Nonspecific genetic regulation of antibody responsiveness in the mouse

Immune recognition of salivary proteins from the cattle tick Rhipicephalus microplus differs according to the genotype of the bovine host

Background

Males of the cattle tick Rhipicephalus microplus produce salivary immunoglobulin-binding proteins and allotypic variations in IgG are associated with tick loads in bovines. These findings indicate that antibody responses may be essential to control tick infestations. Infestation loads with cattle ticks are heritable: some breeds carry high loads of reproductively successful ticks, in others, few ticks feed and they reproduce inefficiently. Different patterns of humoral immunity against tick salivary proteins may explain these phenotypes.

Methods

We describe the profiles of humoral responses against tick salivary proteins elicited during repeated artificial infestations of bovines of a tick-resistant (Nelore) and a tick-susceptible (Holstein) breed. We measured serum levels of total IgG1, IgG2 and IgE immunoglobulins and of IgG1 and IgG2 antibodies specific for tick salivary proteins. With liquid chromatography followed by mass spectrometry we identified tick salivary proteins that were differentially recognized by serum antibodies from tick-resistant and tick-susceptible bovines in immunoblots of tick salivary proteins separated by two-dimensional electrophoresis.

Results

Baseline levels of total IgG1 and IgG2 were significantly higher in tick-susceptible Holsteins compared with resistant Nelores. Significant increases in levels of total IgG1, but not of IgG2 accompanied successive infestations in both breeds. Resistant Nelores presented with significantly higher levels of salivary-specific antibodies before and at the first challenge with tick larvae; however, by the third challenge, tick-susceptible Holsteins presented with significantly higher levels of IgG1 and IgG2 tick salivary protein-specific antibodies. Importantly, sera from tick-resistant Nelores reacted with 39 tick salivary proteins in immunoblots of salivary proteins separated in two dimensions by electrophoresis versus only 21 spots reacting with sera from tick-susceptible Holsteins.

Conclusions

Levels of tick saliva-specific antibodies were not directly correlated with infestation phenotypes. However, in spite of receiving apparently lower amounts of tick saliva, tick-resistant bovines recognized more tick salivary proteins. These reactive salivary proteins are putatively involved in several functions of parasitism and blood-feeding. Our results indicate that neutralization by host antibodies of tick salivary proteins involved in parasitism is essential to control tick infestations.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s13071-017-2077-9) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Trypanosoma cruzi infection in genetically selected mouse lines: genetic linkage with quantitative trait locus controlling antibody response

Trypanosoma cruzi infection was studied in mouse lines selected for maximal (AIRmax) or minimal (AIRmin) acute inflammatory reaction and for high (H_III) or low (L_III) antibody (Ab) responses to complex antigens. Resistance was associated with gender (females) and strain—the high responder lines AIRmax and H_III were resistant. The higher resistance of H_III as compared to L_III mice extended to higher infective doses and was correlated with enhanced production of IFN-γ and nitric oxide production by peritoneal and lymph node cells, in H_III males and females. We also analyzed the involvement of previously mapped Ab and T. cruzi response QTL with the survival of Selection III mice to T. cruzi infections in a segregating backcross [F1(H_III×L_III) ×L_III] population. An Ab production QTL marker mapping to mouse chromosome 1 (34.8 cM) significantly cosegregated with survival after acute T. cruzi infections, indicating that this region also harbors genes whose alleles modulate resistance to acute T. cruzi infection.

Effects of Lonomia obliqua (lepidoptera, saturniidae) toxin on clotting, inflammatory and antibody responsiveness in genetically selected lines of mice

