Human retrovirus-5 proviral DNA is rarely detected in salivary gland biopsy tissues from patients with Sjögren's syndrome

Role of Viral Infections in the Pathogenesis of Sjögren's Syndrome: Different Characteristics of Epstein-Barr Virus and HTLV-1

Viruses are possible pathogenic agents in several autoimmune diseases. Sjögren’s syndrome (SS), which involves exocrine dysfunction and the appearance of autoantibodies, shows salivary gland- and lacrimal gland-oriented clinical features. Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) is the most investigated pathogen as a candidate that directly induces the phenotype found in SS. The reactivation of the virus with various stimuli induced a dysregulated form of EBV that has the potential to infect SS-specific B cells and plasma cells that are closely associated with the function of an ectopic lymphoid structure that contains a germinal center (GC) in the salivary glands of individuals with SS. The involvement of human T-cell leukemia virus type 1 (HTLV-1) in SS has been epidemiologically established, but the disease concept of HTLV-1-associated SS remains unexplained due to limited evidence from basic research. Unlike the cell-to-cell contact between lymphocytes, biofilm-like structures are candidates as the mode of HTLV-1 infection of salivary gland epithelial cells (SGECs). HTLV-1 can infect SGECs with enhanced levels of inflammatory cytokines and chemokines that are secreted from SGECs. Regardless of the different targets that viruses have with respect to affinitive lymphocytes, viruses are involved in the formation of pathological alterations with immunological modifications in SS.

The biological significance of evolution in autoimmune phenomena

It is an inherent part of living to be in constant modification, which are due to answers resulting from environmental changes. The different systems make adaptations based on natural selection. With respect to the immune system of mammals, these changes have a lot to do with the interactions that occur continuously with other living species, especially microorganisms. The immune system is primarily designed to defend from germs and this response triggers inflammatory reactions which must be regulated in order not to generate damage to healthy tissue. The regulatory processes were added over time to prevent such damage. Through evolution the species have stored “an immunological experience,” which provides information that is important for developing effective responses in the future. The human species, which is at a high level of evolutionary immunological accumulation, have multiple immune defense strategies which, in turn, are highly regulated. Imbalances in these can result in autoimmunity.

“There is nothing permanent except change.”

(Heraclitus)

Is Sjögren's syndrome a retroviral disease?

Circumstantial evidence suggests that retroviruses play a role in the pathogenesis of Sjögren's syndrome. Such evidence, derived from studies of patients with Sjögren's syndrome, includes the following: the presence of serum antibodies cross-reactive with retroviral Gag proteins; the occurrence of reverse transcriptase activity in salivary glands; the detection of retroviral antigens, retrovirus-like particles, or novel retroviral sequences in salivary glands; the occurrence of Sjögren's syndrome-like illnesses in patients having confirmed systematic infections with retroviruses such as human immunodeficiency virus-1 (HIV-1) and human T lymphotropic virus type 1; and the beneficial effect of anti-retroviral treatment on the occurrence of HIV-1-associated sicca syndrome. Additional evidence is provided by animal models.

Human RNA "rumor" viruses: the search for novel human retroviruses in chronic disease

Retroviruses are an important group of pathogens that cause a variety of diseases in humans and animals. Four human retroviruses are currently known, including human immunodeficiency virus type 1, which causes AIDS, and human T-lymphotropic virus type 1, which causes cancer and inflammatory disease. For many years, there have been sporadic reports of additional human retroviral infections, particularly in cancer and other chronic diseases. Unfortunately, many of these putative viruses remain unproven and controversial, and some retrovirologists have dismissed them as merely "human rumor viruses." Work in this field was last reviewed in depth in 1984, and since then, the molecular techniques available for identifying and characterizing retroviruses have improved enormously in sensitivity. The advent of PCR in particular has dramatically enhanced our ability to detect novel viral sequences in human tissues. However, DNA amplification techniques have also increased the potential for false-positive detection due to contamination. In addition, the presence of many families of human endogenous retroviruses (HERVs) within our DNA can obstruct attempts to identify and validate novel human retroviruses. Here, we aim to bring together the data on "novel" retroviral infections in humans by critically examining the evidence for those putative viruses that have been linked with disease and the likelihood that they represent genuine human infections. We provide a background to the field and a discussion of potential confounding factors along with some technical guidelines. In addition, some of the difficulties associated with obtaining formal proof of causation for common or ubiquitous agents such as HERVs are discussed.

