Metabolic plasticity in development: Synergistic responses to high temperature and hypoxia in zebrafish, Danio rerio

Fish models to explore epigenetic determinants of hypoxia-tolerance

The occurrence of environmental hypoxia in freshwater and marine aquatic systems has increased over the last century and is predicted to further increase with climate change. As members of the largest extant vertebrate group, freshwater fishes, and to a much lesser extent marine fishes, are vulnerable to increased occurrence of hypoxia. This is important as fishes render important ecosystem services and have important cultural and economic roles. Evolutionarily successful, fishes have adapted to diverse aquatic freshwater and marine habitats with different oxygen conditions. While some fishes exhibit genetic adaptions to tolerate hypoxia and even anoxia, others are limited to oxygen-rich habitats. Recent advances in molecular epigenetics have shown that some epigenetic machinery, especially histone- and DNA demethylases, is directly dependent on oxygen and modulates important transcription-regulating epigenetic marks in the process. At the post-transcriptional level, hypoxia has been shown to affect non-coding microRNA abundance. Together, this evidence adds a new molecular epigenetic basis to study hypoxia tolerance in fishes. Here, we review the documented and predicted changes in environmental hypoxia in aquatic systems and discuss the diversity and comparative physiology of hypoxia tolerance in fishes, including molecular and physiological adaptations. We then discuss how recent mechanistic advances in environmental epigenetics can inform future work probing the role of oxygen-dependent epigenetic marks in shaping organismal hypoxia-tolerance in fishes with a focus on within- and between-species variation, acclimation, inter- and multigenerational plasticity, and multiple climate-change stressors. We conclude by describing the translational potential of this approach for conservation physiology, ecotoxicology, and aquaculture.

Energetic Costs of Stress in Developing Fishes: Quantifying Allostasis and Allostatic Load

Stress exerts negative effects on fish health through stimulation of the hypothalamic-pituitary-interrenal axis and autonomic nervous system, resulting in heightened neural and neuroendocrine responses. Energetic investment and physiological adaptation are then required to re-establish homeostatic stability or reach a new allostatic state. The cost of the energetic investment is referred to as allostatic load (AL). While determining the sources of stress and assessing their consequences have resulted in estimates of AL, most of this work has been conducted in adult mammals and humans; no ALs exist for developing fish. From a series of experiments on a model species, zebrafish (Danio rerio), whose yolk-sac larvae were exposed to two chronic stressors (high-temperature and hypoxia), ALs were quantified based on biomarkers of ontogenetic changes in growth, morphometrics, and metabolic activities. Results showed that for zebrafish yolk-sac larvae, chronic stress imposed high AL and, thus, high total allostatic energetic costs, (Rt (AL)), because of prolonged energy demand in the face of limited resources (e.g., yolk). Under severe chronic stress, energetic costs were sufficiently large that energy-limited developing fish may not be able to fully compensate, resulting in maladaptive responses from allostatic overload, leading either to death or to novel allostatic states, possibly more resilient to environmental change.

A larval zebrafish model of cardiac physiological recovery following cardiac arrest and myocardial hypoxic damage

Contemporary cardiac injury models in zebrafish larvae include cryoinjury, laser ablation, pharmacological treatment and cardiac dysfunction mutations. Although effective in damaging cardiomyocytes, these models lack the important element of myocardial hypoxia, which induces critical molecular cascades within cardiac muscle. We have developed a novel, tractable, high throughput in vivo model of hypoxia-induced cardiac damage that can subsequently be used in screening cardioactive drugs and testing recovery therapies. Our potentially more realistic model for studying cardiac arrest and recovery involves larval zebrafish (Danio rerio) acutely exposed to severe hypoxia (PO2=5-7 mmHg). Such exposure induces loss of mobility quickly followed by cardiac arrest occurring within 120 min in 5 days post fertilization (dpf) and within 40 min at 10 dpf. Approximately 90% of 5 dpf larvae survive acute hypoxic exposure, but survival fell to 30% by 10 dpf. Upon return to air-saturated water, only a subset of larvae resumed heartbeat, occurring within 4 min (5 dpf) and 6-8 min (8-10 dpf). Heart rate, stroke volume and cardiac output in control larvae before hypoxic exposure were 188±5 bpm, 0.20±0.001 nL and 35.5±2.2 nL/min (n=35), respectively. After briefly falling to zero upon severe hypoxic exposure, heart rate returned to control values by 24 h of recovery. However, reflecting the severe cardiac damage induced by the hypoxic episode, stroke volume and cardiac output remained depressed by ∼50% from control values at 24 h of recovery, and full restoration of cardiac function ultimately required 72 h post-cardiac arrest. Immunohistological staining showed co-localization of Troponin C (identifying cardiomyocytes) and Capase-3 (identifying cellular apoptosis). As an alternative to models employing mechanical or pharmacological damage to the developing myocardium, the highly reproducible cardiac effects of acute hypoxia-induced cardiac arrest in the larval zebrafish represent an alternative, potentially more realistic model that mimics the cellular and molecular consequences of an infarction for studying cardiac tissue hypoxia injury and recovery of function.

