Prognostic value of the estrogen receptor level in pathologic stage I and II adenocarcinoma of the breast

Prognostic Factors in Operable Breast Cancer

A series of 743 consecutive cases of operable breast cancer, admitted and treated at the Istituto Nazionale Tumori of Milan from 1969 to 1970, was analized by a multivariate statistical method to evaluate a) the variables of the host and the primary tumor associated with the frequency of nodal metastases, b) the variables that significantly affect survival, and c) the identification of homogeneous risk groups. As regards the frequency of regional node metastases, they were more frequently observed in young than in old patients with large tumors (P values 10–5 and 3×10–5, respectively). Tumors that originated in the axillary tail, upper, outer and central quadrants were significantly associated with a higher rate of node metastases (P = 0.002). Each of these variables maintained its significant value when adjusted by the other two. Survival was affected at a statistically significant level by the age of the patients (P = 2×10–4), the pathologic diameter of the primary tumor (P < 10–6), and the number of metastatic regional nodes (P < 10 –6). The number of involved nodes appears to be the most relevant factor in the assessment of prognosis of patients with positive nodes, Age of the patients, size of the primary tumor, and number of involved nodes maintain their own statistical significance when each is adjusted by the remaining two. The site of origin of the primary tumor, even if associated with the frequency of regional node metastases, did not affect survival. Three groups with a significantly different risk of death were identified in patients with negative lymph nodes and three groups in patients with positive nodes. It is concluded that age, size of the primary, and number of involved lymph nodes are important pieces of information that clinicians should have at hand following radical surgery, not only to make a prognosis, but also to identify groups of patients with high risk of death on which the role of adjuvant treatment should be evaluated.

Estrogen receptor α-negative and progesterone receptor-positive breast cancer: Lab error or real entity?

Aretrospective study comparing the estrogen receptor (ER) alpha subtype and progesterone receptor (PR) profile of breast carcinomas amongst 1625 cases over 2.5 years was carried out. Strictly speaking it is generally believed that breast carcinomas can biochemically express PR only if they are ER-positive. However, a few ERalpha-PR+ cases do exist paradoxically. This class of tumors was the focus of our study in which we looked at the possible reasons for such an immunophenotype and compared it with a group of ERalpha+PR+ breast carcinomas. An internationally recognized immunohistochemical method employing monoclonal antibodies against estrogen and progesterone receptors was used. Correlations with established risk factors i.e. menopausal status, grade, tumor size and lymph node status were analyzed for our study group (ERalpha-PR+) and compared with a control (ERalpha+PR+). Out of the total 1625 cases, 29.91% (486) were ERalpha+PR+, 5.11% (83) were ERalpha+PR-, 56.86% (924) were ERalpha-PR- and 8.12% (132) were ERalpha-PR+. Patients' age was significantly lower in the ERalpha-PR+ group (P=0.002). Statistical analysis of the grading between the two study groups revealed no significant difference (P=0.091), although the ERalpha-PR+ group contained significantly more poorly differentiated tumors than the ERalpha+PR+ one (P=0.032). Tumor size was also significantly larger in the ERalpha-PR+ than in the ERalpha+PR+ group (P=0.046). The frequency of lymph node metastases was independent of receptor profile. In conclusion, our study group does exhibit characteristics which are suggestive of a distinct breast cancer phenotype (ERalpha-PR+) with a different etiology and prognosis.

The H19 gene is expressed within both epithelial and stromal components of human invasive adenocarcinomas

