Validity of a vasculitis activity index for systemic necrotizing vasculitis

Psychometric properties of outcome measurement instruments for ANCA-associated vasculitis: a systematic literature review

OBJECTIVES

To systematically review the psychometric properties of outcome measurement instruments used in ANCA-associated vasculitis (AAV).

METHODS

Medline, EMBASE, Cochrane, Scopus and Web of Science were searched from inception to 14 July 2020 for validation studies of instruments used in AAV. Following the COnsensus-based Standards for the selection of health status Measurement INstruments (COSMIN) and OMERACT frameworks, different psychometric properties (validity, reliability, responsiveness and feasibility) were summarized. Risk of bias was assessed according to the COSMIN checklist.

RESULTS

From 2505 articles identified, 32 met the predefined selection criteria, providing information on 22 instruments assessing disease activity (n = 7), damage (n = 2), activity and damage (n = 1), health-related quality of life (HRQoL; n = 9) and function (n = 3). Most of the instruments were tested in AAV as a group or in granulomatosis with polyangiitis only.The BVAS, any version, the Vasculitis Damage Index (VDI) and the AAV-Patient-Reported Outcome (AAV-PRO) have been more extensively validated than the other instruments. BVAS for Wegener Granulomatosis (BVAS/WG) has been shown to be valid for measuring disease activity [correlation with Physician global assessment (r = 0.90)], reliability (inter-observer intraclass correlation coefficient = 0.97), responsiveness and feasibility. For damage, VDI was shown to be moderately valid (correlations with BVAS version 3 at 6 months r = 0.14, BVAS/WG at 1 year r = 0.40 and 5 years r = 0.20), and feasible. For HRQoL, AAV-PRO demonstrated validity (correlations of the six AAV-PRO domains with EQ-5D-5L: -0.78 to -0.55; discrimination between active disease and remission, P < 0.0001 for all comparisons). The overall performance of instruments assessing function was low-to-moderate.

CONCLUSION

Among the 22 outcome measurement instruments used for AAV, BVAS (any version), VDI and AAV-PRO had the strongest psychometric properties.

Hallmark trials in ANCA-associated vasculitis (AAV) for the pediatric rheumatologist

Anti-neutrophil cytoplasmic antibody (ANCA)-associated vasculitis (AAV) refers to a complex group of systemic vasculitides that are characterized by primary small-to-medium sized blood vessel inflammation with the presence of autoantibodies known as ANCA. AAV diseases include Granulomatosis with Polyangiitis (GPA), Eosinophilic Granulomatosis with Polyangiitis (EGPA), and Microscopic Polyangiitis (MPA). AAVs are challenging conditions associated with high cumulative disease and treatment related morbidity and mortality. Given its rarity and the resulting paucity of pediatric-specific clinical trial evidence, pediatric rheumatologists have had to often extrapolate from adult literature for management and therapeutic decisions. The aim of this review is to provide a comprehensive overview of the important findings and overall conclusions of critical landmark clinical trials in the induction and maintenance treatments in adult AAV for the pediatric rheumatologist. This review also highlights the outcomes of recent pediatric AAV observational studies and discusses the future research priorities in pediatric AAV management.

New Features for Measuring Disease Activity in Pediatric Localized Scleroderma

Objective.

To identify clinical features that define disease activity in pediatric localized scleroderma (LS), and determine their specificity and importance.

Methods.

We conducted a multicenter prospective study of patients with active and inactive LS skin lesions. A standardized evaluation of a single designated study lesion per subject was performed at 3 visits. We evaluated the pattern and correlation between assessed features and physician’s global assessments of activity (PGA-A).

Results.

Ninety of 103 subjects had evaluable data; 66 had active and 24 inactive disease. Subjects had similar age of onset, sex, and disease patterns. Linear scleroderma was the most common subtype. Features specific for active disease included erythema, violaceous color, tactile warmth, abnormal skin texture, and disease extension. Scores for these variables changed over time and correlated with PGA-A of the lesion. Active and inactive lesions could not be distinguished by the presence or level of skin thickening, either of lesion edge or center. However, in active lesions, skin thickening scores did correlate with PGA–A scores. Regression analysis identified the combination of erythema, disease extension, violaceous color, skin thickening, and abnormal texture as predictive of PGA-A at study entry. Damage features were common irrespective of activity status.

