RNA oligonucleotide synthesis via 5'-silyl-2'-orthoester chemistry

Template-independent enzymatic synthesis of RNA oligonucleotides

RNA oligonucleotides have emerged as a powerful therapeutic modality to treat disease, yet current manufacturing methods may not be able to deliver on anticipated future demand. Here, we report the development and optimization of an aqueous-based, template-independent enzymatic RNA oligonucleotide synthesis platform as an alternative to traditional chemical methods. The enzymatic synthesis of RNA oligonucleotides is made possible by controlled incorporation of reversible terminator nucleotides with a common 3'-O-allyl ether blocking group using new CID1 poly(U) polymerase mutant variants. We achieved an average coupling efficiency of 95% and demonstrated ten full cycles of liquid phase synthesis to produce natural and therapeutically relevant modified sequences. We then qualitatively assessed the platform on a solid phase, performing enzymatic synthesis of several N + 5 oligonucleotides on a controlled-pore glass support. Adoption of an aqueous-based process will offer key advantages including the reduction of solvent use and sustainable therapeutic oligonucleotide manufacturing.

Non-viral delivery of the CRISPR/Cas system: DNA versus RNA versus RNP

Since its discovery, the CRISPR/Cas technology has rapidly become an essential tool in modern biomedical research. The opportunities to specifically modify and correct genomic DNA has also raised big hope...

Lipids and Lipid Derivatives for RNA Delivery

RNA-based therapeutics have shown great promise in treating a broad spectrum of diseases through various mechanisms including knockdown of pathological genes, expression of therapeutic proteins, and programmed gene editing. Due to the inherent instability and negative-charges of RNA molecules, RNA-based therapeutics can make the most use of delivery systems to overcome biological barriers and to release the RNA payload into the cytosol. Among different types of delivery systems, lipid-based RNA delivery systems, particularly lipid nanoparticles (LNPs), have been extensively studied due to their unique properties, such as simple chemical synthesis of lipid components, scalable manufacturing processes of LNPs, and wide packaging capability. LNPs represent the most widely used delivery systems for RNA-based therapeutics, as evidenced by the clinical approvals of three LNP-RNA formulations, patisiran, BNT162b2, and mRNA-1273. This review covers recent advances of lipids, lipid derivatives, and lipid-derived macromolecules used in RNA delivery over the past several decades. We focus mainly on their chemical structures, synthetic routes, characterization, formulation methods, and structure-activity relationships. We also briefly describe the current status of representative preclinical studies and clinical trials and highlight future opportunities and challenges.

Recent advances in chemical modifications of guide RNA, mRNA and donor template for CRISPR-mediated genome editing

The discovery and applications of clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeat (CRISPR) systems have revolutionized our ability to track and manipulate specific nucleic acid sequences in many cell types of various organisms. The robustness and simplicity of these platforms have rapidly extended their applications from basic research to the development of therapeutics. However, many hurdles remain on the path to translation of the CRISPR systems to therapeutic applications: efficient delivery, detectable off-target effects, potential immunogenicity, and others. Chemical modifications provide a variety of protection options for guide RNA, Cas9 mRNA and donor templates. For example, chemically modified gRNA demonstrated enhanced on-target editing efficiency, minimized immune response and decreased off-target genome editing. In this review, we summarize the use of chemically modified nucleotides for CRISPR-mediated genome editing and emphasize open questions that remain to be addressed in clinical applications.

Synthesis of Nucleobase-Modified RNA Oligonucleotides by Post-Synthetic Approach

The chemical synthesis of modified oligoribonucleotides represents a powerful approach to study the structure, stability, and biological activity of RNAs. Selected RNA modifications have been proven to enhance the drug-like properties of RNA oligomers providing the oligonucleotide-based therapeutic agents in the antisense and siRNA technologies. The important sites of RNA modification/functionalization are the nucleobase residues. Standard phosphoramidite RNA chemistry allows the site-specific incorporation of a large number of functional groups to the nucleobase structure if the building blocks are synthetically obtainable and stable under the conditions of oligonucleotide chemistry and work-up. Otherwise, the chemically modified RNAs are produced by post-synthetic oligoribonucleotide functionalization. This review highlights the post-synthetic RNA modification approach as a convenient and valuable method to introduce a wide variety of nucleobase modifications, including recently discovered native hypermodified functional groups, fluorescent dyes, photoreactive groups, disulfide crosslinks, and nitroxide spin labels.

Solid-Phase Chemical Synthesis of Stable Isotope-Labeled RNA to Aid Structure and Dynamics Studies by NMR Spectroscopy

RNA structure and dynamic studies by NMR spectroscopy suffer from chemical shift overlap and line broadening, both of which become worse as RNA size increases. Incorporation of stable isotope labels into RNA has provided several solutions to these limitations. Nevertheless, the only method to circumvent the problem of spectral overlap completely is the solid-phase chemical synthesis of RNA with labeled RNA phosphoramidites. In this review, we summarize the practical aspects of this methodology for NMR spectroscopy studies of RNA. These types of investigations lie at the intersection of chemistry and biophysics and highlight the need for collaborative efforts to tackle the integrative structural biology problems that exist in the RNA world. Finally, examples of RNA structure and dynamic studies using labeled phosphoramidites are highlighted.

