Induction of human glioma-specific cytotoxic T-lymphocyte lines by autologous tumor stimulation and interleukin 2

Recent developments on immunotherapy for brain cancer

INTRODUCTION

Brain tumors are a unique class of cancers since they are anatomically shielded from normal immunosurveillance by the blood-brain barrier, lack a normal lymphatic drainage system and reside in a potently immunosuppressive environment. Of the primary brain cancers, glioblastoma multiforme (GBM) is the most common and aggressive in adults. Although treatment options include surgery, radiation and chemotherapy, the average lifespan of GBM patients remains at only 14.6 months post-diagnosis.

AREAS COVERED

A review of key cellular and molecular immune system mediators in the context of brain tumors including TGF-β, cytotoxic T cells, Tregs, CTLA-4, PD-1 and IDO is discussed. In addition, prognostic factors, currently utilized immunotherapeutic strategies, ongoing clinical trials and a discussion of new or potential immunotherapies for brain tumor patients are considered.

EXPERT OPINION

Current drugs that improve the quality of life and overall survival in patients with brain tumors, especially for GBM, are poorly effective. This disease requires a reanalysis of currently accepted treatment strategies, as well as newly designed approaches. Here, we review the fundamental aspects of immunosuppression in brain tumors, new and promising immunotherapeutic drugs as well as combinatorial strategies that focus on the simultaneous inhibition of immunosuppressive hubs, both in immune and brain tumor cells, which is critical to consider for achieving future success for the treatment of this devastating disease.

The immunology of colorectal cancer

Despite the fact that the vast majority of differentiated colorectal cancers express tumour-associated antigens (TAA's) such as Carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA) and Ep-CAM, the immune response particularly in advanced disease is often attenuated. This may result from clonal immunocyte energy to oncofetal antigens normally expressed during cell development, immune complex disease where the TAA is repeatedly shed into the circulation and tumour-induced impairments in T cell receptor recognition and stimulation. Commonly used monoclonal anti-TAA antibody therapy is also hampered by human anti-xenogeneic antibody production and by the physical distribution of the antibody into the center of tumour deposits where blood flow is limited and where tumour neovasculature is hyperpermeable. Moreover, animal models of colorectal cancer should be assessed carefully since CEA is not normally expressed, requiring the transduction of CEA cDNA into tumour xenografts or the creation of transgenic species where the mechanisms of tumour rejection are still governed by non-human antigenic histoincompatibility. All of this has resulted in the generation of novel immune constructs designed to enhance the inherent immunogenicity of colorectal cancer, using antigenic viral genomes or cytokine transduction methodology as well as the ex vivo stimulation of dendritic antigen-presenting cells or autologous tumour-infiltrating lymphocytes. Even these powerful strategies may be foiled by intratumoural mechanisms which result in excessive apoptosis of infused cells even when they have been shown in vitro to be immunocompetent and tumour-specific. This review discusses these immune approaches in colorectal cancer and their inherent limitations.

CD8+ T-cell mediated anti-tumor responses cross-reacting against 9L and RT2 rat glioma cell lines

We have shown that vaccination of animals with two distinct commonly used glioma cell lines, 9L and RT2, generated cross-reactive cellular anti-tumor immunity. Peripheral vaccination with either cell line 9L or RT2 resulted in MHC Class I restricted effector cells capable of in vitro cytolytic activity against both target 9L and RT2 cells but not the syngeneic F98 glioma cell line. In vitro cross-reactive cytolytic activity could be measured for as long as 6 months from the time of initial vaccination. Fractionation of splenic effector cells revealed the cytolytic activity to be CD8+ T-cell mediated but required CD4+ T-cells for effective antigen presentation. Anti-tumor immunity generated after vaccination with either 9L or RT2 was completely protective against subsequent subcutaneous inoculation of animals with either 9L or RT2 cells and resulted in prolonged survival in animals inoculated intracranially with either cell line. Our results suggest that despite the different methods used in their derivation, 9L and RT2 glioma cells share a common glioma antigen recognized by the cellular arm of the immune response.

