Transcription of the soybean leghemoglobin genes during nodule development

Large-Scale Integrative Analysis of Soybean Transcriptome Using an Unsupervised Autoencoder Model

Plant tissues are distinguished by their gene expression patterns, which can help identify tissue-specific highly expressed genes and their differential functional modules. For this purpose, large-scale soybean transcriptome samples were collected and processed starting from raw sequencing reads in a uniform analysis pipeline. To address the gene expression heterogeneity in different tissues, we utilized an adversarial deconfounding autoencoder (AD-AE) model to map gene expressions into a latent space and adapted a standard unsupervised autoencoder (AE) model to help effectively extract meaningful biological signals from the noisy data. As a result, four groups of 1,743, 914, 2,107, and 1,451 genes were found highly expressed specifically in leaf, root, seed and nodule tissues, respectively. To obtain key transcription factors (TFs), hub genes and their functional modules in each tissue, we constructed tissue-specific gene regulatory networks (GRNs), and differential correlation networks by using corrected and compressed gene expression data. We validated our results from the literature and gene enrichment analysis, which confirmed many identified tissue-specific genes. Our study represents the largest gene expression analysis in soybean tissues to date. It provides valuable targets for tissue-specific research and helps uncover broader biological patterns. Code is publicly available with open source at https://github.com/LingtaoSu/SoyMeta.

Excess nitrate induces nodule greening and reduces transcript and protein expression levels of soybean leghaemoglobins

BACKGROUND AND AIMS

Efficient biological nitrogen fixation (BNF) requires leghaemoglobin (Lb) to modulate oxygen pressure in nodules. Excess N supply severely inhibits BNF through effects on Lb during nodulation. As yet, a systematic identification and characterization of Lb-encoding genes in soybean has not been reported.

METHODS

The effects of N on BNF were studied in soybean plants inoculated with rhizobia and exposed to excess or low N availability in hydroponic cultures. To identify soybean Lb proteins, BLAST searches were performed on the Phytozome website. Bioinformatic analysis of identified GmLbs was then carried out to investigate gene structure, protein homology and phylogenetic relationships. Finally, quantitative real-time PCR was employed to analyse the expression patterns of soybean Lb genes in various tissues and in response to high N availability.

KEY RESULTS

Excess N significantly accelerated nodule senescence and the production of green Lb in nodules. In total, seven haemoglobin (Hb) genes were identified from the soybean genome, with these Hb genes readily split into two distinct clades containing predominantly symbiosis-associated or non-symbiotic Hb members. Expression analysis revealed that all of the symbiosis-associated Lbs except GmLb5 were specifically expressed in nodules, while the non-symbiotic GmHbs, GmHb1 and GmHb2, were predominantly expressed in leaves and roots, respectively. Among identified GmLbs, GmLb1-4 are the major Lb genes acting in soybean nodulation, and each one is also significantly suppressed by exposure to excess N.

CONCLUSIONS

Taken together, the results show that excess N inhibits BNF by reducing nodule formation, Lb concentration and nitrogenase activity. The characteristics of the entire Hb family were analysed, and we found that GmLb1-4 are closely associated with nodule development and N2 fixation. This works forms the basis for further investigations of the role of Lbs in soybean nodulation.

CRISPR/Cas9 knockout of leghemoglobin genes in Lotus japonicus uncovers their synergistic roles in symbiotic nitrogen fixation

Legume nodules contain high concentrations of leghemoglobins (Lbs) encoded by several genes. The reason for this multiplicity is unknown. CRISPR/Cas9 technology was used to generate stable mutants of the three Lbs of Lotus japonicus. The phenotypes were characterized at the physiological, biochemical and molecular levels. Nodules of the triple mutants were examined by electron microscopy and subjected to RNA-sequencing (RNA-seq) analysis. Complementation studies revealed that Lbs function synergistically to maintain optimal N₂ fixation. The nodules of the triple mutants overproduced superoxide radicals and hydrogen peroxide, which was probably linked to activation of NADPH oxidases and changes in superoxide dismutase isoforms expression. The mutant nodules showed major ultrastructural alterations, including vacuolization, accumulation of poly-β-hydroxybutyrate and disruption of mitochondria. RNA-seq of c. 20 000 genes revealed significant changes in expression of carbon and nitrogen metabolism genes, transcription factors, and proteinases. Lb-deficient nodules had c. 30-50-fold less heme but similar transcript levels of heme biosynthetic genes, suggesting a post-translational regulatory mechanism of heme synthesis. We conclude that Lbs act additively in nodules and that the lack of Lbs results in early nodule senescence. Our observations also provide insight into the reprogramming of the gene expression network associated with Lb deficiency, probably as a result of uncontrolled intracellular free O₂ concentration.

A JAZ Protein in Astragalus sinicus Interacts with a Leghemoglobin through the TIFY Domain and Is Involved in Nodule Development and Nitrogen Fixation

