Accommodation of insertion mutations on the surface and in the interior of staphylococcal nuclease

A role for indels in the evolution of Cro protein folds

Insertions and deletions in protein sequences, or indels, can disrupt structure and may result in changes in protein folds during evolution or in association with alternative splicing. Pfl 6 and Xfaso 1 are two proteins in the Cro family that share a common ancestor but have different folds. Sequence alignments of the two proteins show two gaps, one at the N terminus, where the sequence of Xfaso 1 is two residues shorter, and one near the center of the sequence, where the sequence of Pfl 6 is five residues shorter. To test the potential importance of indels in Cro protein evolution, we generated hybrid variants of Pfl 6 and Xfaso 1 with indels in one or both regions, chosen according to several plausible sequence alignments. All but one deletion variant completely unfolded both proteins, showing that a longer N-terminal sequence was critical for Pfl 6 folding and a longer central region sequence was critical for Xfaso 1 folding. By contrast, Xfaso 1 tolerated a longer N-terminal sequence with little destabilization, and Pfl 6 tolerated central region insertions, albeit with substantial effects on thermal stability and some perturbation of the surrounding structure. None of the mutations appeared to convert one stable fold into the other. On the basis of this two-protein comparison, short insertion and deletion mutations probably played a role in evolutionary fold change in the Cro family, but were also not the only factors.

Tudor domain proteins in protozoan parasites and characterization of Plasmodium falciparum tudor staphylococcal nuclease

RNA-binding proteins play key roles in post-transcriptional regulation of gene expression. In eukaryotic cells, a multitude of RNA-binding proteins with several RNA-binding domains/motifs have been described. Here, we show the existence of two Tudor domain containing proteins, a survival of motor neuron (SMN)-like protein and a Staphylococcus aureus nuclease homologue referred to as TSN, in Plasmodium and other protozoan parasites. Activity analysis shows that Plasmodium falciparum TSN (PfTSN) possesses nuclease activity and Tudor domain is the RNA-binding domain. A specific inhibitor of micrococcal nucleases, 3',5'-deoxythymidine bisphosphate (pdTp) inhibits the nuclease as well as RNA-binding activities of the protein. PfTSN shows a predominant nuclear localization. Treatment of P. falciparum with pdTp, inhibited in vitro growth of both chloroquine-sensitive and chloroquine-resistant strains of P. falciparum, while a four fold concentration of pdTp did not have any significant effect on the mammalian cell line, Huh-7D12. Altogether, these results suggest that PfTSN is an essential enzyme in the parasite's life cycle.

Structural analysis of cDNAs coding for 4SNc-Tudor domain protein from fish and their expression in yellowtail organs

We cloned complementary DNAs for 4SNc-Tudor protein (SN4TDR) from yellowtail (Seriola quinqueradiata), torafugu (Takifugu rubripes), and zebrafish (Danio rerio). This protein contains 4 staphylococcal nuclease domains at the N terminus followed by a Tudor domain. We also identified the 4SNc-Tudor proteins highly homologous to that in yellowtail from the Takifugu genomic database. According to the smart database, these fish proteins had an overlapping Tudor domain (smart00333) with a complete 5 SNc domain (smart00318). In addition, 2 possible translation start sites were observed at the 5' sequences in all 3 fish species. Northern blot analysis of different yellowtail organs showed that the full SN4TDR messenger RNA was approximately 4000 nucleotides long and that its expression was highest in liver and gallbladder, being about 2 to 5 times higher than in kidney, brain, ovary, and gills, and exceedingly low in spleen, heart, and muscle. A minor 2000-nucleotide transcript observed in kidney, spleen, and gallbladder, was attributable to an alternatively spliced variant of this gene. Total proteins extracted from yellowtail liver were fractionated by heparin affinity column chromatography and separated by sodium dodecylsulfate polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Analyses by SDS-PAGE and liquid chromatography with tandem mass spectroscopy identified the polypeptide encoded by SN4TDR as a single molecule of 102 kDa.

