The diminishing role of diagnostic arteriography in carotid artery disease: duplex scanning as definitive preoperative study

Extracranial and Transcranial Color-Coded Sonography Reduce the Need for Angiography Prior to Carotid Endarterectomy

The growing need for carotid endarterectomy must be accompanied by safe and reliable methods of imaging the cerebral circulation. The authors used extracranial and tran scranial color-coded sonography to evaluate the cervical carotid arteries and the basal cerebral circulation in 76 patients prior to surgery, aiming to reduce the need for preop erative angiography. In 3 patients (proximal and distal carotid disease; subtotal occlusion) carotid ultrasound failed to define the nature and extent of stenosis adequately, and thus conventional angiography was performed. Transcranial imaging identified intracranial stenotic disease in 4 patients and interhemispheric collateral flow in 29 patients. All patients underwent carotid endarterectomy without any complications due to inadequate preoperative imaging. An ultrasound-based approach eliminated the need for angiography in the majority of patients with significant implications for risk reduction and financial expenditure.

Value of Color Flow Duplex Imaging in Detection of Subtotal and Total Internal Carotid Artery Occlusion

The aim of this retrospective study was to estimate the predictive value of color flow duplex imaging (CFDI) in the detection of near-total and total internal carotid artery (ICA) occlusion. The authors reviewed all diagnoses of 95-99% ICA stenosis and ICA occlusion made by CFDI from 1991 to 1994 at St. Mary's Hospital. One hundred thirtyseven patients with CFDI diagnosis of ICA occlusion and 42 with 95-99% stenosis had also been subjected to intraarterial digital substraction angiography during the same period and within one month from the CFDI. They compared the results of both methods to estimate the positive predictive value (PPV) of CDFI in the detection of ICA occlusion and 95-99% stenosis. Furthermore, they compared the PPV of CDFI diagnoses during 1991-1993 with that of 1994 for the same spectrum of ICA disease.

CFDI had 96% PPV in the diagnosis of carotid occlusion (95% confidence interval, 94-97.9%, false-positive rate 3.6%) and 83% in the diagnosis of 95-99% stenosis (95% confidence interval 63.4-88.9%, false-positive rate 17%). Although there was improvement of CFDI's ability in the diagnosis of occlusion during 1994 in comparison with the 1991-1993 period, this was not statistically significant (PPV 95.9% and 97.4% respectively).

CFDI may slightly underestimate or overestimate the degree of tight ICA stenosis. However, in the diagnosis of ICA occlusion CFDI is highly reliable.

Clinical Benefit of Carotid Endarterectomy Based on Duplex Ultrasonography

Carotid endarterectomy has been shown to significantly reduce the risk of stroke caused by carotid artery stenosis in selected patients. Limiting the morbidity and costs of this process without increasing the risks should further improve the benefits of this procedure. Results were prospectively collected from 123 consecutive carotid endarterectomies performed at a community teaching hospital. All patients underwent duplex ultrasonography for preoperative evaluation. Catheter angiography was used on a selective basis. Preferential use of regional anesthetic and selective use of the intensive care unit were applied. The mortality, morbidity, complications, and costs were then compared for the group receiving only preoperative duplex ultrasonography with those undergoing catheter angiography preoperatively. Age, comorbid risk factors, indications for carotid endarterectomy, and incidence of stroke were similar in both patient groups. The rates of mortality, morbidity, and stroke for carotid endarterectomy were low (mortality 0%, morbidity 6.5%, stroke 0.8%). For preoperative evaluation all patients underwent duplex ultrasonography (100%) and 28 (23%) underwent preoperative catheter angiography in addition to duplex ultrasonography. The complication rate associated with catheter angiography was 6/28 (21%). Complications included groin hematoma (7%), pseudoaneurysm (3.6%), bradycardia (7%), and unstable angina (3.6%). Costs for duplex ultrasonography averaged $165 and additional costs incurred by the use of catheter angiography averaged $4,200. Intraoperative assessment of the carotid endarterectomy site did not change based on the use of preoperative catheter angiography. Morbidity, mortality, and stroke rates were the same for the 2 groups. The preoperative use of duplex ultrasonography for the sole evaluation in carotid endarterectomy is well established. The use of preoperative catheter angiography is still preferred by a subset of surgeons. The use of catheter angiography is associated with significant morbidity and additional costs when compared to performing carotid endarterectomy based solely on preoperative duplex ultrasonography. The added costs and morbidity of angiography increase the societal cost of this procedure without significant clinical improvement in patient outcome.

Effect of Ultrasonography in the Assessment of Carotid Artery Stenosis

Although ultrasonography (US) advantageously portrays lumen and wall thickness, velocity criteria have been used primarily to interpret carotid artery stenosis. The relationship of US and velocity measurements was investigated.

Peak-systolic and end-diastolic velocities (PSV, EDV) increase exponentially as the lumen of the internal carotid artery narrows and the percent stenosis (%S) increases. We tested the consistency of the relationship between carotid velocities and US %S in two distinct data sets. One data set was used to obtain regression equations relating velocity parameters and %S based on US. Validation of these equations was conducted using a separate, independent data set. US measurements were classified in 12 %S intervals. PSV, EDV, the ratio of the internal carotid artery to the common carotid artery PSV, and %S were entered consecutively until 10 records for each %S interval were obtained. Regression equations obtained in the first data set were used to predict %S in the second data set. Predicted %S was then compared with actual US %S.

The highest correlation in the first data set ( r = .89) was between %S and the natural logarithm (ln) of PSV. This ln PSV -%S equation was then applied to a second data set of an additional 120 carotid duplex images. In the second data set, actual %S and PSV–predicted %S differed by > 10% in 38 cases (32%). When all velocity-%S regression equations were used for comparison, differences between actual and at least one velocity-predicted %S were > 10% in 19% of the arteries. Conversely, actual %S matched at least one prediction of %S based on velocity data in 81% of the cases.

US %S differed significantly from single velocity-based estimates of %S in at least one-third of the cases. On the other hand, four of five US measurements were confirmed by at least one velocity parameter. Emphasis on US, in addition to velocity data, is recommended for the interpretation of duplex US carotid examinations.

Hyperperfusion Syndrome after Carotid Endarterectomy

The hyperperfusion syndrome is a rare delayed postoperative complication of carotid endarterectomy (CEA) characterized by headache and seizure, with or without intracranial edema or hemorrhage. Between January 1996 and December 2003, 1,602 CEAs were performed. Six patients (0.4%) developed symptoms of hyperperfusion within 2 weeks of surgery. All patients had critical stenoses, five > or =90% and one 80-90%, with poor backbleeding from the distal internal carotid artery noted at operation in all cases. Five patients were asymptomatic prior to operation; one had a hemispheric transient ischemic attack. Three patients had severe contralateral internal carotid disease (two occlusions and one severe stenosis). Two patients developed severe, self-limiting headache that prolonged hospitalization. Three patients had ipsilateral intracranial bleeding, two occurring after an uneventful postoperative course. After initial discharge from the hospital, severe intracranial hemorrhage caused death in two patients. One patient experienced focal seizures 1 week after discharge. Hypertension did not appear to be related to the symptoms in any case. During the study period, the hyperperfusion syndrome caused three of five perioperative strokes (60%) and two of seven deaths (29%) in the entire endarterectomy population. Although rare, the hyperperfusion syndrome accounts for a significant percentage of the neurological morbidity and mortality following CEA.

