Electrosynthesis of Biomimetic Manganese-Calcium Oxides for Water Oxidation Catalysis--Atomic Structure and Functionality

From manganese oxidation to water oxidation: assembly and evolution of the water-splitting complex in photosystem II

The manganese cluster of photosystem II has been the focus of intense research aiming to understand the mechanism of H₂O-oxidation. Great effort has also been applied to investigating its oxidative photoassembly process, termed photoactivation that involves the light-driven incorporation of metal ions into the active Mn₄CaO₅ cluster. The knowledge gained on these topics has fundamental scientific significance, but may also provide the blueprints for the development of biomimetic devices capable of splitting water for solar energy applications. Accordingly, synthetic chemical approaches inspired by the native Mn cluster are actively being explored, for which the native catalyst is a useful benchmark. For both the natural and artificial catalysts, the assembly process of incorporating Mn ions into catalytically active Mn oxide complexes is an oxidative process. In both cases this process appears to share certain chemical features, such as producing an optimal fraction of open coordination sites on the metals to facilitate the binding of substrate water, as well as the involvement of alkali metals (e.g., Ca²⁺) to facilitate assembly and activate water-splitting catalysis. This review discusses the structure and formation of the metal cluster of the PSII H₂O-oxidizing complex in the context of what is known about the formation and chemical properties of different Mn oxides. Additionally, the evolutionary origin of the Mn₄CaO₅ is considered in light of hypotheses that soluble Mn²⁺ was an ancient source of reductant for some early photosynthetic reaction centers ('photomanganotrophy'), and recent evidence that PSII can form Mn oxides with structural resemblance to the geologically abundant birnessite class of minerals. A new functional role for Ca²⁺ to facilitate sustained Mn²⁺ oxidation during photomanganotrophy is proposed, which may explain proposed physiological intermediates during the likely evolutionary transition from anoxygenic to oxygenic photosynthesis.

Early-stage formation of (hydr)oxo bridges in transition-metal catalysts for photosynthetic processes

Ab initio simulations have been used to assess reaction pathways for the formation of M–(hydr)oxo–M (M = Co, Mn, Ni) bridges from M(ii) aqueous solutions, as early-stage building blocks of transition-metal catalysts for oxygen evolution.

Light-driven formation of manganese oxide by today's photosystem II supports evolutionarily ancient manganese-oxidizing photosynthesis

Water oxidation and concomitant dioxygen formation by the manganese-calcium cluster of oxygenic photosynthesis has shaped the biosphere, atmosphere, and geosphere. It has been hypothesized that at an early stage of evolution, before photosynthetic water oxidation became prominent, light-driven formation of manganese oxides from dissolved Mn(2+) ions may have played a key role in bioenergetics and possibly facilitated early geological manganese deposits. Here we report the biochemical evidence for the ability of photosystems to form extended manganese oxide particles. The photochemical redox processes in spinach photosystem-II particles devoid of the manganese-calcium cluster are tracked by visible-light and X-ray spectroscopy. Oxidation of dissolved manganese ions results in high-valent Mn(III,IV)-oxide nanoparticles of the birnessite type bound to photosystem II, with 50-100 manganese ions per photosystem. Having shown that even today’s photosystem II can form birnessite-type oxide particles efficiently, we propose an evolutionary scenario, which involves manganese-oxide production by ancestral photosystems, later followed by down-sizing of protein-bound manganese-oxide nanoparticles to finally yield today’s catalyst of photosynthetic water oxidation.

Photosynthetic formation of manganese (Mn) oxides from dissolved Mn ions was proposed to occur in ancestral photosystems before oxygenic photosynthesis evolved. Here, the authors provide evidence for this hypothesis by showing that photosystem II devoid of the Mn cluster oxidises Mn ions leading to formation of Mn-oxide nanoparticles.

The Determination of Electrochemical Active Surface Area and Specific Capacity Revisited for the System MnOx as an Oxygen Evolution Catalyst

In the last decades several different catalysts for the electrochemical water splitting reaction have been designed and tested. In so-called benchmark papers they are compared with respect to their efficiency and activity. In order to relate the different catalyst to each other the definition of well-defined procedures is required. Two different methods are mainly used: Either the normalization with respect to the geometric surface area or to the catalyst loading. Most often only one of these values is available for a sample and the other one cannot be estimated easily. One approach in electrocatalysis is to determine the Helmholtz double layer capacitance (DLC) and deduce the electrochemical active surface area (ECSA). The DLC can be obtained from two different methods, either using differential capacitance measurement (DCM) or impedance spectroscopy (EIS). The second value needed for the calculation of the ECSA is the specific capacitance, which is the capacitance for a perfectly flat surface of given catalyst material. Here, we present the determination of the different capacitance values using manganese oxide as the exemplary model for the oxygen evolution reaction (OER). We determine the capacitance by DCM and EIS to calculate the ECSA using literature values for the specific capacitance. The obtained values are comparable from the two methods, but are much larger than the surface areas obtained by atomic force microscopy. Therefore, we consider the possibility of using the measured AFM area together with the Helmholtz capacitance to determine the specific capacitances for this material class. The comparison of these results with literature values illustrates the actual limits of the ECSA method, which will be discussed in this paper.

