Charge state dependent top-down characterisation using electron transfer dissociation

Tandem surface-induced dissociation of protein complexes on an ultrahigh resolution platform

We describe instrumentation for conducting tandem surface-induced dissociation (tSID) of native protein complexes on an ultrahigh resolution Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance (FT-ICR) mass spectrometer. The two stages of SID are accomplished with split lenses replacing the entrance lenses of the quadrupole mass filter (stage 1, referred to herein as SID-Q) and the collision cell (stage 2, Q-SID). After SID-Q, the scattered projectile ions and subcomplexes formed in transit traverse the 20 mm pre-filter prior to the mass-selecting quadrupole, providing preliminary insights into the SID fragmentation kinetics of noncovalent protein complexes. The isolated SID fragments (subcomplexes) are then fragmented by SID in the collision cell entrance lens (Q-SID), generating subcomplexes of subcomplexes. We show that the ultrahigh resolution of the FT-ICR can be used for deconvolving species overlapping in m/z, which are particularly prominent in tandem SID spectra due to the combination of symmetric charge partitioning and narrow product ion charge state distributions. Various protein complex topologies are explored, including homotetramers, homopentamers, a homohexamer, and a heterohexamer.

Simple and Minimally Invasive SID Devices for Native Mass Spectrometry

We describe a set of simple devices for surface-induced dissociation of proteins and protein complexes on three instrument platforms. All of the devices use a novel yet simple split lens geometry that is minimally invasive (requiring a few millimeters along the ion path axis) and is easier to operate than prior generations of devices. The split lens is designed to be small enough to replace the entrance lens of a Bruker FT-ICR collision cell, the dynamic range enhancement (DRE) lens of a Waters Q-IM-TOF, or the exit lens of a transfer multipole of a Thermo Scientific Extended Mass Range (EMR) Orbitrap. Despite the decrease in size and reduction in number of electrodes to 3 (from 10 to 12 in Gen 1 and ∼6 in Gen 2), we show sensitivity improvement in a variety of cases across all platforms while also maintaining SID capabilities across a wide mass and energy range. The coupling of SID, high resolution, and ion mobility is demonstrated for a variety of protein complexes of varying topologies.

Electron transfer dissociation mass spectrometry of acidic phosphorylated peptides cationized with trivalent praseodymium

The lanthanide ion praseodymium, Pr(III), was employed to study metallated ion formation and electron transfer dissociation (ETD) of 27 biological and model highly acidic phosphopeptides. All phosphopeptides investigated form metallated ions by electrospray ionization (ESI) that can be studied by ETD to yield abundant sequence information. The ions formed are [M + Pr - H]²⁺ , [M + Pr]³⁺ , and [M + Pr + H]⁴⁺ . All biological phosphopeptides with a chain length of seven or more residues generate [M + Pr]³⁺ . For biological phosphopeptides, [M + Pr]³⁺ undergoes more backbone cleavage by ETD than [M + Pr - H]²⁺ and, in some cases, full sequence coverage occurs. Acidic model phosphorylated hexa-peptides and octa-peptides, composed of alanine residues and one phosphorylated residue, form exclusively [M + Pr - H]²⁺ by ESI. Limited sequence information is obtained by ETD of [M + Pr - H]²⁺ with only metallated product ions being generated. For two biological phosphopeptides, [M + Pr + H]⁴⁺ is observed and may be due to the presence of at least one residue with a highly basic side chain that facilitates the addition of an extra proton. For the model phosphopeptides, more sequence coverage occurs when the phosphorylated residue is in the middle of the sequence than at either the N- or C-terminus. ETD of the metallated precursor ions formed by ESI generates exclusively metallated and nonmetallated c- and z-ions for the biological phosphopeptides, while metallated c-ions, z-ions, and a few y-ions form for the model phosphopeptides. Most of the product ions contain the phosphorylated residue indicating that the metal ion binds predominantly at the deprotonated phosphate group. The results of this study indicate that ETD is a promising tool for sequencing highly acidic phosphorylated peptides by metal adduction with Pr (III) and, by extension, all nonradioactive lanthanide metal ions.

