Three-dimensional structure of scaffolding-containing phage p22 procapsids by electron cryo-microscopy

Assembly and Capsid Expansion Mechanism of Bacteriophage P22 Revealed by High-Resolution Cryo-EM Structures

The formation of many double-stranded DNA viruses, such as herpesviruses and bacteriophages, begins with the scaffolding-protein-mediated assembly of the procapsid. Subsequently, the procapsid undergoes extensive structural rearrangement and expansion to become the mature capsid. Bacteriophage P22 is an established model system used to study virus maturation. Here, we report the cryo-electron microscopy structures of procapsid, empty procapsid, empty mature capsid, and mature capsid of phage P22 at resolutions of 2.6 Å, 3.9 Å, 2.8 Å, and 3.0 Å, respectively. The structure of the procapsid allowed us to build an accurate model of the coat protein gp5 and the C-terminal region of the scaffolding protein gp8. In addition, interactions among the gp5 subunits responsible for procapsid assembly and stabilization were identified. Two C-terminal α-helices of gp8 were observed to interact with the coat protein in the procapsid. The amino acid interactions between gp5 and gp8 in the procapsid were consistent with the results of previous biochemical studies involving mutant proteins. Our structures reveal hydrogen bonds and salt bridges between the gp5 subunits in the procapsid and the conformational changes of the gp5 domains involved in the closure of the local sixfold opening and a thinner capsid shell during capsid maturation.

Fabrication of Protein Macromolecular Frameworks (PMFs) and Their Application in Catalytic Materials

The construction of three-dimensional (3D) array materials from nanoscale building blocks has drawn significant interest because of their potential to exhibit collective properties and functions arising from the interactions between individual building blocks. Protein cages such as virus-like particles (VLPs) have distinct advantages as building blocks for higher-order assemblies because they are extremely homogeneous in size and can be engineered with new functionalities by chemical and/or genetic modification. In this chapter, we describe a protocol for constructing a new class of protein-based superlattices, called protein macromolecular frameworks (PMFs). We also describe an exemplary method to evaluate the catalytic activity of enzyme-enclosed PMFs, which exhibit enhanced catalytic activity due to the preferential partitioning of charged substrates into the PMF.

Protein Cages: From Fundamentals to Advanced Applications

Proteins that self-assemble into polyhedral shell-like structures are useful molecular containers both in nature and in the laboratory. Here we review efforts to repurpose diverse protein cages, including viral capsids, ferritins, bacterial microcompartments, and designed capsules, as vaccines, drug delivery vehicles, targeted imaging agents, nanoreactors, templates for controlled materials synthesis, building blocks for higher-order architectures, and more. A deep understanding of the principles underlying the construction, function, and evolution of natural systems has been key to tailoring selective cargo encapsulation and interactions with both biological systems and synthetic materials through protein engineering and directed evolution. The ability to adapt and design increasingly sophisticated capsid structures and functions stands to benefit the fields of catalysis, materials science, and medicine.

Harnessing physicochemical properties of virus capsids for designing enzyme confined nanocompartments

Viruses have drawn significant scientific interest from a wide variety of disciplines beyond virology because of their elegant architectures and delicately balanced activities. A virus-like particle (VLP), a noninfectious protein cage derived from viruses or other cage-forming proteins, has been exploited as a nano-scale platform for bioinspired engineering and synthetic manipulation with a range of applications. Encapsulation of functional proteins, especially enzymes, is an emerging use of VLPs that is promising not only for developing efficient and robust catalytic materials, but also for providing fundamental insights into the effects of enzyme compartmentalization commonly observed in cells. This review highlights recent advances in employing VLPs as a container for confining enzymes. To accomplish larger and more controlled enzyme loading, various different enzyme encapsulation strategies have been developed; many of these strategies are inspired from assembly and genome loading mechanisms of viral capsids. Characterization of VLPs’ physicochemical properties, such as porosity, could lead to rational manipulation and a better understanding of the catalytic behavior of the materials.

Structural transitions during the scaffolding-driven assembly of a viral capsid

Assembly of tailed bacteriophages and herpesviruses starts with formation of procapsids (virion precursors without DNA). Scaffolding proteins (SP) drive assembly by chaperoning the major capsid protein (MCP) to build an icosahedral lattice. Here we report near-atomic resolution cryo-EM structures of the bacteriophage SPP1 procapsid, the intermediate expanded procapsid with partially released SPs, and the mature capsid with DNA. In the intermediate state, SPs are bound only to MCP pentons and to adjacent subunits from hexons. SP departure results in the expanded state associated with unfolding of the MCP N-terminus and straightening of E-loops. The newly formed extensive inter-capsomere bonding appears to compensate for release of SPs that clasp MCP capsomeres together. Subsequent DNA packaging instigates bending of MCP A domain loops outwards, closing the hexons central opening and creating the capsid auxiliary protein binding interface. These findings provide a molecular basis for the sequential structural rearrangements during viral capsid maturation.

Nanoreactor Design Based on Self-Assembling Protein Nanocages

Self-assembling proteins that form diverse architectures are widely used in material science and nanobiotechnology. One class belongs to protein nanocages, which are compartments with nanosized internal spaces. Because of the precise nanoscale structures, proteinaceous compartments are ideal materials for use as general platforms to create distinct microenvironments within confined cellular environments. This spatial organization strategy brings several advantages including the protection of catalyst cargo, faster turnover rates, and avoiding side reactions. Inspired by diverse molecular machines in nature, bioengineers have developed a variety of self-assembling supramolecular protein cages for use as biosynthetic nanoreactors that mimic natural systems. In this mini-review, we summarize current progress and ongoing efforts creating self-assembling protein based nanoreactors and their use in biocatalysis and synthetic biology. We also highlight the prospects for future research on these versatile nanomaterials.

Protein cage assembly across multiple length scales

Within the materials science community, proteins with cage-like architectures are being developed as versatile nanoscale platforms for use in protein nanotechnology. Much effort has been focused on the functionalization of protein cages with biological and non-biological moieties to bring about new properties of not only individual protein cages, but collective bulk-scale assemblies of protein cages. In this review, we report on the current understanding of protein cage assembly, both of the cages themselves from individual subunits, and the assembly of the individual protein cages into higher order structures. We start by discussing the key properties of natural protein cages (for example: size, shape and structure) followed by a review of some of the mechanisms of protein cage assembly and the factors that influence it. We then explore the current approaches for functionalizing protein cages, on the interior or exterior surfaces of the capsids. Lastly, we explore the emerging area of higher order assemblies created from individual protein cages and their potential for new and exciting collective properties.

