Effect of local application of fluoride on healing of experimental bone fractures in rabbits

Mineral coated microparticles doped with fluoride and complexed with mRNA prolong transfection in fracture healing

Introduction: Impaired fracture healing, specifically non-union, has been found to occur up to 14% in tibial shaft fractures. The current standard of care to treat non-union often requires additional surgeries which can result in long recovery times. Injectable-based therapies to accelerate fracture healing have the potential to mitigate the need for additional surgeries. Gene therapies have recently undergone significant advancements due to developments in nanotechnology, which improve mRNA stability while reducing immunogenicity. Methods: In this study, we tested the efficacy of mineral coated microparticles (MCM) and fluoride-doped MCM (FMCM) to effectively deliver firefly luciferase (FLuc) mRNA lipoplexes (LPX) to the fracture site. Here, adult mice underwent a tibia fracture and stabilization method and all treatments were locally injected into the fracture. Level of osteogenesis and amount of bone formation were assessed using gene expression and histomorphometry respectively. Localized and systemic inflammation were measured through gene expression, histopathology scoring and measuring C-reactive protein (CRP) in the serum. Lastly, daily IVIS images were taken to track and measure transfection over time. Results: MCM-LPX-FLuc and FMCM-LPX-FLuc were not found to cause any cytotoxic effects when tested in vitro. When measuring the osteogenic potential of each mineral composition, FMCM-LPX-FLuc trended higher in osteogenic markers through qRT-PCR than the other groups tested in a murine fracture and stabilization model. Despite FMCM-LPX-FLuc showing slightly elevated il-1β and il-4 levels in the fracture callus, inflammation scoring of the fracture callus did not result in any differences. Additionally, an acute systemic inflammatory response was not observed in any of the samples tested. The concentration of MCM-LPX-FLuc and FMCM-LPX-FLuc that was used in the murine fracture model did not stimulate bone when analyzed through stereological principles. Transfection efficacy and kinetics of delivery platforms revealed that FMCM-LPX-FLuc prolongs the luciferase signal both in vitro and in vivo. Discussion: These data together reveal that FMCM-LPX-FLuc could serve as a promising mRNA delivery platform for fracture healing applications.

Bone healing at implants with a fluoride-modified surface: an experimental study in dogs

OBJECTIVES

The aim of the present experiment was to study early stages of osseointegration to implants with a fluoride-modified surface.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Six mongrel dogs, about 1-year old, were used. All mandibular premolars and the first mandibular molars were extracted. Three months later, mucoperiosteal flaps were elevated in one side of the mandible and six sites were identified for implant placement. The control implants (MicroThread) had a TiOblast surface, while the test implants (OsseoSpeed) had a fluoride-modified TiOblast surface. Both types of implants had a similar geometry, a diameter of 3.5 mm and were 8 mm long. Following installation, cover screws were placed and the flaps were adjusted and sutured to cover all implants. Four weeks after the first implant surgery, the installation procedure was repeated in the opposite side of the mandible. Two weeks later, biopsies were obtained and prepared for histological analysis. The void that occurred between the cut bone wall of the recipient site and the macro-threads of the implant immediately following implant installation was used to study early bone formation.

RESULTS

It was demonstrated that the amount of new bone that formed in the voids within the first 2 weeks of healing was larger at fluoride-modified implants (test) than at TiOblast (control) implants. It was further observed that the amount of bone-to-implant contact that had been established after 2 weeks in the macro-threaded portion of the implant was significantly larger at the test implants than at the controls.

CONCLUSION

It is suggested that the fluoride-modified implant surface promotes osseointegration in the early phase of healing following implant installation.

Effect of controlled local release of sodium fluoride on bone formation: filling a defect in the proximal femoral cortex

To assess the effect of sodium fluoride (NaF) in the healing of a defect in cortical bone, an experimental model was created by the drilling of 5.0 mm holes in the proximal ends of both femora of 12 adult male New Zealand White rabbits. An interlocking intramedullary implant constructed of poly(d,l-lactic acid) containing NaF was placed in the right femur and an identical implant without NaF (sham), in the left. The implant in the right femur was designed to release NaF in a controlled manner over the duration of the experiment. Ten weeks after implantation, the specimens were removed and were tested in torsion. The mechanical properties were not significantly different between the groups. The femora exposed to NaF had an 18.6% increase in intact cortex near the defect (p = 0.023), however, the deposition of mineralized bone within the defect was not significantly greater. In fact, healing appeared to be impaired by the presence of NaF. There was complete closure of the defect in all but one of the femora with a sham implant, but the tissue had not yet calcified. In contrast, only one femoral defect exposed to NaF had closed. Examination of the material filling the defects of the femora exposed to NaF showed that it was predominantly uncalcified osteogenic mesenchymal tissue.

