Reduced DNA methylation in Arabidopsis thaliana results in abnormal plant development

Epigenetic control of plant development by Polycomb-group proteins

Recent genetic studies indicate that the plant Polycomb-group genes play much broader roles in development than was initially apparent from their single mutant phenotypes. At the mechanistic level, evidence is accumulating that their protein products act together in complexes that direct changes in histone methylation patterns. We discuss recent studies that give clues as to how these epigenetic changes are propagated through mitosis, how they are interpreted, and how they might be reset.

DNA methylation increases throughout Arabidopsis development

We used amplified fragment length polymorphisms (AFLP) to analyze the stability of DNA methylation throughout Arabidopsis development. AFLP can detect genome-wide changes in cytosine methylation produced by DNA demethylation agents, such as 5-azacytidine, or specific mutations at the DDM1 locus. In both cases, cytosine demethylation is associated with a general increase in the presence of amplified fragments. Using this approach, we followed DNA methylation at methylation sensitive restriction sites throughout Arabidopsis development. The results show a progressive DNA methylation trend from cotyledons to vegetative organs to reproductive organs.

Eukaryotic cytosine methyltransferases

Large-genome eukaryotes use heritable cytosine methylation to silence promoters, especially those associated with transposons and imprinted genes. Cytosine methylation does not reinforce or replace ancestral gene regulation pathways but instead endows methylated genomes with the ability to repress specific promoters in a manner that is buffered against changes in the internal and external environment. Recent studies have shown that the targeting of de novo methylation depends on multiple inputs; these include the interaction of repeated sequences, local states of histone lysine methylation, small RNAs and components of the RNAi pathway, and divergent and catalytically inert cytosine methyltransferase homologues that have acquired regulatory roles. There are multiple families of DNA (cytosine-5) methyltransferases in eukaryotes, and each family appears to be controlled by different regulatory inputs. Sequence-specific DNA-binding proteins, which regulate most aspects of gene expression, do not appear to be involved in the establishment or maintenance of genomic methylation patterns.

Transgene-triggered, epigenetically regulated ectopic expression of a flower homeotic gene pMADS3 in Petunia

pMADS3 is a class C floral homeotic gene of Petunia that is specifically expressed in stamens and carpels of developing flowers. We previously reported that introduction of a part of the pMADS3 genomic sequence silenced endogenous pMADS3 (sil-pMADS3) in transgenic Petunia hybrida. Here we report that introduction of the same sequence triggers ectopic expression of endogenous pMADS3 in sepals, petals and leaves (ect-pMADS3), accompanied by homeotic conversion of the floral organs and altered leaf morphology similar to that of an Arabidopsis curly leaf mutant. The occurrence of the ect-pMADS3 phenotype depended on the presence of pMADS3 intron 2 in the transgenes. Occasionally, sil-pMADS3 and ect-pMADS3 phenotypes somatically interconverted. Some T1 progeny inherited their parent's pMADS3 expression pattern, while others switched from sil-pMADS3 to ect-pMADS3 and vice versa. Both phenotypes occasionally occurred even after the transgenes were segregated away. RT-PCR analyses of ectopically expressed pMADS3 transcripts indicated that two pMADS3 alleles were often differently regulated. Furthermore, reciprocal crosses with untransformed Petunia indicated that pMADS3 alleles other than the one ectopically expressed in T0 plants were sometimes expressed ectopically in T1 plants: the paramutation-like transmission of epigenetic regulation between alleles. We detected in the transformants aberrant transcripts, including sense and antisense pMADS3 intron 2 sequences of heterogeneous molecular sizes, irrespective of the pMADS3 phenotypes. We speculate on possible molecular mechanisms underlying these epigenetic phenomena.

The methylation cycle and its possible functions in barley endosperm development

Barley endosperm development can be subdivided into the pre-storage, intermediate, storage and desiccation phase. Nothing is known about DNA methylation events involved in different endosperm-specific developmental programmes. A complete set of methylation cycle enzyme genes was identified and investigated by mRNA expression analysis. During the pre-storage phase, methionine synthase and S-adenosylmethionine (AdoMet) synthase genes are expressed at high levels, mainly to produce AdoMet, which might be used for methylation processes as indicated by high expression of methyltransferases HvMET1, HvCMT1 and HvDnmt3-1 as well as AdoHcy hydrolase genes. The methyltransferases, core histones and DNA-unwinding ATPases are co-expressed at the mRNA level. On the contrary, storage protein (prolamin) gene expression is repressed due to CpG methylation. Expression of genes responsible for starch biosynthesis is also developmentally regulated but not methylation-dependent. Thus, during pre-storage phase, activity of HvMET1 and HvCMT1 possibly maintains DNA replication and suppresses specific pathways of maturation. Besides, HvDnmt3-1 might be responsible for differentiation-specific de novo methylation. Expression of methyltransferases HvDnmt3-2 and HvCMT2 peaks during the onset of massive starch accumulation. The enzymes are likely responsible for DNA methylation involved in determining plastid division and amyloplast differentiation as concluded from the patterns of co-expressed genes. Levels of AdoMet decarboxylase mRNA, but not methyltransferase- and AdoHcy mRNA, increase at the beginning of desiccation together with methionine synthase and AdoMet synthase levels. This increase may be indicative for utilization of AdoMet in polyamine production protecting aleuron and embryo cell membranes during desiccation.

Preventing transcriptional gene silencing by active DNA demethylation

DNA methylation is important for stable transcriptional gene silencing. DNA methyltransferases for de novo as well as maintenance methylation have been well characterized. However, enzymes responsible for active DNA demethylation have been elusive and several reported mechanisms of active demethylation have been controversial. There has been a critical need for genetic analysis in order to firmly establish an in vivo role for putative DNA demethylases. Mutations in the bifunctional DNA glycosylase/lyase ROS1 in Arabidopsis cause DNA hypermethylation and transcriptional silencing of specific genes. Recombinant ROS1 protein has DNA glycosylase/lyase activity on methylated but not unmethylated DNA substrates. Therefore, there is now strong genetic evidence supporting a base excision repair mechanism for active DNA demethylation. DNA demethylases may be critical factors for genome wide hypomethylation seen in cancers and possibly important for epigenetic reprogramming during somatic cell cloning and stem cell function.