Critical review of non- or minimally invasive methods (duplex ultrasonography, MR- and CT-angiography) for evaluating stenosis of the proximal internal carotid artery

OBJECTIVE

to assess the performance of non- or minimally invasive methods (duplex ultrasonography, MR- and CT-angiography) in measuring stenosis of the proximal internal carotid prior to endarterectomy without preoperative intra-arterial digital subtraction angiography (DSA).

METHODS

systematic review of the literature (five databases, 1990 to February 2001). The value of each imaging technique was studied through its reproducibility and its sensitivity/specificity compared to DSA.

RESULTS

sensitivity exceeded 80% and specificity 90% in over two-thirds of the methodologically sound studies, regardless of technique, although direct comparisons between results had to be avoided since the findings originated from different populations. The main drawback of duplex ultrasonography is its levels of reproducibility. In contrast, only a few studies have addressed the reproducibility of MR- and CT-angiography. When the results of duplex and MR-angiography agree, the combination use of these two techniques provides a better diagnosis than either technique taken alone.

CONCLUSIONS

all three techniques appear suitable for measuring stenosis of the proximal internal carotid when compared to DSA.

Changing characteristics of carotid endarterectomy

We have noted significant differences in terms of our preoperative work-up, length of stay, morbidity, and mortality of patients undergoing carotid endarterectomy (CEA) from findings reported in large published randomized clinical trials. To further investigate these differences, we have reviewed our recent experience. CEA has proved to be the most effective approach to avert stokes caused by significant atherosclerotic disease of the carotid bifurcation. Between January 1, 1996 and December 31, 1998, 552 patients underwent CEA at our institution. Forty percent were performed in symptomatic patients with stenotic lesions > 60% in diameter by duplex ultrasonography. The remainder were performed for asymptomatic lesions > 60% in diameter. No patient underwent contrast angiography. Fifty-two percent of the patients were males. The mean age was 74 +/- 8 years old. General anesthesia was used in 97% of the cases and regional block, in 3%. All patients underwent routine postoperative measurement of serum creatinine phosphokinase (CPK) isoenzymes. Patients were discharged when deemed clinically stable. The patients' follow-up visits at 1 week and at 3-5 months after the procedure (mean, 3.4 months) included a neurological exam and duplex exam. Patient results suggest that CEAs can be performed in the modern era without contrast arteriography. Most patients can be discharged on the first postoperative day. In addition, previously acceptable rates of postoperative morbidity and mortality should perhaps be revised to meet current standards. Contrary to the previous concept that most postoperative strokes are due to embolic phenomena, hyperperfusion syndrome played an increasingly important role in this review.

Carotid endarterectomy without angiography: a prospective randomised pilot study

OBJECTIVES

to determine whether duplex ultrasonography alone is an adequate examination prior to carotid endarterectomy.

DESIGN

prospective, randomised, single centre study.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

all patients with carotid bifurcation stenosis greater than 70% - based on duplex scanning - were randomised to arteriography followed by carotid surgery (Group A n=96) or carotid surgery alone (Group B n=90). Study endpoints were neurological complications or death occurring between the day of randomisation and until 30 days after surgery.

RESULTS

major neurological complications of death in 1 (1%) vs 3 (3.3%) patients in group A and B, respectively (n.s.). Minor neurological complications (only TIA) were observed in 0 and 3 (3.3%) patients, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

complication rates were low in both groups and within the generally accepted rate after carotid surgery in asymptomatic and symptomatic patients.

Determination of 60% or greater carotid stenosis: a prospective comparison of magnetic resonance angiography and duplex ultrasound with conventional angiography

The morbidity and cost of conventional angiography (CA) have focused recent efforts in cerebrovascular imaging upon the exclusive use of noninvasive techniques. Our purpose was to prospectively evaluate carotid magnetic resonance angiography (MRA) and to compare its accuracy with color-flow duplex (CFD). Fifty patients were prospectively evaluated with CA and MRA after clinical and CFD findings indicated the need for carotid angiography. CFD measurements of peak systolic velocity (PSV) and end-diastolic velocity (EDV) were made. MRA results were categorized as 0%-39%, 40%-59%, 60%-79%, or 80%-99% stenosis or occluded. Determination of percent carotid stenosis by CA was made as in the North American Symptomatic Carotid Endarterectomy Trial (NASCET). Using receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves, the probability of correctly predicting a > or =60% stenosis using various CFD thresholds and MRA was assessed. Sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV), and negative predictive value (NPV) in determining > or =60% stenosis were estimated. For MRA the sensitivity was 85% (95% Confidence Interval [CI] = 69%-94%), specificity 70% (CI = 56%-81 %), PPV 68% (CI = 53%-80%), and NPV 86% (CI = 72%-94%). For CFD the sensitivity was 89% (CI = 74%-96%), specificity 93% (CI = 82%-98%), PPV 89% (CI = 74%-96%), and NPV 93% (CI = 82%-98%). When MRA and CFD results were concordant (n = 64), the sensitivity was 100% (CI = 89%-100%), specificity 95% (CI = 81%-99%), PPV 94% (CI = 77%-99%), and the NPV was 100% (CI = 92%-100%). The area under the ROC curve for CFD was 95%, compared to 83% for MRA (p = 0.0005). We conclude that the low specificity of MRA precludes its use as the definitive imaging modality for carotid stenosis. The 93% specificity of CFD alone warrants its consideration as a definitive carotid imaging study. By ROC curve analysis, CFD offers superior accuracy to MRA. Our data support noninvasive preoperative carotid imaging for detecting a threshold stenosis of > or =60% whether CFD is used alone, or in combination with the selective use of MRA.

Predictive ability of duplex ultrasonography for internal carotid artery stenosis of 70%-99%: a comparative study

This study prospectively compared the accuracy of published duplex ultrasonographic criteria for 70%-99% internal carotid artery (ICA) stenosis according to the North American Symptomatic Carotid Endarterectomy Trial (NASCET) method to determine angiographic stenosis. From March 1, 1995 to December 1, 1995, all patients considered for carotid endarterectomy (CEA) were studied with carotid duplex ultrasound and carotid angiography within 1 month of the ultrasound study. Duplex measurements of ICA peak systolic velocity (PSV), end diastolic velocity (EDV), and ratio of the ICA to common carotid artery (CCA) PSVs were recorded. Degree of stenosis on angiography was determined using NASCET criteria. A MEDLINE search to identify duplex ultrasound criteria to predict NASCET defined 70%-99% ICA stenosis was carried out. In addition, the original University of Washington criteria for critical stenosis (> or = 80%) was also examined. The accuracy of these criteria was determined with angiographic results and the positive predictive value (PPV) of each criterion were compared. Ninety-nine patients with 185 carotid bifurcations were available for comparison. The different duplex criteria for determining NASCET defined 70%-99% ICA stenosis were: ICA PSV > 175 cm/sec or PSV < 40 cm/sec, PSV > 230 cm/sec, ratio of ICA to CCA PSVs > 4, PSV > 130 cm/sec plus EDV > 100 cm/sec, and PSV > 270 cm/sec plus EDV > 110 cm/sec. When compared with angiography, the calculated PPVs for these criteria were 71% (73/103), 81% (71/88), 86% (67/78), 88% (62/70), and 90% (57/63), respectively. The University of Washington criteria for critical stenosis (PSV > 125 cm/sec plus EDV > 135 cm/sec) had the highest PPV at 91.6% (55/60). The University of Washington criteria for critical stenosis had the highest PPV to predict a 70%-99% angiographic stenosis.