Leghemoglobins (Lbs) play an important role in legumes-rhizobia symbiosis. Lbs bind O2 and protect nitrogenase activity from damage by O2 in nodules, therefore, they are regarded as a marker of active nitrogen fixation in nodules. Additionally, Lbs are involved in the nitric oxide (NO) signaling pathway, acting as a NO scavenger during nodule development and nitrogen fixation. However, regulators responsible for Lb expression and modulation of Lb activity have not been characterized. In our previous work, a Jasmonate-Zim-domain (JAZ) protein interacting with a Lb (AsB2510) in Astragalus sinicus was identified and designated AsJAZ1. In this study, the interaction between AsJAZ1 and AsB2510 was verified using a yeast two-hybrid system and in vitro Glutathione S-transferase (GST) pull-down assays, resulting in identification of the interaction domain as a TIFY (previously known as zinc-finger protein expressed in inflorescence meristem, ZIM) domain. TIFY domain is named after the most conserved amino acids within the domain. Bimolecular fluorescence complementation (BiFC) was used to confirm the interaction between AsJAZ1 and AsB2510 in tobacco cells, demonstrating that AsJAZ1-AsB2510 interaction was localized to the cell membrane and cytoplasm. Furthermore, the expression patterns and the symbiotic phenotypes of AsJAZ1 were investigated. Knockdown of AsJAZ1 expression via RNA interference led to decreased number of nodules, abnormal development of bacteroids, accumulation of poly-x-hydroxybutyrate (PHB) and loss of nitrogenase activity. Taken together, our results suggest that AsJAZ1 interacts with AsB2510 and participates in nodule development and nitrogen fixation. Our results provide novel insights into the functions of Lbs or JAZ proteins during legume-rhizobia symbiosis.

Leghemoglobin green derivatives with nitrated hemes evidence production of highly reactive nitrogen species during aging of legume nodules

Globins constitute a superfamily of proteins widespread in all kingdoms of life, where they fulfill multiple functions, such as efficient O(2) transport and modulation of nitric oxide bioactivity. In plants, the most abundant Hbs are the symbiotic leghemoglobins (Lbs) that scavenge O(2) and facilitate its diffusion to the N(2)-fixing bacteroids in nodules. The biosynthesis of Lbs during nodule formation has been studied in detail, whereas little is known about the green derivatives of Lbs generated during nodule senescence. Here we characterize modified forms of Lbs, termed Lba(m), Lbc(m), and Lbd(m), of soybean nodules. These green Lbs have identical globins to the parent red Lbs but their hemes are nitrated. By combining UV-visible, MS, NMR, and resonance Raman spectroscopies with reconstitution experiments of the apoprotein with protoheme or mesoheme, we show that the nitro group is on the 4-vinyl. In vitro nitration of Lba with excess nitrite produced several isomers of nitrated heme, one of which is identical to those found in vivo. The use of antioxidants, metal chelators, and heme ligands reveals that nitration is contingent upon the binding of nitrite to heme Fe, and that the reactive nitrogen species involved derives from nitrous acid and is most probably the nitronium cation. The identification of these green Lbs provides conclusive evidence that highly oxidizing and nitrating species are produced in nodules leading to nitrosative stress. These findings are consistent with a previous report showing that the modified Lbs are more abundant in senescing nodules and have aberrant O(2) binding.

Large-scale analysis of putative soybean regulatory gene expression identifies a Myb gene involved in soybean nodule development

Nodulation is the result of a symbiosis between legumes and rhizobial bacteria in soil. This symbiosis is mutually beneficial, with the bacteria providing a source of nitrogen to the host while the plant supplies carbon to the symbiont. Nodule development is a complex process that is tightly regulated in the host plant cell through networks of gene expression. In order to examine this regulation in detail, a library of quantitative reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction primer sets was developed for a large number of soybean (Glycine max) putative regulatory genes available in the current expressed sequence tag collection. This library contained primers specific to soybean transcription factor genes as well as genes involved in chromatin modification and translational regulation. Using this library, we analyzed the expression of this gene set during nodule development. A large number of genes were found to be differentially expressed, especially at the later stages of nodule development when active nitrogen fixation was occurring. Expression of these putative regulatory genes was also analyzed in response to the addition of nitrate as a nitrogen source. This comparative analysis identified genes that may be specifically involved in nitrogen assimilation, metabolism, and the maintenance of active nodules. To address this possibility, the expression of one such candidate was studied in more detail by expressing in soybean roots promoter beta-glucuronidase and green fluorescent protein fusions. This gene, named Control of Nodule Development (CND), encoded a Myb transcription factor gene. When the CND gene was silenced, nodulation was reduced. These results, associated with a strong expression of the CND gene in the vascular tissues, suggest a role for CND in controlling soybean nodulation.

A cluster of Arabidopsis genes with a coordinate response to an environmental stimulus

Vernalization, the promotion of flowering after prolonged exposure to low temperatures, is an adaptive response of plants ensuring that flowering occurs at a propitious time in the annual seasonal cycle. In Arabidopsis, FLOWERING LOCUS C (FLC), which encodes a repressor of flowering, is a key gene in the vernalization response; plants with high-FLC expression respond to vernalization by downregulating FLC and thereby flowering at an earlier time. Vernalization has the hallmarks of an epigenetically regulated process. The downregulation of FLC by low temperatures is maintained throughout vegetative development but is reset at each generation. During our study of vernalization, we have found that a small gene cluster, including FLC and its two flanking genes, is coordinately regulated in response to genetic modifiers, to the environmental stimulus of vernalization, and in plants with low levels of DNA methylation. Genes encoded on foreign DNA inserted into the cluster also acquire the low-temperature response. At other chromosomal locations, FLC maintains its response to vernalization and imposes a parallel response on a flanking gene. This suggests that FLC contains sequences that confer changes in gene expression extending beyond FLC itself, perhaps through chromatin modification.

CPP1, a DNA-binding protein involved in the expression of a soybean leghemoglobin c3 gene

Nodulin genes are specifically expressed in the nitrogen-fixing root nodules. We have identified a novel type of DNA-binding protein (CPP1) interacting with the promoter of the soybean leghemoglobin gene Gmlbc3. The DNA-binding domain of CPP1 contains two similar Cys-rich domains with 9 and 10 Cys, respectively. Genes encoding similar domains have been identified in Arabidopsis thaliana, Caenorhabditis elegans, the mouse, and human. The domains also have some homology to a Cys-rich region present in some polycomb proteins. The cpp1 gene is induced late in nodule development and the expression is confined to the distal part of the central infected tissue of the nodule. A constitutively expressed cpp1 gene reduces the expression of a Gmlbc3 promoter-gusA reporter construct in Vicia hirsuta roots. These data therefore suggest that CPP1 might be involved in the regulation of the leghemoglobin genes in the symbiotic root nodule.

