Germinal HPRT splice donor site mutation results in multiple RNA splicing products in T-lymphocyte cultures

Lesch-Nyhan Syndrome: Models, Theories, and Therapies

Lesch-Nyhan syndrome (LNS) is a rare X-linked disorder caused by mutations in HPRT1, an important enzyme in the purine salvage pathway. Symptoms of LNS include dystonia, gout, intellectual disability, and self-mutilation. Despite having been characterized over 50 years ago, it remains unclear precisely how deficits in hypoxanthine and guanine recycling can lead to such a profound neurological phenotype. Several studies have proposed different hypotheses regarding the etiology of this disease, and several treatments have been tried in patients, though none have led to a satisfactory explanation of the disease. New technologies such as next-generation sequencing, optogenetics, genome editing, and induced pluripotent stem cells provide a unique opportunity to map the precise sequential pathways leading from genotype to phenotype.

Phenotypic variation among seven members of one family with deficiency of hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyltransferase

We describe a family of seven boys affected by Lesch-Nyhan disease with various phenotypes. Further investigations revealed a mutation c.203T>C in the gene encoding HGprt of all members, with substitution of leucine to proline at residue 68 (p.Leu68Pro). Thus patients from this family display a wide variety of symptoms although sharing the same mutation. Mutant HGprt enzyme was prepared by site-directed mutagenesis and the kinetics of the enzyme revealed that the catalytic activity of the mutant was reduced, in association with marked reductions in the affinity towards phosphoribosylpyrophosphate (PRPP). Its Km for PRPP was increased 215-fold with hypoxanthine as substrate and 40-fold with guanine as substrate with associated reduced catalytic potential. Molecular modeling confirmed that the most prominent defect was the dramatically reduced affinity towards PRPP. Our studies suggest that the p.Leu68Pro mutation has a strong impact on PRPP binding and on stability of the active conformation. This suggests that factors other than HGprt activity per se may influence the phenotype of Lesch-Nyhan patients.

Genotype-phenotype correlations in neurogenetics: Lesch-Nyhan disease as a model disorder

Establishing meaningful relationships between genetic variations and clinical disease is a fundamental goal for all human genetic disorders. However, these genotype-phenotype correlations remain incompletely characterized and sometimes conflicting for many diseases. Lesch-Nyhan disease is an X-linked recessive disorder that is caused by a wide variety of mutations in the HPRT1 gene. The gene encodes hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyl transferase, an enzyme involved in purine metabolism. The fine structure of enzyme has been established by crystallography studies, and its function can be measured with very precise biochemical assays. This rich knowledge of genetic alterations in the gene and their functional effect on its protein product provides a powerful model for exploring factors that influence genotype-phenotype correlations. The present study summarizes 615 known genetic mutations, their influence on the gene product, and their relationship to the clinical phenotype. In general, the results are compatible with the concept that the overall severity of the disease depends on how mutations ultimately influence enzyme activity. However, careful evaluation of exceptions to this concept point to several additional genetic and non-genetic factors that influence genotype-phenotype correlations. These factors are not unique to Lesch-Nyhan disease, and are relevant to most other genetic diseases. The disease therefore serves as a valuable model for understanding the challenges associated with establishing genotype-phenotype correlations for other disorders.

Levodopa is not a useful treatment for Lesch-Nyhan disease

Lesch-Nyhan disease (LND) is characterized by dystonia, cognitive abnormalities, and self-injurious behavior. No effective therapies are available. LND is associated with a presynaptic dopaminergic deficit, but the reported effects of dopamine replacement therapy are conflicting. The current prospective open-label study assesses the effects of levodopa on both neurological and behavioral features of LND. All 6 study participants discontinued levodopa early, due to lack of effect and sometimes worsening of motor function. The results provide important clues for pathophysiological mechanisms and suggestions for future treatment options.

