Immunomodulation with FK506 around the time of intravenous re-administration of an adenoviral vector facilitates gene transfer into primed rat liver

Improving adenovirus based gene transfer: strategies to accomplish immune evasion

Adenovirus (Ad) based gene transfer vectors continue to be the platform of choice for an increasing number of clinical trials worldwide. In fact, within the last five years, the number of clinical trials that utilize Ad based vectors has doubled, indicating growing enthusiasm for the numerous positive characteristics of this gene transfer platform. For example, Ad vectors can be easily and relatively inexpensively produced to high titers in a cGMP compliant manner, can be stably stored and transported, and have a broad applicability for a wide range of clinical conditions, including both gene therapy and vaccine applications. Ad vector based gene transfer will become more useful as strategies to counteract innate and/or pre-existing adaptive immune responses to Ads are developed and confirmed to be efficacious. The approaches attempting to overcome these limitations can be divided into two broad categories: pre-emptive immune modulation of the host, and selective modification of the Ad vector itself. The first category of methods includes the use of immunosuppressive drugs or specific compounds to block important immune pathways, which are known to be induced by Ads. The second category comprises several innovative strategies inclusive of: (1) Ad-capsid-display of specific inhibitors or ligands; (2) covalent modifications of the entire Ad vector capsid moiety; (3) the use of tissue specific promoters and local administration routes; (4) the use of genome modified Ads; and (5) the development of chimeric or alternative serotype Ads. This review article will focus on both the promise and the limitations of each of these immune evasion strategies, and in the process delineate future directions in developing safer and more efficacious Ad-based gene transfer strategies.

PEGylated Adenoviruses: From Mice to Monkeys

Covalent modification with polyethylene glycol (PEG), a non-toxic polymer used in food, cosmetic and pharmaceutical preparations for over 60 years, can profoundly influence the pharmacokinetic, pharmacologic and toxciologic profile of protein and peptide-based therapeutics. This review summarizes the history of PEGylation and PEG chemistry and highlights the value of this technology in the context of the design and development of recombinant viruses for gene transfer, vaccination and diagnostic purposes. Specific emphasis is placed on the application of this technology to the adenovirus, the most potent viral vector with the most highly characterized toxicity profile to date, in several animal models.

Transient pretreatment with glucocorticoid ablates innate toxicity of systemically delivered adenoviral vectors without reducing efficacy

More than 300 human clinical trials utilize recombinant adenoviruses (rAds) as a gene transfer vector, confirming that rAds continue to be of high clinical interest. A primary weakness of rAds is their known propensity to trigger an innate, proinflammatory immune response rapidly after high-dose, systemic administration. In this study, we investigated what affects that pre-emptive treatment with anti-inflammatory glucocorticoids might have upon Ad vector-triggered inflammatory immune responses. We found that a simple pretreatment regimen with Dexamethasone (DEX) can significantly reduce most Ad-induced innate immune responses. DEX prevented rAd induction of systemic cytokine/chemokine releases in a dose-dependent fashion, with higher dosages preventing rAd induction of acute thrombocytopenia, endothelial cell activation, proinflammatory gene induction, and leukocyte infiltration into transduced organs. Transient glucocorticoid pretreatment also significantly reduced rAd-induced adaptive immune responses, including a decreased induction of Ad-neutralizing antibodies (NAbs). Importantly, use of DEX did not reduce the efficacy of rAd-mediated gene transduction nor rAd-derived transgene expression. Our results demonstrate that a simple, pre-emptive and transient glucocorticoid pretreatment is a viable approach to reduce rAd-associated acute toxicities that currently limit the use of Ad vectors in systemic clinical applications.