Persistent viral infection in primary Sjogren's syndrome: review and perspectives

Exocrine gland pathology in primary Sjogren's syndrome is characterized by destruction of acinar epithelial cells and chronic lymphocytic infiltrates surrounding ductal epithelial cells. These cells seem to be activated, as it is inferred by their immunophenotype. The cause of this activation and the chronic inflammatory response that targets epithelial cells remain unknown. Here, we will review the evidence pointing to a persistent viral infection as a probable cause of primary Sjogren's syndrome and discuss potential directions for future research.

Lack of detection of human retrovirus-5 proviral DNA in synovial tissue and blood specimens from individuals with rheumatoid arthritis or osteoarthritis

OBJECTIVE

Prior studies have suggested an association of human retrovirus 5 with rheumatoid arthritis. The purpose of this study was to determine if human retrovirus-5 proviral DNA is present in synovial tissue and blood specimens from patients with rheumatoid arthritis or osteoarthritis, or those without joint disease.

METHODS

Synovial tissue and whole blood from 75 patients with rheumatoid arthritis, 75 patients with osteoarthritis, and 50 patients without a primary arthritis diagnosis were assayed by real-time quantitative polymerase chain reaction (PCR) using primers that amplify a 186-bp fragment of human retrovirus-5 proviral DNA.

RESULTS

A total of 200 tissue specimens, 200 mononuclear cells, and 196 of 200 granulocyte specimens tested negative for human retrovirus-5 proviral DNA. No association between human retrovirus 5 and rheumatoid arthritis or osteoarthritis (P = 0.516) was identified. Granulocyte specimens from 4 patients, 2 with rheumatoid arthritis and 2 with osteoarthritis, yielded a low positive human retrovirus-5 proviral DNA signal (83-1,365 copies of human retrovirus-5 proviral DNA/ml blood).

CONCLUSION

Contrary to prior reports, we did not find an association between human retrovirus 5 and rheumatoid arthritis or osteoarthritis using a real-time PCR assay. Our findings are consistent with the recent finding that human retrovirus 5 is actually rabbit endogenous retrovirus H.

An update of the etiology and management of xerostomia

Salivary gland disease gives rise to salivary gland enlargement, pain, and prolonged xerostomia (dry mouth). Xerostomia is the most common long-standing problem for the majority of affected patients. There are many causes of dry mouth, with long-standing xerostomia being a particular problem in Sjögren's syndrome and after radiation to the head and neck region. Xerostomia is usually managed with saliva substitutes, but a large number of potential systemic therapies of long-standing xerostomia now exist. Some-particularly immunosuppressants-are of fundamental interest for the potential reduction of gland damage in Sjögren's syndrome but as yet are of limited clinical usefulness. Others, particularly pilocarpine and cevimeline, are, or have the potential to be, clinically useful in stimulating salivation by virtue of their action on cholinergic receptors.

Single-tube nested quantitative PCR: a rational and sensitive technique for detection of retroviral DNA. Application to RERV-H/HRV-5 and confirmation of its rabbit origin

