 9 m(1)G(9)-containing species that were testable by this method. There is no obvious growth defect of trm10-Delta/trm10-Delta strains. Trm10p bears no detectable resemblance to the yeast m(1)G(37) methyltransferase, Trm5p, or its orthologs. Trm10p homologs are found widely in eukaryotes and many archaea, with multiple homologs in several metazoans, including at least three in humans.

Comparative evolutionary genomics unveils the molecular mechanism of reassignment of the CTG codon in Candida spp

Using the (near) complete genome sequences of the yeasts Candida albicans, Saccharomyces cerevisiae, and Schizosaccharomyces pombe, we address the evolution of a unique genetic code change, which involves decoding of the standard leucine-CTG codon as serine in Candida spp. By using two complementary comparative genomics approaches, we have been able to shed new light on both the origin of the novel Candida spp. Ser-tRNA(CAG), which has mediated CTG reassignment, and on the evolution of the CTG codon in the genomes of C. albicans, S. cerevisiae, and S. pombe. Sequence analyses of newly identified tRNAs from the C. albicans genome demonstrate that the Ser-tRNA(CAG) is derived from a serine and not a leucine tRNA in the ancestor yeast species and that this codon reassignment occurred approximately 170 million years ago, but the origin of the Ser-tRNA(CAG) is more ancient, implying that the ancestral Leu-tRNA that decoded the CTG codon was lost after the appearance of the Ser-tRNA(CAG). Ambiguous CTG decoding by the Ser-tRNA(CAG) combined with biased AT pressure forced the evolution of CTG into TTR codons and have been major forces driving evolution of the CTN codon family in C. albicans. Remarkably, most of the CTG codons present in extant C. albicans genes are encoded by serine and not leucine codons in homologous S. cerevisiae and S. pombe genes, indicating that a significant number of serine TCN and AGY codons evolved into CTG codons either directly by simultaneous double mutations or indirectly through an intermediary codon. In either case, CTG reassignment had a major impact on the evolution of the coding component of the Candida spp. genome.

1-methylguanosine-deficient tRNA of Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium affects thiamine metabolism

In Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium a mutation in the purF gene encoding the first enzyme in the purine pathway blocks, besides the synthesis of purine, the synthesis of thiamine when glucose is used as the carbon source. On carbon sources other than glucose, a purF mutant does not require thiamine, since the alternative pyrimidine biosynthetic (APB) pathway is activated. This pathway feeds into the purine pathway just after the PurF biosynthetic step and upstream of the intermediate 4-aminoimidazolribotide, which is the common intermediate in purine and thiamine synthesis. The activity of this pathway is also influenced by externally added pantothenate. tRNAs from S. enterica specific for leucine, proline, and arginine contain 1-methylguanosine (m(1)G37) adjacent to and 3' of the anticodon (position 37). The formation of m(1)G37 is catalyzed by the enzyme tRNA(m(1)G37)methyltransferase, which is encoded by the trmD gene. Mutations in this gene, which result in an m(1)G37 deficiency in the tRNA, in a purF mutant mediate PurF-independent thiamine synthesis. This phenotype is specifically dependent on the m(1)G37 deficiency, since several other mutations which also affect translation fidelity and induce slow growth did not cause PurF-independent thiamine synthesis. Some antibiotics that are known to reduce the efficiency of translation also induce PurF-independent thiamine synthesis. We suggest that a slow decoding event at a codon(s) read by a tRNA(s) normally containing m(1)G37 is responsible for the PurF-independent thiamine synthesis and that this event causes a changed flux in the APB pathway.

Conformational preferences of the base substituent in hypermodified nucleotide queuosine 5'-monophosphate 'pQ' and protonated variant 'pQH+'

Conformational preferences of the base substituent in hypermodified nucleotide queuosine 5'-monophosphate 'pQ' and its protonated form 'pQH+' have been studied using quantum chemical Perturbative Configuration Interaction with Localized Orbitals PCILO method. The salient points have also been examined using molecular mechanics force field MMFF, parameterized modified neglect of differential overlap PM3 and Hartree Fock-Density Functional Theory HF DFT (pBP/DN*) approaches. Aqueous solvation of pQ and pQH+ has also been studied using molecular dynamics simulations. Consistent with the observed crystal structure, in isolated protonated form pQH+, the quaternary amine HN(13)(+)H, of the sidechain having 7-aminomethyl linkage, hydrogen bonds with the carbonyl oxygen O(10) of the base. However, N(13)H-O(10) hydrogen bonding is not preferred for unprotonated pQ, whether isolated or hydrated. Interaction between the 5'-phosphate and the 7-aminomethyl group is more likely for isolated pQ. The cyclopentenediol hydroxyl group O4"H may hydrogen bond with the O(10) in isolated pQ as well as in pQH+. The O4"H may hydrogen bond with the 5'-phosphate as well. The presence of -CH2-NH- and O"H groups in pQ and pQH+ allows interesting possibilities for intranucleotide hydrogen bonds and interactions across the anticodon loop. Simultaneous hydrogen bonds O2P-HN(13)+H-O(10) are indicated for hydrated pQH+. Unlike weak involvement of O4"H, these interactions also persist in hydrated pQH+ and may much reduce backbone flexibility. Resulting sub-optimal Q:C base pairing leads to unbiased reading of U or C as the third codon letter. Cyclopentenediol hydroxyl groups may interact with other biomolecules, allowing specific recognition. Prospective pQ(34) and pQ(34)H+ sites for codon-anticodon base pairing remain unhindered, but non canonical Q:G base pairing (amber-suppression) is ruled out.