Reconstruction of the Conserved β-Bulge in Mammalian Defensins Using d-Amino Acids

Defensins are cationic antimicrobial mini-proteins that play important roles in the innate immune defense against microbial infection. Six invariant Cys residues in each defensin form three structurally indispensable intramolecular disulfide bridges. The only other residue invariant in all known mammalian defensins is a Gly. Structural studies indicate that the invariant Gly residue is located in an atypical, classic-type beta-bulge with the backbone torsion angles (Phi, Psi) disallowed for L-amino acids but permissible for D-enantiomers. We replaced the invariant Gly17 residue in human neutrophil alpha-defensin 2 (HNP2) by L-Ala or one of the D-amino acids Ala, Glu, Phe, Arg, Thr, Val, or Tyr. Although L-Ala17-HNP2 could not be folded, resulting in massive aggregation, all of the D-amino acid-substituted analogs folded with high efficiency. The high resolution x-ray crystal structures of dimeric D-Ala17-HNP2 were determined in three different crystal forms, showing a well preserved beta-bulge identical to those found in other defensins. The seven D-analogs of HNP2 exhibited highly variable bactericidal activity against Gram-positive and Gram-negative test strains, consistent with the premise that interplay between charge and hydrophobicity dictates how amphiphilic defensins kill. Further, the bactericidal activity of these d-amino acid analogs of HNP2 correlated well with their ability to induce leakage from large unilamellar vesicles, supporting membrane permeabilization as the lethal event in microbial killing by HNP2. Our findings identify a conformational prerequisite in the beta-bulge of defensins essential for correct folding and native structure, thereby explaining the molecular basis of the Gly-Xaa-Cys motif conserved in all mammalian defensins.

Crucial role of three-center hydrogen bonding in a challenging chiral molecular recognition

The enantio-discrimination of beta-chiral primary ammonium ions is achieved by a rational approach that utilizes three-center (bifurcated) hydrogen bonding. The extraction experiments on various selected guests reveal that the bifurcated H-bonding plays a crucial role for the chiral discrimination. The X-ray data obtained for an inclusion complex substantiate such interactions. Using the bifurcated H-bonding, the chiral molecular recognition with our C(3)-symmetric tripodal oxazoline receptors is extended generally toward ammonium ions of alpha-, beta-, and alpha,beta-chiral amines. Simple molecular models, evoking the bifurcated H-bonding, explain the chiral discrimination modes.

Induction of substrate specificity shifts by placement of alanine insertions within the consensus amphipathic region of the Escherichia coli GABA (gamma-aminobutyric acid) transporter encoded by gabP

The Escherichia coli GABA (gamma-aminobutyric acid) permease GabP is a prototypical APC (amine/polyamine/choline) super-family transporter that has a CAR (consensus amphipathic region) containing multiple specificity determinants, ostensibly organized on two helical surfaces, one hydrophobic [SHS (sensitive hydrophobic surface)] and the other hydrophilic [SPS (sensitive polar surface)]. To gauge the functional effects of placing alanine insertions at close intervals across the entire GabP CAR, 64 insertion variants were constructed. Insertions, particularly those in the SHS and the SPS, were highly detrimental to steady-state [(3)H]GABA accumulation. TSR (transport specificity ratio) analysis, employing [(3)H]nipecotic acid and [(14)C]GABA, showed that certain alanine insertions were associated with a specificity shift (i.e. a change in k (cat)/ K (m)). An insertion (INS Ala-269) located N-terminal to the SHS increased specificity for [(3)H]nipecotic acid relative to [(14)C]GABA, whereas an insertion (INS Ala-321) located C-terminal to the SPS had the opposite effect. Overall, the results are consistent with a working hypothesis that the GabP CAR contains extensive functional surfaces that may be manipulated by insertion mutagenesis to alter the specificity ( k (cat)/ K (m)) phenotype. The thermodynamic basis of TSR analysis provides generality, suggesting that amino acid insertions could affect specificity in many other transporters, particularly those such as the E. coli phenylalanine permease PheP [Pi, Chow and Pittard (2002) J. Bacteriol. 184, 5842-5847] that have a functionally significant CAR-like domain.

Long-distance conformational changes in a protein engineered by modulated sequence duplication

There are few, if any, known instances in which a biological signal is transmitted via a large conformational change through the body of a protein. We describe here a mutant of T4 lysozyme that was engineered to permit structural change at a distance. The design uses a tandem sequence repeat that makes it possible to transmit large-scale structural changes from one end of an alpha-helix to the other over a distance of 17-25 A. The method should be of general applicability and may make it possible to introduce a mutation at one site in a protein that will induce large-scale changes in the structure at a spatially remote site.

