Enucleation of tumor versus partial nephrectomy as conservative treatment of renal cell carcinoma

Tumor enucleation for the treatment of T1 renal tumors: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Purpose

To evaluate the clinical efficacy and safety of tumor enucleation (TE) compared with partial nephrectomy (PN) for T1 renal cell carcinoma.

Materials and Methods

According to protocol, we searched multiple data sources for published and unpublished randomized controlled trials and nonrandomized studies (NRSs) in any language. We performed systematic review and meta-analysis according to the Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions and rated the certainty of the evidence (CoE) using the GRADE framework.

Results

We are uncertain about the effects of TE on perioperative (mean difference [MD] 3.38, 95% CI 1.52 to 5.23; I²=68%; 4 NRSs; 942 participants; very low CoE) and long-term (MD 2.31, 95% CI -1.40 to 6.01; I²=57%; 4 NRSs; 542 participants; very low CoE) residual renal function. TE may result in little to no difference in short-term residual renal function (MD 1.04, 95% CI 0.25 to 1.83; I²=0%; 2 NRSs; 256 participants; low CoE). We are uncertain about the effects of TE on cancer-specific mortality (risk ratio [RR] 0.90, 95% CI: 0.11 to 7.28; I²=0%; 2 NRSs; 551 participants; very low CoE) and major adverse events (RR 0.48, 95% CI: 0.30 to 0.79; I²=0%; 10 NRS; 2,360 participants; very low CoE).

Conclusions

While TE appears to have similar effects on short term postoperative residual renal function, there were uncertainties on mortality and major adverse events. However, we need rigorous RCTs to elucidate the effects of TE as the evidence stems mostly from NRSs.

Tumor Enucleation vs. Partial Nephrectomy for T1 Renal Cell Carcinoma: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Purpose: Tumor enucleation (TE) and partial nephrectomy (PN) have both become main treatment strategies for T1 renal cell carcinoma (RCC), despite the discrepancy between their safety margin. We performed a meta-analysis on all the relevant trials in order to compare the clinical efficacy and safety of TE with those of PN for RCC treatment. Methods: In this meta-analysis, randomized controlled trials or retrospective studies were included if they compared TE and PN therapy in patients with localized renal cancer. The main outcomes extracted were perioperative data and post-operative outcomes. Subgroups for analyses were undertaken according to tumor size and duration of follow up. Data were pooled using the generic variance method with a fixed or random effects model and expressed as mean differences or odds ratios with 95% CI. Results: A total of 13 studies containing 1,792 patients undergoing TE and 3,068 undergoing PN were identified. Our study showed that the patients received TE had significantly shorter operative time (MD = -28.46, 95% CI = -42.09, -14.83, P < 0.0001), less hospital day (MD = -0.68, 95% CI = -1.04, -0.31, P = 0.0003), less estimate blood loss (MD = -59.90, 95% CI = -93.23, -26.58, P = 0.0004) and smaller change in estimated glomerular filtration rate (fixed effect: MD = 4.66, 95% CI = 1.67, 7.66, P = 0.002), fewer complications (fixed effect: OR = 0.65, 95% CI = 0.50, 0.85, P = 0.001) compared with those received PN. However, there were no significant differences in terms of warm ischemic time, positive margin rates, recurrence rates and survival rates between the two groups. All the subgroup analyses presented consistent results with the overall analyses. Conclusions: Our findings suggested that TE is not only less-traumatizing and beneficial for recovery, but also better for renal function protection. Moreover, it did not show the evidence of an increase relapse rate or mortality rate when compared with PN.

Short-term Outcomes of Intraoperative Cell Saver Transfusion During Open Partial Nephrectomy

OBJECTIVE

To determine whether transfusion using the Cell Saver system is associated with inferior outcomes in patients undergoing open partial nephrectomy.

METHODS

All patients who underwent open partial nephrectomy by a single surgeon (BJD) from August 2008 to April 2015 were retrospectively identified. Operations were grouped and compared according to whether they included a transfusion using the Cell Saver intraoperative cell salvage system.

RESULTS

Sixty-nine open partial nephrectomies in 67 patients were identified. Thirty-three procedures (48%) included a Cell Saver transfusion. Most tumors were clear cell renal cell carcinoma (62%) and stage T1a (68%). There were no significant differences between groups for any measured clinical or pathologic characteristics. Operations including a Cell Saver transfusion were longer (141 vs 108 minutes, P <.001), had significantly greater blood loss (600 vs 200 mL, P <.001), and had longer median renal ischemia times (15 vs 10 minutes, P = .03). There were no significant differences in postoperative complication rate (21% vs 17%, P = .83) or median length of hospital stay (3 vs 3 days, P = .09). At a median follow-up of 23 months (interquartile range: 8-42 months), 1 patient in the non-Cell Saver transfusion group had cancer recurrence. There was no metastatic progression or cancer-specific mortality in either group.

CONCLUSION

Cell Saver transfusion during open partial nephrectomy was not associated with inferior outcomes with short-term follow-up, and no patients developed metastatic disease.