Transcranial Doppler: state of the art

INTRODUCTION

Transcranial color Doppler sonography permits the accurate assessment of intracranial arteries. The latest Doppler units, using the color and power techniques, can show even very small flow volumes (1 x 1 mm). Low frequency (2-2.5 MHz) and very focused transducers are used in transcranial color Doppler. The skull is a very strong barrier for ultrasounds, which requires the use of some acoustic windows like some thin portions of the skull bone or some natural skull foramina. The use of echocontrast agents in color Doppler seems to increase the applications of transcranial studies.

OBJECTIVE

(1) To report on transcranial color Doppler technique and findings. (2) To assess the role of contrast agents in the visualization of intracranial vessels. (3) To define the main indications of this technique.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

The temporal, the orbital and the suboccipital are the main acoustic windows used for transcranial color Doppler studies. We use phased-array transducers (2-2.5 MHz) and, preferrably, the echocontrast agent. We examined 15 patients with severe internal carotid artery stenoses after the infusion of Levovist (Schering AG, Berlin, Germany) suspension (8 ml at 300 mg Galactose/ml, infused at 0.5 ml/s).

RESULTS

Levovist infusion permitted to depict the main intracranial vessels in all cases. The middle and the anterior cerebral arteries are shown through the temporal window. The former is the main cerebral artery, it is the easiest to identify and presents the highest peak systolic velocity. The orbital window can be used to visualize the ophthalmic artery and the internal carotid artery siphon, while the vertebral and the basilar arteries are demonstrated through the suboccipital window.

DISCUSSION

We report the most important findings and discuss the main indications of transcranial color Doppler studies. In addition to flow presence and direction, the main indices of arterial flow can be measured thanks to contrast agent administration, namely the peak systolic velocity, the end diastolic velocity, the resistance index and the pulsatility index. A morphological assessment of the Willis circle can also be carried out with color and power Doppler. Functional studies can be performed to assess the residual autoregulatory function of the cerebral circle in the patients with internal carotid artery stenosis or occlusion. The development of intracranial collateral circles can also be studied in these patients. Moreover, the M1 segment of the middle cerebral artery and the internal carotid artery siphon can be demonstrated directly. Transcranial color Doppler is also a useful tool to detect vasospasm after subarachnoid hemorrhage and to monitor blood flow velocity in the middle cerebral artery during carotid endarterectomy. The assessment of blood supply to arteriovenous malformations and to intracranial neoplasms is another application.

CONCLUSION

With reference to internal carotid stenoses, the main applications of transcranial color Doppler are the study of intracranial vessels, of intracranial arterial stenosis, of arteriovenous malformations and of Willis circle aneurysms, as well as the monitoring of blood flow velocity during carotid endarterectomy. Echocontrast agents play an important role in the visualization of intracranial vessels.

Cost-effectiveness of screening for asymptomatic carotid stenosis

PURPOSE

The benefit of carotid endarterectomy for patients who are asymptomatic with > 60% carotid stenosis has been established by the Asymptomatic Carotid Atherosclerosis Study (ACAS). Which screening strategy is most appropriate is still unclear. This study assessed the cost-effectiveness of ultrasound screening for asymptomatic carotid stenosis.

METHODS

Cost-effectiveness analysis was performed with a Markov model and with data from ACAS and other studies.

RESULTS

For 60-year-old patients with a 5% prevalence of 60% to 99% asymptomatic stenosis, duplex ultrasound screening increased average quality-adjusted life years (QALY; 11.485 vs 11.473) and lifetime cost of care ($5500 vs $5012) under base-case assumptions. The incremental cost per QALY gained (cost-effectiveness ratio) was $39,495. Screening was cost-effective with the following conditions: disease prevalence was 4.5% or more, the specificity of the screening test (ultrasound) was 91% or more, the stroke rate of patients who were medically treated was 3.3% or more, the relative risk reduction of surgery was 37% or more, the stroke rate associated with surgery was 160% or less than that of the North American Symptomatic Carotid Endarterectomy Trial or ACAS perioperative complication rates, and the cost of ultrasound screening was $300 or less. A one-time screening, compared with a screening every 5 years, had more QALY (11.485 vs 11.482) and lower cost ($5500 vs $5790). Screening without arteriography, compared with screening with arteriographic verification, provided few additional QALYs (11.486 vs 11.485) at additional cost ($6896 vs $5500). The cost-effectiveness ratio was sensitive to assumptions about the stroke rate of patients who were asymptomatic and other variables.

CONCLUSIONS

Screening for asymptomatic carotid stenosis can be cost-effective when both screening and carotid endarterectomy are performed in centers of excellence.

Accuracy of duplex ultrasound in evaluating carotid artery anatomy before endarterectomy

PURPOSE

Anatomic features, such as a high carotid bifurcation (< 1.5 cm from the angle of the mandible), excessive distal extent of plaque (> 2.0 cm above the carotid bifurcation), or a small diameter (< or = 0.5 cm) redundant or kinked internal carotid artery can complicate carotid endarterectomy. In the past, arteriography was the only preoperative study capable of imaging these features. This study assessed the ability of duplex ultrasound to evaluate their presence before surgery.

METHODS

A consecutive series of 20 patients who underwent 21 carotid endarterectomies had preoperative duplex ultrasound evaluations of these anatomic features. These evaluations were correlated with operative measurements from an observer blinded to the duplex findings.

RESULTS

The mean difference between duplex and operative measurements for the distance between the carotid bifurcation and the angle of the mandible, the distal extent of plaque, and the internal carotid artery diameter was 0.9 cm, 0.3 cm, and 0.8 mm, respectively. The correlation coefficient between the two methods was 0.86, 0.75, and 0.59, respectively. Duplex ultrasound predicted a high carotid bifurcation, excessive distal extent of plaque, or a redundant or kinked internal carotid artery with 100% sensitivity (p < 0.05, p < 0.01, and p < 0.001, respectively). The sensitivity of duplex ultrasound in predicting a small internal carotid artery diameter was 80%. The specificity of duplex ultrasound for predicting excessive distal extent of plaque, small internal carotid artery diameter, high carotid bifurcation, and a coiled or kinked carotid artery was 92%, 56%, 100%, and 100%, respectively.

CONCLUSION

Duplex ultrasound can predict the presence of anatomic features that may complicate carotid endarterectomy. Preoperative duplex imaging of these features may be helpful in patients who undergo carotid endarterectomy without preoperative arteriography.

Can duplex ultrasonography select appropriate patients for carotid endarterectomy?

OBJECTIVES

This study investigated the reliability of carotid duplex ultrasound (DUS) to identify appropriate candidates for carotid endarterectomy (CEA) according to a panel of vascular specialists.

DESIGN

Prospective study.

MATERIAL

102 patients with 145 carotid bifurcation stenosis or occlusions.

METHODS

All patients who required a carotid angiogram were evaluated using DUS followed by carotid angiography. A blinded panel of four vascular specialists individually decided whether CEA would be appropriate for each patient based on pre-angiographic information. Angiograms were then shown to panelists to see if their management decision was altered by the angiogram.

RESULTS

For stenosis > or = 80% on DUS (n = 60), panelists unanimously agreed on CEA without angiography in 57 lesions. In 50 lesions (87.7%), angiography showed > or = 70% stenosis and the management plan remained unchanged. For the other seven lesions, intracranial aneurysms (n = 2), tandem intracranial lesion (n = 1), unsuspected proximal common carotid lesion (n = 1), a 40% stenotic lesion (n = 1), and high carotid bifurcations (n = 2) were seen. In lesions with 50-79% stenosis on DUS (n = 66), none of the panelists recommended CEA without prior angiography. Eighteen (27%) of these lesions were > or = 70% stenosed on angiogram. Complications of angiograms included one stroke, one haematoma, and one severe allergic reaction.