Hypoxia alters the upper thermal limits and blood physiology in zebrafish, Danio rerio

Hypoxic aquatic environments occur more frequently as a result of climate change, thereby exerting challenges on the physiological and metabolic functions of aquatic animals. In this study, a model fish, zebrafish (Danio rerio) was used to observe the climate-induced hypoxic effect on the upper thermal limit (critical thermal maximum; CTmax), hemoglobin, and blood glucose levels, and abnormalities of erythrocytes at cellular and nuclear level. The value of CTmax decreased significantly under hypoxia (39.10 ± 0.96 °C) compared to normoxia (43.70 ± 0.91 °C). At CTmax, hemoglobin levels were much lower (9.33 ± 0.60 g/dL) and blood glucose levels were significantly higher (194.20 ± 11.33 mg/L) under hypoxia than they were under normoxia and at the beginning of the experiment. Increased frequencies of abnormalities in the erythrocytes at both cellular (fusion, twin, elongated, spindle and tear drop shaped) and nuclear (micronucleus, karyopyknosis, binuclei, nuclear degeneration and notched nuclei) levels were also found under hypoxia compared to normoxia. These results suggest that hypoxic conditions significantly alter the temperature tolerance and subsequent physiology in zebrafish. Our findings will aid in the development of effective management techniques for aquatic environments with minimum oxygen availability.

Crucial Development: Criticality Is Important to Cell-to-Cell Communication and Information Transfer in Living Systems

In the fourth paper of this Special Issue, we bridge the theoretical debate on the role of memory and criticality discussed in the three earlier manuscripts, with a review of key concepts in biology and focus on cell-to-cell communication in organismal development. While all living organisms are dynamic complex networks of organization and disorder, most studies in biology have used energy and biochemical exchange to explain cell differentiation without considering the importance of information (entropy) transfer. While all complex networks are mixtures of patterns of complexity (non-crucial and crucial events), it is the crucial events that determine the efficiency of information transfer, especially during key transitions, such as in embryogenesis. With increasing multicellularity, emergent relationships from cell-to-cell communication create reaction-diffusion exchanges of different concentrations of biochemicals or morphogenetic gradients resulting in differential gene expression. We suggest that in conjunction with morphogenetic gradients, there exist gradients of information transfer creating cybernetic loops of stability and disorder, setting the stage for adaptive capability. We specifically reference results from the second paper in this Special Issue, which correlated biophotons with lentil seed germination to show that phase transitions accompany changes in complexity patterns during development. Criticality, therefore, appears to be an important factor in the transmission, transfer and coding of information for complex adaptive system development.

Modeling Cancer Using Zebrafish Xenografts: Drawbacks for Mimicking the Human Microenvironment

The first steps towards establishing xenografts in zebrafish embryos were performed by Lee et al., 2005 and Haldi et al., 2006, paving the way for studying human cancers using this animal species. Since then, the xenograft technique has been improved in different ways, ranging from optimizing the best temperature for xenografted embryo incubation, testing different sites for injection of human tumor cells, and even developing tools to study how the host interacts with the injected cells. Nonetheless, a standard protocol for performing xenografts has not been adopted across laboratories, and further research on the temperature, microenvironment of the tumor or the cell-host interactions inside of the embryo during xenografting is still needed. As a consequence, current non-uniform conditions could be affecting experimental results in terms of cell proliferation, invasion, or metastasis; or even overestimating the effects of some chemotherapeutic drugs on xenografted cells. In this review, we highlight and raise awareness regarding the different aspects of xenografting that need to be improved in order to mimic, in a more efficient way, the human tumor microenvironment, resulting in more robust and accurate in vivo results.