Analysis of surgical complications of renal tumor enucleation with standardized instruments and external validation of PADUA classification

PURPOSE

To assess surgical results and morbidity of tumor enucleation (TE), and to evaluate their correlation with PADUA nephrometric score.

METHODS

We prospectively gathered data, including accurate analysis of tumor nephrometry, from 244 consecutive patients treated with TE for clinically localized renal cell carcinoma. All surgical results were collected, and perioperative complications were stratified for severity according to Clavien system. Correlation between preoperative variables and surgical results/complications was assessed with uni- and multivariate analysis.

RESULTS

Mean (range) tumor size was 3.6 (0.8-10.0) cm, and mean (range) warm ischemia time was 16.8 (5-35) min. Overall, perioperative complications occurred in 45 patients (18.4 %), and of those 8 were medical and 37 were surgical (4 Clavien grade 1, 25 grade 2, and 8 grade 3) complications. Urine leakage rate was 2.0 %. No grade 4/5 complications occurred in this series. At univariate analysis PADUA score, endophytic tumor growth, tumor diameter, involvement of UCS and renal sinus resulted associated with warm ischemia time (p < 0.0001 each) and surgical complications (p = 0.0007, p = 0.049, p = 0.021, p = 0.036, and p = 0.029, respectively). At logistic regression, nephrometry score resulted independently associated with overall complications (related risk for each increased point 1.54; p = 0.017), surgical complications (related risk 1.58; p = 0.016), and Clavien grade 3 surgical complications (related risk 2.99; p = 0.008).

CONCLUSIONS

The TE technique was associated with a 15.2 % surgical complication rate with a 3.3 % reintervention rate (including ureteral stenting and superselective renal artery embolization). Tumor nephrometry and surgical indication resulted independent predictors of Clavien grade 3 complications. The PADUA score is a reliable tool to predict surgical results and morbidity of TE.

Radical or simple nephrectomy in localized renal cell carcinoma: what is a choice?

INTRODUCTION

Renal cell carcinoma (RCC) accounts for approximately 3% of all adult malignancies. Surgery remains the only effective method of renal tumors treatment. In fact, for advanced RCC, radical nephrectomy (RN) should remain a standard treatment. However, in localized RCC (LRCC) a real increase of survival rates realized by RN compared with simple nephrectomy (SN) or organ-sparing surgery is discussable. The aim of our study was to assess the impact of nephrectomy type on the prognosis of LRCC treatment.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

We analyzed the long-term outcomes of RN (n = 248 pts.) and SN (n = 170 pts.) in 418 pts. with LRCC. There were no significant statistical differences in tumor stages, age stratification or gender between these two groups. To compare the efficacy of RN and SN we determined overall survival (OS) and cancer-specific survival (CSS) rates in both divided groups. The 3-year OS in RN group was 93.1% vs. 91.8% in SN group.

RESULTS

CSS rates after the same period were 96.8% vs. 94.7% respectively. The 5-year OS in RN group was 91.5% vs. 88.8% in SN group. After 5 years of follow-up, CSS in RN group was 94.4% vs. 92.4% in SN group. Type of nephrectomy does not influence on LRCC outcomes. The 3- and 5-year overall survival rates and cancer-specific survival rates in RN and SN group were almost identical.

CONCLUSION

Hence, if radical nephrectomy does not ensure better survival than simple nephrectomy, the expediency of vast surgery in localized RCC is doubtful.

Stereotactic body radiotherapy of primary and metastatic renal lesions for patients with only one functioning kidney

BACKGROUND

About 2% of patients with a carcinoma in one kidney develop either metastases or a new primary tumor in the contralateral kidney. Often, renal cancers progress rapidly at peripheral sites and a metastasis to the second kidney may not be the patient's main problem. However, when an initial renal cancer is more indolent yet spreads to the formerly unaffected kidney or a new primary tumor forms there, local treatment may be needed. Stereotactic body radiotherapy (SBRT) has been demonstrated as a valuable treatment option for tumors that cause local symptoms. Presented here is a retrospective analysis of patients in whom SBRT was used to control primary or metastatic renal disease.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Seven patients with a mean age of 64 (44-76) were treated for metastases from a malignant kidney to its contralateral counterpart. Dose/fractionation schedules varied between 10 Gy x 3 and 10 Gy x 4 depending on target location and size, given within one week. Follow-up times for patients who remained alive were 12, 52 and 66 months and for those who subsequently died were 10, 16, 49 and 70 months.

RESULTS

Local control, defined as radiologically stable disease or partial/complete response, was obtained in six of these seven patients and regained after retreatment in the one patient whose lesion progressed. Side effects were generally mild, and in five of the seven patients, kidney function remained unaffected after treatment. In two patients, the creatinine levels remained moderately elevated at approximately 160 micromol/L post treatment. At no time was dialysis required.

