An improved digital polymerase chain reaction protocol to capture low-copy KRAS mutations in plasma cell-free DNA by resolving 'subsampling' issues

Circulating Nucleic Acids in Colorectal Cancer: Diagnostic and Prognostic Value

Colorectal cancer (CRC) is the third most prevalent cancer in the world and the fourth leading cause of cancer-related mortality. DNA (cfDNA/ctDNA) and RNA (cfRNA/ctRNA) in the blood are promising noninvasive biomarkers for molecular profiling, screening, diagnosis, treatment management, and prognosis of CRC. Technological advancements that enable precise detection of both genetic and epigenetic abnormalities, even in minute quantities in circulation, can overcome some of these challenges. This review focuses on testing for circulating nucleic acids in the circulation as a noninvasive method for CRC detection, monitoring, detection of minimal residual disease, and patient management. In addition, the benefits and drawbacks of various diagnostic techniques and associated bioinformatics tools have been detailed.

Monitoring mutant KRAS in plasma cell-free DNA can predict disease progression in a patient with multiple myeloma: A case report

BACKGROUND AND AIMS

Multiple myeloma (MM), a neoplasm of plasma cells (PCs), is a highly heterogeneous disease with multifocal dissemination throughout the body. Minimal residual disease (MRD) detected using PCs in bone marrow (BM) is important for MM management; however, frequent invasive examinations impose a significant burden on patients.

METHODS

Analysis using plasma cell-free DNA (cfDNA) might represent an alternative tool for disease monitoring. In this study, we observed the disease status in a patient with MM by examining the KRAS mutation allele frequency (MAF) in plasma cfDNA using digital PCR.

RESULTS

During treatment, the MAF was correlated with serum immunoglobulin A and free light chain-kappa levels. After the second autologous peripheral blood stem cell transplantation, the KRAS MAF became immediately positive after confirming MRD negativity using PCs from BM. Shortly thereafter, the patient experienced clinical relapse primarily involving bone lesions.

CONCLUSION

Mutant KRAS monitoring in cfDNA using serial blood collection might reflect the disease status more accurately than invasive BM examinations, especially in patients with MM whose primary lesions have extra-BM locations. It could also help predict treatment responses and outcomes.

Current status of molecular diagnostic approaches using liquid biopsy

Pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma (PDAC) is one of the most aggressive and lethal cancers, and developing an efficient and reliable approach for its early-stage diagnosis is urgently needed. Precancerous lesions of PDAC, such as pancreatic intraepithelial neoplasia (PanIN) and intraductal papillary mucinous neoplasms (IPMN), arise through multiple steps of driver gene alterations in KRAS, TP53, CDKN2A, SMAD4, or GNAS. Hallmark mutations play a role in tumor initiation and progression, and their detection in bodily fluids is crucial for diagnosis. Recently, liquid biopsy has gained attention as an approach to complement pathological diagnosis, and in addition to mutation signatures in cell-free DNA, cell-free RNA, and extracellular vesicles have been investigated as potential diagnostic and prognostic markers. Integrating such molecular information to revise the diagnostic criteria for pancreatic cancer can enable a better understanding of the pathogenesis underlying inter-patient heterogeneity, such as sensitivity to chemotherapy and disease outcomes. This review discusses the current diagnostic approaches and clinical applications of genetic analysis in pancreatic cancer and diagnostic attempts by liquid biopsy and molecular analyses using pancreatic juice, duodenal fluid, and blood samples. Emerging knowledge in the rapidly advancing liquid biopsy field is promising for molecular profiling and diagnosing pancreatic diseases with significant diversity.

Non-invasive prenatal testing for fetal Ss, Kidd, and CTL2 blood group prediction by multiplex digital droplet PCR

Background

Some blood groups, such as S and s blood groups in the MNS blood group system, and Kidd and CTL2 blood group systems, can cause severe fetal and newborn alloimmune disorders. Non-invasive prenatal testing (NIPT) to predict fetal blood groups and knowledge of local blood group gene frequency are both important for pregnancy management decisions. Droplet digital PCR (ddPCR) has high specificity and sensitivity in detecting fetal single nucleotide variation.

