Transcriptional proofreading in Escherichia coli

Synergy among Pausing, Intrinsic Proofreading, and Accessory Proteins Results in Optimal Transcription Speed and Tolerable Accuracy

Cleavage of dinucleotides after the misincorporational pauses serves as a proofreading mechanism that increases transcriptional elongation accuracy. The accuracy is further improved by accessory proteins such as GreA and TFIIS. However, it is not clear why RNAP pauses and why cleavage-factor-assisted proofreading is necessary despite transcriptional errors in vitro being of the same order as those in downstream translation. Here, we developed a chemical-kinetic model that incorporates most relevant features of transcriptional proofreading and uncovers how the balance between speed and accuracy is achieved. We found that long pauses are essential for high accuracy, whereas cleavage-factor-stimulated proofreading optimizes speed. Moreover, in comparison to the cleavage of a single nucleotide or three nucleotides, RNAP backtracking and dinucleotide cleavage improve both speed and accuracy. Our results thereby show how the molecular mechanism and the kinetic parameters of the transcriptional process were evolutionarily optimized to achieve maximal speed and tolerable accuracy.

Dysbiosis individualizes the fitness effect of antibiotic resistance in the mammalian gut

In the absence of antibiotics, it is essential that antibiotic resistance has a fitness cost for microorganisms if suspending antibiotics treatment is to be a useful strategy for reducing antibiotic resistance. However, the cost of antibiotic resistance within the complex ecosystem of the mammalian gut is not well understood. Here, using mice, we show that the same antibiotic resistance mutation can reduce fitness in one host, while being neutral or even increasing fitness in other hosts. Such antagonistic pleiotropy is shaped by the microbiota because resistance in germ-free mice is consistently costly across all hosts, and the host-specific effect on antibiotic resistance is reduced in hosts with similar microbiotas. Using an eco-evolutionary model of competition for resources, we identify a general mechanism that underlies between-host variation and predicts that the dynamics of compensatory evolution of resistant bacteria should be host specific, a prediction that was supported by experimental evolution in vivo. The microbiome of each human is close to unique, and our results suggest that the short-term cost of resistances and their long-term within-host evolution are also highly personalized, a finding that may contribute to the observed variable outcome of withdrawing antibiotics to reduce resistance levels.

A genetic assay for transcription errors reveals multilayer control of RNA polymerase II fidelity

We developed a highly sensitive assay to detect transcription errors in vivo. The assay is based on suppression of a missense mutation in the active site tyrosine in the Cre recombinase. Because Cre acts as tetramer, background from translation errors are negligible. Functional Cre resulting from rare transcription errors that restore the tyrosine codon can be detected by Cre-dependent rearrangement of reporter genes. Hence, transient transcription errors are captured as stable genetic changes. We used this Cre-based reporter to screen for mutations of Saccharomyces cerevisiae RPB1 (RPO21) that increase the level of misincorporation during transcription. The mutations are in three domains of Rpb1, the trigger loop, the bridge helix, and in sites involved in binding to TFIIS. Biochemical characterization demonstrates that these variants have elevated misincorporation, and/or ability to extend mispaired bases, or defects in TFIIS mediated editing.

GE23077 binds to the RNA polymerase 'i' and 'i+1' sites and prevents the binding of initiating nucleotides

Using a combination of genetic, biochemical, and structural approaches, we show that the cyclic-peptide antibiotic GE23077 (GE) binds directly to the bacterial RNA polymerase (RNAP) active-center ‘i’ and ‘i+1’ nucleotide binding sites, preventing the binding of initiating nucleotides, and thereby preventing transcription initiation. The target-based resistance spectrum for GE is unusually small, reflecting the fact that the GE binding site on RNAP includes residues of the RNAP active center that cannot be substituted without loss of RNAP activity. The GE binding site on RNAP is different from the rifamycin binding site. Accordingly, GE and rifamycins do not exhibit cross-resistance, and GE and a rifamycin can bind simultaneously to RNAP. The GE binding site on RNAP is immediately adjacent to the rifamycin binding site. Accordingly, covalent linkage of GE to a rifamycin provides a bipartite inhibitor having very high potency and very low susceptibility to target-based resistance.

