The biosynthesis of bacterial and plastidic c-type cytochromes

Overlapping specificities of the mitochondrial cytochrome c and c1 heme lyases

Heme attachment to the apoforms of fungal mitochondrial cytochrome c and c1 requires the activity of cytochrome c and c1 heme lyases (CCHL and CC1HL), which are enzymes with distinct substrate specificity. However, the presence of a single heme lyase in higher eukaryotes is suggestive of broader substrate specificity. Here, we demonstrate that yeast CCHL is active toward the non-cognate substrate apocytochrome c1, i.e. CCHL promotes low levels of apocytochrome c1 conversion to its holoform in the absence of CC1HL. Moreover, that the single human heme lyase also displays a broader cytochrome specificity is evident from its ability to substitute for both yeast CCHL and CC1HL. Multicopy and genetic suppressors of the absence of CC1HL were isolated and their analysis revealed that the activity of CCHL toward cytochrome c1 can be enhanced by: 1) reducing the abundance of the cognate substrate apocytochrome c, 2) increasing the accumulation of CCHL, 3) modifying the substrate-enzyme interaction through point mutations in CCHL or cytochrome c1, or 4) overexpressing Cyc2p, a protein known previously only as a mitochondrial biogenesis factor. Based on the functional interaction of Cyc2p with CCHL and the presence of a putative FAD-binding site in the protein, we hypothesize that Cyc2p controls the redox chemistry of the heme lyase reaction.

Assembly of chloroplast cytochromes b and c

The synthesis of holocytochromes in plastids is a catalyzed process. Several proteins, including plastid CcsA, Ccs1, possibly CcdA and a thioredoxin, plus at least two additional Ccs factors, are required in sub-stoichiometric amounts for the conversion of apocytochromes f and c(6) to their respective holoforms. CcsA, proposed to be a heme delivery factor, and Ccs1, an apoprotein chaperone, are speculated to interact physically in vivo. The formation of holocytochrome b(6) is a multi-step pathway in which at least four, as yet unidentified, Ccb factors are required for association of the b(H) heme. The specific requirement of reduced heme for in vitro synthesis of a cytochrome b(559)-derived holo-beta(2) suggests that cytochrome b synthesis in PSII might also be catalyzed in vivo.

Novel Rhodobacter capsulatus genes required for the biogenesis of various c-type cytochromes

Following chemical mutagenesis and screening for the inability to grow by photosynthesis and the absence of cyt cbb3 oxidase activity, two c-type cytochrome (cyt)-deficient mutants, 771 and K2, of Rhodobacter capsulatus were isolated. Both mutants were completely deficient in all known c-type cyts, and could not be complemented by the previously known cyt c biogenesis genes of R. capsulatus. Complementation of 771 and K2 with a wild-type chromosomal library led to the identification of two novel genes, cycJ and ccdA respectively. The cycJ is highly homologous to ccmE/cycJ, encountered in various Gram-negative species. Unlike in other species, where cycJ is a part of an operon essential for cyt c biogenesis, in R. capsulatus, it is located immediately downstream from argC, involved in arginine biosynthesis. Mutation of its universally conserved histidine residue, which is critical for its proposed haem chaperoning role, to an alanine led to loss of its function. All R. capsulatus cycJ mutants studied so far excrete copious amounts of coproporphyrin and protoporphyrin when grown on enriched media, suggesting that its product is also a component of the haem delivery branch of cyt c biogenesis in this species. In contrast, the R. capsulatus ccdA was homologous to the cyt c biogenesis gene ccdA, found in the gram-positive bacterium Bacillus subtilis, and to the central region of dipZ, encoding a protein disulphide reductase required for cyt c biogenesis in Escherichia coli. Membrane topology of CcdA was established in R. capsulatus using ccdA:phoA and ccdA :lacZ gene fusions. The deduced topology revealed that the two conserved cysteine residues of CcdA are, as predicted, membrane embedded. Mutagenesis of these cysteines showed that both are required for the function of CcdA in cyt c biogenesis. This study demonstrated for the first time that CcdA homologues are also required for cyt c biogenesis in some gram-negative bacteria such as R. capsulatus.

