Chloroplast encoded thioredoxin genes in the red algae Porphyra yezoensis and Griffithsia pacifica: evolutionary implications

Independent evolution of the thioredoxin system in photosynthetic Paulinella species

Redox regulation allows phytoplankton to monitor and stabilize metabolic pathways under changing conditions¹. In plastids, the thioredoxin (TRX) system is linked to photosynthetic electron transport and fine tuning of metabolic pathways to fluctuating light levels. Expansion of the number of redox signal transmitters and their protein targets, as seen in plants, is believed to increase cell robustness². In this study, we searched for genes related to redox regulation in the photosynthetic amoeba Paulinella micropora KR01 (hereafter, KR01). The genus Paulinella includes testate filose amoebae, in which a single clade acquired a photosynthetic organelle, the chromatophore, from an alpha-cyanobacterial donor³. This independent primary endosymbiosis occurred relatively recently (∼124 million years ago) when compared to Archaeplastida (>1 billion years ago), making photosynthetic Paulinella a valuable model for studying the early stages of primary endosymbiosis⁴. Our comparative analysis demonstrates that this lineage has evolved a TRX system similar to other algae, relying, however, on genes with diverse phylogenetic origins (including the endosymbiont, host, bacteria, and red algae). One TRX of eukaryotic provenance is targeted to the chromatophore, implicating host-endosymbiont coordination of redox regulation. A chromatophore-targeted glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase (G6PDH) of red algal origin suggests that Paulinella exploited the existing redox regulation system in Archaeplastida to foster integration. Our study elucidates the independent evolution of the TRX system in photosynthetic Paulinella, whose parts derive from the existing genetic toolkit in diverse organisms.

Comparative genomic study of the thioredoxin family in photosynthetic organisms with emphasis on Populus trichocarpa

The recent genome sequencing of Populus trichocarpa and Vitis vinifera, two models of woody plants, of Sorghum bicolor, a model of monocot using C4 metabolism, and of the moss Physcomitrella patens, together with the availability of photosynthetic organism genomes allows performance of a comparative genomic study with organisms having different ways of life, reproduction modes, biological traits, and physiologies. Thioredoxins (Trxs) are small ubiquitous proteins involved in the reduction of disulfide bridges in a variety of target enzymes present in all sub-cellular compartments and involved in many biochemical reactions. The genes coding for these enzymes have been identified in these newly sequenced genomes and annotated. The gene content, organization and distribution were compared to other photosynthetic organisms, leading to a refined classification. This analysis revealed that higher plants and bryophytes have a more complex family compared to algae and cyanobacteria and to non-photosynthetic organisms, since poplar exhibits 49 genes coding for typical and atypical thioredoxins and thioredoxin reductases, namely one-third more than monocots such as Oryza sativa and S. bicolor. The higher number of Trxs in poplar is partially explained by gene duplication in the Trx m, h, and nucleoredoxin classes. Particular attention was paid to poplar genes with emphasis on Trx-like classes called Clot, thioredoxin-like, thioredoxins of the lilium type and nucleoredoxins, which were not described in depth in previous genomic studies.

The ferredoxin/thioredoxin system of oxygenic photosynthesis

Forty years ago, ferredoxin (Fdx) was shown to activate fructose 1,6-bisphosphatase in illuminated chloroplast preparations, thereby laying the foundation for the field now known as "redox biology." Enzyme activation was later shown to require the ubiquitous protein thioredoxin (Trx), reduced photosynthetically by Fdx via an enzyme then unknown-ferredoxin:thioredoxin reductase (FTR). These proteins, Fdx, FTR, and Trx, constitute a regulatory ensemble, the "Fdx/Trx system." The redox biology field has since grown beyond all expectations and now embraces a spectrum of processes throughout biology. Progress has been notable with plants that possess not only the plastid Fdx/Trx system, but also the earlier known NADP/Trx system in the cytosol, endoplasmic reticulum, and mitochondria. Plants contain at least 19 types of Trx (nine in chloroplasts). In this review, we focus on the structure and mechanism of action of members of the photosynthetic Fdx/Trx system and on biochemical processes linked to Trx. We also summarize recent evidence that extends the Fdx/Trx system to amyloplasts-heterotrophic plastids functional in the biosynthesis of starch and other cell components. The review highlights the plant as a model system to uncover principles of redox biology that apply to other organisms.

PLANT THIOREDOXIN SYSTEMS REVISITED

Thioredoxins, the ubiquitous small proteins with a redox active disulfide bridge, are important regulatory elements in plant metabolism. Initially recognized as regulatory proteins in the reversible light activation of key photosynthetic enzymes, they have subsequently been found in the cytoplasm and in mitochondria. The various plant thioredoxins are different in structure and function. Depending on their intracellular location they are reduced enzymatically by an NADP-dependent or by a ferredoxin (light)-dependent reductase and transmit the regulatory signal to selected target enzymes through disulfide/dithiol interchange reactions. In this review we summarize recent developments that have provided new insights into the structures of several components and into the mechanism of action of the thioredoxin systems in plants.