Geometric Defects and Icosahedral Viruses

We propose that viruses with geometric defects are not necessarily flawed viruses. A geometric defect may be a reactive site. Defects may facilitate assembly, dissociation, or accessibility of cellular proteins to virion components. In single molecule studies of hepadnavirus assembly, defects and overgrowth are common features. Icosahedral alphaviruses and flaviviruses, among others, have capsids with geometric defects. Similarly, immature retroviruses, which are non-icosahedral, have numerous "errors". In many viruses, asymmetric exposure of interior features allows for regulated genome release or supports intracellular trafficking. In these viruses, the defects likely serve a biological function. Commonly used approaches for spherical virus structure determination use symmetry averaging, which obscures defects. We suggest that there are three classes of asymmetry: regular asymmetry as might be found in a tailed phage, irregular asymmetry as found, for example, in defects randomly trapped during assembly, and dynamic asymmetry due to Brownian dynamics of virus capsids. Awareness of their presence and recent advances in electron microscopy will allow unprecedented investigation of capsid irregularities to investigate their biological relevance.

Structure and Assembly of TP901-1 Virion Unveiled by Mutagenesis

Bacteriophages of the Siphoviridae family represent the most abundant viral morphology in the biosphere, yet many molecular aspects of their virion structure, assembly and associated functions remain to be unveiled. In this study, we present a comprehensive mutational and molecular analysis of the temperate Lactococcus lactis-infecting phage TP901-1. Fourteen mutations located within the structural module of TP901-1 were created; twelve mutations were designed to prevent full length translation of putative proteins by non-sense mutations, while two additional mutations caused aberrant protein production. Electron microscopy and Western blot analysis of mutant virion preparations, as well as in vitro assembly of phage mutant combinations, revealed the essential nature of many of the corresponding gene products and provided information on their biological function(s). Based on the information obtained, we propose a functional and assembly model of the TP901-1 Siphoviridae virion.

Highly specific salt bridges govern bacteriophage P22 icosahedral capsid assembly: identification of the site in coat protein responsible for interaction with scaffolding protein

Icosahedral virus assembly requires a series of concerted and highly specific protein-protein interactions to produce a proper capsid. In bacteriophage P22, only coat protein (gp5) and scaffolding protein (gp8) are needed to assemble a procapsid-like particle, both in vivo and in vitro. In scaffolding protein's coat binding domain, residue R293 is required for procapsid assembly, while residue K296 is important but not essential. Here, we investigate the interaction of scaffolding protein with acidic residues in the N-arm of coat protein, since this interaction has been shown to be electrostatic. Through site-directed mutagenesis of genes 5 and 8, we show that changing coat protein N-arm residue 14 from aspartic acid to alanine causes a lethal phenotype. Coat protein residue D14 is shown by cross-linking to interact with scaffolding protein residue R293 and, thus, is intimately involved in proper procapsid assembly. To a lesser extent, coat protein N-arm residue E18 is also implicated in the interaction with scaffolding protein and is involved in capsid size determination, since a cysteine mutation at this site generated petite capsids. The final acidic residue in the N-arm that was tested, E15, is shown to only weakly interact with scaffolding protein's coat binding domain. This work supports growing evidence that surface charge density may be the driving force of virus capsid protein interactions.

IMPORTANCE

Bacteriophage P22 infects Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium and is a model for icosahedral viral capsid assembly. In this system, coat protein interacts with an internal scaffolding protein, triggering the assembly of an intermediate called a procapsid. Previously, we determined that there is a single amino acid in scaffolding protein required for P22 procapsid assembly, although others modulate affinity. Here, we identify partners in coat protein. We show experimentally that relatively weak interactions between coat and scaffolding proteins are capable of driving correctly shaped and sized procapsids and that the lack of these proper protein-protein interfaces leads to aberrant structures. The present work represents an important contribution supporting the hypothesis that virus capsid assembly is governed by seemingly simple interactions. The highly specific nature of the subunit interfaces suggests that these could be good targets for antivirals.

Unraveling the role of the C-terminal helix turn helix of the coat-binding domain of bacteriophage P22 scaffolding protein

Many viruses encode scaffolding and coat proteins that co-assemble to form procapsids, which are transient precursor structures leading to progeny virions. In bacteriophage P22, the association of scaffolding and coat proteins is mediated mainly by ionic interactions. The coat protein-binding domain of scaffolding protein is a helix turn helix structure near the C terminus with a high number of charged surface residues. Residues Arg-293 and Lys-296 are particularly important for coat protein binding. The two helices contact each other through hydrophobic side chains. In this study, substitution of the residues of the interface between the helices, and the residues in the β-turn, by aspartic acid was used examine the importance of the conformation of the domain in coat binding. These replacements strongly affected the ability of the scaffolding protein to interact with coat protein. The severity of the defect in the association of scaffolding protein to coat protein was dependent on location, with substitutions at residues in the turn and helix 2 causing the most significant effects. Substituting aspartic acid for hydrophobic interface residues dramatically perturbs the stability of the structure, but similar substitutions in the turn had much less effect on the integrity of this domain, as determined by circular dichroism. We propose that the binding of scaffolding protein to coat protein is dependent on angle of the β-turn and the orientation of the charged surface on helix 2. Surprisingly, formation of the highly complex procapsid structure depends on a relatively simple interaction.

Structural evolution of the P22-like phages: comparison of Sf6 and P22 procapsid and virion architectures

Coat proteins of tailed, dsDNA phages and in herpesviruses include a conserved core similar to the bacteriophage HK97 subunit. This core is often embellished with other domains such as the telokin Ig-like domain of phage P22. Eighty-six P22-like phages and prophages with sequenced genomes share a similar set of virion assembly genes and, based on comparisons of twelve viral assembly proteins (structural and assembly/packaging chaperones), these phages are classified into three groups (P22-like, Sf6-like, and CUS-3-like). We used cryo-electron microscopy and 3D image reconstruction to determine the structures of Sf6 procapsids and virions (~7Å resolution), and the structure of the entire, asymmetric Sf6 virion (16-Å resolution). The Sf6 coat protein is similar to that of P22 yet it has differences in the telokin domain and in its overall quaternary organization. Thermal stability and agarose gel experiments show that Sf6 virions are slightly less stable than those of P22. Finally, bacterial host outer membrane proteins A and C were identified in lipid vesicles that co-purify with Sf6 particles, but are not components of the capsid.

