Gene-specific criteria for PTEN variant curation: Recommendations from the ClinGen PTEN Expert Panel

Genomic diversity in functionally relevant genes modifies neurodevelopmental versus neoplastic risks in individuals with germline PTEN variants

Individuals with germline PTEN variants (PHTS) have increased risks of the seemingly disparate phenotypes of cancer and neurodevelopmental disorders (NDD), including autism spectrum disorder (ASD). Etiology of the phenotypic variability remains elusive. Here, we hypothesized that decreased genomic diversity, manifested by increased homozygosity, may be one etiology. Comprehensive analyses of 376 PHTS patients of European ancestry revealed significant enrichment of homozygous common variants in genes involved in inflammatory processes in the PHTS-NDD group and in genes involved in differentiation and chromatin structure regulation in the PHTS-ASD group. Pathway analysis revealed pathways germane to NDD/ASD, including neuroinflammation and synaptogenesis. Collapsing analysis of the homozygous variants identified suggestive modifier NDD/ASD genes. In contrast, we found enrichment of homozygous ultra-rare variants in genes modulating cell death in the PHTS-cancer group. Finally, homozygosity burden as a predictor of ASD versus cancer outcomes in our validated prediction model for NDD/ASD performed favorably.

A De Novo PTEN Pathogenic Variant in a Young Girl with Sporadic Cowden Syndrome-A Case Report

Cowden syndrome (CS) is a rare hereditary disorder characterized by benign overgrowth in various tissues and a high risk of breast and thyroid cancer. CS is closely associated with pathogenic variants (PVs) in the phosphatase and tensin homolog (PTEN) tumor suppressor gene. PVs in PTEN are usually inherited and estimates of de novo frequencies remain inconclusive. The diagnosis of PTEN-associated syndromes remains a challenge in clinical practice, due to patients showing seemingly unrelated symptoms. We report on the clinical management of a now 18-year-old female CS patient, who initially presented with macrosomia, motor development delay and later, lipomas on the abdominal wall. Genetic testing revealed a de novo PTEN PV c.1003C>T(p.Arg335X). The PV was detected in leukocyte DNA of the patient. Using direct DNA sequencing, as well as NGS, the PV was not found in any of the tissues derived from immediate family members. However, the PV was detected in multiple samples representing other germ layers of the affected patient, which renders constitutional mosaicism unlikely. This case constitutes the first description of a de novo PTEN PV, in which constitutional mosaicism was systematically ruled out and underscores the importance of timely genetic testing of patients and their relatives. The diagnosis of a PTEN PV in early childhood allows for the implementation of a comprehensive, lifelong care plan that addresses both pediatric and adult medical needs as well as cancer risk surveillance and family planning. This not only accounts for the affected patients, but also their close family members who might be susceptible to the same PV.

Clinical-Genetic Approach to Conditions with Macrocephaly and ASD/Behaviour Abnormalities: Variants in PTEN and PPP2R5D Are the Most Recurrent Gene Mutations in a Patient-Oriented Diagnostic Strategy

BACKGROUND

Macrocephaly can be a component manifestation of several monogenic conditions, in association with intellectual disability/developmental delay (ID/DD) behaviour abnormalities, including autism spectrum disorders (ASD), and variable additional features. On the other hand, idiopathic ASD can present with developmental delay and macrocephaly.

METHODS

We carried out a retrospective analysis of a cohort of 78 patients who were tested from February 2017 to December 2024 by high-throughput sequencing of a panel of 27 genes (ABCC9, AKT1, AKT2, AKT3, BRWD3, DIS3L2, DNMT3A, EZH2, GPC3, GPC4, HERC1, MED12, MTOR, NFIA, NFIX, NSD1, PDGFRB, PIK3CA, PIK3R1, PIK3R2, PPP2R1A, PPP2R5D, PTEN, RAB39B, RNF135, SETD2, and TBC1D7) because of neurodevelopmental impairment, including ID/DD, ASD/behaviour abnormalities associated with macrocephaly, mimicking to a large extent idiopathic ASD.

RESULTS

Pathogenic variants leading to the diagnosis of monogenic conditions were detected in 22 patients (28%), including NSD1 (2), PTEN (16), and PPP2R5D (4). Distinctive of the PTEN-associated phenotype were true macrocephaly (100%), ASD or behaviour abnormalities (92%), mild/borderline ID (79%), and no facial dysmorphisms. Typical of the PPP2R5D-associated phenotype were relative macrocephaly (75%), a few unspecific peculiar facial characteristics (50%), and a more variable presentation of the neurodevelopmental phenotype.

CONCLUSIONS

Pathogenic variants in PTEN and PPP2R5D are the most recurrent gene mutations in a patient-oriented procedure for the genetic diagnosis of apparently idiopathic ASD and behaviour abnormalities associated with macrocephaly. The clinical applicability of the presented diagnostic strategy is discussed.

Non-serous ovarian cancer in PTEN Hamartoma Tumor Syndrome: additional evidence for increased risk

Increased hereditary cancer risk is one of the hallmarks of PTEN Hamartoma Tumor Syndrome (PHTS) which is caused by a pathogenic germline variant in PTEN. Case reports and some cohort studies have described ovarian cancer (OC) in PHTS patients. Previously, we observed an enrichment of non-serous OC in PHTS compared to sporadic cases (3% vs 1%). However, ovarian cancer is currently not considered a PHTS-related cancer. The aim of this study was to describe five PHTS patients with a pathogenic germline variant in PTEN with non-serous OC. Three of the non-serous OCs were mucinous carcinomas (49, 51 and 52 years) and two were malignant germ cell tumors (8 and 15 years) and all were diagnosed before genetic testing and PHTS diagnosis. In addition to OC, the described patients developed other PHTS-related benign and malignant lesions. We provide further evidence that non-serous ovarian cancer, especially mucinous, endometrioid and malignant germ cell tumors should be further investigated as potential PHTS-related cancers.

Extended spectrum of cancers in PTEN hamartoma tumor syndrome

PTEN hamartoma tumor syndrome (PHTS) is associated with increased lifetime risks of breast, thyroid, kidney, endometrial, and colorectal cancers, as well as melanoma (collectively, component cancers). We sought to characterize non-component cancers (NCC) in PHTS. Of 701 research participants with PHTS, 340 (49%) had cancer, with 101 (30%) having at least one NCC. Interestingly, 71 (70%) of those with NCC had at least one other PHTS component malignancy. Patients with pathogenic PTEN variants showed higher risks for prostate cancer and soft tissue sarcomas at younger ages than the general population. A literature survey showed independent cases of NCC in PHTS, with PTEN-related molecular changes including second-hit somatic PTEN alterations in a subset of various specimens. We recommend increased awareness regarding NCC in individuals with PHTS, particularly increased risks for prostate cancer and sarcoma. Further studies are needed to define age-related penetrance and accordingly, the appropriate strategies for cancer risk management.

Exploring MRI and Mammography Lesion Features for Breast Cancer Detection in PTEN Hamartoma Tumor Syndrome

(1) Background/Objectives: Women with PTEN hamartoma tumor syndrome (PHTS) face a significantly increased risk of breast cancer (up to 66%) and a high prevalence of benign breast lesions (30-75%), which can complicate cancer detection and underscore the need for effective surveillance strategies. This study aimed to evaluate the imaging characteristics of breast cancers and benign breast lesions using magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and mammography, with the goal of improving early cancer detection, reducing unnecessary biopsies, and guiding future surveillance protocols. (2) Methods: This retrospective single-institution study included 65 PHTS women aged ≥18 years (2001-2021), 39 of whom participated in a high-risk breast cancer surveillance program. Imaging features of breast cancers from MRI and mammography (when available) and of benign breast lesions from MRI only were assessed independently by two breast radiologists and correlated with pathology reports. Sensitivity and performance of MRI and mammography in detecting breast cancers and benign breast lesions were analyzed using descriptive statistics and correlation analyses, with significance set at p < 0.05. (3) Results: Imaging was available for re-evaluation for 17 breast cancers (with MRI available for 10 cases and mammography for 15 cases) diagnosed in 11 women and 31 benign breast lesions (with MRI available for 29 cases and mammography for 26 cases) in 16 women. MRI identified 90% (9/10) of the breast cancers for which it was available as suspicious, with malignant features retrospectively identifiable in 50% of baseline scans. In comparison, mammography identified only 40% (6/15) of breast cancers and was notably less effective in women with dense breast tissue. For benign breast lesions, MRI identified all lesions (29/29), while mammography underperformed, correctly identifying only 58% (15/26). However, ambiguous enhancement features on MRI occasionally posed challenges in distinguishing between benign breast lesions and malignancies. (4) Conclusions: MRI significantly outperformed mammography in accurately characterizing both breast cancers and benign breast lesions in women with PHTS, particularly in younger women with dense breast tissue. These findings reinforce the critical role of MRI as the primary surveillance tool for this high-risk population, given that breast cancers in women with PHTS tend to exhibit typical malignant features on MRI. However, they also highlight the importance of careful interpretation of MRI findings for benign breast lesions and the need for additional strategies to minimize unnecessary interventions.