Mechanisms for phenotypic variation in Lesch-Nyhan disease and its variants

Lesch-Nyhan disease is a neurogenetic disorder caused by mutation of the HPRT1 gene on the X chromosome. There is significant variation in the clinical phenotype, with more than 300 different known mutations. There are few studies that have addressed whether similar mutations result in similar phenotypes across different patients because hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyltransferase (HGprt) deficiency is rare, and most mutations are unique or limited to individual families. However, recent studies have revealed multiple unrelated patients with similar mutations, providing an opportunity to examine genotype-phenotype correlations. We found significant variation among the clinical features of 10 patients from 8 unrelated families all carrying a mutation replacing guanine with adenine at base position 143 (c.143G>A) in the HPRT1 gene. This mutation results in replacement of arginine by histidine at amino acid position 48 (p.arg48his) in the HGprt enzyme. Biochemically, the enzyme exhibits reduced thermal integrity, a mechanism that may explain clinical variation. The literature reveals similar clinical variation among other patients with similar mutations, although the variation is relatively minor across the whole population of patients. Identifiable sources of clinical variation include known limitations of clinical ascertainment and mechanisms that affect residual enzyme activity and stability. These results are helpful for understanding genotype-phenotype correlations and discordance and likely are applicable to other neurogenetic disorders where similar variation occurs.

Attenuated variants of Lesch-Nyhan disease

Lesch–Nyhan disease is a neurogenetic disorder caused by deficiency of the enzyme hypoxanthine–guanine phosphoribosyltransferase. The classic form of the disease is described by a characteristic syndrome that includes overproduction of uric acid, severe generalized dystonia, cognitive disability and self-injurious behaviour. In addition to the classic disease, variant forms of the disease occur wherein some clinical features are absent or unusually mild. The current studies provide the results of a prospective and multi-centre international study focusing on neurological manifestations of the largest cohort of Lesch–Nyhan disease variants evaluated to date, with 46 patients from 3 to 65 years of age coming from 34 families. All had evidence for overproduction of uric acid. Motor abnormalities were evident in 42 (91%), ranging from subtle clumsiness to severely disabling generalized dystonia. Cognitive function was affected in 31 (67%) but it was never severe. Though none exhibited self-injurious behaviours, many exhibited behaviours that were maladaptive. Only three patients had no evidence of neurological dysfunction. Our results were compared with a comprehensive review of 78 prior reports describing a total of 127 Lesch–Nyhan disease variants. Together these results define the spectrum of clinical features associated with hypoxanthine–guanine phosphoribosyltransferase deficiency. At one end of the spectrum are patients with classic Lesch–Nyhan disease and the full clinical phenotype. At the other end of the spectrum are patients with overproduction of uric acid but no apparent neurological or behavioural deficits. Inbetween are patients with varying degrees of motor, cognitive, or behavioural abnormalities. Recognition of this spectrum is valuable for understanding the pathogenesis and diagnosis of all forms of hypoxanthine–guanine phosphoribosyltransferase deficiency.

Delineation of the motor disorder of Lesch-Nyhan disease

Lesch-Nyhan disease (LND) is caused by deficiency of the purine salvage enzyme hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyltransferase (HPRT). Affected individuals exhibit over-production of uric acid, along with a characteristic neurobehavioural syndrome that includes mental retardation, recurrent self-injurious behaviour and motor disability. Prior studies involving relatively small numbers of patients have provided different conclusions on the nature of the motor disorder. The current study includes the results of a multi-centre international prospective study of the motor disorder in the largest cohort of patients studied to date. A total of 44 patients ranging from 2 to 38 years presented a characteristic motor syndrome that involved severe action dystonia superimposed on baseline hypotonia. Although some patients also displayed other extrapyramidal or pyramidal signs, these were always less prominent than dystonia. These results are compared with a comprehensive review of 122 prior reports that included a total of 254 patients. Explanations for the differing observations available in the literature are provided, along with a summary of how the motor disorder of LND relates to current understanding of its pathophysiology involving the basal ganglia.

