Formation of alternating tiers in the optic chiasm of the chick embryo

Variations in the architecture and development of the vertebrate optic chiasm

At the vertebrate optic chiasm there is major change in fibre order and, in many animals, a separation of fibres destined for different hemispheres of the brain. However, the structure of this region is not uniform among all species but rather shows marked variations both in terms of its gross architecture and the pathways taken by different fibres. There also are striking differences in the developmental mechanisms sculpting this region even between closely related animals. In spite of this, recent studies have provided strong evidence for a remarkable degree of conservation in the molecular nature of the guidance signals and regulatory genes driving chiasmatic development. Here differences and similarities in chiasmatic organisation and development between separate groups of animals will be reviewed. While it may not be possible to ascribe a single set of factors that are universal components of the vertebrate chiasm, there are both strikingly similar elements as well as diverse features to the development, organisation and architecture of this region. This review aims to highlight key issues in the organisation and development of the vertebrate optic chiasm with a focus on comparing and contrasting the data that has been gleaned to date from different vertebrate groups.

Potential role of Pax-2 in retinal axon navigation through the chick optic nerve stalk and optic chiasm

The degree of fiber decussation at the optic chiasm differs between species, ranging from complete crossing in lower vertebrates to highly complex patterns of intermingling of the fibers from the two eyes seen in mammals and birds. Understanding the genetic control of fiber guidance through the chiasm is therefore important to unravel the developmental mechanisms within the visual system. Here we first report on early stages of chiasm formation, with pioneering axons from the left eye consistently arriving earlier than their counterparts from the right eye. This initial left-right asymmetry is transient and no functional significance is assigned to it yet. Secondly, we examined formation of the chiasm in relation with the expression of the transcription factor Pax-2 along the ventral eye cup and optic nerve stalk. Finally, in order to examine causal involvement of Pax-2 in chiasm formation, the gene was overexpressed along the neuraxis and in the eye cup at embryonic stages preceding the exit of axons from the eye, and hence arrival of axons at the chiasm. When studied with neuroanatomical tracing, Pax-2 overexpression resulted in visibly anomalous decussation of axons at the chiasm. A likely consequence of this perturbation was erroneous arrival of axons at the tectum, as observed by anterograde staining from the retina. These data suggest that balanced expression of Pax-2 results in the correct formation of the chick chiasm at early stages by imposing accurate pathfinding within the optic stalk and the midline.

Architecture of the optic chiasm and the mechanisms that sculpt its development

At the optic chiasm the two optic nerves fuse, and fibers from each eye cross the midline or turn back and remain uncrossed. Having adopted their pathways the fibers separate to form the two optic tracts. Research into the architecture and development of the chiasm has become an area of increasing interest. Many of its mature features are complex and vary between different animal types. It is probable that numerous factors sculpt its development. The separate ganglion cell classes cross the midline at different locations along the length of the chiasm, reflecting their distinct periods of production as the chiasm develops in a caudo-rostral direction. In some mammals, uncrossed axons are mixed with crossed axons in each hemi-chiasm, whereas in others they remain segregated. These configurations are the product of different developmental mechanisms. The morphology of the chiasm changes significantly during development. Neurons, glia, and the signals they produce play a role in pathway selection. In some animals fiber-fiber interactions are also critical, but only where crossed and uncrossed pathways are mixed in each hemi-chiasm. The importance of the temporal dimension in chiasm development is emphasized by the fact that in some animals uncrossed ganglion cells are generated abnormally early in relation to their retinal location. Furthermore, in albinos, where many cells do not exit the cell cycle at normal times, there are systematic chiasmatic abnormalities in ganglion cell projections.

Development of the visual system of the chick. II. Mechanisms of axonal guidance

The quest to understand axonal guidance mechanisms requires exact and multidisciplinary analyses of axon navigation. This review is the second part of an attempt to synthesise experimental data with theoretical models of the development of the topographic connection of the chick retina with the tectum. The first part included classic ideas from developmental biology and recent achievements on the molecular level in understanding cytodifferentiation and histogenesis [J. Mey, S. Thanos, Development of the visual system of the chick. (I) Cell differentiation and histogenesis, Brain Res. Rev. 32 (2000) 343-379]. The present part deals with the question of how millions of fibres exit from the eye, traverse over several millimetres and spread over the optic tectum to assemble a topographic map, whose precision accounts for the sensory performance of the visual system. The following topics gained special attention in this review. (i) A remarkable conceptual continuity between classic embryology and recent molecular biology has revealed that positional cellular specification precedes and determines the formation of the retinotectal map. (ii) Graded expression of asymmetric genes, transcriptional factors and receptors for signal transduction during early development seem to play a crucial role in determining the spatial identity of neurons within surface areas of retina and optic tectum. (iii) The chemoaffinity hypothesis constitutes the conceptual framework for development of the retinotopic organisation of the primary visual pathway. Studies of repulsive factors in vitro developed the original hypothesis from a theoretical postulate of chemoattraction to an empirically supported concept based on chemorepulsion. (iv) The independent but synchronous development of retina and optic tectum in topo-chronologically corresponding patterns ensures that ingrowing retinal axons encounter receptive target tissue at appropriate locations, and at the time when connections are due to be formed. (v) The growth cones of the retino-fugal axons seem to be guided both by local cues on glial endfeet and within the extracellular matrix. On the molecular level, the ephrins and their receptors have emerged as the most likely candidates for the material substrate of a topographic projection along the anterior-posterior axis of the optic tectum. Yet, since a number of alternative molecules have been proposed for the same function, it remains the challenge for the near future to define the proportional contribution of each one of the individual mechanisms proposed by matching theoretical predictions with the experimental evidence.

