Activation and hapten inhibition of mast cells sensitized with monoclonal IgE anti-penicillin antibodies: evidence for two-site recognition of the penicillin derived determinant

Classifying cephalosporins: from generation to cross-reactivity

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

To review the most recent literature studying the classifications, immunochemistry, and crossreactivity of allergy reactions to cephalosporins.

RECENT FINDINGS

Over the last five years, research interest has focused on three areas related to cephalosporin allergy: cross-reactivity among cephalosporins and with other beta-lactams; the incidence of adverse reactions in penicillin allergy patients or in reported penicillin allergy labels; and new cephalosporins structures involved in the immunological recognition.

SUMMARY

Meta-analysis of a substantial number of studies shows that cephalosporins are safer than previously thought. Evidence supports two main conclusions in that regard. First, there is a relatively low percentage of cross-reactivity between cephalosporins and other beta-lactams with penicillins in penicillin allergy patients. Second, there is a very low incidence of allergy reactions in nonselected as well as in selected penicillin allergy patients when cephalosporins are used prior to surgical intervention.On the other hand, few structures have been discovered related to the immune mechanism of cephalosporin allergy reactions, and these are far from being ready to use in clinical practice.

Design of a heterobivalent ligand to inhibit IgE clustering on mast cells

We describe the design, synthesis, and characterization of a heterobivalent ligand (HBL) system that competitively inhibits allergen binding to mast cell bound IgE antibody, thereby inhibiting mast cell degranulation. HBLs are composed of a hapten conjugated to a nucleotide analog allowing simultaneous targeting of the antigen-binding site as well the "unconventional nucleotide binding site" on IgE Fab domains. Simultaneous bivalent binding to both sites provides HBLs with over 100-fold enhancement both in avidity for IgE(DNP) (K(d) = 0.33 μM) and in inhibition of allergen binding to IgE(DNP) (IC(50) = 0.45 μM) than the monovalent hapten (K(d)(mono) = 41 μM; IC(50)(mono) = 55.4 μM, respectively). In cellular assays, HBL2 effectively inhibits mast cell degranulation (IC(50) = 15 μM), whereas no inhibition is detected by the monovalent hapten. In conclusion, this study establishes the use of multivalency in a novel HBL design to inhibit mast cell degranulation.

Cross-reactivity among drugs: clinical problems

Cross-reactivity among drugs is either mediated by immunologic mechanisms or not. The former kind is usually explained by the presence of common antigenic determinants in the cross-reacting drugs. In the case of compounds provoking non-allergic hypersensitivity reactions, cross-reactivity is explained by a common pharmacological characteristic, such as the inhibitory effect of non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs on cyclooxygenase-1 and the capability of muscle relaxants or contrast media to release histamine through a non-immunologic mechanism. The main clinical problem deriving from cross-reactivity among drugs is the compelling need to choose a potentially cross-reactive compound and, therefore, to assess cross-reactivity by diagnostic tests. In choosing alternative compounds, skin testing has been used in evaluating IgE-mediated cross-reactivity between penicillins and cephalosporins, as well as among muscle relaxants. In assessing T cell-mediated cross-reactivity among contrast media, corticosteroids, anticonvulsants and heparins, delayed-reading intradermal tests and patch tests, together with lymphocyte transformation tests, can be performed. Because of the limited sensitivity of in vivo and in vitro testing, the most prudent way of establishing the tolerability of a compound of the same group in patients who especially require one is a graded challenge when other allergologic tests are negative.

Drug interaction with T-cell receptors: T-cell receptor density determines degree of cross-reactivity

BACKGROUND

Immune-mediated adverse reactions to drugs are often due to T-cell reactivity, and cross-reactivity is an important problem in pharmacotherapy.

OBJECTIVE

We investigated whether chemical inert drugs can stimulate T cells through their T-cell receptor (TCR) and analyzed the cross-reactivities to related compounds.

METHODS

We transfected human TCRs isolated from two drug-reactive T-cell clones (TCCs) by PCR into a TCR-negative mouse T-cell hybridoma. The TCCs were isolated from a patient with drug hypersensitivity to the antibacterial sulfonamide sulfamethoxazole (SMX).

RESULTS

The transfectants reacted to SMX only in the presence of antigen-presenting cells (APCs). Glutaraldehyde-fixed APCs, however, were sufficient to elicit T-cell stimulation, indicating a processing-independent direct interaction of the drug with the TCR and MHC molecule. The transfected hybridomas secreted IL-2 in a drug dose-dependent manner, whereas the degree of reactivity was dependent on the level of TCR expression. One transfectant reacted not only to SMX but also to related sulfonamide compounds. Interestingly, high TCR expression increased cross-reactivity to other structurally related compounds. In addition, SMX-specific TCR cross-reacted only with sulfonamides bearing a sulfanilamide core structure but not with sulfonamides such as celecoxib, furosemide, or glibenclamide.