Objectives

The objective is to predict fetal Ss, Kidd, and CTL2 blood groups using multiplex ddPCR. The gene frequencies of three blood groups were detected by ddPCR in northwest China.

Design

This is a prospective study.

Methods

Cell-free fetal DNA isolated from 26 healthy single pregnant women at different gestational stages was tested with QX200 Droplet Digital PCR. Results were compared with fetal genotypes. DNA samples purified from 20 blood pools containing a total of 1000 donors in northwest China were subjected to ddPCR to detect the gene frequency of three blood groups.

Results

Ss, Kidd, and CTL2 blood groups of 26 pregnant fetuses were accurately detected by multiplex ddPCR. The multiplex ddPCR results were consistent with the Sanger sequencing results of 26 fetal blood samples after birth. The gene frequencies of the three blood groups detected by ddPCR were 9.30% for S, 90.70% for s, 48.43% for Jka, 51.57% for Jkb, 66.57% for HNA-3A, and 33.43% for HNA-3B.

Conclusions

It is reliable to predict fetal Ss, Kidd, and CTL2 blood groups by multiplex ddPCR. Meanwhile, we designed a simple and efficient method for inferring the gene frequency of three blood groups based on ddPCR.

Multiplex digital PCR assay to detect multiple KRAS and GNAS mutations associated with pancreatic carcinogenesis from minimal specimen amounts

Digital PCR (dPCR) allows for highly sensitive quantification of low-frequency mutations and facilitates early detection of cancer. However, low throughput targeting of single hotspots in dPCR hinders variant specification when multiple probes are used. Here we developed a dPCR method to simultaneously identify major variants related to pancreatic carcinogenesis. Using a 2-D plot of droplet fluorescence under the optimized concentration of two fluorescent probe pools, we determined the absolute quantification of different KRAS and GNAS variants. Successful detection of the multiple driver mutations was verified in 24 surgically resected tumor samples from 19 patients and 22 FNA samples from patients with pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma. Precise quantification of the variant allele frequency was optimized using template DNA at a concentration as low as 1-10 ng. Furthermore, amplicons targeting multiple hotspots were successfully enriched with fewer false positives using high-fidelity polymerase, allowing for the detection of various KRAS and GNAS mutations with high probability in small cell/tissue specimens. Using this target enrichment, mutations at a rate of 90% in small residual tissues, such as the FNA needle flush and microscopic lesions in resected specimens, have successfully been identified. The proposed method allows for low-cost and accurate detection of driver mutations to diagnose cancers, even with minimal tissue collection.

Molecular assessment of endoscopically collected pancreatic juice and duodenal fluid from patients with pancreatic diseases

One concern associated with pancreatic diseases is the poor prognosis of pancreatic cancer. Even with advances in diagnostic modalities, risk stratification of premalignant lesions and differentiation of pancreatic cysts are challenging. Pancreatic lesions of concern include intraductal papillary mucinous neoplasms, mucinous cystic neoplasms, serous cystadenomas, pseudocysts, and retention cysts, as well as cystic degeneration of solid tumors such as solid pseudopapillary neoplasms and pancreatic neuroendocrine neoplasms. Pancreatic juice obtained during endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography has previously been used for the detection of KRAS mutation. Recently, duodenal fluid, which can be obtained during the relatively minimally invasive procedures of endoscopic ultrasound (EUS) and esophagogastroduodenoscopy, and cyst fluid collected by EUS-guided fine-needle aspiration (FNA) were used for molecular biological analysis. Furthermore, advanced analytic methods with high sensitivity were used for the detection of single and multiple markers. Early detection of malignant pancreatic tumors and risk stratification of premalignant tumors can be performed using duodenal fluid samples with a single marker with high sensitivity. Technological advances in simultaneous detection of multiple markers allow for the differentiation of cystic pancreatic tumors. One thing to note is that the clinical guidelines do not recommend pancreatic cyst fluid and pancreatic juice (PJ) sampling by EUS-FNA and endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography, respectively, in actual clinical practice, but state that they be performed at experienced facilities, and duodenal fluid sampling is not mentioned in the guidelines. With improved specimen handling and the combination of markers, molecular markers in PJ samples may be used in clinical practice in the near future.