Lesch-Nyhan disease in a female with a clinically normal monozygotic twin

Lesch-Nyhan disease (LND) is an inborn error of purine metabolism caused by defective activity of the enzyme hypoxanthine guanine phosphoribosyl transferase (HPRT, EC 2.4.2.8), resulting from mutation in the corresponding gene on the long arm of the X chromosome (Xq26). The classic phenotype occurs almost exclusively in males and is characterized by hyperuricemia, mental retardation, severe dystonia, and self-injurious behavior. Heterozygous carrier females are usually clinically normal. However, a small number of clinically affected females have been described. In all previous cases there was a mutation in one HPRT allele and non-random inactivation of the X chromosome carrying the normal HPRT gene. We have analyzed a female MZ twin pair discordant for Lesch-Nyhan disease. The mother and both twins are heterozygous carriers of a HPRT splicing mutation (IVS8 + 4A > G; c.609 + 4A > G) and all three express the mutant allele at similar frequencies in peripheral blood T cells. The mother and one sister are clinically normal. In the affected twin, the clinical phenotype is classical for Lesch-Nyhan disease, despite the fact that HPRT activity in the blood was also normal. X inactivation analysis showed a skewed pattern in the fibroblasts of the affected twin sister, with the X chromosome carrying the normal HPRT allele preferentially inactivated. As in many other reported cases of X-linked diseases, the discordant phenotype of the two monozygous twin sisters suggests that the process responsible for monozygotic twinning can trigger skewed X inactivation.

Mutation Carrier Testing in Lesch-Nyhan Syndrome Families: HPRT Mutant Frequency and Mutation Analysis with Peripheral Blood T Lymphocytes

Mutations in the X chromosome hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyl transferase (HPRT) gene are responsible for Lesch-Nyhan syndrome and related diseases in humans. Because the gene is on the X chromosome, males are affected and females in the families are at risk of being carriers of the mutation. Because there are so many different mutations that can cause the disease (218 different mutations in 271 families), genetic testing for carrier status of females requires detailed molecular analysis of the familial mutation. This analysis can be complicated by the unavailability of an affected male for study. In addition, when the mutation is a deletion (34 reported instances), molecular analysis in females is difficult because of the two X chromosomes. We have applied a peripheral blood T lymphocyte cloning assay that uses resistance to the purine analogue 6-thioguanine (TG) to measure the frequency of cells in females expressing a mutant HPRT allele to determine mutation carrier status in 123 females in 61 families. In families in which the HPRT mutation was determined and could be easily analyzed in samples from females, we found a mean (+/- SD) mutant frequency of 9.7 (+/- 8.7) x 10(-6) in noncarrier females and 2.9 (+/- 3.0) x 10(-2) in carrier females. The frequency in carrier females is less than the 0.5 expected for nonrandom X inactivation because of in vivo selection against HPRT mutation-expressing T lymphocytes or stem cells during prenatal development. The use of this cloning assay allows determination of the carrier status of females even when the HPRT mutation is not yet known or is difficult to determine in DNA samples from females. This approach provides a rapid assay that yields information on carrier status within 10 days of sample receipt.

Intrinsic differences between authentic and cryptic 5' splice sites

Cryptic splice sites are used only when use of a natural splice site is disrupted by mutation. To determine the features that distinguish authentic from cryptic 5' splice sites (5'ss), we systematically analyzed a set of 76 cryptic 5'ss derived from 46 human genes. These cryptic 5'ss have a similar frequency distribution in exons and introns, and are usually located close to the authentic 5'ss. Statistical analysis of the strengths of the 5'ss using the Shapiro and Senapathy matrix revealed that authentic 5'ss have significantly higher score values than cryptic 5'ss, which in turn have higher values than the mutant ones. beta-Globin provides an interesting exception to this rule, so we chose it for detailed experimental analysis in vitro. We found that the sequences of the beta-globin authentic and cryptic 5'ss, but not their surrounding context, determine the correct 5'ss choice, although their respective scores do not reflect this functional difference. Our analysis provides a statistical basis to explain the competitive advantage of authentic over cryptic 5'ss in most cases, and should facilitate the development of tools to reliably predict the effect of disease-associated 5'ss-disrupting mutations at the mRNA level.