Cancer and disease profiles for PTEN pathogenic variants in Japanese population

A germline alteration in the PTEN gene causes a spectrum of disorders conceptualized as PTEN hamartoma tumor syndrome (PHTS), which show high risk of tumor development and a highly variable and complex phenotype. The diagnosis of PHTS is established in a proband by identification of a heterozygous germline PTEN pathogenic variant on molecular genetic testing. In this study, to understand more PTEN-associated clinical phenotype and PHTS in a Japanese population, we extracted 128 germline PTEN rare variants from 113,535 adult Japanese registered in Biobank Japan (BBJ), and categorized 29 pathogenic/likely pathogenic variants in 30 individuals (0.0264%) with ClinVar classifications and ACMG/AMP guideline for PTEN. We examined case-control association in 75,238 patients with various types of cancer and 38,297 non-cancer controls, and identified that PTEN pathogenic variants (PVs) were significantly associated with endometrial cancer (OR = 35.7, P = 9.73E-04) and marginally associated with female breast cancer (OR = 19.5, P = 3.92E-03), especially at young onset and with multiple cancers. We observed that among the 127 disease phenotypes the PTEN PV carriers had uterine fibroid, goiter, ovarian cyst, and epilepsy, which is consistent with PTEN-related phenotypes. We also found that weight/height were significantly higher in adult female carriers with PTEN PV (P = 3.1E-04 and P = 0.0014, respectively), which is consistent with overgrowth syndrome of PHTS. Our results indicate the phenotypical features associated with PTEN PVs in a Japanese population, especially female, and can contribute to the screening for PTEN variants and its associated several phenotypes.

Identification of a germline deep intronic PTEN-deletion leading to exonization through whole genome and targeted RNA sequencing

PTEN Hamartoma Tumor Syndrome (PHTS) is an autosomal dominant disorder characterized by high penetrance and significant phenotypic variability. In most patients, targeted high-throughput sequencing (HTS) approaches enable the detection of loss-of-function pathogenic variants in PTEN, a tumor suppressor gene acting as a negative regulator of the PI3K-AKT pathway. We describe a patient exhibiting a clinical phenotype strongly indicative of PHTS, yet lacking a molecular diagnosis through PTEN-targeted HTS. After several years of diagnostic uncertainty, trio whole genome sequencing (WGS) ultimately identified a de novo germline deep intronic 98 bp deletion in PTEN intron 5 (c.492 + 1671_492 + 1768del). Targeted RNA sequencing revealed the inclusion of a pseudoexon, resulting in a frameshift and predicted protein truncation at codon 171 (p.Val166Asnfs*6). These data underline the importance of WGS approaches in detecting deep intronic structural variants, that may be overlooked by conventional methods.

Cowden Syndrome and Oral Lesions: A Case Report Using MLPA

BACKGROUND Cowden syndrome is a genetic disorder that predisposes individuals to cancer and is characterized by hamartomas derived from 3 germ layers. Although the clinical signs can be pathognomonic, diagnosis is often aided by biopsies, histopathological examination of oral and cutaneous lesions, and genetic studies, including multiple ligation-dependent probe amplification (MLPA). CASE REPORT We report a case of a 35-year-old woman who manifested with multiple lesions in the buccal mucosa, dorsum of the tongue, and gums, along with papillomatous papules on her facial skin and the dorsal surfaces of her hands. These lesions were identified as hamartomas. Laboratory tests, including blood biometry, blood chemistry, and coagulation profiles, returned results within normal ranges. Her medical history revealed uterine fibroids, raising suspicion of Cowden syndrome. A genetic consultation confirmed the diagnosis, revealing a heterozygous PTEN deletion. CONCLUSIONS This case illustrates the importance of a multidisciplinary approach in diagnosing Cowden syndrome, especially the role of dental professionals in recognizing early clinical signs. Early diagnosis through genetic testing is crucial due to the patient's elevated risk of malignancies. Healthcare providers must remain vigilant to syndromes such as Cowden syndrome, particularly in patients with relevant family histories, to ensure timely intervention and comprehensive management.

Using multiplexed functional data to reduce variant classification inequities in underrepresented populations

BACKGROUND

Multiplexed Assays of Variant Effects (MAVEs) can test all possible single variants in a gene of interest. The resulting saturation-style functional data may help resolve variant classification disparities between populations, especially for Variants of Uncertain Significance (VUS).

METHODS

We analyzed clinical significance classifications in 213,663 individuals of European-like genetic ancestry versus 206,975 individuals of non-European-like genetic ancestry from All of Us and the Genome Aggregation Database. Then, we incorporated clinically calibrated MAVE data into the Clinical Genome Resource's Variant Curation Expert Panel rules to automate VUS reclassification for BRCA1, TP53, and PTEN.

RESULTS

Using two orthogonal statistical approaches, we show a higher prevalence (p ≤ 5.95e - 06) of VUS in individuals of non-European-like genetic ancestry across all medical specialties assessed in all three databases. Further, in the non-European-like genetic ancestry group, higher rates of Benign or Likely Benign and variants with no clinical designation (p ≤ 2.5e - 05) were found across many medical specialties, whereas Pathogenic or Likely Pathogenic assignments were increased in individuals of European-like genetic ancestry (p ≤ 2.5e - 05). Using MAVE data, we reclassified VUS in individuals of non-European-like genetic ancestry at a significantly higher rate in comparison to reclassified VUS from European-like genetic ancestry (p = 9.1e - 03) effectively compensating for the VUS disparity. Further, essential code analysis showed equitable impact of MAVE evidence codes but inequitable impact of allele frequency (p = 7.47e - 06) and computational predictor (p = 6.92e - 05) evidence codes for individuals of non-European-like genetic ancestry.

CONCLUSIONS

Generation of saturation-style MAVE data should be a priority to reduce VUS disparities and produce equitable training data for future computational predictors.

Unrecognised actionability for breast cancer risk variants identified in a national-level review of Australian familial cancer centres

Breast cancer remains a significant global health challenge. In Australia, the adoption of publicly-funded multigene panel testing for eligible cancer patients has increased accessibility to personalised care, yet has also highlighted the increasing prevalence of variants of uncertain significance (VUS), complicating clinical decision-making. This project aimed to explore the spectrum and actionability of breast cancer VUS in Australian familial cancer centers (FCCs). Leveraging data from 11 FCCs participating in the Inherited Cancer Connect database, we retrieved VUS results from 1472 patients. Through ClinVar crosschecks and application of gene-specific ACMG/AMP guidelines, we showed the potential for reclassification of 4% of unique VUS as pathogenic or likely pathogenic, and 80% as benign or likely benign. Surveys conducted with FCCs and diagnostic laboratories described current practices and challenges in variant reclassifications, highlighting resource constraints preventing periodic VUS review and notifications from the laboratories to the FCCs. Our study suggests there are benefits to routine VUS review and reclassification, particularly in publicly-funded healthcare systems. Future research should focus on assessing the clinical impact and cost-effectiveness of implementing routine variant review practices, alongside efforts to enhance communication between FCCs and laboratories.

Canadian College of Medical Geneticists: clinical practice advisory document - responsibility to recontact for reinterpretation of clinical genetic testing

BACKGROUND

Advances in technology and knowledge have facilitated both an increase in the number of patient variants reported and variants reclassified. While there is currently no duty to recontact for reclassified genetic variants, there may be a responsibility. The purpose of this clinical practice advisory document is to provide healthcare practitioners guidance for recontact of previously identified and classified variants, suggest methods for recontact, and principles to consider, taking account patient safety, feasibility, ethical considerations, health service capacity and resource constraints. The target audience are practitioners who order genetic testing, follow patients who have undergone genetic testing and those analysing and reporting genetic testing.