CONCLUSION

Carotid duplex ultrasonography without angiography can reliably select lesions appropriate for surgery only when critical stenosis > or = 80% is chosen. Routine angiography is recommended for carotid stenosis of 50-79% when CEA is considered.

The reliability of color duplex ultrasound in diagnosing total carotid artery occlusion

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Color duplex ultrasound has been advocated as an alternative to arteriography before carotid endarterectomy. However, one limitation of color duplex ultrasound is that it sometimes fails to differentiate high-grade stenosis from total carotid occlusion. This study was done to determine (1) the accuracy of carotid duplex ultrasound in diagnosing total carotid occlusion, and (2) when angiography is necessary.

PATIENT POPULATION AND METHODS

Carotid duplex ultrasound and angiography results were compared for 520 carotid arteries, and 103 of these had a duplex diagnosis of total carotid occlusion or suspected almost total-to-total occlusion. The diagnosis of total carotid occlusion was primarily based on the absence of flow in the internal carotid artery as visualized on B-mode imaging for at least 1 inch beyond the bifurcation (optimal study). If the internal carotid artery was not optimally seen beyond the bifurcation, but secondary criteria were present, such as dampening of the common carotid signal and internalization of the external carotid artery, a diagnosis of suspected subtotal to total occlusion was made (limited study).

RESULTS

In the optimal studies, 91 arteries had total carotid occlusions and of these, 87 were confirmed by angiography. The accuracy of carotid duplex ultrasound in diagnosing total carotid occlusion was 97% with a positive predictive value of 96%, negative predictive value of 98%, sensitivity of 91%, and specificity of 99%. Twelve arteries were diagnosed as suspected subtotal to total occlusion (limited studies), and of these, three were occluded on angiography, eight had stenoses ranging from 90% to 99%, and one had 80% stenosis.

CONCLUSIONS

A carotid duplex ultrasound study is an acceptable method for predicting total carotid occlusion when the study is optimal, and angiography is unnecessary in asymptomatic patients. Angiography is recommended for patients who are surgical candidates with a limited duplex study.

Preoperative testing before carotid endarterectomy: a survey of vascular surgeons' attitudes

Traditional surgical practice and published consensus statements from major vascular surgery specialty societies have considered contrast arteriography to be a routine part of the diagnostic evaluation prior to carotid endarterectomy (CEA). However, some surgeons now omit routine preoperative arteriography if a technically adequate carotid duplex scan is performed and indications for CEA are clear. To better establish current practice patterns and to characterize vascular surgeons' opinions about the role of preoperative arteriography, the Peripheral Vascular Surgery Society membership was surveyed by mail. Eighty-six percent of the members responded (430 of 502). Ninety-three percent of all patients considered for CEA are evaluated with duplex scanning; 82% with arteriography. While the majority of surgeons typically obtain both a duplex scan and an arteriogram, 70% have performed CEA without a preoperative arteriogram. Brain imaging studies (CT or MRI) are obtained in 26% and MR angiograms in 10% of cases. Seventy-five percent of the surgeons agreed with the statement that CEA without preoperative arteriography is an acceptable practice if appropriate indications for surgery are present. Furthermore, one third believed that CEA without a preoperative arteriogram is generally acceptable (acceptable more than half the time). Respondents were stratified by surgical experience time in practice and practice type. No significant differences in responses were found, suggesting the acceptance of CEA without preoperative arteriography is broad-based. This survey demonstrates changing attitudes among practicing vascular surgeons regarding the necessity for routine arteriography prior to CEA. Carotid endarterectomy on the basis of duplex scanning and clinical assessment should be considered an accepted alternative.

Advances in Management of Carotid Atherosclerosis

Carotid artery stenosis is a common and potentially treatable cause of stroke. Stroke risk is increased as the degree of carotid stenosis increases, as well as in patients with neurological symptoms referable to the stenosed carotid artery. Carotid stenosis can be quantified by ultrasound imaging, magnetic resonance angiography, or conventional angiography. Medical treatment with platelet antiaggregants reduces stroke risk in some patients; other patients are best treated with carotid endarterectomy. Experimental treatments for carotid stenosis, including carotid angioplasty with or without stenting, are under investigation. We summarize the current literature and provide treatment recommendations for patients with atherosclerotic carotid artery disease.

The practice of carotid endarterectomy in Australasia

BACKGROUND

Carotid endarterectomy (CEA) is a frequently performed surgical procedure and there are variations in the preoperative, operative and postoperative management related to this operation.

METHODS

Questionnaires were sent to all 191 members of the Division of Vascular Surgery, Royal Australasian College of Surgeons, and the Australasian Chapter of the International Society of Cardiovascular Surgery.

RESULTS

The questionnaire was returned by 179 surgeons (94%). One hundred and fifty-nine were vascular surgeons, of whom 139 perform CEA. Most surgeons reported performing more CEA than 5 years previously. Surgery for asymptomatic carotid stenosis was performed by 78% of surgeons at the time of the survey. Routine carotid angiography is performed pre-operatively for symptomatic patients by 61% of surgeons and for asymptomatic patients by 56%. Intra-operative shunting is used routinely by 37% of surgeons, selectively by 58% and never by 5%. Arteriotomy patch closure is performed routinely by 16%, usually by 30%, rarely by 52% and never by 3%. The favoured patch material is Dacron 39%, PTFE 19%, ankle long saphenous vein (LSV) 22%, thigh LSV 18% or other materials 2%. Compared to their practice 5 years previously, arterial patch closure is used more often by 42% of surgeons, the same by 51% and less by 7%. Postoperatively, patients are nursed mainly in intensive care (34%) or a high-dependency unit (33%).

CONCLUSIONS

The practice of CEA by Australasian vascular surgeons reflects the recent trends reported in the world literature. Most Australasian surgeons perform CEA for asymptomatic disease. Forty per cent are performing CEA on the basis of duplex scanning alone. There is a trend towards increased use of patch closure. Most patients are managed in intensive care or high-dependency units.

Cost-efficient carotid surgery: a comprehensive evaluation

PURPOSE

This study was performed to determine whether comprehensive cost-cutting strategies adversely affect the outcome in patients undergoing carotid endarterectomy.

METHODS

From December 1994 to December 1995, 237 consecutive patients undergoing 260 carotid endarterectomies were prospectively studied. The following variables were assessed: carotid arteriography, preoperative laboratory tests, electrocardiograms and chest x-ray films, use of carotid shunts during operation, use of pathology department, intensive care, oxygen therapy, telemetry, and hospital stay. In addition, complications were tabulated.

RESULTS

Previously, all variables evaluated were routinely ordered. Subsequent to initiating the cost-containment strategies, the following results were achieved: arteriography in 52 (22%) of 237 patients, preoperative complete blood cell count and SMA-7 in 161 (62%) of 260 cases, preoperative electrocardiograms in 185 (71%) of 260 cases, preoperative chest x-ray films in 190 (73%) of 260 cases, carotid shunts in 83 (32%) of 260 cases, disease in no cases (0%), intensive care in 29 (11%) of 260 cases, oxygen therapy in 34 (13%) of 260 cases, telemetry in 17 (7%) of 260 cases, and hospital stay was decreased from an average of 2.6 to 1.3 days. Total savings based on average hospital and physician charges was $2.3 million. Complications included four strokes, one myocardial infarction, and no deaths. No patient required readmission. No recurrent or new neurologic or cardiac findings were identified clinically in follow-up at 1 and 4 weeks after surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

The results clearly demonstrate that comprehensive cost-cutting strategies can reduce charges significantly while maintaining patient safety.