Water-Oxidation Electrocatalysis by Manganese Oxides: Syntheses, Electrode Preparations, Electrolytes and Two Fundamental Questions

The efficient catalysis of the four-electron oxidation of water to molecular oxygen is a central challenge for the development of devices for the production of solar fuels. This is equally true for artificial leaf-type structures and electrolyzer systems. Inspired by the oxygen evolving complex of Photosystem II, the biological catalyst for this reaction, scientists around the globe have investigated the possibility to use manganese oxides (“MnOx”) for this task. This perspective article will look at selected examples from the last about 10 years of research in this field. At first, three aspects are addressed in detail which have emerged as crucial for the development of efficient electrocatalysts for the anodic oxygen evolution reaction (OER): (1) the structure and composition of the “MnOx” is of central importance for catalytic performance and it seems that amorphous, MnIII/IV oxides with layered or tunnelled structures are especially good choices; (2) the type of support material (e.g. conducting oxides or nanostructured carbon) as well as the methods used to immobilize the MnOx catalysts on them greatly influence OER overpotentials, current densities and long-term stabilities of the electrodes and (3) when operating MnOx-based water-oxidizing anodes in electrolyzers, it has often been observed that the electrocatalytic performance is also largely dependent on the electrolyte’s composition and pH and that a number of equilibria accompany the catalytic process, resulting in “adaptive changes” of the MnOx material over time. Overall, it thus has become clear over the last years that efficient and stable water-oxidation electrolysis by manganese oxides can only be achieved if at least four parameters are optimized in combination: the oxide catalyst itself, the immobilization method, the catalyst support and last but not least the composition of the electrolyte. Furthermore, these parameters are not only important for the electrode optimization process alone but must also be considered if different electrode types are to be compared with each other or with literature values from literature. Because, as without their consideration it is almost impossible to draw the right scientific conclusions. On the other hand, it currently seems unlikely that even carefully optimized MnOx anodes will ever reach the superb OER rates observed for iridium, ruthenium or nickel-iron oxide anodes in acidic or alkaline solutions, respectively. So at the end of the article, two fundamental questions will be addressed: (1) are there technical applications where MnOx materials could actually be the first choice as OER electrocatalysts? and (2) do the results from the last decade of intensive research in this field help to solve a puzzle already formulated in 2008: “Why did nature choose manganese to make oxygen?”.

H/D Isotope Effects Reveal Factors Controlling Catalytic Activity in Co-Based Oxides for Water Oxidation

Understanding the mechanism for electrochemical water oxidation is important for the development of more efficient catalysts for artificial photosynthesis. A basic step is the proton-coupled electron transfer, which enables accumulation of oxidizing equivalents without buildup of a charge. We find that substituting deuterium for hydrogen resulted in an 87% decrease in the catalytic activity for water oxidation on Co-based amorphous-oxide catalysts at neutral pH, while ¹⁶O-to-¹⁸O substitution lead to a 10% decrease. In situ visible and quasi-in situ X-ray absorption spectroscopy reveal that the hydrogen-to-deuterium isotopic substitution induces an equilibrium isotope effect that shifts the oxidation potentials positively by approximately 60 mV for the proton coupled Co^II/III and Co^III/IV electron transfer processes. Time-resolved spectroelectrochemical measurements indicate the absence of a kinetic isotope effect, implying that the precatalytic proton-coupled electron transfer happens through a stepwise mechanism in which electron transfer is rate-determining. An observed correlation between Co oxidation states and catalytic current for both isotopic conditions indicates that the applied potential has no direct effect on the catalytic rate, which instead depends exponentially on the average Co oxidation state. These combined results provide evidence that neither proton nor electron transfer is involved in the catalytic rate-determining step. We propose a mechanism with an active species composed by two adjacent Co^IV atoms and a rate-determining step that involves oxygen-oxygen bond formation and compare it with models proposed in the literature.