The course of later generated axons in the developing optic nerve of the chick embryo. A morphometric electron microscopic study

The topographic position of growth cones (GCs) shows the course of ingrowing axons within the optic nerve and allows to draw conclusions with respect to the fiber order in this pathway. Therefore, the topographic distribution and frequency of GCs as well as the proximal and distal axon shaft segments were studied within cross-sections of the distal, middle, and prechiasmatic part of the nerve of 3-8-day-old embryos using electron microscopy. The ingrowth of GCs was not confined to a particular region. Initially, GCs were found near the ventral periphery. With increasing age, simultaneous ingrowth occurred within an area that expanded dorsally. In parallel, GCs also occurred in dorsal regions and eventually in the dorsal periphery. GCs intermingled everywhere with more mature axon profiles. However, youngest profiles predominated ventrally, oldest dorsally. Hence, maturity increased from ventral to dorsal. This indicated that the time of arrival of axons and the topographic position in the cross-section correlated significantly. It is concluded that axons are chronotopically organized, but in a probabilistic sense. The predominant ingrowth of axons in the ventral part may be associated largely with the first wave of neurogenesis of retinal ganglion cells. The ingrowth in dorsal regions of the cross section may be related to later generated axons that enter the nerve following older axons of the same retinal sector as well as axons of neighboring ganglion cells which continue to leave the mitotic cycle while the front of neurogenesis has spread into the periphery.

Genesis, neurotrophin responsiveness, and apoptosis of a pronounced direct connection between the two eyes of the chick embryo: a natural error or a meaningful developmental event?

Unilateral intraocular injections of either of two fluorescent carbocyanine dyes into the embryonic chick eye resulted in both retrograde staining of ganglion cells (GCs) in the eye contralateral to site of injection and anterograde labeling of axons whose cell bodies were located within the injected eye. This prominent retino-retinal projection formed by thousands of GCs having a nasal origin and temporal termination appeared at embryonic day 6 (E6), attained its maximum intensity at E13-E14, and gradually disappeared until E18. The axonal growth cones ended superficially and never penetrated deeper layers of the retina. Treatment of the projection with BDNF resulted in massive terminal branching of the axons within deeper layers of the target retina. Double injection into the eye and the isthmo-optic nucleus showed a concomitant ingrowth of axons in the contralateral retina. Individual GCs died between E9 and E13, but massive apoptotic cell death was mainly monitored at E14 and later. Disintegrated cells showed typical images of apoptosis. Because degenerating cells were prelabeled with the membranophilic fluorescent carbocyanine dye, their death allowed the concomitant visualization of phagocytosing cells, too. Radial Müller glia were the only class of cells observed to become phagocytotic between E9 and E16. These cells became replaced exclusively with microglial cells from E17 on. The results suggest that the topologically restricted retino-retinal projection may have some developmental significance rather than representing a massive erroneous projection. Most likely, the projection may serve as a "template" to guide centrifugal isthmo-optic axons into the retina.

Expression of the axonal cell adhesion molecules axonin-1 and Ng-CAM during the development of the chick retinotectal system

Cell surface glycoproteins expressed on growth cones and axons during brain development have been postulated to be involved in the cell-cell interactions that guide axons into their target area. Nevertheless, an unequivocal description of the mechanism by which such molecules exert control over the pathway of a growing axon has not been done. As a crucial requirement in support of a relevant involvement of an axonal surface molecule in growth cone guidance, this molecule should be expressed in the growth cone. The developing retinotectal system provides an excellent opportunity to test whether a particular neuronal surface molecule fulfills the requirement of the spatiotemporal coincidence between its appearance and the emergence of growth cones because its setup follows the rule of chronotopy, i.e., the position of axons in a certain site is determined by the time of their arrival. We have analyzed axonin-1 and the neuron-glia cell adhesion molecule (Ng-CAM), two axonal surface molecules that promote neurite growth in vitro, for their expression in the retina and in the retinotectal system of the chick throughout its development. At stage 18, both axonin-like (A-LI) and Ng-CAM-like immunoreactivity (Ng-CAM-LI) are clearly present in the area where first retinal ganglion cells (RGCs) are generated. The immunoreactivity spreads synchronously with the formation of RGCs over the developing retina. From stage 32 on, the inner plexiform layer is also stained according to its temporospatial gradient of maturation. In later stages, the outer plexiform layer and the inner segments of photoreceptors also show immunoreactivity. The development of A-LI and Ng-CAM-LI along the optic nerve, chiasm, optic tract, and in the superficial layers of the optic tectum follows the chronotopic pattern of axons, as was found by earlier morphological investigations. Older axons loose their A-LI. This allows to localize the position of newly formed axons. The fact that A-LI and Ng-CAM-LI parallel the formation and maturation of axons suggests that axonin-1 and Ng-CAM may play an important role in the organization of the retinotectal system.