Changes in the immunologic phenotype of human malignant glioma cells after passaging in vitro

Although immunotherapeutic strategies against glioblastomas have been promising both in vitro and in animal models, similar successes have not been realized in human clinical trials. One reason may be that immunotherapeutic strategies are based on prior studies that primarily have used human glioblastoma cell lines passaged in vitro, which may not accurately reflect the in vivo properties of glioblastoma cells. In this report, we used flow cytometry to quantify the expression of immunological cell surface molecules on human glioblastomas directly ex vivo (prior to any in vitro culturing) and after varying passages in vitro. Furthermore, we used ELISA to quantitate cytokine secretion after various passages in vitro. We demonstrate that in vitro culturing of established cell lines led to increases in the cell surface expression of MHC class I and ICAM-1 and secretion of IL-6 and TGF-beta(2). Furthermore, there were significant changes in the expression of MHC class I, MHC class II, B7-2, ICAM-1, and FasL when comparing ex vivo tumor cells to those after a single passage in vitro. After passaging once in vitro, there were also significant changes in the secretion of TGF-beta(2) and IL-10. This report indicates that in vitro culturing leads to significant changes in both cell surface molecules and secreted cytokines, which are known to affect the ability of immune cells to initiate an anti-tumor immune response. These changes in the immunological phenotype of glioblastomas after in vitro culturing may in part explain the limited success of immunotherapeutic strategies against glioblastomas in human clinical trials.

Glioma immunology and immunotherapy

OBJECTIVE

Despite advances in conventional therapy, the prognosis for most glioma patients remains dismal. This has prompted an intensive search for effective treatment alternatives. Immunotherapy, one such alternative, has long been recognized as a potentially potent cancer treatment but has been limited by an inadequate understanding of the immune system. Now, increased insight into immunology is suggesting more rational approaches to immunotherapy. In this article, we explore key aspects of modern immunology and discuss their implications for glioma therapy.

METHODS

A thorough literature review of glioma immunology and immunotherapy was undertaken to inquire into the basic immunology, central nervous system immunology, glioma immunobiology, standard glioma immunotherapy, and recent immunotherapeutic advances in glioma treatment.

RESULTS

Although gliomas express tumor-associated antigens and appear potentially sensitive to immune responses, many factors work together to inhibit antiglioma immunity. Not surprisingly, most clinical attempts at glioma immunotherapy have met with little success to date. However, novel immunostimulatory strategies, such as immunogene therapy, directed cytokine delivery, and dendritic cell manipulation, have recently yielded dramatic preclinical results in glioma models. This suggests that glioma-derived immunosuppression can be overcome.

CONCLUSION

Modern molecular biology and immunology techniques have yielded a wealth of new data about glioma immunobiology. Armed with this information, many investigators have proposed novel means to stimulate antiglioma immune responses. Although definitive clinical results remain to be seen, the current renaissance in glioma immunology and immunotherapy shows great promise for the future.

HLA restriction and T-cell-receptor V beta gene expression of cytotoxic T lymphocytes reactive with human squamous-cell carcinoma of the head and neck