A new class of plant homeobox genes is expressed in specific regions of determinate symbiotic root nodules

A cDNA containing a homeobox sequence was isolated from a soybean nodule-specific expression library. This homeobox cDNA, Ndx (nodulin homeobox), represents a small gene family with at least two members in soybean (Glycine max) and three in Lotus japonicus. One complete 3304 bp Ndx cDNA from L. japonicus encodes a protein, NDX, of 958 amino acids. An unusual type of homeodomain that differs in two of the most conserved amino acid positions in the consensus sequence is located close to the C-terminal and appears to be the only DNA-binding domain. Weak Ndx gene expression in the root increases very shortly after infection with Rhizobium and remains throughout nodule development. In situ hybridizations show cell-specific expression patterns that suggest developmentally separate regions in maturing determinate nodules. Thus in the maturing nodule Ndx and leghemoglobin genes are expressed in a mutually exclusive fashion. The Ndx transcript is also detectable in the young nodule primordium. Ndx expression is not confined to the root nodule since Ndx is also expressed in shoot and root meristems, indicating that the Ndx gene products might also be involved in developmental processes in other plant tissues.

Cell-specific expression of the promoters of two nonlegume hemoglobin genes in a transgenic legume, Lotus corniculatus

The promoters of the hemoglobin genes from the nitrogen-fixing tree Parasponia andersonii and the related nonnitrogen-fixing Trema tomentosa both confer beta-glucuronidase reporter gene expression to the central zone of the nodules of a transgenic legume, Lotus corniculatus. beta-Glucuronidase expression was high in the uninfected interstitial cells and parenchyma of the surrounding boundary layer and was low in the Rhizobium-infected cells. This contrasts with the expression of both the P. andersonii hemoglobin protein in P. andersonii nodules and the endogenous Lotus leghemoglobins that are expressed in the infected cells at very high levels. The expression pattern of the P. andersonii and T. tomentosa hemoglobin promoters in L. corniculatus resembles that of a nonsymbiotic hemoglobin gene from Casuarina glauca, which was introduced into this legume, and suggests that only the nonsymbiotic functions of the P. andersonii promoter are being recognized. Deletion of the distal segments of both the P. andersonii and T. tomentosa promoters identified regions important for the control of their tissue-specific and temporal activity in Lotus. Potential regulatory elements, which enhance nodule expression and suppress nonnodule expression, were also identified and localized to a distal promoter segment. A proximal AAGAG motif is present in the P. andersonii, T. tomentosa, and nonsymbiotic Casuarina hemoglobin genes. Mutation of this motif in the P. andersonii promoter resulted in a significant reduction in both the nodule and root expression levels in L. corniculatus. Some of the regulatory motifs characterized are similar to, but different from, the nodulin motifs of the leghemoglobins.

Expression of nodulin genes in plant-determined ineffective nodules of pea

The mutant E135 (sym 13) of pea (Pisum sativum L.) forms a normal number of small white nodules that contain bacteroids, but these bacteroids lack nitrogenase activity. To evaluate the effects of the sym 13 gene on the expression of nodulin genes, cDNA clones for nodulins were isolated from pea nodules and the expression of nodulin genes in ineffective E135 nodules was compared with that in nitrogen-fixing nodules on the wild-type parent, cv. Sparkle. Nineteen cDNA clones for nodulins, including ENOD2 and cDNAs for two distinct leghemoglobins (Lbs), were isolated from Sparkle nodules by a subtractive hybridization procedure. All the nodulin genes examined were expressed in nodules on both E135 and Sparkle plants. However, the level of expression of seven genes, one of which was an Lb gene that corresponded to PsN5, was significantly lower in E135 nodules. The levels of Lb apo-proteins, with the exception of Lb-III and Lb-IV, in E135 nodules resembled those in Sparkle nodules, but the level of heme in E135 nodules was lower than that in Sparkle nodules. Although the expression of the two Lb genes that corresponded to PsN5 and PsN120 in E135 nodules was slightly depressed by exogenous ammonia, the level of the PsN5 transcript was still lower than the control level in Sparkle nodules. Our results indicate that the plant gene sym 13 does not influence the induction of nodulin genes but does influence the level of the expression of some genes, one of which is a gene for Lb, as well as the level of heme.

A soybean coproporphyrinogen oxidase gene is highly expressed in root nodules

In plants the enzyme coproporphyrinogen oxidase catalyzes the oxidative decarboxylation of coproporphyrinogen III to protoporphyrinogen IX in the heme and chlorophyll biosynthesis pathway(s). We have isolated a soybean coproporphyrinogen oxidase cDNA from a cDNA library and determined the primary structure of the corresponding gene. The coproporphyrinogen oxidase gene encodes a polypeptide with a predicted molecular mass of 43 kDa. The derived amino acid sequence shows 50% similarity to the corresponding yeast amino acid sequence. The main difference is an extension of 67 amino acids at the N-terminus of the soybean polypeptide which may function as a transit peptide. A full-length coproporphyrinogen oxidase cDNA clone complements a yeast mutant deleted of the coproporphyrinogen oxidase gene, thus demonstrating the function of the soybean protein. The soybean coproporphyrinogen oxidase gene is highly expressed in nodules at the stage where several late nodulins including leghemoglobin appear. The coproporphyrinogen oxidase mRNA is also detectable in leaves but at a lower level than in nodules while no mRNA is detectable in roots. The high level of coproporphyrinogen oxidase mRNA in soybean nodules implies that the plant increases heme production in the nodules to meet the demand for additional heme required for hemoprotein formation.