A Practical Guide to Genome Editing Using Targeted Nuclease Technologies

Genome engineering using programmable nucleases is a rapidly evolving technique that enables precise genetic manipulations within complex genomes. Although this technology first surfaced with the creation of meganucleases, zinc finger nucleases, and transcription activator-like effector nucleases, CRISPR-Cas9 has been the most widely adopted platform because of its ease of use. This comprehensive review presents a basic overview of genome engineering and discusses the major technological advances in the field. In addition to nucleases, we discuss CRISPR-derived base editors and epigenetic modifiers. We also delve into practical applications of these tools, including creating custom-edited cell and animal models as well as performing genetic screens. Finally, we discuss the potential for therapeutic applications and ethical considerations related to employing this technology in humans. © 2019 American Physiological Society. Compr Physiol 9:665-714, 2019.

Lactobacillus gasseri CRISPR-Cas9 characterization In Vitro reveals a flexible mode of protospacer-adjacent motif recognition

While the CRISPR-Cas9 system from S. pyogenes is a powerful genome engineering tool, additional programmed nucleases would enable added flexibility in targeting space and multiplexing. Here, we characterized a CRISPR-Cas9 system from L. gasseri and found that it has modest activity in a cell-free lysate assay but no activity in mammalian cells even when altering promoter, position of tag sequences and NLS, and length of crRNA:tracrRNA. In the lysate assay we tested over 400 sequential crRNA target sequences and found that the Lga Cas9 PAM is NNGA/NDRA, different than NTAA predicted from the native bacterial host. In addition, we found multiple instances of consecutive crRNA target sites, indicating flexibility in either PAM sequence or distance from the crRNA target site. This work highlights the need for characterization of new CRISPR systems and highlights the non-triviality of porting them into eukaryotes as gene editing tools.

Minimal 2'-O-methyl phosphorothioate linkage modification pattern of synthetic guide RNAs for increased stability and efficient CRISPR-Cas9 gene editing avoiding cellular toxicity

Since its initial application in mammalian cells, CRISPR-Cas9 has rapidly become a preferred method for genome engineering experiments. The Cas9 nuclease is targeted to genomic DNA using guide RNAs (gRNA), either as the native dual RNA system consisting of a DNA-targeting CRISPR RNA (crRNA) and a trans-activating crRNA (tracrRNA), or as a chimeric single guide RNA (sgRNA). Entirely DNA-free CRISPR-Cas9 systems using either Cas9 protein or Cas9 mRNA and chemically synthesized gRNAs allow for transient expression of CRISPR-Cas9 components, thereby reducing the potential for off-targeting, which is a significant advantage in therapeutic applications. In addition, the use of synthetic gRNA allows for the incorporation of chemical modifications for enhanced properties including improved stability. Previous studies have demonstrated the utility of chemically modified gRNAs, but have focused on one pattern with multiple modifications in co-electroporation with Cas9 mRNA or multiple modifications and patterns with Cas9 plasmid lipid co-transfections. Here we present gene editing results using a series of chemically modified synthetic sgRNA molecules and chemically modified crRNA:tracrRNA molecules in both electroporation and lipid transfection assessing indel formation and/or phenotypic gene knockout. We show that while modifications are required for co-electroporation with Cas9 mRNA, some modification patterns of the gRNA are toxic to cells compared to the unmodified gRNA and most modification patterns do not significantly improve gene editing efficiency. We also present modification patterns of the gRNA that can modestly improve Cas9 gene editing efficiency when co-transfected with Cas9 mRNA or Cas9 protein (> 1.5-fold difference). These results indicate that for certain applications, including those relevant to primary cells, the incorporation of some, but not all chemical modification patterns on synthetic crRNA:tracrRNA or sgRNA can be beneficial to CRISPR-Cas9 gene editing.

Synthesis of RNA Containing 5-Hydroxymethyl-, 5-Formyl-, and 5-Carboxycytidine

5-Hydroxymethyl-, 5-formyl-, and 5-carboxy-2'-deoxycytidine are new epigenetic bases (hmdC, fdC, cadC) that were recently discovered in the DNA of higher eukaryotes. The same bases (5-hydroxymethyl-, 5-formyl-, and 5-carboxycytidine; hmC, fC, and caC) have now also been detected in mammalian RNA with a high abundance in mRNA. While DNA phosphoramidites (PAs) that allow the synthesis of xdC-containing oligonucleotides for deeper biological studies are available, the corresponding silyl-protected RNA PAs for fC and caC have not yet been disclosed. Here, we report novel RNA PAs for hmC, fC, and caC that can be used in routine RNA synthesis. The new building blocks are compatible with the canonical PAs and also with themselves, which enables even the synthesis of RNA strands containing all three of these bases. The study will pave the way for detailed physical, biochemical, and biological studies to unravel the function of these non-canonical modifications in RNA.

Versatility of chemically synthesized guide RNAs for CRISPR-Cas9 genome editing

The CRISPR-Cas9 system has become the most popular and efficient method for genome engineering in mammalian cells. The Streptococcus pyogenes Cas9 nuclease can function with two types of guide RNAs: the native dual crRNA and tracrRNA (crRNA:tracrRNA) or a chimeric single guide RNA (sgRNA). Although sgRNAs expressed from a DNA vector are predominant in the literature, guide RNAs can be rapidly generated by chemical synthesis and provide equivalent functionality in gene editing experiments. This review highlights the attributes and advantages of chemically synthesized guide RNAs including the incorporation of chemical modifications to enhance gene editing efficiencies in certain applications. The use of synthetic guide RNAs is also uniquely suited to genome-scale high throughput arrayed screening, particularly when using complex phenotypic assays for functional genomics studies. Finally, the use of synthetic guide RNAs along with DNA-free sources of Cas9 (mRNA or protein) allows for transient CRISPR-Cas9 presence in the cell, thereby resulting in a decreased probability of off-target events.