In a previous work, we have isolated the human H19 gene and shown accumulation of transcripts in various human tumors including breast carcinomas (Douc-Rasy et al (1993) Int J Oncol 2, 753-758). Questions arose, after Northern blot results, about the precise H19 mRNA location, specially in normal breast tissues and benign or malign primary breast tumors. Then we performed molecular in situ hybridization to get insight into tissue expression of the H19 gene. Examined resections included one normal tissue, one fibroadenoma and 13 cancers. Results obtained with the H19 probe can be summarized as follows: 1) in normal breast tissues signals were focally observed in epithelial cells, but more predominantly in the palleal tissue which is sensitive to hormones; 2) in the fibroadenoma, fibroblastic cells were extensively labeled at the stroma-epithelium boundary, but epithelial cells were negative; and 3) in primary cancers, eight specimens exhibited signals on stromal cells, one specimen on epithelial cells and four on both epithelial and stromal cells. Data provide the following evidence: 1) usually labeled cells are clustered, either within normal or pathological tissues; 2) the labeling pattern highly differs from one tumor to another; and 3) H19 probe displays very different signals from one cell to another in given compartment of a given tissue section. In conclusion, it seems that a high H19 expression matches the tumor invasion. Our results suggest that the expression of this gene is concerned by the relationships between epithelial and stromal cells, and can reflect peculiar physiological states of the cells. Furthermore, we discuss results showing an abundant expression of H19 gene in some adenocarcinomas of bad prognosis, in the context of the otherwise established tumor-suppressor role of this gene, or the strictly controlled gene dosage, which could be overridden in these particular cases.

A prospective analysis of immunohistochemically determined hormone receptors and nuclear features as predictors of early recurrence in primary breast cancer

The immunohistochemically determined receptor status, as well as first-generation risk factors (tumor size, lymph node status, histologic grading including subfactors, tumor histology, and biochemically determined receptor status) were prospectively analyzed in 288 cases of primary breast cancer for their impact on recurrence-free survival (RFS) and overall survival (OS) after a median observation period of 41 months. Immunohistochemically (ER-ICA) and biochemically determined estrogen receptors (ER-DCC), as well as tumor size, lymph node status, histologic grading, mitotic rate, and nuclear polymorphism, were of prognostic value for recurrence-free survival and/or overall survival. In multivariate analysis, lymph node status, tumor size, and mitotic rate proved to be independent prognosticators; ER-ICA showed significance in the univariate analysis which dropped, however, when multivariate analysis was applied. The prognostic power of histologic grading in our series seemed to depend mainly on the subfactors which relate to nuclear features.

Immunohistochemical and biochemical measurement of estrogen and progesterone receptors in primary breast cancer. Correlation of histopathology and prognostic factors

OBJECTIVE

The authors investigated correlations of estrogen-receptor and progesterone-receptor with conventional risk factors as well as histopathology in patients with primary breast cancer.

SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA

Immunohistochemically determined hormone receptors have gained importance as prognosticators in primary breast cancer, but their definitive role has not yet been evaluated.

METHODS

Tumor samples from 299 patients were examined for estrogen and progesterone receptors by biochemical and immunohistochemical assay. Correlations with established risk factors (tumor size, lymph node status, menopausal status, grading including subfactors) and histopathology were analyzed.

RESULTS

The estrogen receptor, determined by immunohistochemical method revealed positivity in 80.6% of patients; biochemical measurement yielded 76.2% positive results. The progesterone receptor measured by immunohistochemistry yielded 61.3% positivity versus 55.8% detected by biochemical analysis. Invasive lobular, tubular, and ductal invasive carcinoma with prominent stroma content ("scirrhous carcinoma") rather than ductal invasive carcinoma was more frequently estrogen-receptor positive with immunohistochemistry than with biochemical assay. For progesterone receptor, the same pattern of positivity was seen with immunohistochemical assay. With progesterone receptor determined biochemically, "scirrhous" and lobular carcinoma showed positive results in a lower proportion than invasive ductal and tubular carcinoma. Significant correlations were observed between the estrogen-receptor status, the histologic grade of malignancy, nuclear polymorphism, and the rate of mitosis with both methods (p < 0.001 respectively). Different correlations were found between tumor size, menopausal status and estrogen receptor status with both assays respectively. For the progesterone receptor status, immunohistochemistry yielded significant correlations with the histologic grade of malignancy, nuclear polymorphism, rate of mitosis (p < 0.001 respectively) as well as growth pattern (p < 0.01), while biochemical analysis revealed a correlation with nuclear polymorphism (p < 0.05). The correlation analysis of both components of the immunoreactive score revealed a more significant impact of percentage of positive cells than of staining intensity.

CONCLUSIONS

Immunohistochemistry detected a closer correlation between prognostic factors and receptor data than biochemical analysis.