Seed development and genomic imprinting in plants

Genomic imprinting refers to an epigenetic phenomenon where the activity of an allele depends on its parental origin. Imprinting at individual genes has only been described in mammals and seed plants. We will discuss the role imprinted genes play in seed development and compare the situation in plants with that in mammals. Interestingly, many imprinted genes appear to control cell proliferation and growth in both groups of organisms although imprinting in plants may also be involved in the cellular differentiation of the two pairs of gametes involved in double fertilization. DNA methylation plays some role in the control of parent-of-origin-specific expression in both mammals and plants. Thus, although imprinting evolved independently in mammals and plants, there are striking similarities at the phenotypic and possibly also mechanistic level.

Distinct regulation of histone H3 methylation at lysines 27 and 9 by CpG methylation in Arabidopsis

Transcriptional activity and structure of chromatin are correlated with patterns of covalent DNA and histone modification. Previous studies have revealed that high levels of histone H3 dimethylation at lysine 9 (H3K9me2), characteristic of transcriptionally silent heterochromatin in Arabidopsis, require hypermethylation of DNA at CpG sites. Here, we report that CpG hypermethylation characteristic of heterochromatin specifically prevented H3K27 trimethylation (H3K27me3). H3K27 mono- and dimethylation mark silent heterochromatin independently of DNA methylation. Upon loss of CpG methylation, there was target-specific enrichment of H3K27me3 in heterochromatin that correlated with transcriptional reactivation. Moreover, using the kyp mutant affected in H3K9me2, we showed that changes in H3K27me3 occurred independently of the levels of H3K9me2. Therefore, CpG methylation provides distinct and direct information for a specific subset of histone methylation marks. The observed independence of the regulation of H3K9 and H3K27 methylation by CpG methylation refines the recently proposed combinatorial histone code involving these two marks.

Mutational decay and age of chloroplast and mitochondrial genomes transferred recently to angiosperm nuclear chromosomes

Transfers of organelle DNA to the nucleus established several thousand functional genes in eukaryotic chromosomes over evolutionary time. Recent transfers have also contributed nonfunctional plastid (pt)- and mitochondrion (mt)-derived DNA (termed nupts and numts, respectively) to plant nuclear genomes. The two largest transferred organelle genome copies are 131-kb nuptDNA in rice (Oryza sativa) and 262-kb numtDNA in Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana). These transferred copies were compared in detail with their bona fide organelle counterparts, to which they are 99.77% and 99.91% identical, respectively. No evidence for purifying selection was found in either nuclear integrant, indicating that they are nonfunctional. Mutations attributable to 5-methylcytosine hypermutation have occurred at a 6- to 10-fold higher rate than other point mutations in Arabidopsis numtDNA and rice nuptDNA, respectively, revealing this as a major mechanism of mutational decay for these transferred organelle sequences. Short indels occurred preferentially within homopolymeric stretches but were less frequent than point mutations. The 131-kb nuptDNA is absent in the O. sativa subsp. indica or Oryza rufipogon nuclear genome, suggesting that it was transferred within the O. sativa subsp. japonica lineage and, as revealed by sequence comparisons, after its divergence from the indica chloroplast lineage. The time of the transfer for the rice nupt was estimated as 148,000 (74,000--296,000) years ago and that for the Arabidopsis numtDNA as 88,000 (44,000--176,000) years ago. The results reveal transfer and integration of entire organelle genomes into the nucleus as an ongoing evolutionary process and uncover mutational mechanisms affecting organelle genomes recently transferred into a new mutational environment.

DNA methylating and demethylating treatments modify phenotype and cell wall differentiation state in sugarbeet cell lines

In plants organogenesis, cell differentiation and dedifferentiation are fundamental processes allowing high developmental plasticity. Such plasticity involved epigenetic mechanisms but limited knowledge is available concerning quantitative aspects. Three sugarbeet (Beta vulgaris L. altissima) cell lines originating from the same mother plant and exhibiting graduate states of morphogenesis were used to assess whether these differences could be related or not to changes in DNA methylation levels. Methylcytosine percentages from 18.3 to 28.8% and distinct levels of DNA methyltransferase (EC 2.1.1.37) activities were shown in the three cell lines. The lowest methylcytosine percentage was associated to organogenesis. In order to test the plasticity of these cell lines, various treatments causing DNA hypo or hypermethylation were performed at different times and concentrations. In this collection of treated lines with+/-10% of methylcytosine percentages, loss of organogenic properties and cell dedifferentiation were observed. As cell wall formation fits well with cell differentiation state, the lignification process was further investigated in treated and untreated lines as a biochemical marker of the phenotypic changes. For example, peroxidase specific activities (EC 1.11.1.7) varied from 0.7 to 0.02 pkat mg(-1) of protein in organogenic and dedifferentiated lines, respectively. A negative relationship between peroxidase activities, incorporation of cell wall-bound phenolic compounds as ferulate and sinapate derivatives and methylcytosine percentages was obtained. This is the first biochemical evidence that phenotypic changes in plant cells induced by DNA hypo- or hypermethylating treatments are correlated in a linear relationship to modifications of the cell wall differentiation state.

Gardening the genome: DNA methylation in Arabidopsis thaliana

DNA methylation has two essential roles in plants and animals - defending the genome against transposons and regulating gene expression. Recent experiments in Arabidopsis thaliana have begun to address crucial questions about how DNA methylation is established and maintained. One cardinal insight has been the discovery that DNA methylation can be guided by small RNAs produced through RNA-interference pathways. Plants and mammals use a similar suite of DNA methyltransferases to propagate DNA methylation, but plants have also developed a glycosylase-based mechanism for removing DNA methylation, and there are hints that similar processes function in other organisms.