It was reported earlier that a few patients suffering from non-Hodgkin's lymphoma had low amounts of DNA from the so-called fifth human exogenous retrovirus, HRV-5. A sensitive and rational method for large-scale screening for HRV-5 DNA was therefore developed. It is a single-tube nested quantitative PCR (stnQPCR), which uses two functionally isolated primer pairs and one probe target distinct from related endogenous retroviral sequences, yet encompassing known HRV-5 variation, allowing optimal use of sequence conservation. DNA from lymphoma, myeloma, and follicular dendritic cell lines was tested for HRV-5 positivity, as was DNA from whole blood of blood donors, non-Hodgkin's lymphoma and systemic lupus erythematosus patients, as well as DNA from lymph node biopsies of rheumatoid arthritis patients with lymphoma. One blood donor, one systemic lupus erythematosus patient, two previously known positive non-Hodgkin's lymphoma patients, and one rheumatoid arthritis lymphoma patient, came out positive. They had 24, 2, 148, 480 and 30 proviral copies per microg of DNA from PBMC or lymphoma tissue, respectively. During the completion of this work it was reported that HRV-5 is a rabbit endogenous retrovirus (RERV-H), and that HRV-5 positivity was due to presence of rabbit DNA. DNA from six RERV-H/HRV-5 positive samples was therefore retested. Three also contained rabbit mitochondrial DNA. A search for HRV-5 antibodies using synthetic peptides was negative in sera from three RERV-H/HRV-5 positive individuals, as well as in 144 other sera, according with a noninfectious origin of the RERV-H/HRV-5 DNA in human samples. A search for possible sources of rabbit DNA contamination was negative. Methods for prevention of PCR contamination were strictly adhered to. Three samples from RERV-H/HRV-5 positive individuals positive at the Uppsala laboratory were retested at one or two other laboratories, and all three were positive. Two other samples, which were positive in the Riga laboratory, were tested also in London and also found positive. One non-Hodgkin's lymphoma patient was RERV-H/HRV-5 positive in four consecutive samples, showing that positivity was a property of that patient. It is concluded that the stnQPCR developed to detect and quantify minute amounts of RERV-H/HRV-5 DNA is a principle which can be applied widely and HRV-5 is a RERV-H. Its presence in a few human blood samples could not be explained.

Role of endogenous retroviruses in autoimmune diseases

Endogenous retroviruses (ERVs) correspond to the integrated proviral form of infectious retroviruses that are trapped within the genome by mutations. Endogenous retroviruses represent a key molecular link between the host genome and infectious viral particles. Proteins encoded by ERVs are recognized by antiviral immune responses and become targets of autoreactivity. Activation of ERVs, such as human ERV-K or a human T-cell lymphotropic virus-related endogenous sequence, may also mediate pathogenicity of Epstein-Barr virus. Endogenous retrovirus peptides can directly regulate immune responses. Thus, molecular mimicry and immunomodulation by ERVs may account for self-reactivity and abnormal T- and B-cell functions in autoimmune disorders.

Novel endogenous retrovirus in rabbits previously reported as human retrovirus 5

Human retrovirus 5 (HRV-5) represented a fragment of a novel retrovirus sequence identified in human RNA and DNA preparations. In this study, the genome of HRV-5 was cloned and sequenced and integration sites were analyzed. Using PCR and Southern hybridization, we showed that HRV-5 is not integrated into human DNA. A survey of other species revealed that HRV-5 is present in the genomic DNA of the European rabbit (Oryctolagus cuniculus) and belongs to an endogenous retrovirus family found in rabbits. The presence of rabbit sequences flanking HRV-5 proviruses in human DNA extracts suggested that rabbit DNA was present in our human extracts, and this was confirmed by PCR analysis that revealed the presence of rabbit mitochondrial DNA sequences in four of five human DNA preparations tested. The origin of the rabbit DNA and HRV-5 in human DNA preparations remains unclear, but laboratory contamination cannot explain the preferential detection of HRV-5 in inflammatory diseases and lymphomas reported previously. This is the first description of a retrovirus genome in rabbits, and sequence analysis shows that it is related to but distinct from A-type retroelements of mice and other rodents. The species distribution of HRV-5 is restricted to rabbits; other species, including other members of the order Lagomorpha, do not contain this sequence. Analysis of HRV-5 expression by Northern hybridization and reverse transcriptase PCR indicates that the virus is transcribed at a low level in many rabbit tissues. In light of these findings we propose that the sequence previously designated HRV-5 should now be denoted RERV-H (for rabbit endogenous retrovirus H).

Role of viruses in systemic lupus erythematosus and Sjögren syndrome

Systemic lupus erythematosus and Sjögren syndrome remain elusive in the description of their underlying etiologic causes and pathogenic mechanisms. Although underlying genetic predisposition appears to contribute to both diseases based on twin and other genetic studies, additional factors must play a role. Over the decades additional factors, such as hormonal influence, UV light, environmental exposures (e.g., silica, solvents), and infectious agents have been postulated to play a role. Over the past few years additional information has been published concerning roles of various infectious agents in both lupus and Sjögren syndrome. Although the understanding of this field is still incomplete, significant advances are being made.