Nuclease-Resistant c-di-AMP Derivatives That Differentially Recognize RNA and Protein Receptors

The ability of bacteria to sense environmental cues and adapt is essential for their survival. The use of second-messenger signaling molecules to translate these cues into a physiological response is a common mechanism employed by bacteria. The second messenger 3'-5'-cyclic diadenosine monophosphate (c-di-AMP) has been linked to a diverse set of biological processes involved in maintaining cell viability and homeostasis, as well as pathogenicity. A complex network of both protein and RNA receptors inside the cell activates specific pathways and mediates phenotypic outputs in response to c-di-AMP. Structural analysis of these RNA and protein receptors has revealed the different recognition elements employed by these effectors to bind the same small molecule. Herein, using a series of c-di-AMP analogues, we probed the interactions made with a riboswitch and a phosphodiesterase protein to identify the features important for c-di-AMP binding and recognition. We found that the ydaO riboswitch binds c-di-AMP in two discrete sites with near identical affinity and a Hill coefficient of 1.6. The ydaO riboswitch distinguishes between c-di-AMP and structurally related second messengers by discriminating against an amine at the C2 position more than a carbonyl at the C6 position. We also identified phosphate-modified analogues that bind both the ydaO RNA and GdpP protein with high affinity, whereas symmetrically modified ribose analogues exhibited a substantial decrease in ydaO affinity but retained high affinity for GdpP. These ligand modifications resulted in increased resistance to enzyme-catalyzed hydrolysis by the GdpP enzyme. Together, these data suggest that these c-di-AMP analogues could be useful as chemical tools to specifically target subsections of second-messenger signaling pathways.

pH-Cleavable Nucleoside Lipids: A New Paradigm for Controlling the Stability of Lipid-Based Delivery Systems

Lipid-based delivery systems are an established technology with considerable clinical acceptance and several applications in human. Herein, we report the design, synthesis and evaluation of novel orthoester nucleoside lipids (ONLs) for the modulation of liposome stability. The ONLs contain head groups with 3'-orthoester nucleoside derivatives featuring positive or negative charges. The insertion of the orthoester function in the NL structures allows the formation of pH-sensitive liposomes. ONL-based liposomes can be hydrolyzed to provide nontoxic products, including nucleoside derivatives and hexadecanol. To allow the release to be tunable at different hydrolysis rates, the charge of the polar head structure is modulated, and the head group can be released at a biologically relevant pH. Crucially, when ONLs are mixed with natural phosphocholine lipids (PC), the resultant liposome evolves toward the formation of a hexadecanol/PC lamellar system. Biological evaluation shows that stable nucleic acid lipid particles (SNALPs) formulated with ONLs and siRNAs can effectively enter into tumor cells and release their nucleic acid payload in response to an intracellular acidic environment. This results in a much higher antitumor activity than conventional SNALPs. The ability to use pH-cleavable nucleolipids to control the stability of lipid-based delivery systems represents a promising approach for the intracellular delivery of drug cargos.

Systematic analysis of CRISPR-Cas9 mismatch tolerance reveals low levels of off-target activity

The discovery that the bacterial clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats (CRISPR)-CRISPR-associated protein 9 (Cas9) acquired immune system can be utilized to create double-strand breaks (DSBs) in eukaryotic genomes has resulted in the ability to create genomic changes more easily than with other genome engineering techniques. While there is significant potential for the CRISPR-Cas9 system to advance basic and applied research, several unknowns remain, including the specificity of the RNA-directed DNA cleavage by the small targeting RNA, the CRISPR RNA (crRNA). Here we describe a novel synthetic RNA approach that allows for high-throughput gene editing experiments. This was used with a functional assay for protein disruption to perform high-throughput analysis of crRNA activity and specificity. We performed a comprehensive test of target cleavage using crRNAs that contain one and two nucleotide mismatches to the DNA target in the 20mer targeting region of the crRNA, allowing for the evaluation of hundreds of potential mismatched target sites without the requirement for the off-target sequences and their adjacent PAMs to be present in the genome. Our results demonstrate that while many crRNAs are functional, less than 5% of crRNAs with two mismatches to their target are effective in gene editing; this suggests an overall high level of functionality but low level of off-targeting.

Efficient splinted ligation of synthetic RNA using RNA ligase

RNA ligation allows the creation of large RNA molecules from smaller pieces. This can be useful in a number of contexts: to generate molecules that are larger than can be directly synthesized; to incorporate site-specific changes or RNA modifications within a large RNA in order to facilitate functional and structural studies; to isotopically label segments of large RNAs for NMR structural studies; and to construct libraries of mutant RNAs in which one region is extensively mutagenized or modified. The impediment to widespread use of RNA ligation is the low and variable efficiency of standard ligation strategies, which frequently preclude joining more than two pieces of RNA together.We describe a method using RNA ligase (Rligation), rather than DNA ligase (Dligation), in a splint-mediated ligation reaction that joins RNA molecules with high efficiency. RNA ligase recognizes single-stranded RNA ends, which are held in proximity to one another by the splint. Monitoring the reaction is easily accomplished by denaturing gel electrophoresis and ethidium bromide staining. Using this technique, it is possible to generate a wide range of modified RNAs from synthetic oligoribonucleotides.