Relationship between intraoperative color-flow duplex findings and early restenosis after carotid endarterectomy: a preliminary report

PURPOSE

This study was undertaken to examine the relationship between intraoperative color-flow duplex (CFD) findings and the development of restenosis in patients undergoing carotid endarterectomy (CEA).

METHODS

Seventy-eight patients (43 male and 35 female; mean age, 65 years) underwent 86 CEAs (eight staged bilateral) and intraoperative CFD during a 31-month period. Three patients (three CEAs, 3%) underwent both CFD and a completion arteriographic scan. Patients were observed in a postoperative protocol using CFD surveillance. The follow-up interval ranged from 6 to 24 months (average, 12 months).

RESULTS

After undergoing CEA, 10 patients (10 CEAs, 11%) had an abnormality detected by intraoperative CFD; one was confirmed with a completion arteriographic scan. These abnormalities consisted of elevated peak systolic velocities (PSV) with a mosaic color pattern suggesting turbulence seen in six CEAs, including one internal carotid artery (ICA) with abnormal hemodynamics and an unremarkable completion arteriogram. Intimal defects on B-mode were seen in another four CEAs. These carotid arteries were reexplored, defects (intimal flaps with platelet thrombus) were confirmed by direct examination, and all were repaired with or without a patch (six ICAs, three external carotid arteries, and one common carotid artery). No cerebrovascular events occurred in the perioperative period. No carotid restenosis (> or = 50% diameter reduction) was identified during follow-up of 43 patients (48 CEAs, 56%). Two patients had recurrent neurologic symptoms.

CONCLUSION

Intraoperative CFD is an effective test for detecting flow abnormalities or intimal defects in patients undergoing CEA. Ensuring normal intraoperative hemodynamics after CEA may be a major factor associated with decreased incidence of perioperative cerebrovascular events and subsequent carotid artery restenosis.

Accuracy of carotid duplex examination to predict proximal and intrathoracic lesions

BACKGROUND

There is growing enthusiasm for doing carotid endarterectomy based on duplex examination alone, avoiding the risks of arteriography. Duplex cannot directly visualize proximal carotid or arch lesions. This study evaluates the prevalence of such lesions and the ability of duplex to predict their presence.

METHODS

A retrospective review was conducted of 650 consecutive carotid duplex examinations followed by arteriography.

RESULTS

Twenty-seven proximal lesions (10 occlusions and 17 stenoses) were predicted by duplex and confirmed by arteriography. One lesion was missed by duplex, for a sensitivity and specificity of 96% and 100%, respectively. The accuracy was 99%, and the negative predictive value was 99%. Prevalence of proximal lesions was 4% overall, but only 3% for stenotic lesions.

CONCLUSIONS

Proximal carotid and intrathoracic lesions are rare and can be predicted by duplex scan, thus avoiding arteriography. The absence of such lesions can be inferred with confidence from a negative duplex examination.

Corotid endarterectomy for symptomatic carotid artery disease demonstrated by duplex ultrasound with minimal arteriographic findings

Ulcerated or irregular heterogeneous carotid plaque as seen by duplex ultrasound can cause hemispheric transient ischemic attacks (TIAs) and/or a cerebrovascular accident, even if only associated with nonsignificant carotid stenosis on arteriography. The purpose of this study was to review our experience in patients who underwent a carotid endarterectomy after medical treatment had failed, based on pathologic findings detected by carotid duplex ultrasound with minimal disease on arteriography. The medical records of 14 patients who underwent carotid endarterectomy for TIA symptoms related to ulcerated or irregular heterogeneous plaques were analyzed. All had had preoperative carotid duplex ultrasound, arteriography, and cardiac and neurologic workups to rule out other causes for their TIAs. Medical treatment had failed in all of them. There were 10 men and four women whose median age was 68 years. Carotid duplex ultrasound showed irregular heterogeneous carotid plaque in all patients associated with 20% to 50% stenosis in 12 and approximately 50% to 60% stenosis in two. All had normal to < 20% stenosis on arteriograms. The duplex ultrasound findings were all confirmed at operation. All had an uneventful postoperative course with relief of symptoms. Carotid duplex ultrasound is superior to carotid arteriography in detecting irregular or ulcerative heterogeneous plaque associated with nonsignificant stenosis. Carotid duplex ultrasound can be used to determine the desirability of carotid endarterectomy after failed medical treatment in patients with classical and persistent TIA symptoms despite normal or minimal disease on arteriograms. A successful endarterectomy appears to predict an asymptomatic postoperative course.

Evaluation of carotid artery stenosis: is duplex ultrasonography sufficient?

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to compare the results of duplex ultrasonography and magnetic resonance angiography in the evaluation of carotid artery stenosis to determine whether ultrasonography alone is sufficient for preoperative evaluation.

METHODS

This study consisted of a retrospective review of 33 patients who underwent 35 carotid endarterectomies. A total of 66 vessels were studied by both duplex ultrasonography and magnetic resonance angiography, and an overall correlation between the two studies was determined.

RESULTS

A high correlation was found between duplex and magnetic resonance angiography with an r coefficient equal to 0.87 (Pearson's correlation coefficient) and kappa = 0.75. Discrepancies between the two studies or the presence of intracranial disease did not alter surgical decision making.

CONCLUSION

Duplex ultrasonography alone can accurately determine the degree of internal carotid artery stenosis and when paired with careful clinical evaluation is a reliable and cost-effective method for evaluating surgical carotid disease.

Determination of duplex Doppler ultrasound criteria appropriate to the North American Symptomatic Carotid Endarterectomy Trial

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

The North American Symptomatic Carotid Endarterectomy Trail (NASCET) demonstrated the benefit of carotid endarterectomy for symptomatic patients with > or = 70% carotid stenosis. Screening for detection of significant carotid occlusive disease has relied on duplex Doppler imaging. However, traditional duplex categories (50% to 79%, 80% to 99%) are not directly applicable to NASCET. We sought to evaluate duplex criteria for determination of > or = 70% carotid stenosis.

METHODS

Duplex scan and arteriograms of 110 patients (210 carotids), performed within 1 month of each other, were reviewed by blinded readers. Arteriographic stenosis was determined by the NASCET method. Duplex measurements of peak systolic and end-diastolic velocity (PSV, EDV) were recorded, and ratios of velocities in the internal and common carotid arteries (ICA, CCA) were calculated. Receiver-operator characteristic (ROC) curves of sensitivity, specificity, positive and negative predictive values (PPV, NPV), and accuracy were determined.

RESULTS

Interobserver agreement for measurement of arteriographic stenosis was "almost perfect" (kappa=0.86). The criteria chosen for detection of > or = 70% stenosis were PSVICA>210 cm/s (sensitivity, 94%; specificity, 77%; PPV, 68% NPV, 96% accuracy, 83%) EDVICA>70 cm/s (sensitivity, 92%; specificity, 60%; PPV, 73%; NPV, 86%; accuracy 77%), PSVica/PSVCCA >3.0 (sensitivity, 91%; specificity, 78%; PPV, 70%; NPV, 94%; accuracy, 83%), and EDVICA/EDVCCA>3.3 (sensitivity, 100%; specificity, 65%; PPV, 65% NPV, 100%; accuracy, 79%).

CONCLUSIONS

We conclude that > or = 70% carotid stenosis can be reliably determined by duplex Doppler ultrasound. Individual vascular laboratories must validate their own results.