CONCLUSION

These results indicate that SBRT is a valuable alternative to surgery and other options for patients with metastases from a cancer-bearing kidney to the remaining kidney and provides local tumor control with satisfactory kidney function.

Histopathologic analysis of peritumoral pseudocapsule and surgical margin status after tumor enucleation for renal cell carcinoma

BACKGROUND

The oncologic safety of blunt tumor enucleation (TE) of renal cell carcinoma (RCC) depends on the presence of a continuous pseudocapsule (PS) around the tumor and on the possibility of obtaining negative surgical margins (SMs).

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the PS and SMs after TE to define the real need to take a rim of healthy parenchyma around the tumor to avoid the risk of positive SMs. The risk of PS invasion related to other clinical and pathologic variables was also evaluated.

DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS

Between September 2006 and December 2007, data were gathered prospectively from 187 consecutive patients who had kidney surgery. Overall, 90 consecutive patients who had TE for RCC were eligible for the study. All specimens were evaluated using an image analyzer by a dedicated uropathologist.

INTERVENTION

TE was done by blunt dissection using the natural cleavage plane between the tumor and the normal parenchyma.

MEASUREMENTS

PS, SM, and routinely available clinical and pathologic variables were recorded.

RESULTS AND LIMITATIONS

In 60 RCC tumors (67%) the PS was intact and free from invasion (PS-) while in 30 (33%) there were signs of penetration within its layers, with or without invasion beyond it. Indeed, 26.6% had PS that had been penetrated on the parenchymal side and 6.6% had penetration on the perirenal fat tissue side. The odds of having PS penetration increased significantly with an increase in clinical tumor size. PS penetration was also significantly associated with pathologic tumor dimensions and grade. In all cases the SMs were negative after TE. The present patients, followed for >2 yr, will enable us to correlate the risk of local recurrence with PS status.

CONCLUSIONS

The risk of PS penetration is associated with clinical and pathologic tumor dimensions and grade. If there is PS invasion into normal parenchyma, the presence of a thin layer of tissue allows for negative SM even if a TE is performed.

A 7-case anatomopathology revision in the presence of renal relapse after conservative therapy: implications on surgical technique

Anatomopathology revision of the cases which underwent second surgery because of a renal neoplasm relapsing after conservative surgery in order to find possible relations with the surgical technique.

Materials and Methods.

At our institution, Nephron-sparing surgery (NSS) is currently indicated as elective technique for neoplasms smaller than 4cm in diameter. The technique involves the removal of the neoplasm with a margin of healthy parenchyma and with the perilesional fat. The patients are monitored with a first CT check after 4 months and then with ultrasound/CT checks every 6 months in the first 2 years and then once a year. In the present study we analyze the records of the cases in the period 1994–2005 undergoing a second operation for a renal tumor relapsing in the operated kidney after NSS. All specimens were reviewed by a single experienced uro-pathologist, who determined the size of the surgical margins and the relations between the seat of recidivism and the seat of the preceding enucleoresection.

Results.

Seven cases with renal relapse were found out of 267 undergoing conservative surgery in the same period (incidence: 2.6%). The diagnosis had always been made lacking any other disease localizations at a complete re-staging; the average relapse latency was 19.4 months (8–46 months). In 5 cases the second tumor was found in the seat of the previous NSS: for these cases the minimum margin of the enucleoresection was lower than 3mm (median minimum margin: 1.6 mm). Differently, in the remaining 2 cases, both with a wider surgical margin (median minimum margin: 12.0 mm), the seat of the first and that of the second neoplasm were distant. In particular, in one case a multifocal relapse with a spread microvascular embolization was found, while in the other the two neoplasms showed a different histotype.

Discussion and Conclusions.

In the 5 cases with a little resection margin and relapsing tumor in the seat of the enucleoresection, the persistence of a peritumoral microscopic neoplastic disease can be assumed. In the other 2 cases showing a wider surgical margin the relapse can be attributed to the widespread microscopic multifocality in one case, and to the development of a second de novo neoplasm in the other case. The extension of the surgical margin seems then to have played a role in determining a relapse in the seat of enucleoresection.

Long-term results of simple enucleation for the treatment of small renal cell carcinoma

OBJECTIVE

We have analyzed our institutional experience with simple enucleation for the treatment of small renal tumors for elective indications.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A total of 30 patients underwent elective nephron-sparing surgery (NSS) from May 1997 to January 2001. All patients underwent NSS by means of enucleation. The tumor bed was coagulated carefully for haemostatic and partly for oncological reasons. Median follow-up was 71 months (range: 49-91 months).

RESULTS

Pathological review according to the 2002 TNM classification showed that 70 % (21 of 30) of tumors were pT1a, 26.7 % (8 of 30) pT1b and 3.3 % (1 of 30) pT3a. Median tumor size was 3.7 cm. (range: 3.0 - 5.5 cm). There was no perioperative mortality (within the first 30 days). Bleeding had not been recorded during perioperative period. Urinary leakage was observed in 1 patient (3.3%). No case of local recurrence was observed. Five and 7-year cumulative survival was 96.6% and 93.3%, respectively. Five and 7-year cancer specific survival was 100% and 96.5%, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Simple tumor enucleation is a safe and acceptable approach for elective NSS. It provides excellent long-term progression-free and cancer specific survival rates, and is not associated with an increased risk of local recurrence compared to partial nephrectomy.