Rapid Multiplex Strip Test for the Detection of Circulating Tumor DNA Mutations for Liquid Biopsy Applications

In the era of personalized medicine, molecular profiling of patient tumors has become the standard practice, especially for patients with advanced disease. Activating point mutations of the KRAS proto-oncogene are clinically relevant for many types of cancer, including colorectal cancer (CRC). While several approaches have been developed for tumor genotyping, liquid biopsy has been gaining much attention in the clinical setting. Analysis of circulating tumor DNA for genetic alterations has been challenging, and many methodologies with both advantages and disadvantages have been developed. We here developed a gold nanoparticle-based rapid strip test that has been applied for the first time for the multiplex detection of KRAS mutations in circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) of CRC patients. The method involved ctDNA isolation, PCR-amplification of the KRAS gene, multiplex primer extension (PEXT) reaction, and detection with a multiplex strip test. We have optimized the efficiency and specificity of the multiplex strip test in synthetic DNA targets, in colorectal cancer cell lines, in tissue samples, and in blood-derived ctDNA from patients with advanced colorectal cancer. The proposed strip test achieved rapid and easy multiplex detection (normal allele and three major single-point mutations) of the clinically relevant KRAS mutations in ctDNA in blood samples of CRC patients with high specificity and repeatability. This multiplex strip test represents a minimally invasive, rapid, low-cost, and promising diagnostic tool for the detection of clinically relevant mutations in cancer patients.

Case Report: The Added Value of Liquid Biopsy in Advanced Colorectal Cancer From Clinical Case Experiences

Liquid biopsy represents a valid strategy for tumor molecular characterization. It gives the opportunity to bypass tumor heterogeneity, to monitor tumor characteristics during the course of treatment, and to perform the analysis even when tumor tissue is not available or inadequate. In the clinical practice of metastatic colorectal cancer, tumor molecular characterization is crucial for patient management, as RAS and BRAF status could influence the treatment choice. Although for this type of cancer tumor tissue is usually available at diagnosis, liquid biopsy could give complementary information and could permit monitoring of the mutation status during the course of treatment. At present, there are no clinical indications for its use in clinical practice. However, we report four clinical cases for which liquid biopsy analysis gave integrative information with respect to tumor tissue characterization, which permits us to understand the unresponsiveness of patients to treatment, with potential implications in patient's management.

The feasibility of circulating tumor DNA analysis as a marker of recurrence in triple-negative breast cancer

Triple-negative breast cancer (TNBC) has a poorer prognosis than other breast cancer subtypes; therefore, identifying markers of early recurrence is important. The present study aimed to establish a liquid biopsy protocol for droplet digital PCR-based detection of frequently mutated genes in patients with TNBC. Tumor DNA from 36 patients with TNBC who relapsed within 2 years after surgical resection was retrospectively analyzed. Somatic mutational profiles were evaluated using targeted sequencing to identify frequently mutated genes and genes associated with molecularly targeted therapies. The association between genetic alterations and associated protein phosphorylation was investigated using immunohistochemical analysis. Recurrent hot spot mutations in the plasma were monitored over time. Mutation-specific probes were used to successfully detect mutations in the blood samples of patients who were positive for PIK3CA H1047R and AKT1 E17K mutations. Somatic mutations in AKT1 (14.9%) and PIK3CA (25.5%) were frequently identified in the data. Robust phosphorylation of AKT and S6RP was more common in tumors with PIK3CA H1047R and AKT1 E17K mutational background than in tumors with wild-type PIK3CA and AKT1. In conclusion, the present study evaluated a high-sensitivity detection system for frequently mutated genes that was also applicable for cell-free DNA. The PI3K/AKT pathway was revealed to be activated in patients harboring PIK3CA H1047R and AKT1 E17K mutations; therefore, the PI3K/AKT pathway may be a promising candidate for targeted therapy in these patients.