Prototype of a heme chaperone essential for cytochrome c maturation

Heme, the iron-containing cofactor essential for the activity of many enzymes, is incorporated into its target proteins by unknown mechanisms. Here, an Escherichia coli hemoprotein, CcmE, was shown to bind heme in the bacterial periplasm by way of a single covalent bond to a histidine. The heme was then released and delivered to apocytochrome c. Thus, CcmE can be viewed as a heme chaperone guiding heme to its appropriate biological partner and preventing illegitimate complex formation.

Molecular mechanisms of cytochrome c biogenesis: three distinct systems

The past 10 years have heralded remarkable progress in the understanding of the biogenesis of c-type cytochromes. The hallmark of c-type cytochrome synthesis is the covalent ligation of haem vinyl groups to two cysteinyl residues of the apocytochrome (at a Cys-Xxx-Yyy-Cys-His signature motif). From genetic, genomic and biochemical studies, it is clear that three distinct systems have evolved in nature to assemble this ancient protein. In this review, common principles of assembly for all systems and the molecular mechanisms predicted for each system are summarized. Prokaryotes, plant mitochondria and chloroplasts use either system I or II, which are each predicted to use dedicated mechanisms for haem delivery, apocytochrome ushering and thioreduction. Accessory proteins of systems I and II co-ordinate the positioning of these two substrates at the membrane surface for covalent ligation. The third system has evolved specifically in mitochondria of fungi, invertebrates and vertebrates. For system III, a pivotal role is played by an enzyme called cytochrome c haem lyase (CCHL) in the mitochondrial intermembrane space.

A novel pathway for cytochromes c biogenesis in chloroplasts

The cytochromes c are a useful model for the study of the pathways and mechanisms of assembly of the cofactor-containing components of energy transducing membranes. Genetic analyses have identified proteins that are required for the assembly of c-type cytochromes in mitochondria, bacteria and chloroplasts. The components of the pathway operating in fungal and animal mitochondria, i.e. the cytochrome (cyt) c and c1 heme lyases in the intermembrane space, were identified over a decade ago through the study of cytochrome deficiencies in Neurospora crassa and Saccharomyces cerevisiae. More recently, a large number of membrane or membrane-associated components were identified in various alpha- and gamma-proteobacteria as c-type cytochrome assembly factors; they comprise an assembly pathway that is evolutionarily and mechanistically distinct from that in fungal and animal mitochondria. The components function not only in the lyase reaction but also in the delivery and maintenance of the substrates in a state that is suitable for reaction in the bacterial periplasm. Yet a third pathway is required for cytochrome maturation in chloroplasts. Genetic analyses of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii ccs mutants, which are pleiotropically deficient in both the membrane-anchored cytochrome f and the soluble cytochrome c6, revealed a minimum of six loci, plastid ccsA and nuclear CCS1 through CCS5, that are required for the conversion of the chloroplast apocytochromes to their respective holo forms. Sequence analysis of the cloned ccsA and Ccs1 genes indicates that the predicted protein products are integral membrane proteins with homologues in cyanobacteria, some gram-positive bacteria (Bacillus subtilis, Mycobacterium spp.), beta-proteobacteria (Neisseria spp.) and an epsilon-proteobacterium (Helicobacter pylori). CcsA and Ccs1 require each other for accumulation in vivo and are therefore proposed to function in a complex, possibly with the products of some of the other CCS loci. A tryptophan-rich motif, which has been proposed to represent a heme binding site in bacterial cytochrome biogenesis proteins (CcmC and CcmF), is functionally important in plastid CcsA. As is the case for CcmC and CcmF, the tryptophan-rich sequence is predicted to occur in a loop on the p-side of the membrane, where the heme attachment reaction occurs. Conserved histidine residues in the CcsA and Ccs1 may serve as ligands to the heme iron. A multiple alignment of the tryptophan-rich regions of the CcsA-, CcmC- and CcmF-like sequences in the genome databases indicates that they represent three different families.

