Neuroblastoma screening: the Canadian experience

Newborn screening in North America

Newborn screening in North America dates to the early work of Bob Guthrie in the USA. Screening programmes in both the USA and Canada began in the early 1960s, with documented programmes in both countries as early as 1962. Throughout the 1960s and 1970s, many of the screening tests that later became part of routine screening around the world were developed in US and Canadian laboratories, including tests for phenylketonuria, other inborn errors of metabolism, congenital hypothyroidism, congenital adrenal hyperplasia, and haemoglobinopathies. An automated punching machine developed in the USA facilitated screening expansion by significantly reducing sample preparation time and effort. US and Canadian programmes were leaders in applying computerized data management to newborn screening in the 1980s. In the 1990s, DNA and tandem mass spectrometry testing protocols were developed in the USA and applied to newborn screening. US programmes have continually expanded over time, while most Canadian programmes have not. With impetus from private laboratories and professional and consumer groups, many US programmes now screen for more than 50 conditions and there is increased expansion activity in Canada. NBS research in the USA is focused on improving system efficiency and translating other genetic testing to NBS, particularly where new technologies and treatment therapies exist. Although national newborn screening policies do not exist in either Canada or the USA, there are intense efforts to provide uniform access to screening nationwide in both countries. New partnerships between health professionals, consumers and politicians are benefiting the overall screening systems in both countries.

Screening for neuroblastoma in France: methodological aspects and preliminary observations

A pilot study of neuroblastoma mass screening was initiated in January 1990 in the Rhône French district. The expected number of births per year is 26,000. The study is designed for a 5-year period with three major goals: 1) measurement of the compliance rate of a voluntary test at 4 months of age; 2) evaluation of the technical value of high-pressure liquid chromatography (HPLC) as a screening method; and 3) detailed biological characterization of all detected tumors. 61,551 children were screened between May 1, 1990 and December 31, 1993. Participation was 69% in 1990, 81.5% in 1991, and over 83% in 1992. HPLC was a satisfactory assay method. The number of clinical examinations required for positive tests as defined in the protocol is 1 per 3,621 tests. The false positive rate is 1 per 3,583 tests. Eight neuroblastomas were discovered by-screening (one stage I, three stage II, one stage III, three stage IVs). All are alive and well but were good prognosis cases according to the main prognostic factors. Five patients were discovered before screening (so called Halo effect): one stage I, one stage III, three stage IVs. One died of disease and four are alive in complete remission after treatment. Two patients were false negative (one stage III with N-myc amplification, one stage IV with bad prognosis features) and three cases of neuroblastoma were missed because of noncompliance with the screening program. This pilot study concludes on the feasibility of a mass screening program in France. The estimated cumulative incidence of neuroblastoma at 3 years is 1 per 4,375 living births and overdiagnosis is probable. All the detected cases were of good prognosis and the false negative ones were poor prognosis cases.

Comparison of the diagnostic and prognostic value of biological markers in neuroblastoma. Proposal for a common methodology of analysis. SENSE group

BACKGROUND

The prognosis of pediatric neuroblastoma depends both on clinical presentation and on certain cellular and molecular characteristics. Screening programs have been initiated in infants of less than one year of age, based on the hypothesis that neuroblastoma progresses from early to late clinical stages through a classical multistep process linked to an accumulation of molecular abnormalities. However, recent analyses suggest that most cases discovered by screening are low stage tumors considered as dysembryogenetic residues devoid from major abnormalities and that high-grade tumors with molecular abnormalities are unrelated diseases.

AIM OF THE REVIEW

To confirm one or the other hypothesis, and eventually identify biological factors possibly responsible for the initiation and progression of the disease, it is of utmost importance that all investigators agree on biological criteria for analysis when neuroblastoma tissue is available in screened and unscreened populations. This paper reviews the biological tools available for prognosis in neuroblastoma, the priority for analysis of biological markers according to both methodological reliability and feasibility, and the conditions of tissue storage for further analysis of these biological markers.

CONCLUSION

The standardized biological evaluation of neuroblastoma will allow to collect sufficient data for multivariate analysis; such analysis is now fundamental if one wants to clearly define the respective impacts of biological abnormalities on neuroblastoma progression.

Neuroblastoma: a 32-year population-based study--implications for screening

This paper describes a retrospective population-based study of neuroblastoma in the West Midlands Health Authority Region--childhood population 1.12 million (OPCS, census 1981)--in which 239 cases were diagnosed between 1st January 1957 and 31st December 1988. The age standardised rate of tumour incidence has remained constant at 7.2 cases per million children per year. The median age at diagnosis was 2 years with 18% of children presenting before the age of 6 months. Fifty children (21%) presented before the age of one year, and for this group of children, the prognosis has improved significantly over the 32-year period (10 year survival increasing from 63% in 1957-67 to 87% in 1978-88), whereas for the 189 (79%) children who presented after one year of age, the prognosis has remained very poor during the study period (10 year survival 1957-67 = 9.5%, 1978-88 = 8.5%). This study supports the need for a prospective study of mass screening at several intervals rather than only at 6 months of age.

The development of a catechol enzyme electrode and its possible use for the diagnosis and monitoring of neural crest tumours

A catechol enzyme electrode is described, in which a Clark-type oxygen electrode is coupled to immobilised polyphenol oxidase in albumin cross linked with glutaraldehyde on a dialysis membrane. Electrode calibration, response time, pH response profile, stability, detection limit and selectivity are evaluated and the feasibility of using the electrode for the measurement of catecholamines in the urine of patients with neural crest tumours is assessed.