Chemical Properties Determine Solubility and Stability in βγ-Crystallins of the Eye Lens

Association of Alpha-Crystallin with Human Cortical and Nuclear Lens Lipid Membrane Increases with the Grade of Cortical and Nuclear Cataract

Eye lens α-crystallin has been shown to become increasingly membrane-bound with age and cataract formation; however, to our knowledge, no studies have investigated the membrane interactions of α-crystallin throughout the development of cataracts in separated cortical membrane (CM) and nuclear membrane (NM) from single human lenses. In this study, four pairs of human lenses from age-matched male and female donors and one pair of male lenses ranging in age from 64 to 73 years old (yo) were obtained to investigate the interactions of α-crystallin with the NM and CM throughout the progression of cortical cataract (CC) and nuclear cataract (NC) using the electron paramagnetic resonance spin-labeling method. Donor health history information (diabetes, smoker, hypertension, radiation treatment), sex, and race were included in the data analysis. The right eye lenses CM and NM investigated were 64 yo male (CC: 0), 68 yo male (CC: 3, NC: 2), 73 yo male (CC: 1, NC: 2), 68 yo female (CC: 3, NC: 2), and 73 yo female (CC: 1, NC: 3). Similarly, left eye lenses CM and NM investigated were 64 yo male (CC: 0), 68 yo male (CC: 3, NC: 2), 73 yo male (CC: 2, NC: 3), 68 yo female (CC: 3, NC: 2), and 73 yo female (CC: 1, NC: 3). Analysis of α-crystallin binding to male and female eye lens CM and NM revealed that the percentage of membrane surface occupied (MSO) by α-crystallin increases with increasing grade of CC and NC. The binding of α-crystallin resulted in decreased mobility, increased order, and increased hydrophobicity on the membrane surface in male and female eye lens CM and NM. CM mobility decreased with an increase in cataracts for both males and females, whereas the male lens NM mobility showed no significant change, while female lens NM showed increased mobility with an increase in cataract grade. Our data shows that a 68 yo female donor (long-term smoker, pre-diabetic, and hypertension; grade 3 CC) showed the largest MSO by α-crystallin in CM from both the left and right lens and had the most pronounced mobility changes relative to all other analyzed samples. The variation in cholesterol (Chol) content, size and amount of cholesterol bilayer domains (CBDs), and lipid composition in the CM and NM with age and cataract might result in a variation of membrane surface mobility, membrane surface hydrophobicity, and the interactions of α-crystallin at the surface of each CM and NM. These findings provide insight into the effect of decreased Chol content and the reduced size and amount of CBDs in the cataractous CM and NM with an increased binding of α-crystallin with increased CC and NC grade, which suggests that Chol and CBDs might be a key component in maintaining lens transparency.

Cataract-causing mutations S78F and S78P of γD-crystallin decrease protein conformational stability and drive aggregation

Congenital cataract is the leading cause of childhood blindness, which primarily results from genetic factors. γD-crystallin is the most abundant γ-crystallin and is essential for maintaining lens transparency and refractivity. Numerous mutations in γD-crystallin have been reported with unclear pathogenic mechanism. Two different cataract-causing mutations Ser78Phe and Ser78Pro in γD-crystallin were previously identified at the same conserved Ser78 residue. In this work, firstly, we purified the mutants and characterized for the structural change using fluorescence spectroscopy, circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy, and size-exclusion chromatography (SEC). Both mutants were prone to form insoluble precipitates when expressed in Escherichia coli strain BL21 (DE3) cells. Compared with wild-type (WT), both mutations caused structural disruption, increased hydrophobic exposure, decreased solubility, and reduced thermal stability. Next, we investigated the aggregation of the mutants at the cellular level. Overexpression the mutants in HLE-B3 and HEK 293T cells could induce aggresome formations. The environmental stresses (including heat, ultraviolet irradiation and oxidative stress) promoted the formation of aggregates. Moreover, the intracellular S78F and S78P aggregates could be reversed by lanosterol. Molecular dynamic simulation indicated that both mutations disrupted the structural integrity of Greek-key motif 2. Hence, our results reveal the vital role of conserved Ser78 in maintaining the structural stability, which can offer new insights into the mechanism of cataract formation.