Lines of mice genetically selected for high (H) or low (L) antibody response and for maximal (AIRMAX) or minimal (AIRMIN) acute inflammatory reaction, in which the opposite extreme potentialities have been clearly defined, offer an appropriate model for investigating the environmental and genetic factors acting on innate and adaptative immunobiological functions. This model has been successfully employed to study the resistance or susceptibility against pathogens and/or toxins. It had been demonstrated that the skin contact with Lonomia obliqua caterpillar bristles induces local inflammation and may elicit severe hemorrhagic disorders. In the present study, blood coagulation time, and the acute inflammatory reaction were scored 24 h after injection of the Lonomia bristles crude extract in a subcutaneous dorsal air pouch. The acute inflammation was determined by the leukocyte concentration in the local exudates. The highest interline differences were observed between the AIRMAX (10(6) cells/ml) and AIRMIN (2 x 10(5) cells/ml) and this distinct expression involves the number of monocytes, eosinophils and mainly neutrophils. Regarding coagulation, the highest interline difference was observed between the HIII and LIII mice, and the F1)[LIII x HIII] hybrids showed the overdominance of the fast clotting character. The adaptative immune response was evaluated by comparing the anti-Lonomia bristle extract IgG titer among the lines: the antibody titers were higher in the H lines than in the L ones and equivalent in the AIRMAX and AIRMIN mice, in accordance to the phenotype profiles generated by the distinct selective processes. The genetically selected mice lines-AIRMAX, AIRMIN, HI, HIII, HG, LIII and LG-showed an almost continuous distributions for inflammation, coagulation time and IgG antibody titers, being the interline variances always higher than the intraline ones for the individually measured phenotypes. Altogether, these results suggest the independent polygenic regulation of these traits, being indicative of the genetic control to Lonomia toxin innate and adaptative sensitivity in humans.

Immunocontraception for population control: will resistance evolve?

The prospect for successful biocontrol using immunocontraception is threatened if there is adaptation to the vaccine through natural selection of individuals that are genetically resistant to the contraceptive agent. To assess this possibility we examined the literature and found that little relevant data are available for any species on the appropriate trait, fertility variation among immunized individuals, or about appropriate population and genetic parameters influencing the likelihood of a selection response. Some data are available on variation in antibody response to immunocontraceptives, but the relationship between antibody response and fertility levels is poorly documented. The antibody response data indicate low heritability for this trait suggesting that fertility levels of contraceptive-resistant individuals will also have a low heritability. Slow evolution of contraception resistance might therefore be anticipated. The absence of information about relevant parameters makes the construction of quantitative models premature. We discuss factors in particular need of investigation if predictions about resistance evolution are to be made. These include: 1. the genetic basis of fertility retention, 2. the proportion of the population resistant to the contraceptive agent and how this is affected by gene flow from refuge populations, 3. the genetically-based fitness tradeoffs of resistant individuals that often accompany selection, 4. cross-generation effects that can thwart the effects of selection, and 5. the efficiency of delivery of the contraceptive agent. An understanding of the above for particular species, and the development of appropriate divergently acting multiple vaccines that can be used in temporal rotation or in mixtures, should facilitate the development of management options to minimize resistance evolution.

Specific and non-specific T-cell activation in high and low antibody-producing mice (selection IV-A)

The T-cell regulatory function has been evaluated in lines of mice genetically selected according to the High (H) and Low (L) antibody responsiveness to heterologous erythrocytes. The inhibition of antibody production following CD4+ subset depletion was stronger in L than in H mice. The dose of CD4-specific monoclonal antibody (MoAb) needed for a 50% inhibition of the anti-sheep erythrocyte antibody response was much lower in L mice, even when their responsiveness was improved by repeated antigen injections or by co-injection of lipopolysaccharide as an adjuvant. Lymph-node cells from L mice responded normally or even better than those from H mice to in vitro non-specific triggering via lectins, exogenous superantigens or CD3-specific MoAb. In contrast, the antigen-specific responses of the lymph-node cells from protein-primed mice were consistently lower in the Low responder mice. Altogether the results suggest that a defective stimulation of T helper lymphocytes by the antigen contributes to the weak antibody response of L mice.

Role of macrophages, interferon gamma and procoagulant activity in the resistance of genetic heterogeneous mouse populations to mouse hepatitis virus infection

