Designing a molecular analysis of clonality in tumours

Clinical implications of intratumor heterogeneity: challenges and opportunities

In this review, we highlight the role of intratumoral heterogeneity, focusing on the clinical and biological ramifications this phenomenon poses. Intratumoral heterogeneity arises through complex genetic, epigenetic, and protein modifications that drive phenotypic selection in response to environmental pressures. Functionally, heterogeneity provides tumors with significant adaptability. This ranges from mutual beneficial cooperation between cells, which nurture features such as growth and metastasis, to the narrow escape and survival of clonal cell populations that have adapted to thrive under specific conditions such as hypoxia or chemotherapy. These dynamic intercellular interplays are guided by a Darwinian selection landscape between clonal tumor cell populations and the tumor microenvironment. Understanding the involved drivers and functional consequences of such tumor heterogeneity is challenging but also promises to provide novel insight needed to confront the problem of therapeutic resistance in tumors.

Pathological bases for a robust application of cancer molecular classification

Any robust classification system depends on its purpose and must refer to accepted standards, its strength relying on predictive values and a careful consideration of known factors that can affect its reliability. In this context, a molecular classification of human cancer must refer to the current gold standard (histological classification) and try to improve it with key prognosticators for metastatic potential, staging and grading. Although organ-specific examples have been published based on proteomics, transcriptomics and genomics evaluations, the most popular approach uses gene expression analysis as a direct correlate of cellular differentiation, which represents the key feature of the histological classification. RNA is a labile molecule that varies significantly according with the preservation protocol, its transcription reflect the adaptation of the tumor cells to the microenvironment, it can be passed through mechanisms of intercellular transference of genetic information (exosomes), and it is exposed to epigenetic modifications. More robust classifications should be based on stable molecules, at the genetic level represented by DNA to improve reliability, and its analysis must deal with the concept of intratumoral heterogeneity, which is at the origin of tumor progression and is the byproduct of the selection process during the clonal expansion and progression of neoplasms. The simultaneous analysis of multiple DNA targets and next generation sequencing offer the best practical approach for an analytical genomic classification of tumors.

Adrenocortical adenomas with regression and myelolipomatous changes: urinary steroid profiling supports a distinctive benign neoplasm

BACKGROUND

Adrenocortical neoplasms are classically divided into adenomas (ACA) and carcinomas (ACC). Heterogeneous appearance and greater size are criteria to suggest malignancy, along with the urinary steroid profile (USP). The presence of regression and myelolipomatous changes in adenomas (ACA-RML) can contribute to confusion with ACC and its USP remains unknown.

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the features of ACA-RML in comparison with other adrenocortical neoplasms.

METHODS

We selected consecutive ACA (11), ACA-RML (7) and ACC (13) cases for which USP analysis was performed before surgery and tissue was available for histological evaluation (King's College Hospital, 2005-2012). Cases were classified according to WHO and Armed Forces Institute of Pathology criteria. USPs were obtained by gas chromatography/mass spectrometry. Total excretion of individual steroids and indices (sums and ratios chosen to reflect steroid metabolic activity) were compared between ACA-RML, ACA and ACC.

RESULTS

In comparison with ACA, tumours in ACA-RML were significantly larger (8·5 ± 2·4 vs 3·5 ± 1·0, P = 0·002), presented in older patients and showed relatively higher incidence in males. Mitotic figure counts were significantly lower (0·39 ± 0·04 vs 0·93 ± 0·11 in ACA, P = 0·001) and revealed higher frequency of apoptotic cells (100% vs 9% in ACA, P = 0·001). The USP of ACA-RML showed no diagnostic features of ACC. No differences from ACA were significant, but there was a tendency towards lower dehydroepiandrosterone DHA and DHA metabolites.

CONCLUSIONS

ACA-RML reveals distinctive histological features and lack of USP markers of malignancy. More cases of this rare tumour may confirm differences from ACA in steroid excretion. It is important to recognize ACA-RML because its size and heterogeneous appearance raise the possibility of ACC.