METHODS

A multidisciplinary group of laboratory and ordering clinicians, patient representatives, ethics and legal researchers and a genetic counsellor from the Canadian Association of Genetic Counsellors reviewed the existing literature and guidelines on responsibility to recontact in a clinical context to make recommendations. Comments were collected from the Canadian College of Medical Geneticists (CCMG) Education, Ethics, and Public Policy, Clinical Practice and Laboratory Practice committees, and the membership at large.

RESULTS

Following incorporation of feedback, and external review by the Canadian Association of Genetic Counsellors and patient groups, the document was approved by the CCMG Board of Directors. The CCMG is the Canadian organisation responsible for certifying laboratory and medical geneticists who provide medical genetics services, and for establishing professional and ethical standards for clinical genetics services in Canada.

CONCLUSION

The document describes the ethical and practical factors and suggests a shared responsibility between patients, ordering clinician and laboratory practitioners.

Classification of PTEN germline non-truncating variants: a new approach to interpretation

BACKGROUND

PTEN hamartoma tumour syndrome (PHTS) encompasses distinct syndromes, including Cowden syndrome resulting from PTEN pathogenic variants. Missense variants account for 30% of PHTS cases, but their classification remains challenging. To address these difficulties, guidelines were published by the Clinical Genome Resource PTEN Variant Curation Expert Panel.

METHODS

Between 2010 and 2020, the Bergonie Institute reference laboratory identified 76 different non-truncating PTEN variants in 166 patients, 17 of which have not previously been reported. Variants were initially classified following the current guidelines. Subsequently, a new classification method was developed based on four main criteria: functional exploration, phenotypic features and familial segregation, in silico modelling, and allelic frequency.

RESULTS

This new method of classification is more discriminative and reclassifies 25 variants, including 8 variants of unknown significance.

CONCLUSION

This report proposes a revision of the current PTEN variant classification criteria which at present rely on functional tests evaluating only the phosphatase activity of PTEN and apply a particularly stringent clinical PHTS score.The classification of non-truncating variants of PTEN is facilitated by taking into consideration protein stability for variants with intact phosphatase activity, clinical and segregation criteria adapted to the phenotypic variability of PHTS and by specifying the allelic frequency of variants in the general population. This novel method of classification remains to be validated in a prospective cohort.

The Genomic Landscape of Benign and Malignant Thyroid Tumors from Individuals Carrying Germline PTEN Variants Is Distinct from Sporadic Thyroid Cancers

Patients with PTEN hamartoma tumor syndrome (PHTS), a molecular diagnosis for those carrying germline PTEN pathogenic variants, have a high prevalence of benign and malignant thyroid disease. Characterizing the genomic landscape in PHTS thyroid tumors could provide insights into malignant potential and tumor progression to help optimize diagnosis, surveillance, and treatment in this population. To reveal the somatic alterations in PHTS-associated thyroid tumors, we conducted exome sequencing on 58 thyroid tumors (28 cancers, 30 benign nodules) from 19 patients with PHTS. A control cohort of 447 sporadic papillary thyroid cancers (PTC) from The Cancer Genome Atlas was used for comparison. PHTS-associated thyroid tumors had a unique genomic landscape in the setting of a pathogenic germline PTEN mutation, when compared with the general population. PHTS-associated thyroid tumors demonstrated a high frequency of second-hit somatic PTEN alterations, including variants and loss-of-heterozygosity events. Second-hit somatic PTEN alterations were more prevalent in PHTS-associated PTC than sporadic PTC (65.2% vs. 0.067%), occurring frequently in PHTS-associated follicular thyroid cancer (100%) and benign follicular nodules (90%). PHTS-associated PTC additionally harbored somatic alterations in BRAF, RAS family members, and genes associated with DNA double-stranded break repair, as well as somatic arm-level copy-number variations. Together, these findings suggest that biallelic PTEN alterations may function as foundational mutations in PHTS thyroid tissue, promoting benign growth and increasing potential for malignant transformation through impaired DNA double-stranded break repair and increased genomic instability. The unique genomic landscape of PHTS-associated thyroid tumors carries implications for molecular-targeted therapies for patients. Significance: Exome sequencing reveals the distinct mutational landscape of PTEN hamartoma tumor syndrome-associated thyroid cancers from sporadic counterparts, providing insights into tumor progression and behavior that could help improve diagnosis, surveillance, and treatment.

Assigning credit where it is due: an information content score to capture the clinical value of multiplexed assays of variant effect

BACKGROUND

A variant can be pathogenic or benign with relation to a human disease. Current classification categories from benign to pathogenic reflect a probabilistic summary of the current understanding. A primary metric of clinical utility for multiplexed assays of variant effect (MAVE) is the number of variants that can be reclassified from uncertain significance (VUS). However, a gap in this measure of utility is that it underrepresents the information gained from MAVEs. The aim of this study was to develop an improved quantification metric for MAVE utility. We propose adopting an information content approach that includes data that does not reclassify variants will better reflect true information gain. We adopted an information content approach to evaluate the information gain, in bits, for MAVEs of BRCA1, PTEN, and TP53. Here, one bit represents the amount of information required to completely classify a single variant starting from no information.

RESULTS

BRCA1 MAVEs produced a total of 831.2 bits of information, 6.58% of the total missense information in BRCA1 and a 22-fold increase over the information that only contributed to VUS reclassification. PTEN MAVEs produced 2059.6 bits of information which represents 32.8% of the total missense information in PTEN and an 85-fold increase over the information that contributed to VUS reclassification. TP53 MAVEs produced 277.8 bits of information which represents 6.22% of the total missense information in TP53 and a 3.5-fold increase over the information that contributed to VUS reclassification.

CONCLUSIONS

An information content approach will more accurately portray information gained through MAVE mapping efforts than by counting the number of variants reclassified. This information content approach may also help define the impact of guideline changes that modify the information definitions used to classify groups of variants.

Co-observation of germline pathogenic variants in breast cancer predisposition genes: Results from analysis of the BRIDGES sequencing dataset

Co-observation of a gene variant with a pathogenic variant in another gene that explains the disease presentation has been designated as evidence against pathogenicity for commonly used variant classification guidelines. Multiple variant curation expert panels have specified, from consensus opinion, that this evidence type is not applicable for the classification of breast cancer predisposition gene variants. Statistical analysis of sequence data for 55,815 individuals diagnosed with breast cancer from the BRIDGES sequencing project was undertaken to formally assess the utility of co-observation data for germline variant classification. Our analysis included expected loss-of-function variants in 11 breast cancer predisposition genes and pathogenic missense variants in BRCA1, BRCA2, and TP53. We assessed whether co-observation of pathogenic variants in two different genes occurred more or less often than expected under the assumption of independence. Co-observation of pathogenic variants in each of BRCA1, BRCA2, and PALB2 with the remaining genes was less frequent than expected. This evidence for depletion remained after adjustment for age at diagnosis, study design (familial versus population-based), and country. Co-observation of a variant of uncertain significance in BRCA1, BRCA2, or PALB2 with a pathogenic variant in another breast cancer gene equated to supporting evidence against pathogenicity following criterion strength assignment based on the likelihood ratio and showed utility in reclassification of missense BRCA1 and BRCA2 variants identified in BRIDGES. Our approach has applicability for assessing the value of co-observation as a predictor of variant pathogenicity in other clinical contexts, including for gene-specific guidelines developed by ClinGen Variant Curation Expert Panels.

Cerebral dural arteriovenous fistulas in patients with PTEN-related hamartoma tumor syndrome

Central nervous system (CNS) dural arteriovenous fistulas (DAVF) have been reported in PTEN-related hamartoma tumor syndrome (PHTS). However, PHTS-associated DAVF remain an underexplored field of the PHTS clinical landscape. Here, we studied cases with a PTEN pathogenic variant identified between 2007 and 2020 in our laboratory (n = 58), and for whom brain imaging was available. Two patients had DAVF (2/58, 3.4%), both presenting at advanced stages: a 34-year-old man with a left lateral sinus DAVF at immediate risk of hemorrhage, and a 21-year-old woman with acute intracranial hypertension due to a torcular DAVF. Interestingly, not all patients had 3D TOF/MRA, the optimal sequences to detect DAVF. Early diagnosis of DAVF can be lifesaving, and is easier to treat compared to developed, proliferative, or complex lesions. As a result, one should consider brain MRI with 3D TOF/MRA in PHTS patients at genetic diagnosis, with subsequent surveillance on a case-by-case basis.