Minimal enhancer elements of the leghemoglobin lba and lbc3 gene promoters from Glycine max L. have different properties

The characteristics of the soybean leghemoglobin lba gene promoter were analyzed and important promoter elements from the lba and lbc3 promoters were compared using transgenic Lotus corniculatus plants. A 5' deletion analysis of the lba promoter delimited two cis-acting elements controlling expression: a distal positive element (-1254, -884) required for expression and a proximal element (-285, -60) essential for full-level activity. In contrast to the corresponding region of the lbc3 promoter, the lba proximal element is unable to control expression from the heterologous CaMV 35S enhancer. The upstream positive element of the lba gene contains a position- and orientation-independent enhancer between positions (-1091, -788). The sequence of this enhancer region is conserved in the lbc3 gene upstream (-1333, -1132) of the previously assigned strong positive element (SPE; -1090, -947). The present analysis revealed some of the properties of this extended lbc3 SPE element. The extended element (-1364, -947) functions in both orientations from 5' locations whereas the SPE2 subcomponent (-1364, -1154) containing the conserved sequence is only active in the correct orientation. Removal of the SPE2 by internal deletion demonstrates that the SPE2 subcomponent is indispensable for the activity of the lbc3 upstream positive element. These results indicate that the upstream positive elements of the lba and lbc3 genes possess different properties although their conserved minimal enhancer sequence has similar function. This may reflect the differential expression of the two lb genes of Glycine max L.

Comparative sequence analysis of cis elements present in Glycine max L. leghemoglobin lba and lbc3 genes

The soybean leghemoglobin lba gene promoter sequence was determined and aligned with the promoter sequence of the soybean lbc3 gene from the same gene family. Five highly conserved regions were found. There are two large conserved regions, one of which overlaps the basic promoter while the other defines a minimal enhancer in the upstream positive elements. Within the minimal enhancer, an inverted repeat with similarity to the binding site of a yeast transcription factor, GCN4, was found. This particular repeat is conserved in the promoters of all functional soybean lb genes as well as in lb gene promoters from other legumes. This suggests that the inverted repeat is important for leghemoglobin gene expression.

Isolation and characterization of novel nodulin cDNAs representing genes expressed at early stages of soybean nodule development

We took advantage of a subtractive hybridization procedure to isolate a set of cDNA clones of nodule-specific genes (nodulin genes) from developing soybean root nodules. Single-stranded 32P-labelled cDNA synthesized from nodule poly(A)+ RNA was hybridized with a large excess of uninfected root poly(A)+ RNA. Unhybridized cDNA was selected and used to screen nodule cDNA libraries. By this procedure we isolated several novel nodulin cDNA clones together with most of the nodulin cDNAs previously described. Four novel nodulin genes, which were expressed long before the onset of nitrogen fixation, were further characterized. GmN#36 and GmN#93 transcripts appeared in the roots less than 3 days after sowing and inoculation with Bradyrhizobium, but GmN#36 transcripts were also detected at very low levels in the stems of uninfected plants. Transcripts of GmN#315 and GmN#70 first appeared at 6-7 days, just before nodule emergence. Amino acid sequences of the predicted products of GmN#36, GmN#93 and GmN#70 exhibited no significant homology to proteins identified so far. The GmN#315 encoded protein has a limited but significant homology to some plant cyanins, suggesting that it is a metal-binding glycoprotein. In situ hybridization studies revealed that GmN#36 transcripts first appeared in the pericycle cells of the root stele near the infected site. During nodule emergence they were found in a few cell layers surrounding the vascular strands connecting the nodule meristem with the root stele, and in mature nodules they were present specifically in the pericycle cells in vascular bundles. These observations led us to hypothesize that GmN#36 gene products play a role in the transport and/or degradation of photosynthate. On the other hand, GmN#93 transcripts first appeared in the primary nodule meristem just below the root epidermis. In mature nodules they were only present in the infected cells.

Ferritin (mRNA, protein) and iron concentrations during soybean nodule development

To study how iron-rich nodules concentrate and store iron, ferritin (mRNA, protein) was analyzed in developing soybean nodules and compared to nitrogenase (mRNA/activity) and leghemoglobin (mRNA, protein, heme). Both ferritin mRNA and protein concentrations increased early in nodulation. Later in nodulation ferritin protein declined, in contrast to the mRNA, as nitrogenase (mRNA and activity) increased and leghemoglobin (mRNA and protein) accumulated. A precursor/product relationship between iron stored in ferritin and iron in nitrogenase or leghemoglobin is suggested. The uncoordinated changes in ferritin mRNA and protein during nodulation contrast with nitrogenase mRNA and nitrogenase activity suggesting possible translational and posttranscriptional effects on ferritin expression.

