The effect of water activity on the association constant and the enthalpy of reaction between lysozyme and the specific antibodies D1.3 and D44.1

Structure-Based Reverse Vaccinology Failed in the Case of HIV Because it Disregarded Accepted Immunological Theory

Two types of reverse vaccinology (RV) should be distinguished: genome-based RV for bacterial vaccines and structure-based RV for viral vaccines. Structure-based RV consists in trying to generate a vaccine by first determining the crystallographic structure of a complex between a viral epitope and a neutralizing monoclonal antibody (nMab) and then reconstructing the epitope by reverse molecular engineering outside the context of the native viral protein. It is based on the unwarranted assumption that the epitope designed to fit the nMab will have acquired the immunogenic capacity to elicit a polyclonal antibody response with the same protective capacity as the nMab. After more than a decade of intensive research using this type of RV, this approach has failed to deliver an effective, preventive HIV-1 vaccine. The structure and dynamics of different types of HIV-1 epitopes and of paratopes are described. The rational design of an anti-HIV-1 vaccine is shown to be a misnomer since investigators who claim that they design a vaccine are actually only improving the antigenic binding capacity of one epitope with respect to only one paratope and not the immunogenic capacity of an epitope to elicit neutralizing antibodies. Because of the degeneracy of the immune system and the polyspecificity of antibodies, each epitope studied by the structure-based RV procedure is only one of the many epitopes that the particular nMab is able to recognize and there is no reason to assume that this nMab must have been elicited by this one epitope of known structure. Recent evidence is presented that the trimeric Env spikes of the virus possess such an enormous plasticity and intrinsic structural flexibility that it is it extremely difficult to determine which Env regions are the best candidate vaccine immunogens most likely to elicit protective antibodies.

Quantifying the molecular origins of opposite solvent effects on protein-protein interactions

Although the nature of solvent-protein interactions is generally weak and non-specific, addition of cosolvents such as denaturants and osmolytes strengthens protein-protein interactions for some proteins, whereas it weakens protein-protein interactions for others. This is exemplified by the puzzling observation that addition of glycerol oppositely affects the association constants of two antibodies, D1.3 and D44.1, with lysozyme. To resolve this conundrum, we develop a methodology based on the thermodynamic principles of preferential interaction theory and the quantitative characterization of local protein solvation from molecular dynamics simulations. We find that changes of preferential solvent interactions at the protein-protein interface quantitatively account for the opposite effects of glycerol on the antibody-antigen association constants. Detailed characterization of local protein solvation in the free and associated protein states reveals how opposite solvent effects on protein-protein interactions depend on the extent of dewetting of the protein-protein contact region and on structural changes that alter cooperative solvent-protein interactions at the periphery of the protein-protein interface. These results demonstrate the direct relationship between macroscopic solvent effects on protein-protein interactions and atom-scale solvent-protein interactions, and establish a general methodology for predicting and understanding solvent effects on protein-protein interactions in diverse biological environments.

Light chain somatic mutations change thermodynamics of binding and water coordination in the HyHEL-10 family of antibodies

Thermodynamic and structural studies addressed the increased affinity due to L-chain somatic mutations in the HyHEL-10 family of affinity matured IgG antibodies, using ITC, SPR with van't Hoff analysis, and X-ray crystallography. When compared to the parental antibody H26L26, the H26L10 and H26L8 chimeras binding to lysozyme showed an increase in favorable DeltaG(o) of -1.2+/-0.1 kcal mol(-1) and -1.3+/-0.1 kcal mol(-1), respectively. Increase in affinity of the H26L10 chimera was due to a net increase in favorable enthalpy change with little difference in change in entropy compared to H26L26. The H26L8 chimera exhibited the greatest increase in favorable enthalpy but also showed an increase in unfavorable entropy change, with the result being that the affinities of both chimeras were essentially equivalent. Site-directed L-chain mutants identified the shared somatic mutation S30G as the dominant contributor to increasing affinity to lysozyme. This mutation was not influenced by H-chain somatic mutations. Residue 30L is at the periphery of the binding interface and S30G effects an increase in hydrophobicity and decrease in H-bonding ability and size, but does not make any new energetically important antigen contacts. A new 1.2-A structure of the H10L10-HEL complex showed changes in the pattern of both inter- and intra-molecular water bridging with no other significant structural alterations near the binding interface compared to the H26L26-HEL complex. These results highlight the necessity for investigating both the structure and the thermodynamics associated with introduced mutations, in order to better assess and understand their impact on binding. Furthermore, it provides an important example of how backbone flexibility and water-bridging may favorably influence the thermodynamics of an antibody-antigen interaction.