Psychological response to cancer and survival

The hypothesis is advanced that the psychological stance which patients adopt in response to cancer can, in some cases, influence the course of their disease. This hypothesis is examined in the light of the author's 15-year follow-up study of women with early breast cancer and of other pertinent studies. The available evidence supports the hypothesis in respect of certain early-stage non-metastatic cancers.

Immunocytochemical estrogen and progestin receptor assays in breast cancer with monoclonal antibodies. Histopathologic, demographic, and biochemical correlations and relationship to endocrine response and survival

Breast cancer specimens from 600 women were assayed for estrogen receptors (ER) using an immunocytochemical assay (ICA) employing the monoclonal antiestrophilin antibody H222 Sp gamma. Results showed significant correlation with biochemical ER determinations as well as with tumor grade and menopausal status. In 449 cases, results of progesterone receptor assay by ICA using the monoclonal anti-PgR antibody KD 68, also correlated significantly with biochemical PgR measurements. The ERICA/PgRICA positivity was significantly more frequent in postmenopausal white women. Colloid carcinomas were most likely to be ERICA positive and PgRICA positive whereas medullary carcinomas were most often negative. In 47 patients with advanced mammary carcinoma, results of ERICA and PgRICA were more closely related to endocrine response than those of ER and PgR by dextran-coated charcoal assay (DCC). In 339 women with Stage I or Stage II breast cancer, ERICA was significantly associated with disease-free survival. Analysis by Cox's proportional hazard model, however, showed PgRICA to be the best predictor of survival and disease-free survival in 197 women at the same stages of disease. These data indicate that ICA is more predictive of prognosis than biochemical ER and PgR. The ease of ICA performance coupled with these results indicate that the method is an acceptable substitute for DCC in analyzing breast cancers for ER/PgR.

Estrogen and progesterone receptor analyses in more than 4,000 human breast cancer samples. A study with special reference to age at diagnosis and stability of analyses. Southern Swedish Breast Cancer Study Group

Estrogen (ER) and progesterone receptors (PgR) were measured in the same laboratory in more than 4,000 breast cancer biopsy samples obtained from 15 different hospitals during ten years. ER was measured with isoelectric focusing and PgR with the dextran-coated charcoal method and Scatchard analysis. The distribution pattern for both ER and PgR was during this time period and for the different hospitals rather similar indicating a good stability of the analytical methods. ER concentration was positively correlated with patient age, with a higher percentage of positive samples and higher concentrations in patients greater than or equal to 50 years of age compared with patients less than 50 years. PgR concentration increased with age for patients under 50 years, but a considerable reduction of PgR concentration and of the proportion of positive samples was seen in patients between 50 and 59 years of age. Above this age the PgR concentration again increased with increasing age. The PgR/ER ratio and the proportion of ER- PgR+ samples were higher in patients under 50 years compared to older patients. ER and PgR values decreased during tamoxifen treatment, during pregnancy and after preoperative radiotherapy. Wet weight, DNA and protein were compared as reference parameters for the expression of ER and PgR concentrations. Strong correlations were obtained suggesting that similar information can be obtained with either of these reference parameters.

Steroid hormone receptors and prognosis in breast cancer

The importance of steroid receptors for the prognosis of mammary carcinoma has been evaluated by investigating the course of disease in 163 patients for a median follow up time of 66 months after mastectomy. Multivariate analysis including estrogen receptor (ER), progesterone receptor (PgR), the presence of 8S and 4S ER together or 4S ER only, and the lymph node status revealed only the latter to have significant (p less than 0.001) predictive potency. Lymph node positive (N-pos) patients had a 3.3 (1.7-6.2) fold risk of death and 2.8 (1.7-4.7) fold risk of recurrence relative to node negative (N-neg) patients. When we compared overall survival (OAS) and disease-free survival (DFS) in the various receptor-positive groups with the groups that displayed neither ER nor PgR, significant differences in prognosis were only seen in N-neg patients. PgR did not turn out to be a better prognostic factor than ER, nor was the 8S ER a sign of increased OAS and DFS compared to total ER. However, the number of patients in this group was too small to allow a definite statement.

