Product-oriented Direct Cleavage of Chemical Linkages in Lignin

Advances in catalytic conversion of lignin to vanillin using ionic liquids and deep eutectic solvents

Lignin is the most abundant renewable aromatic resource in nature. Lignin can be valorized into vanillin, an important food flavoring. Recent progress in ionic liquids (ILs) and deep eutectic solvents (DESs), two classes of emerging green solvents, suggest promising pathways for valorizing lignin into vanillin in a green and sustainable manner. This review comprehensively summarizes the methods for vanillin production from lignin, the composition and structure of ILs/DESs, and their mechanisms of dissolving lignin. Recent advances in the catalytic conversion of lignin into vanillin use various ILs/DESs systems are systematically reviewed. Particularly, the underlying mechanism of ILs/DESs catalytic conversion of lignin into vanillin are provided. Finally, the challenges and opportunities of lignin oxidative depolymerization for vanillin production in the future are discussed. This present work will provide new insights into lignin valorization and the sustainable production of vanillin.

Lignin Tandem Catalytic Transformation to Phenolic Aryl Acrylic Esters as Plant Growth Regulators

Based on the concept "Derived from Agroforestry, belong to (Servicing) Agroforestry", we herein achieved the tandem catalytic transformation of lignin to phenolic aryl acrylic esters, which can work as plant growth regulators. The transformation involves the first catalytic oxidative fractionation (COF) of lignin into aromatic aldehydes, which can further undergo Knoevenagel condensation with acids/esters with active Cα-H to generate the phenolic aryl acrylic esters. For the first lignin transformation, the Cu salt (CuSO4) in a 7.5 wt % NaOH aqueous solution could achieve the selective cleavage of lignin C-C bonds to provide a 25.0 wt % yield of aromatic aldehydes. Subsequently, the unique basic sites of the self-assembled hybrid system of CeO2 and 2-cyanopyridine could overcome the limitations of traditional homogeneous/heterogeneous bases and facilitate the condensation between phenolic-containing aromatic aldehydes and malonic ester to aryl acrylic esters. Furthermore, the lignin-based phenolic aryl acrylic esters showed different plant growth regulation activity based on the various structural groups for peppermint seed cultivation. The above results can expand the high-value utilization of lignin in the agroforestry field.

Photoinduced Lignin Cα-Cβ Bond Cleavage and Chemodivergent Functionalization via Iron Catalysis

The photocatalytic conversion of lignin into value-added chemicals especially those functionalized molecules represent one of the most important strategies for sustainable and environmental-friendly development. Cleavage of C-C bonds in lignin under mild photocatalytic conditions for refining lignin into useful molecules is meaningful but challenging. Meanwhile, the assembly of diverse functional groups into active lignin fragments during the depolymerization is of great challenging. Herein, using cheap iron catalysts under visible light irradiation, the highly selective and efficient cleavage of Cα-Cβ bond in lignin is realized via ligand-to-metal charge transfer (LMCT) and hydrogen atom transfer (HAT) processes. The subsequent divergent functionalization of generated lignin fragment-based radical intermediates enables an efficient formation of diverse functionalized molecules. This method is also effective for cleavage of Cα-Cβ bond in native lignin, yielding two identified benzaldehyde monomers in a total yield of 8.7 wt %.

Theoretical Mechanism of Rh-Containing Species Catalyzing the Hydrogenolysis of Lignin Model Compounds Using -CαO-H and -Cα-H Groups as Superior H-Sources