Principles of virus structural organization

Viruses, the molecular nanomachines infecting hosts ranging from prokaryotes to eukaryotes, come in different sizes, shapes, and symmetries. Questions such as what principles govern their structural organization, what factors guide their assembly, how these viruses integrate multifarious functions into one unique structure have enamored researchers for years. In the last five decades, following Caspar and Klug's elegant conceptualization of how viruses are constructed, high-resolution structural studies using X-ray crystallography and more recently cryo-EM techniques have provided a wealth of information on structures of a variety of viruses. These studies have significantly -furthered our understanding of the principles that underlie structural organization in viruses. Such an understanding has practical impact in providing a rational basis for the design and development of antiviral strategies. In this chapter, we review principles underlying capsid formation in a variety of viruses, emphasizing the recent developments along with some historical perspective.

Decoding bacteriophage P22 assembly: identification of two charged residues in scaffolding protein responsible for coat protein interaction

Proper assembly of viruses must occur through specific interactions between capsid proteins. Many double-stranded DNA viruses and bacteriophages require internal scaffolding proteins to assemble their coat proteins into icosahedral capsids. The 303 amino acid bacteriophage P22 scaffolding protein is mostly helical, and its C-terminal helix-turn-helix (HTH) domain binds to the coat protein during virion assembly, directing the formation of an intermediate structure called the procapsid. The interaction between coat and scaffolding protein HTH domain is electrostatic, but the amino acids that form the protein-protein interface have yet to be described. In the present study, we used alanine scanning mutagenesis of charged surface residues of the C-terminal HTH domain of scaffolding protein. We have determined that P22 scaffolding protein residues R293 and K296 are crucial for binding to coat protein and that the neighboring charges are not essential but do modulate the affinity between the two proteins.

Peering down the barrel of a bacteriophage portal: the genome packaging and release valve in p22

The encapsidated genome in all double-strand DNA bacteriophages is packaged to liquid crystalline density through a unique vertex in the procapsid assembly intermediate, which has a portal protein dodecamer in place of five coat protein subunits. The portal orchestrates DNA packaging and exit, through a series of varying interactions with the scaffolding, terminase, and closure proteins. Here, we report an asymmetric cryoEM reconstruction of the entire P22 virion at 7.8 Å resolution. X-ray crystal structure models of the full-length portal and of the portal lacking 123 residues at the C terminus in complex with gene product 4 (Δ123portal-gp4) obtained by Olia et al. (2011) were fitted into this reconstruction. The interpreted density map revealed that the 150 Å, coiled-coil, barrel portion of the portal entraps the last DNA to be packaged and suggests a mechanism for head-full DNA signaling and transient stabilization of the genome during addition of closure proteins.

Conformational changes in bacteriophage P22 scaffolding protein induced by interaction with coat protein

Many prokaryotic and eukaryotic double-stranded DNA viruses use a scaffolding protein to assemble their capsid. Assembly of the double-stranded DNA bacteriophage P22 procapsids requires the interaction of 415 molecules of coat protein and 60-300 molecules of scaffolding protein. Although the 303-amino-acid scaffolding protein is essential for proper assembly of procapsids, little is known about its structure beyond an NMR structure of the extreme C-terminus, which is known to interact with coat protein. Deletion mutagenesis indicates that other regions of scaffolding protein are involved in interactions with coat protein and other capsid proteins. Single-cysteine and double-cysteine variants of scaffolding protein were generated for use in fluorescence resonance energy transfer and cross-linking experiments designed to probe the conformation of scaffolding protein in solution and within procapsids. We showed that the N-terminus and the C-terminus are proximate in solution, and that the middle of the protein is near the N-terminus but not accessible to the C-terminus. In procapsids, the N-terminus was no longer accessible to the C-terminus, indicating that there is a conformational change in scaffolding protein upon assembly. In addition, our data are consistent with a model where scaffolding protein dimers are positioned parallel with one another with the associated C-termini.

Bacteriophage assembly

Bacteriophages have been a model system to study assembly processes for over half a century. Formation of infectious phage particles involves specific protein-protein and protein-nucleic acid interactions, as well as large conformational changes of assembly precursors. The sequence and molecular mechanisms of phage assembly have been elucidated by a variety of methods. Differences and similarities of assembly processes in several different groups of bacteriophages are discussed in this review. The general principles of phage assembly are applicable to many macromolecular complexes.

Crystallization of the nonameric small terminase subunit of bacteriophage P22

The packaging of viral genomes into preformed empty procapsids is powered by an ATP-dependent genome-translocating motor. This molecular machine is formed by a heterodimer consisting of large terminase (L-terminase) and small terminase (S-terminase) subunits, which is assembled into a complex of unknown stoichiometry, and a dodecameric portal protein. There is considerable confusion in the literature regarding the biologically relevant oligomeric state of terminases, which, like portal proteins, form ring-like structures. The number of subunits in a hollow oligomeric protein defines the internal diameter of the central channel and the ability to fit DNA inside. Thus, knowledge of the exact stoichiometry of terminases is critical to decipher the mechanisms of terminase-dependent DNA translocation. Here, the gene encoding bacteriophage P22 S-terminase in Escherichia coli has been overexpressed and the protein purified under native conditions. In the absence of detergents and/or denaturants that may cause disassembly of the native oligomer and formation of aberrant rings, it was found that P22 S-terminase assembles into a concentration-independent nonamer of ∼168 kDa. Nonameric S-terminase was crystallized in two different crystal forms at neutral pH. Crystal form I belonged to space group P2(1)2(1)2, with unit-cell parameters a=144.2, b=144.2, c=145.3 Å, and diffracted to 3.0 Å resolution. Crystal form II belonged to space group P2(1), with unit-cell parameters a=76.48, b=100.9, c=89.95 Å, β=93.73°, and diffracted to 1.75 Å resolution. Preliminary crystallographic analysis of crystal form II confirms that the S-terminase crystals contain a nonamer in the asymmetric unit and are suitable for high-resolution structure determination.