Facile Formation of Nanostructured Manganese Oxide Films as High-Performance Catalysts for the Oxygen Evolution Reaction

The development of inexpensive, earth abundant, and bioinspired oxygen evolution electrocatalysts that are easily accessible and scalable is a principal requirement with regard to the feasibility of water splitting for large-scale chemical energy storage. A unique, versatile, and scalable approach has been developed to fabricate manganese oxide films from single layers to multilayers with a controlled thickness and high reproducibility. The produced MnO_x films are composed of small nanostructures that are assembled closely in the form of porous sponge-like layers. The films were investigated for the electrochemical oxygen evolution reaction in alkaline media and demonstrate a remarkable activity as well as a superior stability of over 60 h. To elucidate the catalytically active species, as well as the striking structural characteristics, the films were further examined in depth by using SEM, TEM, and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, as well as quasi in situ extended X-ray absorption fine structure and X-ray absorption near edge structure analysis. The MnO_x catalyst films excel because of a favorably high fraction of Mn³⁺ ions that are retained even after operation at oxidizing potentials. Upon exposure to oxidizing potentials in strongly alkaline aqueous electrolyte, the catalyst material maintains its structural integrity at the nanostructural, morphological, and atomic level.

Calcium containing iron oxide as an efficient and robust catalyst in (photo-)electrocatalytic water oxidation at neutral pH

The amorphous nature and in situ formation of iron phosphate render CaFeO_x with high activity and stability for the OER at neutral pH.

Nickel oxide–polypyrrole nanocomposite electrode materials for electrocatalytic water oxidation

Electrochemically prepared nickel oxide nanoparticles entrapped into a polymer matrix as efficient material for O₂ evolution.

Preparation of Cobalt-Based Electrodes by Physical Vapor Deposition on Various Nonconductive Substrates for Electrocatalytic Water Oxidation

Artificial photosynthesis requires efficient anodic electrode materials for water oxidation. Cobalt metal thin films are prepared through facile physical vapor deposition (PVD) on various nonconductive substrates, including regular and quartz glass, mica sheet, polyimide, and polyethylene terephthalate (PET). Subsequent surface electrochemical modification by cyclic voltammetry (CV) renders these films active for electrocatalytic water oxidation, reaching a current density of 10 mA cm^-2 at a low overpotential of 330 mV in 1.0 m KOH solution. These electrodes are robust with unchanged activity throughout prolonged chronopotentiometry measurements. This work is thus significant to show that the combination of PVD and CV is very valuable and convenient to fabricate active electrodes on various nonconductive substrates, particularly with flexible polyimide and PET substrates. This efficient, safe and convenient method can potentially be expanded to many other electrochemical applications.

Electrocatalytic Water Oxidation by MnOx /C: In Situ Catalyst Formation, Carbon Substrate Variations, and Direct O2 /CO2 Monitoring by Membrane-Inlet Mass Spectrometry

Layers of amorphous manganese oxides were directly formed on the surfaces of different carbon materials by exposing the carbon to aqueous solutions of permanganate (MnO₄^- ) followed by sintering at 100-400 °C. During electrochemical measurements in neutral aqueous buffer, nearly all of the MnO_x /C electrodes show significant oxidation currents at potentials relevant for the oxygen evolution reaction (OER). However, by combining electrolysis with product detection by using mass spectrometry, it was found that these currents were only strictly linked to water oxidation if MnO_x was deposited on graphitic carbon materials (faradaic O₂ yields >90 %). On the contrary, supports containing sp³ -C were found to be unsuitable as the OER is accompanied by carbon corrosion to CO₂ . Thus, choosing the "right" carbon material is crucial for the preparation of stable and efficient MnO_x /C anodes for water oxidation catalysis. For MnO_x on graphitic substrates, current densities of >1 mA cm^-2 at η=540 mV could be maintained for at least 16 h of continuous operation at pH 7 (very good values for electrodes containing only abundant elements such as C, O, and Mn) and post-operando measurements proved the integrity of both the catalyst coating and the underlying carbon at OER conditions.

Inhibitory and Non-Inhibitory NH3 Binding at the Water-Oxidizing Manganese Complex of Photosystem II Suggests Possible Sites and a Rearrangement Mode of Substrate Water Molecules

The identity and rearrangements of substrate water molecules in photosystem II (PSII) water oxidation are of great mechanistic interest and addressed herein by comprehensive analysis of NH₄⁺/NH₃ binding. Time-resolved detection of O₂ formation and recombination fluorescence as well as Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) difference spectroscopy on plant PSII membrane particles reveals the following. (1) Partial inhibition in NH₄Cl buffer occurs with a pH-independent binding constant of ∼25 mM, which does not result from decelerated O₂ formation, but from complete blockage of a major PSII fraction (∼60%) after reaching the Mn(IV)₄ (S₃) state. (2) The non-inhibited PSII fraction advances through the reaction cycle, but modified nuclear rearrangements are suggested by FTIR difference spectroscopy. (3) Partial inhibition can be explained by anticooperative (mutually exclusive) NH₃ binding to one inhibitory and one non-inhibitory site; these two sites may correspond to two water molecules terminally bound to the "dangling" Mn ion. (4) Unexpectedly strong modifications of the FTIR difference spectra suggest that in the non-inhibited PSII, ammonia binding obliterates the need for some of the nuclear rearrangements occurring in the S₂-S₃ transition as well as their reversal in the O₂ formation transition, in line with the carousel mechanism [Askerka, M., et al. (2015) Biochemistry 54, 5783]. (5) We observe the same partial inhibition of PSII by NH₄Cl also for thylakoid membranes prepared from mesophilic and thermophilic cyanobacteria, suggesting that the results described above are valid for plant and cyanobacterial PSII.