Association energetics of cross-reactive and specific antibodies

HyHEL-8, HyHEL-10, and HyHEL-26 (HH8, HH10, and HH26, respectively) are murine monoclonal IgG(1) antibodies which share over 90% variable-region amino acid sequence identity and recognize identical structurally characterized epitopes on hen egg white lysozyme (HEL). Previous immunochemical and surface plasmon resonance-based studies have shown that these antibodies differ widely in their tolerance of mutations in the epitope. While HH8 is the most cross-reactive, HH26 is rigidified by a more extensive network of intramolecular salt links and is highly specific, with both association and dissociation rates strongly affected by epitope mutations. HH10 is of intermediate specificity, and epitope mutations produce changes primarily in the dissociation rate. Calorimetric characterization of the association energetics of these three antibodies with the native antigen HEL and with Japanese quail egg white lysozyme (JQL), a naturally occurring avian variant, shows that the energetics of interaction correlate with cross-reactivity and specificity. These results suggest that the greater cross-reactivity of HH8 may be mediated by a combination of conformational flexibility and less specific intermolecular interactions. Thermodynamic calculations suggest that upon association HH8 incurs the largest configurational entropic penalty and also the smallest loss of enthalpic driving force with variant antigen. Much smaller structural perturbations are expected in the formation of the less flexible HH26 complex, and the large loss of enthalpic driving force observed with variant antigen reflects its specificity. The observed thermodynamic parameters correlate well with the observed functional behavior of the antibodies and illustrate fundamental differences in thermodynamic characteristics between cross-reactive and specific molecular recognition.

Synthesis of urea picket porphyrins and their use in the elucidation of the role buried solvent plays in the selectivity and stoichiometry of anion binding receptors

The synthesis of alpha,alpha-5,10-diurea and alpha,alpha,alpha-5,10,15-triurea picket porphyrins are detailed in this report. In previous reports, these porphyrins, along with alpha,alpha,alpha,alpha-5,10,15,20-tetraurea picket porphyrin, were used to demonstrate the important role one buried solvent molecule plays in the selectivity and stoichiometry of binding inorganic anions. Building on prior work, this report discusses the results of acetate anion binding studies between tetra- and diurea picket porphyrins (the latter does not contain a buried solvent molecule in the anion-receptor complex), compares differences in thermodynamic data obtained from van't Hoff plots of a porphyrin anion receptor able to utilize buried solvent in its binding motif with one that does not, and compares the crystal structure of a tetraurea porphyrin 1-chloride anion complex that contains buried solvent with new X-ray crystal structures of tetraurea porphyrin 1-dichloride or bisdihydrogenphosphate anion complexes that contain no buried solvent. Data from our previous work, and the work described herein, demonstrates that one buried solvent molecule provides stability to the receptor-anion complex that is similar in energy to a moderately strong hydrogen bond.

Thermodynamic consequences of disrupting a water-mediated hydrogen bond network in a protein:pheromone complex

The mouse pheromones (+/-)-2-sec-butyl-4,5-dihydrothiazole (SBT) and 6-hydroxy-6-methyl-3-heptanone (HMH) bind into an occluded hydrophobic cavity in the mouse major urinary protein (MUP-1). Although the ligands are structurally unrelated, in both cases binding is accompanied by formation of a similar buried, water-mediated hydrogen bond network between the ligand and several backbone and side chain groups on the protein. To investigate the energetic contribution of this hydrogen bond network to ligand binding, we have applied isothermal titration calorimetry to measure the binding thermodynamics using several MUP mutants and ligand analogs. Mutation of Tyr-120 to Phe, which disrupts a hydrogen bond from the phenolic hydroxyl group of Tyr-120 to one of the bound water molecules, results in a substantial loss of favorable binding enthalpy, which is partially compensated by a favorable change in binding entropy. A similar thermodynamic effect was observed when the hydrogen bonded nitrogen atom of the heterocyclic ligand was replaced by a methyne group. Several other modifications of the protein or ligand had smaller effects on the binding thermodynamics. The data provide supporting evidence for the role of the hydrogen bond network in stabilizing the complex.

Structural mechanism for affinity maturation of an anti-lysozyme antibody

In the immune response against a typical T cell-dependent protein antigen, the affinity maturation process is fast and is associated with the early class switch from IgM to IgG. As such, a comprehension of the molecular basis of affinity maturation could be of great importance in biomedical and biotechnological applications. Affinity maturation of anti-protein antibodies has been reported to be the result of small structural changes, mostly confined to the periphery of the antigen-combining site. However, little is understood about how these small structural changes account for the increase in the affinity toward the antigen. Herein, we present the three-dimensional structure of the Fab fragment from BALB/c mouse mAb F10.6.6 in complex with the antigen lysozyme. This antibody was obtained from a long-term exposure to the antigen. mAb F10.6.6, and the previously described antibody D44.1, are the result of identical or nearly identical somatic recombination events. However, different mutations in the framework and variable regions result in an approximately 10(3) higher affinity for the F10.6.6 antibody. The comparison of the three-dimensional structures of these Fab-lysozyme complexes reveals that the affinity maturation produces a fine tuning of the complementarity of the antigen-combining site toward the epitope, explaining at the molecular level how the immune system is able to increase the affinity of an anti-protein antibody to subnanomolar levels.