DNA hypomethylation in 5-azacytidine-induced early-flowering lines of flax

HPLC analysis was used to examine the cytosine methylation of total DNA extracted from four early-flowering lines that were induced by treating germinating seeds of flax (Linum usitatissimum) with the DNA demethylating agent 5-azacytidine. In the normal lines that gave rise to the induced early-flowering lines, flowering usually begins approximately 50 days after sowing. The early-flowering lines flower 7-13 days earlier than normal. The normal level of cytosine methylation was approximately 14% of the cytosines and 2.7% of the nucleosides. In the early-flowering lines, these levels were 6.2% lower than normal in DNA from the terminal leaf clusters of 14-day-old seedlings and 9.7% lower than normal in DNA from the cotyledons and immature shoot buds of 4-day-old seedlings. This hypomethylation was seen in lines that were five to nine generations beyond the treatment generation. The level of hypomethylation was similar in three of the four early-flowering lines, but was not as low in the fourth line, which flowers early but not quite as early as the other three lines. Unexpectedly, the degree of hypomethylation seen in segregant lines, derived by selecting for the early-flowering phenotype in the F(2) and F(3) generations of out-crosses, was similar to that seen in the early-flowering lines. Analysis of the methylation levels in segregating generations of out-crosses between early-flowering and normal lines demonstrated a decrease in methylation level during the selection of early-flowering segregants. The results suggest an association between hypomethylation and the early-flowering phenotype, and that the hypomethylated regions may not be randomly distributed throughout the genome of the early-flowering lines.

DDM1 binds Arabidopsis methyl-CpG binding domain proteins and affects their subnuclear localization

Methyl-CpG binding domain (MBD) proteins in Arabidopsis thaliana bind in vitro methylated CpG sites. Here, we aimed to characterize the binding properties of AtMBDs to chromatin in Arabidopsis nuclei. By expressing in wild-type cells AtMBDs fused to green fluorescent protein (GFP), we showed that AtMBD7 was evenly distributed at all chromocenters, whereas AtMBD5 and 6 showed preference for two perinucleolar chromocenters adjacent to nucleolar organizing regions. AtMBD2, previously shown to be incapable of binding in vitro-methylated CpG, was dispersed within the nucleus, excluding chromocenters and the nucleolus. Recruitment of AtMBD5, 6, and 7 to chromocenters was disrupted in ddm1 and met1 mutant cells, where a significant reduction in cytosine methylation occurs. In these mutant cells, however, AtMBD2 accumulated at chromocenters. No effect on localization was observed in the chromomethylase3 mutant showing reduced CpNpG methylation or in kyp-2 displaying a reduction in Lys 9 histone H3 methylation. Transient expression of DDM1 fused to GFP showed that DDM1 shares common sites with AtMBD proteins. Glutathione S-transferase pull-down assays demonstrated that AtMBDs bind DDM1; the MBD motif was sufficient for this interaction. Our results suggest that the subnuclear localization of AtMBD is not solely dependent on CpG methylation; DDM1 may facilitate localization of AtMBDs at specific nuclear domains.

RNA-directed DNA methylation

Double-stranded RNAs (dsRNAs) and their 'diced' small RNA products can guide key developmental and defense mechanisms in eukaryotes. Some RNA-directed mechanisms act at a post-transcriptional level to degrade target messenger RNAs. However, dsRNA-derived species can also direct changes in the chromatin structure of DNA regions with which they share sequence identity. For example, plants use such RNA species to lay down cytosine methylation imprints on identical DNA sequences, providing a fundamental mark for the formation of transcriptionally silent heterochromatin. Thus, RNA can feed backwards to modulate the accessibility of information stored in the DNA of cognate genes. RNA triggers for DNA methylation can come from different sources, including invasive viral, transgene or transposon sequences, and in some cases are derived from single-stranded RNA precursors by RNA-dependent RNA polymerases. The mechanism by which RNA signals are translated into DNA methylation imprints is currently unknown, but two plant-specific types of cytosine methyltransferase have been implicated in this process. RNA can also direct heterochromatin formation in fission yeast and Drosophila, but in these organisms the process occurs in the absence of DNA methylation.

Stochastic and epigenetic changes of gene expression in Arabidopsis polyploids

Polyploidization is an abrupt speciation mechanism for eukaryotes and is especially common in plants. However, little is known about patterns and mechanisms of gene regulation during early stages of polyploid formation. Here we analyzed differential expression patterns of the progenitors' genes among successive selfing generations and independent lineages. The synthetic Arabidopsis allotetraploid lines were produced by a genetic cross between A. thaliana and A. arenosa autotetraploids. We found that some progenitors' genes are differentially expressed in early generations, whereas other genes are silenced in late generations or among different siblings within a selfing generation, suggesting that the silencing of progenitors' genes is rapidly and/or stochastically established. Moreover, a subset of genes is affected in autotetraploid and multiple independent allotetraploid lines and in A. suecica, a natural allotetraploid derived from A. thaliana and A. arenosa, indicating locus-specific susceptibility to ploidy-dependent gene regulation. The role of DNA methylation in silencing progenitors' genes is tested in DNA-hypomethylation transgenic lines of A. suecica using RNA interference (RNAi). Two silenced genes are reactivated in both ddm1- and met1-RNAi lines, consistent with the demethylation of centromeric repeats and gene-specific regions in the genome. A rapid and stochastic process of differential gene expression is reinforced by epigenetic regulation during polyploid formation and evolution.

Harnessing the developmental potential of nucellar cells: barriers and opportunities

Angiosperm nucellar cells can either use or avoid meiosis in vivo, depending on the developmental context. This unique ability contrasts with the conditions required in vitro, either for a reconstituted oocyte to avoid meiosis and produce clones by somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT), or for mammalian stem cells to undergo meiosis and produce synthetic sex cells (gametes). Current biotechnological initiatives to harness the potential of nucellar cells are based on the transfer of apomixis genes to sexual crop plants with the aim of producing clones through seeds. The elusive genetic basis of apomixis compels us to examine whether this process involves epigenetic factors. The elegant and versatile developmental platform available in nucellar cells should be explored as a genome-scale science and compared with mammalian stem cell biology for a holistic understanding of developmental programming and reprogramming in eukaryotes.

Formation of embryogenic cell clumps from carrot epidermal cells is suppressed by 5-azacytidine, a DNA methylation inhibitor

Using a direct somatic embryogenesis system in carrot, we examined the role of DNA methylation in the change of cellular differentiation state, from somatic to embryogenic. 5-Azacytidine (aza-C), an inhibitor of DNA methylation suppressed the formation of embryogenic cell clumps from epidermal carrot cells. Aza-C also downregulated the expression of DcLEC1c, a LEC1-like embryonic gene in carrot, during morphogenesis of embryos. A carrot DNA methyltransferase gene, Met1-5 was expressed transiently after the induction of somatic embryogenesis by 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D), before the formation of embryogenic cell clumps. These findings suggested the significance of DNA methylation in acquiring the embryogenic competence in somatic cells in carrot.