Enhancement of Th2 responses to replicative herpes simplex virus type 1 vectors by immunomodulative chemotherapy

Replicating, neuroattenuated gamma(1)34.5-deleted herpes simplex virus (HSV)-vectors are tools for experimental therapy of gliomas and autoimmune diseases. Immunomodulative treatment with Linomide (quinoline-3-carboxamide) has earlier been shown to facilitate some virus infections and reduce autoimmunity. Now we aimed at elucidating the safety of immunomodulatory therapy during infection of mice with HSV vectors. We focused on immunological and virological changes in the nervous system. BALB/c mice were infected intranasally with the HSV-1 recombinant viruses R3616, R3659 and R8306 (with mouse IL-4 transgene) and either treated with Linomide or left untreated as control groups. Treatment with Linomide was started 7 days before infection. Virological analysis consisted of viral culture and PCR for HSV DNA. Cytokine responses were studied with quantitative RT-PCR and EIA. Immunomodulatory treatment did not change the clinical course of infections. The expression of IL-4 and IL-10 in brains increased in Linomide-treated mice, particularly in infection with R8306. The expression of IL-23p19 was decreased in brains in Linomide-treated, vector-infected mice, in comparison with nontreated but virus-infected animals. Immunomodulatory treatment did not increase the viral load in brains in any of the mouse groups infected with R3616, R3659 or R8306. Immunomodulative treatment with Linomide did not compromise the safety of replicating HSV-vectors, not even the one with IL-4 transgene, suggesting that combination of immunomodulation with virotherapy may be beneficial in the treatment of certain diseases of the central nervous system. Further investigations are needed to elucidate the effects of immunomodulatory therapy in order to improve vector survival and efficacy of gene therapy.

Gutless adenovirus: last-generation adenovirus for gene therapy

Last-generation adenovirus vectors, also called helper-dependent or gutless adenovirus, are very attractive for gene therapy because the associated in vivo immune response is highly reduced compared to first- and second-generation adenovirus vectors, while maintaining high transduction efficiency and tropism. Nowadays, gutless adenovirus is administered in different organs, such as the liver, muscle or the central nervous system achieving high-level and long-term transgene expression in rodents and primates. However, as devoid of all viral coding regions, gutless vectors require viral proteins supplied in trans by a helper virus. To remove contamination by a helper virus from the final preparation, different systems based on the excision of the helper-packaging signal have been generated. Among them, Cre-loxP system is mostly used, although contamination levels still are 0.1-1% too high to be used in clinical trials. Recently developed strategies to avoid/reduce helper contamination were reviewed.

Immune responses against adenoviral vectors and their transgene products: a review of strategies for evasion

Human adenoviruses have been adopted as attractive vectors for in vivo gene therapy since they have a well-characterized genomic organization, can be grown to high titres and efficiently transduce a wide spectrum of dividing and non-dividing cells. However, the first-generation of adenoviral (Ad) vectors yielded only transient expression of the transgene in most immunocompetent mice. This constituted a major limitation of this early vector type. In contrast, persistent transgene expression can be established in immunodeficient mice. This suggests that the immunogenicity of adenoviral vectors limits the effective period of adenovirus-based gene therapy. Much effort has been put in devising strategies to circumvent the limitations imposed onto gene therapy by the immune system. Improvements in vector design have significantly improved the performance of the adenovirus vectors. Based on these results it is reasonable to anticipate that new modifications of the vectors will overcome some of the immunological barriers and will further expand the applicability of adenovirus-derived vectors.

Simple and effective osteoinductive gene therapy by local injection of a bone morphogenetic protein-2-expressing recombinant adenoviral vector and FK506 mixture in rats

We have previously utilized a human bone morphogenetic protein-2 (BMP-2)-expressing recombinant adenoviral vector (AxCAOBMP-2) for osteoinductive gene therapy in rats. However, immunosuppression is essential for osteoinduction by AxCAOBMP-2 and this is one of the major impediments to its clinical use. Injection of AxCAOBMP-2 together with the immunosuppressant FK506 made it possible to markedly reduce the dose of the immunosuppressive agent and still induce ectopic bone reliably. We injected AxCAOBMP-2 and FK506 into the right calf muscle of rats, while the same number of plaque forming units of AxCAOBMP-2 and the same dose of FK506 placebo (vehicle) were injected into the left calf muscle. At 1, 3, 5, 7, 9 days after injection, BMP-2 mRNA expression was significantly higher in the right calf muscle than in the left calf muscle. At 21 days after injection, significantly more ectopic bone was observed in the right calf muscle than in the left calf muscle. These results indicate that coinjection of FK506 significantly promotes osteoinduction. In addition, local injection of FK506 may also make it possible to prevent a decrease of gene expression with other adenoviral vector.

