Utility Assessment of Moderate to Severe Thyroid Eye Disease Health States

The burden of illness in thyroid eye disease: current state of the evidence

Introduction

Thyroid eye disease (TED) is a disabling autoimmune condition characterized by proptosis and progressive orbital inflammation involving the extraocular muscles, orbital fat, and connective tissues. Clinical features include facial disfigurement, diplopia, dry eyes, and in severe cases, vision loss. Consequently, individuals with TED suffer significant physical and psychological burdens that impact their quality of life. Currently, there is no standardized definition or International Classification of Diseases code for TED, and the disease landscape remains incompletely understood; moreover, TED diagnostic criteria and treatment recommendations have not been thoroughly assessed across diverse populations. It is necessary to better understand the clinical, humanistic, and economic burden of TED and identify gaps in our knowledge to improve TED management and outcomes.

Methods

To describe the current understanding of TED epidemiology, diagnosis, disease burden, and recent TED treatment guidelines, a targeted literature review was conducted, searching multiple databases using key words of specific search topics (i.e., TED; epidemiology, humanistic, economic, and clinical burden; treatment; and practice guidelines) for articles published between October 2013 and October 2023 in the United States, United Kingdom, and Europe (France, Germany, Italy, and Spain). Articles published between May 2014 and May 2024 describing diverse racial and sociodemographic presentations of TED were included.

Results

TED is a complex disease with an array of risk factors, including thyroid dysfunction, thyroid-stimulating immunoglobin, smoking, and comorbid conditions. The natural history of TED is not clearly defined, and diagnosis is complicated due to the array of phenotypes and orbital symptoms observed. Although novel first-line treatments are available in select countries, there is an unmet need for improved treatments for moderate-to-severe and sight-threatening TED. Individuals with TED continue to experience poor health-related quality of life due to the clinical burden that TED imposes along with large healthcare resource utilization costs and treatment costs, and economic evaluation studies are limited. Importantly, there is still a need for studies that explore diverse populations and the impact of race and ethnicity on the disease landscape.

Conclusion

TED remains an incompletely characterized disease with major knowledge gaps, particularly among historically underserved populations.

The role of IL-6 in thyroid eye disease: an update on emerging treatments

Elevated serum interleukin-6 (IL-6) levels have been shown to correlate with disease activity in patients with thyroid eye disease (TED), a complex, heterogeneous, autoimmune disease affecting thousands of people worldwide. IL-6 plays a pivotal role in the pathogenesis of TED through three key mechanisms that together may contribute to inflammation, tissue expansion, remodeling, and fibrosis within the orbit. First, IL-6 drives an autoimmune response targeting the thyroid-stimulating hormone receptor (TSHR) by promoting the production of autoantibodies (i.e. TSHR-Ab, TSI), thereby triggering TSHR-dependent immune pathways. Second, IL-6 stimulates the activation and differentiation of orbital fibroblasts, which contributes to the inflammatory process and increase adipogenesis. Finally, IL-6 stimulates T-cell-mediated inflammation, amplifying the immune response within orbital tissues. Although corticosteroids and surgery have served as mainstays of TED treatment, a multimodal approach is often required due to the disease's heterogeneous presentation and response to current treatment options. TED is a chronic, lifelong condition characterized by periods of exacerbation and remission, with inflammation playing a central role in disease progression and severity. Because inflammation can flare intermittently throughout a patient's life, there is growing interest in targeting specific components of the immune system to reduce disease activity and severity. This review focuses on the current evidence supporting IL-6 as a key mediator of TED pathogenesis and explores its potential as a diagnostic biomarker and therapeutic target of the disease.

Assessment of Hearing Dysfunction in Patients With Graves' Disease and Thyroid Eye Disease Without or With Teprotumumab

CONTEXT

Thyroid eye disease (TED) negatively affects quality of life. TED occurs predominantly in Graves' disease (GD). Teprotumumab improves TED but concern for hearing adverse events (AEs) has emerged. Hearing dysfunction is reported in thyroid autoimmune disease but the background prevalence in GD/TED without teprotumumab remains uncertain.

OBJECTIVE

This work aimed to quantify ear-related diagnostic codes/hearing AEs in GD, TED, and patients receiving teprotumumab by examining medical claims and clinical trials.