Defining and Reducing Variant Classification Disparities

Background

Multiplexed Assays of Variant Effects (MAVEs) can test all possible single variants in a gene of interest. The resulting saturation-style data may help resolve variant classification disparities between populations, especially for variants of uncertain significance (VUS).

Methods

We analyzed clinical significance classifications in 213,663 individuals of European-like genetic ancestry versus 206,975 individuals of non-European-like genetic ancestry from All of Us and the Genome Aggregation Database. Then, we incorporated clinically calibrated MAVE data into the Clinical Genome Resource's Variant Curation Expert Panel rules to automate VUS reclassification for BRCA1, TP53, and PTEN .

Results

Using two orthogonal statistical approaches, we show a higher prevalence ( p ≤5.95e-06) of VUS in individuals of non-European-like genetic ancestry across all medical specialties assessed in all three databases. Further, in the non-European-like genetic ancestry group, higher rates of Benign or Likely Benign and variants with no clinical designation ( p ≤2.5e-05) were found across many medical specialties, whereas Pathogenic or Likely Pathogenic assignments were higher in individuals of European-like genetic ancestry ( p ≤2.5e-05). Using MAVE data, we reclassified VUS in individuals of non-European-like genetic ancestry at a significantly higher rate in comparison to reclassified VUS from European-like genetic ancestry ( p =9.1e-03) effectively compensating for the VUS disparity. Further, essential code analysis showed equitable impact of MAVE evidence codes but inequitable impact of allele frequency ( p =7.47e-06) and computational predictor ( p =6.92e-05) evidence codes for individuals of non-European-like genetic ancestry.

Conclusions

Generation of saturation-style MAVE data should be a priority to reduce VUS disparities and produce equitable training data for future computational predictors.

Disease-Causing TIMP3 Variants and Deep Phenotyping of Two Czech Families with Sorsby Fundus Dystrophy Associated with Novel p.(Tyr152Cys) Mutation

We aim to report the ocular phenotype and molecular genetic findings in two Czech families with Sorsby fundus dystrophy and to review all the reported TIMP3 pathogenic variants. Two probands with Sorsby fundus dystrophy and three first-degree relatives underwent ocular examination and retinal imaging, including optical coherence tomography angiography. The DNA of the first proband was screened using a targeted ocular gene panel, while, in the second proband, direct sequencing of the TIMP3 coding region was performed. Sanger sequencing was also used for segregation analysis within the families. All the previously reported TIMP3 variants were reviewed using the American College of Medical Genetics and the Association for Molecular Pathology interpretation framework. A novel heterozygous variant, c.455A>G p.(Tyr152Cys), in TIMP3 was identified in both families and potentially de novo in one. Optical coherence tomography angiography documented in one patient the development of a choroidal neovascular membrane at 54 years. Including this study, 23 heterozygous variants in TIMP3 have been reported as disease-causing. Application of gene-specific criteria denoted eleven variants as pathogenic, eleven as likely pathogenic, and one as a variant of unknown significance. Our study expands the spectrum of TIMP3 pathogenic variants and highlights the importance of optical coherence tomography angiography for early detection of choroidal neovascular membranes.

Tracking updates in clinical databases increases efficiency for variant reanalysis

Purpose

Variant interpretation, guided by American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics guidelines, can inform clinical decision-making. However, interpretations may change over time for a variety of reasons. Periodic reanalysis of previous variant interpretations is important to ensure that reported genetic findings remain accurate according to current knowledge.

Methods

We performed automated filtering by comparing ClinVar variants available in August 2020 with those from August 2021 to screen for potential reanalysis candidates from 3 projects. These variants were subsequently interpreted based on the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics/Association for Molecular Pathology variant interpretation guideline or ClinGen revised gene-specific guidelines if applicable.

Results

Our method annotated 241 unique variants requiring reanalysis, from 3 projects containing 3,832,210 previously interpreted variants, including those filtered automatically. Among these 241 variants, 43 variants changed interpretation, including 55.81% (N = 24) with upgraded and 44.19% (N = 19) with downgraded classifications. An efficiency study showed that our strategy increased the reanalysis efficiency and saved reviewing time.

Conclusion

We demonstrated an effective high-throughput method, initiating from external data updates, to achieve variant reanalysis in a clinical laboratory. This filtering method reduced the number of variants that need to be reanalyzed, screened potential variants, and saved time and cost for clinical laboratories.

Gene-specific ACMG/AMP classification criteria for germline APC variants: Recommendations from the ClinGen InSiGHT Hereditary Colorectal Cancer/Polyposis Variant Curation Expert Panel

PURPOSE

The Hereditary Colorectal Cancer/Polyposis Variant Curation Expert Panel (VCEP) was established by the International Society for Gastrointestinal Hereditary Tumours and the Clinical Genome Resource, who set out to develop recommendations for the interpretation of germline APC variants underlying Familial Adenomatous Polyposis, the most frequent hereditary polyposis syndrome.

METHODS

Through a rigorous process of database analysis, literature review, and expert elicitation, the APC VCEP derived gene-specific modifications to the ACMG/AMP (American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics and Association for Molecular Pathology) variant classification guidelines and validated such criteria through the pilot classification of 58 variants.

RESULTS

The APC-specific criteria represented gene- and disease-informed specifications, including a quantitative approach to allele frequency thresholds, a stepwise decision tool for truncating variants, and semiquantitative evaluations of experimental and clinical data. Using the APC-specific criteria, 47% (27/58) of pilot variants were reclassified including 14 previous variants of uncertain significance (VUS).

CONCLUSION

The APC-specific ACMG/AMP criteria preserved the classification of well-characterized variants on ClinVar while substantially reducing the number of VUS by 56% (14/25). Moving forward, the APC VCEP will continue to interpret prioritized lists of VUS, the results of which will represent the most authoritative variant classification for widespread clinical use.

Evaluating ClinGen variant curation expert panels' application of PVS1 code

BACKGROUND

The 2015 American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics (ACMG) and Association for Molecular Pathology (AMP) guidelines articulates that the effects of certain types of variants on gene function can often be seen as a complete absence of the gene product by leading to a lack of transcription or nonsense-mediated decay(NMD). However, detailed information considering different types of loss of function(LOF) variants, refined steps assimilating details concerning location of variant, changes in strength levels, NMD boundary, or any additional information pointing to a true null effect, were all left to expert judgement. As part of its Clinical Genome Resource (ClinGen) initiative, Variant Curation Expert Panels (VCEPs) are designated to make gene/disease-centric specifications in accordance with the ACMG/AMP guidelines, including a more detailed definition of what constitutes an appropriate LOF evidence. Our goal was to evaluate the current LOF guidelines developed by the VCEPs and analyse the prior curated variants concerning the PVS1 criteria, bringing people occupied in genetic data analysis a comprehensive understanding of this code.

METHODS

Our study evaluated 7 VCEPs for their LOF criteria (PVS1). Subsequently, we assessed the predictive criteria by considering the underlying disease mechanism, protein transcript, and variant types delineated. Then, we meticulously curated the LOF evidence referenced by each VCEP in their preliminary variant classification, thereby scrutinizing the recommendations put forth by VCEPs and their application in the interpretation of the aforementioned predictive criteria. Based on these, an extensive curation of evidence summary considering PVS1 applied by VCEPs according to their classification of pilot variants for the purpose of analyzing VCEP criteria specifications and their use in the understanding of LOF was conducted.

RESULTS

We observed in this article that the VCEPs discussed followed the majority of Sequence Variant Interpretation (SVI) recommendations concerning the application of this LOF criteria, except for some disease/gene specific considerations. We highlighted the wide range of PVS1 strength levels approved by VCEP, reflecting the diversity of evidence for each variants type. In addition, we observed substantial differences in the approach used to determine relative strengths for different types of null variants and in the attitude towards these principles concerning variant location, NMD and influence to protein function between VCEPs.

CONCLUSIONS

It is difficult to understand the intricacies of the predictive data(PVS1), which often requires expert-level knowledge of disease/gene. The VCEP criteria specifications for the predictive evidence play an important role in making it more accessible for the curators to apply the predictive data by providing details concerning this complex criteria. Despite this, we believe there is a need for more guidance on standardizing this process and ensuring consistency in the application of this predictive evidence.