Contribution of surface salt bridges to protein stability: guidelines for protein engineering

The small globular protein, ubiquitin, contains a pair of oppositely charged residues, K11 and E34, that according to the three-dimensional structure are located on the surface of this protein with a spatial orientation characteristic of a salt bridge. We investigated the strength of this salt bridge and its contribution to the global stability of the ubiquitin molecule. Using the "double mutant cycle" analysis, the strength of the pairwise interactions between K11 and E34 was estimated to be favorable by 3.6kJ/mol. Further, the salt bridge of the reverse orientation, i.e. E11/K34, can be formed and is found to have a strength (3.8kJ/mol) similar to that of the K11/E34 pair. However, the global stability of the K11/E34 variant of ubiquitin is 2.2kJ/mol higher than that of the E11/K34 variant. The difference in the contribution of the opposing salt bridge orientations to the overall stability of the ubiquitin molecule is attributed to the difference in the charge-charge interactions between residues forming the salt bridge and the rest of the ionizable groups in this protein. On the basis of these results, we concluded that surface salt bridges are stabilizing, but their contribution to the overall protein stability is strongly context-dependent, with charge-charge interactions being the largest determinant. Analysis of 16 salt bridges from six different proteins, for which detailed experimental data on energetics have been reported, support the conclusions made from the analysis of the salt bridge in ubiquitin. Implications of these findings for engineering proteins with enhanced thermostability are discussed.

A Tudor protein with multiple SNc domains from pea seedlings: cellular localization, partial characterization, sequence analysis, and phylogenetic relationships

A major high molecular weight protein (HMP) in the cytoskeletal fraction from pea has been purified. A combination of chromatographic techniques and protease fragment analysis also facilitated the isolation of the encoding cDNA, disclosing the sequence of the complete open reading frame. The protein possesses four complete N-terminal Staphylococcal nuclease (SNc) domains, a central Tudor domain and a partial SNc domain at the C-terminus, which may act as a coiled-coil cytoskeleton interaction motif. Cell fractionation studies showed that the protein was abundant in the cytoskeleton fraction in dark-grown pea seedlings, but essentially was absent from the nucleus. Gel filtration column chromatography indicated that the native protein exists as a dimer, while isoelectric focusing suggested that there were at least four HMP isotypes. The protein co-eluted with ribosomes from a heparin affinity column in vitro, consistent with ribosome/polysome interactions in vivo. Significantly, sequence analysis of the C-terminal SNc motif may accurately predict nuclear versus cytoplasmic localization resulting in potentially very different functional roles for this protein family in different organisms. An antibody to HMP from peas was also raised and an HMP with a similar molecular mass was detected in the cytoskeleton fractions and to a lesser extent in the nuclear fraction (250 g pellet) from rice and wheat seedlings.

Thermodynamic consequences of burial of polar and non-polar amino acid residues in the protein interior

Effects of amino acid substitutions at four fully buried sites of the ubiquitin molecule on the thermodynamic parameters (enthalpy, Gibbs energy) of unfolding were evaluated experimentally using differential scanning calorimetry. The same set of substitutions has been incorporated at each of four sites. These substitutions have been designed to perturb packing (van der Waals) interactions, hydration, and/or hydrogen bonding. From the analysis of the thermodynamic parameters for these ubiquitin variants we conclude that: (i) packing of non-polar groups in the protein interior is favorable and is largely defined by a favorable enthalpy of van der Waals interactions. The removal of one methylene group from the protein interior will destabilize a protein by approximately 5 kJ/mol, and will decrease the enthalpy of a protein by 12 kJ/mol. (ii) Burial of polar groups in the non-polar interior of a protein is highly destabilizing, and the degree of destabilization depends on the relative polarity of this group. For example, burial of Thr side-chain in the non-polar interior will be less destabilizing than burial of Asn side-chain. This decrease in stability is defined by a large enthalpy of dehydration of polar groups upon burial. (iii) The destabilizing effect of dehydration of polar groups upon burial can be compensated if these buried polar groups form hydrogen bonding. The enthalpy of this hydrogen bonding will compensate for the unfavorable dehydration energy and as a result the effect will be energetically neutral or even slightly stabilizing.

Role of an alpha-helical bulge in the yeast heat shock transcription factor

The heat shock transcription factor (HSF) is the master transcriptional regulator of the heat shock response. The identity of a majority of the genes controlled by HSF and the circumstances under which HSF becomes induced are known, but the details of the mechanism by which HSF is able to sense and respond to heat remains an enigma. For example, it is unclear whether HSF senses the heat shock directly or requires ancillary interactions from a heat-induced signaling pathway. We present the analysis of a series of mutations in an alpha-helical bulge in the DNA-binding domain of HSF. Deletion of residues in this bulged region increases the overall activity of the protein. Yeast containing the deletion mutant HSF are able to survive growth temperatures that are lethal to yeast containing wild-type HSF, and they are also constitutively thermotolerant. The increase in activity can be measured as an increase in both constitutive and induced transcriptional activity. The mutant proteins bind DNA more tightly than the wild-type protein does, but this is unlikely to account fully for the increase in transcriptional activity as yeast HSF is constitutively bound to its binding site in vivo. The stability of the mutant proteins to thermal denaturation is lower than wild-type, though their native-state structures are still well-folded. Therefore, the mutants may be structurally analogous to the heat-induced state of HSF, and suggest that the DNA-binding domain of HSF may be capable of sensing heat shock directly.