Prognostic significance of estrogen and progesterone receptors in stage II breast cancer

Estrogen (ER) and progesterone receptors (PgR) were evaluated in samples from primary tumors in 539 patients with stage II breast cancer participating in a randomized multicenter controlled clinical trial on adjuvant therapy. At the cut-off points of 10 fmol ER/mg protein and 30 fmol PgR/mg protein, no significant difference in recurrence-free survival (RFS) existed between premenopausal patients with receptor-positive and negative tumors, respectively. After recurrence, premenopausal patients with receptor-positive tumors had a significant longer survival than patients with receptor-negative tumors. In postmenopausal patients not treated with adjuvant tamoxifen, no correlations between RFS and receptor status were found. Patients with ER+ tumors survived longer than patients with ER-tumors. In postmenopausal patients treated with adjuvant tamoxifen, highly significant differences in RFS and in survival were observed when receptor-positive patients were compared with receptor-negative patients. No differences in survival after recurrence were registered among these patients.

Breast cancer prognosis in three different racial groups in relation to steroid hormone receptor status

Follow-up studies on 466 patients over a 5-year period showed Whites to have an overall significantly longer disease-free interval and survival than Blacks and Asians. No racial differences in prognosis were seen in patients with Stage II disease (p greater than 0.2) but in Stage III, White patients had significantly longer disease-free periods than Blacks or Asians; the same was not true of survival. Whites had a 67% incidence of cytoplasmic estrogen receptor (CER) positive tumors compared with only 49% in Blacks and 41% in Asians. When tumors were assayed for CER, nuclear estrogen receptor (NER), and cytoplasmic progesterone receptor (CPR), there were no racial differences in the proportions of tumors containing all 3 receptors, but significant variations were found in neoplasms with no receptors and in those with apparently defective receptors. In White patients receptor status had no influence on prognosis (p greater than 0.3). Black patients whose tumors contained both CER and NER had a significantly better time to recurrence than those whose tumors lacked these receptors, while in Asian women the presence of CER alone, or CER together with NER, or CER, NER, and CPR, was indicative of a significantly longer disease-free period.

Histochemical estrogen binding. An independent predictor of recurrence and survival in stage II breast cancer

Cox's proportional hazards regression model was used to analyze the prognostic significance of multiple variables affecting recurrence and survival in patients with Stage II breast cancer. Among the variables were biochemical estrogen (ER) and progesterone receptor (PgR) values and results of a histochemical estrogen-binding assay using a fluoresceinated bovine serum albumin-estradiol conjugate where carrier and label were bound at position 17. In 190 cases ER and PgR were not found to be significantly associated with either disease recurrence or patient survival. On the other hand, patients with tumors that were demonstrably "rich" in estradiol ligand conjugate binding by histochemistry experienced both a longer disease-free interval (P less than 0.03) and survival (P less than 0.02) than did patients whose tumors were "poor" in conjugate binding or showed a heterogeneous population of positively and negatively stained cells. A patient with a tumor rich in estrogen binding was five times more likely to survive than a patient with a neoplasm that was poor in estrogen binding by histochemistry. These results indicate that the histochemical technique used provides new and independent parameters for determination of prognosis in Stage II breast cancer.

A proposed classification of breast cancer based on kinetic information: derived from a comparison of risk factors in 168 primary operable breast cancers

Flow cytometric DNA analysis was performed on 168 consecutive primary operable breast cancers and the results correlated with thymidine labeling, estrogen receptor (ER) and progesterone receptor values, and various histologic parameters. Seventy-five cancers (45.0%) were diploid and 93 (55.0%) aneuploid. In 83.9% of aneuploid cancers, the DNA index fell between 1.1 and 2.0. Thirteen cancers were hypertetraploid and three hypodiploid. The percent of S-phase cancers (SpF) varied from 1.1% to 24.4%, with a mean of 8.0% and a median of 7.1%. The mean SpF of diploid cancers was 5.2%; of aneuploid cancers, 10.3%. There was no significant correlation between SpF or ploidy and tumor size or axillary lymph node status. The thymidine labeling index (TLI) varied from 0.2 to 23.1, with a mean of 7.5 and a median of 6.1. There was good correlation between TLI and SpF (r = 0.892, P = 0.0001). ER-negative tumors had a significantly higher mean SpF (10.3%) than did ER-positive tumors (6.7%), but there was no significant correlation between ploidy and receptor positivity or negativity. There was a good correlation between invasive tumor necrosis, poor cytologic differentiation, aneuploidy, and above-median SpF. Only a fair correlation was observed between mitotic rate and SpF. A classification of invasive breast cancers based on ploidy and SpF is proposed.