Cryo-reconstructions of P22 polyheads suggest that phage assembly is nucleated by trimeric interactions among coat proteins

Bacteriophage P22 forms an isometric capsid during normal assembly, yet when the coat protein (CP) is altered at a single site, helical structures (polyheads) also form. The structures of three distinct polyheads obtained from F170L and F170A variants were determined by cryo-reconstruction methods. An understanding of the structures of aberrant assemblies such as polyheads helps to explain how amino acid substitutions affect the CP, and these results can now be put into the context of CP pseudo-atomic models. F170L CP forms two types of polyhead and each has the CP organized as hexons (oligomers of six CPs). These hexons have a skewed structure similar to that in procapsids (precursor capsids formed prior to dsDNA packaging), yet their organization differs completely in polyheads and procapsids. F170A CP forms only one type of polyhead, and though this has hexons organized similarly to hexons in F170L polyheads, the hexons are isometric structures like those found in mature virions. The hexon organization in all three polyheads suggests that nucleation of procapsid assembly occurs via a trimer of CP monomers, and this drives formation of a T = 7, isometric particle. These variants also form procapsids, but they mature quite differently: F170A expands spontaneously at room temperature, whereas F170L requires more energy. The P22 CP structure along with scaffolding protein interactions appear to dictate curvature and geometry in assembled structures and residue 170 significantly influences both assembly and maturation.

Fabrication of ordered nanostructures of sulfide nanocrystal assemblies over self-assembled genetically engineered P22 coat protein

Ordered ZnS and CdS nanocrystal assemblies have been synthesized by a facile bioinspired approach consisting of an initial self-assembly of engineered proteins into spherical biotemplates and a subsequent protein-directed nucleation and growth of ZnS and CdS nanocrystals symmetrically distributed over the self-assembled biotemplates.

'Let the phage do the work': using the phage P22 coat protein structures as a framework to understand its folding and assembly mutants

The amino acid sequence of viral capsid proteins contains information about their folding, structure and self-assembly processes. While some viruses assemble from small preformed oligomers of coat proteins, other viruses such as phage P22 and herpesvirus assemble from monomeric proteins (Fuller and King, 1980; Newcomb et al., 1999). The subunit assembly process is strictly controlled through protein:protein interactions such that icosahedral structures are formed with specific symmetries, rather than aberrant structures. dsDNA viruses commonly assemble by first forming a precursor capsid that serves as a DNA packaging machine (Earnshaw, Hendrix, and King, 1980; Heymann et al., 2003). DNA packaging is accompanied by a conformational transition of the small precursor procapsid into a larger capsid for isometric viruses. Here we highlight the pseudo-atomic structures of phage P22 coat protein and rationalize several decades of data about P22 coat protein folding, assembly and maturation generated from a combination of genetics and biochemistry.

Detection of intermediates and kinetic control during assembly of bacteriophage P22 procapsid

Bacteriophage P22 serves as a model for the assembly and maturation of other icosahedral double-stranded DNA viruses. P22 coat and scaffolding proteins assemble in vitro into an icosahedral procapsid, which then expands during DNA packaging (maturation). Efficient in vitro assembly makes this system suitable for design and production of monodisperse spherical nanoparticles (diameter approximately 50 nm). In this work, we explore the possibility of controlling the outcome of assembly by scaffolding protein engineering. The scaffolding protein exists in monomer-dimer-tetramer equilibrium. We address the role of monomers and dimers in assembly by using three different scaffolding proteins with altered monomer-dimer equilibrium (weak dimer, covalent dimer, monomer). The progress and outcome of assembly was monitored by time-resolved X-ray scattering, which allowed us to distinguish between closed shells and incomplete assembly intermediates. Binding of scaffolding monomer activates the coat protein for assembly. Excess dimeric scaffolding protein resulted in rapid nucleation and kinetic trapping yielding incomplete shells. Addition of monomeric wild-type scaffold with excess coat protein completed these metastable shells. Thus, the monomeric scaffolding protein plays an essential role in the elongation phase by activating the coat and effectively lowering its critical concentration for assembly.

A conformational switch in bacteriophage p22 portal protein primes genome injection

Double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) viruses such as herpesviruses and bacteriophages infect by delivering their genetic material into cells, a task mediated by a DNA channel called "portal protein." We have used electron cryomicroscopy to determine the structure of bacteriophage P22 portal protein in both the procapsid and mature capsid conformations. We find that, just as the viral capsid undergoes major conformational changes during virus maturation, the portal protein switches conformation from a procapsid to a mature phage state upon binding of gp4, the factor that initiates tail assembly. This dramatic conformational change traverses the entire length of the DNA channel, from the outside of the virus to the inner shell, and erects a large dome domain directly above the DNA channel that binds dsDNA inside the capsid. We hypothesize that this conformational change primes dsDNA for injection and directly couples completion of virus morphogenesis to a new cycle of infection.

The physical basis for the head-to-tail rule that excludes most fullerene cages from self-assembly

In the companion article, we proposed that fullerene cages with head-to-tail dihedral angle discrepancies do not self-assemble. Here we show why. If an edge abuts a pentagon at one end and a hexagon at the other, the dihedral angle about the edge increases, producing a dihedral angle discrepancy (DAD) vector. The DADs about all five/six edges of a central pentagonal/hexagonal face are determined by the identities-pentagon or hexagon-of its five/six surrounding faces. Each "Ring"-central face plus specific surrounding faces-may have zero, two, or four edges with DAD. In most Rings, the nonplanarity induced by DADs is shared among surrounding faces. However, in a Ring that has DADs arranged head of one to tail of another, the nonplanarity cannot be shared, so some surrounding faces would be especially nonplanar. Because the head-to-tail exclusion rule is an implicit geometric constraint, the rule may operate either by imposing a kinetic barrier that prevents assembly of certain Rings or by imposing an energy cost that makes those Rings unlikely to last in an equilibrium circumstance. Since Rings with head-to-tail DADs would be unlikely to self-assemble or last, fullerene cages with those Rings would be unlikely to self-assemble.