Genetic heterogeneous mouse populations selected for high (HIII) and low (LIII) antibody response were used to study some aspects of mouse hepatitis virus 3 (MHV3) infection, such as the resistance pattern, virus replication in the liver and peritoneal exudate or in cultured peritoneal macrophages, the interferon (IFN) synthesis in the serum and peritoneal exudate and the procoagulant activity (PCA) of the peritoneal exudate (PEC) and spleen cells (SC). The HIII mice, when compared to their LIII mice counterparts, were susceptible to MHV3 infection showing higher virus titres in the liver and peritoneal exudate, comparable IFN alpha/beta or IFN gamma titres in the peritoneal exudate or in the serum, and higher levels of PCA of PEC and SC. A higher virus titre was detected in the supernatants of HIII mouse macrophages infected with MHV3. The activation of HIII mouse macrophages with LPS, IFN alpha/beta or IFN gamma, in contrast to that of LIII mouse macrophages, did not induce an antiviral effect with partial restriction of the MHV3 replication. The LPS antiviral activity was shown to be partially exerted by IFN alpha/beta synthesis. The IFN gamma was shown to be more effective in inducing an antiviral state in LIII macrophages, when compared to IFN alpha/beta. The data obtained are consistent with the notion that the resistance mechanisms to the MHV3 infection involve the PCA and the sensitivity of macrophages to IFN.

Salmonella typhimurium infection in high and low antibody responder mice: inverse correlation between antibody responsiveness and resistance to infection

Susceptibility to Salmonella typhimurium infection was compared in H (high Ab responder) and L (low Ab responder) mice obtained by several selective breeding experiments (Selections I, II, III, IV and IV A). H mice were always much more susceptible to infection than their L mice counterparts within a continuous LD 50 variation range. In three of the selections (I, II and IV A) the low responsiveness character is known to result mainly from rapid Ag degradation in L mice macrophages. It was hypothesized that resistance to multiplication of intracellular pathogens could be related to an increased catabolic activity towards Ag. This was actually demonstrated, in F2 segregant hybrids of selection IV A, by the significant inverse correlation between capacity for Ab production and resistance to infection.

Effect of silica on the genetic regulation of antibody responsiveness

The high (H) and low (L) antibody responder lines of mice produced by selective breeding are characterized by different modifications in immunocompetent cell potentialities, according to the immunization procedure used for the selection process. In selections I and II, the difference in antibody responsiveness between H and L lines was clearly shown to depend mainly on macrophage function: the more rapid catabolism of antigens in L mice was the main cause of the low antibody production. In contrast, up to now, no difference has been observed between H and L mice of selections III and IV in terms of the macrophage accessory role. The administration of silica particles has a well known impairment effect on macrophage activity. Therefore, the effect of silica injection on the kinetics of antibody responses to selection antigens was compared in H and L mice of the four selections. Silica was given either intravenously or locally in one hind footpad 6 or 24 h before immunization by the same route. Silica treatment consistently improved antibody responsiveness in the L mice of selections I and II, but had no effect in the L mice of selections III and IV. The antibody responses of the H lines of the four selections were not substantially modified by silica injections. Therefore, the silica treatment reduced the interline difference in antibody responses in selections I and II only, by interfering with the expression of the genetic modification of macrophage activity. However, a similar effect was not obtained with other substances known to affect macrophages, including dextran sulphate or carrageenan. The results reported here are in agreement with the above-mentioned statement that the genetic modification of macrophage function plays a major role in the interline difference in selections I and II and is not involved in selections III and IV.

Basal immunoglobulin serum concentration and isotype distribution in relation to the polygenic control of antibody responsiveness in mice

Serum Ig concentration and isotype distribution were determined in the high (H) and low (L) responder lines selected for antibody response to complex immunogens. Data were recorded in normal and postimmunization sera from the H and L lines produced by five independent selective breedings (selections I, II, III, IV, and V). Ig levels were much higher in H than in L mice of all the selections. In four selections this interline difference increased further after immunization with the selection antigens. This is in agreement with the general effect of the polygenic control of antibody responses operating in H and L lines. The Ig isotype profiles of normal sera were different in each line; however, similitudes were noticed between H and L lines in selections I and II. In contrast, in selections III, IV, and V a similar interline difference was observed: the lack of IgG2a isotype in L lines only. After immunization there were minor alterations of the isotype profiles except in the H lines of selections III and IV, in which a clear inverse modification of IgG1 and IgG2a proportions occurred. The characteristic pattern of each selection may be partially dependent on isotype-restricted regulatory effects in relation to the immunization procedure used for selective breeding.