Suppression of histone H1 genes in Arabidopsis results in heritable developmental defects and stochastic changes in DNA methylation

Histone H1 is an abundant component of eukaryotic chromatin that is thought to stabilize higher-order chromatin structures. However, the complete knock-out of H1 genes in several lower eukaryotes has no discernible effect on their appearance or viability. In higher eukaryotes, the presence of many mutually compensating isoforms of this protein has made assessment of the global function of H1 more difficult. We have used double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) silencing to suppress all the H1 genes of Arabidopsis thaliana. Plants with a >90% reduction in H1 expression exhibited a spectrum of aberrant developmental phenotypes, some of them resembling those observed in DNA hypomethylation mutants. In subsequent generations these defects segregated independently of the anti-H1 dsRNA construct. Downregulation of H1 genes did not cause substantial genome-wide DNA hypo- or hypermethylation. However, it was correlated with minor but statistically significant changes in the methylation patterns of repetitive and single-copy sequences, occurring in a stochastic manner. These findings reveal an important and previously unrecognized link between linker histones and specific patterns of DNA methylation.

Role of a nonselective de novo DNA methyltransferase in maternal inheritance of chloroplast genes in the green alga, Chlamydomonas reinhardtii

In the green alga, Chlamydomonas, chloroplast DNA is maternally transmitted to the offspring. We previously hypothesized that the underlying molecular mechanism involves specific methylation of maternal gamete DNA before mating, protecting against degradation. To obtain direct evidence for this, we focused on a DNA methyltransferase, DMT1, which was previously shown to be localized in chloroplasts. The full-length DMT1 protein with a molecular mass of 150 kD was expressed in insect cells, and its catalytic activity was determined. In vitro assays using synthetic DNA indicated methylation of all cytosine residues, with no clear selectivity in terms of the neighboring nucleotides. Subsequently, transgenic paternal cells constitutively expressing DMT1 were constructed and direct methylation mapping assays of their DNA showed a clear nonselective methylation of chloroplast DNA. When transgenic paternal cells were crossed with wild-type maternal cells, the frequency of biparental and paternal offspring of chloroplasts increased up to 23% while between wild-type strains it was approximately 3%. The results indicate that DMT1 is a novel type of DNA methyltransferase with a nonselective cytosine methylation activity, and that chloroplast DNA methylation by DMT1 is one of factors influencing maternal inheritance of chloroplast genes.

Epigenetic control of CACTA transposon mobility in Arabidopsis thaliana

Epigenetic mutation, heritable developmental variation not based on a change in nucleotide sequence, is widely reported in plants. However, the developmental and evolutionary significance of such mutations remains enigmatic. On the basis of our studies of the endogenous Arabidopsis transposon CACTA, we propose that the inheritance of epigenetic gene silencing over generations can function as a transgenerational genome defense mechanism against deleterious movement of transposons. We previously reported that silent CACTA1 is mobilized by the DNA hypomethylation mutation ddm1 (decrease in DNA methylation). In this study, we report that CACTA activated by the ddm1 mutation remains mobile in the presence of the wild-type DDM1 gene, suggesting that de novo silencing is not efficient for the defense of the genome against CACTA movement. The defense depends on maintenance of transposon silencing over generations. In addition, we show that the activated CACTA1 element transposes throughout the genome in DDM1 plants, as reported previously for ddm1 backgrounds. Furthermore, the CACTA1 element integrated into both the ddm1-derived and the DDM1-derived chromosomal regions in the DDM1 wild-type plants, demonstrating that this class of transposons does not exhibit targeted integration into heterochromatin, despite its accumulation in the pericentromeric regions in natural populations. The possible contribution of natural selection as a mechanism for the accumulation of transposons and evolution of heterochromatin is discussed.

The effect of stress on genome regulation and structure

BACKGROUND

Stresses exert evolutionary pressures on all organisms, which have developed sophisticated responses to cope and survive. These responses involve cellular physiology, gene regulation and genome remodelling.

SCOPE

In this review, the effects of stress on genomes and the connected responses are considered. Recent developments in our understanding of epigenetic genome regulation, including the role of RNA interference (RNAi), suggest a function for this in stress initiation and response. We review our knowledge of how different stresses, tissue culture, pathogen attack, abiotic stress, and hybridization, affect genomes. Using allopolyploid hybridization as an example, we examine mechanisms that may mediate genomic responses, focusing on RNAi-mediated perturbations.

CONCLUSIONS

A common response to stresses may be the relaxation of epigenetic regulation, leading to activation of suppressed sequences and secondary effects as regulatory systems attempt to re-establish genomic order.

Interaction of Polycomb-group proteins controlling flowering in Arabidopsis

In Arabidopsis, the EMBYRONIC FLOWER2 (EMF2), VERNALISATION2 (VRN2) and FERTILISATION INDEPENDENT ENDOSPERM2 (FIS2) genes encode related Polycomb-group (Pc-G) proteins. Their homologues in animals act together with other Pc-G proteins as part of a multimeric complex, Polycomb Repressive Complex 2 (PRC2), which functions as a histone methyltransferase. Despite similarities between the fis2 mutant phenotype and those of some other plant Pc-G members, it has remained unclear how the FIS2/EMF2/VRN2 class Pc-G genes interact with the others. We have identified a weak emf2 allele that reveals a novel phenotype with striking similarity to that of severe mutations in another Pc-G gene, CURLY LEAF (CLF), suggesting that the two genes may act in a common pathway. Consistent with this, we demonstrate that EMF2 and CLF interact genetically and that this reflects interaction of their protein products through two conserved motifs, the VEFS domain and the C5 domain. We show that the full function of CLF is masked by partial redundancy with a closely related gene, SWINGER (SWN), so that null clf mutants have a much less severe phenotype than emf2 mutants. Analysis in yeast further indicates a potential for the CLF and SWN proteins to interact with the other VEFS domain proteins VRN2 and FIS2. The functions of individual Pc-G members may therefore be broader than single mutant phenotypes reveal. We suggest that plants have Pc-G protein complexes similar to the Polycomb Repressive Complex2 (PRC2) of animals, but the duplication and subsequent diversification of components has given rise to different complexes with partially discrete functions.