Human retrovirus type 5 sequences in non-Hodgkin's lymphoma of T cell origin

DNA of a recently described fifth exogenous retrovirus (HRV-5) has been found in blood samples from patients with autoimmune diseases and lymphoma. We analyzed HRV-5 sequence in DNA extracted from whole blood of 17 patients with T cell non-Hodgkin's lymphoma (NHL) and 186 patients with hematological malignancies other than NHL, using a sensitive PCR technique. While all samples of patients with hematological malignancies other than NHL were negative, 2 of the 17 patients with T cell NHL were HRV-5 DNA positive. Both HRV-5-positive patients had T cell NHL of high-grade malignancy (stage IV) and diffuse distribution of the lymphoma, including infiltration of bone marrow or lung and pleura. The difference in HRV-5 DNA detection frequency between NHL and control groups is significant (p value of 0.0004 judged by the Fisher exact test). These data, together with our previous finding of HRV-5 DNA in three B cell NHL cases, are compatible with an association between HRV-5 and NHL, of both T cell and B cell origin.

Multiple groups of novel retroviral genomes in pigs and related species

In view of the concern over potential infection hazards in the use of porcine tissues and organs for xenotransplantation to humans, we investigated the diversity of porcine endogenous retrovirus (PERV) genomes in the DNA of domestic pigs and related species. In addition to the three known envelope subgroups of infectious gamma retroviruses (PERV-A, -B, and -C), classed together here as PERV group gamma 1, four novel groups of gamma retrovirus (gamma 2 to gamma 5) and four novel groups of beta retrovirus (beta 1 to beta 4) genomes were detected in pig DNA using generic and specific PCR primers. PCR quantification indicated that the retroviral genome copy number in the Landrace x Duroc F(1) hybrid pig ranged from 2 (beta 2 and gamma 5) to approximately 50 (gamma 1). The gamma 1, gamma 2, and beta 4 genomes were transcribed into RNA in adult kidney tissue. Apart from gamma 1, the retroviral genomes are not known to be infectious, and sequencing of a small number of amplified genome fragments revealed stop codons in putative open reading frames in several cases. Analysis of DNA from wild boar and other species of Old World pigs (Suidae) and New World peccaries (Tayassuidae) showed that one retrovirus group, beta 2, was common to all species tested, while the others were present among all Old World species but absent from New World species. The PERV-C subgroup of gamma1 genomes segregated among domestic pigs and were absent from two African species (red river hog and warthog). Thus domestic swine and their phylogenetic relatives harbor multiple groups of hitherto undescribed PERV genomes.

Retroviruses and psoriasis

Psoriasis occurs with at least undiminished frequency in HIV infected individuals. The behaviour of psoriasis in HIV disease is of interest, both in terms of pathogenesis and therapy, because of the background of profound immunodysregulation. It is paradoxical that, while drugs that target T lymphocytes are effective in psoriasis, the condition should be exacerbated by HIV infection. Antiretroviral therapy may improve psoriasis in tandem with improvement in the overall clinical and virological condition of the patient. The aetiopathogenesis of psoriasis is unknown but genetic and environmental factors are thought to be involved. There are controversial issues regarding the immunological basis of psoriasis and the role of CD4+ versus CD8+ T lymphocytes. Current opinion favours an autoimmune basis for psoriasis, although the precipitating activating signal(s) within psoriatic plaques remains unknown. The immunodysregulation resulting from HIV infection may trigger psoriasis in those genetically predisposed by the Cw*0602 allele. Since CD8+ T cells recognize antigen in the context of class I molecules, the identification of a human leucocyte antigen class I association in HIV-associated psoriasis strengthens the argument for an important role for CD8+ T lymphocytes in the immunopathogenesis of psoriasis. HLA-Cw*0602 could act as a cross-reactive target for cytotoxic T lymphocytes responding to processed peptides from microorganisms. Human retrovirus-5 is a recently described, partially characterized retrovirus and has been implicated in the pathogenesis of psoriatic arthropathy but not psoriasis.