An inverse relationship between heparin content and antibody response in genetically selected mice. Sex effect and evidence of a polygenic control for skin heparin concentration

The heparin content of genetically selected mice with high and low antibody response to bacterial antigens is reported. An inverse relationship between antibody titres and concentration of heparin was observed for both male and female mice. The lower-antibody-responder line contains twice as much heparin as the higher-responder ones. Furthermore, the female mice also contained twice as much heparin as the male mice. Genetic analysis of the parental and interline hybrids has shown a partial dominance for the character 'heparin content' in favour of the high-heparin phenotype and this character appears to be subjected to polygenic control. The possible biological role of heparin and/or mast cells in the surveillance of the organism against some pathogens is discussed in the light of these and other findings.

Genetic parameters of the polygenic regulation of antibody responsiveness to flagellar and somatic antigens of salmonellae

Selective breedings of mice were carried out for quantitative antibody responsiveness to flagellar Ag., f (Selection III) or somatic Ag., s (Selection IV) of two non cross-reacting Salmonellae (Salm. tm., Salm. or.) alternated for immunization of consecutive generations. At the selection limit, these selections produced homozygous high (H) and low (L) responder lines for the character investigated: peak agglutinin response to optimal secondary immunization. The responsiveness to both f and s Ags. is submitted to polygenic regulation. The heritability (h2) realized during the selective breeding was 0.37 +/- 0.07 for the response to fAg. and 0.40 +/- 0.1 for the response to s Ag. The respective part of genetic and environmental variance in F2 hybrids was 64% and 36% in selection III and 61% and 39% in selection IV. In the two selections, the dominance variance is negligible (less than 1%), therefore the genetic variance is essentially additive. The additive variance calculated as the heritable fraction of the F2 hybrid variance is somewhat lower, the reason for this difference is discussed. The quantitative antibody response to f Ag. in selection III is controlled by about seven independent loci. The antibody response to s Ag. in selection IV is controlled by about four independent loci. A possible association of relevant genes with the H-2 locus was investigated. In selection III, no significant participation if H-2 linked genes, in the regulation of responses to f and s Ags. of Salm. tm and Salm. or. could be demonstrated. In selection IV a partial contribution of H-2 linked genes was observed concerning responsiveness to both f and s Ags. of Salm. tm. but not Salm. or. Ags. The H-2 effect accounts for 25% of the total interline difference.

Evidence for distinct polygenic regulation of antibody responses to some unrelated antigens in lines of mice selected for high or low antibody responses to somatic antigen of Salmonella

The effect of the selective breeding of mice for high or low antibody production to complex immunogens is largely "nonspecific", since it modifies the responsiveness of high (H) and low (L) lines to many antigens unrelated to the selection antigen. However, the nonspecific effect of the polygenic control operating in these lines is not a general feature. For example, the group of genes in selection IV, carried out for responsiveness to somatic antigen of Salmonella, does not modify the responses to sheep erythrocytes (SE). Despite equivalent responses in H and L mice of selection IV, a large variability was found in individual responses of F2 interline hybrids, which demonstrates the presence of alleles with high or low effect on responses to SE. A selective breeding (Selection IV-A) was therefore initiated from this F2 population for responsiveness to SE.A progressive interline divergence occurred during the first seven generations of selection; the interline separation was due to polygenic regulation (about four independent loci from a preliminary estimate). Equivalent responses to the s antigen of Salmonella are observed in the two lines. This constitutes additional evidence for distinct polygenic regulation of responses to SE and to somatic antigen. Moreover, the pattern of responses to several unrelated antigens (nonspecific effect) also differs between Selections IV and IV-A.

Rabies virus immunity in genetically selected high- and low-responder lines of mice

The antibody responsiveness to and the specific vaccination effect of rabies virus infection were investigated in high- and low-responder lines of mice produced by two-way selective breedings for quantitative production of antibodies to flagellar (H/f and L/f lines) or somatic (H/s and L/s lines) antigens of salmonellae. After specific immunization, both high lines were more resistant to rabies virus infection than were the low lines, and the protector effect was related to the level of antibody produced, as demonstrated by neutralizing serum activity. The present findings confirm the nonspecific genetic modification of the general antibody responsiveness induced in high- and low-responder lines selected for quantitative antibody production.