First synthesis of fully modified 4'-selenoRNA and 2'-OMe-4'-selenoRNA based on the mechanistic considerations of an unexpected strand break

This study investigated oligonucleotide (ON) synthesis containing 4'-selenoribonucleoside(s) under standard phosphoramidite conditions. Careful operation using a manual ON synthetic system revealed that an unexpected strand break occurred to afford a C2-symmetric homodimer as a byproduct. In addition, this side reaction occurred during I2 oxidation. On the basis of these findings, the first synthesis of fully modified 4'-selenoRNA and 2'-OMe-4'-selenoRNA was achieved using tert-butyl hydroperoxide (TBHP) as the alternative oxidant.

Efficient solid-phase synthesis of pppRNA by using product-specific labeling

A novel solid-phase synthesis and purification strategy for 5'-triphosphate oligonucleotides by using lipophilic tagging of the triphosphate moiety is reported. This is based on triphosphate synthesis with 5'-O-cyclotriphosphate intermediates, whereby a lipophilic tag, such as decylamine, is introduced during the ring-opening reaction to give a linear gamma-phosphate-tagged species. This method enables the highly efficient synthesis of 5'-triphosphorylated RNA derivatives and their gamma-phosphate-substituted analogues and will especially facilitate the advancement of therapeutic approaches that make use of 5'-triphosphate oligonucleotides as potent activators of the cytosolic immune sensor RIG-I.

[Protection of 2'-hydroxyls in the chemical synthesis of oligoribonucleotides]

The review is devoted to the chemical synthesis of oligoribonucleotides and the protecting groups used. In particular the existent methods of blocking 2'-OH function in nucleotide monomers for the RNA synthesis are discussed in detail.

Solid-phase supports for oligonucleotide synthesis

This unit attempts to provide a reasonably complete inventory of over 280 solid supports available to oligonucleotide chemists for preparation of natural and 3'-modified oligonucleotides. Emphasis is placed on non-nucleosidic solid supports. The relationship between the structural features of linkers and their behavior in oligonucleotide synthesis and deprotection is discussed wherever the relevant observations are available.

Structural and mechanistic basis for enhanced translational efficiency by 2-thiouridine at the tRNA anticodon wobble position

The 2-thiouridine (s(2)U) at the wobble position of certain bacterial and eukaryotic tRNAs enhances aminoacylation kinetics, assists proper codon-anticodon base pairing at the ribosome A-site, and prevents frameshifting during translation. By mass spectrometry of affinity-purified native Escherichia coli tRNA1(Gln)UUG, we show that the complete modification at the wobble position 34 is 5-carboxyaminomethyl-2-thiouridine (cmnm(5)s(2)U). The crystal structure of E. coli glutaminyl-tRNA synthetase (GlnRS) bound to native tRNA1(Gln) and ATP demonstrates that cmnm(5)s(2)U34 improves the order of a previously unobserved 11-amino-acid surface loop in the distal β-barrel domain of the enzyme and imparts other local rearrangements of nearby amino acids that create a binding pocket for the 2-thio moiety. Together with previously solved structures, these observations explain the degenerate recognition of C34 and modified U34 by GlnRS. Comparative pre-steady-state aminoacylation kinetics of native tRNA1(Gln), synthetic tRNA1(Gln) containing s(2)U34 as sole modification, and unmodified wild-type and mutant tRNA1(Gln) and tRNA2(Gln) transcripts demonstrates that the exocyclic sulfur moiety improves tRNA binding affinity to GlnRS 10-fold compared with the unmodified transcript and that an additional fourfold improvement arises from the presence of the cmnm(5) moiety. Measurements of Gln-tRNA(Gln) interactions at the ribosome A-site show that the s(2)U modification enhances binding affinity to the glutamine codons CAA and CAG and increases the rate of GTP hydrolysis by E. coli EF-Tu by fivefold.

Probing the stabilizing effects of modified nucleotides in the bacterial decoding region of 16S ribosomal RNA

The bacterial decoding region of 16S ribosomal RNA has multiple modified nucleotides. In order to study the role of N(4),2'-O-dimethylcytidine (m(4)Cm), the corresponding phosphoramidite was synthesized utilizing 5'-silyl-2'-ACE chemistry. Using solid-phase synthesis, m(4)Cm, 5-methylcytidine (m(5)C), 3-methyluridine (m(3)U), and 2'-O-methylcytidine (Cm) were site-specifically incorporated into small RNAs representing the decoding regions of different bacterial species. Biophysical studies were then used to provide insight into the stabilizing roles of the modified nucleotides. These studies reveal that methylation of cytidine and uridine has different effects. The same modifications at different positions or sequence contexts within similar RNA constructs also have contrasting roles, such as stabilizing or destabilizing the RNA helix.

Differential analogue binding by two classes of c-di-GMP riboswitches

The ability of bacteria to adapt to a changing environment is essential for their survival. One mechanism bacteria have evolved to sense environmental cues and translate these signals into phenotypic changes uses the second messenger signaling molecule, cyclic diguanosine monophosphate (c-di-GMP). In addition to several classes of protein receptors, two classes of c-di-GMP-binding riboswitches (class I and class II) have been identified as downstream targets of the second messenger in this signaling pathway. The crystal structures of both riboswitch classes bound to c-di-GMP were previously reported. Here, we further investigate the mechanisms that RNA has evolved for recognition and binding of this second messenger. Using a series of c-di-GMP analogues, we probed the interactions made in the RNA-ligand complex for both classes of riboswitches to identify the most critical elements of c-di-GMP for binding. We found that the structural features of c-di-GMP required for binding differ between these two effectors and that the class II riboswitch is much less discriminatory in ligand binding than the class I riboswitch. These data suggest an explanation for the predicted preferential use of the class I motif over the class II motif in the c-di-GMP signaling pathway.