POSTTRANSLATIONAL ASSEMBLY OF PHOTOSYNTHETIC METALLOPROTEINS

The assembly of chloroplast metalloproteins requires biochemical catalysis. Assembly factors involved in the biosynthesis of metalloproteins might be required to synthesize, chaperone, or transport the cofactor; modify or chaperone the apoprotein; or catalyze cofactor-protein association. Genetic and biochemical approaches have been applied to the study of the assembly of chloroplast iron-sulfur centers, cytochromes, plastocyanin, and the manganese center of photosystem II. These have led to the discovery of NifS-homologues and cysteine desulfhydrase for iron-sulfur center assembly, six loci (CCS1-CCS5, ccsA) for c-type cytochrome assembly, four loci for cytochrome b6 assembly (CCB1-CCB4), the CtpA protease, which is involved in pre-D1 processing, and the PCY2 locus, which is involved in holoplastocyanin accumulation. New assembly factors are likely to be discovered via the study of assembly-defective mutants of Arabidopsis, cyanobacteria, Chlamydomonas, maize, and via the functional analysis of candidate cofactor metabolizing components identified in the genome databases.

Translation of cytochrome f is autoregulated through the 5' untranslated region of petA mRNA in Chlamydomonas chloroplasts

A process that we refer to as control by epistasy of synthesis (CES process) occurs during chloroplast protein biogenesis in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii: the synthesis of some chloroplast-encoded subunits, the CES subunits, is strongly attenuated when some other subunits from the same complex, the dominant subunits, are missing. Herein we investigate the molecular basis of the CES process for the biogenesis of the cytochrome b6f complex and show that negative autoregulation of cytochrome f translation occurs in the absence of other complex subunits. This autoregulation is mediated by an interaction, either direct or indirect, between the 5' untranslated region of petA mRNA, which encodes cytochrome f, and the C-terminal domain of the unassembled protein. This model for the regulation of cytochrome f translation explains both the decreased rate of cytochrome f synthesis in vivo in the absence of its assembly partners and its increase in synthesis when significant accumulation of the C-terminal domain of the protein is prevented. When expressed from a chimeric mRNA containing the atpA 5' untranslated region, cytochrome f no longer showed an assembly-dependent regulation of translation. Conversely, the level of antibiotic resistance conferred by a chimeric petA-aadA-rbcL gene was shown to depend on the state of assembly of cytochrome b6f complexes and on the accumulation of the C-terminal domain of cytochrome f. We discuss the possible ubiquity of the CES process in organellar protein biogenesis.

Molecular genetic identification of a pathway for heme binding to cytochrome b6

Heme binding to cytochrome b6 is resistant, in part, to denaturing conditions that typically destroy the noncovalent interactions between the b hemes and their apoproteins, suggesting that one of two b hemes of holocytochrome b6 is tightly bound to the polypeptide. We exploited this property to define a pathway for the conversion of apo- to holocytochrome b6, and to identify mutants that are blocked at one step of this pathway. Chlamydomonas reinhardtii strains carrying substitutions in either one of the four histidines that coordinate the bh or bl hemes to the apoprotein were created. These mutations resulted in the appearance of distinct immunoreactive species of cytochrome b6, which allowed us to specifically identify cytochrome b6 with altered bh or bl ligation. In gabaculine-treated (i.e. heme-depleted) wild type and site-directed mutant strains, we established that (i) the single immunoreactive band, observed in strains carrying the bl site-directed mutations, corresponds to apocytochrome b6 and (ii) the additional band present in strains carrying bh site-directed mutations corresponds to a bl-heme-dependent intermediate in the formation of holocytochrome b6. Five nuclear mutants (ccb strains) that are defective in holocytochrome b6 formation display a phenotype that is indistinguishable from that of strains carrying site-directed bh ligand mutants. The defect is specific for cytochrome b6 assembly, because the ccb strains can synthesize other b cytochromes and all c-type cytochromes. The ccb strains, which define four nuclear loci (CCB1, CCB2, CCB3, and CCB4), provide the first evidence that a b-type cytochrome requires trans-acting factors for its heme association.