Conclusion.

We identified variables strongly associated with disease activity, expanding upon those used in current measures, and determined their relative importance in physician activity scoring. Skin thickening was found to lack specificity for disease activity. These results will help guide development of a sensitive, responsive activity tool to improve care of patients with LS.

Paediatric anti-neutrophil cytoplasmic antibody (ANCA)-associated vasculitis: an update on renal management

The anti-neutrophil cytoplasmic antibody (ANCA)-associated vasculitides (AAV) are a group of disorders characterized by necrotizing inflammation of the small to medium vessels in association with autoantibodies against the cytoplasmic region of the neutrophil. Included in this definition are granulomatosis with polyangiitis (GPA, formerly known as Wegener's granulomatosis), microscopic polyangiitis (MPA) and eosinophilic granulomatosis with polyangiitis (formerly known as Churg-Strauss syndrome). AAV are chronic, often relapsing diseases that can be organ or life threatening. Despite immunosuppression, the morbidity and mortality remain high. Renal involvement contributes significantly to the morbidity with high numbers of patients progressing to end-stage kidney disease. Current therapies have enabled improvements in renal function in the short term, but evidence for long-term protection is lacking. In MPA, renal involvement is common at presentation (90%) and often follows a more severe course than that seen in paediatric GPA. Renal biopsy remains the 'gold standard' in diagnosing ANCA-associated glomerulonephritis. While GPA and MPA are considered separate entities, the two are managed identically. Current treatment regimens are extrapolated from adult studies, although it is encouraging to see recruitment of paediatric patients to recent vasculitis trials. Traditionally more severe disease has been managed with the 'gold standard' treatment of glucocorticoids and cyclophosphamide, with remission rates achieved of between 70 and 100%. Other agents employed in remission induction include anti-tumor necrosis factor-alpha therapy and mycophenolate mofetil. Recently, however, increasing consideration is being given to rituximab as a therapy for children in severe or relapsing disease, particularly for those at risk for glucocorticoid or cyclophosphamide toxicity. Removal of circulating ANCA through plasma exchange is a short-term measure reserved for severe or refractory disease. Maintenance therapy usually involves azathioprine. The aim of this article is to provide a comprehensive review of paediatric AAV, with a focus on renal manifestations, and to highlight the recent advances made in therapeutic management.

Whole-body MRI for full assessment and characterization of diffuse inflammatory myopathy

Background

Conventional magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is a highly valuable tool for full assessment of the extent of bilateral symmetrical diffuse inflammatory myopathy, owing to its high sensitivity in the detection of edema which correlates with, and sometimes precedes, clinical findings.

Purpose

To evaluate the use of whole-body (WB)-MRI in characterization and full assessment of the extent and distribution of diffuse inflammatory myopathy.

Material and Methods

A prospective study on 15 patients presenting with clinical evidence of inflammatory myopathy. It included 4 boys/men and 11 girls/women (age range, 6–44 years; mean age, 25.5 years). 1.5 T WB-MRI was performed and the distribution and extent of disease severity was assessed according to muscle edema on STIR images.

Results

Four cases of dermatomyositis showed lower limb disease predilection with edema in gluteal, thigh, and calf muscles. The same finding was seen in one case with recurrent polymyositis and three cases with overlap myositis with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). Bilateral upper and lower limb myositis was demonstrated in three cases of polymyositis and one case of overlap myositis with scleroderma. Bilateral edema involving all scanned muscle groups was detected in three cases of polymyositis with paraneoplastic syndrome, SLE, and severe active dermatomyositis (including the neck muscles).

Conclusion

WB-MRI is the diagnostic modality of choice for cases of inflammatory myopathy. It accurately detects the most severely affected muscles candidate for biopsy and provides a reliable baseline study for follow-up of disease progression as well as response to treatment.