Mapping interactions between the RNA chaperone FinO and its RNA targets

Bacterial conjugation is regulated by two-component repression comprising the antisense RNA FinP, and its protein co-factor FinO. FinO mediates base-pairing of FinP to the 5′-untranslated region (UTR) of traJ mRNA, which leads to translational inhibition of the transcriptional activator TraJ and subsequent down regulation of conjugation genes. Yet, little is known about how FinO binds to its RNA targets or how this interaction facilitates FinP and traJ mRNA pairing. Here, we use solution methods to determine how FinO binds specifically to its minimal high affinity target, FinP stem–loop II (SLII), and its complement SLIIc from traJ mRNA. Ribonuclease footprinting reveals that FinO contacts the base of the stem and the 3′ single-stranded tails of these RNAs. The phosphorylation or oxidation of the 3′-nucleotide blocks FinO binding, suggesting FinO binds the 3′-hydroxyl of its RNA targets. The collective results allow the generation of an energy-minimized model of the FinO–SLII complex, consistent with small-angle X-ray scattering data. The repression complex model was constrained using previously reported cross-linking data and newly developed footprinting results. Together, these data lead us to propose a model of how FinO mediates FinP/traJ mRNA pairing to down regulate bacterial conjugation.

Recent advances in the chemical synthesis of RNA

As a consequence largely of recent developments in RNA interference (RNAi) research, the availability of rapid and efficient methods for the chemical synthesis of RNA sequences has become a matter of considerable urgency. This unit is concerned mainly with work that has been carried out, especially in the past decade, on the design of new and improved methods of RNA synthesis. The main criteria for the choice of protecting groups for the 2'-hydroxy functions of the ribonucleoside building blocks, which is arguably the most crucial strategic decision to be made, are discussed. A number of new ether-, acetal-, orthoester-, and ester-based 2'-protecting groups are described and their application, mainly in phosphoramidite-based solid-phase synthesis, is discussed in some detail. Brief consideration is also given to solution-phase RNA synthesis, which may well prove to be of great importance if a systemic drug is developed and multikilogram quantities of synthetic RNA sequences are required.

Rigid spin-labeled nucleoside C: a nonperturbing EPR probe of nucleic acid conformation

Rigid spin-labeled nucleoside C, an analog of deoxycytidine that base-pairs with deoxyguanosine, was incorporated into DNA oligomers by chemical synthesis. Thermal denaturation experiments and circular dichroism (CD) measurements showed that C has a negligible effect on DNA duplex stability and conformation. Nucleoside C was incorporated into several positions within single-stranded DNA oligomers that can adopt two hairpin conformations of similar energy, each of which contains a four-base loop. The relative mobility of nucleotides in the alternating C/G hairpin loops, 5'-d(GCGC) and 5'-d(CGCG), was determined by electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy. The most mobile nucleotide in the loop is the second one from the 5'-end, followed by the third, first and fourth nucleotides, consistent with previous NMR studies of DNA hairpin loops of different sequences. The EPR hairpin data were also corroborated by fluorescence spectroscopy using oligomers containing reduced C (C(f)), which is fluorescent. Furthermore, EPR spectra of duplex DNAs that contained C at the end of the helix showed features that indicated dipolar coupling between two spins. These data are consistent with end-to-end duplex stacking in solution, which was only observed when G was paired to C, but not when C was paired with A, C or T.

Key labeling technologies to tackle sizeable problems in RNA structural biology

The ability to adopt complex three-dimensional (3D) structures that can rapidly interconvert between multiple functional states (folding and dynamics) is vital for the proper functioning of RNAs. Consequently, RNA structure and dynamics necessarily determine their biological function. In the post-genomic era, it is clear that RNAs comprise a larger proportion (>50%) of the transcribed genome compared to proteins (< or =2%). Yet the determination of the 3D structures of RNAs lags considerably behind those of proteins and to date there are even fewer investigations of dynamics in RNAs compared to proteins. Site specific incorporation of various structural and dynamic probes into nucleic acids would likely transform RNA structural biology. Therefore, various methods for introducing probes for structural, functional, and biotechnological applications are critically assessed here. These probes include stable isotopes such as (2)H, (13)C, (15)N, and (19)F. Incorporation of these probes using improved RNA ligation strategies promises to change the landscape of structural biology of supramacromolecules probed by biophysical tools such as nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy, X-ray crystallography and Raman spectroscopy. Finally, some of the structural and dynamic problems that can be addressed using these technological advances are outlined.

pH-dependent structural changes of helix 69 from Escherichia coli 23S ribosomal RNA

Helix 69 in 23S rRNA is a region in the ribosome that participates in a considerable number of RNA-RNA and RNA-protein interactions. Conformational flexibility is essential for such a region to interact and accommodate protein factors at different stages of protein biosynthesis. In this study, pH-dependent structural and stability changes were observed for helix 69 through a variety of spectroscopic techniques, such as circular dichroism spectroscopy, UV melting, and nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. In Escherichia coli 23S rRNA, helix 69 contains pseudouridine residues at positions 1911, 1915, and 1917. The presence of these pseudouridines was found to be essential for the pH-induced conformational changes. Some of the pH-dependent changes appear to be localized to the loop region of helix 69, emphasizing the importance of the highly conserved nature of residues in this region.