Simple Enucleation for the Treatment of Renal Cell Carcinoma Between 4 and 7 cm in Greatest Dimension: Progression and Long-Term Survival

PURPOSE

We present our findings in a series of patients treated with simple enucleation for RCC 4 to 7 cm in greatest dimension. We specifically report the incidence of local and systemic recurrence, and the disease specific survival rate.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We retrospectively reviewed clinical and pathological data on 71 patients who underwent nephron sparing surgery by simple enucleation between 1986 and 2004 for sporadic, unilateral, pathologically confirmed, 4 to 7 cm RCC. Patients with a solitary kidney due to previous RCC treated with radical nephrectomy were excluded from study. None of the patients had preoperative or intraoperative suspicion of positive nodes. All patients were free of distant metastases before surgery (M0). Patient status was last evaluated in May 2005. Mean followup was 74 months (median 51, range 12 to 225).

RESULTS

Pathological review according to the 2002 TNM classification showed that 42% of the tumors (30 of 71) were pT1a, 44% (31 of 71) were pT1b and 14% (10 of 71) were pT3a. Mean tumor greatest dimension +/- SD was 4.7 +/- 0.81 cm (median 4.5, range 4.0 to 7.0) cm. None of the patients died within the first 30 days of surgery. There were no major complications requiring open reoperation, such as bleeding and urinary leakage/urinoma. Five and 8-year cancer specific survival was 85.1% and 81.6%, respectively. Five-year cancer specific survival in patients with pT1a (4 cm), pT1b and pT3a disease was 95.7%, 83.3% and 58.3%, respectively (pT1a vs pT1b p = 0.254, pT1a vs pT3a p = 0.006 and pT1b vs pT3a p = 0.143). Overall 10 patients experienced progressive disease (14.9%), of whom 3 had local recurrence (4.5%) alone or local recurrence associated with distant metastases.

CONCLUSIONS

Simple tumor enucleation is a useful and acceptable approach to nephron sparing surgery for 4 to 7 cm RCC. It provides long-term cancer specific survival rates similar to those of radical nephrectomy and is not associated with a greater risk of local recurrence than partial nephrectomy for RCC less than 4 cm in greatest dimension.

PROGRESSION AND LONG-TERM SURVIVAL AFTER SIMPLE ENUCLEATION FOR THE ELECTIVE TREATMENT OF RENAL CELL CARCINOMA: EXPERIENCE IN 107 PATIENTS

PURPOSE

We present our findings in a series of T1a renal cell carcinoma treated with elective simple enucleation, specifically reporting the incidence of local recurrence, and progression-free and disease specific survival rates.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A total of 107 patients who underwent elective nephron sparing surgery performed with simple enucleation from January 1989 to December 2000 were studied retrospectively. None of the patients had preoperative or intraoperative suspicion of positive nodes. All patients were free from distant metastases before surgery (M0). Patient status was last evaluated in July 2004. Mean (median, range) followup was 88.3 (84, 44 to 175) months.

RESULTS

Pathological review according to the 2002 TNM classification showed that 95% (102 of 107) of tumors were pT1a, 4% (4 of 107) pT1b and 1% (1 of 107) pT3a. Mean (SD, median, range) tumor greatest dimension was 2.7 (0.93, 2.5, 0.6 to 5) cm. None of the patients died in the immediate postoperative period (within the first 30 days). There were no major complications such as bleeding and urinary leakage/urinoma requiring reoperation. The 5 and 10-year cancer specific survival was 99% and 97.8%, respectively. The 5 and 10-year progression-free survival was 98.1% and 94.7%, respectively. Overall 3 patients had disease progression (2.8%) of whom 2 (1.9%) were local recurrence, 1 alone and 1 associated with distant metastases diagnosed 12 months earlier.

CONCLUSIONS

Simple tumor enucleation is a safe and acceptable approach for elective nephron sparing surgery. It provides excellent long-term progression-free and cancer specific survival rates, and is not associated with an increased risk of local recurrence compared with partial nephrectomy.

Contrast-enhanced second-harmonic sonography in the detection of pseudocapsule in renal cell carcinoma

OBJECTIVE

Our purpose was to assess the capacity of contrast-enhanced second-harmonic sonography to detect a pseudocapsule in renal masses compared with conventional gray-scale sonography. SUBJECTS AND METHODS. Thirty-two patients with 40 renal masses suspicious for renal cancer (mean diameter, 3.1 cm) were prospectively studied with contrast-enhanced second-harmonic sonography during IV administration of a second-generation sonographic contrast agent. The sonographic criteria for the presence of a pseudocapsule were a peritumoral hypoanechoic halo on conventional gray-scale imaging and a rim of perilesional enhancement, increasing in the tardive phase of the examination, on contrast-enhanced second-harmonic imaging. Multiphasic helical CT or dynamic MRI or both were performed in all patients.

