Serological investigation of enterococcal infections using western blot

Western Immunoblotting for the Diagnosis of Enterococcus faecalis and Streptococcus gallolyticus Infective Endocarditis

Blood culture-negative endocarditis (BCNE) remains a diagnostic challenge. In our center, despite a systematic and exhaustive microbiological diagnostics strategy, 22% of patients with BCNE remain without an identified etiology. In an effort to determine the relevance of using Western blot (WB) for the etiological diagnosis of BCNE in patients with early antibiotic use, we developed specific assays for the major infective endocarditis (IE) causative agents, namely, Staphylococcus aureus, Enterococcus faecalis, Streptococcus anginosus, and Streptococcus gallolyticus. Our technique was effective to identify the antigenic profiles of the four tested agents, but cross-reactions with S. aureus and S. anginosus antigens were frequent. A scoring method was developed for the diagnosis of E. faecalis and S. gallolyticus IE using the presence of reactivity to at least two antigenic bands for each bacterium and the positivity to at least one of the Ef300, Ef72, or Ef36 proteic bands for E. faecalis, and positivity for the two Sg75 and Sg97 proteic bands for S. gallolyticus. We tested these diagnostic criteria in a prospective cohort of 363 patients with suspected IE. Immunoblotting for the diagnosis of E. faecalis IE showed a sensitivity of 100% and a specificity of 99%. The positive and negative predictive values were 73 and 100%, respectively. Regarding S. gallolyticus infection, immunoblot had a sensitivity of 100% and a specificity of 95%. However, the positive predictive value was 22%, whereas the predictive negative value was 100%. Using WB, we identified a potential etiological agent in 4 of 14 BCNE cases with no identified pathogen. In conclusion, WB constitutes a promising and helpful method to diagnose E. faecalis or S. gallolyticus IE in patients with early antibiotic uptake and negative blood cultures.

Getting to the heart of the problem: serological and molecular techniques in the diagnosis of infective endocarditis

Infective endocarditis is diagnosed using the Duke criteria, which rely predominantly on cardiac imaging and recovery of a causative organism from the bloodstream. These criteria can be inconclusive, particularly when blood cultures remain sterile either due to the fastidious nature of the infecting organism or prior antibiotic therapy. Serology and, more recently, molecular techniques have been investigated as a solution to the problematic negative blood culture. The detection of elevated antibody levels has proved particularly useful in the diagnosis of those patients infected with organisms that cannot be cultured using standard laboratory methods, whilst molecular methods have been successfully used in the detection of both fastidious pathogens and those inhibited by prior antibiotic therapy. In view of recent and ongoing developments in the field of molecular diagnostics, these techniques will become increasingly important not only in the routine investigation of infectious disease, but specifically the diagnosis of endocarditis.

Identification of ABC transporters in vancomycin-resistant Enterococcus faecium as potential targets for antibody therapy

The occurrence of an outbreak of septicaemias due to vancomycin-resistant Enterococcus faecium (VRE), in Manchester, UK, provided an opportunity to examine the antibody responses in patients infected by the same strain. Immunoblotting sera from 24 cases, six of whom died, showed an immunodominant cluster of antigens at 34, 54 and 97 kDa, with a statistically significant correlate between survival and immunoglobulin G to the 34 and 97 kDa bands (P<0.05). Screening a genomic expression library of VRE with seropositive serum and peritoneal dialysate from a survivor gave a recombinant clone with two contiguous open reading frames, the derived amino acid sequences of which both showed sequence homologue with ABC transporters, with a Walker A and Walker B motif and the signature sequence LSGGQ. The first open reading frame (putative VRE ABC1) showed 57% homologue with YbxA from Bacillus subtilis. A partial sequence (putative VRE ABC2) was also obtained, in the same recombinant clone, of a second ABC transporter with 72% homologue with ybaE from B. subtilis. Affinity selection with the seropositive serum and peritoneal dialysate used to screen the library showed that the eluted antibody bound to the 97, 54, 34 and 30 kDa bands. Direct amino acid sequencing identified this as a possible ABC transporter. Rabbit antiserum against peptides representing Walker A and an area adjacent to the Walker B site cross-reacted with bands at 34, 54, 97, 110 kDa and at 30, 34 and 54 kDa respectively. This therefore appeared to be an immunodominant complex of ABC transporters of which the smallest was the 30 kDa antigen. Epitope mapping of this antigen with seropositive patients' sera delineated three linear epitopes (KVGIV, FGPKNF and RVAI). The Walker A site represented by peptide 1 (GHNGSGKSTLAKTIN), epitope RVAI represented by peptides 2 (MRRVAIAGVLAMPRE) and 3 (ELSGGQMRRVAIAGV), epitope KVGIV represented by peptide 4 (LKPIRKKVGIVFQFP), and recombinant VRE ABC1 and VRE ABC2 expressed in Escherichia coli pBAD were then used to isolate human genetically recombinant antibodies from a phage antibody display library. An assessment of the protective potential of these antibodies was carried out in a mouse model of the infection. This study suggests that an ABC transporter homologue could be a target for antibody therapy against VRE infections.