Escherichia coli ccm in-frame deletion mutants can produce periplasmic cytochrome b but not cytochrome c

Escherichia coli CcmA, CcmB and CcmC polypeptides are required for cytochrome c synthesis and are thought to constitute the subunits of an ABC-type transporter as judged from sequence data. Using a periplasmic reporter system based on Bacillus subtilis cytochrome c-550 and E. coli cytochrome b-562 we show that the synthesis of the b-type cytochrome in the periplasm is normal in E. coli ccmA and ccmC in-frame deletion mutants. Mutants deleted for ccmF or ccmG encoding a component of a putative cytochrome c-heme lyase and a membrane bound thioredoxin-like protein, respectively, have the same phenotype. The ccm mutants produce cytochrome c-550 polypeptide, but not holocytochrome c. Taken together the results demonstrate that heme can be transported to the periplasm by a ccm-independent mechanism.

A putative cytochrome c biogenesis gene in Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803

A gene (orf334) with homology to chloroplast ycf5 (ccsA) was isolated from the cyanobacterium Synechocystis PCC 6803. The mRNA level of orf334 decreases in the dark and increases rapidly upon illumination. Transcription is initiated 69 nucleotides upstream of the start site of translation. The deduced amino acid sequence of orf334 has limited identity with bacterial proteins involved in cytochrome c biogenesis. Sequence comparison indicates differing pathways of cytochrome c biogenesis in cyanobacteria/chloroplasts and Gram positive bacteria versus proteobacteria and mitochondria. Insertional inactivation of the orf334 gene gave rise to a heterozygous mutant, i.e. complete absence of the orf334 product seems to be lethal to the cell.

Mutants of Escherichia coli lacking disulphide oxidoreductases DsbA and DsbB cannot synthesise an exogenous monohaem c-type cytochrome except in the presence of disulphide compounds

Absence through mutation of two proteins involved in periplasmic disulphide bond formation, DsbA and DsbB, results in failure of anaerobically grown Escherichia coli to synthesise the holo forms of either its endogenous c-type cytochrome nitrite reductase or exogenous cytochrome c550 from Paracoccus denitrificans. The synthesis of both cytochromes can be restored to the mutants by inclusion in the growth media of compounds containing disulphide bonds, e.g., the oxidised form of glutathione. The results suggest that the attachment of haem to the CXXCH motif of a periplasmic c-type cytochrome may be preceeded by the formation of one or more intra- or intermolecular disulphide bonds involving the cysteine residues of this motif.

Rhodobacter capsulatus CycH: a bipartite gene product with pleiotropic effects on the biogenesis of structurally different c-type cytochromes