The hydrogenolysis of lignin model compounds (MCs) into high-value chemicals has received increasing attention, but their catalytic reaction mechanisms are not yet very clear. Here, we report the reaction mechanisms of the hydrogenolysis of MC into 4-acetylanisole (AAL) and guaiacol (GAL) catalyzed by LRuCl3 (L = 4'-(4-methoxyphenyl)-2,2':6',2″-terpyridine) with MC, H2, and 1-phenylethan-1-ol (PEO) as the H-sources in aqueous solution with the Bro̷nsted base (NaOH), at the M06/def2-TZVP, 6-311++G (d,p) theoretical level, namely, RS-Self, RS-H2, and RS-PEO, respectively. After dissociation in NaOH aqueous solution, the LRuCl3 compound can form a stable complex LRh (OH)3 as the initial catalytically active species. Their rate-determining steps are related to the cleavage of the -CαO-H bond in both RS-Self-and RS-PEO, whereas it is associated with the heterolysis of the H-H bond in RS-H2. From NaOH aqueous solution, the OH- ligand of LRh(OH)3 promotes the cleavage of the -CαO-H bond with MC and PEO as H-sources, whereas it advances the heterolysis of the H-H bond with H2 as the H-source, owing to its strong Bro̷nsted basicity. Furthermore, the Rh center of LRh(OH)3 mediates the cleavage of the -Cα-H bond, because of its Lewis acidity. The reaction activity lowers as RS-Self > RS-PEO ≫ RS-H2, which is positively dependent on the protonation degree of the departing H atom. Compounds containing both -CαO-H and -Cα-H groups can act as effective donors for H-sources. In the meantime, the stronger the electron-withdrawing groups they contain, the more pronounced the protonation of the -CαO-H group and the higher the reaction activity in providing H-sources. The present results provide insights into utilizing lignin's own functional groups as a hydrogen source for high-value conversion.

Mini-review on lignin-based self-healing polymer

Lignin, a biopolymer derived from plant biomass, is recognized as a highly promising substance for developing self-healing polymers owing to its dynamic linkages and functional groups. This paper provides a thorough review of lignin-based self-healing polymer, from the process of extracting lignin, chemical modification, synthesis techniques such as via reversible addition-fragmentation chain transfer (RAFT) polymerization, crosslinking with polymers like polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) and chitosan, and reactions with isocyanates to create lignin-based networks with reversible interactions. This work also summarizes the optimization of self-healing ability, such as including dynamic copolymers, encapsulating healing agents like dicyclopentadiene and polycaprolactone (PCL), and chain extenders with disulfide or Diels-Alder (DA) moieties. The material's characterization focuses on its capacity to recover via hydrogen bonding and dynamic re-associations, improved mechanical properties from lignin's rigid structure, and enhanced temperature resistance. Primary obstacles involve the optimization of lignin extraction, enhancement of polymer compatibility, and the establishment of efficient procedures for synthesis and characterization. Overall, lignin shows great potential as a renewable component of self-healing polymers, with plenty of opportunities for further development.

A green and efficient approach for the simultaneous extraction and mechanisms of essential oil and lignin from Cinnamomum camphora: Process optimization based on deep learning

The utilization and economic benefits of biomass resources can be maximized through rational design and process optimization. In this study, an innovative approach for the simultaneous extraction of essential oil and lignin from Cinnamomum camphora leaves by deep eutectic solvent (DES) and optimization of the process parameters was achieved using deep learning tools. With the water content of 40 %, liquid-solid ratio of 9.00 mL/g, and distillation time of 51.81 min, the yields of the essential oil and lignin reached 3.15 ± 0.02 % and 9.75 ± 0.15 %, respectively. Notably, the efficiency of simultaneous extraction of essential oil improved by 23 % compared to that of traditional steam distillation. Moreover, the extraction mechanism of the process was clarified. The connection between lignin with cellulose and hemicellulose was disintegrated by the DES, resulting in lignin shedding and hence accelerating the dissolution of essential oil. Moreover, the compositions of lignin and essential oil were also identified.

Current status and future prospects of pretreatment for tobacco stalk lignocellulose

With the growing demand for sustainable development, tobacco stalks, as a resource-rich and low-cost renewable resource, hold the potential for producing high-value chemicals and materials within a circular economy. Due to the complex and unique structure of tobacco stalk biomass, traditional methods are ineffective in its utilization, making the pretreatment of tobacco stalk lignocellulose a crucial step in obtaining high-value products. This paper reviews recent advancements in various pretreatment technologies for tobacco stalk lignocellulosic biomass, including hydrothermal, steam explosion, acid, alkaline, organic solvent, ionic liquid, and deep eutectic solvent pretreatment. It emphasizes the impact and efficiency of these pretreatment methods on the conversion of tobacco stalk biomass and discusses the advantages and disadvantages of each technique. Finally, the paper forecasts future research directions in the pretreatment of tobacco stalk lignocellulose, providing new insights and methods for enhancing its efficient utilization.

