Asbestos-induced visceral pleural fibrosis reduces pulmonary compliance

Systematic review of pleural plaques and lung function

Context

US EPA proposed a Reference Concentration for Libby amphibole asbestos based on the premise that pleural plaques are adverse and cause lung function deficits.

Objective

We conducted a systematic review to evaluate whether there is an association between pleural plaques and lung function and ascertain whether results were dependent on the method used to identify plaques.

Methods

Using the PubMed database, we identified studies that evaluated pleural plaques and lung function. We assessed each study for quality, then integrated evidence and assessed associations based on the Bradford Hill guidelines. We also compared the results of HRCT studies to those of X-ray studies.

Results

We identified 16 HRCT and 36 X-ray studies. We rated six HRCT and 16 X-ray studies as higher quality based on a risk-of-bias analysis. Half of the higher quality studies reported small but statistically significant mean lung function decrements associated with plaques. None of the differences were clinically significant. Many studies had limitations, such as inappropriate controls and/or insufficient adjustment for confounders. There was little consistency in the direction of effect for the most commonly reported measurements. X-ray results were more variable than HRCT results. Pleural plaques were not associated with changes in lung function over time in longitudinal studies.

Conclusion

The weight of evidence indicates that pleural plaques do not impact lung function. Observed associations are most likely due to unidentified abnormalities or other factors.

The validity of static lung compliance in asbestos-induced diseases

BACKGROUND

Pulmonary compliance can be viewed as an indicator of distensibility of the lungs, not only in asbestos-induced pulmonary disorders but also in visceral pleural fibrosis extending into the lung parenchyma. In this study we evaluated static compliance measurements in asbestos-derived diseases, especially in patients with parietal pleura plaques. Lung function analyses, especially static lung compliance, were correlated with high-resolution computer tomography examinations.

METHODS

Sixty-three patients with parietal pleural plaques, 10 with visceral pleural fibrosis, 39 with parenchymal pulmonary asbestosis together with parietal pleural plaques, and 42 with parenchymal pulmonary asbestosis together with visceral pleural fibrosis were enrolled in the study.

RESULTS

In comparison with patients having only parietal pleural plaques, those having asbestosis and visceral pleural fibrosis showed significant decreases in static lung compliance, diffusing capacity, and vital capacity. Visceral pleural thickening was also associated with significantly reduced FEV(1), MEF(50), and FEV(1)/FVC ratios. Multiple regression analyses indicated that the existence of visceral pleural fibrosis (p = 0.017) is the most important factor accounting for a decrease in static compliance. Reference values of static lung compliance differ notably. In comparison with mean reference values, the sensitivity of detecting reduced lung compliance was calculated to be between 9.7 and 45.5 %. Other respiratory function variables failed to show any significant differences.

CONCLUSION

Our data indicate that the measurement of static compliance is not sufficient for early detection of pulmonary function impairment in patients with parietal pleural plaques.

Reference values for dynamic and static pulmonary compliance in men

The aim of the present study was to determine new reference values and predictive variables for dynamic and static pulmonary compliance in men. The investigation was conducted as a prospective study in healthy, non-smoking men with normal pulmonary function parameters including spirometry, bodyplethysmography and CO diffusing capacity. The esophageal pressure method was used to measure dynamic compliance (Cdyn), specific dynamic compliance (Cdyn/ITGV), static compliance (Cstat) and specific static compliance (Cstat/ITGV). Lung recoil pressures were recorded at different levels of total lung capacity (TLC). A total of 208 men aged 20-69 years were included in the study. The mean values for the compliance parameters were: Cdyn: 2.91+/-1.08 L/kPa; Cdyn/ITGV: 0.71 +/- 0.30 kPa (-1); Cstat: 3.34 +/- 1.04 L/kPa; Cstat/ITGV: 0.82 +/- 0.31 kPa (-1). Cdyn, Cdyn/ITGV and Cstat/ITGV were significantly correlated with age and Cstat was related to height, but in multiple regression analyses the predictability for compliance parameters was very low. Lung recoil pressures at all TLC levels significantly decreased with ageing. In conclusion, we demonstrated that the contribution of anthropometric variables to the regression equations of pulmonary compliance was low. With ageing the static pressure-volume curve of the lung shifted to the left without substantial alteration of the slope.

Functional consequences of pleural disease evaluated with chest radiography and CT

PURPOSE

To identify a system for the quantification of pleural thickening with an acceptable level of interobserver variation and good functional correlation in individuals with pleural disease.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The extent of pleural thickening and plaques was assessed in 50 patients by using the following: (a) a radiographic score based on the International Labour Office system, (b) a subjective simple computed tomographic (CT) score, (c) a subjective comprehensive CT score, (d) an objective nonautomated method, and (e) an objective computer-aided semiautomated method.

RESULTS

Similar correlations between the extent of diffuse pleural thickening and forced vital capacity were seen for each system (objective CT, r = -0.72, P <.001; simple CT, r = -0.69, P <.001; radiographic, r = -0.67, P <.001; comprehensive CT, r = -0.66, P <.001). Comparable correlations were observed for total lung capacity. After controlling for extent of diffuse pleural thickening, pleural plaque scores were functionally irrelevant.

CONCLUSION

Comparable functional-morphologic correlations were achieved by using different CT and radiographic scoring systems for pleural disease. A subjective simple CT system had the advantages of ease of application and potential to aid in the accurate assessment of the lung parenchyma, which may be important in individuals exposed to asbestos.

Asbestos fibers and interleukin-1 upregulate the formation of reactive nitrogen species in rat pleural mesothelial cells

Nitric oxide radical (.NO) and peroxynitrite anion (ONOO-) have been implicated in lung inflammation and may be important in pleural injury. The present study was undertaken to determine the effects of asbestos exposure and cytokine stimulation on .NO and ONOO- production by rat pleural mesothelial cells. Accordingly, rat parietal pleural mesothelial cells were cultured for 2 to 72 h with or without 50 ng/ml of recombinant interleukin-1beta (IL-1beta) in the presence (1.05 to 8.4 microg/cm2) or absence of crocidolite or chrysotile asbestos fibers. The effects of asbestos were compared with those of carbonyl iron, a nonfibrogenic particulate. Mesothelial cell messenger RNA (mRNA) expression of the inducible form of .NO synthase (iNOS), assessed with the reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR), increased progressively from 2 to 12 h in IL-1beta-containing cultures. Nitrite (NO2-), the stable oxidation product of .NO in mesothelial cell conditioned medium, was assayed through the Griess reaction. Both types of asbestos fibers (chrysotile > crocidolite) upregulated the formation of NO2- in mesothelial cells costimulated with IL-1beta in a concentration-dependent and time-dependent fashion. In contrast, carbonyl iron did not upregulate NO2- formation in IL-1beta-stimulated cells. Both types of asbestos fibers also induced iNOS protein expression and the formation of nitrotyrosine in mesothelial cells and greatly induced the formation of nitrate (NO3-), a surrogate marker of ONOO- formation, in IL-1beta-stimulated cells. However, the effects of chrysotile were notably greater than those of crocidolite. These findings may have significance for the induction of pleural injury by asbestos fibers.