The changing face of carotid endarterectomy

PURPOSE

The economic milieu and improvements in care have altered the diagnostic and therapeutic algorithm of the patient with carotid stenosis. This study analyzes the efficacy and safety of these changes.

METHODS

The records of patients who underwent 320 consecutive carotid endarterectomies performed by three surgeons at our institution from 1990 to 1994 were reviewed retrospectively. Use of diagnostic angiography, use of carotid duplex ultrasound, length of hospital stay, postanesthesia recovery observation, intensive care unit (ICU) observation, complications, and hospital charges were analyzed.

RESULTS

The average length of hospital stay decreased from 6.18 days to 2.00 days (p < or = 0.001). The day of discharge decreased from 3.10 days to 1.24 days after surgery (p < or = 0.01). By 1993, 68% were discharged by the first day after surgery, increasing to 73% by 1994. From 1990 to 1992, average postoperative ICU observation time fluctuated between 18 and 25 hours; this time decreased to 12.2 hours by 1994. In 1993, only 12.5% of patients were admitted to the ICU, down from 94.8% in 1990; by 1994, only 7.3% were admitted to the ICU (p < or = 0.001). Postanesthesia recovery observation time decreased from 3.77 hours to 1.63 hours during this time (p < or = 0.04). With regard to preoperative diagnosis, angiography was performed in 93.1% of patients in 1990; by 1994, only 32.8% underwent this procedure (p < or = 0.0001). Average hospital charges decreased significantly (1990, $14,378; 1994, $10,436) with these modifications in patient care (p < or = 0.001). The complication rate reflected no significant changes over the course of the study. There were six incidences of cerebrovascular accident (6/320, 1.9%), including one death. There were four incidences of transient ischemic attack (4/320, 1.3%), with no significant differences noted from year to year.

CONCLUSIONS

This study confirms the changing nature of carotid endarterectomy and documents that these changes have not adversely affected the safety of the operation.

A critical analysis of cerebral computed tomography scanning before elective carotid endarterectomy and its correlation to carotid stenosis

BACKGROUND

Cerebral computed tomography (CT) scanning has been suggested to play a role in the management of patients before carotid endarterectomy (CEA). This prospective study analyzes the value of CT scanning before elective CEA and the correlation of CT findings to significant carotid stenosis.

METHODS

This study includes 131 consecutive patients considered for CEA during a 2-year period. All patients underwent carotid duplex ultrasonography, carotid arteriography, and CT scanning.

RESULTS

Eighty patients (61%) had transient ischemic attacks or prior strokes, and 51 (39%) had nonhemispheric symptoms or were asymptomatic. The CT scan was abnormal in 36 (27%) patients; however, no brain tumors or abnormalities to affect clinical management were revealed. Ninety-two CEAs were performed on 87 patients. Twenty-nine (32%) in the operative group had abnormal CT scans, but these did not influence operative decisions. On the basis of this rate of 0% of patients with CT findings to change surgical management in 92 cases, a maximum true rate of occurrence of up to 5% could be detected with alpha equals 0.05 by sampling a population of this size. Four patients (4%) had postoperative cerebral vascular accidents, and all of these had normal preoperative scans. Patients with 50% or more carotid stenosis on arteriogram were significantly more likely to have abnormal CT scans than patients with less than 50% stenosis (20% versus 7%, p = 0.0034). As carotid stenosis became more significant, the frequency of abnormal CT scans increased (p < 0.01). The cost of CT scanning was $66,089.50 in this study.

CONCLUSIONS

Significant carotid stenosis was associated with a higher frequency of abnormal CT scans; however, routine preoperative CT scanning was unnecessary before elective CEA.

The role of common carotid artery end-diastolic velocity in near total or total internal carotid artery occlusion

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the role of the end-diastolic velocity (EDV) in the common carotid artery (CCA) as a marker of internal carotid artery (ICA) occlusion.

DESIGN

Validation of retrospective data in a prospective clinical study.

METHODS

The EDV in 94 patients with total ICA occlusion and in 24 patients with high grade (95-99%) unilateral ICA stenosis identified on extracranial carotid colour-flow Duplex imaging (CFDI) and arteriography was reviewed, and was retrospectively compared to the EDV of 176 normal individuals. Identification of patients with ICA occlusion was most accurate (99.3%) with an ipsilateral EDV > or = 12 cm/s and a DIFF > or = 10 cm/s (DIFF = contralateral EDV -- ipsilateral EDV). These values were then prospectively applied to all 886 patients (67 with high grade stenosis or occlusion) who underwent CFDI at our institution during 1994.

RESULTS

The EDV > or = 12 had a 92% sensitivity, a 99.4% negative predictive value (NPV) and a 85% specificity in distinguishing between occluded and patent ICA's. In combination with a DIFF > or = 10 was 80.4% sensitive and 97.5% specific. The positive predictive value of the EDV > or = 12 in the distinction between 95-99% ICA stenosis and ICA occlusion was 78.3%, and that of the combination was 85.4%. The EDV was rarely zero and 10% of patients with normal or minimally diseased ICA's had an EDV > or = 12 and/or a DIFF > or = 10.

CONCLUSIONS

The EDV < or = 12 cm/s is a sensitive marker of ICA occlusion with a high NPV and in combination with the DIFF > or = 10 cm/s, is specific. Nevertheless, EDV parameters are inaccurate in the distinction of 95-99% ICA stenosis from occlusion. Low EDV can be found in a number of patients with minor or no ICA disease, particularly in those with a stroke or silent cerebral infarct.

Determination of sixty percent or greater carotid artery stenosis by duplex Doppler ultrasonography

PURPOSE

The Asymptomatic Carotid Atherosclerosis Study, demonstrating the benefit of carotid endarterectomy for symptom-free patients with 60% or greater carotid artery stenosis, has given rise to the need for development of screening parameters for detection of these lesions. Traditional duplex categories (50% to 79%, 80% to 99%) are not applicable. We sought to develop duplex criteria for determination of 60% or greater carotid artery stenosis by comparison with arteriography.

METHODS

The duplex scans and arteriograms of 110 patients (210 carotid arteries), obtained within 1 month of each other, were reviewed by blinded readers. Arteriographic stenosis was determined by the method of the Asymptomatic Carotid Atherosclerosis Study. Duplex measurements of peak systolic velocity (PSV) and end-diastolic velocity (EDV) were recorded, and ratios of velocities in the internal and common carotid arteries (ICA, CCA) were calculated. Sensitivity, specificity, positive and negative predictive values (PPV, NPV), and accuracy were determined, and receiver-operator characteristic curves were generated.

RESULTS

Interobserver agreement for measurement of arteriographic stenosis was "almost perfect" (kappa = 0.86). The criteria determined for detection of 60% or greater stenosis were as follows: PSVICA > 170 cm/sec (sensitivity 98%, specificity 87%, PPV 88%, NPV 98%, accuracy 92%), EDVICA > 40 cm/sec (sensitivity 97%, specificity 52%, PPV 86%, NPV 86%, accuracy 86%), PSVICA/PSVCCA > 2.0 (sensitivity 97%, specificity 73%, PPV 78%, NPV 96%, accuracy 76%), EDVICA/EDVCCA > 2.4 (sensitivity 100%, specificity 80%, PPV 88%, NPV 100%, accuracy 88%). If all of the above criteria were met, 100% accuracy was achieved.

CONCLUSION

It is concluded that 60% or greater carotid artery stenosis can be reliably determined by duplex criteria. The use of receiver-operator characteristic curves allows the individualization of duplex criteria appropriate to specific clinical situations of patient screening for lesions (high sensitivity and NPV) or use as a sole preoperative imaging modality (high PPV). Individual vascular laboratories must validate their own results.