Catalytic Conversion of Lignin into Valuable Chemicals: Full Utilization of Aromatic Nuclei and Side Chains

ConspectusIn recent years, significant efforts have been directed toward achieving efficient and mild lignocellulosic biomass conversion into valuable chemicals and fuels, aiming to address energy and environmental concerns and realize the goal of carbon neutrality. Lignin is one of the three primary building blocks of lignocellulose and the only aromatic renewable feedstock. However, the complex and diverse nature of lignin feedstocks, characterized by their three-dimensional, highly branched polymeric structure and intricate C-O/C-C chemical bonds, results in substantial challenges. To tackle these challenges, we carried out extensive research on selectively activating and transforming chemical bonds in lignin for chemical synthesis. In this Account, we discuss our recent progress in catalytic lignin conversion.Our work is focused on two main objectives: (i) achieving precise and selective transformation of C-O/C-C bonds in lignin (and its model compounds) and (ii) fully utilizing the aromatic nuclei and side chains present in lignin to produce valuable chemicals. Lignin consists of interconnected phenylpropanoid subunits linked by interlaced C-C/C-O bonds. To unlock the full potential of lignin, we propose the concept of "the full utilization of lignin", which encompasses both the aromatic nuclei and the side chains (e.g., methoxyl and polyhydroxypropyl groups).For the conversion of aromatic nuclei, selective activation of C-O and/or C-C bonds is crucial in synthesizing targeted aromatic products. We begin with model compounds (such as anisole, phenol, guaiacol, etc.) and then transition to protolignin feedstocks. Various reaction routes are developed, including self-supported hydrogenolysis, direct Caryl-Csp3 cleavage, coupled Caryl-Csp3 cleavage and Caryl-O hydrogenolysis, and tandem selective hydrogenation and hydrolysis processes. These tailored pathways enable high-yield and sustainable production of a wide range of aromatic (and derived) products, including arenes (benzene, toluene, alkylbenzenes), phenols, ketones, and acids.In terms of side chain utilization, we have developed innovative strategies such as selective methyl transfer, coupling depolymerization-methyl shift, selective acetyl utilization, and new activation methods such as amine-assisted prefunctionalization. These strategies enable the direct synthesis of methyl-/alkyl-derived products, such as acetic acid, 4-ethyltoluene, dimethylethylamine, and amides. Additionally, aromatic residues can be transformed into chemicals or functionalized ingredients that can serve as catalysts or functional biopolymer materials. These findings highlight promising opportunities for harnessing both the aromatic nuclei and side chains of lignin in a creative manner, thereby improving the overall atom economy of lignin upgrading.Through innovative catalyst engineering and reaction route strategies, our work achieves the sustainable and efficient production of various valuable chemicals from lignin. By integrating side chains and aromatic rings, we have successfully synthesized methyl-/alkyl-derived and aromatic-derived products with high yields. The full utilization of lignin not only minimizes waste but also opens up new possibilities for generating chemical products from lignin. These novel approaches unlock the untapped potential of lignin, expand the boundaries of lignin upgrading, and enhance the efficiency and economic viability of lignin biorefining.

Progress on quantum dot photocatalysts for biomass valorization

Biomass with abundant reproducible carbon resource holds great promise as an intriguing substitute for fossil fuels in the manufacture of high-value-added chemicals and fuels. Photocatalytic biomass valorization using inexhaustible solar energy enables to accurately break desired chemical bonds or selectively functionalize particular groups, thus emerging as an extremely creative and low carbon cost strategy for relieving the dilemma of the global energy. Quantum dots (QDs) are an outstandingly dynamic class of semiconductor photocatalysts because of their unique properties, which have achieved significant successes in various photocatalytic applications including biomass valorization. In this review, the current development rational design for QDs photocatalytic biomass valorization effectively is highlighted, focusing on the principles of tuning their particle size, structure, and surface properties, with special emphasis on the effect of the ligands for selectively broken chemical bonds (C─O, C─C) of biomass. Finally, the present issues and possibilities within that exciting field are described.