Diversity of ace, a gene encoding a microbial surface component recognizing adhesive matrix molecules, from different strains of Enterococcus faecalis and evidence for production of ace during human infections

Our previous work reported that most Enterococcus faecalis strains adhered to the extracellular matrix proteins collagen types I and IV and laminin after growth at 46 degrees C, but not 37 degrees C, and we subsequently identified an E. faecalis sequence, ace, that encodes a bacterial adhesin similar to the collagen binding protein Cna of Staphylococcus aureus. In this study, we examined the diversity of E. faecalis-specific ace gene sequences among different isolates obtained from various geographic regions as well as from various clinical sources. A comparison of nucleotide and deduced amino acid sequences of Ace from nine E. faecalis strains identified a highly conserved N-terminal A domain, followed by a variable B domain which contains two to five repeats of 47 amino acids in tandem array, preceded by a 20-amino-acid partial repeat. Using 17 other strains collected worldwide, the 5' region of ace that encodes the A domain was sequenced, and these sequences showed > or =97.5% identity. Among the previously reported five amino acids critical for collagen binding by Cna of S. aureus, four were found to be identical in Ace from all strains tested. Polyclonal immune rabbit serum prepared against recombinant Ace A derived from E. faecalis strain OG1RF detected Ace in mutanolysin extracts of seven of nine E. faecalis strains after growth at 46 degrees C; Ace was detected in four different molecular sizes that correspond to the variation in the B repeat region. To determine if there was any evidence to indicate that Ace might be produced under physiological conditions, we quantitatively assayed sera collected from patients with enterococcal infections for the presence of anti-Ace A antibodies. Ninety percent of sera (19 of 21) from patients with E. faecalis endocarditis showed reactivity with titers from 1:32 to >1:1,024; the only 2 sera which lacked antibodies to Ace A had considerably lower titers of antibodies to other E. faecalis antigens as well. Human-derived, anti-Ace A immunoglobulins G purified from an E. faecalis endocarditis patient serum inhibited adherence of 46 degrees C-grown E. faecalis OG1RF to collagen types I and IV and laminin. In conclusion, these results show that ace is highly conserved among isolates of E. faecalis, with at least four variants related to the differences in the B domain, is expressed by different strains during infection in humans, and human-derived antibodies can block adherence to these extracellular matrix proteins.

Specific antibody promotes opsonization and PMN-mediated killing of phagocytosis-resistant Enterococcus faecium

Many clinical isolates of Enterococcus faecium are resistant to neutrophil (PMN)-mediated phagocytosis and killing in the presence of normal human serum. We have now examined the ability of specific polyclonal rabbit antibodies to promote opsonization and killing of phagocytosis-resistant E. faecium. Immune rabbit serum generated against formalin-killed E. faecium TX0016, a phagocytosis-resistant strain, markedly promoted binding of TX0016 organisms to PMNs and PMN-mediated killing. These effects were dramatically reduced by (a) adsorption of immune serum with E. faecium TX0016, but not by adsorption with a strain of E. faecium susceptible to phagocytosis, and (b) incubation of immune serum with carbohydrate purified from TX0016, but not by incubation with a surface protein extract from TX0016. IgG purified from immune serum was unable by itself to promote bacterial binding to PMNs. However, specific IgG was able to promote binding to PMNs and PMN-mediated killing in the presence of normal human serum as a complement source, as were F(ab')(2) and Fab fragments produced from it, and the alternative pathway of complement was sufficient to promote IgG- and F(ab')(2)-mediated opsonization. PMN complement receptor type 3, but not complement receptor type 1, was involved in bacterial binding to PMNs induced by the combination of F(ab')(2) fragments and normal human serum. These results suggest that opsonization by antibodies potentially directed against bacterial carbohydrate, in conjunction with complement activation, has an important role in the host defense against phagocytosis-resistant E. faecium.

Enterococci: new aspects of an old organism

Enterococci are a long-known cause of bacterial endocarditis and a more recently recognized cause of nosocomial infection and superinfection. While much is known about the many antibiotic resistances of enterococci, less is known about the organism itself and how it causes disease. This article presents a brief overview of enterococci and its possible virulence factors and summarizes the authors' efforts to understand the features of this organism that may contribute to its disease potential.