A human cytotoxic-T-lymphocyte (CTL) line capable of killing autologous tumor (AuTu) cell targets was established from peripheral-blood lymphocytes of a patient with squamous-cell carcinoma of the tongue. The cultured CTL were CD3+CD8+CD11b-HLA-DR+T cell receptor (TCR) alpha/beta+. When tested in 4-hr 51Cr-release assays against various lines of squamous-cell carcinoma of the head and neck (SCCHN) and a variety of non-squamous human tumor and normal cell targets, the CTL were found to lyse the autologous SCCHN cell line (PCI-50) and 7 allogeneic SCCHN lines: PCI-1, -2, -4A, -4B, -13, -30 and -38. Of these tumor cell lines, PCI-13, -30 and -38 shared HLA-A2 locus with the AuTu, PCI-50, while PCI-4A and -4B shared HLA-B44 with AuTu. Lysis of AuTu (A2+B44+), PCI-13 (A2+B44-) and PCI-4B (A2- B44+) by the CTL was efficiently inhibited by monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) to CD3, CD8, TCR alpha/beta or the major-histocompatibility-complex (MHC)-class-I antigens. MAbs to HLA-A2 antigens inhibited lysis of PCI-50 or PCI-13 targets by the CTL. In cold-target inhibition assays, unlabeled PCI-4B or PCI-13 cells inhibited CTL lysis of AuTu targets. The CTL incubated in the presence of the HLA-A2+ SCCHN PCI-50 or -13, but not an HLA-A2+ gastric carcinoma, produced TNF-alpha, IFN-gamma and GM-CSF. The CTL were tested for their TCR V beta gene expression by polymerase chain reaction (PCR). At week 10 in culture, the time of the highest AuTu cytotoxicity mediated by the CTL line, V beta 6 was expressed by 26% of T cells. Three clones, obtained by limiting dilution from 10-week CTL and selected for high cytotoxicity against AuTu, were found to be V beta6+. Further analysis of the specificity of these clones indicated lytic activity against PCI-13 (A2+B44-), but not PCI-4B (A2-B44+) targets. In 16-week cultures, which retained AuTu cytotoxicity as well as V beta 6 expression, TCR V beta 2 was also expressed at high frequency (29%), and AuTu-reactive clones were found to be V beta 2+. Our results indicate that at least 2 different CTL populations (V beta 6+ and V beta 2+) are able to recognize SCCHN-associated antigen(s) and that the V beta 6+ T cells are HLA-A2 restricted, while V beta 2+ T cells may be HLA-B44 restricted.

Generation of cytotoxic immune responses during the progression of a rat glioma

Cytotoxic T lymphocytes specific for tumor-associated antigens are produced by exposing animals to tumor cells and stimulating lymphocytes from animals immunized in vitro with tumor cells and small amounts of interleukin-2 (IL-2). This study was designed to determine whether a fast-growing immunogenic avian sarcoma virus-induced glioma produces primed cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursors during its progression. Lymphocytes from intracerebral glioma-bearing rats generally failed to proliferate in vitro in response to immunization with tumor cells and IL-2 and, when proliferative responses were observed, the lymphocytes were not cytotoxic for glioma cells. However, when the same tumor was growing subcutaneously, lymphocytes proliferated and exhibited glioma-specific cytotoxicity when stimulated in vitro with autologous tumor cells and IL-2. Subcutaneous immunization of intracerebral glioma-bearing rats with tumor cells and adjuvant induced strong cytotoxic T lymphocyte responses. The results demonstrated that, while intracerebral tumor progression itself does not induce an anti-glioma immune response, immune responses to tumor-associated antigens may be induced by systemic immunization of tumor-bearing animals. The results suggest that the immunogenicity of brain tumors is masked by the immunologically privileged status of the brain, not by the induction of generalized immune suppression during tumor progression.

Generation of cellular immune responses against a glioma-associated antigen(s)

The study demonstrated that RT2, a highly malignant anaplastic glioma, expresses antigens that make it susceptible to in vivo adoptive immunotherapy with cytotoxic T lymphocyte-containing immune cell populations. Rats were immunized with irradiated RT2 tumor cells and the adjuvant C. parvum. Lymphocytes from immunized rats were restimulated in vitro with irradiated RT2 tumor cells plus interleukin-2 (IL-2). The cells that proliferated and differentiated in vitro effectively killed RT2, but only low levels of cytotoxicity were observed against other histopathologically related and unrelated, syngeneic and allogeneic target cells. Adoptive transfer of immune cells combined with a 5-day course of systemic IL-2 produced specific regression of brain tumors growing as lung microfoci.