A cluster of Arabidopsis genes with a coordinate response to an environmental stimulus

Vernalization, the promotion of flowering after prolonged exposure to low temperatures, is an adaptive response of plants ensuring that flowering occurs at a propitious time in the annual seasonal cycle. In Arabidopsis, FLOWERING LOCUS C (FLC), which encodes a repressor of flowering, is a key gene in the vernalization response; plants with high-FLC expression respond to vernalization by downregulating FLC and thereby flowering at an earlier time. Vernalization has the hallmarks of an epigenetically regulated process. The downregulation of FLC by low temperatures is maintained throughout vegetative development but is reset at each generation. During our study of vernalization, we have found that a small gene cluster, including FLC and its two flanking genes, is coordinately regulated in response to genetic modifiers, to the environmental stimulus of vernalization, and in plants with low levels of DNA methylation. Genes encoded on foreign DNA inserted into the cluster also acquire the low-temperature response. At other chromosomal locations, FLC maintains its response to vernalization and imposes a parallel response on a flanking gene. This suggests that FLC contains sequences that confer changes in gene expression extending beyond FLC itself, perhaps through chromatin modification.

Chromatin dynamics and Arabidopsis development

The plant life cycle involves a series of developmental phase transitions. These transitions require the regulation and highly co-ordinated expression of many genes. Epigenetic controls have now been shown to be a key element of this mechanism of regulation. In the model plant Arabidopsis, recent genetic and molecular studies on chromatin have begun to dissect the molecular basis of these epigenetic controls. Chromatin dynamics represent the emerging and exciting field of gene regulation notably involved in plant developmental transitions. By comparing plant and animal systems, new insights into the molecular complexes and mechanisms governing development can be delineated. We are now beginning to identify the components of chromatin complexes and their functions.

Association between up-regulation of stress-responsive genes and hypomethylation of genomic DNA in tobacco plants

Transcripts that specifically accumulate in transgenic tobacco plants expressing an anti-sense construct for a tobacco type I DNA methyltransferase, NtMET1, were screened by the differential display method. Of the 31 genes identified, 16 encoded proteins with known functions; ten of these were related to biotic and abiotic stress responses, and the other six to cellular functions. In order to examine whether expression of these genes is correlated with DNA methylation status under natural stress conditions, a pathogen-responsive gene (NtAlix1) was selected as representative, and assayed for transcript induction and genomic methylation in tobacco plants infected with tobacco mosaic virus (TMV). In inoculated leaves of wild-type plants, NtAlix1 transcripts began to accumulate 12 h after the onset of the hypersensitive response (HR), and levels remained high for up to 24 h. Changes in the methylation status at the locus became obvious 24 h later, as detected by digestion of genomic DNA with a methylation-sensitive restriction enzyme. The results suggest that the level of DNA methylation may change in response to external stresses, and that this is closely related to the activation of stress-responsive genes.

Aberrant endosperm development in interploidy crosses reveals a timer of differentiation

The common assumption that the seed failure in interploidy crosses of flowering plants is due to parental genomic imprinting is based on vague interpretations and needs reevaluation since the general question is involved, how differentiation is timed so that cell progenies, while specializing, pass through proper numbers of amplification divisions before proliferation ceases. As recently confirmed, endosperm differentiation is accelerated or de-accelerated, depending upon whether polyploid females are crossed with diploid males, or vice-versa. Unlike the zygote, the first cell of the endosperm is determined to produce a tissue that successively induces growth of maternal tissues, stimulates and nourishes the embryo, and finally ceases cell cycling. Altered timing of endosperm differentiation, thus, perturbs seed development. During fertilization, only the female genomes contribute cytoplasmic equivalents to endosperm development so that in interploidy crosses, the initial amount of cytoplasm per chromosome set is altered, and due to semi-autonomy of cytoplasmic growth, altered numbers of division cycles are needed to provide the amount of cytoplasmic organelles required for differentiation. Cytoplasmic semi-autonomy and dependence of differentiation on an increase in cytoplasm has been shown in other tissues of plants and animals, thus, revealing a common mechanism for intracellular timing of differentiation. As demonstrated, imprinted genes can alter the extent of cell proliferation by interfering with this mechanism.

Identification of new members of Fertilisation Independent Seed Polycomb Group pathway involved in the control of seed development in Arabidopsis thaliana

In higher plants, double fertilisation initiates seed development. One sperm cell fuses with the egg cell and gives rise to the embryo, the second sperm cell fuses with the central cell and gives rise to the endosperm. The endosperm develops as a syncytium with the gradual organisation of domains along an anteroposterior axis defined by the position of the embryo at the anterior pole and by the attachment to the placenta at the posterior pole. We report that ontogenesis of the posterior pole in Arabidopsis thaliana involves oriented migration of nuclei in the syncytium. We show that this migration is impaired in mutants of the three founding members of the FERTILIZATION INDEPENDENT SEED (FIS) class, MEDEA (MEA), FIS2 and FERTILIZATION INDEPENDENT ENDOSPERM (FIE). A screen based on a green fluorescent protein (GFP) reporter line allowed us to identify two new loci in the FIS pathway, medicis and borgia. We have cloned the MEDICIS gene and show that it encodes the Arabidopsis homologue of the yeast WD40 domain protein MULTICOPY SUPRESSOR OF IRA (MSI1). The mutations at the new fis loci cause the same cellular defects in endosperm development as other fis mutations, including parthenogenetic development, absence of cellularisation, ectopic development of posterior structures and overexpression of the GFP marker.

The role of MET1 in RNA-directed de novo and maintenance methylation of CG dinucleotides

A genetic screen for mutants defective in RNA-directed DNA methylation and transcriptional silencing of the constitutive nopaline synthase (NOS) promoter in Arabidopsis identified two independent mutations in the gene encoding the DNA methyltransferase MET1. Both mutant alleles are disrupted structurally in the MET1 catalytic domain, suggesting that they are complete loss of function alleles. Experiments designed to test the effect of a met1 mutation on both RNA-directed de novo and maintenance methylation of the target NOS promoter revealed in each case approximately wild type levels of non-CG methylation together with significant reductions of CG methylation. These results confirm a requirement for MET1 to maintain CG methylation induced by RNA. In addition, the failure to establish full CG methylation in met1 mutants, despite normal RNA-directed de novo methylation of Cs in other sequence contexts, indicates that MET1 is required for full de novo methylation of CG dinucleotides. We discuss MET1 as a site-specific DNA methyltransferase that is able to maintain CG methylation during DNA replication and contribute to CG de novo methylation in response to RNA signals.