Eye lens β-crystallins are predicted by native ion mobility-mass spectrometry and computations to form compact higher-ordered heterooligomers

Eye lens α- and β-/γ-crystallin proteins are not replaced after fiber cell denucleation and maintain lens transparency and refractive properties. The exceptionally high (∼400-500 mg/mL) concentration of crystallins in mature lens tissue and multiple other factors impede precise characterization of β-crystallin interactions, oligomer composition, size, and topology. Native ion mobility-mass spectrometry is used here to probe β-crystallin association and provide insight into homo- and heterooligomerization kinetics for these proteins. These experiments include separation and characterization of higher-order β-crystallin oligomers and illustrate the unique advantages of native IM-MS. Recombinantly expressed βB1, βB2, and βA3 isoforms are found to have different homodimerization propensities, and only βA3 forms larger homooligomers. Heterodimerization of βB2 with βA3 occurs ∼3 times as fast as that of βB1 with βA3, and βB1 and βB2 heterodimerize less readily. Ion mobility experiments, molecular dynamics simulations, and PISA analysis together reveal that observed oligomers are consistent with predominantly compact, ring-like topologies.

Binding of βL-Crystallin with Models of Animal and Human Eye Lens-Lipid Membrane

Several discoveries show that with age and cataract formation, β-crystallin binds with the lens membrane or associates with other lens proteins, which bind with the fiber cell plasma membrane, accompanied by light scattering and cataract formation. However, how lipids (phospholipids and sphingolipids) and cholesterol (Chol) influence β-crystallin binding to the membrane is unclear. This research aims to elucidate the role of lipids and Chol in the binding of β-crystallin to the membrane and the membrane's physical properties (mobility, order, and hydrophobicity) with β-crystallin binding. We used electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spin-labeling methods to investigate the binding of βL-crystallin with a model of porcine lens-lipid (MPLL), model of mouse lens-lipid (MMLL), and model of human lens-lipid (MHLL) membrane with and without Chol. Our results show that βL-crystallin binds with all of the investigated membranes in a saturation manner, and the maximum parentage of the membrane surface occupied (MMSO) by βL-crystallin and the binding affinity (Ka) of βL-crystallin to the membranes followed trends: MMSO (MPLL) > MMSO (MMLL) > MMSO (MHLL) and Ka (MHLL) > Ka (MMLL) ≈ Ka (MPLL), respectively, in which the presence of Chol reduces the MMSO and Ka for all membranes. The mobility near the headgroup regions of the membranes decreases with an increase in the binding of βL-crystallin; however, the decrease is more pronounced in the MPLL and MMLL membranes than the MHLL membrane. In the MPLL and MMLL membranes, the membranes become slightly ordered near the headgroup with an increase in βL-crystallin binding compared to the MHLL membrane. The hydrophobicity near the headgroup region of the membrane increases with βL-crystallin binding; however, the increase is more pronounced in the MPLL and MMLL membranes than the MHLL membrane, indicating that βL-crystallin binding creates a hydrophobic barrier for the passage of polar molecules, which supports the barrier hypothesis in cataract formation. However, in the presence of Chol, there is no significant increase in hydrophobicity with βL-crystallin binding, suggesting that Chol prevents the formation of a hydrophobic barrier, possibly protecting against cataract formation.

