High-grade non-Hodgkin lymphoma relapsing as low-grade follicular lymphoma: so-called downgraded lymphoma

Lymphoma recurrence 5 years or later following diffuse large B-cell lymphoma: clinical characteristics and outcome

PURPOSE Patients with diffuse large B-cell lymphoma (DLBCL) usually relapse early following diagnosis but some relapses happen at 5 years or later. Few data exist regarding clinical characteristics and outcome of these patients. PATIENTS AND METHODS We performed a retrospective analysis of all patients from two centers in Lyon, France, between 1985 and 2003 who had a biopsy-proven relapse 5 years or later following diagnosis of DLBCL. All available biopsies were reviewed and immunohistochemistry was completed. Results Among 1,492 patients with DLBCL, 54 were eligible. At diagnosis, 63% of patients had stage I-II, 82% had low/low-intermediate International Prognostic Index (IPI) score, 65% had extranodal involvement, 24% had an indolent component associated with DLBCL, 57% had germinal center phenotype, and 43% had non-germinal center phenotype. Median time from diagnosis to relapse was 7.4 years (range, 5 to 20.5 years). At time of relapse, 83% had DLBCL histology, and 17% had indolent histology. Having an indolent component at diagnosis was associated with indolent histology at relapse (P = .028). Five-year event free-survival (EFS) was 17% for patients with DLBCL relapse and 61% for patients with indolent relapse (P = .027). Five-year overall survival was 27% for patients with DLBCL and 75% for patients with indolent relapse (P = .029). For DLBCL relapse, 3-year EFS was 56% versus 18% with autologous stem-cell transplantation or not, respectively (P = .0661). CONCLUSION Patients with DLBCL who had a late relapse usually had localized stage, favorable IPI score, and extranodal involvement at diagnosis. The outcome of patients with DLBCL at time of relapse remains poor, and aggressive treatment such as autologous stem-cell transplantation should be pursued whenever possible. Biopsy at relapse is essential because some patients relapse with indolent histology.

Haematopathology practice: the commonest problems encountered in a consultation practice

Although not specifically recognized as a subspecialty of histopathology, haematopathology has a long history of specialist practice in the UK, with a few centres attracting large numbers of referred cases. The specialist nature of haematopathology has been enhanced by the advent of immunohistochemistry and, more recently, molecular genetics, which now play a major role in the diagnosis of haematopoietic and lymphoid neoplasms. Problems encountered by non-specialist pathologists, and reflected in those cases submitted for consultation, include difficulties in the differential diagnosis of certain benign lymphoproliferative disorders from lymphoma and the precise classification of lymphomas which may have an impact on therapeutic decisions. Lymphomas that frequently pose problems include common lesions such as follicular lymphoma and more esoteric disorders such as T-cell/histiocyte-rich large B-cell lymphoma. This review is an attempt to clarify a logical approach to the differential diagnosis of these lesions.

Reliability of lymphoma classification in bone marrow trephines

The aim of this study was to test and establish the accuracy and reliability of lymphoma classification in bone marrow trephines according to the new World Health Organization (WHO) classification by considering predominantly the morphology and immunophenotype. Therefore, we retrospectively compared lymphoma diagnoses, rendered exclusively on bone marrow trephines without knowledge of lymph node diagnosis in 124 patients, with the results of the reference centres that had reviewed lymph node (n = 90) or extranodal biopsies (n = 34). The overall concordance rate was higher than 85% and 91%, respectively, when patients with discordant malignancy grades were excluded. The concordance rate for low-grade B-cell lymphomas was 93% and for high-grade B-cell lymphomas 84%. The main reasons for discordant diagnoses were divergent immunophenotypes among low-grade B-cell lymphomas (6 out of 81, i.e. 7.4%) and discrepant malignancy grades within high-grade B-cell lymphomas (6 out of 31, i.e. 19.4%). No relationship between discordant diagnoses and chemotherapy given during the course of the disease with the site of biopsy (i.e. lymph nodes, extranodal sites) was noted. We conclude from our results that bone marrow trephines are a reliable tool, not only for establishing bone marrow infiltration, but also for the subtyping of lymphomas.