Organization of non-vertebrate globin genes

The organization of non-vertebrate globin genes exhibits substantially more variability than the three-exon, two-intron structure of the vertebrate globin genes. (1) The structures of genes of the single-domain globin chains of the annelid Lumbricus and the mollusc Anadara, and the globin gene coding for the two-domain chains of the clam Barbatia, are similar to the vertebrate plan. (2) Genes for single-domain chains exist in bacteria and protozoa. Although the globin gene is highly expressed in the bacterium Vitreoscilla, the putative globin gene hmp in E. coli, which codes for a chimeric protein whose N-terminal moiety of 139 residues contains 67 residues identical to the Vitreoscilla globin, may be either unexpressed or expressed at very low levels, despite the presence of normal regulatory sequences. The DNA sequence of the globin gene of the protozoan Paramecium, determined recently by Yamauchi and collaborators, appears to consist of two exons separated by a short intron. (3) Among the lower eukaryotes, the yeasts Saccharomyces and Candida have chimeric proteins consisting of N-terminal globin and C-terminal flavoprotein moieties of about the same size. The structure of the gene for the chimeric protein of Saccharomyces exhibits no introns. According to Riggs, the presence of chimeric proteins in E. coli and other prokaryotes, such as Alcaligenes and Rhizobium, as well as in yeasts, suggests a previously unrecognized evolutionary pathway for hemoglobin, namely that of a multipurpose heme-binding domain attached to a variety of unrelated proteins with diverse functions. (4) The published globin gene sequences of the insect larva Chironomus have an intron-less structure and are present as clusters of multiple copies; the expression of the globin genes is tissue and developmental stage-specific. Furthermore, the expression of many of these genes has not yet been demonstrated despite the presence of apparently normal regulatory sequences in the two flanking regions. Unexpectedly, Bergtrom and collaborators have recently shown that at least three Ctt globin II beta genes contain putative introns. (5) Pohajdak and collaborators have found a seven-exon and six-intron structure for the globin gene of the nematode Pseudoterranova which codes for a two-domain globin chain. Although the second and fourth introns of the N-terminal domain correspond to the two introns found in vertebrate globin genes, the position of the third intron is close to that of the central intron in plant hemoglobins.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

A two-component nodule-specific enhancer in the soybean N23 gene promoter

The two positive cis elements in the soybean nodulin N23 gene promoter were investigated in transgenic Lotus corniculatus plants and shown to constitute a two-component nodule-specific enhancer. Equal quantitative contributions from the two components were suggested by the similar expression level of chimeric N23-chloramphenicol acetyltransferase genes after deletion of either the distal positive element (PE-A, -320 to -298) or the proximal positive element (PE-B, -257 to -165). A combined effect of the two elements was indicated by orientation-dependent effects in the N23 promoter, and by the observation that neither PE-A nor PE-B separately was able to confer any activity to the cauliflower mosaic virus 35S minimal promoter. Reactivation of the minimal N23 and the minimal cauliflower mosaic virus 35S promoters by the inverted complete element (PE-AB) further suggested that PE-AB is a nodule-specific enhancer containing two equally strong enhancer components. Two 12-bp sequence motifs, InvA and InvB, constituting an inverted repeat, were identified as the core of the enhancer components PE-A and PE-B, respectively. Point mutations in InvA or InvB resulted in lower expression levels and mutations in both abolished enhancer activity. Point mutations in two nodulin consensus sequences, 5'-CTCTT and 5'-AAAGAT located downstream of PE-AB, resulted in a decreased level of expression, confirming the involvement of these two motifs in nodulin gene expression. The binding site for the nodule-specific trans-acting factor, NAT2, present in the PE-A segment, was removed without affecting expression significantly. This interaction is, therefore, dispensable for enhancer activity.

Oxygen regulation of uricase and sucrose synthase synthesis in soybean callus tissue is exerted at the mRNA level

The effect of lowering oxygen concentration on the expression of nodulin genes in soybean callus tissue devoid of the microsymbiont has been examined. Poly(A)+ RNA was isolated from tissue cultivated in 4% oxygen and in normal atmosphere. Quantitative mRNA hybridization experiments using nodule-specific uricase (Nodulin-35) and sucrose synthase (Nodulin-100) cDNA probes confirmed that the synthesis of the uricase and sucrose synthase is controlled by oxygen at the mRNA level. The steady-state levels of uricase and sucrose synthase mRNA increased significantly (5-6- and 4-fold respectively) when the callus tissue was incubated at reduced oxygen concentration. Concomitant with the increase in mRNA level a 6-fold increase in specific activity of sucrose synthase was observed. Two messengers representing poly-ubiquitin precursors also responded to lowering the oxygen concentration. The increase was about 5-fold at 4% oxygen. No expression at atmospheric oxygen or in response to low oxygen was observed when using cDNA probes for other nodulin genes such as leghemoglobin c3, nodulin-22 and nodulin-44.

Characterization of a novel nodulin gene in soybean that shares sequence similarity to the gene for nodulin-24

A gene encoding for nodulin-16 (N-16) was isolated from a soybean genomic library. Nucleotide sequence analysis of the cDNA and the genomic clone of N-16 indicated that the coding region of this gene is 330 bp long and is interrupted by a single intron of 494 bp. The coding region of the N-16 gene shows a high degree of localized sequence similarity with the coding sequence of soybean nodulin-24 (N-24). Sequence similarity between the two genes is limited to the coding region of 90 bp in the first exon and the first 54 bp in the second exon of the N-16 gene which is repeated as the 2nd, 3rd, and 4th exons in the N-24 gene. The N-24 gene has been postulated to be a result of repeated duplication of an insertion element consisting of the 54 bp exon and the flanking intron sequences. In the absence of sequence similarity in the regions flanking the 54 bp sequence between the N-16 and N-24 genes, the N-16 gene does not appear to be the ancestral gene. Both N-16 and N-24 have a similar hydrophobic amino terminal end suggesting that N-16 like N-24 is targeted to the peribacteroid membrane. Southern analysis of soybean genomic DNA shows the presence of other related sequences to the N-16 gene, one of which is found to be closely linked to it. Analysis of the temporal accumulation of the N-16 transcripts during nodule development in effective and ineffective nodules suggests that N-16 and related genes might differ from leghemoglobin and some other late nodulin genes in their mechanism of regulation.