Tumor heterogeneity: mechanisms and bases for a reliable application of molecular marker design

Tumor heterogeneity is a confusing finding in the assessment of neoplasms, potentially resulting in inaccurate diagnostic, prognostic and predictive tests. This tumor heterogeneity is not always a random and unpredictable phenomenon, whose knowledge helps designing better tests. The biologic reasons for this intratumoral heterogeneity would then be important to understand both the natural history of neoplasms and the selection of test samples for reliable analysis. The main factors contributing to intratumoral heterogeneity inducing gene abnormalities or modifying its expression include: the gradient ischemic level within neoplasms, the action of tumor microenvironment (bidirectional interaction between tumor cells and stroma), mechanisms of intercellular transference of genetic information (exosomes), and differential mechanisms of sequence-independent modifications of genetic material and proteins. The intratumoral heterogeneity is at the origin of tumor progression and it is also the byproduct of the selection process during progression. Any analysis of heterogeneity mechanisms must be integrated within the process of segregation of genetic changes in tumor cells during the clonal expansion and progression of neoplasms. The evaluation of these mechanisms must also consider the redundancy and pleiotropism of molecular pathways, for which appropriate surrogate markers would support the presence or not of heterogeneous genetics and the main mechanisms responsible. This knowledge would constitute a solid scientific background for future therapeutic planning.

Heterogeneous topographic profiles of kinetic and cell cycle regulator microsatellites in atypical (dysplastic) melanocytic nevi

Atypical (dysplastic) melanocytic nevi are clinically heterogeneous malignant melanoma precursors, for which no topographic analysis of cell kinetic, cell cycle regulators and microsatellite profile is available. We selected low-grade atypical melanocytic nevi (92), high-grade atypical melanocytic nevi (41), melanocytic nevi (18 junctional, 25 compound) and malignant melanomas (16 radial growth phase and 27 vertical growth phase). TP53, CDKN2A, CDKN1A, and CDKN1B microsatellite patterns were topographically studied after microdissection; Ki-67, TP53, CDKN2A, CDKN1A, and CDKN1B expressions and DNA fragmentation by in situ end labeling for apoptosis were topographically scored. Results were statistically analyzed. A decreasing junctional-dermal marker expression gradient was observed, directly correlating with atypical melanocytic nevus grading. High-grade atypical melanocytic nevi revealed coexistent TP53-CDKN2A-CDKN1B microsatellite abnormalities, and significantly higher junctional Ki67-TP53 expression (inversely correlated with CDKN1A-CDKN1B expression and in situ end labeling). Malignant melanomas showed coexistent microsatellite abnormalities (CDKN2A-CDKN1B), no topographic gradient, and significantly decreased expression. Melanocytic nevi and low-grade atypical melanocytic nevi revealed sporadic junctional CDKN2A microsatellite abnormalities and no significant topographic kinetic differences. High-grade atypical melanocytic nevi accumulate junctional TP53-CDKN1A-CDKN1B microsatellite abnormalities, being progression TP53-independent and better assessed in the dermis. Melanocytic nevi and low-grade atypical melanocytic nevi show low incidence of microsatellite abnormalities, and kinetic features that make progression unlikely.

Coexistent intraurothelial carcinoma and muscle-invasive urothelial carcinoma of the bladder: clonality and somatic down-regulation of DNA mismatch repair

Muscle-invasive urothelial carcinomas are heterogeneous neoplasms for which the clonal relationship with low-grade urothelial dysplasia and carcinomas in situ remains unknown, and both monoclonal and field change models have been proposed. Low-grade dysplasia (18) and carcinoma in situ (12) associated with muscle-invasive urothelial carcinoma were microdissected and topographically analyzed (intraepithelial and invasive superficial and deep to muscularis mucosa) for methylation pattern of androgen receptor alleles, TP53, RB1, WT1, and NF1 microsatellite analysis to assess clonal identity; MLH1 and MSH2 sequencing/immunostaining. Appropriate controls were run. Carcinoma in situ (100%) and invasive urothelial carcinoma (100%) revealed monoclonal patterns, whereas low-grade dysplasia was preferentially polyclonal (80%). Carcinoma in situ showed aneuploid DNA content and more abnormal microsatellites than the corresponding invasive compartments, opposite to low-grade dysplasia. Absent MLH1 protein expression with no gene mutations were identified in carcinoma in situ and nodular-trabecular urothelial carcinoma with high microsatellite abnormalities. Somatic mismatch repair protein down-regulation and the accumulation of tumor suppressor gene microsatellite abnormalities contribute to a molecular evolution for monoclonal carcinoma in situ divergent from coexistent muscle-invasive urothelial carcinoma. Low-grade dysplasia is however unlikely connected with this molecular progression.