Influence of the metals and ligands in dinuclear complexes on phosphopeptide sequencing by electron-transfer dissociation tandem mass spectrometry

Phosphorylation is one of the most important protein modifications, and electron-transfer dissociation tandem mass spectrometry (ETD-MS/MS) is a potentially useful method for the sequencing of phosphopeptides, including determination of the phosphorylation site. Notably, ETD-MS/MS typically provides useful information when the precursor contains more than three positive charges. It is not yet used as an analysis method for large-scale phosphopeptide production due to difficulties occurring in the production of acidic phosphopeptides having more than three positive charges. To increase the charge state of phosphopeptides, we used dinuclear metal complexes, which selectively bind to the phosphate group in phosphopeptides with the addition of positive charge(s). Dinuclear copper, zinc, and gallium complexes were tested and it was found that the type of metal present in the complex strongly affected the affinity of the phosphorylated compounds and their ETD fragmentation. The dinuclear copper complex interacted weakly with the phosphate groups and ETD-induced peptide fragmentation was largely suppressed by the presence of Cu²⁺, which worked as an electron trap. The dinuclear gallium complex was strongly bound to a phosphate group. However, the ligand binding to gallium acted as an electron trap and the presence of dinuclear gallium complex in the precursor for ETD-MS/MS hampered the sequencing of the phosphopeptides, as in the case of dinuclear copper complexes. In contrast, dinuclear zinc complexes efficiently bind to phosphopeptides with an increase in the charge state, facilitating phosphopeptide sequencing by ETD-MS/MS. The fragmentation of the ligand and peptide backbone in the dinuclear zinc-phosphopeptide complex were competitively induced by ETD. These processes are influenced by the ligand structure and so the detailed ETD fragmentation pathways were investigated using density functional theory calculations.

The Value of Activated Ion Electron Transfer Dissociation for High-Throughput Top-Down Characterization of Intact Proteins

High-throughput top-down proteomic experiments directly identify proteoforms in complex mixtures, making high quality tandem mass spectra necessary to deeply characterize proteins with many sources of variation. Collision-based dissociation methods offer expedient data acquisition but often fail to extensively fragment proteoforms for thorough analysis. Electron-driven dissociation methods are a popular alternative approach, especially for precursor ions with high charge density. Combining infrared photoactivation concurrent with electron transfer dissociation (ETD) reactions, i.e., activated ion ETD (AI-ETD), can significantly improve ETD characterization of intact proteins, but benefits of AI-ETD have yet to be quantified in high-throughput top-down proteomics. Here, we report the first application of AI-ETD to LC-MS/MS characterization of intact proteins (<20 kDa), highlighting improved proteoform identification the method offers over higher energy-collisional dissociation (HCD), standard ETD, and ETD followed by supplemental HCD activation (EThcD). We identified 935 proteoforms from 295 proteins from human colorectal cancer cell line HCT116 using AI-ETD compared to 1014 proteoforms, 915 proteoforms, and 871 proteoforms with HCD, ETD, and EThcD, respectively. Importantly, AI-ETD outperformed each of the three other methods in MS/MS success rates and spectral quality metrics (e.g., sequence coverage achieved and proteoform characterization scores). In all, this four-method analysis offers the most extensive comparisons to date and demonstrates that AI-ETD both increases identifications over other ETD methods and improves proteoform characterization via higher sequence coverage, positioning it as a premier method for high-throughput top-down proteomics.

High-Confidence Sequencing of Phosphopeptides by Electron Transfer Dissociation Mass Spectrometry Using Dinuclear Zinc(II) Complex

Phosphorylation is the most abundant protein modification, and tandem mass spectrometry (MS²) with electron transfer dissociation (ETD) has proven to be a promising method for phosphoproteomic applications owing to its ability to determine phosphorylation sites on proteins. However, low precursor charge states hinder the ability to obtain useful information through peptide sequencing by ETD, and the presence of acidic phosphate groups contributes to a low charge state of peptide ions. In the present report, we used a dinuclear zinc complex, (Zn₂L)³⁺ (L = alkoxide form of 1,3-bis[bis(pyridin-2-ylmethyl)amino]propan-2-ol) for electrospray ionization (ESI), followed by ETD-MS² analysis. Since (Zn₂L)³⁺ selectively bound to phosphopeptide with addition of a positive charge per phosphate group, the use of (Zn₂L)³⁺ for ESI improved the ionization yield of phosphopeptides in phosphoprotein digest. Additionally, an increase in the charge state of phosphopeptides were observed by addition of (Zn₂L)³⁺, facilitating phosphopeptide sequencing by ETD-MS². Since the binding between (Zn₂L)³⁺ and the phosphate group was retained during the ETD process, a comparison between the ETD mass spectra obtained using two dinuclear zinc complex derivatives containing different zinc isotopes, namely (⁶⁴Zn₂L)³⁺ and (⁶⁸Zn₂L)³⁺, provided information about the number of phosphate groups in each fragment ion, allowing the phosphorylation site to be unambiguously determined. The details of the fragmentation processes of the (Zn₂L)³⁺-phosphopeptide complex were investigated using a density functional theory calculation. As in the case of protonated peptides, ETD induced peptide backbone dissociation in the (Zn₂L)³⁺-phosphopeptide complex proceeded through an aminoketyl radical intermediate.