Identification of c.104T>G, p.Met35Arg (NM_00314.8) heterozygous variant in exon 2 of PTEN as the causative factor for Cowden syndrome: a medical case study

A representative case of Cowden syndrome with florid mucocutaneous manifestations is presented. A genetic study revealed the c.104T&gt;G, p.Met35Arg (NM_00314.8) heterozygous variant in exon 2 of PTEN. A satisfactory response of skin lesions to sirolimus was obtained.

Variant spectrum of F8 and F9 in hemophilia patients from southern China and 26 novel variants

Hemophilia, an X-linked recessive disorder, is characterized by spontaneous or trauma-induced prolonged bleeding. It is classified as hemophilia A when caused by variants in the F8 gene, and hemophilia B when caused by F9 variants. Few studies have described hemophilia variants in the Chinese population. This study aimed to investigate the clinical and genetic profiles of 193 hemophilia patients from southern China. Utilizing Sanger sequencing, multiplex ligation-dependent probe amplification, gap detection, long-range PCR, and multiplex PCR, we identified both F8 and F9 gene variants. Pregnant women with a history of hemophilia A offspring underwent amniocentesis or villus sampling for the variant detection. Variants in F8 and F9 were pinpointed in 183 patients, with 26 being novel discoveries. Notably, genetic testing was absent in the initial evaluation of 133 out of 161 patients, leading to a protracted average definitive diagnosis timeline of 2 years. Remarkably, two hemophilia A cases with anticipated severe phenotypes due to protein-truncating variants presented with only moderate or mild clinical manifestations. Among the 40 fetuses tested, 34 were males, with 17 exhibiting hemizygous variants in the F8 gene. Our results contribute to the broader understanding of F8 and F9 variant spectrum and highlight the underuse of genetic analyses in southern China.

Quantitative thresholds for variant enrichment in 13,845 cases: improving pathogenicity classification in genetic hearing loss

BACKGROUND

The American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics (ACMG)/Association for Molecular Pathology (AMP) guidelines recommend using variant enrichment among cases as "strong" evidence for pathogenicity per the PS4 criterion. However, quantitative support for PS4 thresholds from real-world Mendelian case-control cohorts is lacking.

METHODS

To address this gap, we evaluated and established PS4 thresholds using data from the Chinese Deafness Genetics Consortium. A total of 9,050 variants from 13,845 patients with hearing loss (HL) and 6,570 ancestry-matched controls were analyzed. Positive likelihood ratio and local positive likelihood ratio values were calculated to determine the thresholds corresponding to each strength of evidence across three variant subsets.

RESULTS

In subset 1, consisting of variants present in both cases and controls with an allele frequency (AF) in cases ≥ 0.0005, an odds ratio (OR) ≥ 6 achieved strong evidence, while OR ≥ 3 represented moderate evidence. For subset 2, which encompassed variants present in both cases and controls with a case AF < 0.0005, and subset 3, comprising variants found only in cases and absent from controls, we defined the PS4_Supporting threshold (OR > 2.27 or allele count ≥ 3) and the PS4_Moderate threshold (allele count ≥ 6), respectively. Reanalysis applying the adjusted PS4 criteria changed the classification of 15 variants and enabled diagnosis of an additional four patients.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study quantified evidence strength thresholds for variant enrichment in genetic HL cases, highlighting the importance of defining disease/gene-specific thresholds to improve the precision and accuracy of clinical genetic testing.

Genomic diversity in functionally relevant genes modifies neurodevelopmental versus neoplastic risks in individuals with germline PTEN variants

Individuals with germline PTEN variants (PHTS) have increased risks of the seemingly disparate phenotypes of cancer and neurodevelopmental disorders (NDD), including autism spectrum disorder (ASD). Etiology of the phenotypic variability remains elusive. Here, we hypothesized that decreased genomic diversity, manifested by increased homozygosity, may be one etiology. Comprehensive analyses of 376 PHTS patients of European ancestry revealed significant enrichment of homozygous common variants in genes involved in inflammatory processes in the PHTS-NDD group and in genes involved in differentiation and chromatin structure regulation in the PHTS-ASD group. Pathway analysis revealed pathways germane to NDD/ASD, including neuroinflammation and synaptogenesis. Collapsing analysis of the homozygous variants identified suggestive modifier NDD/ASD genes. In contrast, we found enrichment of homozygous ultra-rare variants in genes modulating cell death in the PHTS-cancer group. Finally, homozygosity burden as a predictor of ASD versus cancer outcomes in our validated prediction model for NDD/ASD performed favorably.

Assigning credit where it's due: An information content score to capture the clinical value of Multiplexed Assays of Variant Effect

Background

A variant can be pathogenic or benign with relation to a human disease. Current classification categories from benign to pathogenic reflect a probabilistic summary of current understanding. A primary metric of clinical utility for multiplexed assays of variant effect (MAVE) is the number of variants that can be reclassified from uncertain significance (VUS). However, we hypothesized that this measure of utility underrepresents the information gained from MAVEs and that an information theory approach which includes data that does not reclassify variants will better reflect true information gain. We used this information theory approach to evaluate the information gain, in bits, for MAVEs of BRCA1, PTEN, and TP53. Here, one bit represents the amount of information required to completely classify a single variant starting from no information.

Results

BRCA1 MAVEs produced a total of 831.2 bits of information, 6.58% of the total missense information in BRCA1 and a 22-fold increase over the information that only contributed to VUS reclassification. PTEN MAVEs produced 2059.6 bits of information which represents 32.8% of the total missense information in PTEN and an 85-fold increase over the information that contributed to VUS reclassification. TP53 MAVEs produced 277.8 bits of information which represents 6.22% of the total missense information in TP53 and a 3.5-fold increase over the information that contributed to VUS reclassification.

Conclusions

An information content approach will more accurately portray information gained through MAVE mapping efforts than counting the number of variants reclassified. This information content approach may also help define the impact of modifying information definitions used to classify many variants, such as guideline rule changes.

Recommendations for the classification of germline variants in the exonuclease domain of POLE and POLD1

BACKGROUND

Germline variants affecting the proofreading activity of polymerases epsilon and delta cause a hereditary cancer and adenomatous polyposis syndrome characterized by tumors with a high mutational burden and a specific mutational spectrum. In addition to the implementation of multiple pieces of evidence for the classification of gene variants, POLE and POLD1 variant classification is particularly challenging given that non-disruptive variants affecting the proofreading activity of the corresponding polymerase are the ones associated with cancer. In response to an evident need in the field, we have developed gene-specific variant classification recommendations, based on the ACMG/AMP (American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics/Association for Molecular Pathology) criteria, for the assessment of non-disruptive variants located in the sequence coding for the exonuclease domain of the polymerases.

METHODS

A training set of 23 variants considered pathogenic or benign was used to define the usability and strength of the ACMG/AMP criteria. Population frequencies, computational predictions, co-segregation data, phenotypic and tumor data, and functional results, among other features, were considered.

RESULTS

Gene-specific variant classification recommendations for non-disruptive variants located in the exonuclease domain of POLE and POLD1 were defined. The resulting recommendations were applied to 128 exonuclease domain variants reported in the literature and/or public databases. A total of 17 variants were classified as pathogenic or likely pathogenic, and 17 as benign or likely benign.

CONCLUSIONS

Our recommendations, with room for improvement in the coming years as more information become available on carrier families, tumor molecular characteristics and functional assays, are intended to serve the clinical and scientific communities and help improve diagnostic performance, avoiding variant misclassifications.

Identification of a novel pathogenic deep intronic variant in PTEN resulting in pseudoexon inclusion in a patient with juvenile polyps

Colorectal, hamartomatous juvenile polyps occur as part of different hereditary syndromes, including Juvenile polyposis syndrome and PTEN-hamartoma tumour syndrome. However, based on clinical manifestations alone, it is difficult to differentiate between the syndromes, and genetic analysis with an NGS-panel is often used to aid diagnostics. We report a 59-year-old male with colorectal juvenile polyps, who had been referred to genetic testing but had normal genetic analysis. He did not fulfil the clinical criteria of PTEN- hamartoma tumour syndrome, but the clinical criteria of Juvenile polyposis syndrome. With Whole Genome Sequencing we detected a novel intronic variant of unknown significance in PTEN (NC_000010.11:g.89687361 A > G(chr10, hg19), NM_000314.8:c.209 + 2047 A > G). RNA analysis classified the variant as likely pathogenic as it results in a pseudoexon inclusion introducing a frameshift and a premature stop codon. The patient was then diagnosed with PTEN-hamartoma Tumour syndrome. To our knowledge this is the first report of a variant resulting in pseudoexon inclusion in PTEN.