Overcoming the immune response to permit ex vivo gene therapy for spine fusion with human type 5 adenoviral delivery of the LIM mineralization protein-1 cDNA

STUDY DESIGN

An animal study in immune competent rabbits and athymic rats was conducted.

OBJECTIVES

To develop an animal model for simulation of previous human Type 5 adenovirus (Ad5) exposure, to determine the impact of adenoviral pre-exposure on spine fusion induced with ex vivo Ad5-LMP-1, and to test strategies for overcoming any potential immune response.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Cells transduced with adenovirus containing the osteoinductive LMP-1 cDNA (Ad5-LMP-1) can induce spine fusion in rabbits. Because up to 80% of the human population has been exposed to adenovirus, immune responses to the vector may limit this strategy in humans. Few studies have modeled previous adenoviral exposure and tested strategies to circumvent it.

METHODS

Adult New Zealand white rabbits were injected with 10 or 10 viral particles of Ad5-LacZ. At 4 or 16 weeks after Ad5 injection, autologous buffy coats were prepared from peripheral blood, and 4 million cells per side were infected ex vivo for 10 minutes with Ad5-LMP-1 (multiplicity of infection = 4). Cells were implanted on a collagen matrix instead of an autograft for posterolateral lumbar arthrodesis. Unimmunized rabbits served as control subjects. Additional immunized rabbits underwent arthrodesis at 4 weeks with increased cell number (10 million) and viral dose (multiplicity of infection = 10), or with both parameters increased. The rabbits were killed at 4 weeks, and the spines were assessed by palpation and radiograph. A parallel study was performed in athymic rats using immunized rabbits for the donor cells.

RESULTS

All the unimmunized rabbits had solid spine fusions. None of the rabbits arthrodesed 4 weeks after Ad5 pre-exposure achieved fusion. At 4 weeks after Ad5 exposure, increasing the multiplicity of infection to 10 did not overcome the immune response (0/3 fused), but increasing the cell number to 10 million (2/3 fused) or increasing both cell number and multiplicity of infection (3/3 fused) did overcome the immune effects. Delaying arthrodesis until 16 weeks after Ad5 pre-exposure also overcame the immune response (3/3 fused). Similar results were seen in the athymic rat ectopic implant model, suggesting that the immune effect was mediated by humoral antibodies rather than a T-cell response.

CONCLUSIONS

Two model systems were developed that simulate previous exposure to human Ad5 and could separate the cellular and humoral components of the response. There was a dose-dependent inhibition of ex vivo Ad5-LMP-1 gene transfer to cells from animals previously exposed to human Ad5. Data suggested that the inhibition of Ad5 infection was caused by humoral antibodies rather than a T-cell-based response. Minor modifications in the gene transfer protocol, such as doubling the viral dose or number of cells infected, or increasing the infection time, could overcome the immune response for an ex vivo approach.

PEGylation of E1-deleted adenovirus vectors allows significant gene expression on readministration to liver

Systemic administration of adenoviral vectors leads to activation of innate and antigen-specific immunity. In an attempt to diminish T and B cell-specific immune responses to E1-deleted adenoviral vectors, capsid proteins were modified with various activated monomethoxypolyethylene glycols (MPEGs). The impact of this modification was studied in a murine model of liver-directed gene transfer in which an E1-deleted adenovirus expressing the lacZ gene was given intravenously. The efficiency of vector transduction of hepatocytes in vivo was not compromised by any of the polymer chemistries. PEGylation of the virus, however, diminished the activation of cytotoxic T lymphocytes and helper T cells of the type 1 subset (Th1 cells) against native viral antigens; neutralizing antibodies to native virus were also diminished. PEGylation prolonged transgene expression and allowed partial readministration with native virus or with a virus PEGylated with a heterologous chemical moiety. Apparently, modification of the capsid leads to a shift in antigenic epitopes because vector readministration was not possible when the immunizing vector had been modified by the same PEGylation chemistry used to modify the second vector. In light of these results, the concept of improving the performance of adenoviral vectors through modification of the capsid with PEG shows promise.