Differential kinetic features by tumour topography in cutaneous small-cell neuroendocrine (Merkel cell) carcinomas

BACKGROUND/OBJECTIVES

Merkel cell carcinomas (MCC) reveal epithelial and neuroendocrine differentiation, but its topographic cell kinetics remains unknown. This study analyses proliferation, apoptosis, and DNA ploidy by topography, features that can help planning therapeutic protocols. This study topographically analyses proliferation, apoptosis, and DNA ploidy.

METHODS

We selected 27 small-cell MCCs (expressing one epithelial and two neural markers, with consistent ultrastructural findings) to evaluate mitotic figure counting, Ki-67 index, apoptosis index based on the in situ end labelling of fragmented DNA (using Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I, Klenow fragment), DNA ploidy, and BCL2 and TP53 immuno-expression. At least 50 high-power fields were screened per topographic compartment (superficial or papillary dermis, and deep or reticular dermis), recording average and standard deviation for each variable. Variables were statistically compared in each tumour compartment using analysis of variance and Student's t-test (significant if P < 0.05).

RESULTS

MCCs revealed superficial aneuploid DNA content, and no topographic differences for proliferation markers. Apoptosis showed significantly lower values in the deep compartment (average, P = 0.0050, and standard deviation, P = 0.0074), correlating with increased BCL2 and TP53 immuno-expressions.

CONCLUSIONS

High homogeneously distributed proliferation and superficial aneuploid DNA content defines MCCs. Apoptosis follows proliferation in superficial compartments, being less variable and proliferation independent in deep compartments, where it is inversely correlated with BCL2/TP53 expression.

Microsatellite abnormalities and somatic down-regulation of mismatch repair characterize nodular-trabecular muscle-invasive urothelial carcinoma of the bladder

AIMS

To correlate histological infiltration patterns with genetic and mismatch repair (MMR) profiles in muscle-invasive bladder urothelial carcinomas (UroC).

METHODS AND RESULTS

Infiltration patterns were assessed in the deep compartment of muscle-invasive UroC (nodular-trabecular, 45 cases; infiltrative, 27 cases). Tumour compartment (superficial and deep to muscularis mucosa) analysis included: microsatellite pattern of TP53, RB1, WT1 and NF1 by polymerase chain reaction/denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis; mitotic, Ki67, in situ end labelling (ISEL) indices and DNA ploidy. MMR was assessed by MLH1 and MSH2 sequencing and immunohistochemistry in UroC with two or more abnormal microsatellite loci. Statistical differences were tested using anova and Fisher's exact tests. Infiltrative UroC showed lower Ki67 index 14.94 +/- 4.28, ISEL index 14.1 +/- 10.0 and shorter median survival (20 months) than nodular-trabecular UroC (Ki67 index 20.65 +/- 4.94, ISEL 20.2 +/- 22.7, 37-month survival, respectively). The genetic profile was significantly different for RB1 (P = 0.0003) and NF1 (P = 0.0023) only, being more frequently abnormal in nodular-trabecular UroC. A significant decrease in MLH1 or MSH2 protein expression with no gene mutations was identified in UroC with microsatellite abnormalities and a nodular-trabecular growth pattern.

CONCLUSIONS

Somatic down-regulation of MMR proteins in nodular-trabecular muscle-invasive UroC results in RB1/NF1 microsatellite abnormalities, correlating with higher cellular turnover and longer survival.