Childhood hyperuricemia and acute renal failure resulting from a missense mutation in the HPRT gene

A 6-year-old boy was determined to have partial hypoxanthine phosphoribosyl transferase (HPRT) enzyme deficiency without the phenotypic features of Lesch-Nyhan syndrome. He presented with recurrent acute renal failure (ARF) from hyperuricemia. Treatment with allopurinol prevented further attacks of renal failure. T lymphocyte cultures were used to sequence the HPRT cDNA and a novel single nucleotide substitution at codon 65 in exon 3 was found (193C>T, 65leu>phe). This mutation was confirmed by genomic DNA sequencing and was also detected in his heterozygous, asymptomatic mother and sister. Unlike the cells from patients with classic Lesch-Nyhan syndrome, the in vitro cultures of our patient's T-lymphocytes did not proliferate in the presence of purine analogue 6-thioguanine (TG). This report highlights the unusual occurrence of recurrent ARF in a child with partial HPRT enzyme deficiency. The absence of TG resistance in vitro with this mutation shows that even small alterations in enzyme activity in vivo can result in disease symptoms, in this instance, hyperuricemia sufficient to cause ARF. Atypical HPRT mutations should also be considered in cases of unusual renal failure, because correct diagnosis can allow appropriate treatment, as well as informed genetic counseling.

Molecular description of three macro-deletions and an Alu-Alu recombination-mediated duplication in the HPRT gene in four patients with Lesch-Nyhan disease

Mutations in the HPRT gene cause a spectrum of diseases that ranges from hyperuricemia alone to hyperuricemia with profound neurological and behavioral dysfunction. The extreme phenotype is termed Lesch-Nyhan syndrome. In 271 cases in which the germinal HPRT mutation has been characterized, 218 different mutations have been found. Of these, 34 (13%) are large- (macro-) deletions of one exon or greater and four (2%) are partial gene duplications. The deletion breakpoint junctions have been defined for only three of the 34 macro-deletions. The molecular basis of two of the four duplications has been defined. We report here the breakpoint junctions for three new deletion mutations, encompassing exons 4-8 (20033bp), exons 4 and 5 (13307bp) and exons 5 and 6 (9454bp), respectively. The deletion breakpoints were defined by a combination of long polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplifications, and conventional PCR and DNA sequencing. All three deletions are the result of non-homologous recombinations. A fourth mutation, a duplication of exons 2 and 3, is the result of an Alu-mediated homologous recombination between identical 19bp sequences in introns 3 and 1. In toto, two of three germinal HPRT duplication mutations appear to have been caused by Alu-mediated homologous recombination, while only one of six deletion mutations appears to have resulted from this type of recombination mechanism. The other five deletion mutations resulted from non-homologous recombination. With this admittedly limited number of characterized macro-mutations, Alu-mediated unequal homologous recombinations account for at least 8% (3 of 38) of the macro-alterations and 1% (3 of 271) of the total HPRT germinal mutations.

The spectrum of hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyltransferase (HPRT) deficiency. Clinical experience based on 22 patients from 18 Spanish families