RESULTS

Final diagnoses of the 40 renal masses were as follows: hemorrhagic cysts, five; angiomyolipomas, four; lymphomas, four; metastasis from lung cancer, one; and renal cell carcinomas (RCCs), 26. Histologic diagnosis of RCC was surgically obtained in all patients. Nephron-sparing surgery was performed in 12 of 26 RCCs, and radical nephrectomy was performed in the remaining 14. At pathologic examination, pseudocapsule was found in 14 (53.8%) of 26 RCCs. On conventional sonography, the presence of a pseudocapsule was detected in 3 of 14 RCCs (sensitivity, 21%). Sonographic contrast-enhanced harmonic imaging revealed the presence of pseudocapsule in 12 of 14 RCCs (sensitivity, 85.7%). In the remaining 12 RCCs with either absent or extensive neoplastic infiltration of pseudocapsule seen at pathologic evaluation, pseudocapsule was not visible on either conventional or contrast-enhanced second-harmonic sonography. The pseudocapsule was not visible in any of the 14 noncancerous renal masses on either conventional or contrast-enhanced sonography.

CONCLUSION

Sonographic contrast-specific imaging with a second-generation contrast agent is effective in improving the sonographic visualization of tumoral pseudocapsule. This finding could be useful both in the sonographic diagnosis and in the choice of conservative surgery for renal cell carcinoma. The potential role of second-harmonic contrast-enhanced sonography in the management of renal cell carcinoma should be investigated in larger series and compared with the findings of state-of-the-art MRI and CT.

Which Is the Real Gold Standard for Small-Volume Renal Tumors? Radical Nephrectomy versus Nephron-Sparing Surgery

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Until recently, the gold standard for treatment of localized renal-cell carcinoma with a normal contralateral unit was deemed to be a formal radical nephrectomy. Advocates of nephron-sparing surgery have recently challenged this concept; we wished to evaluate the evidence to determine which treatment is objectively superior for patients with renal tumors up to 4 cm.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

MEDLINE, CANCERLIT, and EMBASE computer literature searches were performed to identify peer-reviewed papers pertaining to radical nephrectomy (RN), nephron-sparing surgery (NSS), or comparisons of these methods for tumors as large as 4 cm in maximum diameter. Review of the bibliographies of recovered articles and data in recent textbooks were used to supplement the computerized searches. There were a total of 797 cases in the RN group and 1211 in the NSS group. The parameters specifically evaluated were evidence of local recurrence, disease progression, and death within 33 months, this period being chosen primarily because it was the shortest follow-up in the studies evaluated. The data were then subjected to rigorous statistical analysis. Laparoscopic radical nephrectomy (LRN) and laparoscopic nephron-sparing surgery (LNSS) articles were also reviewed; however, current follow-up periods were considered too short to draw a statistically significant conclusion.

RESULTS

Disease-specific survival rates (P=0.001; Mann-Whitney test) as well as the incidence of metastases (P<0.05; Mann-Whitney test) were significantly better in the NSS group. The incidence of local recurrence (P=0.22; Mann-Whitney test) was not significantly different. It should be borne in mind that there are different follow-up periods for each study, and this may have had an impact on the results.

CONCLUSION

Nephron-sparing surgery seems to be as effective as RN in patients with renal cell tumours up to 4 cm, although only a large randomized controlled trial with long follow-up periods would provide a definite answer.

Renal cell carcinoma in the solitary kidney: an analysis of complications and outcome after nephron sparing surgery

PURPOSE

We evaluated surgical techniques, pathological features and extended outcomes in patients with renal cell carcinoma in a solitary kidney treated with surgical excision.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Between 1970 and 1998, 76 patients underwent nephron sparing surgery for sporadic renal cell carcinoma in a solitary kidney, including 63 with tissue specimens available for pathological review who comprised the cohort. Six (9.5%) patients had a congenitally absent kidney and 57 (90.5%) had previously undergone contralateral nephrectomy for renal cell carcinoma. The clinical and pathological features examined were patient age at nephron sparing surgery, sex, type of nephron sparing surgery (enucleation, partial nephrectomy or ex vivo resection), tumor size, nuclear grade, histological subtype and 1997 tumor stage. Overall cancer specific, local recurrence-free and metastasis-free survival as well as early (within 30 days of nephron sparing surgery) and late (30 days to 1 year after nephron sparing surgery) complications were assessed. Univariate and multivariate analyses were done to test for the associations of clinical and pathological features with outcome.