Digital next-generation sequencing of cell-free DNA for pancreatic cancer

Background and Aim

The clinical applicability of digital next‐generation sequencing (dNGS), which eliminates polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and sequencing error‐derived noise by using molecular barcodes (MBs), has not been fully evaluated. We evaluated the utility of dNGS of cell‐free DNA (cfDNA) in liquid biopsies obtained from patients with pancreatic cancer.

Methods

Fifty‐eight patients with pancreatic cancer undergoing endoscopic ultrasound‐guided fine‐needle aspiration (EUS‐FNA) were included. Samples were subjected to sequencing of 50 cancer‐related genes using next‐generation sequencing (NGS). The results were used as reference gene alterations. NGS of cfDNA from plasma was performed for patients with a mutant allele frequency (MAF) >1% and an absolute mutant number > 10 copies/plasma mL in KRAS or GNAS by digital PCR. Sequence readings with and without MBs were compared with reference to EUS‐FNA‐derived gene alterations.

Results

The concordance rate between dNGS of cfDNA and EUS‐FNA‐derived gene alterations was higher with than without MBs (p = 0.039), and MAF cut‐off values in dNGS could be decreased to 0.2%. dNGS using MBs eliminated PCR and sequencing error by 74% and 68% for TP53 and all genes, respectively. Overall, dNGS detected mutations in KRAS (45%) and TP53 (26%) and copy number alterations in CCND2, CCND3, CDK4, FGFR1, and MYC, which are targets of molecular‐targeted drugs.

Conclusions

dNGS of cfDNA using MBs is useful for accurate detection of gene alterations even with low levels of MAFs. These results may be used to inform the development of diagnostics and therapeutics that can improve the prognosis of pancreatic cancer.

Validation of Preamplification to Improve Quantification of Cytomegalovirus DNA Using Droplet Digital Polymerase Chain Reaction

Subclinical cytomegalovirus (CMV) replication is associated with strong cellular immune response and chronic inflammation, which could contribute to aging-related conditions such as cardiovascular disease and frailty. However, because of very low levels of CMV DNA present in people with chronic CMV infection, it has been difficult to explore the virologic and immunologic mechanisms of chronic low-level CMV infection and a sensitive method to monitor CMV replication is needed. Droplet digital PCR (ddPCR) has been shown to have higher precision and reproducibility than real-time quantitative PCR (qPCR) in quantifying low levels of CMV DNA, but it is not always sensitive enough for this purpose. Through rigorous validation experiments, we demonstrated that sensitivity and precision of quantification of very low levels of CMV DNA by ddPCR can be significantly increased by preamplification of samples with 10-20 cycles of conventional PCR, especially when testing CMV DNA in the presence of cellular DNA. With preamplification, we could reliably quantify down to two copies of CMV DNA, as opposed to five copies without preamplification. Further studies are needed to determine if ddPCR with preamplification can facilitate mechanistic studies of the characteristics and consequences of chronic CMV infection in aging adults.

Digital PCR-based plasma cell-free DNA mutation analysis for early-stage pancreatic tumor diagnosis and surveillance

BACKGROUND

Cell-free DNA (cfDNA) shed from tumors into the circulation offers a tool for cancer detection. Here, we evaluated the feasibility of cfDNA measurement and utility of digital PCR (dPCR)-based assays, which reduce subsampling error, for diagnosing pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma (PDA) and surveillance of intraductal papillary mucinous neoplasm (IPMN).

METHODS

We collected plasma from seven institutions for cfDNA measurements. Hot-spot mutations in KRAS and GNAS in the cfDNA from patients with PDA (n = 96), undergoing surveillance for IPMN (n = 112), and normal controls (n = 76) were evaluated using pre-amplification dPCR.

