Foreign DNA introduced into the vas deferens is gained by mammalian spermatozoa

Nucleic acids delivery methods for genome editing in zygotes and embryos: the old, the new, and the old-new

In the recent years, sequence-specific nucleases such as ZFNs, TALENs, and CRISPR/Cas9 have revolutionzed the fields of animal genome editing and transgenesis. However, these new techniques require microinjection to deliver nucleic acids into embryos to generate gene-modified animals. Microinjection is a delicate procedure that requires sophisticated equipment and highly trained and experienced technicians. Though over a dozen alternate approaches for nucleic acid delivery into embryos were attempted during the pre-CRISPR era, none of them became routinely used as microinjection. The addition of CRISPR/Cas9 to the genome editing toolbox has propelled the search for novel delivery approaches that can obviate the need for microinjection. Indeed, some groups have recently developed electroporation-based methods that have the potential to radically change animal transgenesis. This review provides an overview of the old and new delivery methods, and discusses various strategies that were attempted during the last three decades. In addition, several of the methods are re-evaluated with respect to their suitability to deliver genome editing components, particularly CRISPR/Cas9, to embryos.

Production of transgenic rabbit embryos through intracytoplasmic sperm injection

The objective of this study was to test if intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI)-mediated gene transfer was an effective method in the production of transgenic rabbit embryos. Rabbit sperm diluted in different media with various pH were treated by freezing without cryoprotectant, and their ability for DNA uptake was determined. In these experiments using production of transgenic rabbit embryos by ICSI, exogenous genes at three concentrations and of two conformation types were used. The rate of DNA association to the sperm seen by rhodamine-tagged DNA encoding green fluorescent protein (GFP) was 90.0%, 92.7%, 91.0%, 91.7%, and 92.3%, respectively in TCM199, DM, DPBS, CZB, and HCZB media. The DNA attachment to sperm was not affected by media pH within the range of 5.4-9.4 (p > 0.05). Expression of GFP first occurred at the 2-cell stage and continued to blastocyst formation. DNA concentration (between 5, 10, and 20 ng/μl) or conformation (linear and circular) had no effect on the production rate of transgenic embryos. These results indicated that genetically modified rabbit blastocysts can be efficiently produced by ICSI technique.

In-vivo gene transfer induces transgene expression in cells and secretions of the mouse cauda epididymis

Mouse cauda epididymis were in-vivo transfected using the lipid FuGENE 6 as gene vector. Two gene constructions were employed: the p-GeneGRIP which codifies for the Green Fluorescent Protein (GFP) and the pSEAP-control that expresses an alkaline phosphatase as a secretion. Transfection was detected by fluorescence and appeared in the nucleus and cytoplasm of epithelial cells. Transfection was observed in 39.70% of cells after 2 days and in 31.77% after 7 days, and then diminished progressively. Moreover, the presence of the transgene in the DNA isolated from treated epididymides was observed by polymerase chain reaction. GFP gene expression appeared in large areas of the cauda epididymis and it was observed exclusively in the cytoplasm of epithelial cells. GFP gene expression occurred during 2 weeks after gene injection and occupied 32.24, 29.98 and 22.37% of the area of the tubules when analyzed 2, 7 and 15 days after gene injection. The cauda was also analyzed in toto and showed similar results. The use of the pSEAP-control gene showed that cauda epididymis secretions can also be modified by the transfection procedure. A significant increase of alkaline phosphatase activity appeared in the epididymal fluids 7 days after gene injection. These results indicate that transfection procedures could be an important tool in the future to study epididymal physiology or to change the fertilizing ability of spermatozoa.

Direct gene delivery to murine testis as a possible means of transfection of mature sperm and epithelial cells lining epididymal ducts

The use of a sperm cell to introduce exogenous DNA into an oocyte at the time of fertilization is of interest for the simple production of transgenic mice, and is now called 'sperm-mediated gene transfer (SMGT)'. In vivo transfection of sperm cells has been developed as an alternative method for SMGT and can be carried out by direct gene delivery into an interstitial space in a testis (now called 'testis-mediated gene transfer [TMGT]'), into the vas deferens, or into seminiferous tubules. This review summarizes what has been achieved in the field of in vivo gene transfer using sperm cells. (Reprod Med Biol 2006; 5: 1-7).

