Autoimmune diabetes and the germ theory of disease

The fallacy of reduction

The "accelerator hypothesis" has made a significant impact on research into the etiology of type 1 diabetes. Some, but not all prospective studies have confirmed a weak association between insulin resistance and faster progression to diabetes among persons with advanced islet autoimmunity. However, there is hardly any evidence that insulin resistance can cause development of islet autoimmunity, thus be responsible for the ongoing pandemic of type 1 diabetes in children.

Bridging epidemiology and demography: theories and themes

Epidemiology and demography, although both encumbering several theoretical constructs, are generally applied, problem-solving disciplines concerned with the nature and trajectories of defined groups. There are differences between the two disciplines in substantive interests and methodological traditions, however both have comprehensive perspectives and both are deeply concerned with the health, social, and economic well-being of human populations. One way to promote productive interdisciplinary research is to apply or develop scientific theories that exploit the complementary interests and methods of the two disciplines. Several candidate theories and themes are suggested here, including (1) the life course approach as applied to the biology of longevity; (2) the "modernized" Malthusian dilemma; (3) the demographic transition within developing countries; (4) the theory of evolution and its social and biological implications; (5) reciprocal effects of ecological and environmental characteristics on population health and well-being; and (6) systems theory as an approach to population complexity. Other approaches to fostering interdisciplinary investigation between these disciplines include joint course work, specifically targeted research funding initiatives and collaborative development of new population theory. The latter may be particularly important from several perspectives: uniting disciplines to jointly approach common and important scientific problems, providing existing frameworks with which to generate new scientific questions, and promoting enhanced scientific rigor by more tightly linking methods with hypotheses.

Hypothesis. Bystanders or bad seeds? Many autoimmune-target cells may be transforming to cancer and signalling "danger" to the immune system

Autoimmune-target cells in autoimmune disease (AID) are usually construed as constitutionally normal healthy cells. A related assumption is that other cells in the body of AID patients, except for certain immunocytes, are healthy cells. An implication of that view is that any systemic pathology in organ-specific AID is related to metabolic derangements secondary to tissue destruction. However, much data on target and other cells in AID suggest widespread primary cellular defects. In insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM), for example, many "complications" such as atherosclerosis, premature arterial stiffening, senescence of fibroblasts in vitro, and exuberant growth of smooth muscle and mesangial cells in vivo are not strictly attributable to glucose elevation. Also unexplained is the similar appearance of IDDM beta-cells and cells from insulinoma and why the prodromal phase of IDDM has many insulinoma-like features. While AID target cells have often been likened to neoplastic cells, investigators have rarely explored the possibility that autoimmunity in AID is fundamentally antineoplastic. This is likely because the dominant ideas in oncology and immunology-somatic mutation and clonal deletion, respectively-have prevented explanations for how normal immunity could detect transforming cells not expressing non-self antigens. New and less conventional theories of cancer and immunity have facilitated such an explanation. I use Rubin's "epigenetic" aging model of carcinogenesis and Matzinger's "danger" model of immunity to integrate the immunological and oncological sides of AID. In particular, I postulate that individuals suffering from AID have inherited many foci of prematurely aging cells. Those inherently damaged cells adapt to in vivo challenges by beginning to transform into cancer cells. However, as long as those stressed cells have not fully transformed, they will continue to signal "danger" to the innate immune system. The clinical outcome of that struggle between incipient neoplasia and immunity will vary depending upon the degree of tumor-proneness and resistance of the individual. Borrowing from cancer geneticist Henry Lynch, I postulate that tumor-resistance is inherited as a quantitative polygenic trait in direct proportion to tumor-proneness. I further contend that tumor-proneness and immunity are linked polygenic traits such that the greater one's tumor-proneness, the more powerful his/her antitumor immunity. I point to the shared DNA repair deficiency of certain cancer-prone syndromes and HLA-linked AID, their occasional co-occurrence, and their demonstrably exceptional immunity against solid tumors. I propose that HLA-linked AID constitute "chronic hypersensitivity syndromes" due to immunity's largely hidden battle to suppress multiple incipient neoplastic microfoci. Much of the physiopathology of AID is explicable as a sustained systemic response to threatened neoplastic transformation.