Generation of cytotoxic immune responses against a rat glioma by in vivo priming and secondary in vitro stimulation with tumor cells

Cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) responses to most antigens are generated by in vivo priming and secondary stimulation with antigen in vitro. The present studies were designed to determine whether that strategy could be used to stimulate development of CTL against brain tumors. Rats were primed with one of two tumors, RT2, an astrocytoma, or 9L, a gliosarcoma, and Corynebacterium parvum. Spleen cells from primed rats were stimulated with tumor cells and interleukin-2 in vitro to generate CTL. CTL generated against RT2 killed RT2 and 9L, but not allogeneic or histopathologically unrelated tumor cells, suggesting that the killing was brain tumor-specific and major histocompatibility complex gene product-restricted. Similar results were obtained with rats primed and secondarily stimulated with 9L. Specific cytotoxic cells only developed when syngeneic brain tumor cells were used for both priming and secondary stimulation. The cytotoxic cell populations were composed of OX-19+ T cells with a mixed CD4/CD8 phenotype. Controls consisting of spleen cells from unprimed or primed rats tested before culture exhibited low levels of cytotoxicity against brain tumor targets. Culturing unprimed or primed cells with interleukin-2 alone stimulated cell proliferation, but the cells that grew out exhibited only low levels of cytotoxicity for brain tumor cells. Cell populations exhibited consistent cytotoxicity against natural killer cell targets. None of the cell populations killed lymphokine-activated killer cell targets. The results demonstrated that brain tumor-specific CTL could be produced by priming in vivo followed by secondary stimulation with brain tumor cells in vitro. The results further demonstrated that RT2 and 9L share antigens that both induce and serve as target structures for specific cytotoxic cells.

Sustained outgrowth of autotumor-reactive T lymphocytes from human ovarian carcinomas in the presence of tumor necrosis factor alpha and interleukin 2

Tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes (TIL) freshly isolated from human ovarian carcinomas were phenotyped (up to 75% CD3+ HLA-DR+ cells) and cultured in the presence of recombinant interleukin 2 and tumor necrosis factor alpha. In short-term cultures, an initial outgrowth of CD3+ CD8+ T lymphocytes resulted in the enrichment of autotumor cytotoxicity under these culture conditions. The early peak of autotumor cytotoxicity was accompanied by interleukin 1 beta and interferon gamma production. The RNA message for interferon gamma was detected by in situ hybridization in TIL induced with interleukin 2 and tumor necrosis factor alpha but not in freshly isolated TIL. A combination of interleukin 2 and tumor necrosis factor alpha was also advantageous for selective outgrowth of CD3+ CD8+ T lymphocytes with autotumor reactivity in long-term cultures of ovarian TIL. At days 30-40 of growth, total lytic units of autotumor cytotoxicity per culture increased from a mean of 59 to 2155, and the percentage of CD3+ CD8+ T lymphocytes rose to 98% in some of the cultures. Thus, the combination of interleukin 2 and tumor necrosis factor alpha provided conditions favorable for sustained growth of autotumor-reactive CD3+ CD8+ TIL in vitro.

Immunology of central nervous system tumors

With progress in cellular immunology and the development of hybridoma technology, the idea of manipulating host-tumor immune interactions to improve the prognosis of brain tumors has aroused renewed interest. Although no brain tumor-specific antigens have been found, and in spite of the wide antigenic heterogeneity of brain tumor cells, some monoclonal antibodies possessing restricted specificity have been isolated and their potential clinical applications investigated. One of the most pronounced changes in the cellular immune responses of brain tumor patients is a profound depression of the T4-helper lymphocytes. Clinical and laboratory trials are under way to assess the ability of lymphokines, such as gamma-interferon or interleukin-2, to restore immunologic competence in these patients and potentiate a specific anti-tumor immunologic response. Recent work suggests that the endothelium-astrocyte complex may have a pivotal role in assisting the escape of brain tumors from the host's immunologic responses, since it is responsible for the intracerebral sequestration of antigens and local anti-tumor responses. In this review, the data on the antigenic properties of central nervous system tumors and the host's humoral and cellular immune responses to them are analyzed and potential immunologic therapies are discussed.