Cost-effective carotid endarterectomy in community practice

The purpose of this study was to compare hospital charges for carotid endarterectomy on a surgeon-specific basis. The cost of carotid endarterectomy is influenced by preoperative evaluation, operating time, use of the intensive care unit, length of hospital stay, and surgical results. Length of stay and average hospital charges for 18 doctors performing 344 carotid endarterectomies at three hospitals were analyzed. Outcome data were also reviewed. The results demonstrated a wide variation in hospital charges among surgeons. Surgeons using the most cost-effective measures achieved comparable or superior outcomes. In an era of managed care, severe cost constraints mandate that surgeons perform similar studies in their own communities so that cost-effective clinical pathways can be developed. With the use of appropriate guidelines, carotid endarterectomy can be performed at relatively low cost without sacrificing quality.

Short-stay carotid endarterectomy is safe and cost-effective

BACKGROUND

Carotid endarterectomy (CEA) is conventionally performed following a contrast arteriogram, under general anesthesia, and with postoperative admission to an intensive care unit (ICU). We investigated whether any of these traditional adjuncts to CEA is necessary.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Eighteen consecutive patients had CEA performed according to a protocol of duplex scanning only, operation under regional anesthesia, and admission to the ICU only in cases of a proven need for services unique to the ICU (group I). Utilization of preoperative arteriography, admission to the ICU, postoperative complications, total hospital length of stay, and hospital charges were calculated for this group and results were compared with a group of 178 patients undergoing conventional CEA (arteriography, general anesthesia, routine ICU admission) during the same period (group II).

RESULTS

In group I, 1 patient (6%) underwent preoperative arteriography and 4 patients (22%) were admitted to the ICU after CEA. Most group II patients (114 of 178, or 64%) underwent preoperative arteriography and virtually all (175 of 178, or 98%) were admitted to the ICU. Compared with group II, the average hospital length of stay for group I was significantly shorter (1.3 +/- 0.1 versus 3.1 +/- 0.3 days, P = 0.03) and hospital charges were significantly reduced ($5,861 +/- 229 versus $11,140 +/- 729, P = 0.02).

CONCLUSIONS

This pilot study suggests that CEA can be safely performed without routine preoperative carotid arteriography; that routine ICU admission is unnecessary for the majority of cases; and that elimination of routine arteriography and ICU admission can reduce hospital charges for CEA by nearly one half.

Comparison of magnetic resonance angiography, duplex ultrasound, and digital subtraction angiography in assessment of extracranial internal carotid artery stenosis

The results of a prospective study comparing ultrasound, intra-arterial digital subtraction angiography, and magnetic resonance angiography in the assessment of the degree of extracranial internal carotid artery stenosis are reported in patients with symptoms of recent carotid territory ischaemia. A total of 70 patients and 137 vessels were examined by all three techniques. The results obtained by each technique were reported blind. The mean difference (SD) for the comparison of magnetic resonance angiography and digital subtraction angiography was -0.7 (14)%, for ultrasound and digital subtraction angiography 3.1 (15)%, and for magnetic resonance angiography and ultrasound -3.8 (15)%. The level of agreement was greater for the more tightly stenosed vessels. With the assumption that the results of the digital subtraction angiogram reflect the true situation, the sensitivity and specificity in the detection of > or = 30% stenoses were 93% and 82% with ultrasound and 89% and 82% with magnetic resonance angiography; for stenoses > or = 70% 93% and 92% with ultrasound and 90% and 95% with magnetic resonance angiography; and for stenoses of 70-99% 89% and 93% with ultrasound and 86% and 93% with magnetic resonance angiography. For occlusion the values were 93% and 99% with ultrasound and 80% and 99% with magnetic resonance angiography. Increased sensitivity and specificity were obtained when analysis was confined to those vessels in which ultrasound and magnetic resonance angiography were in agreement over classification. It is thus possible to accurately categorize the degree of stenosis of the extracranial internal carotid artery from a combination of ultrasound and magnetic resonance angiography. The adoption of this combination for the investigation of patients before carotid endarterectomy removes the risk associated with conventional angiography and represents an important advance in the management of carotid stenosis.

Reappraisal of duplex criteria to assess significant carotid stenosis with special reference to reports from the North American Symptomatic Carotid Endarterectomy Trial and the European Carotid Surgery Trial

PURPOSE

Duplex examination is today the principal initial method of assessing extracranial carotid or vertebral artery disease. However, varying haemodynamic criteria have been described to categorize the degree of internal carotid artery stenosis, and similarly the degree of stenosis detected with angiography has been assessed with different methods as highlighted in studies performed by the North American Symptomatic Carotid Endarterectomy Trial and the European Carotid Surgery Trial. This study looks at the correlation between two commonly used methods of assessing carotid artery stenosis with duplex criteria and the two methods of angiographic interpretation used in these trials. Duplex parameters are also identified to determine the greater than 70% stenosis group identified as at risk in these studies.

METHODS

A total of 120 carotid bifurcations were studied in patients who underwent both carotid duplex and angiography. Correlations of duplex with angiography were assessed with duplex criteria described by Zwiebel and by Strandness and the angiographic methods used in studies performed by the North American Symptomatic Carotid Endarterectomy Trial and the European Carotid Surgery Trial. Receiver operator curves were constructed from the duplex data for the detection of stenosis greater than 70% based on the angiographic assessment used in the study performed by the North American Symptomatic Carotid Endarterectomy Trial.

RESULTS

The duplex criteria described by Zwiebel and Strandness differed in their accuracy depending on which of the two methods was used to report the angiograms. Zwiebel's criteria agreed more with the angiographic method used in the study performed by the European Carotid Surgery Trial (sensitivity 98%, specificity 81%, accuracy 88%), whereas Strandness' criteria agreed more with the angiographic method used in the study performed by the North American Symptomatic Carotid Endarterectomy Trial (sensitivity 96%, specificity 85%, accuracy 89%). For the detection of a stenosis greater than 70%, a peak systolic velocity greater than 270 cm/sec and end diastolic velocity greater than 110 cm/sec provided a sensitivity of 96%, specificity of 91%, and accuracy of 93%.

CONCLUSIONS

The accuracy of duplex studies compared with angiography in the assessment of extracranial vascular disease depends on the method of angiographic determination of carotid stenosis. Vascular laboratories should validate the duplex criteria they use against a standard method of angiographic assessment of carotid artery stenosis, with special reference to the recently reported studies noting the significance of a stenosis greater than 70% in patients with symptoms.

The diagnostic accuracy of duplex ultrasonography for evaluating carotid bifurcation

BACKGROUND

In many medical centers the standard preoperative study for patients undergoing carotid endarterectomy is four-vessel carotid arteriography, but duplex scanning of the carotid bifurcation is also reported to be highly accurate for detecting stenotic or occluded carotid arteries.

METHODS

The diagnostic accuracy of duplex ultrasonography was evaluated in a study of 774 carotid bifurcations, in 400 patients comparing the degree of predicted internal carotid artery (ICA) stenosis found using that technique, with that found by contrast arteriography. Agreement between the predicted degree of ICA stenosis and the arteriographic measurement was evaluated using the Spearman rank order correlation. Accuracy statistics for duplex scanning as a diagnostic modality were assessed using 2 x 2 tables.

RESULTS

The Spearman rank order correlation coefficient was 0.74 (P = 0) for the symptomatic group, 0.65 (P = 0) for the asymptomatic group, and 0.68 (P = 0) for the total group. The accuracy of duplex ultrasonography for detecting all grades of ICA stenosis ranged from 80% to 97%.