DOI:http://dx.doi.org/10.7554/eLife.02450.001

As increasing numbers of bacteria become resistant to antibiotics, new drugs are needed to fight bacterial infections. To develop new antibacterial drugs, researchers need to understand how existing antibiotics work. There are many ways to kill bacteria, but one of the most effective is to target an enzyme called bacterial RNA polymerase. If bacterial RNA polymerase is prevented from working, bacteria cannot synthesize RNA and cannot survive.

GE23077 (GE for short) is an antibiotic produced by bacteria found in soil. Although GE stops bacterial RNA polymerase from working, and thereby kills bacteria, it does not affect mammalian RNA polymerases, and so does not kill mammalian cells. Understanding how GE works could help with the development of new antibacterial drugs.

Zhang et al. present results gathered from a range of techniques to show how GE inhibits bacterial RNA polymerase. These show that GE works by binding to a site on RNA polymerase that is different from the binding sites of previously characterized antibacterial drugs. The mechanism used to inhibit the RNA polymerase is also different.

The newly identified binding site has several features that make it an unusually attractive target for development of antibacterial compounds. Bacteria can become resistant to an antibiotic if genetic mutations lead to changes in the site the antibiotic binds to. However, the site that GE binds to on RNA polymerase is essential for RNA polymerase to function and so cannot readily be changed without crippling the enzyme. Therefore, this type of antibiotic resistance is less likely to develop.

In addition, the newly identified binding site for GE on RNA polymerase is located next to the binding site for a current antibacterial drug, rifampin. Zhang et al. therefore linked GE and rifampin to form a two-part (‘bipartite’) compound designed to bind simultaneously to the GE and the rifampin binding sites. This compound was able to inhibit drug-resistant RNA polymerases tens to thousands of times more potently than GE or rifampin alone.

DOI:http://dx.doi.org/10.7554/eLife.02450.002

Isolation and characterization of RNA polymerase rpoB mutations that alter transcription slippage during elongation in Escherichia coli

Transcription fidelity is critical for maintaining the accurate flow of genetic information. The study of transcription fidelity has been limited because the intrinsic error rate of transcription is obscured by the higher error rate of translation, making identification of phenotypes associated with transcription infidelity challenging. Slippage of elongating RNA polymerase (RNAP) on homopolymeric A/T tracts in DNA represents a special type of transcription error leading to disruption of open reading frames in Escherichia coli mRNA. However, the regions in RNAP involved in elongation slippage and its molecular mechanism are unknown. We constructed an A/T tract that is out of frame relative to a downstream lacZ gene on the chromosome to examine transcriptional slippage during elongation. Further, we developed a genetic system that enabled us for the first time to isolate and characterize E. coli RNAP mutants with altered transcriptional slippage in vivo. We identified several amino acid residues in the β subunit of RNAP that affect slippage in vivo and in vitro. Interestingly, these highly clustered residues are located near the RNA strand of the RNA-DNA hybrid in the elongation complex. Our E. coli study complements an accompanying study of slippage by yeast RNAP II and provides the basis for future studies on the mechanism of transcription fidelity.

The Influence of Look-Ahead on the Error Rate of Transcription

In this paper we study the error rate of RNA synthesis in the look-ahead model for the random walk of RNA polymerase along DNA during transcription. The model's central assumption is the existence of a window of activity in which ribonucleoside triphosphates (rNTPs) bind reversibly to the template DNA strand before being hydrolyzed and linked covalently to the nascent RNA chain. An unknown, but important, integer parameter of this model is the window size w. Here, we use mathematical analysis and computer simulation to study the rate at which transcriptional errors occur as a function of w. We find dramatic reduction in the error rate of transcription as w increases, especially for small values of w. The error reduction method provided by look-ahead occurs before hydrolysis and covalent linkage of rNTP to the nascent RNA chain, and is therefore distinct from error correction mechanisms that have previously been considered.