The enzyme hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyltransferase (HPRT) catalyzes the reutilization of hypoxanthine and guanine to the purine nucleotides IMP and GMP, respectively. HPRT deficiency is an X-linked disorder characterized by uric acid overproduction and variable neurologic impairment. The complete deficiency of HPRT is diagnostic of Lesch-Nyhan syndrome manifested by choreoathetosis, spasticity, mental retardation, and self-injurious behavior. In some HPRT-deficient patients the enzyme defect appeared to be "partial" and the neurologic symptoms mild to severe (Kelley-Seegmiller syndrome). This has prompted the classification of HPRT deficiency in 2 distinct groups: Lesch-Nyhan syndrome and Kelley-Seegmiller syndrome, which has created much confusion. A spectrum of clinical consequences of HPRT deficiency has been recognized in small series of patients, but the complete spectrum of the neurologic disorder has not been described in a single series of patients examined by the same observers. We analyzed our experience with 22 patients belonging to 18 different families with HPRT deficiency diagnosed at "La Paz" University Hospital in Madrid over the past 16 years. The clinical spectrum of these HPRT-deficient Spanish patients was similar to the different phenotypes occasionally reported in the literature, in some cases diagnosed as Lesch-Nyhan "variants." The clinical, biochemical, enzymatic, and molecular genetic studies on these 22 patients allowed us to delineate a new classification of HPRT deficiency. Based on the neurologic symptoms, dependency for personal care, HPRT activity in hemolysate and in intact erythrocytes, and predicted protein size, patients were classified into 4 groups: Group 1 (2 patients), normal development with no neurologic symptoms, HPRT activity was detectable in hemolysates and in intact erythrocytes, and the mutation did not affect the predicted protein size. Group 2 (3 patients) mild neurologic symptoms that did not prevent independent lives, HPRT activity was detectable in intact erythrocytes, and the protein size was normal. Group 3 (2 patients), severe neurologic impairment that precluded an independent life, no residual HPRT activity, and normal protein size. Group 4 (15 patients), clinical characteristics of Lesch-Nyhan syndrome (some may not show self-injurious behavior), no residual HPRT activity, and in most (7 of 8 patients in whom the mutation could be detected) the mutation affected the predicted protein size. This classification of HPRT deficiency into 4 groups may be more useful in terms of accuracy, reproducibility, assessment for treatment trials and prognosis. The study of this Spanish series allows us to conclude that HPRT deficiency may be manifested by a wide spectrum of neurologic symptoms; the overall severity of the disease is associated with mutations permitting some degree of residual enzyme activity; and mutation analysis provides a valuable tool for prognosis, carrier identification, and prenatal diagnosis.

The spectrum of inherited mutations causing HPRT deficiency: 75 new cases and a review of 196 previously reported cases

In humans, mutations in the gene encoding the purine salvage enzyme hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyltransferase (HPRT) are associated with a spectrum of disease that ranges from hyperuricemia alone to hyperuricemia with profound neurological and behavioral dysfunction. Previous attempts to correlate different types or locations of mutations with different elements of the disease phenotype have been limited by the relatively small numbers of available cases. The current article describes the molecular genetic basis for 75 new cases of HPRT deficiency, reviews 196 previously reported cases, and summarizes four main conclusions that may be derived from the entire database of 271 mutations. First, the mutations associated with human disease appear dispersed throughout the hprt gene, with some sites appearing to represent relative mutational hot spots. Second, genotype-phenotype correlations provide no indication that specific disease features associate with specific mutation locations. Third, cases with less severe clinical manifestations typically have mutations that are predicted to permit some degree of residual enzyme function. Fourth, the nature of the mutation provides only a rough guide for predicting phenotypic severity. Though mutation analysis does not provide precise information for predicting disease severity, it continues to provide a valuable tool for genetic counseling in terms of confirmation of diagnoses, for identifying potential carriers, and for prenatal diagnosis.

Lesch-Nyhan disease and the basal ganglia

The purpose of this review is to summarize emerging evidence that the neurobehavioral features of Lesch-Nyhan disease (LND), a developmental disorder caused by congenital deficiency of the purine salvage enzyme hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyltransferase (HPRT), may be attributable to dysfunction of the basal ganglia. Affected individuals have severe motor disability described by prominent extrapyramidal features that are characteristic of dysfunction of the motor circuits of the basal ganglia. They also display disturbances of ocular motility, cognition, and behavioral control that may reflect disruption of other circuits of the basal ganglia. Though neuropathologic studies of autopsy specimens have revealed no obvious neuroanatomical abnormalities in LND, neurochemical studies have demonstrated 60-90% reductions in the dopamine content of the basal ganglia. In addition, recent PET studies have documented significant reductions in dopamine transporters and [18F]fluorodopa uptake in the basal ganglia. These findings support the proposal that many of the neurobehavioral features of LND might be related to dysfunction of the basal ganglia.