2'-Methylseleno-modified oligoribonucleotides for X-ray crystallography synthesized by the ACE RNA solid-phase approach

Site-specifically modified 2'-methylseleno RNA represents a valuable derivative for phasing of X-ray crystallographic data. Several successful applications in three-dimensional structure determination of nucleic acids, such as the Diels-Alder ribozyme, have relied on this modification. Here, we introduce synthetic routes to 2'-methylseleno phosphoramidite building blocks of all four standard nucleosides, adenosine, cytidine, guanosine and uridine, that are tailored for 2'-O-bis(acetoxyethoxy)methyl (ACE) RNA solid-phase synthesis. We additionally report on their incorporation into oligoribonucleotides including deprotection and purification. The methodological expansion of 2'-methylseleno labeling via ACE RNA chemistry is a major step to make Se-RNA generally accessible and to receive broad dissemination of the Se-approach for crystallographic studies on RNA. Thus far, preparation of 2'-methylseleno-modified oligoribonucleotides has been restricted to the 2'-O-[(triisopropylsilyl)oxy]methyl (TOM) and 2'-O-tert-butyldimethylsilyl (TBDMS) RNA synthesis methods.

Spin labeling of oligonucleotides with the nitroxide TPA and use of PELDOR, a pulse EPR method, to measure intramolecular distances

In this protocol, we describe the facile synthesis of the nitroxide spin-label 2,2,5,5-tetramethyl-pyrrolin-1-oxyl-3-acetylene (TPA) and then its coupling to DNA/RNA through Sonogashira cross-coupling during automated solid-phase synthesis. Subsequently, we explain how to perform distance measurements between two such spin-labels on RNA/DNA using the pulsed electron paramagnetic resonance method pulsed electron double resonance (PELDOR). This combination of methods can be used to study global structure elements of oligonucleotides in frozen solution at RNA/DNA amounts of approximately 10 nmol. We especially focus on the Sonogashira cross-coupling step, the advantages of the ACE chemistry together with the appropriate parameters for the RNA synthesizer and on the PELDOR data analysis. This procedure is applicable to RNA/DNA strands of up to approximately 80 bases in length and PELDOR yields reliably spin-spin distances up to approximately 6.5 nm. The synthesis of TPA takes approximately 5 days and spin labeling together with purification approximately 4 days. The PELDOR measurements usually take approximately 16 h and data analysis from an hour up to several days depending on the extent of analysis.

Base-specific spin-labeling of RNA for structure determination

To facilitate the measurement of intramolecular distances in solvated RNA systems, a combination of spin-labeling, electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR), and molecular dynamics (MD) simulation is presented. The fairly rigid spin label 2,2,5,5-tetramethyl-pyrrolin-1-yloxyl-3-acetylene (TPA) was base and site specifically introduced into RNA through a Sonogashira palladium catalyzed cross-coupling on column. For this purpose 5-iodo-uridine, 5-iodo-cytidine and 2-iodo-adenosine phosphoramidites were synthesized and incorporated into RNA-sequences. Application of the recently developed ACE chemistry presented the main advantage to limit the reduction of the nitroxide to an amine during the oligonucleotide automated synthesis and thus to increase substantially the reliability of the synthesis and the yield of labeled oligonucleotides. 4-Pulse Electron Double Resonance (PELDOR) was then successfully used to measure the intramolecular spin-spin distances in six doubly labeled RNA-duplexes. Comparison of these results with our previous work on DNA showed that A- and B-Form can be differentiated. Using an all-atom force field with explicit solvent, MD simulations gave results in good agreement with the measured distances and indicated that the RNA A-Form was conserved despite a local destabilization effect of the nitroxide label. The applicability of the method to more complex biological systems is discussed.

Assessment of 4-Nitrogenated Benzyloxymethyl Groups for 2‘-Hydroxyl Protection in Solid-Phase RNA Synthesis

The search for a 2'-OH protecting group that would impart ribonucleoside phosphoramidites with coupling kinetics and coupling efficiencies comparable to those of deoxyribonucleoside phosphoramidites led to an assessment of 2'-O-(4-nitrogenated benzyloxy)methyl groups through solid-phase RNA synthesis using phosphoramidites 2a-d, 12a, and 14a. These phosphoramidites exhibited rapid and efficient coupling properties. Particularly noteworthy is the cleavage of the 2'-O-[4-(N-methylamino)benzyloxy]methyl groups in 0.1 M AcOH, which led to U19dT within 15 min at 90 degrees C. [reaction: see text]

Human RNase H1 discriminates between subtle variations in the structure of the heteroduplex substrate

In a previous study, we demonstrated that the sugar conformation and helical geometry of the heteroduplex substrate at the catalytic site of human RNase H1 directs the selective recognition of the substrate by the enzyme (J Biol Chem 279: 36317-36326, 2004). In this study, we systematically introduced 2'-methoxyethoxy (MOE) nucleotides into the antisense oligodeoxyribonucleotide (ASO) of the heteroduplex to alter the helical geometry of the substrate. The MOE substitutions at the 3' and 5' poles of the ASO resulted in fewer cleavage sites and slower cleavage rates compared with the unmodified substrates. Furthermore, a greater reduction in cleavage activity was observed for MOE substitutions at the 5' pole of the ASO. The 3'- and 5'-most cleavage sites were positioned two and four to five base pairs, respectively, from the nearest MOE residues, suggesting a conformational transmission of the MOE/RNA helical geometry into the DNA/RNA portion of the heteroduplex. Similar conformational transmission was observed for Okazaki-like substrates containing deoxyribonucleotide substitutions at the 3' pole of the oligoribonucleotide. Finally, the heteroduplex substrates exhibited preferred cleavage sites that were cleaved 2- to 3-fold faster than other sites in the substrate, and these sites exhibited the greatest influence on the initial cleavage rates. The data presented here offer further insights into the role substrate structure plays in directing human RNase H1 activity as well as the design of effective ASOs.