Pathology of lymphoma progression

Reflecting the stepwise process of oncogenesis, lymphomas may cumulatively develop a more aggressive phenotype during the course of disease, a process referred to as lymphoma progression. Although morphological, clinical and biological aspects of lymphoma progression do not always overlap, changes in lymphoma morphology frequently indicate alterations in the clinical and biological behaviour of the disease. Indolent and aggressive lymphomas in disease progression can either be clonally related or represent clonally unrelated neoplasms. We propose to use the term 'lymphoma progression' in a biological sense denoting only clonal development of and within a lymphoma entity. The term 'composite lymphoma' should be used as a merely descriptive morphological designation for different lymphoma entities in one individual irrespective of clonal relationship. Many types of aggressive B-cell non-Hodgkin's lymphomas and Hodgkin's lymphomas are reported to secondarily develop in lymphoma progression. Genetic changes associated with lymphoma progression frequently abrogate the differentiating effects of alterations occurring in indolent lymphomas, leading to increased cell proliferation. Within different lymphoma entities, high-risk disease variants mimicking lymphoma progression exist.

Transformation of the small cell variant Ki-1+ lymphoma to anaplastic large cell lymphoma: pathologic and clinical features

The disease spectrum of anaplastic large cell lymphoma (ALCL) includes a biologically aggressive small cell variant (SCV). The SCV may progress to ALCL, but little is known about the transformation process and its significance. The goals of this study were (1) to identify the clinical and pathologic features that characterize ALCL arising in SCV and (2) to determine whether some cases with ALCL histologic appearance at the outset arose from an SCV. Seventeen SCV were reviewed, and four cases (24%) transformed to ALCL as shown by subsequent biopsy. The ALCLs were predominantly monomorphic (3 cases) rather than pleomorphic (1 case). Residual SCV was detected at transformation in 3 of 4 cases. Twenty-one de novo T-cell ALCLs were reviewed for an SCV component; such a component was identified in two ALCLs with monomorphic features, suggesting a preceding SCV phase. There was no change in the immunophenotype between the SCV and ALCL, all marking as EMA+ T cells. Expression of p80 was detected in 3 of 4 (75%) SCV with transformation and 10 of 12 (77%) SCV without transformation. Chromosomal abnormalities involving the sex chromosomes and 6, 7, 9, and 15, in addition to the characteristic t(2;5)(p23;q35), were present in 2 cases at transformation. Times to transformation ranged from 1 to 146 months (mean: 63 months) after diagnosis. Transformation to ALCL signaled a rapid clinical course, with 75% of patients dying in less than a year; one patient remains alive at 15 months. In summary, some ALCLs, particularly those with monomorphic features, arise from an SCV. Transformation to ALCL signals a rapid course, with death occurring in less than a year in most cases. Necrosis in the SCV may be predictive of transformation. Chromosomal abnormalities in addition to the t(2;5)(p23;q35) are present at transformation, suggesting that multiple genetic alterations are involved in disease progression.

Risk of relapse and clinico-pathological features in 103 patients with diffuse large-cell lymphoma in complete response after first-line treatment