Self-Supported Hierarchical FeCoNi-LTH/NiCo2O4/CC Electrodes with Enhanced Bifunctional Performance for Efficient Overall Water Splitting

The development of advanced earth-abundant electrocatalysts for hydrogen production is highly desirable. In this paper, we report the design and synthesis of a novel and highly efficient electrode of NiCo₂O₄ nanoneedles decorated with FeCoNi layered ternary hydroxides supported on carbon cloth (FeCoNi-LTH/NiCo₂O₄/CC) by a facile and efficient two-step approach. It exhibits superior bifunctional catalytic activities for the oxygen evolution reaction (OER) and hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) in alkaline media, due to the special structure and strong synergies. The FeCoNi-LTH/NiCo₂O₄/CC obtains an onset overpotential of 240 mV and an overpotential of 302 mV at the current density of 50 mA cm^-2 for OER, which is superior to RuO₂. It also efficiently catalyzes HER with onset overpotential of 96 mV and overpotential of 151 mV to achieve a current density of 20 mA cm^-2. Serving as both cathode and anode in a two-electrode water splitting system, FeCoNi-LTH/NiCo₂O₄/CC only requires an overpotential of 1.65 V at current density of 50 mA cm^-2. The cell exhibits outstanding stability as well, indicating that FeCoNi-LTH/NiCo₂O₄/CC is a befitting material to be utilized as effective bifunctional catalysts for overall water splitting.

Surface Electrochemical Modification of a Nickel Substrate to Prepare a NiFe-based Electrode for Water Oxidation

The slow kinetics of water oxidation greatly jeopardizes the efficiency of water electrolysis for H₂ production. Developing highly active water oxidation electrodes with affordable fabrication costs is thus of great importance. Herein, a Ni^II Fe^III surface species on Ni metal substrate was generated by electrochemical modification of Ni in a ferrous solution by a fast, simple, and cost-effective procedure. In the prepared Ni^II Fe^III catalyst film, Fe^III was incorporated uniformly through controlled oxidation of Fe^II cations on the electrode surface. The catalytically active Ni^II originated from the Ni foam substrate, which ensured the close contact between the catalyst and the support toward improved charge-transfer efficiency. The as-prepared electrode exhibited high activity and long-term stability for electrocatalytic water oxidation. The overpotentials required to reach water oxidation current densities of 50, 100, and 500 mA cm^-2 are 276, 290, and 329 mV, respectively.

Nanolayered manganese oxides: insights from inorganic electrochemistry

The electrochemistry of nanolayered Mn oxides in the presence of LiClO₄ at pH = 6.3 under different conditions was studied.

Photocatalytic water oxidation by persulphate with a Ca2+ ion-incorporated polymeric cobalt cyanide complex affording O2 with 200% quantum efficiency

Incorporation of a small amount of Ca²⁺ ions into a polymeric cobalt cyanide complex enhanced the activity for photocatalytic water oxidation by persulphate with [Ru(bpy)₃]²⁺ at pH 7.0 to achieve a maximum quantum efficiency of 200%.

Homogeneous Cobalt/Vanadium Complexes as Precursors for Functionalized Mixed Oxides in Visible-Light-Driven Water Oxidation

The heterometallic complexes (NH₄ )₂ [Co(H₂ O)₆ ]₂ [V₁₀ O₂₈ ]⋅4 H₂ O (1) and (NH₄ )₂ [Co(H₂ O)₅ (β-HAla)]₂ [V₁₀ O₂₈ ]⋅4 H₂ O (2) have been synthesized and used for the preparation of mixed oxides as catalysts for water oxidation. Thermal decomposition of 1 and 2 at relatively low temperatures (<500 °C) leads to the formation of the solid mixed oxides CoV₂ O₆ /V₂ O₅ (3) and Co₂ V₂ O₇ /V₂ O₅ (4). The complexes (1, 2) and heterogeneous materials (3, 4) act as catalysts for photoinduced water oxidation. A modification of the thermal decomposition procedure allowed the deposition of mixed metal oxides (MMO) on a mesoporous TiO₂ film. The electrodes containing Co/V MMOs in TiO₂ films were used for electrocatalytic water oxidation and showed good stability and sustained anodic currents of about 5 mA cm^-2 at 1.72 V versus relative hydrogen electrode (RHE). This method of functionalizing TiO₂ films with MMOs at relatively low temperatures (<500 °C) can be used to produce other oxides with different functionality for applications in, for example, artificial photosynthesis.