Ribosomal Proteins in the Spotlight

The assignment of specific ribosomal functions to individual ribosomal proteins is difficult due to the enormous cooperativity of the ribosome; however, important roles for distinct ribosomal proteins are becoming evident. Although rRNA has a major role in certain aspects of ribosomal function, such as decoding and peptidyl-transferase activity, ribosomal proteins are nevertheless essential for the assembly and optimal functioning of the ribosome. This is particularly true in the context of interactions at the entrance pore for mRNA, for the translation-factor binding site and at the tunnel exit, where both chaperones and complexes associated with protein transport through membranes bind.

Why is transcription coupled to translation in bacteria?

Active mechanisms exist to prevent transcription that is uncoupled from translation in the protein-coding genes of bacteria, as exemplified by the phenomenon of nonsense polarity. Bacterial transcription-translation coupling may be viewed as one among several co-transcriptional processes, including those for mRNA processing and export in the eukaryotes, that operate in the various life forms to render the nascent transcript unavailable for formation of otherwise deleterious R-loops in the genome.

Specificity of an Escherichia coli RNA polymerase-associated NTPase

Standard preparations of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase harbor a 70 kDa protein with NTPase (beta-gamma cleavage) activity that is not a recognized polymerase subunit. The NTPase activity of this component, before and after separation from the polymerase, is strongly dependent on the presence of DNA; single-stranded polydeoxynucleotides are more effective than double-stranded. ATP and GTP are cleaved, the latter much less readily. The NTPase as it occurs with the polymerase displays cleavage preference for NTPs that are not complementary to the DNA, a fact that has led to proposals for involvement of the NTPase in transcriptional error prevention [Volloch, V. Z., Rits, L. & Tumerman, L. (1979) Nucleic Acids Res. 6, 1535-1546; Libby, R. T., Nelson, J. L., Calvo, J. M., & Gallant, J. A. (1989) EMBO J. 8, 3253-3158]. We find, however, that the lesser cleavage in the presence of complementary DNA results from competition for the NTP between the processes of incorporation by the polymerase and of cleavage by the NTPase, operating on the same substrate pool. The greater cleavage with noncomplementary DNA occurs because of the lack of incorporation by the polymerase, which then does not compete with the NTPase for the substrate pool. Thus, these findings indicate that the cleavage preference of the NTPase for noncomplementary NTPs is not part of a mechanism for error prevention during transcription.

Ribosomal decoding processes at codons in the A or P sites depend differently on 2'-OH groups

The importance of 2'-OH groups of codons for binding of cognate tRNAs to ribosomal P and A sites was analyzed applying the following strategy. An mRNA of 41 nucleotides was synthesized with the structure C16-GAA-UUC-GUC-C16 coding for glutamic acid (E), phenylalanine (F) and valine (V), respectively, in the middle (EFV-mRNA). A second template, the E(dF)V-mRNA, was identical except that it carried a deoxyribo-codon-dUdUdC- for phenylalanine. tRNA binding to the P site is totally insensitive to the presence or absence of the 2'-OH group of the P-site codon, and tRNA binding to the P site is also not affected if the A-site codon lacks the 2'-OH groups. However, binding is impaired if the deoxy-codon is present at the E site. In sharp contrast, the A-site binding of Ac-aminoacyl-tRNA was severely reduced in the presence of the deoxy-codon at the A site as well as at the P site. The results demonstrate that the correctness of base pairing is also "sensed" via a correct sugar structure of the codon, e.g. positioning of the sugar pucker (2'-OH), during the decoding process at the A site (elongation) but not during the decoding at the P site (initiation).