Patients with diffuse large-cell lymphoma (DLCL) achieve a complete response (CR) in most cases, but at least one-third of them eventually relapse. Such an event occurs most frequently within 2 yr from CR achievement. The aim of the present study was to analyse the risk and pattern of relapse of patients with DLCL in CR. One hundred and three patients with DLCL (53 male/50 female; median age: 55 yr) in CR after doxorubicin-containing first-line treatments were included in the study. Main clinicobiological characteristics at diagnosis and at relapse were analysed. Uni- and multivariate studies were performed. Forty-one patients (40%) eventually relapsed, in 27 cases within 2 yr from CR and 14 thereafter. Histological subtype was the same at diagnosis and at relapse in all the early relapsing patients and in 8 of 10 late relapsing patients with available biopsy. The most important variables at diagnosis for predicting relapse were advanced stage (p<0.01) and bone marrow infiltration (p=0.05), with stage (I-II vs. III-IV) (p=0.009; relative risk=2.28) being the only predictive variable in the multivariate analysis. No differences were found according to the treatment given. The second CR rate obtained in the late relapsing patients after salvage therapies was higher that in early relapsing (50% vs. 37%). Median survival from relapse was 1.4 yr for patients early relapsing and it was not achieved for those with late relapses (p=0.09). Late relapse is a quite common event in DLCL lymphomas, with those patients achieving more frequently a second CR and having better survival than early relapsed patients.

Advanced diffuse large-cell lymphoma treated with 12-week combination chemotherapy: natural history of relapse after initial complete response and prognostic variables defining outcome after relapse

PURPOSE

To define both the natural history of and prognostic factors affecting outcome post relapse from a complete response in advanced stage diffuse large-cell lymphoma.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

A total of 468 patients aged 17-74 years received the 12-week duration chemotherapy regimens MACOP-B, VACOP-B and ACOP-12 between 1 April 1981 and 31 December 1995 for advanced stage diffuse large, mixed or immunoblastic lymphoma. Of these 402 entered a complete remission, 97 (24%) of whom subsequently relapsed. Initial staging data, follow-up, and relapse information were analyzed to define the natural history of relapse and also subjected to univariate and multivariate correlation with overall (OS) and failure free survival (FFS).

RESULTS

Eleven percent of the relapses were low grade. All other relapses were of intermediate grade with 75% occurring within the first two years, the remainder up until the eleventh year. Median and five-year OS from the time of relapse for intermediate grade relapse were 12 months and 20%; for FFS they were eight months and 18% respectively. Adverse independent factors, for both OS and FFS were: less than one year to relapse, decreasing performance status at relapse, and more than three nodal sites at relapse.

CONCLUSIONS

Low-grade relapse is not uncommon in patients who initially presented with diffuse large cell lymphoma. As the management of low- and intermediate grade disease is so different biopsy proof of the nature of the relapse is of value. The prognostic factors identified need to be taken into consideration when analyzing results from trials of secondary treatment so as to avoid erroneous conclusions about comparative treatment efficacy.

Prognostic factors for therapeutic outcome of diffuse small non-cleaved cell lymphoma in adults

Most reports of prognosis and therapy in diffuse small non-cleaved cell lymphoma (DSNCL), an aggressive high-grade non-Hodgkin's lymphoma (NHL) which appears to be of two histopathologic subtypes, have included predominantly a pediatric population and very few adults. We studied 20 newly diagnosed, previously untreated adults with DSNCL. Three patients had Ann Arbor Stage I disease, five Stage II, and 12 Stage IV. Bone marrow involvement was present in seven of 20 (35%) patients; no patient had central nervous system involvement at diagnosis. Clonal chromosomal abnormalities were found on cytogenetic analysis of all 12 cases studied. Ten patients had specific recurring translocations, including t(8;14) (q23;q32) (five patients), t(14;18) (q32;q21) (four patients), and t(2;8) (p12;q24) (one patient). Induction chemotherapy with the COMP regimen (cyclophosphamide, vincristine, methotrexate, and prednisone) or a variant schedule of the same drugs resulted in complete remission for 13 patients (65%), and partial remission for 5 patients (25%). Clinical characteristics predictive of a favorable response to induction therapy included Stage I or II disease, a normal lactic dehydrogenase (LDH), and performance status (PS) of 0 or 1. Remission duration ranged from two to 125+ (median 37+) months. Survival ranged from one to 126+ (median 23) months; ten patients (50%) remain alive, nine with no active disease. Factors predictive of longer survival included achievement of a complete remission with induction therapy, a normal LDH, and PS 0 or 1. As in children with DSNCL, long-term disease-free survival may be achieved in adults with combination chemotherapy.