The Y46D Mutation Destabilizes Dense Packing of the Second Greek Key Pair of Human γC-Crystallin Causing Congenital Nuclear Cataracts

The γ-crystallins are highly expressed structural lens proteins comprising four Greek key motifs arranged in two domains. Their globular structure and short-range spatial ordering are essential for lens transparency. Aromatic residues play a vital role in stabilizing Greek key folds by forming Greek key or non-Greek key pairs or tyrosine corners. We investigated the effects of the cataractogenic Y46D mutation in the second Greek key pair (Y46-Y51) of human γC-crystallin on its stability and aggregation. Wild-type and Y46D mutant human γC-crystallin were overexpressed in E. coli BL-21(DE3) PLysS cells, purified using ion-exchange and size-exclusion chromatography, and analyzed by fluorescence spectroscopy and circular dichroism spectroscopy. The Y46D mutation does not affect the γC-crystallin backbone conformation under benign conditions but alters the tryptophan microenvironment, exposing hydrophobic residues to the surface. The Y46D mutant undergoes a three-state transition under thermal stress with midpoints of 54.6 and 67.7 °C while the wild type shows a two-state transition with a midpoint of 77.6 °C. The Y46D mutant also shows a three-state transition under GuHCl stress with Cm values of 0.9 and 2.1 M while the wild type shows a two-state transition with a Cm of 2.4 M GuHCl. Mutant but not wild-type γC-crystallin forms light scattering particles upon heating at 65 °C. Overall, the Y46D CRYGS mutation leaves the protein fold intact under benign conditions but destabilizes the molecule by altering the tryptophan microenvironment and exposing hydrophobic residues to its surface, thus increasing its susceptibility to thermal and chemical stress with resultant self-aggregation, light scattering, and cataract.

Insights into the solubility of γ $$ \gamma $$ D-crystallin from multiscale atomistic simulations

The molecular basis underlying the rich phase behavior of globular proteins remains poorly understood. We use atomistic multiscale molecular simulations to model the solution-state conformational dynamics and interprotein interactions of γ $$ \gamma $$ D-crystallin and its P23T-R36S mutant, which drastically limits the protein solubility, at both infinite dilution and at a concentration where the mutant fluid phase and crystalline phase coexist. We find that while the mutant conserves the protein fold, changes to the surface exposure of residues in the neighborhood of residue-36 enhance protein-protein interactions and develop specific protein-protein contacts found in the protein crystal lattice.

Copper Reductase Activity and Free Radical Chemistry by Cataract-Associated Human Lens γ-Crystallins

Cataracts are caused by high-molecular-weight aggregates of human eye lens proteins that scatter light, causing lens opacity. Metal ions have emerged as important potential players in the etiology of cataract disease, as human lens γ-crystallins are susceptible to metal-induced aggregation. Here, the interaction of Cu²⁺ ions with γD-, γC-, and γS-crystallins, the three most abundant γ-crystallins in the lens, has been evaluated. Cu²⁺ ions induced non-amyloid aggregation in all three proteins. Solution turbidimetry, sodium dodecyl sulfate poly(acrylamide) gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE), circular dichroism, and differential scanning calorimetry showed that the mechanism for Cu-induced aggregation involves: (i) loss of β-sheet structure in the N-terminal domain; (ii) decreased thermal and kinetic stability; (iii) formation of metal-bridged species; and (iv) formation of disulfide-bridged dimers. Isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) revealed distinct Cu²⁺ binding affinities in the γ-crystallins. Electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) revealed two distinct Cu²⁺ binding sites in each protein. Spin quantitation demonstrated the reduction of γ-crystallin-bound Cu²⁺ ions to Cu⁺ under aerobic conditions, while X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS) confirmed the presence of linear or trigonal Cu⁺ binding sites in γ-crystallins. Our EPR and XAS studies revealed that γ-crystallins' Cu²⁺ reductase activity yields a protein-based free radical that is likely a Tyr-based species in human γD-crystallin. This unique free radical chemistry carried out by distinct redox-active Cu sites in human lens γ-crystallins likely contributes to the mechanism of copper-induced aggregation. In the context of an aging human lens, γ-crystallins could act not only as structural proteins but also as key players for metal and redox homeostasis.