RESULTS

Upon Qubit measurement and copy number assessment of hemoglobin-subunit (HBB) and mitochondrially encoded NADH:ubiquinone oxidoreductase core subunit 1 (MT-ND1) in plasma cfDNA, HBB offered the best resolution between patients with PDA relative to healthy subjects [area under the curve (AUC) 0.862], whereas MT-ND1 revealed significant differences between IPMN and controls (AUC 0.851). DPCR utilizing pre-amplification cfDNA afforded accurate tumor-derived mutant KRAS detection in plasma in resectable PDA (AUC 0.861-0.876) and improved post-resection recurrence prediction [hazard ratio (HR) 3.179, 95% confidence interval (CI) 1.025-9.859] over that for the marker CA19-9 (HR 1.464; 95% CI 0.674-3.181). Capturing KRAS and GNAS could also provide genetic evidence in patients with IPMN-associated PDA and undergoing pancreatic surveillance.

CONCLUSIONS

Plasma cfDNA quantification by distinct measurements is useful to predict tumor burden. Through appropriate methods, dPCR-mediated mutation detection in patients with localized PDA and IPMN likely to progress to invasive carcinoma is feasible and complements conventional biomarkers.

Aberrant expression of a novel circular RNA in pancreatic cancer

Circular RNAs (circRNAs) are single-stranded, covalently closed RNA molecules that are produced from pre-mRNAs through a process known as back-splicing. Although circRNAs are expressed under specific conditions, current understanding of their comprehensive expression status is still limited. Here, we performed a large-scale circRNA profiling analysis in human pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma (PDAC) tissues, using circular RNA-specific RNA sequencing. We identified more than 40,000 previously unknown circRNAs, some of which were upregulated in PDAC tissues, compared with normal pancreatic tissues. We determined the full-length sequence of a circRNA upregulated in PDAC, which was derived from two noncoding RNA loci on chromosome 12. The novel circRNA, named circPDAC RNA, was not expressed in normal human cells, but was expressed in PDAC and other carcinoma cells. While postulated biological functions, such as peptide production from the circPDAC RNA, were not detected, its aberrant expression was confirmed in other PDAC tissues and in serum from a PDAC patient. These results demonstrate that comprehensive studies are necessary to reveal the expression status of circRNAs and that the circPDAC RNA identified here might serve as a novel biomarker for cancers, including PDAC.

Time-saving method for directly amplifying and capturing a minimal amount of pancreatic tumor-derived mutations from fine-needle aspirates using digital PCR

It is challenging to secure a cytopathologic diagnosis using minute amounts of tumor fluids and tissue fragments. Hence, we developed a rapid, accurate, low-cost method for detecting tumor cell-derived DNA from limited amounts of specimens and samples with a low tumor cellularity, to detect KRAS mutations in pancreatic ductal carcinomas (PDA) using digital PCR (dPCR). The core invention is based on the suspension of tumor samples in pure water, which causes an osmotic burst; the crude suspension could be directly subjected to emulsion PCR in the platform. We examined the feasibility of this process using needle aspirates from surgically resected pancreatic tumor specimens (n = 12). We successfully amplified and detected mutant KRAS in 11 of 12 tumor samples harboring the mutation; the positive mutation frequency was as low as 0.8%. We used residual specimens from fine-needle aspiration/biopsy and needle flush processes (n = 10) for method validation. In 9 of 10 oncogenic KRAS pancreatic tumor samples, the "water-burst" method resulted in a positive mutation call. We describe a dPCR-based, super-sensitive screening protocol for determining KRAS mutation availability using tiny needle aspirates from PDAs processed using simple steps. This method might enable pathologists to secure a more accurate, minimally invasive diagnosis using minute tissue fragments.

Fractionated small cell-free DNA increases possibility to detect cancer-related gene mutations in advanced colorectal cancer

Background and Aim

Liquid biopsy is a method that can efficiently detect tumor genetic abnormalities from body fluids such as blood and urine. Detection sensitivity and the available number of mutations in cell-free DNA (cfDNA) are limited. In this study, we develop a highly sensitive and comprehensive method to detect mutations from cfDNA by concentrating tumor fractions of small cfDNA in advanced colorectal cancers.