Top-Down Mass Spectrometry: Proteomics to Proteoforms

This chapter highlights many of the fundamental concepts and technologies in the field of top-down mass spectrometry (TDMS), and provides numerous examples of contributions that TD is making in biology, biophysics, and clinical investigations. TD workflows include variegated steps that may include non-specific or targeted preparative strategies, orthogonal liquid chromatography techniques, analyte ionization, mass analysis, tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) and informatics procedures. This diversity of experimental designs has evolved to manage the large dynamic range of protein expression and diverse physiochemical properties of proteins in proteome investigations, tackle proteoform microheterogeneity, as well as determine structure and composition of gas-phase proteins and protein assemblies.

New supercharging reagents produce highly charged protein ions in native mass spectrometry

The effectiveness of two new supercharging reagents for producing highly charged ions by electrospray ionization (ESI) from aqueous solutions in which proteins have native structures and reactivities were investigated. In aqueous solution, 2-thiophenone and 4-hydroxymethyl-1,3-dioxolan-2-one (HD) at a concentration of 2% by volume can increase the average charge of cytochrome c and myoglobin by up to 163%, resulting in even higher charge states than those that are produced from water/methanol/acid solutions in which these proteins are denatured. The greatest extent of supercharging occurs in pure water, but these supercharging reagents are also highly effective in aqueous solutions containing 200 mM ammonium acetate buffer commonly used in native mass spectrometry (MS). These reagents are less effective supercharging reagents than m-nitrobenzyl alcohol (m-NBA) and propylene carbonate (PC) when ions are formed from water/methanol/acid. The extent to which loss of the heme group from myoglobin occurs is related to the extent of supercharging. Results from guanidine melts of cytochrome c monitored with tryptophan fluorescence show that the supercharging reagents PC, sulfolane and HD are effective chemical denaturants in solution. These results provide additional evidence for the role of protein structural changes in the electrospray droplet as the primary mechanism for supercharging with these reagents in native MS. These results also demonstrate that for at least some proteins, the formation of highly charged ions from native MS is no longer a significant barrier for obtaining structural information using conventional tandem MS methods.

Lysine residues in the N-terminal huntingtin amphipathic α-helix play a key role in peptide aggregation

Huntington's disease is a genetic neurodegenerative disorder caused by an expansion in a polyglutamine domain near the N-terminus of the huntingtin (htt) protein that results in the formation of protein aggregates. Here, htt aggregate structure has been examined using hydrogen-deuterium exchange techniques coupled with tandem mass spectrometry. The focus of the study is on the 17-residue N-terminal flanking region of the peptide that has been shown to alter htt aggregation kinetics and morphology. A top-down sequencing strategy employing electron transfer dissociation is utilized to determine the location of accessible and protected hydrogens. In these experiments, peptides aggregate in a deuterium-rich solvent at neutral pH and are subsequently subjected to deuterium-hydrogen back-exchange followed by rapid quenching, disaggregation, and tandem mass spectrometry analysis. Electrospray ionization of the peptide solution produces the [M + 5H](5+) to [M + 10H](10+) charge states and reveals the presence of multiple peptide sequences differing by single glutamine residues. The [M + 7H](7+) to [M + 9](9+) charge states corresponding to the full peptide are used in the electron transfer dissociation analyses. Evidence for protected residues is observed in the 17-residue N-terminal tract and specifically points to lysine residues as potentially playing a significant role in htt aggregation.

Electron transfer dissociation mass spectrometry of peptides containing free cysteine using group XII metals as a charge carrier

Electron transfer dissociation (ETD) has been used for peptide sequencing. Since ETD preferentially produces the c'/z(•) fragment pair, peptide sequencing is generally performed by interpretation of mass differences between series of consecutive c' and z(•) ions. However, the presence of free cysteine residues in a precursor promotes peptide bond cleavage, hindering interpretation of the ETD spectrum. In the present study, the divalent group XII metals, such as Zn(2+), Cd(2+) and Hg(2+), were used as charge carriers to produce metal-peptide complexes. The thiol group is deprotonated by complexation with the group XII metal. The formation of b and y' ions was successfully suppressed by using the zinc-peptide complex as a precursor, indicating Zn(2+)-aided ETD to be a useful method for sequencing of cysteine-containing peptides. By contrast, ETD of Cd(2+)- and Hg(2+)-peptide complexes mainly led to SH2 loss and radical cation formation, respectively. These processes were mediated by recombination energy between the metal cation and an electron. The presence of monovalent cadmium and neutral mercury in ETD products was confirmed by MS(3) analysis with collision-induced dissociation.