Cytoarchitectural and kinetic features in the histological evaluation of follicular thyroid neoplasms

AIMS

The diagnosis of follicular thyroid carcinomas is mainly based on capsular and vascular invasion. The aim of this study was to determine the diagnostic relevance of nuclear features, inflammation and stromal changes.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Anisokaryosis, chromatin pattern, nucleolus, nuclear pleomorphism, nuclear/cytoplasmic ratio, necrosis, stromal changes and tumour interstitial lymphocytes (TIL) were analysed in adenomatous hyperplastic nodules (39), adenomas (43) and carcinomas (28 minimally invasive, 48 widely invasive and 27 anaplastic). Ki67 immunostaining, in situ end labelling (ISEL) for apoptosis and the Ki67/ISEL index were analysed by topographical compartments. Variables were compared by histological diagnosis using Fisher's exact test, analysis of variance and Student's t-tests and considered significant if P < 0.05. TIL were absent in 96% of neoplasms and 54% of adenomatous hyperplastic nodules. Conspicuous nucleoli, increased nuclear-cytoplasmic ratio and coexistent apoptosis-myxoid changes distinguished minimally invasive carcinomas from adenomas. The most specific variables of high-grade carcinoma were vasculonecrotic patterns, nuclear hyperchromatism and pleomorphism. A kinetic advantage predominated in the internal compartments of benign lesions and in the peripheral compartments of malignant lesions.

CONCLUSIONS

Follicular carcinomas show up-regulation of proliferation markers and the distinctive topographical kinetic profiles provide a basis for the distinction between benign and malignant and an explanation for the circumscription and encapsulation of benign lesions.

Complementary analysis of microsatellite tumor profile and mismatch repair defects in colorectal carcinomas

Microsatellite instability (MSI) is a prognostic factor and a marker of deficient mismatch repair (MMR) in colorectal adenocarcinomas (CRC). However, a proper application of this marker requires understanding the following: (1) The MSI concept: The PCR approach must amplify the correct locus and accurately identify the microsatellite pattern in the patient’s normal tissue. MSI is demonstrated when the length of DNA sequences in a tumor differs from that of nontumor tissue. Any anomalous expansion or reduction of tandem repeats results in extra-bands normally located in the expected size range (100 bp, above or below the expected product), differ from the germline pattern by some multiple of the repeating unit, and must show appropriate stutter. (2) MSI mechanisms: MMR gene inactivation (by either mutation or protein down-regulation as frequently present in deep CRC compartments) leads to mutation accumulation in a cell with every cellular division, resulting in malignant transformation. These mechanisms can express tumor progression and result in a decreased prevalence of aneuploid cells and loss of the physiologic cell kinetic correlations in the deep CRC compartments. MSI molecular mechanisms are not necessarily independent from chromosomal instability and may coexist in a given CRC. (3) Because of intratumoural heterogeneity, at least two samples from each CRC should be screened, preferably from the superficial (tumor cells above the muscularis propria) and deep (tumor cells infiltrating the muscularis propria) CRC compartments to cover the topographic tumor heterogeneity. (4) Pathologists play a critical role in identifying microsatellite-unstable CRC, such as occur in young patients with synchronous or metachronous tumors or with tumors showing classic histologic features. In these cases, MSI testing and/or MMR immunohistochemistry are advisable, along with gene sequencing and genetic counseling if appropriate. MSI is an excellent functional and prognostically useful marker, whereas MMR immunohistochemistry can guide gene sequencing.

DNA and kinetic heterogeneity during the clonal evolution of adrenocortical proliferative lesions