Methods

Biopsied specimens and 37 serum samples were collected from 27 patients with advanced colorectal carcinoma. A serum-extracted cfDNA was divided into enriched fractionated small cfDNA and unfractionated cfDNA. Both cfDNAs were subjected to digital polymerase chain reaction (PCR) to evaluate their KRAS, BRAF, CDKN2A, and TP53 status. Consequently, their mutant allele frequencies (MAFs) were compared and analyzed by next-generation sequencing (NGS) in conjunction with tissue-derived DNA.

Results

NGS analyses revealed mutations in TP53 (63%), KRAS (63%), APC (30%), and PIK3CA (22%). Digital PCR could detect mutations in 25 of 27 samples (93%) of unfractionated cfDNA, a rate that increased to 100% when samples were enriched with fractionated small cfDNA (6.8 vs 10.7%, P < 0.001). NGS also showed increased MAFs in fractionated small cfDNA compared to unfractionated cfDNA (16.3 vs 18.8%, P = 0.012) and a tendency to detect a greater number of cancer-related genes in fractionated cfDNA.

Conclusions

Fractionated small cfDNA increased MAFs of gene mutations and increases the possibilities to detect cancer-related genes even in advanced cancer patients from whom it is difficult to obtain tissue samples.

Application of a digital PCR method for WT1 to myeloid neoplasms in CR and deep ELN WT1 molecular response (< 10 copies)

Bone marrow WT1 mRNA levels assessed by the ELN method are useful to establish prognostic correlations in myeloid malignancies treated with chemotherapy or hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HCT). Those patients with WT1 levels below ten copies have a good outcome. However, some of these patients relapse. To further characterize this group of cases, we applied a new and sensitive digital (ddPCR) WT1 method. A consecutive series of 49 patients with treated myeloid malignancies and with an ELN WT1 quantitation of < 10 copies were included in the study. All cases (47 AML and 2 MDS) have received intensive chemotherapy or HCT. One to four micrograms of total RNA were retrotranscribed to obtain ≥ 10,000 ABL1 copies using the ELN protocol. Only those cases with a good quality cDNA were used in the ddPCR WT1 test. The ddPCR Gene Expression WT1 Assay of Bio-Rad© was used to perform the PCR amplification, and the microdroplets were quantified in the Bio-Rad's QX200 droplet reader. Eighteen patients showed a negative WT1 ddPCR assay (0 copies/μl), whereas 31 cases were positive (results ranged from 1 to 15.2 copies/μl). Survival analysis showed statistically significant differences in terms of OS between both groups, 83 ± 8% vs. 46 ± 9% (p = 0.024). A statistically significant correlation was also found between ddPCRWT1 results and CD123+ cell number detected by flow cytometry (p = 0.024). Larger series of patients tested with the current ddPCRWT1 method will solve whether it could be used to stratify patients with myeloid malignancies achieving deep WT1 molecular response (< 10 copies).

Cell-free DNA BRAF V600E measurements during BRAF inhibitor therapy of metastatic melanoma: long-term analysis

OBJECTIVE

We assessed the status of the BRAF V600E mutation in cell-free circulating tumor DNA (cfDNA) isolated from the plasma of patients with metastatic melanoma treated with the BRAF inhibitor vemurafenib, collected at different time points during therapy to evaluate the sensitivity and specificity of quantitative polymerase chain reaction and droplet digital polymerase chain reaction (ddPCR) and the correlation between the level of plasma cfDNA p.V600E and the long-term clinical outcome.

METHODS

cfDNA in patients with BRAF-mutated melanoma (n = 62) was analyzed at baseline and at 4-8 weeks from the start of vemurafenib therapy. BRAF mutations were assessed using tumor tissue-derived DNA and circulating cfDNA from plasma samples. Quantification of BRAF V600E was performed in cfDNA using ddPCR.

RESULTS

cfDNA V600E was detected in the plasma of 48/62 (77%) patients at baseline and in 18/62 (29%) patients after 4-8 weeks of treatment. Patients positive for BRAF mutations in cfDNA at baseline had shorter progression-free survival (PFS) and overall survival (OS) compared with patients with undetectable cfDNA BRAF mutations. Undetectable cfDNA p.V600E at baseline and after 4-8 weeks of therapy was associated with the best prognosis. When treated as a continuous variable, the log-transformed concentration of baseline cfDNA p.V600E was significantly associated with both PFS and OS. This effect was retained in the multivariate OS Cox model adjusted for Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group performance status, the presence of brain metastases, patient age, and previous systemic treatment.