Disease assessment in systemic vasculitis

The anti-neutrophil cytoplasm antibody-associated vasculitides are complex multi-system disorders with many overlapping clinical features. Their outcome has been transformed by effective immunosuppression, preventing death in over 70% of cases. The quality of survival is affected by the disease course, which is characterized by a significant likelihood of relapse in 38%, chronic effects from the disease and its treatment, as well as emerging or worsening comorbidity, all of which contribute to the patient's clinical condition and outcome. Whilst imaging and laboratory testing including histology are important aspects of diagnosis, they are of limited value in assessing response to therapy or subsequent disease course. We have developed standardized validated clinical methods to quantify disease activity and damage; we are developing effective measures of patient experience to complement these procedures. This approach provides a rational basis for clinical management as well as being essential in the conduct of clinical trials and studies in vasculitis, by providing reproducible definitions of relapse, remission and response to therapy for patients with systemic vasculitis. Clinical assessment remains the current gold standard for evaluating disease progress, but requires regular training to ensure standardization. The development of biomarkers in future may produce a more accurate description of disease and identify potential targets for therapy as well as predictors of response to drugs.

Quality of life and outcome measures in vasculitis

The primary vasculitides are a life- and organ-threatening set of diseases with a course often marked by alternating periods of active vasculitis and remission. As opposed to clinical trials within the fields of cardiology and oncology, where treatment interventions have been tested in a controlled fashion using hard 'end' points, such as mortality and hospitalisation, surrogate 'end' points have to be used in randomised clinical trials (RCTs) in vasculitis. Given the multisystem nature of the vasculitides, their heterogeneous clinical presentations and rarity, outcome-measure development is a challenging task. The objective of this review is to summarise the data on how health-related quality of life is affected by vasculitis, to describe the currently used outcome measures and provide insight into future outcome-measures development. The primary focus is on anti-neutrophil cytoplasmic antibodies (ANCA)-associated vasculitis, where the most data exist and outcome measure development is farthest along. Data on other vasculitides will also be briefly discussed.

Assessing the performance of the Birmingham Vasculitis Activity Score at diagnosis for children with antineutrophil cytoplasmic antibody-associated vasculitis in A Registry for Childhood Vasculitis (ARChiVe)

OBJECTIVE

There are no validated tools for measuring disease activity in pediatric vasculitis. The Birmingham Vasculitis Activity Score (BVAS) is a valid disease activity tool in adult vasculitis. Version 3 (BVAS v.3) correlates well with physician's global assessment (PGA), treatment decision, and C-reactive protein in adults. The utility of BVAS v.3 in pediatric vasculitis is not known. We assessed the association of BVAS v.3 scores with PGA, treatment decision, and erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR) at diagnosis in pediatric antineutrophil cytoplasmic antibody-associated vasculitis (AAV).

METHODS

Children with AAV diagnosed between 2004 and 2010 at all ARChiVe centers were eligible. BVAS v.3 scores were calculated with a standardized online tool (www.vasculitis.org). Spearman's rank correlation coefficient (r(s)) was used to test the strength of association between BVAS v.3 and PGA, treatment decision, and ESR.

RESULTS

A total of 152 patients were included. The physician diagnosis of these patients was predominantly granulomatosis with polyangiitis (n = 99). The median BVAS v.3 score was 18.0 (range 0-40). The BVAS v.3 correlations were r(s) = 0.379 (95% CI 0.233 to 0.509) with PGA, r(s) = 0.521 (95% CI 0.393 to 0.629) with treatment decision, and r(s) = 0.403 (95% CI 0.253 to 0.533) with ESR.

CONCLUSION

Applied to children with AAV, BVAS v.3 had a weak correlation with PGA and moderate correlation with both ESR and treatment decision. Prospective evaluation of BVAS v.3 and/or pediatric-specific modifications to BVAS v.3 may be required before it can be formalized as a disease activity assessment tool in pediatric AAV.