Functional analysis of the Sesbania rostrata leghemoglobin glb3 gene 5'-upstream region in transgenic Lotus corniculatus and Nicotiana tabacum plants

Expression of the Sesbania rostrata leghemoglobin glb3 gene was analyzed in transgenic Lotus corniculatus and tobacco plants harboring chimeric glb3-uidA (gus) gene fusions to identify cis-acting elements involved in nodule-specific gene expression and general transcriptional control. A 1.9-kilobase fragment of the glb3 5'-upstream region was found to direct a high level of nodule-specific beta-glucuronidase (GUS) activity in L. corniculatus, restricted to the Rhizobium-infected cells of the nodules. The same fragment directed a low level of GUS activity in tobacco, restricted primarily to the roots and to phloem cells of the stem and petiole vascular system. A deletion analysis revealed that the region between coordinates -429 and -48 relative to the ATG was sufficient for nodule-specific expression. Replacement of the -161 to -48 region, containing the glb3 CAAT and TATA boxes, with the heterologous truncated promoters delta-p35S and delta-pnos resulted in a loss of nodule specificity and reduction of GUS activity in L. corniculatus but a significant increase in tobacco, primarily in the roots. The same fragment could not direct nodule-specific expression when fused to a heterologous enhancer in cis. This region contains DNA sequences required, but not sufficient, for nodule-specific expression in L. corniculatus that function poorly or may be involved in promoter silencing in tobacco. By fusing further upstream fragments to the delta-p35S and delta-pnos promoters, two positive regulatory regions were delimited between coordinates -1601 and -670, as well as -429 and -162. The former region appears to function as a general enhancer because it significantly increased promoter activity in both orientations in L. corniculatus and tobacco. The latter region could enhance gene expression in both orientations in tobacco, but only in the correct orientation in L. corniculatus. These results show that efficient expression of the S. rostrata glb3 gene in nodules is mediated by an ATG-proximal, tissue-specific element, as well as further 5'-upstream positive elements; that the S. rostrata glb3 promoter is induced in a nodule-specific fashion in the heterologous legume L. corniculatus, suggesting a high degree of conservation of the relevant regulatory signals; and that the S. rostrata lb promoter is not silent in the nonlegume tobacco, but is expressed primarily in the roots.

Nonlegume hemoglobin genes retain organ-specific expression in heterologous transgenic plants

Hemoglobin genes from the nitrogen-fixing nonlegume Parasponia andersonii and the related non-nitrogen-fixing nonlegume Trema tomentosa have been isolated [Landsmann et al. (1986). Nature 324, 166-168; Bogusz et al. (1988). Nature 331, 178-180]. The promoters of these genes have been linked to a beta-glucuronidase reporter gene and introduced into both the nonlegume Nicotiana tabacum and the legume Lotus corniculatus. Both promoters directed root-specific expression in transgenic tobacco. When transgenic Lotus plants were nodulated by Rhizobium loti, both promoter constructs showed a high level of nodule-specific expression confined to the central bacteroid-containing portion of the nodule corresponding to the expression seen for the endogenous Lotus leghemoglobin gene. The T. tomentosa promoter was also expressed at a low level in the vascular tissue of the Lotus roots. The hemoglobin promoters from both nonlegumes, including the non-nodulating species, must contain conserved cis-acting DNA signals that are responsible for nodule-specific expression in legumes. We have identified sequence motifs postulated previously as the nodule-specific regulatory elements of the soybean leghemoglobin genes [Stougaard et al. (1987). EMBO J. 6, 3565-3569].

Interdependence and nodule specificity of cis-acting regulatory elements in the soybean leghemoglobin lbc3 and N23 gene promoters

The qualitative and quantitative contributions of four separate cis-acting DNA elements controlling the root nodule-specific soybean leghemoglobin lbc3 gene were analyzed in transgenic Lotus corniculatus plants. Expression from internal deletions in the 5' region between positions -49 and -1956 was monitored from a CAT reporter gene. The strong positive element (SPE; -1090, -947) responsible for high-level expression was demonstrated to be an organ-specific element by deleting proximal nodule-specific control elements. Deletion of the downstream qualitative organ-specific element (OSE; -139, -102) containing the putative nodulin consensus sequences 5'AAAGAT and 5'CTCTT resulted in a low expression level. Efficient SPE enhancement is therefore dependent on the organ-specific element, which by itself does not enhance expression. This quantitative effect of the immediate upstream region carrying the consensus sequences was also found in hybrid promoter studies using the soybean nodulin N23 gene promoter, suggesting the involvement of these motifs in a regulatory mechanism for nodulin genes. Deletion of the lbc3 negative element (NE, -102, -49) linking the SPE and OSE onto the TATA box did not lead to unregulated expression. These results indicate that interaction between positive, negative and neutral qualitative elements controls lbc3 expression. Binding of the nuclear protein NAT2 at the lbc3 weak positive element (WPE; -230, -170) is probably not directly required for this mechanism.

Chimeric genes and transgenic plants are used to study the regulation of genes involved in symbiotic plant-microbe interactions (nodulin genes)

Nodulin genes are plant genes specifically activated during the formation of nitrogen-fixing nodules on leguminous plants. These genes are interesting to study since they are not only induced in a specific developmental fashion by signals coming directly or indirectly from the rhizobial symbiont, but are also expressed in a tissue-specific manner. By examining the expression of chimeric nodulin-reporter genes in transgenic legume plants it has been shown that nodule specific expression is mediated by DNA sequences present in the 5 upstream region of several nodulin genes. Here we summarize the available data on these cis-acting elements and the trans-acting factors interacting with them. We also review experiments designed to identify rhizobial "signals" which may play a role in nodule specific gene expression.