Precision medicine in rare diseases: What is next?

Molecular diagnostics is a cornerstone of modern precision medicine, broadly understood as tailoring an individual's treatment, follow-up, and care based on molecular data. In rare diseases (RDs), molecular diagnoses reveal valuable information about the cause of symptoms, disease progression, familial risk, and in certain cases, unlock access to targeted therapies. Due to decreasing DNA sequencing costs, genome sequencing (GS) is emerging as the primary method for precision diagnostics in RDs. Several ongoing European initiatives for precision medicine have chosen GS as their method of choice. Recent research supports the role for GS as first-line genetic investigation in individuals with suspected RD, due to its improved diagnostic yield compared to other methods. Moreover, GS can detect a broad range of genetic aberrations including those in noncoding regions, producing comprehensive data that can be periodically reanalyzed for years to come when further evidence emerges. Indeed, targeted drug development and repurposing of medicines can be accelerated as more individuals with RDs receive a molecular diagnosis. Multidisciplinary teams in which clinical specialists collaborate with geneticists, genomics education of professionals and the public, and dialogue with patient advocacy groups are essential elements for the integration of precision medicine into clinical practice worldwide. It is also paramount that large research projects share genetic data and leverage novel technologies to fully diagnose individuals with RDs. In conclusion, GS increases diagnostic yields and is a crucial step toward precision medicine for RDs. Its clinical implementation will enable better patient management, unlock targeted therapies, and guide the development of innovative treatments.

DECIPHER: Improving Genetic Diagnosis Through Dynamic Integration of Genomic and Clinical Data

DECIPHER (Database of Genomic Variation and Phenotype in Humans Using Ensembl Resources) shares candidate diagnostic variants and phenotypic data from patients with genetic disorders to facilitate research and improve the diagnosis, management, and therapy of rare diseases. The platform sits at the boundary between genomic research and the clinical community. DECIPHER aims to ensure that the most up-to-date data are made rapidly available within its interpretation interfaces to improve clinical care. Newly integrated cardiac case-control data that provide evidence of gene-disease associations and inform variant interpretation exemplify this mission. New research resources are presented in a format optimized for use by a broad range of professionals supporting the delivery of genomic medicine. The interfaces within DECIPHER integrate and contextualize variant and phenotypic data, helping to determine a robust clinico-molecular diagnosis for rare-disease patients, which combines both variant classification and clinical fit. DECIPHER supports discovery research, connecting individuals within the rare-disease community to pursue hypothesis-driven research.

Specifications of the ACMG/AMP Variant Classification Guidelines for Germline DICER1 Variant Curation

Germline pathogenic variants in DICER1 predispose individuals to develop a variety of benign and malignant tumors. Accurate variant curation and classification is essential for reliable diagnosis of DICER1-related tumor predisposition and identification of individuals who may benefit from surveillance. Since 2015, most labs have followed the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics and the Association for Molecular Pathology (ACMG/AMP) sequence variant classification guidelines for DICER1 germline variant curation. However, these general guidelines lack gene-specific nuances and leave room for subjectivity. Consequently, a group of DICER1 experts joined ClinGen to form the DICER1 and miRNA-Processing Genes Variant Curation Expert Panel (VCEP), to create DICER1- specific ACMG/AMP guidelines for germline variant curation. The VCEP followed the FDA-approved ClinGen protocol for adapting and piloting these guidelines. A diverse set of 40 DICER1 variants were selected for piloting, including 14 known Pathogenic/Likely Pathogenic (P/LP) variants, 12 known Benign/Likely Benign (B/LB) variants, and 14 variants classified as variants of uncertain significance (VUS) or with conflicting interpretations in ClinVar. Clinically meaningful classifications (i.e., P, LP, LB, or B) were achieved for 82.5% (33/40) of the pilot variants, with 100% concordance among the known P/LP and known B/LB variants. Half of the VUS or conflicting variants were resolved with four variants classified as LB and three as LP. These results demonstrate that the DICER1-specific guidelines for germline variant curation effectively classify known pathogenic and benign variants while reducing the frequency of uncertain classifications. Individuals and labs curating DICER1 variants should consider adopting this classification framework to encourage consistency and improve objectivity.

vaRHC: an R package for semi-automation of variant classification in hereditary cancer genes according to ACMG/AMP and gene-specific ClinGen guidelines

MOTIVATION

Germline variant classification allows accurate genetic diagnosis and risk assessment. However, it is a tedious iterative process integrating information from several sources and types of evidence. It should follow gene-specific (if available) or general updated international guidelines. Thus, it is the main burden of the incorporation of next-generation sequencing into the clinical setting.

RESULTS

We created the vaRiants in HC (vaRHC) R package to assist the process of variant classification in hereditary cancer by: (i) collecting information from diverse databases; (ii) assigning or denying different types of evidence according to updated American College of Molecular Genetics and Genomics/Association of Molecular Pathologist gene-specific criteria for ATM, CDH1, CHEK2, MLH1, MSH2, MSH6, PMS2, PTEN, and TP53 and general criteria for other genes; (iii) providing an automated classification of variants using a Bayesian metastructure and considering CanVIG-UK recommendations; and (iv) optionally printing the output to an .xlsx file. A validation using 659 classified variants demonstrated the robustness of vaRHC, presenting a better criteria assignment than Cancer SIGVAR, an available similar tool.

AVAILABILITY AND IMPLEMENTATION

The source code can be consulted in the GitHub repository (https://github.com/emunte/vaRHC) Additionally, it will be submitted to CRAN soon.

Benign goiters requiring thyroidectomy as the signal for PTEN hamartoma tumor syndrome diagnosis

PTEN hamartoma tumor syndrome (PHTS) is a rare genetic cancer and tumor predisposition syndrome. Due to the wide spectrum of clinical manifestations and variable age at onset, the pathways leading to a PHTS diagnosis are difficult and highly variable. Many patients were found to have PHTS after a cancer diagnosis, missing the opportunity of prevention or enhanced cancer screening. This retrospective study evaluated a PHTS cohort followed in a high-risk surveillance clinic in a comprehensive cancer institution. A significant portion of the patients (60.9%, 14/23) had at least one cancer diagnosis (average age 34.6 years at diagnosis). A significant portion (78.3%, 18/23) were affected with clinically significant goiters (age 27.9 years), and many (60.9%, 14/23) had partial or total thyroidectomy (age 27.1 years). The average age at goiter diagnosis or thyroidectomy is younger than a cancer diagnosis. In 12 individuals who were affected with clinically significant goiter and cancer, all cancers were diagnosed after the thyroid disease (6.3 years). As clinically significant thyroid nodules in childhood or early young adulthood are common in PHTS, but uncommon for general population, these early onset thyroid nodules may alert the clinician to initiate PHTS-targeted evaluation and genetic testing.

Gingival Overgrowths Revealing PTEN Hamartoma Tumor Syndrome: Report of Novel PTEN Pathogenic Variants

PTEN hamartoma tumor syndrome (PHTS), is a spectrum of disorders caused by mutations of PTEN, in which non-cancerous growths, called hamartomas, develop in different areas of the body, often including the oral mucosa. PHTS also implies a recognized increased risk of malignancies, as PTEN is a tumor suppressor gene capable of inhibiting progression of several cancers. One of the main and most common clinical manifestation of PHTS are gingival overgrowths presenting as warty lumps. The current study describes patients with gingival or mucosal enlargements leading to the diagnosis of PHTS associated to novel PTEN pathogenic variants. Patients referred to us for gingival lumps suggestive of PHTS associated overgrowths were submitted to genetic analysis in the PTEN gene. Two related and two unrelated patients were investigated. PTEN novel pathogenic variant was found in all of them. Two patients also fulfilled diagnostic criteria of Cowden syndrome (CS). Mucocutaneous lesions, and particularly diffuse gingival overgrowths, are both early and major clinical signs revealing a potential diagnosis of PHTS. Further genetic and clinical assessments are needed in order to confirm and clarify the diagnosis within the PHTS spectrum, including, among others, the CS. A correct interpretation of oral clinical features potentially associated to PHTS is mandatory for diagnosis and a surgical approach can be useful just in case of impairment of periodontal health or for aesthetic needs. The increased risk of malignancies associated to PHTS makes a correct diagnosis pivotal to set up an appropriate lifelong surveillance, aiming at secondary cancer prevention.