The OMERACT core set of outcome measures for use in clinical trials of ANCA-associated vasculitis

There has been a marked increase in the past 15 years in the number and quality of clinical trials in the idiopathic inflammatory vasculitides, especially the small-vessel vasculitides known as antineutrophil cytoplasmic autoantibody (ANCA)-associated vasculitis [AAV; granulomatosis, with polyangiitis (Wegener's)]. These trials have been conducted by multicenter, international groups in Europe and the United States with financial support provided by government agencies and biopharmaceutical companies. This increased clinical trial activity in vasculitis has been accompanied by the development and validation of new outcome measures--a challenging process for these complex, multiorgan system diseases. The international OMERACT Vasculitis Working Group has developed and implemented an iterative research agenda that has utilized accumulated experience and datasets from several multicenter clinical trials and large cohort studies. This work has led to the development, evaluation, validation, and endorsement, through the OMERACT consensus and validation processes, of a "core set" of outcome measurements for use in clinical trials of AAV. The core set includes domains of disease activity, damage assessment, patient-reported outcomes, and mortality; there is at least one validated outcome measurement instrument available for each domain. This report reviews the domains of illness in AAV included in the OMERACT core set, describes the instruments validated to measure these domains, and presents the approved core set.

A multi-dimensional health assessment questionnaire (MDHAQ) and routine assessment of patient index data (RAPID3) scores are informative in patients with all rheumatic diseases

Although indices have been developed for many rheumatic diseases in usual care, they are rarely used in usual care. In most visits to rheumatologists, the only quantitative data collected are laboratory tests. Patient history data often are more important in management of patients with rheumatic diseases than other diseases. A two-page multidimensional health assessment questionnaire (MDHAQ) can be completed by the patient in 5 to 10 minutes and reviewed by the physician in 10 seconds, with RAPID3 scored in 5 to 10 seconds. The MDHAQ is useful in rheumatic diseases, to improve management documentation and outcomes. MDHAQ data for physical function, pain, global status, and RAPID3 scores appear preferable to no quantitative data.

Reliability and validity of the myositis disease activity assessment tool

OBJECTIVE

To test the interrater reliability and validity of the Myositis Disease Activity Assessment Tool, which consists of the Myositis Intention-to-Treat Activity Index and the Myositis Disease Activity Assessment Visual Analog Scales.

METHODS

Two phases of the study were conducted to assess the reliability and validity of the tool, which was modified following the first phase. In the first phase of the reliability study, 123 adult myositis patients were evaluated in 7 centers, and in the second phase 40 patients were evaluated in 2 centers. The validity study included 294 patients in 5 centers in the first phase and 65 patients in 3 centers in the second phase. The interrater reliability was assessed using intraclass correlation coefficients. The criterion validity was calculated using sensitivity, specificity, and positive predictive value (PPV) of a grade of A in any system. Spearman's rank correlation coefficient was used to measure the convergent validity of cross-sectional scores between the 2 instruments.

RESULTS

There was a 2:1 ratio of female to male patients. There was no significant difference in mean age at diagnosis (46.3 versus 46.8 years) and mean disease duration (7.7 versus 10 years) between the 2 groups recruited for the different phases of the study. There was an improvement in interrater reliability in the second phase of the study. There was a significant improvement in the validity of the assessment tool following modification of the tool. The sensitivity, specificity, and PPV of a grade of A in any system improved from 86%, 92%, and 67% in the first phase to 96%, 94%, and 83%, respectively, in the second phase. Convergent validity between the 2 activity tools showed good correlation, ranging from 0.8 to 0.94, for the individual organ systems.

CONCLUSION

This is the first major attempt to assess the reliability and validity of a disease activity index in myositis. Our findings indicate that, following within-study modification, the tool appears to be a reliable and valid instrument to assess myositis disease activity.

Quantitative measures of rheumatic diseases for clinical research versus standard clinical care: differences, advantages and limitations

No single measure can serve as a 'gold standard' for the diagnosis, prognosis, and monitoring of patients with rheumatic diseases. Therefore, pooled indices of several measures have been developed for patient assessment. Quantitative measures and indices in rheumatology have been used primarily in clinical trials and other clinical research, but not in standard clinical care. Indeed, most standard rheumatology care is conducted without quantitative data other than laboratory tests, which often are uninformative. Some measures used in research have been adapted for standard care. The classical 66/68-joint count with graded scoring for swelling, tenderness, pain on motion, limited motion, and deformity has been shortened for clinical care to a 28-joint count, scored only as 'Yes' or 'No' for swelling or tenderness. Patient questionnaires designed for clinical research can be lengthy, with complex scoring, so that information is not available to help guide clinical decisions. By contrast, patient questionnaires designed for standard care, such as a simple one-page, multi-dimensional health assessment questionnaire (MDHAQ), are short, save time, are easily scored, and are useful in all rheumatic diseases to monitor patient status at each visit and document changes over long periods. More attention to measures for use in standard care could improve care and outcomes for patients with rheumatic diseases.