METHODS

Deidentified claims for ear/labyrinth-related International Classification of Disorders, Tenth Revision codes (KOMODO) were examined in GD patients without TED, and TED patients without/with teprotumumab treatment. Hearing AE incidence/severity was evaluated in teprotumumab clinical trials. Graves' Ophthalmopathy Quality of Life questionnaire (GO-QOL) scores were compared in teprotumumab TED trial patients without/with hearing AEs.

RESULTS

GD (469 720), TED (38 566) and teprotumumab-treated (967) patients were identified in the claims database. Ear-related codes (including those not specific for hearing) occurred in 24% GD, 33% TED, and 32% teprotumumab-treated patients. "Sensorineural hearing loss bilateral" was most frequent: 7% (32 961/469 720) GD, 11.1% (4279/38 566) TED, and 10.8% (104/967) teprotumumab patients. Before teprotumumab use, 17.1% (165) patients had ear-related codes, while 10.1% (98) had new ear-related codes post treatment.Eight teprotumumab oncology trials revealed 8.1% (51/633) had ear/labyrinth disorders with 2.1% (13) considered study-drug-related and 3.8% (24) hearing impairment/tinnitus-related AEs with 1.3% (8) considered study-drug-related. Similar rates occurred in TED trials.GO-QOL improved in teprotumumab-treated patients without/with hearing AEs. Incidence/severity was consistent across patients with chronic and acute TED.

CONCLUSION

These analyses indicate similar prevalence of hearing claims in patients with GD/TED alone as following teprotumumab treatment. Future analyses of incremental hearing risk from teprotumumab should use a priori study designs accounting for background hearing dysfunction in patients with GD/TED.

Investigating factors influencing quality of life in thyroid eye disease: insight from machine learning approaches

Aims

Thyroid eye disease (TED) is an autoimmune orbital disorder that diminishes the quality of life (QOL) in affected individuals. Graves' ophthalmopathy (GO)-QOL questionnaire effectively assesses TED's effect on patients. This study aims to investigate the factors influencing visual functioning (QOL-VF) and physical appearance (QOL-AP) scores in Chinese TED patients using innovative data analysis methods.

Methods

This cross-sectional study included 211 TED patients whose initial visit to our clinic was from July 2022 to March 2023. Patients with previous ophthalmic surgery or concurrent severe diseases were excluded. GO-QOL questionnaires, detailed medical histories and clinical examinations were collected. The distribution of GO-QOL scores was analyzed, and linear regression and machine learning algorithms were utilized.

Results

The median QOL-VF and QOL-AP scores were 64.29 and 62.5, respectively. Multivariate linear regression analysis revealed age (P = 0.013), ocular motility pain (P = 0.012), vertical strabismus (P < 0.001) and diplopia scores as significant predictors for QOL-VF. For QOL-AP, gender (P = 0.013) and clinical activity (P = 0.086) were significant. The XGBoost model demonstrated superior performance, with an R2 of 0.872 and a root mean square error of 11.083. Shapley additive explanations (SHAP) analysis highlighted the importance of vertical strabismus, diplopia score and age in influencing QOL-VF and age, clinical activity and sex in QOL-AP.

Conclusion

TED significantly affects patient QOL. The study highlights the efficacy of XGBoost and SHAP analyses in identifying key factors influencing the QOL in TED patients. Identifying effective interventions and considering specific demographic characteristics are essential to improving the QOL of patients with TED.

Assessment of health state utilities associated with adult and pediatric acid sphingomyelinase deficiency (ASMD)

INTRODUCTION

Acid sphingomyelinase deficiency (ASMD) type B is a rare genetic disorder leading to enlargement of the spleen and liver, pulmonary dysfunction, and other symptoms. Cost-utility analyses are often conducted to quantify the value of new treatments, and these analyses require health state utilities. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to estimate utilities associated with varying levels of severity of adult and pediatric ASMD type B.

METHODS

Seven adult and seven child health state vignettes describing ASMD were developed based on published literature, clinical trial results, and interviews with clinicians, patients with ASMD, and parents of children with ASMD. The health states were valued in time trade-off interviews with adult general population respondents in the UK.

RESULTS

Interviews were completed with 202 participants (50.0% female; mean age = 41.3 years). The health state representing ASMD without impairment had the highest mean utility for both the adult and child health states (0.92/0.94), and severe ASMD had the lowest mean utility (0.33/0.45). Every child health state had a significantly greater utility than the corresponding adult health state. Differences between adult/child paired states ranged from 0.02 to 0.13. Subgroup analyses explored the impact of parenting status on valuation of child health states.