CONCLUSIONS

Duplex ultrasonography of the carotid bifurcation is a reliable diagnostic tool and can be used as the sole preoperative study for selected patients with extracranial cerebrovascular disease. Our current algorithm is discussed in conjunction with a critical analysis of this large database.

Carotid endarterectomy without arteriography

Arteriography has been considered the "gold standard" for evaluation of the cerebrovascular circulation prior to carotid endarterectomy. However, arteriography is associated with a neurologic complication rate of up to 12% in certain high-risk groups. Previous studies have shown that the duplex scanner has greater sensitivity than arteriography when both are correlated to the surgical specimen. From January 1986 to December 1991 a total of 174 carotid endarterectomies were performed in 152 patients, of which 61% were symptomatic. A total of 110 carotid endarterectomies in 92 patients were performed without the use of arteriography. Of the 64 patients in whom arteriograms were obtained, 33 were made at consultation and the others for various indications. Operative findings confirmed the duplex scan findings in all cases. A total of 91% of patients had intraoperative completion arteriograms. Of the 55 patients who also had intracranial views taken, two had a 50% siphon stenosis and one patient had a small intracranial aneurysm. None of these findings would have changed our management. The overall neurologic complication rate was one (0.66%) death due to stroke and four (2.6%) patients with transient ischemic attacks. Carotid endarterectomy can be safely performed without preoperative arteriography based on a detailed history and physical examination that includes bilateral upper extremity blood pressures and a duplex scan performed by a validated laboratory.

Carotid artery occlusion: positive predictive value of duplex sonography compared with arteriography

PURPOSE

Duplex ultrasonography is an accurate, noninvasive method for diagnosing, characterizing, and classifying atherosclerotic stenoses of the extracranial carotid artery system. To date, however, no large series has studied the predictive value of duplex sonography in the diagnosis of carotid artery occlusion, an important consideration, given the marked difference in clinical treatment between patients with high-grade stenosis (surgical therapy) and those with occlusive disease (nonsurgical therapy).

METHODS

We retrospectively reviewed 158 patients with 174 occluded carotid artery segments (examined over a 6 1/2-year period) to determine the predicative value of duplex sonography in differentiating carotid artery occlusion from high-grade stenosis.

RESULTS

All patients had arteriographic correlation. Duplex ultrasonography had a positive predictive value of 92.5% (7.5% false-positive rate; 95% confidence interval, 3.6% to 11.4%) in establishing a diagnosis of carotid artery occlusion. Further analysis revealed no significant improvement in the false-positive rate with the addition of color Doppler flow imaging to high-resolution B-mode scanning and pulsed Doppler spectral analysis. Predictive value increased to 96.7% (95% confidence interval, 90.7% to 99.3%) over the last 2 years of the study, a statistically significant improvement.

CONCLUSIONS

We believe that duplex ultrasonography is an acceptably accurate method for diagnosing carotid arterial occlusion in most patients. Arteriography should be reserved for patients with symptoms who are surgical candidates to identify those who may still have a surgically correctable high-grade stenosis.

Are both color-flow duplex scanning and cerebral arteriography required prior to carotid endarterectomy?

In an attempt to eliminate the morbidity, mortality, and cost associated with arteriography, surgeons are relying increasingly on duplex scanning of the extracranial arteries as the primary preoperative evaluation prior to carotid endarterectomy (CEA). This study was initiated to evaluate the need for cerebral arteriography in the preoperative evaluation of patients for CEA. One hundred five patients undergoing 114 CEA procedures are included in a retrospective review to determine whether the addition of cerebral arteriography changed the operative management of these patients. In 58 of 105 patients (55%), color-flow duplex scanning and cerebral arteriography were performed in the workup prior to CEA. In four patients a discrepancy was found between the duplex results and the arteriogram, leading to a change in the operative approach in two. The remaining 47 patients (45%) underwent color-flow duplex scanning as the definitive preoperative study; the surgical management was altered because of the operative findings in one patient. Although color-flow duplex scanning does not provide absolute concordance with cerebral arteriography, in most instances it can be used as the definitive preoperative study prior to CEA. We define the indications for cerebral arteriography in patients undergoing CEA.

Cardiovascular ultrasound: expanding frontiers in vascular disease

Advances in cardiovascular ultrasound have included development of instrumentation providing outstanding images, as well as color spectral Doppler hemodynamic information. The increasing utilization of cardiovascular ultrasound has led to its increasing diagnostic application and accuracy in the evaluation of the patient with known or suspected cerebrovascular and peripheral vascular disease. The sensitivity of duplex ultrasound to detect carotid disease varies from 87% to 94% with a specificity of 88% to 93%. The accuracy of duplex examination for detection of peripheral venous disease, when compared to contrast venography, is high. A sensitivity of nearly 93% with a specificity of 98% has been noted. Cardiovascular ultrasound is a noninvasive technology with no known biological hazard that can be applied to the broad spectrum of patients including those who are critically ill. It is a relatively low-cost procedure when compared to other diagnostic procedures and can be performed on a serial basis. Since it provides anatomical and functional hemodynamic information, it is rapidly becoming the procedure of choice not only for diagnosis, but also for management.

Carotid endarterectomy in the elderly

The records of 146 patients 80 years of age or older who underwent 183 carotid endarterectomy operations from 1964 through 1990 were reviewed to determine surgical risk. The indications for operation were asymptomatic patients with carotid stenosis (n = 36); ipsilateral transient ischemic attacks (n = 46); ipsilateral stroke (n = 28); ipsilateral retinal embolus (n = 15); nonlateralizing symptoms (n = 40); and asymptomatic side in patients with contralateral symptoms (n = 18). Postoperatively, three patients (1.6% of operations) had a stroke with a residual deficit and three (1.6%) died. All deaths were from myocardial infarction. For comparison, during the same time period, the combined stroke with residual deficit and death rate for patients less than 80 operated upon for similar indications was 3.5%. Since 80-year-old patients have a life expectancy of at least five years, the authors conclude that elderly patients should be evaluated for carotid endarterectomy using criteria similar to that used for younger patients.

Identifying total carotid occlusion with colour flow duplex scanning

A major limitation of conventional duplex scanning is its inability reliably to differentiate severe stenosis from total occlusion of the internal carotid artery (ICA). Colour flow duplex scanning (CFS) facilitates the identification of internal and external carotid arteries, enables simultaneous evaluation of flow in multiple vessels in longitudinal and transverse views, and allows more accurate assessment of very low Doppler-shift frequencies with new "slow-flow" software technology. From July 1987 to January 1991, 9731 ICAs (4866 patients) were evaluated with CFS. Arteriography was performed in 483 of these patients (959 ICAs), and the results of the two studies were compared. Colour flow scanning was highly accurate in differentiating total occlusion from carotid stenosis. Eighty-two of 87 totally occluded ICAs were detected (sensitivity 94%) and 873 of 878 patient arteries were properly identified (specificity 99%). Positive and negative predictive values were 93 and 99%, respectively. False positive results (n = 6) were due to interpreter error (n = 4) and poor scanning technique (n = 2). All false negative results (n = 5) were the result of interpreter error. During the last 24 months of the study, no false positive or false negative results were detected, giving an accuracy of 100%. We conclude that CFS offers distinct advantages in the diagnosis of carotid occlusion, thereby overcoming the limitations of conventional duplex scanning in distinguishing total occlusion of the ICA from less severe disease, and is the method of choice for evaluating the carotid bifurcation.