Can a Multi-Dimensional Health Assessment Questionnaire (MDHAQ) and Routine Assessment of Patient Index Data (RAPID) scores be informative in patients with all rheumatic diseases?

A multidimensional health assessment questionnaire (MDHAQ) is useful in standard care of patients with all rheumatic diseases in a busy clinical setting. The MDHAQ was adapted from the classical health assessment questionnaire (HAQ) for feasibility in standard clinical care, with reduction of the number of activities from 20 to 10, visual analog scales (VAS) as 21 circles rather than 10 cm lines, availability of all core data set patient self-report measures and scoring templates on the front side, and a review of systems symptom checklist and review of recent medical history on the reverse side of a single page. Scoring templates are also available for routine assessment of patient index data (RAPID) scores, based on a composite of the three patient reported outcome (PRO) measures from the core data set included on the HAQ and MDHAQ, physical function pain, and patient estimate of global status. Flow sheets illustrating use of the MDHAQ in standard clinical care of patients with various rheumatic diseases, including psoriatic arthritis, systemic lupus erythematosus, ankylosing spondylitis, gout, scleroderma, vasculitis, fibromyalgia, inflammatory bowel disease arthritis, Behcet's syndrome, and familial Mediterranean fever, are presented to illustrate use of this simple questionnaire to add to clinical decisions and document patient courses and outcomes in standard clinical care of patients with all rheumatic diseases.

EULAR recommendations for conducting clinical studies and/or clinical trials in systemic vasculitis: focus on anti-neutrophil cytoplasm antibody-associated vasculitis

OBJECTIVES

To develop the European League Against Rheumatism (EULAR) recommendations for conducting clinical studies and/or clinical trials in systemic vasculitis.

METHODS

An expert consensus group was formed consisting of rheumatologists, nephrologists and specialists in internal medicine representing five European countries and the USA, a clinical epidemiologist and representatives from regulatory agencies. Using an evidence-based and expert opinion-based approach in accordance with the standardised EULAR operating procedures, the group identified nine topics for a systematic literature search through a modified Delphi technique. On the basis of research questions posed by the group, recommendations were derived for conducting clinical studies and/or clinical trials in systemic vasculitis.

RESULTS

Based on the results of the literature research, the expert committee concluded that sufficient evidence to formulate guidelines on conducting clinical trials was available only for anti-neutrophil cytoplasm antibody-associated vasculitides (AAV). It was therefore decided to focus the recommendations on these diseases. Recommendations for conducting clinical trials in AAV were elaborated and are presented in this summary document. It was decided to consider vasculitis-specific issues rather than general issues of trial methodology. The recommendations deal with the following areas related to clinical studies of vasculitis: definitions of disease, activity states, outcome measures, eligibility criteria, trial design including relevant end points, and biomarkers. A number of aspects of trial methodology were deemed important for future research.

CONCLUSIONS

On the basis of expert opinion, recommendations for conducting clinical trials in AAV were formulated. Furthermore, the expert committee identified a strong need for well-designed research in non-AAV systemic vasculitides.

Increased serum levels of soluble fractalkine (CX3CL1) correlate with disease activity in rheumatoid vasculitis

OBJECTIVE

To determine levels of soluble fractalkine (sFkn) in rheumatoid arthritis (RA) patients with and without rheumatoid vasculitis (RV), and to assess the relationship of sFkn levels to disease activity.

METHODS

Serum was obtained from 98 RA patients (54 without vasculitis, 36 with extraarticular manifestations but without histologically proven vasculitis, and 8 with histologically proven vasculitis) and from 38 healthy individuals. Levels of sFkn were measured by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. Expression of Fkn and CX(3)CR1 was quantified by real-time polymerase chain reaction. Vasculitis disease activity was assessed using the Birmingham Vasculitis Activity Score and the Vasculitis Activity Index.