While searching for components of the soluble electron carrier (cytochrome c2)-independent photosynthetic (Ps) growth pathway in Rhodobacter capsulatus, a Ps- mutant (FJM13) was isolated from a Ps+ cytochrome c2-strain. This mutant could be complemented to Ps+ growth by cycA encoding the soluble cytochrome c2 but was unable to produce several c-type cytochromes. Only cytochrome c1 of the cytochrome bc1 complex was present in FJM13 cells grown on enriched medium, while cells grown on minimal medium contained at various levels all c-type cytochromes, including the membrane-bound electron carrier cytochrome cy. Complementation of FJM13 by a chromosomal library lacking cycA yielded a DNA fragment which also complemented a previously described Ps- mutant, MT113, known to lack all c-type cytochromes. Deletion and DNA sequence analyses revealed an open reading frame homologous to cycH, involved in cytochrome c biogenesis. The cycH gene product (CycH) is predicted to be a bipartite protein with membrane-associated amino-terminal (CycH1) and periplasmic carboxyl-terminal (CycH2) subdomains. Mutations eliminating CyCH drastically decrease the production or all known c-type cytochromes. However, mutations truncating only its CycH2 subdomain always produce cytochrome c1 and affect the presence of other cytochromes to different degrees in a growth medium-dependent manner. Thus, the subdomain CycH1 is sufficient for the proper maturation of cytochrome c1 which is the only known c-type cytochrome anchored to the cytoplasmic membrane by its carboxyl terminus, while CycH2 is required for efficient biogenesis of other c-type cytochromes. These findings demonstrate that the two subdomains of CycH play different roles in the biogenesis of topologically distinct c-type cytochromes and reconcile the apparently conflicting data previously obtained for other species.

The plastid-encoded ccsA gene is required for heme attachment to chloroplast c-type cytochromes

A chloroplast gene, ycf5, which displays limited sequence identity to bacterial genes (ccl1/cycK) required for the biogenesis of c-type cytochromes, was tested for its function in chloroplast cytochrome biogenesis in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. Targeted inactivation of the ycf5 gene results in a non-photosynthetic phenotype attributable to the absence of c-type cytochromes. The cloned ycf5 gene also complements the phototrophic growth deficiency in strain B6 of C. reinhardtii. B6 is unable to synthesize functional forms of cytochromes f and c6 owing to a chloroplast genome mutation that prevents heme attachment. The selected (phototrophic growth) as well as the unselected (holocytochrome c6 accumulation) phenotypes were restored in complemented strains. The complementing gene, renamed ccsA (for c-type cytochrome synthesis), is expressed in wild-type and B6 cells but is non-functional in B6 owing to an early frameshift mutation. Antibodies raised against the ccsA gene product recognize a 29-kDa protein in C. reinhardtii. The 29-kDa protein is absent in strain B6 but is restored in a spontaneous revertant (B6R) isolated from a culture of B6. Sequence analysis of the ccsA gene in strain B6R indicates that it is a true revertant. We conclude that the ccsA gene is expressed and that it encodes a protein required for heme attachment to c-type cytochromes.

Maturation of pre-apocytochrome f in vivo. A site-directed mutagenesis study in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii

The biosynthesis of cytochrome f is a multistep process which requires processing of the precursor protein and covalent ligation of a c-heme upon membrane insertion of the protein. The crystal structure of a soluble form of cytochrome f has revealed that one axial ligand of the c-heme is provided by the alpha-amino group of Tyr1 generated upon cleavage of the signal sequence from the precursor protein (Martinez S. E., Huang D., Szczepaniak A., Cramer W.A., and Smith J. L. (1994) Structure 2, 95-105). We therefore investigated, by site-directed mutagenesis, the possible interplay between protein processing and heme attachment to cytochrome f in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. These modifications were performed by chloroplast transformation using a petA gene encoding the full-length precursor protein and also a truncated version lacking the C-terminal membrane anchor. We first substituted the two cysteinyl residues responsible for covalent ligation of the c-heme, by a valine and a leucine, and showed that heme binding is not a prerequisite for cytochrome f processing. In another series of experiments, we replaced the consensus cleavage site for the thylakoid processing peptidase, AQA, by an LQL sequence. The resulting transformants were nonphototrophic and displayed delayed processing of the precursor form of cytochrome f, but nonetheless both the precursor and processed forms showed heme binding and assembled in cytochrome b6f complexes. Thus, pre-apocytochrome f adopts a suitable conformation for the cysteinyl residues to be substrates of the heme lyase and pre-holocytochrome f folds in an assembly-competent conformation. In the last series of experiments, we compared the rates of synthesis and degradation of the various forms of cytochrome f in the four types of transformants under study: (i) the C terminus membrane anchor apparently down-regulates the rate of synthesis of cytochrome f and (ii) degradation of misfolded forms of cytochrome f occurs by a proteolytic system intimately associated with the thylakoid membranes.