Top-down protein identification of proteasome proteins with nanoLC-FT-ICR-MS employing data-independent fragmentation methods

A comparison of different data-independent fragmentation methods combined with LC coupled to high-resolution FT-ICR-MS/MS is presented for top-down MS of protein mixtures. Proteins composing the 20S and 19S proteasome complexes and their PTMs were identified using a 15 T FT-ICR mass spectrometer. The data-independent fragmentation modes with LC timescales allowed for higher duty-cycle measurements that better suit online LC-FT-ICR-MS. Protein top-down dissociation was effected by funnel-skimmer collisionally activated dissociation (FS-CAD) and CASI (continuous accumulation of selected ions)-CAD. The N-termini for 9 of the 14 20S proteasome proteins were found to be modified, and the α3 protein was found to be phosphorylated; these results are consistent with previous reports. Mass-measurement accuracy with the LC-FT-ICR system for the 20- to 30-kDa 20S proteasome proteins was 1 ppm. The intact mass of the 100-kDa Rpn1 subunit from the 19S proteasome complex regulatory particle was measured with a deviation of 17 ppm. The CASI-CAD technique is a complementary tool for intact-protein fragmentation and is an effective addition to the growing inventory of dissociation methods that are compatible with online protein separation coupled to FT-ICR-MS.

ETD allows for native surface mapping of a 150 kDa noncovalent complex on a commercial Q-TWIMS-TOF instrument

Top-down approaches for the characterization of intact proteins and macromolecular complexes are becoming increasingly popular, since they potentially simplify and speed up the assignment process. Here we demonstrate how, on a commercially available Q-TWIMS-TOF instrument, we performed top-down ETD of the native form of tetrameric alcohol dehydrogenase. We achieved good sequence coverage throughout the first 81 N-terminal amino acids of ADH, with the exception of a loop located on the inside of the protein. This is in agreement with the exposed parts of the natively folded protein according to the crystal structure. Choosing the right precursor charge state and applying supplemental activation were found to be key to obtaining a high ETD fragmentation efficiency. Finally, we briefly discuss opportunities to further increase the performance of ETD based on our results.

Anions in electrothermal supercharging of proteins with electrospray ionization follow a reverse Hofmeister series

The effects of different anions on the extent of electrothermal supercharging of proteins from aqueous ammonium and sodium salt solutions were investigated. Sulfate and hydrogen phosphate are the most effective anions at producing high charge state protein ions from buffered aqueous solution, whereas iodide and perchlorate are ineffective with electrothermal supercharging. The propensity for these anions to produce high charge state protein ions follows the following trend: sulfate > hydrogen phosphate > thiocyanate > bicarbonate > chloride > formate ≈ bromide > acetate > iodide > perchlorate. This trend correlates with the reverse Hofmeister series over a wide range of salt concentrations (1 mM to 2 M) and with several physical properties, including solvent surface tension, anion viscosity B-coefficient, and anion surface/bulk partitioning coefficient, all of which are related to the Hofmeister series. The effectiveness of electrothermal supercharging does not depend on bubble formation, either from thermal degradation of the buffer or from coalescence of dissolved gas. These results provide evidence that the effect of different ions in the formation of high charge state ions by electrothermal supercharging is largely a result of Hofmeister effects on protein stability leading to protein unfolding in the heated ESI droplet.

Electrothermal supercharging in mass spectrometry and tandem mass spectrometry of native proteins

Electrothermal supercharging of protein ions formed by electrospray ionization from buffered aqueous solutions results in significant increases to both the maximum and average charge states compared to native mass spectrometry in which ions are formed from the same solutions but with lower spray potentials. For eight of the nine proteins investigated, the maximum charge states of protonated ions formed from native solutions with electrothermal supercharging is greater than those obtained from conventional denaturing solutions consisting of water/methanol/acid, although the average charging is slightly lower owing to contributions of small populations of more folded low charge-state structures. Under these conditions, electrothermal supercharging is slightly less effective for anions than for cations. Equivalent sequence coverage (80%) is obtained with electron transfer dissociation of the same high charge-state ion of cytochrome c formed by electrothermal supercharging from native solutions and from denaturing solutions. Electrothermal supercharging should be advantageous for combining structural studies of proteins in native environments with mass spectrometers that have limited high m/z capabilities and for significantly improving tandem mass spectrometry performance for protein ions formed from solutions in which the molecules have native structures and activities.