Polyhead formation in phage P22 pinpoints a region in coat protein required for conformational switching

Eighteen single amino acid substitutions in phage P22 coat protein cause temperature-sensitive folding defects (tsf). Three intragenic global suppressor (su) substitutions (D163G, T166I and F170L), localized to a flexible loop, rescue the folding of several tsf coat proteins. Here we investigate the su substitutions in the absence of the original tsf substitutions. None of the su variant coat proteins displayed protein folding defects. Individual su substitutions had little effect on phage production in vivo; yet double and triple combinations resulted in a cold-sensitive (cs) phenotype, consistent with a defect in assembly. During virus assembly and maturation, conformational switching of capsid subunits is required when chemically identical capsid subunits form an icosahedron. Analysis of double- and triple-su phage-infected cell lysates by negative-stain electron microscopy reveals an increase in aberrant structures at the cs temperature. In vitro assembly of F170L coat protein causes production of polyheads, never seen before in phage P22. Purified procapsids composed of all of the su coat proteins showed defects in expansion, which mimics maturation in vitro. Our results suggest that a previously identified surface-exposed loop in coat protein is critical in conformational switching of subunits during both procapsid assembly and maturation.

GroEL/S substrate specificity based on substrate unfolding propensity

Phage P22 wild-type (WT) coat protein does not require GroEL/S to fold but temperature-sensitive-folding (tsf) coat proteins need the chaperone complex for correct folding. WT coat protein and all variants absolutely require P22 scaffolding protein, an assembly chaperone, to assemble into precursor structures termed procapsids. Previously, we showed that a global suppressor (su) substitution, T1661, which rescues several tsf coat protein variants, functioned by inducing GroEL/S. This led to an increased formation of tsf:T1661 coat protein:GroEL complexes compared with the tsf parents. The increased concentration of complexes resulted in more assembly-competent coat proteins because of a shift in the chaperone-driven kinetic partitioning between aggregation-prone intermediates toward correct folding and assembly. We have now investigated the folding and assembly of coat protein variants that carry a different global su substitution, F170L. By monitoring levels of phage production in the presence of a dysfunctional GroEL we found that tsf:F170L proteins demonstrate a less stringent requirement for GroEL. Tsf:F170L proteins also did not cause induction of the chaperones. Circular dichroism and tryptophan fluorescence indicate that the native state of the tsf: F170L coat proteins is restored to WT-like values. In addition, native acrylamide gel electrophoresis shows a stabilized native state for tsf:F170L coat proteins. The F170L su substitution also increases procapsid production compared with their tsf parents. We propose that the F170L su substitution has a decreased requirement for the chaperones GroEL and GroES as a result of restoring the tsf coat proteins to a WT-like state. Our data also suggest that GroEL/S can be induced by increasing the population of unfolding intermediates.

Determinants of bacteriophage phi29 head morphology

Bacteriophage phi29 requires scaffolding protein to assemble the 450 x 540 A prolate prohead with T = 3 symmetry end caps. In infections with a temperature-sensitive mutant scaffolding protein, capsids assemble predominantly into 370 A diameter isometric particles with T = 3 symmetry that lack a head-tail connector. However, a few larger, 430 A diameter, particles are also assembled. Cryo-electron microscopy shows that these larger particles are icosahedral with T = 4 symmetry. The prolate prohead, as well as the two isometric capsids with T = 3 and T = 4 symmetry, are composed of similar pentamers and differently skewed hexamers. The skewing of the hexamers in the equatorial region of proheads and in the T = 4 isometric particles reflects their different environments. One of the functions of the scaffolding protein, present in the prohead, may be to stabilize skewed hexamers during assembly.

Binding-induced stabilization and assembly of the phage P22 tail accessory factor gp4

To infect and replicate, bacteriophage P22 injects its 43 kbp genome across the cell wall of Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium. The attachment of phage P22 to the host cell as well as the injection of the viral DNA into the host is mediated by the virion's tail complex. This 2.8 MDa molecular machine is formed by five proteins, which include the portal protein gp1, the adhesion tailspike protein gp9, and three tail accessory factors: gp4, gp10, gp26. We have isolated the tail accessory factor gp4 and characterized its structure and binding interactions with portal protein. Interestingly, gp4 exists in solution as a monomer, which displays an exceedingly low structural stability (Tm 34 degrees C). Unfolded gp4 is prone to aggregation within a narrow range of temperatures both in vitro and in Salmonella extracts. In the virion the thermal unfolding of gp4 is prevented by the interaction with the dodecameric portal protein, which stabilizes the structure of gp4 and suppresses unfolded gp4 from irreversibly aggregating in the Salmonella milieu. The structural stabilization of gp4 is accompanied by the concomitant oligomerization of the protein to form a ring of 12 subunits bound to the lower end of the portal ring. The interaction of gp4 with portal protein is complex and likely involves the distinct binding of two non-equivalent sets of six gp4 proteins. Binding of the first set of six gp4 equivalents to dodecameric portal protein yields a gp(1)12:gp(4)6 assembly intermediate, which is stably populated at 30 degrees C and can be resolved by native gel electrophoresis. The final product of the assembly reaction is a bi-dodecameric gp(1)12:gp(4)12 complex, which appears hollow by electron microscopy, suggesting that gp4 does not physically plug the DNA entry/exit channel, but acts as a structural adaptor for the other tail accessory factors: gp10 and gp26.

Cryo-EM asymmetric reconstruction of bacteriophage P22 reveals organization of its DNA packaging and infecting machinery

The mechanisms by which most double-stranded DNA viruses package and release their genomic DNA are not fully understood. Single particle cryo-electron microscopy and asymmetric 3D reconstruction reveal the organization of the complete bacteriophage P22 virion, including the protein channel through which DNA is first packaged and later ejected. This channel is formed by a dodecamer of portal proteins and sealed by a tail hub consisting of two stacked barrels capped by a protein needle. Six trimeric tailspikes attached around this tail hub are kinked, suggesting a functional hinge that may be used to trigger DNA release. Inside the capsid, the portal's central channel is plugged by densities interpreted as pilot/injection proteins. A short rod-like density near these proteins may be the terminal segment of the dsDNA genome. The coaxially packed DNA genome is encapsidated by the icosahedral shell. This complete structure unifies various biochemical, genetic, and crystallographic data of its components from the past several decades.