Association and dissociation kinetics of anti-hen egg lysozyme monoclonal antibodies HyHEL-5 and HyHEL-10

The immunoglobulin G1 (IgG1) kappa antibodies HyHEL-5 and HyHEL-10 interact with nonoverlapping epitopes on hen egg lysozyme (HEL); the HyHEL-5/HEL interface has two energetically and structurally important salt links, whereas the HyHEL-10/HEL interface involves predominantly hydrogen bonds and van der Waals interactions. The kinetics of association and dissociation of antibodies HyHEL-5 and HyHEL-10 with HEL under a variety of conditions were investigated in this study. The association of each antibody with HEL follows second-order kinetics. The association process is significantly diffusion-limited, as indicated by the viscosity dependence of the interaction of both antibodies with HEL, although detailed energetics suggest that the association process may be more complex. The association rate constant for the HyHEL-5/HEL system is within a factor of 2 of the modified Smoluchowski estimate for proteins of this size, whereas HyHEL-10 interacts with HEL with an association rate an order of magnitude lower. The association reactions are insensitive to ionic strength, showing only a twofold decrease in the association rate constant when the ionic strength was increased from 27 mM to 500 mM. Interestingly, the association rate constant for the interaction of HyHEL-5 with HEL varies with pH in the range 6.0-10.0, whereas HyHEL-10/HEL association is not affected by pH in the same range. The dissociation of the HyHEL-5/HEL and HyHEL-10/HEL complexes follow first-order kinetics with half-lives at 25 degrees C of approximately 3,150 s and approximately 21,660 s, respectively.

Conformational correction mechanisms aiding antigen recognition by a humanized antibody

The crystal structure of the complex between hen egg lysozyme and the Fv fragment of a humanized antilysozyme antibody was determined to 2.7-A resolution. The structure of the antigen combining site in the complex is nearly identical to that of the complexed form of the parent mouse antibody, D1.3. In contrast, the combining sites of the unliganded mouse and humanized antilysozymes show moderate conformational differences. This disparity suggests that a conformational readjustment process linked to antigen binding reverses adverse conformations in the complementarity determining regions that had been introduced by engineering these segments next to human framework regions in the humanized antibody.

Involvement of water molecules in the association of monoclonal antibody HyHEL-5 with bobwhite quail lysozyme

Fluorescence polarization spectroscopy and isothermal titration calorimetry were used to study the influence of osmolytes on the association of the anti-hen egg lysozyme (HEL) monoclonal antibody HyHEL-5 with bobwhite quail lysozyme (BWQL). BWQL is an avian species variant with an Arg-->Lys mutation in the HyHEL-5 epitope, as well as three other mutations outside the HyHEL-5 structural epitope. This mutation decreases the equilibrium association constant of HyHEL-5 for BWQL by over 1000-fold as compared to HEL. The three-dimensional structure of this complex has been obtained recently. Fluorescein-labeled BWQL, obtained by labeling at pH 7.5 and purified by hydrophobic interaction chromatograpy, bound HyHEL-5 with an equilibrium association constant close to that determined for unlabeled BWQL by isothermal titration calorimetry. Fluorescence titration, stopped-flow kinetics, and isothermal titration calorimetry experiments using various concentrations of the osmolytes glycerol, ethylene glycol, and betaine to perturb binding gave a lower limit of the uptake of approximately 6-12 water molecules upon formation of the HyHEL-5/BWQL complex.

Characterization of anti-anti-idiotypic antibodies that bind antigen and an anti-idiotype

Two mouse monoclonal anti-anti-idiotopic antibodies (anti-anti-Id, Ab3), AF14 and AF52, were prepared by immunizing BALB/c mice with rabbit polyclonal anti-idiotypic antibodies (anti-Id, Ab2) raised against antibody D1.3 (Ab1) specific for the antigen hen egg lysozyme. AF14 and AF52 react with an "internal image" monoclonal mouse anti-Id antibody E5.2 (Ab2), previously raised against D1.3, with affinity constants (1.0 x 10(9) M-1 and 2.4 x 10(7) M-1, respectively) usually observed in secondary responses against protein antigens. They also react with the antigen but with lower affinity (1.8 x 10(6) M-1 and 3.8 x 10(6) M-1). This pattern of affinities for the anti-Id and for the antigen also was displayed by the sera of the immunized mice. The amino acid sequences of AF14 and AF52 are very close to that of D1.3. In particular, the amino acid side chains that contribute to contacts with both antigen and anti-Id are largely conserved in AF14 and AF52 compared with D1.3. Therapeutic immunizations against different pathogenic antigens using anti-Id antibodies have been proposed. Our experiments show that a response to an anti-Id immunogen elicits anti-anti-Id antibodies that are optimized for binding the anti-Id antibodies rather than the antigen.