DISCUSSION

Greater severity of ASMD was associated with lower mean utility. Results have implications for valuation of pediatric health states. The resulting utilities may be useful in cost-utility modeling estimating the value of treatment for ASMD.

Long-Term Efficacy of Teprotumumab in Thyroid Eye Disease: Follow-Up Outcomes in Three Clinical Trials

Introduction: Thyroid eye disease (TED) is an autoimmune process characterized by extraocular muscle and orbital fat remodeling/expansion resulting in swelling, pain, redness, proptosis, and diplopia. Teprotumumab, an insulin-like growth factor-I receptor inhibitor, demonstrated improvements in TED signs and symptoms in three adequately powered clinical trials of 24 weeks duration. Here we analyze the long-term maintenance of responses with teprotumumab from these trials. Methods: A total of 112 patients who received 7 or 8 infusions of teprotumumab in the Phase 2, Phase 3 (OPTIC study), and OPTIC Extension (OPTIC-X) studies were included in this analysis. Responses, including clinical activity score (CAS ≥2-point improvement), the European Group of Graves' Orbitopathy ophthalmic composite outcome, diplopia (≥1 Gorman grade improvement), proptosis (≥2 mm improvement), Overall (improvement in proptosis + CAS), and disease inactivation (CAS ≤1), were assessed and pooled from study baseline to week 24 (formal study) and up to week 72 (formal follow-up). Graves' Ophthalmopathy quality-of-life (GO-QoL) scores were also assessed. Outcomes included the percentages of observed patient responses from the study baseline. Additional alternative treatments for TED were assessed as a surrogate of persistent benefit from week 24 through week 120 (extended follow-up). Studies differed in the timing of follow-up visits, and data from some visits were unavailable. Results: At week 72, 52/57 (91.2%), 51/57 (89.5%), 35/48 (72.9%), 38/56 (67.9%), and 37/56 (66.1%) of patients were responders for CAS, composite outcome, diplopia, proptosis, and Overall response, respectively. The mean reduction in proptosis was 2.68 mm (SD 1.92, n = 56), mean GO-QoL improvement was 15.22 (SE 2.82, n = 56), and disease inactivation (CAS ≤1) was detected in 40/57 (70.2%). Over 99 weeks following teprotumumab therapy, 19/106 (17.9%) patients reported additional TED therapy during formal and extended follow-up. Conclusion: The long-term response to teprotumumab as observed 51 weeks after therapy was similar to week 24 results in the controlled clinical trials. Inflammatory and ophthalmic composite outcome improvements were seen in 90% of patients with nearly 70% reporting improvement in diplopia and proptosis. Further, 82% of patients in this analysis did not report additional TED treatment (including surgery) over 99 weeks following the final teprotumumab dose.

Bridging and Validation of the Specific Graves Ophthalmopathy Quality of Life Questionnaire With Health State Utility Values

OBJECTIVE

In thyroid eye disease (TED), inflammation and expansion of orbital muscle and periorbital fat result in diplopia and proptosis, severely impacting patient quality of life (QOL). The reported health state utility (HSU) scores, which are QOL measures, allow quantification of TED impact and improvement with therapies; however, no current QOL instrument has been validated with HSU scores for TED. Here, we used the disease-specific Graves Ophthalmopathy Quality of Life (GO-QOL) questionnaire and HSU scores to validate QOL impact.

METHODS

The GO-QOL scores from patients in 2 randomized, masked, placebo-controlled teprotumumab trials (N=171) were compared with 6 HSU values based on severity of proptosis/diplopia in those studies. Patient GO-QOL and HSU scores were compared at baseline and after 6-month treatment via regression analyses. GO-QOL and HSU scores were correlated for validation and quantification of QOL impact by severity state and to estimate quality-adjusted life year improvement.

RESULTS

GO-QOL scores were correlated with TED severity, indicating that worse severity was associated with lower (worse) GO-QOL scores. Less severe health states were represented by higher (better) GO-QOL scores. Importantly, GO-QOL scores were positively correlated with utility scores of the 6 health states, allowing for conversion of the GO-QOL scores to utility scores. A positive (improved) 0.013 utility change was found for each 1-point (positive) improvement in GO-QOL score produced by teprotumumab versus placebo.