DNA methylation in insects

Cytosine DNA methylation has been demonstrated in numerous eukaryotic organisms and has been shown to play an important role in human disease. The function of DNA methylation has been studied extensively in vertebrates, but establishing its primary role has proved difficult and controversial. Analysing methylation in insects has indicated an apparent functional diversity that seems to argue against a strict functional conservation. To investigate this hypothesis, we here assess the data reported in four different insect species in which DNA methylation has been analysed more thoroughly: the fruit fly Drosophila melanogaster, the cabbage moth Mamestra brassicae, the peach-potato aphid Myzus persicae and the mealybug Planococcus citri.

Role of the DRM and CMT3 methyltransferases in RNA-directed DNA methylation

RNA interference is a conserved process in which double-stranded RNA is processed into 21-25 nucleotide siRNAs that trigger posttranscriptional gene silencing. In addition, plants display a phenomenon termed RNA-directed DNA methylation (RdDM) in which DNA with sequence identity to silenced RNA is de novo methylated at its cytosine residues. This methylation is not only at canonical CpG sites but also at cytosines in CpNpG and asymmetric sequence contexts. In this report, we study the role of the DRM and CMT3 DNA methyltransferase genes in the initiation and maintenance of RdDM. Neither drm nor cmt3 mutants affected the maintenance of preestablished RNA-directed CpG methylation. However, drm mutants showed a nearly complete loss of asymmetric methylation and a partial loss of CpNpG methylation. The remaining asymmetric and CpNpG methylation was dependent on the activity of CMT3, showing that DRM and CMT3 act redundantly to maintain non-CpG methylation. These DNA methyltransferases appear to act downstream of siRNAs, since drm1 drm2 cmt3 triple mutants show a lack of non-CpG methylation but elevated levels of siRNAs. Finally, we demonstrate that DRM activity is required for the initial establishment of RdDM in all sequence contexts including CpG, CpNpG, and asymmetric sites.

Comparative analysis of DNA methylation patterns in transgenic Drosophila overexpressing mouse DNA methyltransferases

DNA methyltransferases (Dnmts) mediate the epigenetic modification of eukaryotic genomes. Mammalian DNA methylation patterns are established and maintained by co-operative interactions among the Dnmt proteins Dnmt1, Dnmt3a and Dnmt3b. Owing to their simultaneous presence in mammalian cells, the activities of individual Dnmt have not yet been determined. This includes a fourth putative Dnmt, namely Dnmt2, which has failed to reveal any activity in previous assays. We have now established transgenic Drosophila strains that allow for individual overexpression of all known mouse Dnmts. Quantitative analysis of genomic cytosine methylation levels demonstrated a robust Dnmt activity for the de novo methyltransferases Dnmt3a and Dnmt3b. In addition, we also detected a weak but significant activity for Dnmt2. Subsequent methylation tract analysis by genomic bisulphite sequencing revealed that Dnmt3 enzymes preferentially methylated CpG dinucleotides in a processive manner, whereas Dnmt2 methylated isolated cytosine residues in a non-CpG dinucleotide context. Our results allow a direct comparison of the activities of mammalian Dnmts and suggest a significant functional specialization of these enzymes.

Flower development: initiation, differentiation, and diversification

Flowering is one of the most intensively studied processes in plant development. Despite the wide diversity in floral forms, flowers have a simple stereotypical architecture. Flowers develop from florally determined meristems. These small populations of cells proliferate to form the floral organs, including the sterile outer organs, the sepals and petals, and the inner reproductive organs, the stamens and carpels. In the past decade, analyses of key flowering genes have been carried out primarily in Arabidopsis and have provided a foundation for understanding the underlying molecular genetic mechanisms controlling different aspects of floral development. Such studies have illuminated the transcriptional cascades responsible for the regulation of these key genes, as well as how these genes effect their functions. In turn, these studies have resulted in the refinement of the original ideas of how flowers develop and have indicated the gaps in our knowledge that need to be addressed.

Extensive maternal DNA hypomethylation in the endosperm of Zea mays

A PCR-based genomic scan has been undertaken to estimate the extent and ratio of maternally versus paternally methylated DNA regions in endosperm, embryo, and leaf of Zea mays (maize). Analysis of several inbred lines and their reciprocal crosses identified a large number of conserved, differentially methylated DNA regions (DMRs) that were specific to the endosperm. DMRs were hypomethylated at specific methylation-sensitive restriction sites upon maternal transmission, whereas upon paternal transmission, the methylation levels were similar to those observed in embryo and leaf. Maternal hypomethylation was extensive and offers a likely explanation for the 13% reduction in methyl-cytosine content of the endosperm compared with leaf tissue. DMRs showed identity to expressed genic regions, were observed early after fertilization, and maintained at a later stage of endosperm development. The implications of extensive maternal hypomethylation with respect to endosperm development and epigenetic reprogramming will be discussed.

Epigenetic control of plant development: new layers of complexity

Important aspects of plant development are under epigenetic control, that is, under the control of heritable changes in gene expression that are not associated with alterations in DNA sequence. It is becoming clear that RNA molecules play a key role in epigenetic gene regulation by providing sequence specificity for the targeting of developmentally important genes. RNA-based control of gene expression can be exerted posttranscriptionally by interfering with transcript stability or translation. Moreover, RNA molecules also appear to direct developmentally relevant gene regulation at the transcriptional level by modifying chromatin structure and/or DNA methylation.

One-Way Control of FWA Imprinting in Arabidopsis Endosperm by DNA Methylation

The Arabidopsis FWA gene was initially identified from late-flowering epigenetic mutants that show ectopic FWA expression associated with heritable hypomethylation of repeats around transcription starting sites. Here, we show that wild-type FWA displays imprinted (maternal origin-specific) expression in endosperm. The FWA imprint depends on the maintenance DNA methyltransferase MET1, as is the case in mammals. Unlike mammals, however, the FWA imprint is not established by allele-specific de novo methylation. It is established by maternal gametophyte-specific gene activation, which depends on a DNA glycosylase gene, DEMETER. Because endosperm does not contribute to the next generation, the activated FWA gene need not be silenced again. Double fertilization enables plants to use such "one-way" control of imprinting and DNA methylation in endosperm.