Transgenic animals: current and alternative strategies

Transgenic animal technology is one of the most fascinating technologies developed in the last two decades. It allows us to address questions in life sciences that no other methods have achieved. The impact on biomedical and biological research, as well as commercial interests are overwhelming. The questions accompanying this fast growing technology and its diversified applications attract the attention from a variety of entities. Still, one of the most fundamental problems remaining is the search for an efficient and reliable gene delivery system for creating transgenic animals. The traditional method of pronuclear microinjection has displayed great variability in success among species. While an acceptable efficiency in the production of transgenic mice has been attained, the relative low efficiency (<1%) in creating transgenic livestock has become one of the barriers for its application. In the past decades, improvements in producing transgenic livestock have made a slow progression, however, the recent advancement in cloning technology and the ability to create transgenic livestock in a highly efficient manner, have opened the gate to a new era in transgenic technology. Discoveries of new gene delivery systems have created an enthusiastic atmosphere that has made this technology so unique. This review focuses on gene delivery strategies as well as various approaches that may assist the advancement of transgenic efficiency in large animals.

Sperm-mediated gene transfer: applications and implications

Recent developments in studies of sperm-mediated gene transfer (SMGT) now provide solid ground for the notion that sperm cells can act as vectors for exogenous genetic sequences. A substantive body of evidence indicates that SMGT is potentially useable in animal transgenesis, but also suggests that the final fate of the exogenous sequences transferred by sperm is not always predictable. The analysis of SMGT-derived offspring has shown the existence of integrated foreign sequences in some cases, while in others stable modifications of the genome are difficult to detect. The appearance of SMGT-derived modified offspring on the one hand and, on the other hand, the rarity of actual modification of the genome, suggest inheritance as extrachromosomal structures. Several specific factors have been identified that mediate distinct steps in SMGT. Among those, a prominent role is played by an endogenous reverse transcriptase of retrotransposon origin. Mature spermatozoa are naturally protected against the intrusion of foreign nucleic acid molecules; however, particular environmental conditions, such as those occurring during human assisted reproduction, can abolish this protection. The possibility that sperm cells under these conditions carry genetic sequences affecting the integrity or identity of the host genome should be critically considered. These considerations further suggest the possibility that SMGT events may occasionally take place in nature, with profound implications for evolutionary processes.

Gene Therapy: The Potential Applicability of Gene Transfer Technology to the Human Germline

The theoretical possibility of applying gene transfer methodologies to the human germline is explored. Transgenic methods for genetically manipulating embryos may in principle be applied to humans. In particular, microinjection of retroviral vector appears to hold the greatest promise, with transgenic primates already obtained from this approach. Sperm-mediated gene transfer offers potentially the easiest route to the human germline, however the requisite methodology is presently underdeveloped. Nuclear transfer (cloning) offers an alternative approach to germline genetic modification, however there are major health concerns associated with current nuclear transfer methods. It is concluded that human germline gene therapy remains for all practical purposes a future possibility that must await significant and important advances in gene transfer technology.

In vitro transfection of the human vas deferens using DNA-liposome and DNA-neutral lipid complexes

OBJECTIVE

To transfect the human vas deferens in vitro.

DESIGN

Prospective study, description of a procedure.

SETTING

Research center and university hospital.

PATIENT(S)

Seven fertile men undergoing vasectomies or vasovasostomies.

INTERVENTION(S)

Human vas deferens pieces were transfected in vitro using the p-GeneGrip gene construction, which codifies for the green fluorescent protein (GFP). Lipofectamine or GenePorter were employed as gene vectors.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

After vas deferens epithelium transfection, we described the vas deferens foreign gene expression. Maximum transfection occurred in 14.7% of the vas deferens epithelial cells. After using GenePorter, we observed green fluorescent protein gene expression in 40% of samples, which occupied 9.86% of the epithelial area. After Lipofectamine treatment, transgene expression occurred in 33% of the samples and occupied 9.05% of the epithelial area.

CONCLUSION(S)

The human vas deferens epithelium has the potential to be modified by gene transfection.

Gene therapy: theoretical and bioethical concepts

Gene therapy holds great promise. Somatic gene therapy has the potential to treat a wide range of disorders, including inherited conditions, cancers, and infectious diseases. Early progress has already been made in the treatment of a range of disorders. Ethical issues surrounding somatic gene therapy are primarily those concerned with safety. Germline gene therapy is theoretically possible but raises serious ethical concerns concerning future generations.

Gene transfer in higher animals: theoretical considerations and key concepts

Gene transfer technology provides the ability to genetically manipulate the cells of higher animals. Gene transfer permits both germline and somatic alterations. Such genetic manipulation is the basis for animal transgenesis goals and gene therapy attempts. Improvements in gene transfer are required in terms of transgene design to permit gene targeting, and in terms of transfection approaches to allow improved transgene uptake efficiencies.