Human retrovirus 5 sequences in peripheral blood cells of patients with B-cell non-Hodgkin's lymphoma

A recently described sequence from a probable 5th human exogenous retrovirus, HRV-5, is related to type A, B and D retroviruses. It was initially detected in a salivary gland biopsy from a patient with Sjögren's syndrome, but it is not consistently associated with this disease. We searched for the HRV-5 sequence in DNA extracted from whole blood of 300 blood donors, 81 patients with hematological malignancy and 21 patients with neurological disease using PCR. While samples from none of the blood donors and the neurological patients became positive, 3 of the 81 patients with hematological malignancy were HRV-5 DNA positive. All 3 had B-cell non-Hodgkin's lymphoma of low grade. The difference in frequency between NHL and controls is statistically significant. HRV-5 DNA was found in DNA from whole blood and in plastic-adherent cells but not in tumor cell DNA. Thus, monocytes/macrophages may be preferred targets for HRV-5. Our result, together with a previous finding of HRV-5 DNA in 2 NHL cases, is compatible with an association between HRV-5 and NHL, whether causal or not.

Retroviruses: ancient and modern

Retroviruses are transmitted in two distinct ways: as infectious virions and as 'endogenous' proviral DNA integrated in the germ line of their hosts. Modern infectious viruses such as HIV recently infected mankind from simian hosts, whereas human endogenous retroviral genomes have been present throughout old world primate evolution. Recently we have characterised novel retroviruses in humans and pigs. Human retrovirus 5 (HRV-5) is detected as an exogenous genome in association with arthritis and systemic lupus erythematosus. Porcine endogenous retroviruses (PERV) are carried in swine DNA but can be activated to produce virions that are infectious for human cells, which has implications for xenotransplantation. A brief account of HRV-5 and PERV is given here.

The pathogenic potential of endogenous retroviruses: facts and fantasies

Endogenous retroviruses are descendants of viruses that became cellular genes by integration into their host's genome. They still contribute to pathogenicity as a partner in recombination events, by de novo insertion after mobilization followed by activation of downstream proto-oncogenes, or by gene disruption. Re-expression of viral proteins accompanied by loss of immune tolerance could induce immune disturbances.

Current issues in the diagnosis and treatment of Sjögren's syndrome

Modification of the European Cooperative Group (EEC) criteria for Sjögren's Syndrome (SS) should lead to less confusion in diagnosis and therapeutic trials. The proposed EEC modification will require either a positive minor salivary gland biopsy or a positive autoantibody against Sjögren's-associated A (Ro) or B (La) antigen. This modification will decrease the proportion of women fulfilling EEC criteria from 3-5% to about 0.5%, which is similar to San Diego and San Francisco criteria. Genetic studies have shown increased frequency of alleles for peptide transporter genes TAP1 (0101) and TAP2 (0101) genes as well as tumor necrosis factor microsatellite a2 alleles. Although these markers confer markedly increased risk, they are found in only a small proportion of patients. An increased frequency of drug (antibiotic) allergy and other allergic manifestations appears present in patients with SS and may be linked to HLA-DR3. Hepatitis C as a cause of sicca symptoms, positive anti-nuclear autoantibodies, and mixed cryoglobulinemia is increasingly reported in different parts of the world. Antibodies against muscarinic M3 receptor and expression of costimulatory molecules (CD80 and CD86) by ductal epithelial cells may play a role in pathogenesis. Treatment with pilocarpine is effective in double-blind trials and low dose oral alpha interferon looks promising in initial open studies. In pregnant patients who exhibit evidence of neonatal heart block, treatment with dexamethasone is preferred over prednisone, since the placenta is unable to metabolically activate the latter compound.