RNA editing by adenosine deaminases generates RNA and protein diversity

RNA editing is defined as a post-transcriptional change of a gene-encoded sequence at the RNA level, excluding alterations due to processes such as pre-mRNA splicing and 3'-end formation. RNA editing is found in many organisms and can occur either by the insertion or deletion of nucleotides or by the substitution of bases by modification. The nucleoside inosine (I) was first detected in cytoplasmic tRNA and was later found in messenger RNA precursors (pre-mRNAs) and in viral transcripts. It is formed by hydrolytic deamination of a genomically encoded adenosine (A) at C6 of the base and this reaction is catalysed by a family of related enzymes. ADARs (for adenosine deaminases acting on RNA) catalyse A to I conversion either promiscuously or site-specifically in pre-mRNAs, viral RNAs and synthetic double-stranded RNAs (dsRNAs), whereas ADATs (for adenosine deaminases acting on tRNA) are involved in inosine formation in tRNAs. ADAT1 generates I at position 37 (3' of the anticodon) in eukaryotic tRNA(Ala). ADAT2 and ADAT3 function as a heterodimer which catalyses inosine formation at the wobble position (position 34) in eukaryotic tRNAs. Here, we review the state of knowledge on ADARs and ADATs and their RNA substrates, with an emphasis on the developments over the past few years that have increased the understanding of the mechanism of action of these enzymes and of the functional consequences of the widespread modification they catalyse.

tadA, an essential tRNA-specific adenosine deaminase from Escherichia coli

We report the characterization of tadA, the first prokaryotic RNA editing enzyme to be identified. Escherichia coli tadA displays sequence similarity to the yeast tRNA deaminase subunit Tad2p. Recombinant tadA protein forms homodimers and is sufficient for site-specific inosine formation at the wobble position (position 34) of tRNA(Arg2), the only tRNA having this modification in prokaryotes. With the exception of yeast tRNA(Arg), no other eukaryotic tRNA substrates were found to be modified by tadA. How ever, an artificial yeast tRNA(Asp), which carries the anticodon loop of yeast tRNA(Arg), is bound and modified by tadA. Moreover, a tRNA(Arg2) minisubstrate containing the anticodon stem and loop is sufficient for specific deamination by tadA. We show that nucleotides at positions 33-36 are sufficient for inosine formation in mutant Arg2 minisubstrates. The anticodon is thus a major determinant for tadA substrate specificity. Finally, we show that tadA is an essential gene in E.coli, underscoring the critical function of inosine at the wobble position in prokaryotes.

Trm7p catalyses the formation of two 2'-O-methylriboses in yeast tRNA anticodon loop

The genome of Saccharomyces cerevisiae encodes three close homologues of the Escherichia coli 2'-O-rRNA methyltransferase FtsJ/RrmJ, designated Trm7p, Spb1p and Mrm2p. We present evidence that Trm7p methylates the 2'-O-ribose of nucleotides at positions 32 and 34 of the tRNA anticodon loop, both in vivo and in vitro. In a trm7Delta strain, which is viable but grows slowly, translation is impaired, thus indicating that these tRNA modifications could be important for translation efficiency. We discuss the emergence of a family of three 2'-O-RNA methyltransferases in Eukaryota and one in Prokaryota from a common ancestor. We propose that each eukaryotic enzyme is located in a different cell compartment, in which it would methylate a different RNA that can adopt a very similar secondary structure.