Monoclonal adrenocortical lesions show inverse correlation between proliferation and apoptosis, with proliferation being the single most important criterion of malignancy in adrenal lesions. No study yet has evaluated the variability of proliferation regarding the clonal pattern and diagnosis in adrenocortical nodular hyperplasias (ACNHs), adrenocortical adenomas (ACAs), and adrenocortical carcinomas (ACCs). We studied 69 ACNHs, 64 ACAs, and 23 ACCs (World Health Organization criteria) from 156 females. Clonality HUMARA test (from microdissected DNA samples), DNA content and proliferation analysis (slide and flow cytometry), and mitotic figure (MF) counting/50 high-power fields (HPFs) were performed in the same areas. Heterogeneity was assessed by 5cER (percentage of nonoctaploid cells with DNA content exceeding 5c) and standard deviation of MF/HPF. Statistics included analysis of variance/Student t tests regarding the clonal patterns and diagnosis. Polyclonal patterns were observed in 48 of 62 informative ACNHs and 7 of 56 informative ACAs, and monoclonal in 14 of 62 ACNHs, 49 of 56 ACAs, and 21 of 21 ACCs, with all hyperdiploid lesions (14 ACCs and 13 ACAs) being monoclonal. The standard deviation of MF/HPF progressively increased in ACNH-ACA-ACC (0.048 +/- 0.076, 0.110 +/- 0.097, 0.506 +/- 0.291, respectively; P = .0023), but did not differentiate ACNH/ACA. Only tetraploid percentage (P = .0496) and 5cER (P = .0352) distinguished polyclonal (3.64 +/- 2.20 and 0.14 +/- 0.15) from monoclonal (7.25 +/- 7.52 and 1.00 +/- 1.74) benign lesions. Malignancy significantly correlated with a low diploid percentage and high tetraploid percentage. Cell kinetic heterogeneity is the hallmark of adrenocortical neoplasms: tetraploid/hypertetraploid cell accumulation characterizes monoclonal lesions (suggesting nondisjunctional mitoses), whereas heterogeneously distributed mitotic figures and decreased diploid percentage define ACCs.

Novel perspective: focusing on the X chromosome in reproductive cancers

In an XX female, one of the two X chromosomes has been inactivated during early embryonic life to achieve a compensation of X-linked gene products between males and females, leaving only one allele of X-linked genes functional. There are some X-linked genes escaping the X-inactivation, i.e., being expressed from both alleles. Escape from X-inactivation varies at different levels; some genes have both alleles active in some women but only one allele active in others, whereas some other genes have both alleles active in neoplastic tissue but only one allele active normally. The X-inactivation may be considered functionally equivalent to a loss of heterozygosity (LOH) for some genes, whereas escape from X-inactivation may be equivalent to functional gene amplification for others. The physiological LOH may make X-linked tumor suppressor genes lose their function more easily, compared with autosomal tumor suppressor genes, thus predisposing women to cancer formation more easily. Moreover, the human X chromosome contains many genes related to cancer or to sex and reproduction. All these properties of the X chromosome suggest that it may play more important roles than any autosomal chromosome in the development and progression of reproductive and urologic cancers.

Epithelial carcinogenesis: challenging monoclonality

How carcinomas begin remains unclear, but experimental data do not entirely exclude the participation of more than one clone of neoplastic cells, even in relatively advanced epithelial tumour growth. Microdissection and new PCR clonality assays exploiting X-linked polymorphisms, some of which (including XIST) are expressed in RNA, create investigational opportunities complementary to other molecular analyses, but a reliable in situ assay of X-inactivation remains desirable. The necessity for stringent controls in clonality analysis is emphasized. While it may be possible to reconcile 'pluriclonal' (oligoclonal or polyclonal) carcinogenesis with widely accepted paradigms of genetic/epigenetic change and clonal selection in epithelial neoplasia, it deserves critical study as novel carcinogenic mechanisms would be implied.

Kinetic profiles by topographic compartments in muscle-invasive transitional cell carcinomas of the bladder: role of TP53 and NF1 genes

We evaluated 71 muscle-invasive transitional cell carcinomas (TCCs) of the bladder by tumor compartments. Kinetic parameters included mitotic figure counting, Ki-67 index, proliferation rate (DNA slide cytometry), and apoptotic index (in situ end labeling [ISEL] of fragmented DNA using digoxigenin-labeled deoxyuridine triphosphate and Escherichia coli DNA polymerase [Klenow fragment]). At least 50 high-power fields per compartment were screened from the same tumor areas; results are expressed as percentage of positive neoplastic cells. Mean and SD were compared by tumor compartment. DNA was extracted from microdissected samples (superficial and deep) and used for microsatellite analysis of TP53 and NF1 by polymerase chain reaction-denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis. Significantly higher marker scores were revealed in the superficial compartment than in the deep compartment. An ISEL index of less than 1% was revealed in 63% (45/71) of superficial compartments and 86% (61/71) of deep compartments. Isolated NF1 alterations were observed mainly in superficial compartments, whereas isolated TP53 abnormalities were present in deep compartments. Lower proliferation and down-regulation of apoptosis define kinetically the deep compartment of muscle-invasive TCC of the bladder and correlate with the topographic heterogeneity, NF1-defective in superficial compartments and TP53-defective in deep compartments.