Water-Promoted Carbon-Carbon Bond Cleavage Employing a Reusable Fe Single-Atom Catalyst

The development of methods for selective cleavage reactions of thermodynamically stable C-C/C=C bonds in a green manner is a challenging research field which is largely unexplored. Herein, we present a heterogeneous Fe-N-C catalyst with highly dispersed iron centers that allows for the oxidative C-C/C=C bond cleavage of amines, secondary alcohols, ketones, and olefins in the presence of air (O2 ) and water (H2 O). Mechanistic studies reveal the presence of water to be essential for the performance of the Fe-N-C system, boosting the product yield from <1 % to >90 %. Combined spectroscopic characterizations and control experiments suggest the singlet 1 O2 and hydroxide species generated from O2 and H2 O, respectively, take selectively part in the C-C bond cleavage. The broad applicability (>40 examples) even for complex drugs as well as high activity, selectivity, and durability under comparably mild conditions highlight this unique catalytic system.

Laccase-catalyzed lignin depolymerization in deep eutectic solvents: challenges and prospects

Lignin has enormous potential as a renewable feedstock for depolymerizing to numerous high-value chemicals. However, lignin depolymerization is challenging owing to its recalcitrant, heterogenous, and limited water-soluble nature. From the standpoint of environmental friendliness and sustainability, enzymatic depolymerization of lignin is of great significance. Notably, laccases play an essential role in the enzymatic depolymerization of lignin and are considered the ultimate green catalysts. Deep eutectic solvent (DES), an efficient media in biocatalysis, are increasingly recognized as the newest and utmost green solvent that highly dissolves lignin. This review centers on a lignin depolymerization strategy by harnessing the good lignin fractionating capability of DES and the high substrate and product selectivity of laccase. Recent progress and insights into the laccase-DES interactions, protein engineering strategies for improving DES compatibility with laccase, and controlling the product selectivity of lignin degradation by laccase or in DES systems are extensively provided. Lastly, the challenges and prospects of the alliance between DES and laccase for lignin depolymerization are discussed. The collaboration of laccase and DES provides a great opportunity to develop an enzymatic route for lignin depolymerization.

Nature-inspired pretreatment of lignocellulose - Perspective and development

As sustainability gains increasing importance in addition to cost-effectiveness as a criterion for evaluating engineering systems and practices, biological processes for lignocellulose pretreatment have attracted growing attention. Biological systems such as white and brown rot fungi and wood-consuming insects offer fascinating examples of processes and systems built by nature to effectively deconstruct plant cell walls under environmentally benign and energy-conservative environments. Research in the last decade has resulted in new knowledge that advanced the understanding of these systems, provided additional insights into these systems' functional mechanisms, and demonstrated various applications of these processes. The new knowledge and insights enable the adoption of a nature-inspired strategy aiming at developing technologies that are informed by the biological systems but superior to them by overcoming the inherent weakness of the natural systems. This review discusses the nature-inspired perspective and summarizes related advancements, including the evolution from biological systems to nature-inspired processes, the features of biological pretreatment mechanisms, the development of nature-inspired pretreatment processes, and future perspective. This work aims to highlight a different strategy in the research and development of novel lignocellulose pretreatment processes and offer some food for thought.

A novel ternary deep eutectic solvent pretreatment for the efficient separation and conversion of high-quality gutta-percha, value-added lignin and monosaccharide from Eucommia ulmoides seed shells

A novel ternary deep eutectic solvent (DES), consisted of choline chloride, oxalic acid and ethylene glycol, was developed as a green, low-cost and recyclable pretreatment system for multi-stage utilization of Eucommia ulmoides seed shells. Under optimum conditions, 79.7 % hemicellulose and 65.6 % lignin were quickly removed while 84.0 % cellulose was retained. After DES pretreatment, the yield and purity of gutta-percha achieved 85.1 mg/g and 96.2 %, which increased 1.4 and 1.8 folds higher than that of un-treatment ones. Meanwhile, 69.1 % enzymatic digestibility of cellulose was obtained, that was 2.3 folds higher than that of raw substrates. Moreover, 53.6 % low-condensation lignin with aromatic structures and valuable aryl-ether linkages was well collected. Importantly, the DES that has been recycled five runs can still remove 73.9 % hemicellulose and 58.0 % lignin. Overall, the DES was determined to efficiently promote the separation and conversion of high-quality gutta-percha, value-added lignin and high-yield glucose from Eucommia ulmoides seed shells.