Phosphorolytic error correction during transcription

Escherichia coli DNA-directed RNA polymerase is shown to contain a novel phosphorolytic error correction activity which removes erroneous nucleotides, as rNDPs, from the 3'-end of the growing transcript. The activity we describe is biochemically similar to polynucleotide phosphorylase (PNP), yet in contrast to PNP is activated by Mn2+. We demonstrate that the activity, which is mediated by Pi, is dependent on the presence of an incorrectly incorporated nucleotide at the leading 3'-end of the transcript. The correction activity we describe exhibits a 4 x 10(4)-fold preference for the excision of incorrect nucleotides from the transcript. These findings suggest the possibility that RNA phosphorolysis may play a critical role in the process of transcriptional proofreading.

Solution of the ribosome riddle: how the ribosome selects the correct aminoacyl-tRNA out of 41 similar contestants

Three tRNA binding sites, the A, P and E sites, have been demonstrated on ribosomes of bacterial, archaebacterial and eukaryotic origin. In all these cases the first and the third site, the A and the E site, are allosterically coupled in the sense of a negative co-operativity. Therefore, the allosteric three-site model seems to be a generally valid description of the ribosomal elongation phase, where in a cycle of reactions the nascent peptide chain is prolonged by one amino acid. The molecular concept of the allosteric three-site model explains the astonishing ability of the ribosome to select the correct substrate out of a large number of very similar substrates, and it provides a framework within which the mechanisms of the elongation factors could be understood.

Editing of errors in selection of amino acids for protein synthesis

All living cells must conduct protein synthesis with a high degree of accuracy maintained in the transmission and flow of information from gene to finished protein product. One crucial "quality control" point in maintaining a high level of accuracy is the selectivity by which aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases furnish correctly activated amino acids, attached to tRNA species, as the building blocks for growing protein chains. During selection of amino acids, synthetases very often have to distinguish the cognate substrate from a homolog having just one fewer methyl group in its structure. The binding energy of a methyl group is estimated to contribute only a factor of 100 to the specificity of binding, yet synthetases distinguish such closely related amino acids with a discrimination factor of 10,000 to 100,000. Examples of this include methionine versus homocysteine, isoleucine versus valine, alanine versus glycine, and threonine versus serine. Many investigators have demonstrated in vitro the ability of certain aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases to edit, that is, correct or prevent incorrect attachment of amino acids to tRNA molecules. Several major editing pathways are now established from in vitro data. Further, at least some aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases have recently been shown to carry out the editing function in vivo. Editing has been demonstrated to occur in both Escherichia coli and Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Significant energy is expended by the cell for editing of misactivated amino acids, which can be reflected in the growth rate. Because of this, cellular levels of aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases, as well as amino acid biosynthetic pathways which yield competing substrates for protein synthesis, must be carefully regulated to prevent excessive editing. High-level expression of recombinant proteins imposes a strain on the biosynthetic capacity of the cell which frequently results in misincorporation of abnormal or wrong amino acids owing in part to limited editing by synthetases. Unbalanced amino acid pools associated with some genetic disorders in humans may also lead to errors in tRNA aminoacylation. The availability of X-ray crystallographic structures of some synthetases, combined with site-directed mutagenesis, allows insights into molecular details of the extraordinary selectivity of synthetases, including the editing function.

Accuracy of wheat-germ RNA polymerase II. General enzymatic properties and effect of template conformational transition from right-handed B-DNA to left-handed Z-DNA