DNA methylation and epigenetics

In many eukaryotes, including plants, DNA methylation provides a heritable mark that guides formation of transcriptionally silent heterochromatin. In plants, aberrant RNA signals direct DNA methylation to target sequences, sometimes appropriately and sometimes inappropriately. This chapter discusses the generation of RNA signals for epigenetic changes, the factors that mediate those changes, and some of the consequences of those changes for plant gene expression and genome integrity.

Characterization of two rice DNA methyltransferase genes and RNAi-mediated reactivation of a silenced transgene in rice callus

Two genomic clones ( OsMET1-1, AF 462029 and OsMET1-2, TPA BK001405), each encoding a cytosine-5 DNA methyltransferase (MTase), were isolated from rice ( Oryza sativa L.) BAC libraries. OsMET1-1 has an open reading frame of 4,566 nucleotides with 12 exons and 11 introns while OsMET1-2 has an open reading frame of 4,491 nucleotides with 11 exons and 10 introns. Although OsMET1-1 and OsMET1-2 have high sequence similarity overall, they share only 24% identity in exon 1, and intron 3 of OsMET1-1 is absent from OsMET1-2. As for other eukaryotic DNA MTases of the Dnmt1/MET l class, the derived amino acid sequences of OsMET1-1 and OsMET1-2 suggest that they are comprised of two-thirds regulatory domain and one-third catalytic domain. Most functional domains identified for other MTases were present in the rice MET1 sequences. Amino acid sequence comparison indicated high similarity (56-75% identity) of rice MET1 proteins to other plant MET1 sequences but limited similarity (approx. 24% identity) to animal Dnmt1 proteins. Genomic blot and database analysis indicated the presence of a single copy of OsMET1-1 (on chromosome 3) and single copy of OsMET1-2 (on chromosome 7). Ribonuclease protection assays revealed expression of both OsMET1-1 and OsMET1-2 in highly dividing cells, but the steady-state level of OsMET1-2 was 7- to 12-fold higher than that for OsMET1-1 in callus, root and inflorescence. The functional involvement of the rice DNA MTases in gene silencing was investigated using an RNAi strategy. Inverted repeat constructs of either the N- or C-terminal regions of OsMET1-1 were supertransformed into calli derived from a rice line bearing a silenced 35S-uidA-nos transgene. Restoration of uidA expression in the bombarded calli was consistent with the inactivation of maintenance methylation and with previous evidence for the involvement of methylation in silencing of this line.

Characteristics of RNA silencing in plants: similarities and differences across kingdoms

RNA silencing is a collective term that encompasses the sequence of events that leads to the targeted degradation of cellular mRNA and thus to the silencing of corresponding gene expression. RNA silencing is initiated after introduction into the host genome of a gene that is homologous to an endogenous gene. Transcription of the introduced gene results in the formation of double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) that is cut into smaller dsRNA species termed small interfering RNAs (siRNAs) by an RNaseIII-like enzyme called 'Dicer'. siRNAs associate with a protein complex termed the 'RNA-induced silencing complex' (RISC), which mediates the binding of one strand of siRNAs with mRNAs transcribed from the native 'target' gene. The binding of siRNAs with native gene mRNAs earmarks native gene mRNAs for destruction, resulting in gene silencing. In plants, RNA silencing appears to serve as a defence mechanism against viral pathogens and also to suppress the activity of virus-like mobile genetic elements. In an apparent response to RNA silencing, some plant viruses express suppressors of RNA silencing. RNA silencing also is directly implicated in the regulation of the function(s) of microRNAs, which are the key determinants in an additional cellular mechanism related to the translational repression of genes, the effect of which ultimately impinges on development. The high degree of sequence similarity that exists between genes involved in RNA silencing in widely different organisms underscores the conserved nature of many aspects of the RNA silencing mechanism. However, depending (for example) on the precise nature of the target gene involved, there also are significant differences in the silencing pathways that are engaged by various organisms.

Structure and function of eukaryotic DNA methyltransferases

DNA methylation is a common epigenetic modification found in eukaryotic organisms ranging from fungi to mammals. Over the past 15 years, a number of eukaryotic DNA methyltransferases have been identified from various model organisms. These enzymes exhibit distinct biochemical properties and biological functions, partly due to their structural differences. The highly variable N-terminal extensions of these enzymes harbor various evolutionarily conserved domains and motifs, some of which have been shown to be involved in functional specializations. DNA methylation has divergent functions in different organisms, consistent with the notion that it is a dynamically evolving mechanism that can be adapted to fulfill various functions. Genetic studies using model organisms have provided evidence suggesting the progressive integration of DNA methylation into eukaryotic developmental programs during evolution.

Imprinting of the MEA Polycomb Gene Is Controlled by Antagonism between MET1 Methyltransferase and DME Glycosylase

The MEA Polycomb gene is imprinted in the Arabidopsis endosperm. DME DNA glycosylase activates maternal MEA allele expression in the central cell of the female gametophyte, the progenitor of the endosperm. Maternal mutant dme or mea alleles result in seed abortion. We identified mutations that suppress dme seed abortion and found that they reside in the MET1 methyltransferase gene, which maintains cytosine methylation. Seeds with maternal dme and met1 alleles survive, indicating that suppression occurs in the female gametophyte. Suppression requires a maternal wild-type MEA allele, suggesting that MET1 functions upstream of, or at, MEA. DME activates whereas MET1 suppresses maternal MEA::GFP allele expression in the central cell. MET1 is required for DNA methylation of three regions in the MEA promoter in seeds. Our data suggest that imprinting is controlled in the female gametophyte by antagonism between the two DNA-modifying enzymes, MET1 methyltransferase and DME DNA glycosylase.

