Quantitative analysis of GABA-immunoreactive synapses in the inner plexiform layer of the Bufo marinus retina: identification of direct output to ganglion cells and contacts with dopaminergic amacrine cells

Ionotropic GABA Receptors and Distal Retinal ON and OFF Responses

In the vertebrate retina, visual signals are segregated into parallel ON and OFF pathways, which provide information for light increments and decrements. The segregation is first evident at the level of the ON and OFF bipolar cells in distal retina. The activity of large populations of ON and OFF bipolar cells is reflected in the b- and d-waves of the diffuse electroretinogram (ERG). The role of gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA), acting through ionotropic GABA receptors in shaping the ON and OFF responses in distal retina, is a matter of debate. This review summarized current knowledge about the types of the GABAergic neurons and ionotropic GABA receptors in the retina as well as the effects of GABA and specific GABAA and GABAC receptor antagonists on the activity of the ON and OFF bipolar cells in both nonmammalian and mammalian retina. Special emphasis is put on the effects on b- and d-waves of the ERG as a useful tool for assessment of the overall function of distal retinal ON and OFF channels. The role of GABAergic system in establishing the ON-OFF asymmetry concerning the time course and absolute and relative sensitivity of the ERG responses under different conditions of light adaptation in amphibian retina is also discussed.

Synaptic organization of GABAergic amacrine cells in the salamander retina

The synaptic organization of GABA-immunoreactive (GABA-IR) amacrine cells in the inner plexiform layer (IPL) of salamander retina was studied with the use of postembedding immuno-electron microscopy. A total of 457 GABA-IR amacrine synapses, with identified postsynaptic elements, were analyzed on photomontages of electron micrographs covering 3,618 microm2 of the IPL. GABA-IR amacrine synapses were distributed throughout the IPL, with a small peak at the proximal margin of sublamina a. The majority of the output targets (81%) were GABA(-) neurons. Most of the contacts were simple synapses with one postsynaptic element identified as a process of an amacrine cell (55%), bipolar cell (19%) or ganglion cell (26%), and serial synapses were very rare. Of the 89 postsynaptic bipolar terminals, 63% participated in a reciprocal feedback synapse with the same presynaptic GABA-IR amacrine profile. There appeared to be no preference between GABA-IR amacrine contacts with rod- or cone-dominated bipolar cells (9.1% vs. 8.9%) or in the total number of amacrine synapses in sublaminas a and b (52% vs. 47%). The preponderance of amacrine cell input to bipolar cells in the OFF layer was derived from GABA-IR cells. These findings provide ultrastructural support to the existing physiological studies regarding the functional roles of the GABAergic amacrine cells in this species. Our results have added to the data base demonstrating that, in contrast to mammals, GABA-IR amacrine cells in amphibians and other nonmammals contact other amacrine cells more frequently, suggesting greater involvement of GABAergic amacrine cells in modulating lateral inhibitory pathways.

Differential synaptic organization of GABAergic bipolar cells and non-GABAergic (glutamatergic) bipolar cells in the tiger salamander retina

The synaptic organizations of gamma-aminobutyric acid-immunoreactive (GABA-IR, GABAergic) and non-GABA-IR (non-IR, glutamatergic) bipolar cells in salamander retina were compared by postembedding immunoelectron microscopy. A total of 238 presynaptic bipolar cell synapses were studied; 61 were GABA-IR and 177 were non-IR. Both groups were similar in that (1). they made asymmetrical ribbon synapses as well as asymmetrical non-ribbon synapses; (2). they made ribbon synapses at dyads, triads, and monads; and (3). the vast majority of ribbon synapses ( approximately 90%) were with dyads. The differences were that synapses of GABA-IR bipolar cells had a higher proportion of (1). direct contact with ganglion cells, (2). non-ribbon synapses, (3). output to GABA-IR amacrine cells, and (4). output in sublamina a. Overall, the output of GABA-IR ribbons was equally split between amacrine and ganglion cell processes, whereas for non-IR ribbons, it was approximately 2:1 in favor of amacrine cells. The ribbon:non-ribbon synapse ratio was approximately 1.2:1 (33:28) for GABA-IR but approximately 2:1 (118:59) for non-IR terminals. Thus, GABA-IR bipolar cells made more direct contacts with ganglion cells and used a higher proportion of non-ribbon synapses. GABA-IR dyads were more likely to contact GABA-IR amacrine profiles (52% vs. 38%). Finally, GABA-IR ribbon synapses were more common in sublamina a than sublamina b (2:1), whereas non-IR synapses were equally present in sublaminas a and b. This differential targeting of ganglion cells and amacrine cells in the OFF vs. ON layers indicates a difference in the role of bipolar cells in the generation of receptive field properties, depending on whether or not they use GABA as well as glutamate for their transmitter.