Optimising clinical care through CDH1-specific germline variant curation: improvement of clinical assertions and updated curation guidelines

BACKGROUND

Germline pathogenic variants in CDH1 are associated with increased risk of diffuse gastric cancer and lobular breast cancer. Risk reduction strategies include consideration of prophylactic surgery, thereby making accurate interpretation of germline CDH1 variants critical for physicians deciding on these procedures. The Clinical Genome Resource (ClinGen) CDH1 Variant Curation Expert Panel (VCEP) developed specifications for CDH1 variant curation with a goal to resolve variants of uncertain significance (VUS) and with ClinVar conflicting interpretations and continues to update these specifications.

METHODS

CDH1 variant classification specifications were modified based on updated genetic testing clinical criteria, new recommendations from ClinGen and expert knowledge from ongoing CDH1 variant curations. The CDH1 VCEP reviewed 273 variants using updated CDH1 specifications and incorporated published and unpublished data provided by diagnostic laboratories.

RESULTS

Updated CDH1-specific interpretation guidelines include 11 major modifications since the initial specifications from 2018. Using the refined guidelines, 97% (36 of 37) of variants with ClinVar conflicting interpretations were resolved to benign, likely benign, likely pathogenic or pathogenic, and 35% (15 of 43) of VUS were resolved to benign or likely benign. Overall, 88% (239 of 273) of curated variants had non-VUS classifications. To date, variants classified as pathogenic are either nonsense, frameshift, splicing, or affecting the translation initiation codon, and the only missense variants classified as pathogenic or likely pathogenic have been shown to affect splicing.

CONCLUSIONS

The development and evolution of CDH1-specific criteria by the expert panel resulted in decreased uncertain and conflicting interpretations of variants in this clinically actionable gene, which can ultimately lead to more effective clinical management recommendations.

Systematic use of phenotype evidence in clinical genetic testing reduces the frequency of variants of uncertain significance

Guidelines for variant interpretation include criteria for incorporating phenotype evidence, but this evidence is inconsistently applied. Systematic approaches to using phenotype evidence are needed. We developed a method for curating disease phenotypes as highly or moderately predictive of variant pathogenicity based on the frequency of their association with disease-causing variants. To evaluate this method's accuracy, we retrospectively reviewed variants with clinical classifications that had evolved from uncertain to definitive in genes associated with curated predictive phenotypes. To demonstrate the clinical validity and utility of this approach, we compared variant classifications determined with and without predictive phenotype evidence. The curation method was accurate for 93%-98% of eligible variants. Among variants interpreted using highly predictive phenotype evidence, the percentage classified as pathogenic or likely pathogenic was 80%, compared with 46%-54% had the evidence not been used. Positive results among individuals harboring variants with highly predictive phenotype-guided interpretations would have been missed in 25%-37% of diagnostic tests and 39%-50% of carrier screens had other approaches to phenotype evidence been used. In summary, predictive phenotype evidence associated with specific curated genes can be systematically incorporated into variant interpretation to reduce uncertainty and increase the clinical utility of genetic testing.

Development and Progression of Thyroid Disease in PTEN Hamartoma Tumor Syndrome: Refined Surveillance Recommendations

Background: PTEN hamartoma tumor syndrome (PHTS) is associated with a high prevalence and early onset of differentiated thyroid cancer and benign thyroid disease. However, a consensus on the time of initiation and frequency of thyroid cancer surveillance has not yet been reached. Most commonly, guidelines recommend annual thyroid ultrasounds, but vary widely in the time of initiation, ranging from shortly after birth to 18 years of age. Minimal data are available on the development and progression of thyroid disease over time in this population. This study aimed to target this knowledge gap by investigating the time to develop thyroid nodules and thyroid cancer from an initial ultrasound in 76 PHTS patients. Methods: The electronic records of 281 prospectively accrued PHTS patients were retrospectively reviewed between 2005 and 2021, and 76 patients were identified as having at least two thyroid ultrasounds. Time-to-event analyses were performed, determining the probability of developing thyroid nodules and thyroid cancer over time. Results: We demonstrated that PHTS patients with an initial thyroid ultrasound without nodules (n = 41) had >90% likelihood of remaining free of a clinically actionable nodule at 3 years and an 85% likelihood at 6 years. None of these patients developed thyroid cancer over the entire follow-up period (mean 4.6 years). In patients with a clinically nonactionable nodule, defined as not meeting criteria for fine needle aspiration or thyroidectomy (n = 14), we demonstrated that 80% will not have an actionable nodule at 3 years, and none developed thyroid cancer over the entire follow-up period. Conclusions: Our observations suggest stratifying surveillance intervals based on thyroid ultrasound result, and support extending surveillance intervals in PHTS patients without nodules on ultrasound to 3-5 years, and patients with clinically nonactionable nodules to 2-3 years, in contrast to the current recommendation of annual ultrasounds. This change in practice would decrease the burden of frequent ultrasounds, especially in young children and adolescents who are more likely to have a normal or nonactionable ultrasound result.

Expanding ACMG variant classification guidelines into a general framework

BACKGROUND

The American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics (ACMG)-recommended five variant classification categories (pathogenic, likely pathogenic, uncertain significance, likely benign, and benign) have been widely used in medical genetics. However, these guidelines are fundamentally constrained in practice owing to their focus upon Mendelian disease genes and their dichotomous classification of variants as being either causal or not. Herein, we attempt to expand the ACMG guidelines into a general variant classification framework that takes into account not only the continuum of clinical phenotypes, but also the continuum of the variants' genetic effects, and the different pathological roles of the implicated genes.

MAIN BODY

As a disease model, we employed chronic pancreatitis (CP), which manifests clinically as a spectrum from monogenic to multifactorial. Bearing in mind that any general conceptual proposal should be based upon sound data, we focused our analysis on the four most extensively studied CP genes, PRSS1, CFTR, SPINK1 and CTRC. Based upon several cross-gene and cross-variant comparisons, we first assigned the different genes to two distinct categories in terms of disease causation: CP-causing (PRSS1 and SPINK1) and CP-predisposing (CFTR and CTRC). We then employed two new classificatory categories, "predisposing" and "likely predisposing", to replace ACMG's "pathogenic" and "likely pathogenic" categories in the context of CP-predisposing genes, thereby classifying all pathologically relevant variants in these genes as "predisposing". In the case of CP-causing genes, the two new classificatory categories served to extend the five ACMG categories whilst two thresholds (allele frequency and functional) were introduced to discriminate "pathogenic" from "predisposing" variants.

CONCLUSION

Employing CP as a disease model, we expand ACMG guidelines into a five-category classification system (predisposing, likely predisposing, uncertain significance, likely benign, and benign) and a seven-category classification system (pathogenic, likely pathogenic, predisposing, likely predisposing, uncertain significance, likely benign, and benign) in the context of disease-predisposing and disease-causing genes, respectively. Taken together, the two systems constitute a general variant classification framework that, in principle, should span the entire spectrum of variants in any disease-related gene. The maximal compliance of our five-category and seven-category classification systems with the ACMG guidelines ought to facilitate their practical application.

Exome sequencing reveals a distinct somatic genomic landscape in breast cancer from women with germline PTEN variants

Germline PTEN variants (PTEN hamartoma tumor syndrome [PHTS]) confer up to 85% lifetime risk of female breast cancer (BC). BCs arising in PHTS are clinically distinct from sporadic BCs, including younger age of onset, multifocality, and an increased risk of second primary BCs. Yet, there is no previous investigation into the underlying genomic landscape of this entity. We sought to address the hypothesis that BCs arising in PHTS have a distinct genomic landscape compared to sporadic counterparts. We performed and analyzed exome sequencing data from 44 women with germline PTEN variants who developed BCs. The control cohort comprised of 497 women with sporadic BCs from The Cancer Genome Atlas (TCGA) dataset. We demonstrate that PHTS-derived BCs have a distinct somatic mutational landscape compared to the sporadic counterparts, namely second somatic hits in PTEN, distinct mutational signatures, and increased genomic instability. The PHTS group had a significantly higher frequency of somatic PTEN variants compared to TCGA (22.7% versus 5.6%; odds ratio [OR] 4.93; 95% confidence interval [CI] 2.21 to 10.98; p < 0.001) and a lower mutational frequency in PIK3CA (22.7% versus 33.4%; OR 0.59; 95% CI 0.28 to 1.22; p = 0.15). Somatic variants in PTEN and PIK3CA were mutually exclusive in PHTS (p = 0.01) but not in TCGA. Our findings have important implications for the personalized management of PTEN-related BCs, especially in the context of more accessible genetic testing.