CONCLUSIONS

Monitoring of plasma BRAF p.V600E cfDNA concentrations in patients with metastatic melanoma on targeted therapy may have prognostic value. Undetectable cfDNA p.V600E before and during treatment was associated with a favorable prognosis.

Circulating Tumor DNA Analysis: Clinical Implications for Colorectal Cancer Patients. A Systematic Review

Background

Liquid biopsies could improve diagnosis, prognostication, and monitoring of colorectal cancer (CRC). Mutation, chromosomal copy number alteration, and methylation analysis in circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) from plasma or serum has gained great interest. However, the literature is inconsistent on preferred candidate markers, hampering a clear direction for further studies and clinical translation. This review assessed the potential of ctDNA analysis for clinical utility.

Methods

A systematic review according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-analyses guidelines was conducted up to December 3, 2018, followed by methodological quality assessment. Primary endpoints were accuracy for detection, prognostication, and monitoring.

Results

Eighty-four studies were included. For CRC detection, sensitivity was 75% using ctDNA mutation analysis and up to 96% using copy number analysis. Septin 9 (SEPT9) hypermethylation analysis showed sensitivities of 100% and specificities of 97%. Regarding prognostication, ctDNA KRAS mutations were associated with oncological outcome and could predict response to anti-epidermal growth factor receptor therapy. For monitoring, sequential ctDNA KRAS mutation analysis showed promise for detection of relapses or therapy resistance.

Conclusions

This comprehensive overview of ctDNA candidate markers demonstrates SEPT9 methylation analysis to be promising for CRC detection, and KRAS mutation analysis could assist in prognostication and monitoring. Prospective evaluation of marker panels in clinical decision making should bring ctDNA analysis into practice.

An ultrasensitive test for profiling circulating tumor DNA using integrated comprehensive droplet digital detection

Current cancer detection systems lack the required sensitivity to reliably detect minimal residual disease (MRD) and recurrence at the earliest stages when treatment would be most effective. To address this issue, we present a novel liquid biopsy approach that utilizes an integrated comprehensive droplet digital detection (IC3D) digital PCR system which combines microfluidic droplet partitioning, fluorescent multiplex PCR chemistry, and our rapid 3D, large-volume droplet counting technology. The IC3D ddPCR assay can detect cancer-specific, ultra-rare genomic targets due to large sample input and high degree of partitioning. We first demonstrate our droplet digital PCR assay can robustly detect common cancer mutants including KRAS G12D spiked in wild-type genomic background or isolated from patient samples with 100% specificity. We then demonstrate that the IC3D ddPCR system can detect oncogenic KRAS G12D mutant alleles against a background of wild-type genomes at a sensitivity of 0.00125-0.005% with a false positive rate of 0% which is 50 to 1000× more sensitive than existing commercial liquid biopsy ddPCR and qPCR platforms, respectively. In addition, our technology can uniquely enable detection of circulating tumor cells using their genetic markers without a pre-enrichment step, and analysis of total tumor DNA isolated from blood samples, which will increase clinical sensitivity and specificity, and minimize inter-assay variability. Therefore, our technology holds the potential to provide clinicians with a powerful decision-making tool to monitor and treat MRD with unprecedented sensitivity for earlier stage intervention.

Pathways of Progression From Intraductal Papillary Mucinous Neoplasm to Pancreatic Ductal Adenocarcinoma Based on Molecular Features

BACKGROUND & AIMS

Intraductal papillary mucinous neoplasms (IPMNs) are regarded as precursors of pancreatic ductal adenocarcinomas (PDAs), but little is known about the mechanism of progression. This makes it challenging to assess cancer risk in patients with IPMNs. We investigated associations of IPMNs with concurrent PDAs by genetic and histologic analyses.