Insights into the biochemical and biophysical mechanisms mediating the longevity of the transparent optics of the eye lens

In the human eye, a transparent cornea and lens combine to form the "refracton" to focus images on the retina. This requires the refracton to have a high refractive index "n," mediated largely by extracellular collagen fibrils in the corneal stroma and the highly concentrated crystallin proteins in the cytoplasm of the lens fiber cells. Transparency is a result of short-range order in the spatial arrangement of corneal collagen fibrils and lens crystallins, generated in part by post-translational modifications (PTMs). However, while corneal collagen is remodeled continuously and replaced, lens crystallins are very long-lived and are not replaced and so accumulate PTMs over a lifetime. Eventually, a tipping point is reached when protein aggregation results in increased light scatter, inevitably leading to the iconic protein condensation-based disease, age-related cataract (ARC). Cataracts account for 50% of vision impairment worldwide, affecting far more people than other well-known protein aggregation-based diseases. However, because accumulation of crystallin PTMs begins before birth and long before ARC presents, we postulate that the lens protein PTMs contribute to a "cataractogenic load" that not only increases with age but also has protective effects on optical function by stabilizing lens crystallins until a tipping point is reached. In this review, we highlight decades of experimental findings that support the potential for PTMs to be protective during normal development. We hypothesize that ARC is preventable by protecting the biochemical and biophysical properties of lens proteins needed to maintain transparency, refraction, and optical function.

Binding of Alpha-Crystallin to Cortical and Nuclear Lens Lipid Membranes Derived from a Single Lens

Several studies reported that α-crystallin concentrations in the eye lens cytoplasm decrease with a corresponding increase in membrane-bound α-crystallin with age and cataracts. The influence of the lipid and cholesterol composition difference between cortical membrane (CM) and nuclear membrane (NM) on α-crystallin binding to membranes is still unclear. This study uses the electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spin-labeling method to investigate the α-crystallin binding to bovine CM and NM derived from the total lipids extracted from a single lens. Compared to CMs, NMs have a higher percentage of membrane surface occupied by α-crystallin and binding affinity, correlating with less mobility and more order below and on the surface of NMs. α-Crystallin binding to CM and NM decreases mobility with no significant change in order and hydrophobicity below and on the surface of membranes. Our results suggest that α-crystallin mainly binds on the surface of bovine CM and NM and such surface binding of α-crystallin to membranes in clear and young lenses may play a beneficial role in membrane stability. However, with decreased cholesterol content within the CM, which mimics the decreased cholesterol content in the cataractous lens membrane, α-crystallin binding increases the hydrophobicity below the membrane surface, indicating that α-crystallin binding forms a hydrophobic barrier for the passage of polar molecules, supporting the barrier hypothesis in developing cataracts.

α-Crystallin chaperone mimetic drugs inhibit lens γ-crystallin aggregation: potential role for cataract prevention

Γ-Crystallins play a major role in age-related lens transparency. Their destabilization by mutations and physical chemical insults are associated with cataract formation. Therefore, drugs that increase their stability should have anticataract properties. To this end, we screened 2560 Federal Drug Agency–approved drugs and natural compounds for their ability to suppress or worsen H₂O₂ and/or heat-mediated aggregation of bovine γ-crystallins. The top two drugs, closantel (C), an antihelminthic drug, and gambogic acid (G), a xanthonoid, attenuated thermal-induced protein unfolding and aggregation as shown by turbidimetry fluorescence spectroscopy dynamic light scattering and electron microscopy of human or mouse recombinant crystallins. Furthermore, binding studies using fluorescence inhibition and hydrophobic pocket–binding molecule bis-8-anilino-1-naphthalene sulfonic acid revealed static binding of C and G to hydrophobic sites with medium-to-low affinity. Molecular docking to HγD and other γ-crystallins revealed two binding sites, one in the “NC pocket” (residues 50–150) of HγD and one spanning the “NC tail” (residues 56–61 to 168–174 in the C-terminal domain). Multiple binding sites overlap with those of the protective mini αA-crystallin chaperone MAC peptide. Mechanistic studies using bis-8-anilino-1-naphthalene sulfonic acid as a proxy drug showed that it bound to MAC sites, improved T_m of both H₂O₂ oxidized and native human gamma D, and suppressed turbidity of oxidized HγD, most likely by trapping exposed hydrophobic sites. The extent to which these drugs act as α-crystallin mimetics and reduce cataract progression remains to be demonstrated. This study provides initial insights into binding properties of C and G to γ-crystallins.