In vivo transfection of the mouse vas deferens

To explore the possibility that specific characteristics of the epithelium of the male tract can be modified, transfections of the mouse vas deferens have been performed using in vivo injections of cationic DNA/liposome complexes. Gene transfer was done employing the reporter genes pEGFP-C1 encoding Green Fluorescent Protein (GFP) and pCMV-nls-beta encoding the nuclear beta-Galactosidase (beta-Gal). Foreign gene expression reached a maximum of 6.8% in the epithelial cells of the vas after treatment with the nuclear beta-Gal gene construction and of 13.3% after employing the GFP gene construction. Expression of the GFP gene appeared from one week up to three months following injection, and it appeared as patches of modified cells along the epithelium. Results from immunocytochemistry and Western Blotting support the conclusion that transfection of epithelial cells was achieved. We have also transfected the vas using gene constructions that express secretory proteins--specifically, the reporter system pSEAP-control that expresses a secretory form of human placental alkaline phosphatase, and the pGFP-Ctk-37 that expresses a secretion form of GFP. In both cases, the fluids expressed from the transfected vas showed a significant increase of alkaline phosphatase activity after pSEAP transfection and the presence of GFP protein when pGFP-Ctk-37 gene construction was employed. Our results indicate that the vas can be transfected in vivo using liposomes as vectors of foreign genes and that the vas fluid contents can be modified.

Transient transmission of a transgene in mouse offspring following in vivo transfection of male germ cells

Sperm-mediated gene transfer in vertebrates has undergone various developments over the last few years, in different laboratories. In the present study, we microinjected a circular plasmid, carrying the lacZ reporter gene mixed with noncommercial cationic lipids, into the seminiferous tubules of anesthetized adult mice. Histochemical analysis was used to estimate the transfection efficiency 48-96 hr and 40 days after injection. As early as 48-96 hr post-injection, an efficient transfection was revealed by a beta-galactosidase expression within both immature and differentiated germ cells. By 40 days post-injection, the specific LacZ expression was restricted to the most immature germ cells in the basal portion of the seminiferous tubules. At this time, some injected males were mated with wild-type females and the progeny were analyzed by PCR and Southern blot. We showed that the transgene was transmitted to the offspring but remained episomal, as it was found in the tail of the young animals but not at adulthood. Therefore, the plasmid seemed to be lost during the numerous germ cells divisions. This plasmid stayed in some tissues, such as skeletal muscle and cardiac muscle. No integrative forms have yet been found with the use of a circular DNA.

Direct injection of foreign DNA into mouse testis as a possible in vivo gene transfer system via epididymal spermatozoa

We have attempted to transfect testicular spermatozoa with plasmid DNA by direct injection into testes to obtain transgenic animals [this technique was thus termed "testis-mediated gene transfer (TMGT)"]. When injected males were mated with superovulated females 2 and 3 days after injection, (i) high efficiencies (more than 50%) of gene transmission were achieved in the mid-gestational F0 fetuses, (ii) the copy number of plasmid DNA in the fetuses was estimated to be less than 1 copy per diploid cell, and (iii) overt gene expression was not found in these fetuses. These findings suggest the possibility that plasmid DNA introduced into a testis is rapidly transported to the epididymis and then incorporated by epididymal spermatozoa. The purpose of this study was to elucidate the mechanism of TMGT by introducing trypan blue (TB) or Hoechst 33342 directly into testis. We found that TB is transported to the ducts of the caput epididymis via rete testis within 1 min after testis injection, and TB reached the corpus and cauda epididymis within 2-4 days after injection. Staining of spermatozoa isolated from any portion of epididymis was observed 4 days after injection of a solution containing Hoechst 33342. Injection of enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP) expression vector/liposome complex into testis resulted in transfection of epithelial cells of epididymal ducts facing the lumen, although the transfection efficiency appeared to be low. In vivo electroporation toward the caput epididymis immediately after injection of EGFP expression vector into a testis greatly improved the uptake of foreign DNA by the epididymal epithelial cells. PCR analysis using spermatozoa isolated from corpus and cauda epididymis 4 days after injection of a DNA/liposome complex into testis revealed exogenous DNA in these spermatozoa even after treatment with DNase I. These findings indicate that exogenous DNA introduced into tesits is rapidly transported to epididymal ducts via the rete testis and efferent ducts, and then incorporated by epithelial cells of epididymis and epididymal spermatozoa.