The molecular specificity of insulin autoantibodies

Insulin autoantibodies (IAA) are one of several markers for Type I (autoimmune) diabetes, but alone deserve special attention. Unlike the other markers, their ligand is unique to the beta cell. IAA are the first markers to appear during the symptomless period which precedes diabetes and they are present in the vast majority of young children destined to develop diabetes. The primary and tertiary structures of insulin have been known for decades. Binding studies with insulin variants have shown epitope restriction that can distinguish Type 1 diabetes-predictive from non-predictive IAA-positive sera, thereby improving specificity for the test. With two major international Type 1 diabetes prevention trials underway, there is a pressing need to refine markers that reliably indicate the presence of, and remission from, autoimmune insulitis. The binding regions of antibodies are assembled from three multi-gene families, and some of their diversity derives from random mutation during their antigen-driven maturation. There is evidence that mature IAA derive from germline-encoded 'natural' antibodies, and that the gene segments utilised by IAA may be influenced by clinical context. Monoclonal anti-idiotypic (anti-Id) antibodies can serve as probes for antibody variable region determinants, and antibodies to the different epitopes of beef and porcine insulins have already been analysed with monoclonal reagents. Used as antibodies in a radioimmunoassay format, monoclonal anti-Ids will identify and measure autoantibody idiotopes as if they were ligands. The challenge now is to replace the conventional radiobinding assays for IAA, which only detect and titrate, with radioimmunoassays that can be standardised in absolute units. There is sufficient evidence for the existence of Type 1 diabetes-predictive IAA idiotopes to justify the development of idiotope-specific radioimmunoassays which ignore Type 1 diabetes-unrelated IAA.

Insulin secretion by pancreas of athymic mice injected with peripheral mononuclear cells from insulin-dependent diabetic patients

We studied the effect of peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMNC) from insulin-dependent diabetic (IDDM) children on the insulin secretion pattern of the pancreas from recipient athymic mice. PBMNC from healthy controls or IDDM patients in different stages of disease were injected into athymic mice. PBMNC from newly diagnosed IDDM children elicited basal nonfasting hyperglycemia and in vitro inhibition of the first and second phases of glucose-stimulated insulin secretion in recipient mice. Animals injected with cells from chronically IDDM children showed normoglycemia, abnormal tolerance to glucose, and inhibition of first-phase insulin secretion. Mitomycin C treatment of MNC from IDDM patients abolished insulin secretion inhibition in recipient mice. PBMNC from newly diagnosed and chronically IDDM patients showed positive anti-beta-cell cellular immune aggression. Mice injected with cells from patients during the remission period showed normoglycemia and no alteration of insulin secretion patterns. When relapsed to their former clinical stage, injection of the cells significantly inhibited first-phase glucose-induced insulin secretion in recipients. PBMNC from newly diagnosed IDDM patients were found to migrate to the pancreas of recipient mice preferably as compared with cells from controls. Cells from chronically IDDM patients cultured with concanavalin A (Con A) increased insulin secretion inhibition; despite this, cells from children during the remission period cultured with Con A failed to modify insulin secretion in recipients. These results show that injection of PBMNC from diabetic patients leads to insulin secretion impairment in recipient mice pancreas, and provide a basis for the study of mechanisms involved in the onset and modulation of anti-beta-cell cellular immune aggression induced by human PBMNC.

Islet cell antibodies (ICA), insulin autoantibodies (IAA), islet cell surface antibodies (ICSA) and C-peptide in 1031 school children in a population with a high background incidence of IDDM

Islet cell antibodies (ICA), insulin autoantibodies (IAA) and islet cell surface antibodies (ICSA) together with C-peptide were determined in 1031 healthy schoolchildren to evaluate the frequency of autoimmune reactions towards endocrine pancreas and its relation to insulin secretion in non-diabetic children. The prevalence of ICA (levels > 6 JDF units) was 1.4% (14/1012) while 44 children (4.3%) were ICSA-positive and 40 (4%) had IAA. Girls had higher titres of ICSA than boys. Young children (7-8 years) more often had IAA than 12-13-year-old children who, however, had ICA three times more often than the young children. There were no clear associations between the different antibodies. Of the children, 2.4% had very low post-prandial serum C-peptide values (< or = 0.25 nmol/l). Serum C-peptide was higher in girls than in boys (P < 0.001) and in older children than in younger (P < 0.001). Girls with low levels of ICA had high C-peptide values, while girls with high ICA titers had low C-peptide values, the latter perhaps indicating partial beta cell loss. IAA and ICSA were not related to C-peptide values but both positive ICSA and high C-peptide values were most common in the autumn (P < 0.02 and P < 0.0001, respectively). One of the ICA-positive children developed diabetes in 1991, 4 years after the blood sample was taken. Since after 5 years only one of the children has developed IDDM, it can be concluded autoimmune reactions towards endocrine pancreas and insulin may occur in many children without the development of manifest diabetes. Those with high ICA titers may have lost so many beta cells that their insulin secretion is affected, which in some cases might lead to diabetes many years later.