Immunomagnetic separation of infiltrating T lymphocytes from brain tumors

Tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes (TIL's) were isolated from human glioma biopsy specimens by immunomagnetic separation using T cell-specific monoclonal antibodies coupled to paramagnetic beads, and were expanded in culture with feeder cells and interleukin-2 (IL-2). The infiltrating cells from five of seven patients proliferated in culture. When tested after 2 to 3 weeks of culture, virtually all of the cells stained with antibodies against the CD2 and CD3 antigens. Most cells also expressed human leukocyte antigen class II molecules, while varying percentages of cells stained with antibodies against the IL-2 receptor and the CD4 and CD8 antigens. The cytotoxicity of the cultured TIL's against autologous and allogeneic glioma cells and the K562 and Daudi cell lines was measured and compared with that of lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cells from the same patients. None of the TIL's showed significant cytotoxicity against these targets, whereas LAK cells lysed all of the targets.

Human interleukin-2 activated cytotoxic cells kill autologous glioma cells in vitro

We have cultured peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) from glioblastoma patients in recombinant interleukin-2 (IL-2) containing medium for a period of 5 days. The cytotoxicity of these cells was tested on 51Cr-labelled autologous dissociated glioblastoma cells which had not been cultured. Significant cytotoxicity against glioma cells was observed in seven out of nine cases. IL-2 activated PBL from normal donors were equally cytotoxic against these glioma cells. Autologous lymphocytes activated by phytohaemagglutinin were also lysed in most cases, and the erythroleukemia cell line K562 was highly susceptible to the cytotoxic capability of the IL-2 activated PBL. In cold target inhibition experiments, K562 inhibited the cytotoxicity against both autologous and allogenic glioma cells, and glioma cells inhibited the cytotoxicity against K562. Following immunomagnetic separation, the IL-2 activated cells demonstrated cytotoxicity against glioma cells, K562 cells, and PHA blasts in both the CD8+ and the CD8- subsets.

In situ characterization, clonogenic potential, and antitumor cytolytic activity of T lymphocytes infiltrating human brain cancers

Mononuclear cells infiltrating human brain tumors were isolated from seven of nine surgical biopsy specimens. These cells were small T11+, T3+ lymphocytes that did not express DR antigens or the receptor for interleukin-2. In addition, large granular lymphocytes were recovered from two of these tumors. The clonogenic potential of tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes (TIL's) was assessed by limiting-dilution analysis (LDA) using a microculture system that permits proliferation of virtually 100% of normal peripheral blood T lymphocytes (PBL-T's). In comparison to normal and autologous PBL-T's, TIL's had a strikingly reduced proliferative potential revealed by a decrease in the frequency of proliferating T lymphocyte precursors calculated by LDA. On average, only one of every 100 T cells from TIL's was able to proliferate, as compared to one of every two or all of the T cells from the patient's peripheral blood or from normal donors. Furthermore, the TIL populations showed depressed proliferative responses to the lectins phytohemagglutinin and concanavalin A and to the phorbol ester 12-0-tetradecanoyl-phorbol-13-acetate. Clonal analysis performed on the proliferating microcultures from three tumors demonstrated that the majority of these clones possessed cytolytic activity against various tumor cell targets. Among clones tested for cytolytic activities with glioma cells, four lysed cultured autologous tumor cells, and the specific lysis was greater than 50% in all cases. Numerous clones with natural killer (NK)-like activity were obtained from two TIL preparations, and the frequency of cytolytic T lymphocyte precursors with NK-like activity was determined for one of these preparations and was found to be higher than that in the patient's peripheral blood. Glioma cells grown in culture and then mixed with normal peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL's) were capable of inhibiting the PBL's response to lectins. This inhibitory property may account in part for the observed poor clonogenicity of TIL's from brain tumors. Nevertheless, nearly all proliferating clones displayed cytotoxicity against either autologous or allogeneic tumor cell targets and may imply selective accumulation of cytolytic effector cells at the tumor site.