Transfection of mouse eggs and embryos using DNA combined to cationic liposomes

We have used plasmid DNA in combination with cationic liposomes to transfect mouse eggs and embryos. The plasmid was rhodamine labeled, which allowed a direct visualization of the DNA uptake by the cells. Immature eggs, collected from the ovaries, were easily transfected, but once the egg was ovulated the zona pellucida (ZP) acted as a barrier and prevented transfection. Permeabilization or removal of the ZP was therefore a requirement to allow transfection. Transfected eggs were capable of being fertilized in vitro giving raise to embryos that expressed the recombinant protein. Morulae and blastocysts were also transfected when the ZP was permeabilized, but the efficiency of transfection decreased and in some cases not all the blastomeres incorporated the plasmid. Pronuclear embryos were cultured and showed expression of the transgene from the 2-cell stage. This indicates that liposome-transfection of oocytes or pronuclear embryos could be a simple and suitable method to introduce foreign genes in embryos and perhaps could be also useful to generate transgenic animals.

Generation of genetically modified mice by spermatozoa transfection in vivo: preliminary results

Mouse vas deferens were injected with a plasmid DNA encoding the GFP (Green Fluorescent Protein). The night after injection males were mated with normal oestrus females, and the offspring were analyzed. From 53 newborns, 4 were found positive by PCR for the GFP gene. In these positive animals, some tissues showed expression for GFP as evidenced by a strong green cytoplasmic fluorescence. GFP expression was particularly patent in the liver (hepatocytes), kidney (renal corpuscle and tubules), abdominal wall, and lung. These preliminary results indicate the possibility to use this method as a simple alternative procedure to create transgenic animals, and it could be especially helpful in species in which the microinjection procedure is not feasible.

Interaction of exogenous DNA with the nuclear matrix of live spermatozoa

Sperm chromatin is a highly organized array of protamines and DNA, with the protamines serving to tightly condense the DNA into a compact, defined structure. We have previously demonstrated that the sperm nucleus is an ordered library of DNA organized into functional zones, such as the nuclear matrix and nuclear annulus. Other laboratories have suggested that mouse spermatozoa can interact with exogenous pSV2CAT plasmid DNA. In this work, we explored this interaction and examined the subcellular localization of the exogenous DNA. We found a repeatable association of exogenous DNA with a specific region of the sperm nuclear matrix. This region of the nucleus correlates with the equatorial segment of the sperm head. This interaction requires only a defined fertilization media, transfection quality DNA, and incubation with spermatozoa.

Sperm-mediated DNA transfer to cells of the uterus and embryo

There is a paucity of information about sperm-mediated transmission of exogenous DNA to implanting embryos and cells of the reproductive tract. Preliminary experiments established that sperm has the capacity to actively take in exogenous DNA derived from HPV. In addition, blastocysts also take up exogenous HPV DNA, but in contrast to sperm, the process appears passive. DNA-carrying sperm migrating in an artificial glass tube or excised mouse bicornuate uteri transfected the blastocysts at the remote position using a flip-flop mechanism. There were preferential transmission of the types of HPV DNA but this was not attributed to the gene sequence or the size of the DNA fragments. The internalized DNA became undetectable unless continuous sperm bombardment or pricking took place. Mycoplasma vectors offer a novel way to enhance the transfection of blastocyst with exogenous DNA.

Sperm-mediated transgenesis

The idea of using a sperm cell for introducing exogenous DNA into an oocyte at the time of fertilization would be brilliant if only we were sure that it can be done. Since 1989, contradictory reports have appeared in the literature and, at present, no consensus has been reached on the topic. Given the potential impact of this method for the generation of transgenic animals, for both mammalian and non-mammalian species, this review summarizes what has been achieved in this field. While some aspects, such as the binding of DNA molecules to spermatozoa, have now a solid experimental base, others, such as the generation of real transgenic individuals, are still based on disputed evidence. A critical analysis of the most relevant data will be presented in order to provide the tools for an objective evaluation of the efficiency of this method.

Mammalian transgenesis by intracytoplasmic sperm injection

Coinjection of unfertilized mouse oocytes with sperm heads and exogenous DNA encoding either a green fluorescent protein (GFP) or beta-galactosidase reporter produced 64 to 94 percent transgene-expressing embryos, reflecting DNA-sperm head association before coinjection. Nonselective transfer to surrogate mothers of embryos in the GFP series generated about 20 percent offspring expressing the integrated transgene. These data indicate that exogenous DNA can reproducibly be delivered into an oocyte by microinjected spermatozoa and suggest an adaptable method of transgenesis.