CONCLUSIONS

These results demonstrate that the T-cell reactivity to drugs is solely determined by the TCR. Moreover, these results show that cross-reactivity of structurally similar compounds correlates with the density of the TCR. Stably transfected T-cell hybridomas may represent a powerful screening tool for cross-reactivity of newly generated sulfonamide-containing compounds such as celecoxib.

Cross-reactivity with drugs at the T cell level

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Cross-reactivity with drugs is an important clinical problem in drug hypersensitivity. Once a patient is labeled 'drug-allergic' all drugs of the same class are withheld and future therapeutic interventions are limited. Here we review cross-reactivity with drugs at the T cell level.

RECENT FINDINGS

Analysis of T cell recognition of various classes of drugs (beta-lactam antibiotics, sulfonamides, local anesthetics) using T cell clones suggests that at the T cell level the whole structure, in particular the core and to a lesser degree side chains, are recognized.

SUMMARY

It is necessary to differentiate cross-reactivity mediated by T cells and antibodies as only the latter seem to recognize side chains exclusively.

Penicillin conjugates to interferon-gamma and reduces its activity: a novel drug-cytokine interaction

Beta-lactam antibiotics are the class of drug most frequently associated with IgE-mediated allergy but the mechanisms underlying this response are poorly understood. IFN-gamma is a key cytokine in immunity with regulatory actions on monocytes, NK cells, epithelial cells, and T and B lymphocytes. IFN-gamma promotes Th1 responses and inhibits Th2- and IgE-mediated responses. In this study we show, by Western blotting, that the prototype beta-lactam benzylpenicillin (BP) conjugates to human IFN-gamma but not to IL-4. The interaction of BP with IFN-gamma inhibited the cytokine's detection by immunoassay and impaired its activity, as assessed in three different assays: upregulation of MHC molecules on monocytes plus induction of nitric oxide synthesis and expression of monocyte chemoattractant protein-1 mRNA by epithelial cells. This is the first reported example of a direct drug-cytokine interaction and suggests a mechanism by which penicillin may disrupt IFN-gamma-dependent immune responses and promote allergy.

Clinical usefulness of patch and challenge tests in the diagnosis of cell-mediated allergy to betalactams

BACKGROUND

Literature reports dealing with cell-mediated allergy to betalactams have appeared with increasing frequency in the last years.

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate patients with such reactions and to identify cross-reactivities among betalactams in order to provide safe guidelines for their further clinical management.

METHODS

Thirty consecutive subjects with cell-mediated allergy to betalactams (history of adverse reactions to these antibiotics; serum total IgE within the normal range; absence of serum specific IgE antibodies to penicillin G and V, amoxicillin, and ampicillin; negative skin tests with a wide pattern of betalactam preparations; and positive patch-test to at least one betalactam antigenic determinant) were investigated. The subjects admitted to the study were patch tested with a wide variety of betalactam preparations in order to identify alternative molecules tolerated by the patient. To better evaluate the cross-reactivity pattern, tolerance challenges with patch-negative betalactams were also performed in each subject.

RESULTS

Both specific IgE and skin tests were negative in all patients. The skin biopsies performed on the positive patch-tested area in four patients showed a clear T-lymphocyte, CD4+-type infiltrate, thus definitely proving the occurrence of a cell-mediated response. A total of 44 adverse reactions (mean: 1.47 episodes for each patient) were reported in history, with a mean interval of 15 hours after betalactam administration. The reported symptoms were mainly cutaneous (maculo-papular rash and urticaria) and the responsible drugs were chiefly aminopenicillins (86.4% of cases) and penicillin G (9.1%). We were able to identify three separate groups of patients on the basis of clinical history, patch-test, and tolerance challenge pattern: allergy to the side chain of aminopenicillins in 16 patients (53.3%); allergy to the thiazolidine ring in 3 patients (10.0%); undetermined specificity in the remainder 11 patients (36.7%). Cross-reactivity among different betalactam molecules (revealed by positive tolerance tests performed with patch-negative betalactams) was found in 4.8% of cases only (23.3% of all investigated patients). This fact demonstrates a very high (95.2%) predictive value of a negative patch-test in excluding the occurrence of a cross-reactivity. The mis-match between patch and tolerance tests was observed in 3 out of 178 cases only (1.7% of cases, 10.5% of patients) in groups A and B, and in as much as 12.2% of cases (45.5% of subjects) in group C (P < .05).