RESULTS

Most patients were treated with enucleation (36.5%), standard partial nephrectomy (38.1%) or the 2 procedures (11.1%) and in 8 (12.7%) ex vivo tumor resection was done. The renal cell carcinoma histological subtypes were clear cell in 82.5% of cases, papillary in 15.9% and chromophobe in 1.6%. Grade was 1 to 3 in 10 (15.9%), 42 (66.7%) and 10 (15.9%) tumors, respectively. At 5 and 10 years the overall survival rate was 74.7% and 45.8%, the cancer specific survival rate was 80.7% and 63.7%, the local recurrence-free survival rate was 89.2% and 80.3%, and the metastasis-free survival rate was 69% and 50.4%, respectively. Tumor stage and nuclear grade were significantly associated with death from any cause, death from renal cell carcinoma and distant metastases on multivariate analysis. Notably no patient with papillary or chromophobe renal cell carcinoma died of renal cell carcinoma, or had recurrence or metastasis. The type of nephron sparing surgery was not significantly associated with outcome, although there were too few patients with recurrence to assess the association of the type of nephron sparing surgery with local recurrence. The most common early complication was acute renal failure in 12.7% of cases, while the most common late complications were proteinuria in 15.9% and renal insufficiency in 12.7%.

CONCLUSIONS

The 1997 tumor stage and nuclear grade were significant predictors of death from any cause, death from renal cell carcinoma and distant metastases in patients treated with nephron sparing surgery for renal cell carcinoma involving a solitary kidney. Nephron sparing surgery in a solitary kidney can be performed safely and with minimal morbidity.

Is a 1-CM margin necessary during nephron-sparing surgery for renal cell carcinoma?

OBJECTIVES

To determine whether a 1-cm margin is necessary for cancer control during nephron-sparing surgery (NSS) for renal cell carcinoma (RCC).

METHODS

A retrospective review of 67 patients who underwent NSS for RCC between 1990 and 2000 was conducted. The data collected included patient demographics, tumor size and location, histologic type and grade, margin status (positive or negative), and the shortest distance of normal parenchyma (in millimeters) around the tumor in the final pathologic specimen. Recurrence was determined from the clinical follow-up, which included physical examination, ultrasonography or computed tomography, and various laboratory tests.

RESULTS

Fifty-five cases were performed open and 12 laparoscopically. The mean follow-up was 60 months (range 5 to 124). The mean tumor size was 3.0 cm (range 0.9 to 11.0). Seven patients were found to have a positive margin; 1 died of metastatic RCC, 1 was alive with systemic recurrence, and 5 had no evidence of disease. Of 11 patients with a negative margin distance of less than 1 mm, 9 were recurrence free, 1 had simultaneous local and pulmonary relapse, and the other had pulmonary recurrence only. The remainder of the study patients (n = 49) had negative margins greater than 1 mm, and all were alive without evidence of disease at the last follow-up.

CONCLUSIONS

This review questions the necessity of a 1-cm margin to prevent recurrence after NSS for RCC. Additional studies to determine the optimal margin distance should be conducted.

Nephron-sparing surgery of renal cell carcinoma with a normal opposite kidney: long-term outcome in 180 patients

OBJECTIVES

To investigate the long-term outcome of an organ-saving approach for renal cell carcinoma (RCC) with a normal opposite kidney (elective indication).

METHODS

Since 1979, 180 patients have undergone nephron-sparing surgery at our institution for RCC in the presence of a normal contralateral kidney. The mean age was 56 years (range 23 to 83), and the mean follow-up was 4.7 years (maximum 14. 8). Most of these tumors were found incidentally, with a mean tumor diameter on ultrasound of 3.3 cm (range 1.0 to 8.6).

RESULTS

The postoperative course was unremarkable in 173 patients. Postoperative bleeding was encountered in 4 patients and urinary extravasation in an additional 3 patients. No surgical reintervention was necessary. One hundred seventy-five RCCs were pT1 and 5 were pT3a; 73 were grade 1, 100 grade 2, and 7 were grade 3. The mean tumor diameter (surgical specimen) was 3.2 cm (range 0.5 to 7). In 132 cases, the tumor was less than 4 cm and in 48 cases, greater than 4 cm. Three patients experienced local tumor recurrence (1.6%) during follow-up, and two others developed distant metastases. The 5-year tumor-specific survival rate was 98.0%.

CONCLUSIONS

Nephron-sparing surgery for RCC under an elective indication in selected patients offers excellent long-term survival and an acceptably low local tumor recurrence rate. These results support the concept of nephron-sparing surgery in the presence of a normal contralateral kidney.

Renal parenchyma-sparing surgery in carcinoma

BACKGROUND

There is controversy regarding the role of renal-sparing surgery in patients with kidney cancer who have a functioning contralateral kidney.

METHODS

The present study aimed to review the recent experience of renal-sparing surgery at Royal Prince Alfred Hospital (RPAH), Sydney. Eighteen consecutive patients undergoing conservative surgery for kidney tumours at RPAH between February 1987 and January 1995, were reviewed. Eleven patients had imperative indications for conservative surgery and the remaining seven patients had elective indications. Ten patients had modified enucleation with a margin of normal parenchyma. Six patients underwent partial nephrectomy and two had wedge resections. Patients were followed up at 1, 6 and 12 months, and thence every 6-12 months. Follow-up ranged from 9 to 104 months (mean: 46.2 months, median: 48 months).