Thioredoxins: structure and function in plant cells

Thioredoxins are ubiquitous small-molecular-weight proteins (typically 100-120 amino-acid residues) containing an extremely reactive disulphide bridge with a highly conserved sequence -Cys-Gly(Ala/Pro)-Pro-Cys-. In bacteria and animal cells, thioredoxins participate in multiple reactions which require reduction of disulphide bonds on selected target proteins/ enzymes. There is now ample biochemical evidence that thioredoxins exert very specific functions in plants, the best documented being the redox regulation of chloroplast enzymes. Another area in which thioredoxins are believed to play a prominent role is in reserve protein mobilization during the process of germination. It has been discovered that thioredoxins constitute a large multigene family in plants with different-subcellular localizations, a unique feature in living cells so far. Evolutionary studies based on these molecules will be discussed, as well as the available biochemical and genetic evidence related to their functions in plant cells. Eukaryotic photosynthetic plant cells are also unique in that they possess two different reducing systems, one extrachloroplastic dependent on NADPH as an electron donor, and the other one chloroplastic, dependent on photoreduced ferredoxin. This review will examine in detail the latest progresses in the area of thioredoxin structural biology in plants, this protein being an excellent model for this purpose. The structural features of the reducing enzymes ferredoxin thioredoxin reductase and NADPH thioredoxin reductase will also be described. The properties of the target enzymes known so far in plants will be detailed with special emphasis on the structural features which make them redox regulatory. Based on sequence analysis, evidence will be presented that redox regulation of enzymes of the biosynthetic pathways first appeared in cyanobacteria possibly as a way to cope with the oxidants produced by oxygenic photosynthesis. It became more elaborate in the chloroplasts of higher plants where a co-ordinated functioning of the chloroplastic and extra chloroplastic metabolisms is required. CONTENTS Summary 543 I. Introduction 544 II. Thioredoxins from photosynthetic organisms as a structural model 545 III. Physiological functions 552 IV. The thioredoxin reduction systems 556 V. Structural aspects of target enzymes 558 VI. Concluding remarks 563 Acknowledgements 564 References 564.

Intron position as an evolutionary marker of thioredoxins and thioredoxin domains

In contrast to prokaryotes, which typically possess one thioredoxin gene per genome, three different thioredoxin types have been described in higher plants. All are encoded by nuclear genes, but thioredoxins m and f are chloroplastic while thioredoxins h have no transit peptide and are probably cytoplasmic. We have cloned and sequenced Arabidopsis thaliana genomic fragments encoding the five previously described thioredoxins h, as well as a sixth gene encoding a new thioredoxin h. In spite of the high divergence of the sequences, five of them possess two introns at positions identical to the previously sequenced tobacco thioredoxin h gene, while a single one has only the first intron. The recently published sequence of Chlamydomonas thioredoxin h shows three introns, two at the same positions as in higher plants. This strongly suggests a common origin for all cytoplasmic thioredoxins of plants and green algae. In addition, we have cloned and sequenced pea DNA genomic fragments encoding thioredoxins m and f. The thioredoxin m sequence shows only one intron between the regions encoding the transit peptide and the mature protein, supporting the prokaryotic origin of this sequence and suggesting that its association with the transit peptide has been facilitated by exon shuffling. In contrast, the thioredoxin f sequence shows two introns, one at the same position as an intron in various plant and animal thioredoxins and the second at the same position as an intron in thioredoxin domains of disulfide isomerases. This strongly supports the hypothesis of a eukaryotic origin for chloroplastic thioredoxin f.

Crystal structure of thioredoxin-2 from Anabaena

BACKGROUND

Thioredoxins are ubiquitous proteins that serve as reducing agents and general protein disulfide reductases. The structures of thioredoxins from a number of species, including man and Escherichia coli, are known. Cyanobacteria, such as Anabaena, contain two thioredoxins that exhibit very different activities with target enzymes and share little sequence similarity. Thioredoxin-2 (Trx-2) from Anabaena resembles chloroplast type-f thioredoxin in its activities and the two proteins may be evolutionarily related. We have undertaken structural studies of Trx-2 in order to gain insights into the structure/function relationships of thioredoxins.

RESULTS

Anabaena Trx-2, like E. coli thioredoxin, consists of a five-stranded beta sheet core surrounded by four alpha helices. The active site includes a conserved disulfide ring (in the sequence 31WCGPC35). An aspartate (E. coli) to tyrosine (Trx-2) substitution alters the position of this disulfide ring relative to the central pleated sheet. However, loss of this conserved aspartate does not affect the disulfide geometry. In the Trx-2 crystals, the N-terminal residues make extensive contacts with a symmetry-related molecule with hydrogen bonds to residues 74-76 mimicking thioredoxin-protein interactions.

CONCLUSIONS

The overall three-dimensional structure of Trx-2 is similar to E. coli thioredoxin and other related disulfide oxido-reductases. Single amino acid substitutions around the protein interaction area probably account for the unusual enzymatic activities of Trx-2 and its ability to discriminate between substrate and non-substrate peptides.

Chlamydomonas reinhardtii thioredoxins: structure of the genes coding for the chloroplastic m and cytosolic h isoforms; expression in Escherichia coli of the recombinant proteins, purification and biochemical properties

Based on known amino acid sequences, probes have been generated by PCR and used for the subsequent isolation of cDNAs and genes coding for two thioredoxins (m and h) of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. Thioredoxin m, a chloroplastic protein, is encoded as a preprotein of 140 amino acids (15,101 Da) containing a transit peptide of 34 amino acids with a very high content of Ala and Arg residues. The sequence for thioredoxin h codes for a 113 amino acid protein with a molecular mass of 11,817 Da and no signal sequence. The thioredoxin m gene contains a single intron and seems to be more archaic in structure than the thioredoxin h gene, which is split into 4 exons. The cDNA sequences encoding C. reinhardtii thioredoxins m and h have been integrated into the pET-3d expression vector, which permits efficient production of proteins in Escherichia coli cells. A high expression level of recombinant thioredoxins was obtained (up to 50 mg/l culture). This has allowed us to study the biochemical/biophysical properties of the two recombinant proteins. Interestingly, while the m-type thioredoxin was found to have characteristics very close to the ones of prokaryotic thioredoxins, the h-type thioredoxin was quite different with respect to its kinetic behaviour and, most strikingly, its heat denaturation properties.