An RNA ligase-mediated method for the efficient creation of large, synthetic RNAs

RNA ligation has been a powerful tool for incorporation of cross-linkers and nonnatural nucleotides into internal positions of RNA molecules. The most widely used method for template-directed RNA ligation uses DNA ligase and a DNA splint. While this method has been used successfully for many years, it suffers from a number of drawbacks, principally, slow and inefficient product formation and slow product release, resulting in a requirement for large quantities of enzyme. We describe an alternative technique catalyzed by T4 RNA ligase instead of DNA ligase. Using a splint design that allows the ligation junction to mimic the natural substrate of RNA ligase, we demonstrate several ligation reactions that appear to go nearly to completion. Furthermore, the reactions generally go to completion within 30 min. We present data evaluating the relative importance of various parameters in this reaction. Finally, we show the utility of this method by generating a 128-nucleotide pre-mRNA from three synthetic oligoribonucleotides. The ability to ligate synthetic or in vitro transcribed RNA with high efficiency has the potential to open up areas of RNA biology to new functional and biophysical investigation. In particular, we anticipate that site-specific incorporation of fluorescent dyes into large RNA molecules will yield a wealth of new information on RNA structure and function.

Synthesis of a 2'-Se-uridine phosphoramidite and its incorporation into oligonucleotides for structural study

[chemical reaction: see text]. We report here the synthesis of the 5'-[benzhydryloxybis(trimethylsilyloxy)]silyl-2'-methylseleno-2'-deoxyuridine phosphoramidite and its incorporation into oligonucleotides by solid-phase synthesis. The coupling yield of this phosphoramidite into oligonucleotides is higher than 99%. We also demonstrate that this 2'-methylselenophosphoramidite is compatible with the 5'-silyl-2'-ACE chemistry, for longer Se-RNA solid-phase synthesis. Our preliminary NMR study on the synthesized 2'-Se-DNA has revealed a U(Se)-A base pair and a duplex structure formation when its complementary strand was present.

Widespread siRNA "off-target" transcript silencing mediated by seed region sequence complementarity

Transfected siRNAs and miRNAs regulate numerous transcripts that have only limited complementarity to the active strand of the RNA duplex. This process reflects natural target regulation by miRNAs, but is an unintended ("off-target") consequence of siRNA-mediated silencing. Here we demonstrate that this unintended off-target silencing is widespread, and occurs in a manner reminiscent of target silencing by miRNAs. A high proportion of unintended transcripts silenced by siRNAs showed 3' UTR sequence complementarity to the seed region of the siRNA. Base mismatches within the siRNA seed region reduced the set of original off-target transcripts but generated new sets of silenced transcripts with sequence complementarity to the mismatched seed sequence. An inducible shRNA silenced a subset of transcripts that were silenced by an siRNA of the same sequence, demonstrating that unintended silencing is sequence mediated and is independent of delivery method. In all cases, off-target transcript silencing was accompanied by loss of the corresponding protein and occurred with dependence on siRNA concentration similar to that of silencing of the target transcript. Thus, short stretches of sequence complementarity to the siRNA or shRNA seed region are key to the silencing of unintended transcripts.

Synthesis of the ribosomal P-site substrate CCA-pcb

[reaction: see text] CCA-pcb (cytidylyl-(3'5')-cytidylyl-(3'5')-3'(2')-O-(N-(6-D-(+)-biotinoylaminohexanoyl)-L-phenylalanyl)adenosine), a ribosomal P-site substrate, was synthesized by phosphoramidite chemistry in 26 steps with an overall yield of 18%, starting from biotin. The synthesis relies on the judicious selection of orthogonal silyl protecting groups for the 5'-hydroxyls and acid-labile protecting groups (DMTr, AcE, and MeE) at other reactive sites to ensure the intactness of the labile ester. Both 3'-esterification and nucleotide coupling were accomplished by in situ activation with imidazolium ions.

4,5-bis(ethoxycarbonyl)-[1,3]dioxolan-2-yl as a new orthoester-type protecting group for the 2'-hydroxyl function in the chemical synthesis of RNA

We wish to report 4,5-bis(ethoxycarbonyl)-[1,3]dioxolan-2-yl as a new protecting for the 2'-hydroxyl function. Our cyclic orthoester-type group is compatible with the DMTr strategy for oligonucleotide synthesis. This group was introduced to the 2'-hydroxyl group of appropriately protected nucleoside derivatives in good yields under mild acidic conditions. Post-synthetic conversion of the moiety of this protecting group with an amine resulted in formation of a new amide moiety that is more stable to acid deprotection in aqueous solution, but it can still be easily removed by treatment with acids in organic solvents. In this article, we also describe the stability of not only the original and modified protecting groups but also internucleotidic phosphate linkages of protected RNA intermediates under deprotection conditions.

Large-scale synthesis of "Cpep" RNA monomers and their application in automated RNA synthesis

Small interfering RNAs (siRNA) are the latest candidates for oligonucleotide-based therapeutics. Should siRNA be successful in clinical trials, a huge demand for synthetic RNA is anticipated. We believe that 1-(4-chlorophenyl)-4-ethoxypiperidin-4-yl (Cpep) is an ideal 2'-protecting group for large-scale syntheses. Unlike 2'-silyl groups, mild acid hydrolysis instead of fluoride ion is used for the 2'-deprotection. The syntheses of 2'-Cpep protected nucleosides (A, C, G, and U) has been accomplished on a 0.5 Kg scale. The 2'-Cpep monomers were transformed into 3'-O-phosphoramidites for conventional automated solid-phase synthesis. Cost-effective processes for large-scale synthesis of Cpep monomers and initial automated solid-phase synthesis are demonstrated.