Lignin-First Depolymerization of Lignocellulose into Monophenols over Carbon Nanotube-Supported Ruthenium: Impact of Lignin Sources

Lignin-first depolymerization of lignocellulosic biomass into aromatics is of great significance to sustainable biorefinery. However, it remains a challenge, owing to the variance between lignin sources and structures. In this study, ruthenium supported on carbon nanotubes (Ru/CNT) exhibits efficient catalytic activity toward lignin hydrogenolysis to exclusively afford monophenols in high yields. Catalytic tests indicate that the yields of aromatic monomers are related to lignin sources and decrease in the order: hardwoods > herbaceous plants > softwoods. Experimental results demonstrate that the scission of C-O bonds and the high selectivity to monomeric aromatic compounds over the Ru/CNT catalyst are enhanced by avoiding side condensation. Furthermore, the fabricated Ru/CNT shows good reusability and recyclability, applicability, and biomass feedstock compatibility, rendering it a promising candidate for lignin valorization. These findings pave the way for rational design of highly active and stable catalysts to potentially address challenges in lignin chemistry.

A mechanistic study on electro-Fenton system cooperating with phangerochate chrysosporium to degrade lignin

The combined catalytic system of Electro-Fenton (E-Fenton) and Phanerochaete chrysosporium (P. chrysosporium) was constructed in liquid medium with additional potential to overcome the limitations of lignin degradation by white rot fungi alone. To further understand the mechanism of synergistic catalysis, we optimized the optimum potential for lignin catalysis by P. chrysosporium and built synergistic versus separate catalyses. After 48 h of incubation, the optimum growth environment and the highest lignin degradation rate (43.8%) of P. chrysosporium were achieved when 4 V was applied. After 96 h, the lignin degradation rate of the cocatalytic system was 62% (E-Fenton catalysis alone 22% and P. chrysosporium catalysis alone 19%), the pH of the growth maintenance system of P. chrysosporium was approximately 3.5, and the lignin peroxidase (LiP) and manganese-dependent peroxidase (MnP) enzyme activities, were significantly better than those of the control. The qPCR results indicated that the expression of both MnP and LiP genes was higher in the cocatalytic system. Meanwhile, FTIR and 2D-HSQC NMR confirmed that the synergistic catalysis was effective in breaking the aromatic functional groups and the side chains of the aliphatic region of lignin. This study showed that the synergistic catalytic process of electro-Fenton and P. chrysosporium was highly efficient in the degradation of lignin. In addition, the synergetic system is simple to operate, economical and green, and has good prospects for industrial application.

Mechanochemical Transformations of Biomass into Functional Materials

Biomass is one of the promising alternatives to petroleum-derived materials and plays a major role in our fight against climate change by providing renewable sources of chemicals and materials. Owing to its chemical and structural complexity, the transformation of biomass into value-added products requires a profound understanding of its composition at different scales and innovative methods such as combining physical and chemical processes. In this context, the use of mechanochemistry in biomass valorization is currently growing owing to its potentials as an efficient, sustainable, and environmentally friendly approach. This review highlights the latest advances in the transformation of biomass (i. e., chitin, cellulose, hemicellulose, lignin, and starch) to functional materials using mechanochemical-assisted methods. We focused here on the methodology of biomass processing, influencing factors, and resulting properties with an emphasis on achieving functional materials rather than breaking down the biopolymer chains into smaller molecules. Opportunities and limitations associated this methodology were discussed accordingly for future directions.

Catalytic self-transfer hydrogenolysis of lignin with endogenous hydrogen: road to the carbon-neutral future

Due to the depletion of fossil sources, it is imperative to develop a sustainable and carbon-neutral biorefinery for supporting the fuel and chemical supply in modern society. Lignin, the only renewable aromatic source, is still an underutilized component in lignocellulose. Very recently, it has been found that hydrogenolysis is a promising technology for lignin valorization. However, high-pressure H₂ is necessary during lignin hydrogenolysis, resulting in safety problems. Furthermore, H₂ is mainly produced from steam reforming of fossil sources in industry, which makes the conversion of renewable lignin unsustainable and costly. Plentiful aliphatic hydroxyl and methoxy groups exist in native lignin and offer a renewable alternative to H₂, and can be hydrogen sources for the depolymerization and upgradation of lignin via the intramolecular catalytic transfer hydrogenation. The hydrogen source in situ generated from lignin is a type of green hydrogen, decreasing the carbon footprint. The purpose of this review is to provide a summary and perspective of lignin valorization via self-transfer hydrogenolysis, mainly focusing on a comprehensive understanding of the mechanism of catalytic self-transfer hydrogenolysis at the molecular level and developing highly effective catalytic systems. Moreover, some opportunities and challenges within this attractive field are given to discuss future research directions.