Crystallogenesis of bacteriophage P22 tail accessory factor gp26 at acidic and neutral pH

Gp26 is one of three phage P22-encoded tail accessory factors essential for stabilization of viral DNA within the mature capsid. In solution, gp26 exists as an extended triple-stranded coiled-coil protein which shares profound structural similarities with class I viral membrane-fusion protein. In the cryo-EM reconstruction of P22 tail extracted from mature virions, gp26 forms an approximately 220 angstroms extended needle structure emanating from the neck of the tail, which is likely to be brought into contact with the cell's outer membrane when the viral DNA-injection process is initiated. To shed light on the potential role of gp26 in cell-wall penetration and DNA injection, gp26 has been crystallized at acidic, neutral and alkaline pH. Crystals of native gp26 grown at pH 4.6 diffract X-rays to 2.0 angstroms resolution and belong to space group P2(1), with a dimer of trimeric gp26 molecules in the asymmetric unit. To study potential pH-induced conformational changes in the gp26 structure, a chimera of gp26 fused to maltose-binding protein (MBP-gp26) was generated. Hexagonal crystals of MBP-gp26 were obtained at neutral and alkaline pH using the high-throughput crystallization robot at the Hauptman-Woodward Medical Research Institute, Buffalo, NY, USA. These crystals diffract X-rays to beyond 2.0 angstroms resolution. Structural analysis of gp26 crystallized at acidic, neutral and alkaline pH is in progress.

Electrostatic interactions govern both nucleation and elongation during phage P22 procapsid assembly

Icosahedral capsid assembly is an example of a reaction controlled solely by the interactions of the proteins involved. Bacteriophage P22 procapsids can be assembled in vitro by mixing coat and scaffolding proteins in a nucleation-limited reaction, where scaffolding protein directs the proper assembly of coat protein. Here, we investigated the effect of the buffer composition on the interactions necessary for capsid assembly. Different concentrations of various salts, chosen to follow the electroselectivity series for anions, were added to the assembly reaction. The concentration and type of salt was found to be crucial for proper nucleation of procapsids. Nucleation in low salt concentrations readily occurred but led to bowl-like partial procapsids, as visualized by negative stain electron microscopy. The edge of the partial capsids remained assembly-competent since coat protein addition triggered procapsid completion. The addition of salt to the partial capsids also caused procapsid completion. In addition, each salt affected both assembly rates and the extent of procapsid formation. We hypothesize that low salt conditions increase the coat protein:scaffolding protein affinity, causing excessive nuclei to form, which decreases coat protein levels leading to incomplete assembly.

Bacteriophage P22 Tail Accessory Factor GP26 Is a Long Triple-stranded Coiled-coil

P22 is a well characterized tailed bacteriophage that infects Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium. It is characterized by a "short" tail, which is formed by five proteins: the dodecameric portal protein (gp1), three tail accessory factors (gp4, gp10, gp26), and six trimeric copies of the tail-spike protein (gp9). We have isolated the gene encoding tail accessory factor gp26, which is responsible for stabilization of viral DNA within the mature phage, and using a variety of biochemical and biophysical techniques we show that gp26 is very likely a triple stranded coiled-coil protein. Electron microscopic examination of purified gp26 indicates that the protein adopts a rod-like structure approximately 210 angstroms in length. This trimeric rod displays an exceedingly high intrinsic thermostability (T(m) approximately 85 degrees C), which suggests a potentially important structural role within the phage tail apparatus. We propose that gp26 forms the thin needle-like fiber emanating from the base of the P22 neck that has been observed by electron microscopy of negatively stained P22 virions. By analogy with viral trimeric coiled-coil class I membrane fusion proteins, gp26 may represent the membrane-penetrating device used by the phage to pierce the host outer membrane.

A concerted mechanism for the suppression of a folding defect through interactions with chaperones

Specific amino acid substitutions confer a temperature-sensitive-folding (tsf) phenotype to bacteriophage P22 coat protein. Additional amino acid substitutions, called suppressor substitutions (su), relieve the tsf phenotype. These su substitutions are proposed to increase the efficiency of procapsid assembly, favoring correct folding over improper aggregation. Our recent studies indicate that the molecular chaperones GroEL/ES are more effectively recruited in vivo for the folding of tsf:su coat proteins than their tsf parents. Here, the tsf:su coat proteins are studied with in vitro equilibrium and kinetic techniques to establish a molecular basis for suppression. The tsf:su coat proteins were monomeric, as determined by velocity sedimentation analytical ultracentrifugation. The stability of the tsf:su coat proteins was ascertained by equilibrium urea titrations, which were best described by a three-state folding model, N <--> I <--> U. The tsf:su coat proteins either had stabilized native or intermediate states as compared with their tsf coat protein parents. The kinetics of the I <--> U transition showed a decrease in the rate of unfolding and a small increase in the rate of refolding, thereby increasing the population of the intermediate state. The increased intermediate population may be the reason the tsf:su coat proteins are aggregation-prone and likely enhances GroEL-ES interactions. The N --> I unfolding rate was slower for the tsf:su proteins than their tsf coat parents, resulting in an increase in the native state population, which may allow more competent interactions with scaffolding protein, an assembly chaperone. Thus, the suppressor substitution likely improves folding in vivo through increased efficiency of coat protein-chaperone interactions.

Folding of phage P22 coat protein monomers: kinetic and thermodynamic properties

To assemble into a virus with icosahedral symmetry, capsid proteins must be able to attain multiple conformations. Whether this conformational diversity is achieved during folding of the subunit, or subsequently during assembly, is not clear. Phage P22 coat protein offers an ideal model to investigate the folding of a monomeric capsid subunit since its folding is independent of assembly. Our early studies indicated that P22 coat protein monomers could be folded into an assembly-competent state in vitro, with evidence of a kinetic intermediate. Using urea denaturation, coat protein monomers are shown to be marginally stable. The reversible folding of coat protein follows a three-state model, N if I if U, with an intermediate exhibiting most of the tryptophan fluorescence of the folded state, but little secondary structure. Folding and unfolding kinetics monitored by circular dichroism, tryptophan fluorescence, and bisANS fluorescence indicate that several kinetic intermediates are populated sequentially through parallel channels en route to the native state. Additionally, two native states were identified, suggesting that the several conformers required to assemble an icosahedral capsid may be found in solution before assembly ensues.