Identification of two groups of leghemoglobin genes in alfalfa (Medicago sativa) and a study of their expression during root nodule development

Differential screening of an alfalfa root nodule cDNA library with either root or nodule mRNA resulted in the isolation of two groups of leghemoglobin cDNA which differ significantly in sequence. Analysis of one member of each group revealed a divergence within the coding region of 15% at the nucleotide level and 14% at the amino acid level. The 3' non-coding sequences are 25% divergent but are highly conserved over a stretch of 54 nucleotides which contains two sequence motifs common to leghemoglobin genes from other plant species. Southern blotting analysis with exon-specific probes has shown that there are approximately twice as many leghemoglobin gene copies in the alfalfa genome corresponding to one type of cDNA as compared with the other. Using the same criterium of DNA sequence relatedness these two distinct groups of leghemoglobin genes have also been identified in the genomes of the diploid annual Medicago truncatula and the closely related genus, Melilotus. Transcripts corresponding to both groups of leghemoglobin genes are first detected in alfalfa nodules 9-10 days after Rhizobium inoculation. Thereafter, mRNA levels increase rapidly and synchronously, reaching a maximum approximately 2 days later. There is a 2-3 fold difference in the steady-state levels of the two mRNA populations and this is maintained throughout the subsequent two weeks of nodule growth. The absence of any detectable transcription during the early stages of nodule development and the apparent co-ordinate expression of leghemoglobin genes in alfalfa contrasts with the situation in soybean and suggests that important differences in leghemoglobin gene regulation exist between these two distantly related legume species.

Nodulin gene expression in effective alfalfa nodules and in nodules arrested at three different stages of development

Nodulin gene expression was analyzed in effective and ineffective root nodules of alfalfa (Medicago sativa L. cv Iroquois) elicited by three different Rhizobium meliloti mutants: an exoB mutant having defective acidic exopolysaccharide that does not fluoresce on plates containing the fluorescent brightener Calcofluor; fix21, a spontaneous mutant that has defective lipopolysaccharide and is Calcofluor bright; and a Rhizobium mutant resulting from a Tn5 insertion in the nifH gene of the nif operon. The ineffective nodules elicited by these various mutant rhizobia are blocked at different stages of nodule development and have unique phenotypes. A distinctive pattern of nodulin gene expression as determined by in vitro translations of total nodule RNA characterizes each nodule phenotype. Seventeen nodulins are found in effective nodules including five leghemoglobins. Only one nodulin gene is expressed in the bacteria-free nodules elicited by the exoB mutant. Other nodulin genes (leghemoglobin and nine others) are expressed in fix21-induced nodules. The genes for nodule-enhanced glutamine synthetase as well as for all the other nodulins are expressed in nodules induced by the nifH mutant. The expression of genes for the nodulins, including leghemoglobin, is independent of the nitrogen-fixing ability of the nodule and appears to correlate with the differentiation of densely cytoplasmic host cells in the nodule and, to some extent, with bacterial release from infection threads.

Primary structure and promoter analysis of leghemoglobin genes of the stem-nodulated tropical legume Sesbania rostrata: conserved coding sequences, cis-elements and trans-acting factors

The primary structure of a leghemoglobin (lb) gene from the stem-nodulated, tropical legume Sesbania rostrata and two lb gene promoter regions was analysed. The S. rostrata lb gene structure and Lb amino acid composition were found to be highly conserved with previously described lb genes and Lb proteins. Distinct DNA elements were identified in the S. rostrata lb promoter regions, which share a high degree of homology with cis-active regulatory elements found in the soybean (Glycine max) lbc3 promoter. One conserved DNA element was found to interact specifically with an apparently universal, trans-acting factor present in nuclear extracts of nodules. These results suggest a conserved mechanism for nodule specific induction of lb genes in leguminous plants.

Organ regulated expression of Parasponia andersonii haemoglobin gene in transgenic tobacco plants

Plant haemoglobin genes are known to occur in legume and non-legume families and in both nodulating (e.g., Parasponia andersonii) and non-nodulating species (e.g., Trema tomentosa). Their presence in non-nondulating plants raises the possibility that haemoglobins might serve a function in non-symbiotic tissues distinct from their role in the nitrogen-fixing root nodules induced by micro-organisms. We report here that a P. andersonii haemoglobin promoter can regulate expression of either the P. andersonii haemoglobin gene, or a hybrid construct with the bacterial chloramphenicol acetyltransferase gene (cat), in the non-symbiotic plant, Nicotiana tabacum. Expression is predominantly in the roots, implying that haemoglobins might have a function in roots of non-nodulated plants. We have also observed a low level of haemoglobin protein in non-nodulated P. andersonii roots, but not leaves, supporting this assertion. The expression in transgenic plants will allow further characterization of the promoter sequences essential for the organ-specific expression of haemoglobins in non-symbiotic tissues.

Functioning haemoglobin genes in non-nodulating plants

Haemoglobin has previously been recorded in plants only in the nitrogen-fixing nodules formed by symbiotic association between Rhizobium or Frankia and legume or non-legume hosts. Structural similarities amongst these and animal haemoglobins at the protein and gene level suggested a common evolutionary origin. This suggests that haemoglobin genes, inherited from an ancestor common to plants and animals, might be present in all plants. We report here the isolation of a haemoglobin gene from Trema tomentosa, a non-nodulating relative of Parasponia (Ulmaceae). The gene has three introns located at positions identical to those in the haemoglobin genes of nodulating plant species, strengthening the case for a common origin of all plant haemoglobin genes. The data argue strongly against horizontal haemoglobin gene transfer from animals to plants. The Trema gene has a tissue-specific pattern of transcription and translation, producing monomeric haemoglobin in Trema roots. We have also found that the Parasponia haemoglobin gene is transcribed in roots of non-nodulated plants. These results suggest that haemoglobin has a role in the respiratory metabolism of root cells of all plant species. We propose that its special role in nitrogen-fixing nodules has required adaptation of the haemoglobin-gene regulation pathway, to give high expression in the specialized environment of the nodule.