Dual function of the tRNA(m(5)U54)methyltransferase in tRNA maturation

A 5-methyluridine (m(5)U) residue at position 54 is a conserved feature of bacterial and eukaryotic tRNAs. The methylation of U54 is catalyzed by the tRNA(m5U54)methyltransferase, which in Saccharomyces cerevisiae is encoded by the nonessential TRM2 gene. In this study, we identified four different strains with mutant forms of tRNA(Ser)CGA. The absence of the TRM2 gene in these strains decreased the stability of tRNA(Ser)CGA and induced lethality. Two alleles of TRM2 encoding catalytically inactive tRNA(m5U54)methyltransferases were able to stabilize tRNA(Ser)CGA in one of the mutants, revealing a role for the Trm2 protein per se in tRNA maturation. Other tRNA modification enzymes interacting with tRNA(Ser)CGA in the maturation process, such as Pus4p, Trm1 p, and Trm3p were essential or important for growth of the tRNA(Ser)CGA mutants. Moreover, Lhp1p, a protein binding RNA polymerase III transcripts, was required to stabilize the mutant tRNAs. Based on our results, we suggest that tRNA modification enzymes might have a role in tRNA maturation not necessarily linked to their known catalytic activity.

Pus1p-dependent tRNA pseudouridinylation becomes essential when tRNA biogenesis is compromised in yeast

Yeast Pus1p catalyzes the formation of pseudouridine (psi) at specific sites of several tRNAs, but its function is not essential for cell viability. We show here that Pus1p becomes essential when another tRNA:pseudouridine synthase, Pus4p, or the essential minor tRNA for glutamine are mutated. Strikingly, this mutant tRNA, which carries a mismatch in the T psi C arm, displays a nuclear export defect. Furthermore, nuclear export of at least one wild-type tRNA species becomes defective in the absence of Pus1p. Our data, thus, show that the modifications formed by Pus1p are essential when other aspects of tRNA biogenesis or function are compromised and suggest that impairment of nuclear tRNA export in the absence of Pus1p might contribute to this phenotype.

Post-transcriptional modification in archaeal tRNAs: identities and phylogenetic relations of nucleotides from mesophilic and hyperthermophilic Methanococcales

Post-transcriptional modifications in archaeal RNA are known to be phylogenetically distinct but relatively little is known of tRNA from the Methanococci, a lineage of methanogenic marine euryarchaea that grow over an unusually broad temperature range. Transfer RNAs from Methanococcus vannielii, Methanococcus maripaludis, the thermophile Methanococcus thermolithotrophicus, and hyperthermophiles Methanococcus jannaschii and Methanococcus igneus were studied to determine whether modification patterns reflect the close phylogenetic relationships inferred from small ribosomal subunit RNA sequences, and to examine modification differences associated with temperature of growth. Twenty-four modified nucleosides were characterized, including the complex tricyclic nucleoside wyosine characteristic of position 37 in tRNA(Phe) and known previously only in eukarya, plus two new wye family members of presently unknown structure. The hypermodified nucleoside 5-methylaminomethyl-2-thiouridine, reported previously only in bacterial tRNA at the first position of the anticodon, was identified by liquid chromatography-electrospray ionization mass spectrometry in four of the five organisms. The ribose-methylated nucleosides, 2'-O-methyladenosine, N(2),2'-O-dimethylguanosine and N(2),N(2),2'-O-trimethylguanosine, were found only in hyperthermophile tRNA, consistent with their proposed roles in thermal stabilization of tRNA.

The renaissance of aminoacyl-tRNA synthesis

The role of tRNA as the adaptor in protein synthesis has held an enduring fascination for molecular biologists. Over four decades of study, taking in numerous milestones in molecular biology, led to what was widely held to be a fairly complete picture of how tRNAs and amino acids are paired prior to protein synthesis. However, recent developments in genomics and structural biology have revealed an unexpected array of new enzymes, pathways and mechanisms involved in aminoacyl-tRNA synthesis. As a more complete picture of aminoacyl-tRNA synthesis now begins to emerge, the high degree of evolutionary diversity in this universal and essential process is becoming clearer.

Improvement of reading frame maintenance is a common function for several tRNA modifications

Transfer RNAs from all organisms contain many modified nucleosides. Their vastly different chemical structures, their presence in different tRNAs, their occurrence in different locations in tRNA and their influence on different reactions in which tRNA participates suggest that each modified nucleoside may have its own specific function. However, since the frequency of frameshifting in several different mutants [mnmA, mnmE, tgt, truA (hisT), trmD, miaA, miaB and miaE] defective in tRNA modification was higher compared with the corresponding wild-type controls, these modifications have a common function: they all improve reading frame maintenance. Frameshifting occurs by peptidyl-tRNA slippage, which is influenced by the hypomodified tRNA in two ways: (i) a hypomodified tRNA in the ternary complex may decrease the rate by which the complex is recruited to the A-site and thereby increasing peptidyl-tRNA slippage; or (ii) a hypomodified peptidyl-tRNA may be more prone to slip than its fully modified counterpart. We propose that the improvement of reading frame maintenance has been and is the major selective factor for the emergence of new modified nucleosides.