A deoxyribozyme that synthesizes 2',5'-branched RNA with any branch-site nucleotide

RNA molecules with internal 2',5'-branches are intermediates in RNA splicing, and branched RNAs have recently been proposed as retrotransposition intermediates. A broadly applicable in vitro synthetic route to branched RNA that does not require self-splicing introns or spliceosomes would substantially improve our ability to study biochemical processes that involve branched RNA. We recently described 7S11, a deoxyribozyme that was identified by in vitro selection and has general RNA branch-forming ability. However, an important restriction for 7S11 is that the branch-site RNA nucleotide must be a purine (A or G), because a pyrimidine (U or C) is not tolerated. Here, we describe the compact 6CE8 deoxyribozyme (selected using a 20 nt random region) that synthesizes 2',5'-branched RNA with any nucleotide at the branch site. The Mn2+-dependent branch-forming ligation reaction is between an internal branch-site 2'-hydroxyl nucleophile on one RNA substrate with a 5'-triphosphate on another RNA substrate. The preference for the branch-site nucleotide is U > C congruent with A > G, although all four nucleotides are tolerated with useful ligation rates. Nearly all other nucleotides elsewhere in both RNA substrates allow ligation activity, except that the sequence requirement for the RNA strand with the 5'-triphosphate is 5'-pppGA, with 5'-pppGAR (R = purine) preferred. These characteristics permit 6CE8 to prepare branched RNAs of immediate practical interest, such as the proposed branched intermediate of Ty1 retrotransposition. Because this branched RNA has two strands with identical sequence that emerge from the branch site, we developed strategies to control which of the two strands bind with the deoxyribozyme during the branch-forming reaction. The ability to synthesize the proposed branched RNA of Ty1 retrotransposition will allow us to explore this important biochemical pathway in greater detail.

Crystal structures of the antitermination factor NusB from Thermotoga maritima and implications for RNA binding

NusB is a prokaryotic transcription factor involved in antitermination processes, during which it interacts with the boxA portion of the mRNA nut site. Previous studies have shown that NusB exhibits an all-helical fold, and that the protein from Escherichia coli forms monomers, while Mycobacterium tuberculosis NusB is a dimer. The functional significance of NusB dimerization is unknown. We have determined five crystal structures of NusB from Thermotoga maritima. In three crystal forms the protein appeared monomeric, whereas the two other crystal forms contained assemblies, which resembled the M. tuberculosis dimers. In solution, T. maritima NusB could be cross-linked as dimers, but it migrated as a monomer in gel-filtration analyses, suggesting a monomer/dimer equilibrium with a preference for the monomer. Binding to boxA-like RNA sequences could be detected by gel-shift analyses and UV-induced cross-linking. An N-terminal arginine-rich sequence is a probable RNA binding site of the protein, exhibiting aromatic residues as potential stacking partners for the RNA bases. Anions located in various structures support the assignment of this RNA binding site. The proposed RNA binding region is hidden in the subunit interface of dimeric NusB proteins, such as NusB from M. tuberculosis, suggesting that such dimers have to undergo a considerable conformational change or dissociate for engagement with RNA. Therefore, in certain organisms, dimerization may be employed to package NusB in an inactive form until recruitment into antitermination complexes.

Rational modification of a selection strategy leads to deoxyribozymes that create native 3'-5' RNA linkages

We previously used in vitro selection to identify several classes of deoxyribozymes that mediate RNA ligation by attack of a hydroxyl group at a 5'-triphosphate. In these reactions, the nucleophilic hydroxyl group is located at an internal 2'-position of an RNA substrate, leading to 2',5'-branched RNA. To obtain deoxyribozymes that instead create linear 3'-5'-linked (native) RNA, here we strategically modified the selection approach by embedding the nascent ligation junction within an RNA:DNA duplex region. This approach should favor formation of linear rather than branched RNA because the two RNA termini are spatially constrained by Watson-Crick base pairing during the ligation reaction. Furthermore, because native 3'-5' linkages are more stable in a duplex than isomeric non-native 2'-5' linkages, this strategy is predicted to favor the formation of 3'-5' linkages. All of the new deoxyribozymes indeed create only linear 3'-5' RNA, confirming the effectiveness of the rational design. The new deoxyribozymes ligate RNA with k(obs) values up to 0.5 h(-1) at 37 degrees C and 40 mM Mg2+, pH 9.0, with up to 41% yield at 3 h incubation. They require several specific RNA nucleotides on either side of the ligation junction, which may limit their practical generality. These RNA ligase deoxyribozymes are the first that create native 3'-5' RNA linkages, which to date have been highly elusive via other selection approaches.

Structure Determination of Protein⧸RNA Complexes by NMR

Structure determination of protein?RNA complexes in solution provides unique insights into factors that are involved in protein/RNA recognition. Here, we review the methodology used in our laboratory to overcome the challenges of protein?RNA structure determination by nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR). We use as two examples complexes recently solved in our laboratory, the nucleolin RBD12/b2NRE and Rnt1p dsRBD/snR47h complexes. Topics covered are protein and RNA preparation, complex formation, identification of the protein/RNA interface, protein and RNA resonance assignment, intermolecular NOE assignment, and structure calculation and analysis.