Heme regulates the expression in Saccharomyces cerevisiae of chimaeric genes containing 5'-flanking soybean leghemoglobin sequences

The TM1 yeast mutant was transformed with a 2 micron-derived plasmid (YEp24) which carries a chimaeric gene containing the Escherichia coli chloramphenicol acetyl transferase (CAT) gene fused to the 5'- and 3'-flanking regions of the soybean leghemoglobin (Lb) c3 gene. Expression of the chimaeric CAT gene is controlled specifically by heme at a post-transcriptional level, most likely by regulating the efficiencies of translation. Expression of another chimaeric gene consisting of the neomycin phosphotransferase (NPTII) gene fused to only the 5'-flanking region of the Lbc3 gene is regulated by heme in a similar way. Thus, in yeast, heme modulates the translation of the chimaeric mRNAs through interactions with the 5' Lbc3 non-coding region.

Expression of nodule-specific glutamine synthetase genes during nodule development in soybeans

A cDNA clone (pcPvNGS-01) to glutamine synthetase (GS) mRNA from root nodules of Phaseolus vulgaris showed cross-hybridization to GS and mRNA from soybean root nodules, thus allowing its use as a probe to study the expression of GS genes during root nodule development in soybeans. Hybrid-select translation of root and nodule RNA of soybean with DNA from pcPvNGS-01, followed by 2D gel electrophoresis, showed six peptides in the root and an additional four peptides in the nodule which represent nodule-specific glutamine synthetase (GSn) gene products. The GSn gene products appeared for the first time between day 11 and 12 after infection, either concomitant with the onset of nitrogenase activity or immediately following it. The levels of expression of the GSn and leghemoglobin genes were not affected in young Fix(-) nodules formed by Bradyrhizobium japonicum strains that are defective in nitrogenase activity, suggesting that the induction of these two sets of host genes take place independent of nitrogenase activity. However, in Fix(-) nodules that are incapable of maintaining the peribacteroid membrane, GSn gene products were not detected while 1ba, 1bc2 and 1bc3 appeared. In both the timing of appearance during root nodule development and the effect of different bacterial mutations on the expression, GSn genes differ from most other nodulin genes examined (30), suggesting different regulatory mechanisms.

Discrepancies among published amino acid sequences of soybean leghemoglobins: experimental evidence against cultivar differences as the sources of the discrepancies

Despite discrepancies among charged amino acid residues in published amino acid sequences, isoelectric focusing experiments failed to detect varietal differences in soybean leghemoglobins a, c1, c2, or c3. Leghemoglobins from 69 domesticated soybean (Glycine max) cultivars and plant introductions and 18 wild soybean (Glycine soja) plant introductions were compared; the sources included soybean cultivars used by research groups in obtaining amino acid sequences and most of the ancestors of North American soybean cultivars. Thus, at least some of the discrepancies among published amino acid sequences of soybean leghemoglobins are due to sequencing difficulties rather than structural differences among the leghemoglobins used by different research groups.

Expression of plant genes during the development of pea root nodules

The expression of plant genes involved in the pea-Rhizobium symbiosis was studied by analysing mRNA from root nodules. The RNA was translated in vitro and the translation products were separated by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis. The results show differential expression of nodulin genes during root nodule development. One gene encoding N-40' is expressed at a significant level 5 days before the leghemoglobin genes. Most other nodulin genes are expressed more of less concomitantly with the leghemoglobin genes whereas the N-21 mRNA is only present late during the development. In the development of ineffective root nodules induced by infection with different nod+fix- mutants of R. leguminosarum all nodulin genes are expressed except for the N-21 gene. The results suggest that neither bacteroid development, heme excretion nor nitrogen fixation are essential for the induction of nodulin gene expression in the host plant. Further, it appears that the amount of leghemoglobin in ineffective nodules is regulated at a post-transcriptional level.

The human ubiquitin multigene family: some genes contain multiple directly repeated ubiquitin coding sequences

Ubiquitin coding sequences were isolated from a human genomic library and two cDNA libraries. One human ubiquitin gene consists of 2055 nucleotides and codes for a polyprotein consisting of 685 amino acid residues. The polyprotein contains nine direct repeats of the ubiquitin amino acid sequence and the last ubiquitin sequence is extended with an additional valyl residue at the C-terminal end. No spacer sequences separate the ubiquitin repeats and the coding regions are not interrupted by intervening sequences. This particular gene is transcribed since cDNAs corresponding to the genomic sequence have been isolated. At least two more types of ubiquitin genes are encoded in the human genome, one coding for an ubiquitin monomer while another presumably codes for three or four direct repeats of the ubiquitin sequence. Human DNA contains many copies of the ubiquitin sequence. Ubiquitin is therefore encoded in the human genome as a multigene family.

The human ubiquitin multigene family: some genes contain multiple directly repeated ubiquitin coding sequences

Ubiquitin coding sequences were isolated from a human genomic library and two cDNA libraries. One human ubiquitin gene consists of 2055 nucleotides and codes for a polyprotein consisting of 685 amino acid residues. The polyprotein contains nine direct repeats of the ubiquitin amino acid sequence and the last ubiquitin sequence is extended with an additional valyl residue at the C-terminal end. No spacer sequences separate the ubiquitin repeats and the coding regions are not interrupted by intervening sequences. This particular gene is transcribed since cDNAs corresponding to the genomic sequence have been isolated. At least two more types of ubiquitin genes are encoded in the human genome, one coding for an ubiquitin monomer while another presumably codes for three or four direct repeats of the ubiquitin sequence. Human DNA contains many copies of the ubiquitin sequence. Ubiquitin is therefore encoded in the human genome as a multigene family.