Preferential de novo methylation of cytosine residues in non-CpG sequences by a domains rearranged DNA methyltransferase from tobacco plants

In plant DNA, cytosines in symmetric CpG and CpNpG (N is A, T, or C) are thought to be methylated by DNA methyltransferases, MET1 and CMT3, respectively. Cytosines in asymmetric CpNpN are also methylated, and genetic analysis has suggested the responsible enzyme to be domains rearranged methyltransferase (DRM). We cloned a tobacco cDNA, encoding a novel protein consisting of 608 amino acids, that resembled DRMs found in maize and Arabidopsis and designated this as NtDRM1. The protein could be shown to be localized exclusively in the nucleus and exhibit methylation activity toward unmethylated synthetic as well as native DNA samples upon expression in Sf9 insect cells. It also methylated hemimethylated DNA, but the activity was lower than that for unmethylated substrates. Methylation mapping of a 962-bp DNA, treated with NtDRM1 in vitro, directly demonstrated methylation of approximately 70% of the cytosines in methylatable CpNpN and CpNpG sequences but only 10% in CpG. Further analyses indicated that the enzyme apparently non-selectively methylates any cytosines except in CpG, regardless of the adjacent nucleotide at both 5' and 3' ends. Transcripts of NtDRM1 ubiquitously accumulated in all tissues and during the cell cycle in tobacco cultured BY2 cells. These results indicate that NtDRM1 is a de novo cytosine methyltransferase, which actively excludes CpG substrate.

Methylation of the exon/intron region in the Ubi1 promoter complex correlates with transgene silencing in barley

Methylation of plant promoters is often associated with transcriptional gene silencing, while methylation of the transcribed region is associated with post-transcriptional gene silencing. Promoter complexes that include the first untranslated exon and intron, such as maize ubiquitin1 and rice actin1, have been widely used in monocot transformation because they support higher levels of transient transgene expression than the core promoter does. However, persistent problems with transgene silencing driven by these promoter complexes brought up a troubling question: were higher initial levels of transgene expression at the expense of long-term expression stability? Here we report that methylation of an untranslated exon and intron in the promoter complex is correlated with transcriptional transgene silencing in barley. Two sibling sublines, designated T(3)30 and T(3)31, were identified in a homozygous T3 population from a single transgenic parental line. In the T6 generation, all progeny of one subline, T(3)30, expressed ubiquitin-driven bar and uidA, but both transgenes were transcriptionally silenced in the other subline, T(3)31. Although the structure of the transgene locus is complex, no differences in the physical structure or location of the locus were detected between the two sublines. Transcriptional transgene silencing in T(3)31 correlated with two molecular events: methylation of the first untranslated exon and 5' end of the intron of the promoter complex, and condensation of the chromatin in regions containing transgenes. Passage of the non-silenced subline through in vitro culture recreated the silenced phenotype of T(3)31 and the molecular events leading to its silencing.

Strand-biased DNA methylation associated with centromeric regions in Arabidopsis

The Arabidopsis genome project assembled 15 megabases of heterochromatic sequence, facilitating investigations of heterochromatin assembly, maintenance, and structure. In many species, large quantities of methylcytosine decorate heterochromatin; these modifications are typically maintained by methyltransferases that recognize newly replicated hemimethylated DNA. We assessed the extent and patterns of Arabidopsis heterochromatin methylation by amplifying and sequencing genomic DNA treated with bisulfite, which converts cytosine, but not methylcytosine, to uracil. This survey revealed unexpected asymmetries in methylation patterns, with one helix strand often exhibiting higher levels of methylation. We confirmed these observations both by immunoprecipitating methylated DNA strands and by restriction enzyme digestion of amplified, bisulfite-treated DNA. We also developed a primer-extension assay that can monitor the methylation status of an entire chromosome, demonstrating that strand-specific methylation occurs predominantly in the centromeric regions. Conventional models for methylation maintenance do not explain these unusual patterns; instead, new models that allow for strand specificity are required. The abundance of Arabidopsis strand-specific modifications points to their importance, perhaps as epigenetic signals that mark the heterochromatic regions that confer centromere activity.

Ten members of the Arabidopsis gene family encoding methyl-CpG-binding domain proteins are transcriptionally active and at least one, AtMBD11, is crucial for normal development

Animal proteins that contain a methyl-CpG-binding domain (MBD) are suggested to provide a link between DNA methylation, chromatin remodelling and gene silencing. However, some MBD proteins reside in chromatin remodelling complexes, but do not have specific affinity for methylated DNA. It has recently been shown that the Arabidopsis genome contains 12 putative genes encoding proteins with domains similar to MBD, of which at least three bind symmetrically methylated DNA. Using a bioinformatics approach, we have identified additional domains in a number of these proteins and, on this basis and extended sequence similarity, divided the proteins into subgroups. Using RT-PCR we show that 10 of the AtMBD genes are active and differentially expressed in diverse tissues. To investigate the biological significance of AtMBD proteins, we have transformed Arabidopsis with a construct aimed at RNA interference with expression of the AtMBD11 gene, normally active in most tissues. The resulting 35S::AtMBD11-RNAi plants displayed a variety of phenotypic effects, including aerial rosettes, serrated leaves, abnormal position of flowers, fertility problems and late flowering. Arabidopsis lines with reduced expression of genes involved in chromatin remodelling and transgene silencing show similar phenotypes. Our results suggest an important role for AtMBD proteins in plant development.

Genetic Control of Developmental Changes Induced by Disruption of Arabidopsis Histone Deacetylase 1 (AtHD1) Expression

Little is known about the role of genetic and epigenetic control in the spatial and temporal regulation of plant development. Overexpressing antisense Arabidopsis thaliana HD1 (AtHD1) encoding a putative major histone deacetylase induces pleiotropic effects on plant growth and development. It is unclear whether the developmental abnormalities are caused by a defective AtHD1 or related homologs and are heritable in selfing progeny. We isolated a stable antisense AtHD1 (CASH) transgenic line and a T-DNA insertion line in exon 2 of AtHD1, resulting in a null allele (athd1-t1). Both athd1-t1 and CASH lines display increased levels of histone acetylation and similar developmental abnormalities, which are heritable in the presence of antisense AtHD1 or in the progeny of homozygous (athd1-t1/athd1-t1) plants. Furthermore, when the athd1-t1/athd1-t1 plants are crossed to wild-type plants, the pleiotropic developmental abnormalities are immediately restored in the F1 hybrids, which correlates with AtHD1 expression and reduction of histone H4 Lys12 acetylation. Unlike the situation with the stable code of DNA and histone methylation, developmental changes induced by histone deacetylase defects are immediately reversible, probably through the restoration of a reversible histone acetylation code needed for the normal control of gene regulation and development.