METHODS

We obtained 30 pancreatic tissues with concurrent PDAs and IPMNs, and 168 lesions, including incipient foci, were mapped, microdissected, and analyzed for mutations in 18 pancreatic cancer-associated genes and expression of tumor suppressors.

RESULTS

We determined the clonal relatedness of lesions, based on driver mutations shared by PDAs and concurrent IPMNs, and classified the lesions into 3 subtypes. Twelve PDAs contained driver mutations shared by all concurrent IPMNs, which we called the sequential subtype. This subset was characterized by less diversity in incipient foci with frequent GNAS mutations. Eleven PDAs contained some driver mutations that were shared with concurrent IPMNs, which we called the branch-off subtype. In this subtype, PDAs and IPMNs had identical KRAS mutations but different GNAS mutations, although the lesions were adjacent. Whole-exome sequencing and methylation analysis of these lesions indicated clonal origin with later divergence. Ten PDAs had driver mutations not found in concurrent IPMNs, called the de novo subtype. Expression profiles of TP53 and SMAD4 increased our ability to differentiate these subtypes compared with sequencing data alone. The branch-off and de novo subtypes had substantial heterogeneity among early clones, such as differences in KRAS mutations. Patients with PDAs of the branch-off subtype had a longer times of disease-free survival than patients with PDAs of the de novo or the sequential subtypes.

CONCLUSIONS

Detailed histologic and genetic analysis of PDAs and concurrent IPMNs identified 3 different pathways by which IPMNs progress to PDAs-we call these the sequential, branch-off, and de novo subtypes. Subtypes might be associated with clinical and pathologic features and be used to select surveillance programs for patients with IPMNs.

Utility of "liquid biopsy" using pancreatic juice for early detection of pancreatic cancer

Background  Despite advances in the diagnosis of pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma (PDA), histological evaluation of small and poorly defined masses in the pancreas is uncomfortable and unsafe. Methods  We herein report a case of early stage PDA, in which multiple KRAS mutations were detected in the pancreatic juice preoperatively. A small hypoechoic area adjacent to the portal vein was detected through endoscopic ultrasound in the pancreatic body. KRAS mutations were evaluated using plasma, and the pancreatic juice by digital PCR. Results  Pancreatic duct biopsy and pancreatic juice cytology were performed with no evidence of malignancy; however, KRAS mutations, KRAS G12V and G12D, were detected in the pancreatic juice. Histological assessment of the resected specimen demonstrated a solid tumor with desmoplastic reaction accompanied by carcinoma in situ in the main pancreatic duct where KRAS G12V mutation was identified. More detailed analysis demonstrated KRAS G12D mutation in the cluster of low grade pancreatic intraepithelial neoplasia, implying that the lesion developed independently. Conclusions  Our study indicates the potential of "endoscopic liquid biopsy" to capture the driver gene for PDA diagnosis.

Preamplification with dUTP and Cod UNG Enables Elimination of Contaminating Amplicons

Analyzing rare DNA and RNA molecules in limited sample sizes, such as liquid biopsies and single cells, often requires preamplification, which makes downstream analyses particularly sensitive to polymerase chain reaction (PCR) generated contamination. Herein, we assessed the feasibility of performing Cod uracil-DNA N-glycosylase (Cod UNG) treatment in combination with targeted preamplification, using deoxyuridine triphosphate (dUTP) to eliminate carry-over DNA. Cod UNG can be completely and irreversibly heat inactivated, a prerequisite in preamplification methods, where any loss of amplicons is detrimental to subsequent quantification. Using 96 target assays and quantitative real-time PCR, we show that replacement of deoxythymidine triphosphate (dTTP) with dUTP in the preamplification reaction mix results in comparable dynamic range, reproducibility, and sensitivity. Moreover, Cod UNG essentially removes all uracil-containing template of most assays, regardless of initial concentration, without affecting downstream analyses. Finally, we demonstrate that the use of Cod UNG and dUTP in targeted preamplification can easily be included in the workflow for single-cell gene expression profiling. In summary, Cod UNG treatment in combination with targeted preamplification using dUTP provides a simple and efficient solution to eliminate carry-over contamination and the generation of false positives and inaccurate quantification.