RESULTS

Serum sFkn levels were significantly higher in patients with RA than in controls and were significantly higher in RA patients with RV than in those without vasculitic complications. Statistically significant correlations were observed between serum sFkn levels in RA patients and levels of C-reactive protein, rheumatoid factor, immune complex, and complement. In the RV group, sFkn levels also correlated with disease activity. Immunohistochemical analysis indicated that Fkn levels were associated mainly with endothelial cells in vasculitic arteries. In addition, expression of CX(3)CR1 messenger RNA was significantly greater in peripheral blood mononuclear cells from patients with active RV than in those from other RA patients or controls. Notably, serum sFkn levels were significantly diminished following successful treatment and clinical improvement.

CONCLUSION

These findings suggest that Fkn and CX(3)CR1 play crucial roles in the pathogenesis of RV and that sFkn may serve as a serologic inflammatory marker of disease activity in RA patients with vasculitis.

Development of comprehensive disease assessment in systemic vasculitis

The systemic vasculitides are multisystem disorders with considerable mortality and morbidity and frequent relapses. In the absence of reliable serological markers, accurate clinical tools are required to assess disease activity and damage for treatment decisions, and for the performance of clinical trials. This article reviews and summarises the development and use of disease assessment tools for determining activity and damage in systemic vasculitis and reports ongoing initiatives for further development of disease assessment tools. A literature search was conducted using PubMed and reference lists for vasculitis, assessment, clinical trials, outcome and prognosis. The findings indicate that comprehensive disease assessment in vasculitis requires documentation of disease activity, chronic irreversible damage and impairment of function.

Classification of the vasculitides: are they clinically useful?

Several classification systems for the vasculitides have been developed over the second half of the past century. These classifications systems have been modified according to the advances made in the differentiation of these syndromes, particularly their histopathologic features (the vessel size involved) and their clinical features. Although these classifications have been widely used in the clinical setting for the diagnosis of these disorders, they were developed for research purposes. Given the common clinical and, sometimes, histopathologic features of the different vasculitides, a classification system that facilitates a diagnosis and the formulation of a therapeutic plan is still needed. The development and utilization of novel serum markers and new imaging modalities coupled with advances in the understanding of these disorders, may allow the development of a classification system for the vasculitides that will be of greater value in the clinical setting.

International consensus outcome measures for patients with idiopathic inflammatory myopathies. Development and initial validation of myositis activity and damage indices in patients with adult onset disease

OBJECTIVE

To devise new tools to assess activity and damage in patients with idiopathic myopathies (IIM).

METHODS

An international multidisciplinary consensus effort to standardize the conduct and reporting of the myositis clinical trials has been established. Two tools, known as the myositis intention to treat index (MITAX) and the myositis disease activity assessment visual analogue scale (MYOACT), have been developed to capture activity in patients with IIM. In addition, the myositis damage index (MDI) has been devised to assess the extent and severity of damage developing in different organs and systems. These measures have been reviewed by the myositis experts participating in the International Myositis Assessment and Clinical Studies (IMACS) group and have been found to have good face validity and to be comprehensive. The instruments were assessed in two real patient exercises involving patients with adult dermatomyositis and inclusion body myositis.

RESULTS

The reliability of MITAX, MYOACT and MDI, measured by the intraclass correlation coefficient among the physicians, and the inter-rater reliability, as assessed by variation in the physicians' rating of patients, was fair to good for most aspects of the tools. Reliability and inter-rater agreement improved at the second exercise after the participants had completed additional training.

CONCLUSIONS

The MITAX, MYOACT and MDI tools, which are now undergoing validity testing, should enhance the consistency, comprehensiveness and reliability of disease activity and damage assessment in patients with myositis.

Assessing disease activity in the systemic vasculitides

The improvement in survival of the systemic vasculitides with the use of current immunosuppression has heightened awareness of their poor long-term outcome in terms of chronic morbidity and relapse. Assessment of systemic vasculitis is an essential part of its management. Better understanding of the underlying pathophysiology of the antineutrophil cytoplasmic antibody-related vasculitides has resulted in improved assays and may result in more precise serologic assessment of disease. Clinical assessment tools for accurately measuring disease activity and damage have been developed and are reviewed in this article. It is becoming increasingly clear that these clinical tools are practical, effective measures that can assist in the treatment of individual patients and play an important role in clinical trials of systemic vasculitis.