CONCLUSIONS

Delayed allergy to betalactams (mainly to aminopenicillins) may be exerted by a cell-mediated response. Patch tests and tolerance challenges are extremely useful and safe for diagnosis and further clinical treatment of these patients, helping to identify safe alternative betalactam molecules that could be successfully tolerated by the allergic subjects.

[Exploration of 112 children suspected of amoxicillin allergy. Indications and efficacy of oral provocation test]

BACKGROUND

One to 10% of treatments using betalactams, particularly synthetic penicillin, are complicated by allergic reactions, usually cutaneous, and not easily imputable to immunologic sensitization in children.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

The aim of this study was to identify, using cutaneous and biological tests, those from a group of 112 children suspected of amoxicillin allergy (evidenced by rash) who were actually sensitized, and to confirm the absence of allergy in others by an oral provocation test (OPT) associated to a long-term survey. The cutaneous tests were made by prick test and intra-dermo reaction (IDR) with Allergopen and with amoxicillin or amoxicillin + clavulanic acid. The biological tests included examination for penicillin and amoxicillin antibodies by using various techniques including enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) immunoglobulin G (IgG) and IgE, FARR, radioallergo sorbent test (RAST) and a histaminoliberation. When these tests were negative, an OPT with the suspected antibiotic was subsequently performed.

RESULTS

Thirty-nine children (36.4%) confidently presented at least one positive cutaneous test (38 Allergopen, ten amoxicillin); 25 biological tests were positive (16 ELISA IgE, one ELISA IgG and eight histaminolibarations), seven times with negative cutaneous test. Forty-five children were judged to be sensitized to amoxicillin, with only one who subsequently took amoxicillin again. Among the 67 others, 52 received an OPT, six of them with moderate cutaneous reactions. Fifty-one (45.5%) children were allergic and 46 (41%) were allowed to take amoxicillin again; 17 did, one of them with a benign cutaneous reaction.

CONCLUSION

Efficacy and safety of this type of investigation seems clear; it will have to be confirmed by other studies.

Penicilloyl peptides are recognized as T cell antigenic determinants in penicillin allergy

Although hapten immune responses have been intensively studied in the mouse, very little is known about hapten determinants involved in human allergic reactions. Penicillins, as chemically reactive compounds of low molecular weight, constitute typical examples of hapten allergens for humans. Penicillins become immunogenic only after covalent binding to carrier proteins and in this form frequently induced IgE-mediated allergic reactions in patients subjected to antibiotic treatment. However, our previous data strongly indicated that penicillins also form part of the epitopes contacting the antigen receptors of beta lactam-specific T cells in allergic individuals. We have therefore investigated the molecular constraints involved in the T cell immune response to penicillin G (Pen G). Designer peptides containing a DRB1*0401-binding motif and covalently modified with Pen G via a lysine epsilon-amino group were found to induce proliferation of Pen G-specific T cell clones. A precise positioning of the hapten molecule on the peptide backbone was required for optimal T cell recognition. Furthermore, we extended these observations from our designer peptides to show that a peptide sequence derived from a natural DRB1*1101-binding peptide modified in vitro with Pen G, also acquired antigenic properties. Our data for the first time provide insight into the manner in which allergenic haptens are recognized by human T cells involved in allergic reactions to drugs and suggest possible mechanisms leading to the onset of these adverse immune responses.

T cell recognition of penicillin G: structural features determining antigenic specificity

Penicillin G (Pen G) and other beta-lactam antibiotics frequently induce allergic reactions constituting typical examples of human immune responses to haptens. In fact, penicillins represent a unique set of haptens with outstanding structural variability on the basis of an identical protein-reactive beta-lactam containing backbone. Although both cellular and humoral responses are involved in drug-induced allergies, little is known about the T cell reactivity to penicillins. To understand which structural features determine antigenic specificity, we isolated a panel of MHC-restricted, Pen G-reactive T cell clones from different penicillin-allergic patients and tested them for their capacity to proliferate in the presence of other penicillin derivatives. We found that the antigenic epitope consists of both the amide-linked side chain, which is different in every member of the penicillin family, as well as the thiazolidine ring common to all penicillin derivatives. We also demonstrated the presence of two different types of penicillin-specific T cells, one dependent, and the other independent of antigen processing by autologous antigen-presenting cells. Our data strongly suggest that penicillins form part of the epitopes contacting the antigen receptors of T cells.