A multifactorial analysis of steroid hormone receptors in stages I and II breast cancer

It has been shown that the level of estrogen receptors (ER), and to some extent progesterone receptors (PR), correlate to a high degree to the response to endocrine therapy in advanced breast cancer patients. To evaluate the prognostic value of ER/PR in early breast cancer, 80 patients with stages I and II were studied. They all underwent modified radical mastectomy. Patients with stage I disease (negative LN) received no further treatment, while those with stage II received standard adjuvant chemotherapy. All the patients were followed for 4 years. The ER and PR were measured in each primary tumor by the glycerol density gradient method. Values of 10 fmole/mgm protein or greater were considered positive (+) and less than 10 fmole/mgm were considered negative (-). The results revealed: (1) Fifty-two patients (65%) had ER+, of which 44 (85%) were also PR+; 28 patients had ER-, of which 24 were also PR- (p less than 0.0001). (2) ER/PR correlated with age as 71% of the patients over age 50 had ER+/PR+, compared to 33% of those under age 50 (p less than 0.05). (3) Postmenopausal patients had a higher incidence of ER+/PR+. (4) Primary tumors less than 2 cm in size had higher ER+; 71% in those with stage I and 80% in stage II. (5) Fifty-eight per cent (38) of patients with ductal carcinoma had ER+/PR+, compared to 67% (4) with lobular carcinoma. (6) The disease-free survival of patients with ER+ tumors was significantly longer than those with ER- tumors (p less than 0.005) both in positive and negative LN patients. The same was true for PR+ compared to PR- (p less than 0.005), but only in those with stage II disease. The overall survival rates were similarly significant in favor of ER+ and PR+ patients (p less than 0.025), but only in stage II disease. It seems that the status of steroid hormone receptors has a major prognostic factor second only to the LN status.

The effect of oestrogen and progesterone receptors on recurrence and survival in patients with carcinoma of the breast

Recurrence and survival rates were studied in 175 women with breast cancer who, until the development of recurrent disease, received no treatment other than a modified radical (Patey) mastectomy, and in whom the oestrogen (REc) and progesterone (RPc) receptor content of the primary tumour was measured. At the time of first relapse most patients received endocrine therapy. At a minimum follow-up of 58 months post menopausal patients who possessed REc had an increased relapse-free survival (RFS) (P = 0.02). When examined by node status patients with 1-3 axillary nodes containing tumour also had an improvement in RFS (P = 0.02). There was no benefit for node-negative or premenopausal patients. In 163 patients in whom RPc was measured, RFS was unaffected by the possession of this receptor regardless of the degree of node involvement or menopausal status. Patients with REc had a significantly longer survival following mastectomy than patients without it (P = 0.006). This was most marked in post-menopausal (P = 0.003) and node-positive (P = 0.03) patients. Survival following mastectomy was also increased in patients possessing RPc (P = 0.04) and again was most marked for post-menopausal patients (P = 0.01), although no difference could be identified within node subgroups. There were significant differences in the post-relapse survival of REc and RPc positive and negative patients (REc P = 0.03, RPc P = 0.001). Patients with both receptors survived approximately 37 months longer than their receptor-negative counterparts. This study failed to confirm that the measurement of REc and RPc can reliably predict early relapse in breast cancer. The greater overall survival of receptor-positive patients is mainly due to an increase in survival following relapse. This may reflect the response of receptor-positive tumours to endocrine therapy given for recurrent disease.