Studying Large Viruses

In this article we have attempted to describe some structural aspects of large viruses. Although this may seem a straightforward task, it is complicated by the fact that large viruses do not represent a distinctive class of organisms and any grouping under this heading will include a range of unrelated viruses with different structures, replication strategies, and host types. To simplify matters we limited our definition to dsDNA viruses with genomes of 100 kbp or larger. However, even this restricted grouping includes viruses with diverse and seemingly unrelated structures. Furthermore, few if any structural features are exclusive to large viruses and most of what appears distinctive about their structure or assembly can also be found in smaller, and usually better characterized, viruses. Therefore we have not attempted to provide a comprehensive catalog of the properties of large viruses but have tried to illustrate particular structural points with examples from a few of the better known forms, notably herpes simplex virus (HSV) and phage T4. The two techniques used to provide rigorous analyses of virus structures are X-ray crystallography and electron cryomicroscopy with computer-assisted reconstruction. To date, X-ray crystallography has been successful only with smaller viruses, and what is known about the structures of these large viruses has come primarily from electron cryomicroscopy. However, with the notable exception of the HSV capsid, such studies have been limited in extent and of relatively low resolution, and the information obtained has been confined largely to describing the spatial distributions and relationships between the subunits. Nevertheless, these studies have given us our clearest insights into the biology of these complex particles and increases in resolution promise to extend these insights by bridging the gap between gross and atomic structures, as exemplified by the identification and mapping of secondary structural elements in the HSV capsid.

Molecular Mechanisms In Bacteriophage T7 Procapsid Assembly, Maturation, And Dna Containment

Bacteriophage T7 is a double-stranded DNA bacteriophage that has attracted particular interest in studies of gene expression and regulation and of morphogenesis, as well as in biotechnological applications of expression vectors and phage display. We report here studies of T7 capsid assembly by cryoelectron microscopy and image analysis. T7 follows the canonical pathway of first forming a procapsid that converts into the mature capsid, but with some novel variations. The procapsid is a round particle with an icosahedral triangulation number of 7 levo, composed of regular pentamers and elongated hexamers. A singular vertex in the procapsid is occupied by the connector/portal protein, which forms 12-fold and 13-fold rings when overexpressed, of which the 12-mer appears to be the assembly-competent form. This vertex is the site of two symmetry mismatches: between the connector and the surrounding five gp 10 hexamers; and between the connector and the 8-fold cylindrical core mounted on its inner surface. The scaffolding protein, gp9, which is required for assembly, forms nubbin-like protrusions underlying the hexamers but not the pentamers, with no contacts between neighboring gp9 monomers. We propose that gp9 facilitates assembly by binding to gp10 hexamers, locking them into a morphogenically correct conformation. gp9 is expelled as the procapsid matures into the larger, thinner walled, polyhedral capsid. Several lines of evidence implicate the connector vertex as the site at which the maturation transformation is initiated: in vivo, maturation appears to be triggered by DNA packaging whereby the signal may involve interaction of the connector with DNA. In the mature T7 head, the DNA is organized as a tightly wound coaxial spool, with the DNA coiled around the core in at least four and perhaps as many as six concentric shells.

A P22 scaffold protein mutation increases the robustness of head assembly in the presence of excess portal protein

Bacteriophage with linear, double-stranded DNA genomes package DNA into preassembled protein shells called procapsids. Located at one vertex in the procapsid is a portal complex composed of a ring of 12 subunits of portal protein. The portal complex serves as a docking site for the DNA packaging enzymes, a conduit for the passage of DNA, and a binding site for the phage tail. An excess of the P22 portal protein alters the assembly pathway of the procapsid, giving rise to defective procapsid-like particles and aberrant heads. In the present study, we report the isolation of escape mutant phage that are able to replicate more efficiently than wild-type phage in the presence of excess portal protein. The escape mutations all mapped to the same phage genome segment spanning the portal, scaffold, coat, and open reading frame 69 genes. The mutations present in five of the escape mutants were determined by DNA sequencing. Interestingly, each mutant contained the same mutation in the scaffold gene, which changes the glycine at position 287 to glutamate. This mutation alone conferred an escape phenotype, and the heads assembled by phage harboring only this mutation had reduced levels of portal protein and exhibited increased head assembly fidelity in the presence of excess portal protein. Because this mutation resides in a region of scaffold protein necessary for coat protein binding, these findings suggest that the P22 scaffold protein may define the portal vertices in an indirect manner, possibly by regulating the fidelity of coat protein polymerization.

pH reduction as a trigger for dissociation of herpes simplex virus type 1 scaffolds

Assembly of the infectious herpes simplex virus type 1 virion is a complex, multistage process that begins with the production of a procapsid, which is formed by the condensation of capsid shell proteins around an internal scaffold fashioned from multiple copies of the scaffolding protein, pre-VP22a. The ability of pre-VP22a to interact with itself is an essential feature of this process. However, this self-interaction must subsequently be reversed to allow the scaffolding proteins to exit from the capsid to make room for the viral genome to be packaged. The nature of the process by which dissociation of the scaffold is accomplished is unknown. Therefore, to investigate this process, the properties of isolated scaffold particles were investigated. Electron microscopy and gradient sedimentation studies showed that the particles could be dissociated by low concentrations of chaotropic agents and by moderate reductions in pH (from 7.2 to 5.5). Fluorescence spectroscopy and circular dichroism analyses revealed that there was relatively little change in tertiary and secondary structures under these conditions, indicating that major structural transformations are not required for the dissociation process. We suggest the possibility that dissociation of the scaffold may be triggered by a reduction in pH brought about by the entry of the viral DNA into the capsid.

The structure of P4 procapsids produced by coexpression of capsid and external scaffolding proteins

The double-stranded DNA bacteriophage P4 has a T = 4 icosahedral arrangement of the gpN capsid protein derived from the P2 helper phage. The precursor procapsids in addition contain an external scaffold made up of the P4-encoded Sid protein. High yields of pure P4 procapsids have been obtained by coexpressing the gpN and Sid proteins from a chimeric plasmid. Biochemical measurements show that the ratio of gpN to Sid in the procapsids is 2:1, corresponding to 120 copies of Sid per procapsid particle. A reconstruction of the P4 procapsid, made from 213 particle images to an effective resolution of about 21 A, greatly improves on the previously determined P4 procapsid structures. The structure shows a T = 4 capsid shell and a unique tandem arrangement of 120 copies of chilli-shaped Sid monomers, which form trimers and dimers on the procapsid surface.