Activity, damage and outcome in systemic vasculitis

Current therapy has transformed the prognosis of the systemic vasculitides from diseases that had a high acute mortality rate to chronic relapsing diseases with high rates of morbidity. This improved survival has highlighted the need for better methods of monitoring disease activity and recording the accumulation of organ damage that occurs during the course of the disease. Several clinical indices have been developed that record disease activity, damage and the extent of disease. These validated indices allow a detailed assessment of the patient's response to therapy and provide an essential tool for insuring uniformity of patient monitoring in multi-centre trials. In addition, more data are now available supporting the use of these assessment tools as prognostic and outcome criteria for clinical studies. The development, properties, application and inter-relationships of the available clinical assessment tools for patients with systemic vasculitis are reviewed in this chapter.

A disease-specific activity index for Wegener's granulomatosis: modification of the Birmingham Vasculitis Activity Score. International Network for the Study of the Systemic Vasculitides (INSSYS)

OBJECTIVE

To refine and validate the Birmingham Vasculitis Activity Score (BVAS) as a disease-specific activity index for Wegener's granulomatosis (WG).

METHODS

Sixteen members of the International Network for the Study of the Systemic Vasculitides (INSSYS) revised the BVAS, with 3 goals: to reduce the redundancy of some component items, to enhance its ability to capture important disease manifestations specific to WG, and to streamline the instrument for use in clinical research. We defined the items and weighted them empirically as either minor (e.g., nasal crusting = 1 point) or major (e.g., alveolar hemorrhage = 3 points). We then validated the new, disease-specific BVAS/WG in 2 simulation exercises and a clinical case series that involved 117 patients with WG.

RESULTS

We removed 38 items from the original BVAS, revised 9 items, and added 7 new items. Correlations between the scores on the BVAS/WG and the physician's global assessment (PGA) of disease activity were high, even when patients in remission were excluded. In the clinical case series, Spearman's rank correlation coefficient between the BVAS/WG and the PGA was r = 0.81 (95% confidence interval 0.73-0.87). The interobserver reliability using intraclass (within-case) correlation coefficients in the 2 simulation exercises was r = 0.93 for the BVAS/WG and r = 0.88 for the PGA in the first and r = 0.91 for the BVAS/WG and r = 0.88 for the PGA in the second. There was no significant observer effect in the scoring of the BVAS/WG or the PGA. The discriminant validity of the BVAS/WG was good: r = 0.73 (95% confidence interval 0.43-0.83).

CONCLUSION

The BVAS/WG is a valid, disease-specific activity index for WG. Tested in simulation exercises and in actual patients, the BVAS/WG correlates well with the PGA, is sensitive to change, and has good inter- and intraobserver reliability. The INSSYS will use the BVAS/WG to assess the primary outcome in a phase II/III trial of etanercept in WG.

Update on the European Vasculitis Study Group trials

Over the last fifteen years, collaborative vasculitis studies in Europe have established the association of antineutrophil cytoplasmic antibodies (ANCA) with vasculitis and defined its clinical role as a diagnostic tool. More recently, the European Vasculitis Study Group has developed a consensus approach to the treatment of vasculitis and has aimed to harmonize and optimize current therapy by a series of multicenter randomized controlled trials. The first trial to report, CYClophosphamide or AZathioprine As a REMission therapy for vasculitis (CYCAZAREM), demonstrated that, for generalized vasculitis, azathioprine is as effective as continued cyclophosphamide for the maintenance of remission. Other trials are investigating the roles of methotrexate, plasma exchange, and pulse cyclophosphamide in acute disease, and strategies to prevent relapse over the longer term. Parallel studies are determining prognostic markers, evaluating tools for monitoring disease, and examining the association of ANCA and infection with relapse. The established infrastructure and accumulated database are well placed to facilitate testing of newer therapeutic strategies in the future.