Prognostic significance of estrogen receptor status in breast cancer in relation to tumor stage, axillary node metastasis, and histopathologic grading

The value of estrogen receptor (ER) measurements for predicting recurrence and survival rates in primary breast cancer was examined in 121 women who were followed from 5 to 12 years after mastectomy with a median follow-up of 64 months. The prognostic significance of the ER status was evaluated independently and in association with tumor stage, axillary node metastasis, and histopathologic grade. The independent evaluation demonstrated no statistically significant difference in prognosis between women with ER-negative and ER-positive cancers, although the latter group tended to have a longer time to recurrence and longer survival. Multivariate analysis of the data by Cox's proportional hazard regression techniques revealed a synergistic effect of ER status on the risk associated with axillary node metastasis. Patients with nodal metastasis were at 2.8 times the risk of recurrence compared to patients without metastasis. For women with nodal metastasis whose primary cancer was ER-negative, this risk increased to 4.6 times compared to women without metastasis and ER-positive tumors (P = 0.0003). The risk of cancer-related death was 5.6 times more likely for poorly differentiated tumors than for highly differentiated tumors. Patients with poorly differentiated ER-negative tumors were at an even higher risk (7.0) of dying than women with highly differentiated ER-positive carcinomas (P = 0.009). In conjunction with tumor stage, axillary node metastasis and histopathologic grade ER determination is useful for identifying subpopulations at increased risk of tumor recurrence or mortality.

Estrogen receptors and long-term prognosis in breast cancer

The long-term prognosis in 233 primary breast cancer patients, most of whom had received ovarian irradiation, has been related to the estrogen-receptor status of the primary tumors. The median observation time was 9 years. The receptor status did influence disease-free interval and survival only in patients having metastases in axillary nodes. Thus, in the postmenopausal patients with axillary metastases, the disease-free interval and survival time were longer in receptor-positive than in receptor-negative patients during the first few years of observation. However, this difference disappeared in the course of the subsequent years. In the premenopausal women with axillary metastases the receptor status did not influence the short-term prognosis, and, unexpectedly, seemed to affect adversely the long-term prognosis. It is concluded that the long-term prognosis is no better in breast cancer patients having estrogen receptors in their primary tumors than in those with receptor-negative tumors.

Practical breast carcinoma cell kinetics: review and update

The S-phase fraction (SP) measured by flow cytometry of DNA and the thymidine labeling index (TLI) measured autoradiographically indicate the proportion of carcinoma cells currently synthesizing DNA and reflect the rate of proliferation. The TLI and SPF are lognormally distributed. The median TLI performed to maximize precursor uptake is near 5% (5 labeled carcinoma cells per 100) the mean near 7%, and the range from less than 1% to near 40%. Corresponding values for the SPF measured by DNA flow cytometry are slightly higher when appropriate measures are taken to reduce background debris counts and other artefacts. Residual elevation of SPF above TLI may result from S-phase arrested cells. Flow cytometric histograms show that clearly aneuploid cell lines exist in 50-80% of primary breast carcinomas. Aneuploid breast carcinomas have higher mean TLI than diploid breast carcinomas, and therefore proliferate more rapidly. They also more frequently lack estrogen receptor (ER). Carcinomas with minimal nuclear anaplasia, particularly those of tubular, mucinous, infiltrating lobular and adenocystic types have low TLI and SPF, whereas carcinomas with highly anaplastic nuclei, including medullary carcinomas, have high TLI and SPF. TLI and SPF correlate inversely with ER and PgR content, have no relationship to axillary lymph nodal status, and have a weak positive correlation with tumor size and a weak negative correlation with age. High TLI predicts a high risk of early relapse after primary therapy for both node-negative and node-positive carcinomas. Carcinomas that produce brain metastases have particularly high TLI. Current evidence suggests that high SPF and aneuploidy may prove to have prognostic significance like TLI.

Multimodality therapy of stage III adenocarcinoma of the breast

The results of a pilot multimodality program (surgery + radiotherapy + chemotherapy) are reported in 34 women with advanced stage III and IV adenocarcinoma of the breast. The median relapse-free survival for all patients was 24 months, with 74% of the premenopausal patients and 37% of the postmenopausal alive at five years (P = 0.18). The relapse rate was significantly lower in premenopausal patients when compared to the postmenopausal subgroup. Estrogen receptor status was not predictive for relapse or survival.