Late relapse with nodular lymphoma after treatment for diffuse non-Hodgkin's lymphoma

Histologic conversion from a low-grade non-Hodgkin's lymphoma (NHL) into a more aggressive histologic pattern is a common, well-documented event in NHL. The converse phenomenon, appearance of a low-grade, follicular NHL after treatment for diffuse, intermediate, or high-grade NHL, has only recently been recognized. The clinical, morphologic, and immunologic features of a patient in whom relapse with an indolent nodular lymphoma was noticed after combination chemotherapy for diffuse lymphoma are presented. Immunologic markers at presentation and relapse were similar. Other previously reported cases are reviewed. Implications for diagnosis and therapy as well as the pathogenesis of this unique form of conversion are discussed.

Biologic progression in non-Hodgkin's lymphoma. A flow cytometric study

The nuclear DNA content of 37 primary non-Hodgkin's lymphomas both at presentation and at relapse was determined by flow cytometric analysis from paraffin-embedded tissue to investigate changes in DNA ploidy and S-phase fraction (SPF) during the course of the disease, and their association with survival. The repeat biopsies were done from 5 months to 15 years after the diagnosis. Four low-grade lymphomas according to the Working Formulation transformed into intermediate-grade lymphomas (four of 11, 36%), and four intermediate-grade lymphomas into high-grade lymphomas during the follow-up (four of 16, 25%), and five of these eight transformed lymphomas were fatal within 18 months after relapse. The SPF correlated strongly with poor prognosis if measured either from the primary biopsy (P = 0.008), the first (P = 0.009), or the latest repeat biopsy (P = 0.006). If SPF was greater than or equal to 6% larger in a repeat biopsy than at presentation prognosis was poor; six of nine such patients died from lymphoma within 11 months from recurrence. An increase of greater than or equal to 6% in the SPF was more common in high-grade (four of nine, 44%) and intermediate-grade (four of 16, 25%) lymphomas than in low-grade lymphomas (one of 11, 9%), and it was occasionally (three of nine) associated with a morphologic change. In a few cases a repeat biopsy was diploid despite DNA aneuploidy at presentation. In conclusion, the study provides evidence that not only may low-grade lymphomas transform into higher grade lymphomas, but high-grade lymphomas may also frequently transform into more malignant forms during the course of the disease. The SPF is useful in monitoring the biological behavior of non-Hodgkin's lymphoma, and it appears to give information not obtained by histologic study alone.

Long-term follow-up of CHOP-treated non-Hodgkin lymphoma of high-grade malignancy

The long-term outcome of 116 NHL patients (38 CB, 33 IB, 24 LB, 11 high-grade unclassified, 9 PTCL, 1 Ki-1 lymphoma - see list of abbreviations) treated with an age-adjusted CHOP regimen from 1980-85 was evaluated. The median age was 64 years. Of these patients 28% had significant comorbidity. CB patients had the best outcome; the median survival was not reached after 110 months. However, the differences in survival of all histological entities are not significant (P = 0.08). Fifty-six percent of the patients had clinical stages I-II. The CR rate of all 116 patients was 47%. After a median follow-up of 58 months, 30% of the patients are alive and disease-free. Of 14 relapses 11 occurred within 2 years. The median time period before relapse was 9 months. Salvage therapy failed, as none of the IB and LB patients achieved CR. Five CB patients had CR with second-line therapy, four had PR after induction therapy, one patient relapsed after 30 months. Of the CR patients 15% developed second or third neoplasms. Only one instance of acute myeloblastic leukemia was observed. These results indicate that age-adjusted CHOP is a well-tolerated therapy.