We investigated the accuracy of the insertion process in RNA chain elongation catalyzed by wheat germ RNA polymerase II. Error frequencies varied from 1 misinserted nucleotide per 250 polymerized correct substrates to less than 1 in 2 x 10(5), depending on template sequence and nature of the divalent metal cofactor. Higher error ratios were observed in the presence of Mn2+ compared to Mg2+, and with alternating poly[d(G-C)].poly[d(G-C)] compared to poly[d(A-T)].poly[d(A-T)]. In this latter case the eukaryotic RNA polymerase was as accurate as Escherichia coli RNA polymerase holo-enzyme. The fidelity of wheat germ RNA polymerase II was also examined in transcription of polynucleotide templates in the poly[d(G-C)] family adopting either the right-handed B or left-handed Z conformations. Error ratios for noncomplementary ATP increased markedly under experimental conditions favoring the B-to-Z conformational transition of the alternating copolymers. In accordance with the results of previous studies, the rate of productive elongation, i.e. the synthesis of poly[r(G-C)], was depressed, suggesting that the decreased accuracy of the enzyme derived from an altered competence of the enzyme to form elongation complexes on the left-handed DNA. As judged by the large difference in apparent Km values of the enzyme for complementary and noncomplementary nucleoside triphosphates, part of the discrimination between substrates seemed to take place at the initial binding step. Furthermore, the results indicate that wheat germ RNA polymerase II was able to elongate a primer with a 3'-terminal mismatch, and thus to incorporate the mismatched nucleotide stably in the nascent RAN. However, the probability of productive RNA chain elongation was much lower with noncognate than with the complementary substrates.

Identification of a component separated on Mono Q purification of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase as an NTPase

Standard preparations of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase (RNAP) contain NTPase activity. High-performance anion-exchange chromatography on Mono Q has recently been used by Hager et al. [1990, Biochemistry 29, 7890-7894] to fractionate RNAP into holoenzyme (alpha 2 beta beta' sigma) and core (alpha 2 beta beta') forms, plus other protein components. We found that one of these components, of protomer size slightly larger than the sigma 70 subunit, has NTPase activity; it is efficiently separated on Mono Q, leaving transcriptionally active holoenzyme and core apparently free of NTPase activity. Because of the similarity in size with sigma 70, the NTPase component may escape detection by routine gel electrophoresis.

Effects of template topology on RNA polymerase pausing during in vitro transcription of the Escherichia coli rrnB leader region

Transcription elongation catalysed by DNA-dependent RNA polymerase does not occur at a constant rate. Instead, during the transcription of many genes pausing occurs at defined template positions. Pausing is known to be influenced by the intracellular NTP concentration, the secondary structure of the growing transcript or by transcription factors like NusA. We have investigated the effects of the template topology of transcriptional pauses in the presence and absence on purified NusA protein. Taking advantage of a method for quantifying transcriptional pauses we have studied pausing behaviour during in vitro transcription of the early region of a plasmid-encoded ribosomal RNA operon. Plasmid templates with different superhelical densities (sigma between +0.0017 and -0.055) were employed in transcription elongation assays. If linearized or relaxed templates are used, some of the characteristic pauses can no longer be detected. For the stronger pauses we could demonstrate a direct correlation between pause strength and the negative superhelical densities of the templates used. This correlation is observed regardless of whether or not pauses are dependent upon NusA. Changes in the average transcription elongation rate, caused by variations in the NTP concentration or the temperature, do not appear to have a comparable effect on transcription pausing. The results are consistent with the assumption that the template topology has a regulatory function in transcription elongation of rRNA genes in Escherichia coli.

Connections between translation, transcription and replication error-rates

The analysis of published data from E coli suggests that in all three processes of translation, transcription, and replication, a minority of errors are produced by sub-classes of error-prone components. These add to the basal level of errors a noise of about 10 to 30%. Each one of the three processes contributes to the noisiness of the two others in a loose manner: a large increase in one error-rate produces a moderate increase in another error-rate. The strongest influence is that of transcription on translation errors. There it is possible that a majority of the misacylation errors are produced during the encounter of a correct amino acyl-tRNA ligase with a mistranscribed tRNA. Extreme mutator mutants are expected to produce a moderate increase in translation errors.