Structure and function of photoreceptor and second-order cell mosaics in the retina of Xenopus

The structure, physiology, synaptology, and neurochemistry of photoreceptors and second-order (horizontal and bipolar) cells of Xenopus laevis retina is reviewed. Rods represent 53% of the photoreceptors; the majority (97%) are green light-sensitive. Cones belong to large long-wavelength-sensitive (86%), large short-wavelength-sensitive (10%), and miniature ultraviolet wavelength-sensitive (4%) groups. Photoreceptors release glutamate tonically in darkness, hyperpolarize upon light stimulation and their transmitter release decreases. Photoreceptors form ribbon synapses with second-order cells where postsynaptic elements are organized into triads. Their overall adaptational status is regulated by ambient light conditions and set by the extracellular dopamine concentration. The activity of photoreceptors is under circadian control and is independent of the central body clock. Bipolar cell density is about 6000 cells/mm2 They receive mixed inputs from rods and cones. Some bipolar cell types violate the rule of ON-OFF segregation, giving off terminal branches in both sublayers of the inner plexiform layer. The majority of them contain glutamate, a small fraction is GABA-positive and accumulates serotonin. Luminosity-type horizontal cells are more frequent (approximately 1,000 cells/mm2) than chromaticity cells (approximately 450 cells/mm2). The dendritic field size of the latter type was threefold bigger than that of the former. Luminosity cells contact all photoreceptor types, whereas chromatic cells receive their inputs from the short-wavelength-sensitive cones and rods. Luminosity cells are involved in generating depolarizing responses in chromatic horizontal cells by red light stimulation which form multiple synapses with blue-light-sensitive cones. Calculations indicate that convergence ratios in Xenopus are similar to those in central retinal regions of mammals, predicting comparable spatial resolution.

Amacrine cells of the anuran retina: morphology, chemical neuroanatomy, and physiology

Amacrine cells are third-order retinal interneurons, projecting their processes into the inner plexiform layer. Historically, they were not considered as neurons first. By the middle of the 20th century, their neuronal nature was confirmed, and their enormous diversity established. Amacrine cells have been most successfully subdivided into morphological categories based on two parameters: diameter of the dendritic field and ramification pattern in the inner plexiform layer. Works combining anatomy, physiology, and neurochemistry are scarce and in the case of the anuran retina, the situation is even worse. Correlation between morphology, neurochemistry, and physiology is little studied. Here we try to build up a database and pinpoint some of the missing data. Obtaining those could help to better understand retinal function. Sporadic attempts did not make it possible to develop a comprehensive catalog of morphologically distinct amacrine cell types in the anuran retina. The number of morphologically identified amacrine cells currently stands at 16. The list of neurochemically identified distinct cell types can be given as follows: five types GABA-containing cell types with secondary markers and at least one without; two glycinergic cell types and one interplexiform cell where glycine colocalizes with somatostatin; one dopaminergic amacrine cell and also a variant of this with interplexiform morphology; two types of serotoninergic cells; three NADPHdiaphorase-positive cells, one substance P-positive cell type without identified second marker; one CCK-positive cell type without identified second marker and the calbindin positive cells (at least one but potentially more types). This adds up to 19 cell types, out of which two are interplexiform in character. This is more than that could be identified by purely morphological means. Out of Cajal's original 13 amacrine cell types described in the frog retina, 5 parallel unequivocally with neurons defined by neurochemistry. Three others have one close match each, but their exact identity is uncertain. The remaining amacrine cells have more than one potential matches. At the same time, on one hand the amacrine cell named two-layered by Cajal so far has no match among the neurochemically identified amacrine cells. On the other hand, the interplexiform subtype of the dopaminergic cell, the somatostatin-containing glycinergic interplexiform cell, the starburst cell, and the bistratified neuropeptide Y-immunoreactive cell have no match among Cajal's cells. All in all, the number of known amacrine and interplexiform cells now stands at at least 21 in the anuran retina. Physiological characterization of amacrine cells shows that their general features seem to be rather similar to those described in tiger salamander retina. In Xenopus retina, morphologically and physiologically identified amacrine cells responded to light stimulation most frequently with ON-OFF characteristics. Immunhistochemical identification of the recorded and dye injected cells showed that amacrine cells of the "same physiological type" might have different morphology. In other words, amacrine cells with different morphology can respond similarly to illumination. Even so, small differences between almost identical responses may reflect that the cell they stem from indeed belongs to different cell types.