Zinc and Copper Ions Induce Aggregation of Human β-Crystallins

Cataracts are defined as the clouding of the lens due to the formation of insoluble protein aggregates. Metal ions exposure has been recognized as a risk factor in the cataract formation process. The γ and β crystallins are members of a larger family and share several structural features. Several studies have shown that copper and zinc ions induce the formation of γ-crystallins aggregates. However, the interaction of metal ions with β-crystallins, some of the most abundant crystallins in the lens, has not been explored until now. Here, we evaluate the effect of Cu(II) and Zn(II) ions on the aggregation of HβA1, as a representative of the acidic form, and HβB2, as a representative of the basic β-crystallins. We used several biophysical techniques and computational methods to show that Cu(II) and Zn(II) induce aggregation following different pathways. Both metal ions destabilize the proteins and impact protein folding. Copper induced a small conformational change in HβA1, leading to high-molecular-weight light-scattering aggregates, while zinc is more aggressive towards HβB2 and induces a larger conformational change. Our work provides information on the mechanisms of metal-induced aggregation of β-crystallins.

Acquired disorder and asymmetry in a domain-swapped model for γ-crystallin aggregation

Misfolding and aggregation of proteins occur in many pathological states. Because of the inherent disorder involved, these processes are difficult to study. We attempted to capture aggregation intermediates of γ S-crystallin, a highly stable, internally symmetrical monomeric protein, by crystallization under mildly acidic and oxidizing conditions. Here we describe novel oligomerization through strained domain-swapping and partial intermolecular disulfide formation. This forms an octamer built from asymmetric tetramers, each of which comprises an asymmetric pair of twisted, domain-swapped dimers. Each tetramer shows patterns of acquired disorder among subunits, ranging from local loss of secondary structure to regions of intrinsic disorder. The octamer ring is tied together by partial intermolecular disulfide bonds, which may contribute to strain and disorder in the octamer. Oligomerization in this structure is self-limited by the distorted octamer ring. In a more heterogeneous environment, the disordered regions could serve as seeds for cascading interactions with other proteins. Indeed, solubilized protein from crystals retain many features observed in the crystal and are prone to further oligomerization and precipitation. This structure illustrates modes of loss of organized structure and aggregation that are relevant for cataract and for other disorders involving deposition of formerly well-folded proteins.

Deamidation of the human eye lens protein γS-crystallin accelerates oxidative aging

Cataract, a clouding of the eye lens from protein precipitation, affects millions of people every year. The lens proteins, the crystallins, show extensive post-translational modifications (PTMs) in cataractous lenses. The most common PTMs, deamidation and oxidation, promote crystallin aggregation; however, it is not clear precisely how these PTMs contribute to crystallin insolubilization. Here, we report six crystal structures of the lens protein γS-crystallin (γS): one of the wild-type and five of deamidated γS variants, from three to nine deamidation sites, after sample aging. The deamidation mutations do not change the overall fold of γS; however, increasing deamidation leads to accelerated disulfide-bond formation. Addition of deamidated sites progressively destabilized protein structure, and the deamidated variants display an increased propensity for aggregation. These results suggest that the deamidated variants are useful as models for accelerated aging; the structural changes observed provide support for redox activity of γS-crystallin in the lens.