Escherichia coli genes required for cytochrome c maturation

The so-called aeg-46.5 region of Escherichia coli contains genes whose expression is induced under anaerobic growth conditions in the presence of nitrate or nitrite as the terminal electron acceptor. In this work, we have examined more closely several genes of this cluster, here designated ccmABCDEFGH, that are homologous to two separate Bradyrhizobium japonicum gene clusters required for the biogenesis of c-type cytochromes. A deletion mutant of E. coli which lacked all of these genes was constructed. Maturation of indigenous c-type cytochromes synthesized under anaerobic respiratory conditions, with nitrite, nitrate, or trimethylamine N-oxide as the electron acceptor, was found to be defective in the mutant. The biogenesis of foreign cytochromes, such as the soluble B. japonicum cytochrome c550 and the membrane-bound Bacillus subtilis cytochrome c550, was also investigated. None of these cytochromes was synthesized in its mature form when expressed in the mutant, as opposed to the situation in the wild type. The results suggest that the E. coli ccm gene cluster present in the aeg-46.5 region is required for a general pathway involved in cytochrome c maturation.

Biosynthesis of cytochrome f in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii: analysis of the pathway in gabaculine-treated cells and in the heme attachment mutant B6

Chlamydomonas reinhardtii uses two c-type cytochromes for photosynthetic electron transfer: the thylakoid membrane-bound cytochrome f of the cytochrome b6f complex and the soluble cytochrome c6. Previously, a class of photosynthesis-minus, acetate-requiring mutants was identified which were deficient in both c-type cytochromes, and biochemical analyses of cytochrome c6 biosynthesis in these strains indicated that they were each blocked at the step of heme attachment to apocytochrome c6. In order to demonstrate that the deficiency in cytochrome f results from the same biochemical and genetic defect, cytochrome f biosynthesis was examined in the B6 mutant (a representative of this phenotypic class) and in spontaneous suppressor strains derived from B6. Pulse-radiolabeling experiments show that B6 synthesizes a form of cytochrome f that is rapidly degraded in vivo. This polypeptide is membrane associated and migrates with an electrophoretic mobility identical to that of standard apocytochrome f produced in vitro but slightly greater than that of standard holocytochrome f produced in vivo by wild-type cells. These findings suggest that the B6 strain is unable to convert apocytochrome f to holocytochrome f and that apocytochrome f is unstable in vivo. In the suppressed strains, accumulation of both holocytochrome f and holocytochrome c6 is restored. One suppressor mutation (strain B6R) displays uniparental inheritance whereas another (B6T3) displays Mendelian inheritance. In both cases, the three phenotypes, photosynthesis-plus, b6f+ and cyt c6+ co-segregate in genetic crosses. This study therefore confirms that the dual cyt b6f-/cytc6- deficiency in B6 results from a single mutation that affects a step in holocytochrome formation that is common to the biosynthetic pathways of both plastidic c-type cytochromes. The study also confirms that pre-apocytochrome f synthesis, processing and association with the membrane is not dependent on heme attachment. Synthesis of cytochrome f does, however, appear to be dependent on heme availability. In cells depleted of tetrapyrrole pathway intermediates by gabaculine treatment, cytochrome f synthesis was significantly reduced. Since gabaculine treatment did not affect the stability of cytochrome f nor the accumulation of cytochrome f-encoding transcripts, the reduction is attributed to post-transcriptional regulation of preapocytochrome f synthesis via a pathway that is sensitive to the availability of heme or a tetrapyrrole pathway intermediate.