Evolution of a protein fold in vitro

A "switch" mutant of the Arc repressor homodimer was constructed by interchanging the sequence positions of a hydrophobic core residue, leucine 12, and an adjacent surface polar residue, asparagine 11, in each strand of an intersubunit beta sheet. The mutant protein adopts a fold in which each beta strand is replaced by a right-handed helix and side chains in this region undergo significant repacking. The observed structural changes allow the protein to maintain solvent exposure of polar side chains and optimal burial of hydrophobic side chains. These results suggest that new protein folds can evolve from existing folds without drastic or large-scale mutagenesis.

Isolation and physical characterization of random insertions in Staphylococcal nuclease

Using genetic engineering techniques we generated randomly located internal tandem duplications of random size within Staphylococcal nuclease. Those insertions, possessing greater than 0.1% of normal activity, were sequenced and characterized physically. Insertions were found to begin and end in regions possessing secondary structure as well as in regions without secondary structure. All proteins remained folded and monomeric, although one mutant appeared, by both circular dichroism and size exclusion chromatography, to be partially unfolded. The stability of the insertions as assayed by guanidine hydrochloride denaturation ranged from nearly normal to destabilized by almost 4 kcal per mol. The activities of the insertion mutants ranged from 1/30 to 1/2000 of the parental nuclease.

Protein structural plasticity exemplified by insertion and deletion mutants in T4 lysozyme

To further investigate the ways in which proteins respond to changes in the length of the polypeptide chain, a series of 32 insertions and five deletions were made within nine different alpha-helices of T4 lysozyme. In most cases, the inserted amino acid was a single alanine, although in some instances up to four residues, not necessarily alanine, were used. Different insertions destabilized the protein by different amounts, ranging from approximately 1 to 6 kcal/mol. In one case, no protein could be obtained. An "extension" mutant in which the carboxy terminus of the molecule was extended by four alanines increased stability by 0.3 kcal/mol. For the deletions, the loss in stability ranged from approximately 3 to 5 kcal/mol. The structures of six insertion mutants, as well as one deletion mutant and the extension mutant, were determined, three in crystal forms nonisomorphous with wild type. In all cases, including previously described insertion mutants within a single alpha-helix, there appears to be a strong tendency to preserve the helix by translocating residues so that the effects of the insertion are propagated into a bend or loop at one end or the other of the helix. In three mutants, even the hydrophobic core was disrupted so as to permit the preservation of the alpha-helix containing the insertion. Translocation (or "register shift") was also observed for the deletion mutant, in this case a loop at the end of the helix being shortened. In general, when translocation occurs, the reduction in stability is only moderate, averaging 2.5 kcal/mol. Only in the most extreme cases does "bulging" or "looping-out" occur within the body of an alpha-helix, in which case the destabilization is substantial, averaging 4.9 kcal/mol. Looping-out can occur for insertions close to the end of a helix, in which case the destabilization is less severe, averaging 2.6 kcal/mol. Mutant A73-[AAA] as well as mutants R119-[A] and V131-[A], include shifts in the backbone of 3-6 A, extending over 20 residues or more. As a result, residues 114-142, which form a "cap" on the carboxy-terminal domain, undergo substantial reorganizations such that the interface between this "cap" and the rest of the protein is altered substantially. In the case of mutant A73-[AAA], two nearby alpha-helices, which form a bend of approximately 105 degrees in the wild-type structure, reorganize in the mutant structure to form a single, essentially straight helix. These structural responses to mutation demonstrate the plasticity of protein structures and illustrate ways in which their three-dimensional structures might changes during evolution.

The emerging role of insertions and deletions in protein engineering

Most attempts to engineer the properties of proteins have employed single or multiple substitution mutations, which typically produce minor changes in structure. Recent structural and stability studies of insertion and deletion mutants clearly indicate that relatively large structural perturbations can be induced by altering the spacing of residues along the polypeptide backbone, often without major losses in protein stability. Although their effects are difficult to anticipate, insertions and deletions provide important new tools for altering protein structures in directions not achievable with substitutions alone.