Human retrovirus-5 in rheumatic disease

It has long been suggested that retroviral infection may play a role in the pathogenesis of autoimmune rheumatic disease. Particles resembling retroviruses have been reported in tissue from patients with Sjögren's syndrome, lupus and rheumatoid arthritis, and molecular mimicry between retroviral antigens and host proteins has been proposed as a mechanism of induction of autoimmunity. Since 1980, four distinct human infectious retroviruses have been discovered, HTLV-I, HTLV-II, HIV-1 and HIV-2. We recently cloned part of a new human retrovirus genome, designated human retrovirus-5 (HRV-5) and demonstrated that this is not endogenous and is therefore a novel infectious retrovirus. Because symptoms resembling arthritis, polymyositis and Sjögren's syndrome occur in individuals infected with HTLV-I and HIV-1, we investigated the possibility that HRV-5 was associated with idiopathic rheumatic disease. Using nested PCR, HRV-5 we demonstrated that proviral DNA was present in approximately 50% of synovial samples of arthritic joints and was also found in over 10% of blood samples of patients with rheumatoid arthritis and systemic lupus erythematosus. HRV-5 proviral DNA was not detectable in affected tissues of autoimmune diseases and was found in only one of over 200 tissues taken at autopsy from non-rheumatoid patients. Sequence analysis of the amplified viral segment showed genetic variation between samples with maintenance of the open reading frame typical of a replicating infectious retrovirus. Thus HRV-5 appears to be a human retrovirus found with a very low genome copy number in most tissues, but which is increased to detectable levels in inflamed joints and blood from patients with rheumatic disease. Whether HRV-5 is aetiologically important in these diseases remains to be determined.

Viral induction, transmission and apoptosis among cells infected by a Human Intracisternal A-type retrovirus

Sjogren's Syndrome, a systemic autoimmune disease, is characterized by lymphocytic infiltration of the salivary or lacrimal glands, producing xerostomia or xerophthalmia. Although definitive proof of viral etiology has not been established, a cell line containing viral particles termed Human Intracisternal A-type Particles (HIAP) resulted from co-culture with patient lip biopsies. We stimulated these chronically infected cells with phorbol myristate acetate (PMA) in an effort to enhance production of viral particles for further characterization. We report that the virus present in the HIAP cell line can be induced to become lytic when subjected to PMA and that there is a difference in the effects of PMA on H9 and HIAP cell groups, with apparent protection from apoptosis due to PMA being exerted by viral presence. Delayed apoptosis may prolong exposure of the foreign/self complex, thus enhancing an autoimmune response. Polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) revealed the presence of new peptides in pellets of supernatants of PMA-stimulated HIAP cells, with prominent bands at 55 and 43 kDa, and several fainter ones. HIAP infection was transferred by cell-free filtered supernatants from stimulated cells to H9 cells, which became identical to parent HIAP cells by PAGE and fluorescence activated cell sorter.

Human retroviral sequences associated with extracellular particles in autoimmune diseases: epiphenomenon or possible role in aetiopathogenesis?

Publications describing retroviral sequences associated with extracellular particles in Sjögren's syndrome or systemic lupus erythematosus, multiple sclerosis, and type I diabetes present novel arguments and raise complex questions about eventual relationships between retroviruses and autoimmunity. They are presented and discussed in the present review, preceded by an overview of the biology of retroviral elements.

Detection of human retrovirus 5 in patients with arthritis and systemic lupus erythematosus

OBJECTIVE

To examine whether human retrovirus 5 (HRV-5) infection is associated with autoimmune rheumatic disease.

METHODS

DNA from patients with various disorders including inflammatory diseases and from normal subjects was tested by nested polymerase chain reaction (PCR) for HRV-5 proviral DNA. Positive results were confirmed by DNA sequencing.

RESULTS

HRV-5 proviral DNA was detected in 53% of synovial samples from arthritic joints, in 12% of blood samples from patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA), and in 16% of blood samples from patients with systemic lupus erythematosus. In contrast, it was not detectable by PCR of affected tissues from patients with several other autoimmune diseases and was found in only 1 of >200 tissue specimens obtained at autopsy from non-RA patients. Sequence analysis of the amplified viral segment showed genetic variation between samples with maintenance of the open reading frame, typical of a replicating infectious retrovirus.

CONCLUSION

This is the first report of the frequent detection of HRV-5 in any disease. We propose that the possible involvement of HRV-5 in autoimmune and rheumatic disease should be investigated further.