Recommendations by the ClinGen Rett/Angelman-like expert panel for gene-specific variant interpretation methods

The genes MECP2, CDKL5, FOXG1, UBE3A, SLC9A6, and TCF4 present unique challenges for current ACMG/AMP variant interpretation guidelines. To address those challenges, the Rett and Angelman-like Disorders Variant Curation Expert Panel (Rett/AS VCEP) drafted gene-specific modifications. A pilot study was conducted to test the clarity and accuracy of using the customized variant interpretation criteria. Multiple curators obtained the same interpretation for 78 out of the 87 variants (~90%), indicating appropriate usage of the modified guidelines the majority of times by all the curators. The classification of 13 variants changed using these criteria specifications compared to when the variants were originally curated and as present in ClinVar. Many of these changes were due to internal data shared from laboratory members however some changes were because of changes in strength of criteria. There were no two-step classification changes and only 1 clinically relevant change (Likely pathogenic to VUS). The Rett/AS VCEP hopes that these gene-specific variant curation rules and the assertions provided help clinicians, clinical laboratories, and others interpret variants in these genes but also other fully penetrant, early-onset genes associated with rare disorders.

The yield and effectiveness of breast cancer surveillance in women with PTEN Hamartoma Tumor Syndrome

BACKGROUND

Women with PTEN Hamartoma Tumor Syndrome (PHTS) are offered breast cancer (BC) surveillance because of an increased BC lifetime risk. Surveillance guidelines are, however, expert opinion-based because of a lack of data. We aimed to assess the yield and effectiveness of BC surveillance and the prevalence and type of breast disease in women with PHTS.

METHODS

Sixty-five women with PHTS who visited our center between 2001 and 2021 were included. Surveillance consisted of annual magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and mammography from ages 25 and 30 years, respectively.

RESULTS

Thirty-nine women enrolled in the BC surveillance program (median age at first examination, 38 years [range, 24-70]) and underwent 156 surveillance rounds. Surveillance led to detection of BC in 7/39 women (cancer detection rate [CDR], 45/1000 rounds) and benign breast lesions (BBLs) in 11/39 women. Overall sensitivity₂ (which excludes prophylactic-mastectomy detected BCs) was 100%, whereas sensitivity₂ of mammography and MRI alone was 50% and 100%, respectively. Overall specificity was higher in follow-up rounds (86%) versus first rounds (71%). Regardless of surveillance, 21/65 women developed 35 distinct BCs (median age at first diagnosis, 40 years [range, 24-59]) and 23/65 developed 89 BBLs (median age at first diagnosis, 38 years [range, 15-61]). Surveillance-detected BCs were all T1 and N0, whereas outside surveillance-detected BCs were more often ≥T2 (60%) and N+ (45%) (p < .005).

CONCLUSIONS

The findings show that annual BC surveillance with MRI starting at age 25 years enables detection of early-stage BCs. Performance measures of surveillance and CDR were both high. BBLs were commonly present, underlining the importance of evaluation of all lesions independently.

LAY SUMMARY

Breast cancer surveillance leads to decreased tumor stage and improved survival. Breast cancer surveillance with breast magnetic resonance imaging from age 25 years onward is recommended.

Improving genetic diagnosis by disease-specific, ACMG/AMP variant interpretation guidelines for hearing loss

The 2018 Hearing Loss Expert Panel (HL-EP)-specific guidelines specified from the universal 2015 ACMG/AMP guidelines are proposed to be used in genetic HL, which prompted this study. A genetic HL cohort comprising 135 unrelated probands with available exome sequencing data was established. Overall, 169 variants were prioritized as candidates and interpreted using the 2015 ACMG/AMP and 2018 HL-EP guidelines. Changes in rule application and variant classification between the guidelines were compared. The concordance rate of variant classification of each variant between the guidelines was 71.60%, with significant difference. The proportion of pathogenic variants increased from 13.02% (2015) to 29.59% (2018). Variant classifications of autosomal recessive (AR) variants that previously belonged to VUS or likely pathogenic in the 2015 guidelines were changed toward pathogenic in the 2018 guidelines more frequently than those of autosomal dominant variants (29.17% vs. 6.38%, P = 0.005). Stratification of the PM3 and PP1 rules in the 2018 guidelines led to more substantial escalation than that in the 2015 guidelines. We compared the disease-specific guidelines (2018) with the universal guidelines (2015) using real-world data. Owing to the sophistication of case-level data, the HL-specific guidelines have more explicitly classified AR variants toward "likely pathogenic" or "pathogenic", serving as potential references for other recessive genetic diseases.

A calibrated functional patch-clamp assay to enhance clinical variant interpretation in KCNH2-related long QT syndrome

Modern sequencing technologies have revolutionized our detection of gene variants. However, in most genes, including KCNH2, the majority of missense variants are currently classified as variants of uncertain significance (VUSs). The aim of this study was to investigate the utility of an automated patch-clamp assay for aiding clinical variant classification in KCNH2. The assay was designed according to recommendations proposed by the Clinical Genome Sequence Variant Interpretation Working Group. Thirty-one variants (17 pathogenic/likely pathogenic, 14 benign/likely benign) were classified internally as variant controls. They were heterozygously expressed in Flp-In HEK293 cells for assessing the effects of variants on current density and channel gating in order to determine the sensitivity and specificity of the assay. All 17 pathogenic variant controls had reduced current density, and 13 of 14 benign variant controls had normal current density, which enabled determination of normal and abnormal ranges for applying evidence of moderate or supporting strength for VUS reclassification. Inclusion of functional assay evidence enabled us to reclassify 6 out of 44 KCNH2 VUSs as likely pathogenic. The high-throughput patch-clamp assay can provide moderate-strength evidence for clinical interpretation of clinical KCNH2 variants and demonstrates the value of developing automated patch-clamp assays for functional characterization of ion channel gene variants.

Fibroadenoma in vulval ectopic breast tissue in a patient with PTEN Hamartoma Tumour Syndrome

PTEN is a tumour suppressor gene involved in regulating cell division. Pathogenic germline variants in PTEN predispose to benign and malignant growths of numerous organs, including of the breast. In the following report, we describe the first documented case of a fibroadenoma developing in ectopic breast tissue of the vulva in a patient with a germline pathogenic variant in PTEN. This highlights the risk of hyperplasia developing in any breast tissue, including rare ectopic sites, particularly in patients with underlying germline variants in cancer susceptibility genes.

Standards for the classification of pathogenicity of somatic variants in cancer (oncogenicity): Joint recommendations of Clinical Genome Resource (ClinGen), Cancer Genomics Consortium (CGC), and Variant Interpretation for Cancer Consortium (VICC)

PURPOSE

Several professional societies have published guidelines for the clinical interpretation of somatic variants, which specifically address diagnostic, prognostic, and therapeutic implications. Although these guidelines for the clinical interpretation of variants include data types that may be used to determine the oncogenicity of a variant (eg, population frequency, functional, and in silico data or somatic frequency), they do not provide a direct, systematic, and comprehensive set of standards and rules to classify the oncogenicity of a somatic variant. This insufficient guidance leads to inconsistent classification of rare somatic variants in cancer, generates variability in their clinical interpretation, and, importantly, affects patient care. Therefore, it is essential to address this unmet need.

METHODS

Clinical Genome Resource (ClinGen) Somatic Cancer Clinical Domain Working Group and ClinGen Germline/Somatic Variant Subcommittee, the Cancer Genomics Consortium, and the Variant Interpretation for Cancer Consortium used a consensus approach to develop a standard operating procedure (SOP) for the classification of oncogenicity of somatic variants.

RESULTS

This comprehensive SOP has been developed to improve consistency in somatic variant classification and has been validated on 94 somatic variants in 10 common cancer-related genes.

CONCLUSION

The comprehensive SOP is now available for classification of oncogenicity of somatic variants.