RESULTS

Sixteen of the 18 patients were still alive at the end of the follow-up (October 1995), with no clinical evidence of local or distant metastasis. The two deaths were not related to the fact that these patients had conservative surgery. The average tumour dimensions were 43 mm x 49 mm, with an average volume of 194 mm3. All resections were complete, with margins ranging between 1.0 and 20.0 mm (mean: 8.7 mm). The survival rate in the present study is comparable to those found by other researchers.

CONCLUSIONS

Conservative surgery is indicated in renal tumours where radical surgery would render the patient anephric. Conservative surgery, however, is controversial in a patient with a normal contralateral kidney. The present study has shown that renal parenchyma-preserving surgery for localized tumours provides a feasible treatment option.

Surgical enucleation for renal cell carcinoma (RCC). Prognostic significance of tumour stage, grade and DNA ploidy

This study reviews a total of 26 renal cell carcinoma (RCC) who underwent enucleation of the tumour with functionally and anatomically normal controlateral kidney and no evidence of systemic renal disease. At follow-up, after a mean of 62 months the disease specific survival rate for this series was 88.5%. Survival rates according to the pathologic stage, grading, tumour diameter and ploidy are reported. Local recurrences were documented in 4 of the 26 RCC. All 4 RCC were more than 5 cm in diameter and recurred in the remaining parenchyma. After local recurrence, three tumours with aneuploid DNA content underwent radical nephrectomy, whereas 1 with diploid DNA content was submitted to a new enucleation of the recurrence. To date the diploid case is still alive 3 years after the original resection of the primary tumour whereas the other 3 patients died for metastatic disease. In our experience the ideal candidate for renal sparing surgery in the presence of a normal opposite kidney is an asymptomatic patient that incidentally is brought to our attention with a small size (less than 5 cm in diameter), low stage (T1-T2) tumour, well surrounded by a pseudocapsule. DNA content is a valuable prognostic factor in patients submitted to conservative surgery. Diploid tumours have been seen to have a better prognosis and in case of local recurrence they may be reconsidered for a new enucleation of the recurrence.

Renal cell carcinoma: preoperative assessment for enucleative surgery with angiography, CT, and MRI

PURPOSE

Our purpose was to assess various imaging methods in detecting a pseudocapsule of renal cell carcinoma (RCC), which is critical for successful tumor enucleation.

METHOD

In 42 patients with histopathologically proven RCC, images obtained at angiography (n = 42), CT (n = 30), and MRI (n = 19) were investigated retrospectively. All patients underwent treatment (enucleation: n = 15; nephrectomy: n = 27). The imaging criteria for the presence of a pseudocapsule were as follows: a surrounding radiolucent rim on angiography, a low or high density rim on CT, and a low intensity rim on MRI. All images were retrospectively reviewed by three radiologists without knowledge of the clinical and histological findings.

RESULTS

Thirty-three of 42 RCCs showed a pseudocapsule on the surgical specimen. A pseudocapsule was detected in 67% of tumors (22/33) on angiography, 26% (6/23) on CT, 27% (4/15) on T1-weighted MRI, 93% (14/15) on T2-weighted MRI, 67% (8/12) on dynamic enhanced T1-weighted MRI, and 15% (2/13) on delayed enhanced T1-weighted MRI.

CONCLUSION

T2-weighted MR images are superior for visualizing a pseudocapsule of RCC and for providing reliable selection criteria for tumor enucleation.

Laparoscopic enucleation of a renal cell carcinoma

The purpose of this study was to report on the feasibility of laparoscopic excision of renal cell carcinoma. An 81-year-old female with renovascular disease underwent a laparoscopic excisional operation for a 2-cm tumor localized in the left kidney. Pathological evaluation showed a low-grade tumor without any extension through the renal capsule (grade I Hand Broder, stage I Robson). The postoperative course was uneventful; there was minimal postoperative pain. The patient was discharged home on the sixth day. Laparoscopic excision would appear to be a safe and effective technique in selected cases.

Renal parenchyma-sparing surgery as conservative treatment of renal cell carcinoma

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the role of parenchyma-sparing surgery in patients with renal cell carcinoma (RCC).

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Between 1965 and 1990, 34 patients with RCC underwent renal parenchyma-sparing surgery. There were 22 men and 12 women with a mean age of 62 years (range 40-89). Ten patients underwent enucleation (Group A), 15 partial nephrectomy (Group B), and nine a combination of procedures (Group C). Conservative surgery was performed in the presence of a normal contralateral unit in four patients (12%).

RESULTS

Five patients developed local recurrence. Metastases appeared in six patients (18%) from 12 to 58 months post-operatively. Adequate renal function was obtained in 32 of the 34 patients. The mean follow-up for all patients was 64.6 months overall, 75.6 months for group A, 64.1 months for group B and 53.4 months for group C. The 3 and 5 year probabilities of survival for all patients were 77.8% and 69.5% respectively. The probabilities of 3 and 5 year survival were 80% for group A, 80% for group B and 71.4% and 57.1% for group C.