Dihydroxyacetone valorization with high atom efficiency via controlling radical oxidation pathways over natural mineral-inspired catalyst

Diminishing fossil fuel resources and calls for sustainability are driving the urgent need for efficient valorization of renewable resources with high atom efficiency. Inspired from the natural goethite mineral with Mn paragenesis, we develop cost-effective MnO2/goethite catalysts for the efficient valorization of dihydroxyacetone, an important biomass-based platform molecule, into value-added glycolic acid and formic acid with 83.2% and 93.4% yields. The DHA substrates first undergo C-C cleavage to selectively form glycolic acid and hydroxymethyl (·CH2OH) radicals, which are further oxidized into formic acid. The kinetic and isotopic labeling experiments reveal that the catalase-like activity of MnO2 turns the oxidative radicals into oxygen, which then switches towards a hydroxymethyl peroxide (HMOO) pathway for formic acid generation and prevents formic acid over-oxidation. This nature-inspired catalyst design not only significantly improves the carbon efficiency to 86.6%, but also enhances the oxygen atom utilization efficiency from 11.2% to 46.6%, indicating a promising biomass valorization process.

Recent advances in lignocellulose prior-fractionation for biomaterials, biochemicals, and bioenergy

Due to over-consumption of fossil resources and environmental problems, lignocellulosic biomass as the most abundant and renewable materials is considered as the best candidate to produce biomaterials, biochemicals, and bioenergy, which is of strategic significance and meets the theme of Green Chemistry. Highly efficient and green fractionation of lignocellulose components significantly boosts the high-value utilization of lignocellulose and the biorefinery development. However, heterogeneity of lignocellulosic structure severely limited the lignocellulose fractionation. This paper offers the summary and perspective of the extensive investigation that aims to give insight into the lignocellulose prior-fractionation. Based on the role and structure of lignocellulose component in the plant cell wall, lignocellulose prior-fractionation can be divided into cellulose-first strategy, hemicelluloses-first strategy, and lignin-first strategy, which realizes the selective dissociation and transformation of a component in lignocellulose. Ultimately, the challenges and opportunities of lignocellulose prior-fractionation are proposed on account of the existing problems in the biorefining valorization.

Exploiting Nature's Most Abundant Polymers: Developing New Pathways for the Conversion of Cellulose, Hemicellulose, Lignin and Chitin into Platform Molecules (and Beyond)

The four most prominent forms of biomass are cellulose, hemicellulose, lignin and chitin. In efforts to develop sustainable sources of platform molecules there has been an increasing focus on examining how these biopolymers could be exploited as feedstocks that support the chemical supply chain, including in the production of fine chemicals. Many different approaches are possible and some of the ones being developed in the authors' laboratories are emphasised.

Investigations of Hydrocarbon Species on Solid Catalysts by Inelastic Neutron Scattering

The status of surface species on solid catalysts during heterogeneous catalysis is often mysterious. Investigations of these surface species are crucial to deconvolute the reaction network and design more efficient catalysts. Vibrational spectroscopy is a powerful technique to study the interactions between surface species and the catalysts and infrared (IR) and Raman spectroscopies have been widely applied to study reaction mechanisms in heterogeneous catalysis. However, IR/Raman spectra are difficult to model computationally and important vibrational modes may be IR-, Raman- (or both) inactive due to restrictions by optical selection rules. Inelastic neutron scattering (INS) is another form of vibrational spectroscopy and relies on the scattering of neutrons by the atomic nucleus. A consequence of this is that INS is not subject to any optical selection rules and all vibrations are measurable in principle. INS spectroscopy has been used to investigate surface species on catalysts in a wide range of heterogeneous catalytic reactions. In this mini-review, we focus on applications of INS in two important fields: petrochemical reactions and C1 chemistry. We introduce the basic principles of the INS technique, followed by a discussion of its application in investigating two key catalytic systems: (i) the behaviour of hydrocarbons on metal-oxide and zeolite catalysts and (ii) the formation of hydrocarbonaceous species on methane reforming and Fischer–Tropsch catalysts. The power of INS in studying these important catalytic systems is demonstrated.