The effects of temperature on the proxies of visual detection of Danio rerio larvae: observations from the optic tectum

Numerous studies have indicated that temperature improves the visual capabilities of different ectotherms, including a variety of fish species. However, none of these studies has directly tested whether elevated temperature extends the visual detection distance - the distance from which a visual stimulus is detected. To test this hypothesis, we investigated the effect of temperature on the visual detection distance of zebrafish (Danio rerio) larvae by measuring the largest distance from a moving target that induced a neural response in the optic tectum. We applied advanced methods of functional calcium imaging such as selective plane illumination microscopy in combination with a miniature OLED screen. The screen displayed an artificial, mobile prey, appearing in the visual field of the larvae. We performed experiments in three temperature treatments (18, 23 and 28°C) on transgenic fish expressing a fluorescent probe (GCaMP5G) that changes intensity in response to altered Ca2+ concentrations in the nerves in the optic tectum. Based on the obtained data, we also measured three additional parameters of the neural response in the optic tectum, each being a proxy of sensitivity to changes in the stimulus movement. We did not confirm our hypothesis, since the visual detection distance shortened as the temperature increased. Moreover, all of the three additional parameters indicated a negative effect of the temperature on the speed of the neural response to the stimuli. However, the obtained results could be explained not only by worse visual capabilities at the elevated temperature, but also by the differences in the visual field and in turn, the retinotopic location of the visual stimulus between the temperature treatments, since the stimulus in the experiments moved horizontally rather than forward and backward from the fish's eye.

Hemoglobin Polymerization in Red Blood Cells of Marine Fishes: A Case of Adaptive Phenotypic Plasticity?

We investigated the occurrence of the unusual phenomenon of hemoglobin polymerization in a 10-year survey of 47 species of fishes. Similar to human sickle cell disease, hemoglobin polymers in fish red blood cells can cause distortion or sickling under low oxygen and low pH. We sampled fish from three geographic areas, including the east and west coasts of the Atlantic Ocean and the Gulf of Mexico. Fifteen species spanning five orders and nine families exhibited hemoglobin polymerization in vitro, with a majority in or related to Gadiformes, as well as species within Notocanthiformes, Perciformes, and Scorpianiformes. Atlantic cod, Gadus morhua, also showed the trait in vivo. Light and transmission electron microscopy confirmed the presence of hemoglobin polymers at the cellular level, but the morphology of hemoglobin polymers and rates of polymerization varied across species. Hemoglobin polymerization in red blood cells in vitro was pH dependent and reversible. For two species, G. morhua and Opsanus tau, >60% and >40% of all red blood cells contained hemoglobin polymers at pH 7.6, while 100% and 90% of red blood cells polymerized at pH 6.96, respectively. In both species, recovery of 60%-70% of red blood cells occurred within 45 minutes when pH increased from 6.96 to 7.99. From these results we conclude that hemoglobin polymerization is present in a broad range of fish taxa occupying wide biogeographical ranges and habitats and that it is oxygen and pH sensitive. The physiology and adaptive significance of hemoglobin polymerization in fishes remain unclear, but as oceans and coastal environments become more hypoxic and hypercapnic, this trait may have the potential to affect fish survival.

Combined effects of warming and hypoxia on early life stage Chinook salmon physiology and development

Early life stages of salmonids are particularly vulnerable to warming and hypoxia, which are common stressors in hyporheic, gravel bed, rearing habitat (i.e. a 'redd'). With the progression of global climate change, high temperatures and hypoxia may co-occur more frequently within redds, particularly for salmonid species at their southern range limit. Warming and hypoxia have competing effects on energy supply and demand, which can be detrimental to energy-limited early life stages. We examined how elevated temperature and hypoxia as individual and combined stressors affected the survival, physiological performance, growth, and development of Chinook salmon (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha). We reared late fall-run Chinook salmon from fertilization to the fry stage in a fully factorial design of two temperatures [10°C (ambient) and 14°C (warm)] and two oxygen levels [normoxia (100% air saturation, 10 mg O₂/l) and hypoxia (50% saturation, 5.5 mg O₂/l)]. Rearing in hypoxia significantly reduced hatching success, especially in combination with warming. Both warming and hypoxia improved acute thermal tolerance. While rearing in hypoxia improved tolerance to acute hypoxia stress, warming reduced hypoxia tolerance. Hypoxia-reared fish were smaller at hatch, but were able to reach similar sizes to the normoxia-reared fish by the fry stage. High temperature and normoxia resulted in the fastest rate of development while low temperature and hypoxia resulted in the slowest rate of development. Despite improved physiological tolerance to acute heat and hypoxia stress, hypoxia-reared embryos had reduced survival and growth, which could have larger population-level effects. These results suggest that both warming and hypoxia are important factors to address in conservation strategies for Chinook salmon.