Budesonide enhances repeated gene transfer and expression in the lung with adenoviral vectors

The immune response with generation of neutralizing antiviral antibodies is an obstacle to effective repeated adenoviral gene transfer. Different immunosuppressive drugs facilitate repeat administration of adenovectors, but the clinical utility is uncertain because of systemic side effects. We investigated the use of topical corticosteroid in improving gene expression after repeated injection of adenovectors into mouse lungs. Using a vector expressing murine interleukin-6 (mIL-6) as a marker cytokine for gene expression, we show that budesonide given around exposure to adenovirus to the lung significantly maintained high levels of expressed transgene protein in bronchoalveolar lavage fluid (BALF) after as many as four consecutive injections of virus at two weekly intervals (p = 0.02 versus saline). Differences between treatment groups were most obvious 4 and 6 wk after the initial exposure to adenovirus (equivalent to three and four total exposures). In Week 4, transgene mIL-6 concentration was 2,327 +/- 955 pg/ml in budesonide compared with 336 +/- 246 pg/ml in saline-treated mice (p = 0.001). However, budesonide did not significantly protect transgene expression beyond Week 8 (four prior exposures). The improved transgene expression in budesonide-treated compared with saline-treated animals was associated with a reduction, but not prevention of neutralizing antiviral antibodies (BALF p < 0.001, serum p = 0.04). We conclude that budesonide can be valuable in gene therapy of the lung where repeated transient gene transfer is necessary.

Factors affecting long-term expression of a secreted transgene product after intravenous administration of a retroviral vector

We have studied parameters affecting in vivo expression of human growth hormone (hGH) in mice after intravenous administration of a retroviral vector encoding the protein as a model system for clotting factor VIII gene therapy. Such treatment results in a brief burst of high-level expression followed by lower level sustained expression of the hGH in the circulation. The major targets for transduction in the mouse are liver and spleen. Such direct transduction (i.e., without surgical or chemical induction of cell division) requires vector at high titer (>/=10(8) cfu/ml) and is dose dependent. Transduction efficiency decreases with increasing age of the recipient. Nevertheless, long-term expression in adults is observed after administration of vector as a split dose on 2 consecutive days. We also show that anti-vector immune responses may enhance long-term expression and that both anti-vector and anti-transgene immunity can be modulated. This work provides a framework for the rational development of means to enhance the efficiency of retroviral vectors for use in clinical gene replacement therapy.

Particle-mediated gene transfer into murine livers using a newly developed gene gun

Although particle-mediated gene transfer using gene gun technology has been applied for gene transfer into epidermis, applications of this technology to visceral tissues have not been well investigated. Although all helium gas-driven gene gun instruments have used macrocarriers to discharge DNA-coated microprojectiles so far, we used a newly developed gene gun instrument, in which a hammering bullet is used to discharge microprojectiles. With the gene gun, gold particles coated with lacZ expression plasmid were discharged to murine livers. LacZ expression was induced much more profoundly in the liver by particle-mediated gene transfer than by simple plasmid injection and electroporation-mediated gene transfer. LacZ expression was broadly and randomly distributed throughout the bombarded livers, indicating that particle-mediated gene transfer can induce transgene expression even at relatively distant areas from the surface of the bombarded tissue. Furthermore, although transgene expression was at its peak on day 2 after the bombardment, it was still detectable even on day 28. These results indicate that particle-mediated gene transfer with a newly developed gene gun may provide a new approach to gene therapy for human diseases.