Effect of controlled local release of sodium fluoride on trabecular bone

Systemic sodium fluoride has been used in the treatment of osteoporosis. Recent studies have shown that it has a positive risk/benefit ratio for use in increasing spinal trabecular bone density. However, thinning of the cortices of the long bones with a resulting increase in fracture incidence has been observed. This study was designed to determine the response of bone to sodium fluoride released from a biodegradable polymer matrix, a technique which could potentially deliver it locally to a site of need in the skeleton which has a positive response to fluoride. In one group of mature New Zealand white rabbits, cylindrical poly(D,L-lactic acid) (PLA) implants, with or without impregnated sodium fluoride, were implanted into the contralateral femoral trochanters and tibial metaphyses. In a second group, similar implants were placed in adjacent vertebrae. Four weeks postimplantation, the femora, tibiae, and vertebrae were removed, sectioned, cleaned of all but mineralized tissue, and the surfaces of the sections stained. The stained surfaces were imaged and analyzed for morphometric properties of the trabeculae. Comparing contralateral vertebrae, those exposed to sodium fluoride had significantly thickened trabeculae, with decreased spacing between them and a greater bone fraction. A similar increase in trabecular width was found in the subchondral bone of the proximal tibiae exposed to local release fluoride. Femoral sections showed no difference, possibly due to the lack of extensive trabecular bone in the region chosen for study.

Response of cortical bone to local controlled release of sodium fluoride: the effect of implant insertion site

In a previous experiment, sodium fluoride in a biodegradable polymer matrix was introduced into the femoral canal of the rabbit and bone formation was compared with contralateral controls. We noted significant bone formation, but only in the distal third of the periosteal surface of the femur. This experiment was performed to distinguish fluoride-induced periosteal bone formation from that due to the reactive osteogenic changes associated with local injury caused by the process of implantation. A proximal approach on the right leg and a distal approach on the left were used for the insertion of the implants in rabbits. Femurs were removed after 30 days and tested for stiffness and load to failure. The cross-sectional area of mineralized bone was determined at proximal, midshaft, and distal locations. Fluorescent bone tissue growth labels were injected at weekly intervals to measure the rate of new periosteal bone formation. The results were compared with a control group that received sham implants. Results showed no difference between measured properties in right and left femurs in the control group or in those exposed to fluoride. A significant increase was found in the fluoride group in load to failure, along with cross-sectional area of mineralized bone, and periosteal growth rates compared with the control group, but no difference was seen in stiffness. No difference was detected between the response proximally and distally in the fluoride group regardless of the location of insertion. There were no detectable changes in serum fluoride level after implantation of the poly L-lactic acid/sodium fluoride matrix. These results show that fluoride exerts its osteogenic effects equally at proximal, midshaft, and distal regions of diaphyseal bone and is uninfluenced by the site of local injury due to insertion of the implant.

The effect of protein malnutrition and nutritional support on the mechanical properties of fracture healing in the injured rat

We investigated the effect of different nutritional regimens on fracture healing in the injured rat model. Four groups, each consisting of 12 male rats (307 +/- 16 g), were subjected to anesthesia, laparotomy (injury), and tibial osteotomy with internal fixation. Group I received 23% protein, group II received 23% protein and high caloric feed, group III received 5% protein, and group IV received 38% protein. After 8 weeks, calluses were x-rayed and the tibia was removed, fixed in a special block of methyl-metacrylate, and tested at tension up to failure in a mechanical testing apparatus. The distraction force at failure was measured, and callus stiffness and energy absorbed to failure were calculated. The low protein diet resulted in significantly lower tensile strength and stiffness of calluses compared to the other three dietary regimens, this despite adequate caloric intake. In addition, the low protein diet resulted in a callus with "rubbery" mechanical properties compared to the "rigid" calluses of the other three groups. The high protein diet did not result in any significant improvement in fracture healing. These results gain clinical significance in the face of a high incidence of protein calorie malnutrition in injured orthopedic surgery patients.