The role of RNA polymerase in transcriptional fidelity

The overall transcription of DNA has previously been demonstrated to proceed at extremely high levels of accuracy. We review the evidence that the process of transcription is subject to proof-reading in the Hopfield sense. In addition, we speculate that the proof-reading activity associated with transcription is subject to cyclical phase transitions. That is, during periods of low processivity associated with initiation, RNA synthesis is relatively imprecise. The transition to the elongation phase of RNA synthesis, characterized by a shift to high processivity, is accompanied by enhanced proof-reading. A model for the damping of transcriptional errors, based on a PPi-mediated processive pyrophosphorolysis reaction, is discussed in terms of pausing during transcription.

Requirement for the beta,gamma-pyrophosphate bond of ATP in a stage between transcription initiation and elongation by Escherichia coli RNA polymerase

A linear fragment of DNA was fixed to acrylamide or agarose beads by its ends. When a fragment containing the lambda PR promoter is immobilized and transcribed, the RNA products are unchanged from those obtained on the unfixed DNA. Transcription from the immobilized fragment can be interrupted by diluting the reaction mixture into a large volume of the same buffer. Brief centrifugation allows isolation of the transcription complex with the immobilized DNA. If interruption occurs during elongation, the elongation can be resumed upon a second addition of substrates. If ATP is replaced by a beta, gamma-unhydrolyzable analogue in the second addition, the elongated products are similar to those obtained when the substrate contain ATP. When ATP is replaced by the analogue at the initiation step, however, the yield of elongated products is decreased to less than one-sixth and that of short abortive products is increased. Thus the ATP analogues are good substrates once elongation has been established in the presence of ATP, but not good enough to get past a stage just after initiation in the absence of ATP. We conclude that the beta, gamma-pyrophosphate bond of ATP is important for preparation of efficient elongation.

A quantitative assessment for transcriptional pausing of DNA-dependent RNA polymerases in vitro

A simple definition for pause strength (tau i) has been given, quantitatively describing transcriptional pausing of RNA polymerases. It permits derivation of practical assessments, based on single-round transcription reactions, which measure the average time a polymerase stops in vitro at certain sites during transcription elongation. We demonstrate that pause strengths can be determined with high accuracy when transcription elongation is started simultaneously from radioactively labeled and purified ternary complexes and transcripts are separated on sequencing gels. Our concept is exemplified by measuring pause strengths on supercoiled templates in the leader region of the Escherichia coli rrnB operon in the presence and the absence of the transcription factor NusA.

The allosteric three-site model for the ribosomal elongation cycle: features and future

The ribosome contains three binding sites for tRNA, viz., the A site for aminoacyl-tRNA (decoding site), the P site for peptidyl-tRNA, and the E site for deacylated tRNA (E for exit). The surprising finding of an allosteric linkage between the E and A sites in the sense of a negative cooperativity has three consequences: (a) it improves the proper selection of aminoacyl-tRNAs while preventing interference from noncognate aminoacyl-tRNAs in the decoding process, (b) it provides an explanation for the ribosomal accuracy without having to resort to the proofreading hypothesis, and (c) it has deepened our understanding of the mode of action of some antibiotics.

A putative ATP binding protein influences the fidelity of branchpoint recognition in yeast splicing

We previously described a dominant suppressor of the splicing defect conferred by an A----C intron branchpoint mutation in S. cerevisiae. Suppression occurs by increasing the frequency with which the mutant branchpoint is utilized. We have now cloned the genomic region encoding the prp16-1 suppressor function and have demonstrated that PRP16 is essential for viability. A 1071 amino acid open reading frame contains sequence motifs characteristic of an NTP binding fold and further similarities to a superfamily of proteins that includes members with demonstrated RNA-dependent ATPase activity. A single nucleotide change necessary to confer the prp16-1 suppressor phenotype results in a Tyr----Asp substitution near the "A site" consensus for NTP binding proteins. We propose that PRP16 is an excellent candidate for mediating one of the many ATP-requiring steps of spliceosome assembly and that accuracy of branchpoint recognition may be coupled to ATP binding and/or hydrolysis.