Synaptology of the inner plexiform layer in the anuran retina

The inner plexiform layer of the retina is a synaptic layer mostly devoid of perikarya. It contains the processes of three major neuron types: the bipolar cells, which carry information from the photoreceptors, the ganglion cells, which are the output elements of the retina, and the amacrine cells, which are able to influence the communication between the former two. Since amacrine cells are the most diverse retinal neurons, they are in a position to carve out and delineate the neural circuits of the inner retina. The aim of this review is to offer a summary of findings related to the general synaptology of the inner retina in frogs and also to provide some insight into the synaptic organization of neurochemically identified amacrine cells. The main conclusions of this paper are as follows: (i) Most contacts are formed between amacrine cells. (2) Direct bipolar to ganglion cell synapses exist, but are rare in the anuran retina. (3) All neurochemically identified amacrine cell types receive inputs from bipolar cells, but not all of them form reciprocal contacts with bipolar cell axon terminals. (4) A major inhibitory transmitter, gamma-aminobutyric acid, is involved in more than 50% of the synapses. Since contacts between inhibitory elements were often observed, disinhibitory circuits must also play a role in retinal information processing. (5) Reciprocal relationship between dopaminergic and gamma-aminobutyric acid-containing cells have been confirmed. Similar situation was observed in case of serotoninergic and gamma-aminobutyric acid-positive elements. No contacts were verified between serotoninergic and dopaminergic elements. (6) Both monoamine- and neuropeptide-containing amacrine cells establish direct contacts with ganglion cell dendrites, providing a morphological basis for neuromodulatory influence on the output elements of the retina. Unfortunately, only a handful of studies have been carried out to identify the synaptic connections between neurochemically identified cells in the anuran retina. Double-label studies at the electron microscope level to reveal the synaptic relationship of cell populations containing two different transmitters/modulators are extremely rare. Further insight into retinal synaptic circuitries could be gained with a combination of electrophysiology and morphology at the electron microscopic level. These studies must also involve identification of the transmitter receptors on identified cell types. Only after this step can the function of different synaptic circuitries be better approximated.

Anatomical and electrophysiological evidence for GABAergic bipolar cells in tiger salamander retina

Our previous work showed that about 12% of bipolar cells in salamander retina synthesize and take up gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA), are GABA transporter (GAT)-immunoreactive, and respond with a GAT current to extracellularly applied GABA, suggesting that these bipolar cells use GABA, in addition to glutamate, as a neurotransmitter. Further support for this idea was obtained in this study by use of immunogold electron microscopy and whole-cell patch clamp electrophysiology. Ultrastructural analysis showed that amacrine cell and ganglion cell processes were postsynaptic to GABA-immunoreactive synapses made by bipolar cell axon terminals. Whole-cell recordings were obtained from amacrine and ganglion cells in response to activation of bipolar cells by puffing KCl at their dendrites in the outer plexiform layer. Inhibitory postsynaptic currents were observed in several third order neurons, even after blocking the excitatory postsynaptic responses, generated in the inner plexiform layer, with a combined application of NMDA and non-NMDA receptor antagonists, AP-5 and CNQX. These ultrastructural and electrophysiological data support our previous neurochemical results, and suggest that the retinal through-information pathway in salamander includes both inhibitory GABAergic as well as excitatory glutamatergic synaptic mechanisms.

Two groups of TH-like immunoreactive neurons in the frog (Rana pipiens) retina

The morphology and distribution of TH-like immunoreactive (TH-IR) cells in the retina of Rana pipiens were studied in retinal whole mounts and in radial and horizontal sections. A large majority (96%) of the immunoreactive cells were found in the inner nuclear layer while a few cells were found in the ganglion cell layer. All TH-IR cells had round to oval somata with average diameter of 10 microm. The 2-4 primary processes of these cells distributed extensively to sublamina 1 of the inner plexiform layer (IPL) and sparsely to sublamina 5. Two groups of TH-IR cells were distinguished: one, designated thin cells, had only thin (<2 microm diameter) primary processes; the second, designated thick cells, had one or more primary processes with diameter(s) exceeding 2 microm for a distance of 5 microm or more from the soma. The thin cells did not significantly differ from the thick cells in soma diameter, number of primary processes, horizontal spread of processes or vertical lamination of processes. Nearest neighbor analyses of the two types revealed that the population of TH-IR cells (thick and thin together) have an orderly distribution while the thick cells alone are more randomly distributed, indicating that the thick cells do not comprise a functional population. The total number of TH-IR cells varied between retinas; the variability was due principally to variation of thin cell density. It is hypothesized that the thick cells are a subpopulation of the TH-IR cells which are in a particular physiological state at the time of fixation.