Understanding viral partitioning in two-phase aqueous nonionic micellar systems: 1. Role of attractive interactions between viruses and micelles

The partitioning behavior of viruses in the two-phase aqueous nonionic n-decyl tetra(ethylene oxide) (C10E4) micellar system cannot be fully explained by considering solely the repulsive, steric, excluded-volume interactions that operate between the viruses and the nonionic C10E4 micelles. Specifically, an excluded-volume theory developed recently by our group is not able to quantitatively predict the observed viral partition coefficients, even though this theory is capable of providing reasonable quantitative predictions of protein partition coefficients. To shed light on the discrepancy between the theoretically predicted and the experimentally measured viral partition coefficients, a central assumption underlying the excluded-volume theory that the viruses and the C10E4 micelles interact solely through repulsive, excluded-volume interactions was challenged in this study. In particular, utilizing bacteriophage P22 as a model virus, a competitive inhibition test and a partitioning study of the capsids of bacteriophage P22 were conducted. Based on the results of these two experimental studies, it was concluded that any attractive interactions between the tailspikes of bacteriophage P22 and the C10E4 micelles are negligible. Another experimental study was carried out wherein the partition coefficients of the model viruses, bacteriophages P22 and T4, were measured at various temperatures, and compared with those previously obtained for bacteriophage phiX174. This comparison also indicated that possible attractive, electromagnetic-induced interactions between the bacteriophage particles and the C10E4 micelles cannot be invoked to rationalize the observed discrepancy between the theoretically predicted and the experimentally measured viral partition coefficients.

Understanding viral partitioning in two-phase aqueous nonionic micellar systems: 2. Effect of entrained micelle-poor domains

Unlike the partitioning behavior of hydrophilic, water-soluble proteins, the partitioning behavior of viruses in the two-phase aqueous nonionic n-decyl tetra(ethylene oxide) (C10E4) micellar system cannot be fully explained using the excluded-volume theory developed recently by our group. A central assumption underlying the excluded-volume theory--that macroscopic phase separation equilibrium is attained--was therefore challenged experimentally and theoretically. Photographs of the two-phase aqueous C10E4 micellar system were taken for different volume ratios to demonstrate that the entrainment of micelle-poor (virus-rich) domains in the macroscopic, top, micelle-rich phase decreases with a decrease in the volume ratio. Partitioning experiments were then conducted with the model virus bacteriophage P22 and the model protein cytochrome c at different operating temperatures for different volume ratios. For bacteriophage P22, the measured viral partition coefficient at each temperature decreased by about an order of magnitude when the volume ratio was decreased from 10 to 0.1, which clearly indicated that entrainment is an important factor influencing viral partitioning. For cytochrome c, the measured protein partition coefficient did not change, which demonstrated that this entrainment effect negligibly influences protein partitioning. A new theoretical description of partitioning was also developed that combines the excluded-volume theory with this entrainment effect. In this theory, one fitted parameter--the volume fraction of entrained micelle-poor domains in the macroscopic, top, micelle-rich phase--is used to account for the entrainment. To fit this parameter, only a single partitioning experiment is required for a given volume ratio, irrespectively of the partitioning solute. The new theoretical description of partitioning yielded very good quantitative predictions of the viral partition coefficients. Accordingly, it can be concluded that the primary mechanisms governing viral partitioning in the two-phase aqueous C10E4 micellar system are the entrainment of micelle-poor (virus-rich) domains in the macroscopic, top, micelle-rich phase and the excluded-volume interactions that operate between the viruses and the micelles.

Bacteriophage p22 portal vertex formation in vivo

Bacteriophage with double-stranded, linear DNA genomes package DNA into pre-assembled icosahedral procapsids through a unique vertex. The packaging vertex contains an oligomeric ring of a portal protein that serves as a recognition site for the packaging enzymes, a conduit for DNA translocation, and the site of tail attachment. Previous studies have suggested that the portal protein of bacteriophage P22 is not essential for shell assembly; however, when assembled in the absence of functional portal protein, the assembled heads are not active in vitro packaging assays. In terms of head assembly, this raises an interesting question: how are portal vertices defined during morphogenesis if their incorporation is not a requirement for head assembly? To address this, the P22 portal gene was cloned into an inducible expression vector and transformed into the P22 host Salmonella typhimurium to allow control of the dosage of portal protein during infections. Using pulse-chase radiolabeling, it was determined that the portal protein is recruited into virion during head assembly. Surprisingly, over-expression of the portal protein during wild-type P22 infection caused a dramatic reduction in the yield of infectious virus. The cause of this reduction was traced to two potentially related phenomena. First, excess portal protein caused aberrant head assembly resulting in the formation of T=7 procapsid-like particles (PLPs) with twice the normal amount of portal protein. Second, maturation of the PLPs was blocked during DNA packaging resulting in the accumulation of empty PLPs within the host. In addition to PLPs with normal morphology, smaller heads (apparently T=4) and aberrant spirals were also produced. Interestingly, maturation of the small heads was relatively efficient resulting in the formation of small mature particles that were tailed and contained a head full of DNA. These data suggest that incorporation of portal vertices into heads occurs during growth of the coat lattice at decision points that dictate head assembly fidelity.

Reconstruction principles of icosahedral virus structure determination using electron cryomicroscopy

Electron cryomicroscopy is a useful tool for studying the three-dimensional structure of icosahedral viruses. This review is intended to provide beginners with an understanding of icosahedral virus structure determination focusing on the data processing aspects. We begin with an overview of the entire structure determination process and a brief summary of the sample preparation and imaging aspects. Next, we provide detailed descriptions of each data processing step leading to three-dimensional reconstruction, including application of image corrections, resolution assessment, and structure visualization. To aid in understanding this reconstruction process we provide a variety of illustrative examples. Last, we summarize future prospects for icosahedral virus structural studies.