CONCLUSION

Enucleation and partial nephrectomy are both viable options in the management of solitary or bilateral RCC, as there is no decline in effective tumour control and prognosis. Larger groups and longer follow-ups are needed to assess the role of renal parenchyma-sparing surgery more definitively.

Expanding indications for conservative renal surgery in renal cell carcinoma

OBJECTIVE

To more clearly define the selection criteria for conservative renal surgery in renal cell carcinoma.

METHOD

The survival experience of 42 patients who underwent in situ partial nephrectomy (21), enucleation (18), or both (3) over an eighteen-year period was examined. The presence or a history of contralateral cancer, type of surgery, gender, grade, diameter of tumor, age at diagnosis, presenting symptoms, positive surgical margins, smoking history, and stage were examined with regard to prognostic significance.

RESULTS

The five-year cancer-specific survival rates were 100 percent for those patients undergoing partial nephrectomy and 84 percent for those undergoing enucleation. The local recurrence rate was 4.8 percent (2/42) for the group, with both recurrences occurring in patients with von Hippel-Lindau disease. The mean diameter of tumor resected was 4.2 cm. Those patients found to have a positive surgical margin (6) had a significantly shorter disease-specific survival than those who did not (37) (p = 0.004), and those with a smoking history (23) had a significantly shorter survival than non-smokers (19) (p = 0.038).

CONCLUSIONS

We conclude that both partial nephrectomy and enucleation are acceptable approaches to renal cell carcinoma in select cases, with survival rates that closely approximate those found in radical nephrectomy series. Renal carcinomas that are peripherally located and small in diameter (< or = 5 cm) are most appropriate for these procedures, and given the excellent results noted to date, the expanded use of these approaches to include very young patients and those with any disease process that may affect renal function is warranted. A positive surgical margin is an ominous pathologic finding and should be avoided by frozen section biopsy at surgery or possibly intraoperative ultrasonography. Additionally, smokers with renal cell carcinoma have a poorer disease-specific survival than non-smokers, further questioning a carcinogenic etiology in this disease.

Laparoscopic wedge resection of a renal tumor: initial experience

Advances in laparoscopic surgery have resulted in the development of reliable techniques for performing laparoscopic simple, radical, and partial nephrectomy. Herein, we present a case of a small, low-stage renal mass laparoscopically explored and excised by a wedge resection. Although this minimally invasive technique allowed the patient a rapid recovery and achieved local tumor excision, the clinical appropriateness remains controversial.

Radical and Conservative Surgery of Renal Cell Carcinoma

After having outlined the approaches for radical nephrectomy and after some critical considerations, the authors dwell upon the current indications for conservative surgery of renal cell carcinoma. They discuss the problems related to such therapy, emphasizing the advantages and possible risks. In particular, the problems connected with multifocal lesions and peritumoral spread are examined, the real clinical meaning of which is at present unknown, as shown by the discrepancy between experimental and clinical data. Then the authors present their own experience concerning 11 cases of renal carcinoma who underwent conservative surgical treatment between January 89 and September 92. None had relapses nor further progression. The conclusion is that, although the results of such surgery are very encouraging, nonetheless prospective studies and a wider selection of cases are required in order to define its role in the treatment of renal carcinoma.

Outcome of renal transplantation or dialysis in patients with a history of renal cancer

BACKGROUND

Therapeutic options for patients with bilateral renal cancer or cancer in a solitary kidney are limited to partial nephrectomy or bilateral radical nephrectomy with subsequent renal transplantation or dialysis. The outcome after partial nephrectomy is well documented, but few reports discuss the long-term survival of patients receiving chronic dialysis or after renal transplantation. Information regarding the long-term prognosis for these patients is important when deciding on the appropriate treatment.

METHODS

The authors retrospectively evaluated the long-term prognosis of 23 patients who lost renal function because of surgery for renal cell carcinoma or Wilms' tumor between 1970 and 1990.

RESULTS

Twelve patients had renal transplantation (Tx group), and 11 had chronic dialysis (DS group). In the Tx group, four patients had Wilms' tumor and eight had renal cell carcinoma (Stage I, 5 patients; Stage II, 2 patients; Stage III, 1 patient). In the DS group, three patients had Wilms' tumor, and eight had renal cell carcinoma (Stage I, 5 patients; Stage III, 2 patients; Stage IV, 1 patient). Unexpectedly, 9 of 11 (82%) patients from the DS group died of cancer, compared with 1 of 12 (8%) patients who had transplantation (P = 0.0133) despite comparable stages of renal cell carcinoma and Wilms' tumor in the two groups.

CONCLUSIONS

For patients who have had bilateral nephrectomy or removal of a solitary kidney, the authors recommend waiting at least 12 months, during which time the patient receives dialysis, before proceeding with transplantation if there is no evidence of recurrent tumor.