The number and distribution of bipolar to ganglion cell synapses in the inner plexiform layer of the anuran retina

The main route of information flow through the vertebrate retina is from the photoreceptors towards the ganglion cells whose axons form the optic nerve. Bipolar cells of the frog have been so far reported to contact mostly amacrine cells and the majority of input to ganglion cells comes from the amacrines. In this study, ganglion cells of frogs from two species (Bufo marinus, Xenopus laevis) were filled retrogradely with horseradish peroxidase. After visualization of the tracer, light-microscopic cross sections showed massive labeling of the somata in the ganglion cell layer as well as their dendrites in the inner plexiform layer. In cross sections, bipolar output and ganglion cell input synapses were counted in the electron microscope. Each synapse was assigned to one of the five equal sublayers (SLs) of the inner plexiform layer. In both species, bipolar cells were most often seen to form their characteristic synaptic dyads with two amacrine cells. In some cases, however, the dyads were directed to one amacrine and one ganglion cell dendrite. This type of synapse was unevenly distributed within the inner plexiform layer with the highest occurrence in SL2 both in Bufo and Xenopus. In addition, SL4 contained also a high number of this type of synapse in Xenopus. In both species, we found no or few bipolar to ganglion cell synapses in the marginal sublayers (SLs 1 and 5). In Xenopus, 22% of the bipolar cell output synapses went onto ganglion cells, whereas in Bufo this was only 10%. We conclude that direct bipolar to ganglion cell information transfer exists also in frogs although its occurrence is not as obvious and regular as in mammals. The characteristic distribution of these synapses, however, suggests that specific type of the bipolar and ganglion cells participate in this process. These contacts may play a role in the formation of simple ganglion cell receptive fields.

Taurine, amino acid transmitters, and related molecules in the retina of the Australian lungfish Neoceratodus forsteri: a light-microscopic immunocytochemical and electron-microscopic study

The morphology of the retina of the Australian lungfish Neoceratodus forsteri was investigated by means of light- and electron microscopy, whilst immunocytochemical studies were performed to determine the cellular distributions of the major amino acid neurotransmitters and other amino acids. The distributions of glycine and GABA were similar to those previously described for teleost, amphibian and mammalian retinae. Labelling was abundant in amacrine cells, whilst GABA was also present in one layer of horizontal cells and some bipolar cells. Taurine was present in both rods and cones, but, unlike the mammalian or avian retina, was absent from other cellular structures, including glial elements. Unexpectedly, the photoreceptor terminals lacked an apparent content of the excitatory amino acid transmitter glutamate. The glutamate that was present in the rods and cones occupied a crescentic arc corresponding to the location of glycogen-rich paraboloids. Asparagine was also present in rods, albeit in the modified mitochondria that formed the elipsoids of the rod inner segments. Arginine, the precursor for formation of nitric oxide, was present in glial cells, and in the paraboloids of both rods and cones.

Synaptic contacts of serotonin-like immunoreactive and 5,7-dihydroxytryptamine-accumulating neurons in the anuran retina

The synapses of serotonin-like immunoreactive retinal neurons were studied in Bufo marinus and Xenopus laevis and those of 5,7-dihydroxytryptamine-labelled cells in Xenopus. Immunoreactivity to serotonin was mostly confined to amacrine cells. Synapses formed by profiles of labelled cells were almost uniformly distributed in the inner plexiform layer in both species. Interamacrine synapses were the most frequent, and in some cases two labelled amacrine cell profiles made a gap junction. Some of the labelled amacrine cells synapsed on to presumed ganglion cell dendrites and onto bipolar cell terminals. Labelled bipolar cell terminals synapsed on to non-labelled amacrine cell dendrites and received inputs both from labelled and non-labelled amacrine cells. Labelled bipolar cell profiles were not observed in the outer plexiform layer. After preloading and photoconversion of 5,7-dihydroxytryptamine in the Xenopus retina, labelled bipolar cell dendrites in the outer plexiform layer were observed to be postsynaptic to cone pedicles and less frequently to rods and horizontal cells. In the inner plexiform layer, synapse types formed by labelled bipolar cells were similar to those with serotonin immunoreactivity. The frequency of synapses formed by 5,7-dihydroxytryptamine-labelled amacrine cells increased, compared with serotonin immunocytochemistry. Labelled amacrine cells synapsed mostly with non-labelled amacrine cells, although the ratio of contacts formed by two labelled profiles increased. Synapses from labelled amacrine cell dendrites to non-labelled bipolar cell terminals and from non-labelled bipolar cell terminals to labelled amacrine cell profiles increased in number, while those from labelled amacrine cells to presumed ganglion cell dendrites decreased. The quantitative data obtained by the two approaches enabled us to propose different neuronal circuits for serotonin-synthesizing and -accumulating neurons of the Xenopus retina.