Contribution of the microvessel network to the clonal and kinetic profiles of adrenal cortical proliferative lesions

Monoclonal adrenocortical lesions have been characterized by an inverse correlation between proliferation and apoptosis, and polyclonal lesions show a direct correlation. Their relationship with the vascular pattern remains unknown in adrenocortical nodular hyperplasias (ACNHs), adenomas (ACAs), and carcinomas (ACCs). We studied 20 ACNHs, 25 ACAs, and 10 ACCs (World Health Organization classification criteria) from 55 women. The analysis included X-chromosome inactivation assay (on microdissected samples), slide and flow cytometry, and in situ end labeling. Endothelial cells were stained with anti-CD31, and the blood vessel area and density were quantified by image analysis in the same areas. Appropriate tissue controls were run in every case. Regression analyses between kinetic and vascular features were performed in both polyclonal and monoclonal lesions. Polyclonal patterns were observed in 14 of 18 informative ACNHs and 3 of 22 informative ACAs, and monoclonal patterns were seen in 4 of 18 ACNHs, 19 of 22 ACAs, and 9 of 9 ACCs. A progressive increase in microvessel area was observed in the ACNH-ACA-ACC transition but was statistically significant between benign and malignant lesions only (191.36 +/- 168.32 v 958.07 +/- 1279.86 microm(2); P < .0001). In addition, case stratification by clonal pattern showed significant differences between polyclonal and monoclonal benign lesions; 6% of polyclonal and 57% of monoclonal lesions had microvessel area >186 microm(2) (P = .0000008). Monoclonal lesions showed parallel trends (but with opposite signs) for microvessel area and density in comparison with proliferation and apoptosis, whereas polyclonal lesions showed inverse trends. In conclusion, the kinetic advantage of monoclonal adrenal cortical lesions (increased proliferation, decreased apoptosis) is maintained by parallel increases in microvessel area and density.

Germline RET 634 mutation positive MEN 2A-related C-cell hyperplasias have genetic features consistent with intraepithelial neoplasia

C-cell hyperplasias are normally multifocal in multiple endocrine neoplasia type 2A. We compared clonality, microsatellite pattern of tumor suppressor genes, and cellular kinetics of C-cell hyperplasia foci in each thyroid lobe. We selected 11 females from multiple endocrine neoplasia type 2A kindred treated with thyroidectomy due to hypercalcitoninemia. C-cell hyperplasia foci were microdissected for DNA extraction to analyze the methylation pattern of androgen receptor alleles and microsatellite regions (TP53, RB1, WT1, and NF1). Consecutive sections were selected for MIB-1, pRB1, p53, Mdm-2, and p21WAF1 immunostaining, DNA content analysis, and in situ end labeling. Appropriate tissue controls were run. Only two patients had medullary thyroid carcinoma foci. Nine informative C-cell hyperplasia patients showed germline point mutation in RET, eight of them with the same androgen receptor allele preferentially methylated in both lobes. C-cell hyperplasia foci showed heterogeneous DNA deletions revealed by loss of heterozygosity of TP53 (12 of 20), RB1 (6 of 14), and WT1 (4 of 20) and hypodiploid G0/G1 cells (14 of 20), low cellular turnover (MIB-1 index 4.5%, in situ end labeling index 0.03%), and significantly high nuclear area to DNA index ratio. MEN 2A (germline point mutation in RET codon 634) C-cell hyperplasias are monoclonal and genetically heterogeneous and show down-regulated apoptosis, findings consistent with an intraepithelial neoplasia. Concordant X-chromosome inactivation and interstitial gene deletions suggest clone expansions of precursors occurring at a point in embryonic development before divergence of each thyroid lobe and may represent a paradigm for other germline mutations.