CONCLUSION

Patients with moderate-to-severe active TED health states demonstrate increasing TED severity associated with declining utility values and worsening GO-QOL scores. These results indicate that the GO-QOL scores can be used to bridge to the HSU scores for benefit quantification.

Efficacy and Safety of Teprotumumab in Patients With Thyroid Eye Disease of Long Duration and Low Disease Activity

CONTEXT

Early inflammatory thyroid eye disease (TED) can lead to symptomatic chronic disease, including disabling proptosis. Teprotumumab, an insulin-like growth factor-1 receptor (IGF-1R) inhibitor, previously demonstrated efficacy in acute, high-inflammation TED trials.

OBJECTIVE

We present data from the first placebo-controlled trial with teprotumumab in chronic/low disease activity TED.

METHODS

This randomized double-masked, placebo-controlled trial, conducted at 11 US centers, enrolled adult participants with TED duration of 2 to 10 years, Clinical Activity Score (CAS) ≤ 1 or no additional inflammation or progression in proptosis/diplopia for ≥1 year, proptosis ≥3 mm from before TED and/or from normal, euthyroid/mildly hypo/hyperthyroid, no prior teprotumumab, and no steroids within 3 weeks of baseline. Patients received (2:1) intravenous teprotumumab or placebo once every 3 weeks (total 8 infusions). The primary endpoint was proptosis (mm) improvement at Week 24. Adverse events (AEs) were assessed.

RESULTS

A total of 62 (42 teprotumumab and 20 placebo) patients were randomized. At Week 24, least squares mean (SE) proptosis improvement was greater with teprotumumab (-2.41 [0.228]) than with placebo (-0.92 [0.323]), difference -1.48 (95% CI -2.28, -0.69; P = .0004). Proportions of patients with AEs were similar between groups. Hyperglycemia was reported in 6 (15%) vs 2 (10%) and hearing impairment in 9 (22%) vs 2 (10%) with teprotumumab and placebo, respectively. AEs led to discontinuation in 1 teprotumumab (left ear conductive hearing loss with congenital anomaly) and 1 placebo patient (infusion-related). There were no deaths.

CONCLUSION

Teprotumumab significantly improved proptosis vs placebo in longstanding/low inflammation TED, demonstrating efficacy regardless of disease duration/activity. The safety profile was comparable to that previously reported.

How patients experience thyroid eye disease

Objective

To determine the impact of thyroid eye disease (TED) on patients in various stages of the disease.

Background

TED is a debilitating and potentially sight-threatening inflammatory autoimmune disease that is frequently misdiagnosed. Challenging quality-of-life (QoL) issues can persist long after the active phase of disease has subsided.

Methods

A 62-question survey was designed as a hypothesis-generating instrument to identify key issues confronting patients ≥18 years old with physician-diagnosed TED. Questions focused primarily on physical and emotional status, and QoL experiences in the 2 months prior to the survey. Data for individual questions are presented as summary statistics. Correlations between questions were determined using χ2 analyses.

Results

The 443 respondents were 18 to >80 years old; >90% female, and >80% from the United States. Time since TED diagnosis ranged from <1 year to >10 years. Participants provided >500 free-form responses describing experiences of living with TED. Physical signs/symptoms were experienced by 307/443 (69%) patients. Of those responding to the QoL questions (N = 394), 53 (13%) reported symptoms improving, 73 (19%) reported symptoms worsening, and 255 (65%) reported no change in the 2 months prior to the survey. The most bothersome signs/symptoms were dry/gritty eyes, light sensitivity, bulging eyes, and pressure or pain behind the eyes. Respondents <60 years were significantly (p < 0.0001) more likely to report symptomatic TED than older patients. Of 394 respondents, 179 (45%) reported feeling depressed and/or anxious, 174 (44%) reported concern about their appearance, and 73 (19%) avoided public situations; 192 (49%) reported declines in confidence or feelings of general well-being, and 78 (20%) reported an inability to achieve goals. Activities limited by TED included reading, driving, and socializing. The proportion of respondents experiencing these negative QoL measures was higher when patients reported experiencing >5 symptoms, had been diagnosed within the last 5 years, or were <60 years of age.

Conclusions

Physical manifestations of TED impact QoL for patients through all phases of the disease. It is essential that physicians and healthcare professionals become more familiar with patient experiences such as those described here to better help patients manage their disease.