Pathogenic mechanism of congenital cataract caused by the CRYBA1/A3-G91del variant and related intervention strategies

Congenital cataracts, which are genetically heterogeneous eye disorders, lead to visual impairment in childhood. In our previous study, we identified a novel mutation in exon 4 of the CRYBA1/BA3 gene, which resulted in the deletion of a highly conserved glycine at codon 91 (G91del) and perinuclear zonular cataract. The G91del variant is one of the most frequent pathogenic mutations in CRYBA1/BA3; however, its pathogenic mechanism remains unclear. In this study, we purified βA3-crystallin and the βA3-G91del variant. βA3-G91del was prone to proteolysis and exhibited very low solubility and low structural stability. Next, we constructed a CRYBA1/BA3 mutant cell model and observed that G91del mutant proteins were more sensitive to environmental stress and prone to form aggregates. Size-exclusion chromatography and molecular dynamics simulation showed that the G91del mutation impaired the ability of βA3 to form homo-oligomers. In addition, the protein folding process of βA3-G91del was complicated and showed more intermediate states, resulting in amyloid fiber aggregation and induction of cellular apoptosis. Finally, we investigated intervention strategies for congenital cataract caused by the CRYBA1/A3-G91del variant. The addition of lanosterol reversed the negative effects of the G91del mutation under external stress. This study may help explore potential treatment strategies for related cataracts.

Heat treatment of soluble proteins isolated from human cataract lens leads to the formation of non-fibrillar amyloid-like protein aggregates

The loss of crystallins solubility with aging and the formation of amyloid-like aggregates is considered the hallmark characteristic of cataract pathology. The present study was carried out to assess the effect of temperature on the soluble lens protein and the formation of protein aggregates with typical amyloid characteristics. The soluble fraction of lens proteins was subjected for heat treatment in the range of 40-60 °C, and the nature of protein aggregates was assessed by using Congo red (CR), thioflavin T (ThT), and 8-anilinonaphthalene-1-sulfonic acid (ANS) binding assays, circular dichroism (CD), Fourier-transform infrared (FT-IR) spectroscopy, and transmission electron microscopy (TEM). The heat-treated protein samples displayed a substantial bathochromic shift (≈15 nm) in the CR's absorption maximum (λ_max) and increased ThT and ANS binding. The heat treatment of lens soluble proteins results in the formation of nontoxic, β-sheet rich, non-fibrillar, protein aggregates similar to the structures evident in the insoluble fraction of proteins isolated from the cataractous lens. The data obtained from the present study suggest that the exposure of soluble lens proteins to elevated temperature leads to the formation of non-fibrillar aggregates, establishing the role of amyloid in the heat-induced augmentation of cataracts pathology.

Association of Alpha-Crystallin with Fiber Cell Plasma Membrane of the Eye Lens Accompanied by Light Scattering and Cataract Formation

α-crystallin is a major protein found in the mammalian eye lens that works as a molecular chaperone by preventing the aggregation of proteins and providing tolerance to stress in the eye lens. These functions of α-crystallin are significant for maintaining lens transparency. However, with age and cataract formation, the concentration of α-crystallin in the eye lens cytoplasm decreases with a corresponding increase in the membrane-bound α-crystallin, accompanied by increased light scattering. The purpose of this review is to summarize previous and recent findings of the role of the: (1) lens membrane components, i.e., the major phospholipids (PLs) and sphingolipids, cholesterol (Chol), cholesterol bilayer domains (CBDs), and the integral membrane proteins aquaporin-0 (AQP0; formally MIP26) and connexins, and (2) α-crystallin mutations and post-translational modifications (PTMs) in the association of α-crystallin to the eye lens's fiber cell plasma membrane, providing thorough insights into a molecular basis of such an association. Furthermore, this review highlights the current knowledge and need for further studies to understand the fundamental molecular processes involved in the association of α-crystallin to the lens membrane, potentially leading to new avenues for preventing cataract formation and progression.