Identification of a new Lesch-Nyhan syndrome mutation (HPRTBrasil) and analysis of potentially heterozygous females

The mutation in the hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyltransferase (HPRT) gene has been determined in two brothers affected with Lesch-Nyhan syndrome. Female members of the family who are at risk for being heterozygous carriers of the HPRT mutation were also studied to determine whether they carry the mutation. DNA sequencing revealed that the boys' mother is heterozygous for the mutation in her somatic cells, but that three maternal aunts are not heterozygous. Such carrier information is important for the future pregnancy plans of at-risk females. The mutation, an A-->T transversion at cDNA base 590 (590A-->T), results in an amino acid change of glutamic acid to valine at codon 197, and has not been reported previously in a Lesch-Nyhan syndrome male. This mutation is designated HPRTBrasil.

Molecular bases of hprt mutations in malathion-treated human T-lymphocytes

Recently, we reported that 6 of 84 (7.1%) hprt mutants arising in in vitro malathion-treated human T-lymphocytes were characterized by specific genomic deletions in a 125-bp region of exon 3 (Pluth et al., Cancer Research 56 (1996) 2393-2399. We have now extended study to determine whether additional differences in molecular spectrum at a basepair level exist between control and malathion-treated mutations, and investigated whether there is evidence to support the hypothesis that malathion is an alkylating agent. We analyzed 101 hprt mutants (24 from control and 77 from treated cultures) isolated form six in vitro malathion exposures of T-lymphocytes from four healthy male donors. Analysis consisted of: Southern blotting, genomic multiplex PCR, genomic DNA sequencing and reverse transcription of PCR amplification (RT/PCR) and sequencing of the cDNA product. Mutations at several basepair sites were frequent after malathion exposure and were isolated from treated cells from at least two different individuals. Using a human hprt mutation database for comparison, the frequency of mutations at one of these sites (basepair 134) was found to be significantly elevated in the malathion-treated cell (p < 0.0005). Hprt mutations in malathion-treated cells arose preferentially at G:C basepairs, which is consistent with earlier reports that malathion alkylates guanine nucleotides. Assessing molecular changes at both genomic and cDNA levels in the same mutants revealed that many small, partial exon deletions (< 20 bp) in genomic DNA were often represented in the cDNA at the loss of one or more exons. In addition, It was noted that identical genomic mutations can result in different cDNA products in different T-cell isolates. These observations affirm the importance of genomic sequence analysis in combination with RT/PCR for a more accurate definition of the mutation spectrum.

A splice site mutation in the gene of the human type I hair keratin hHa1 results in the expression of a tailless keratin isoform

In this study, we have elucidated the molecular mechanisms underlying the expression of an acidic 41-kDa protein inherited as an autosomal dominant trait of the hair keratin pattern of about 5% of the human population. We show that this protein is a size variant of the large type I hair cortex keratin hHa1 due to a genetic polymorphism in the hHa1 gene. We detected a G-A substitution in the 5' splice site of intron 6 of the hHa1 gene, which segregates with the 41-kDa protein phenotype in two pedigrees and is responsible for the formation of an abnormally spliced hHa1 mRNA species. The use of an alternative 5' splice site leads to the retention of 41 nucleotides of the initial intron 6 sequences in the mature transcript. The open reading frame of the aberrant mRNA creates a premature stop codon immediately downstream of the mutation site. The resulting hHa1 protein variant, hHa1-t, is about 6-kDa smaller than the 47-kDa hHa1 hair keratin and lacks the complete nonhelical tail domain. We show that the tailless hHa1-t is functional, since both recombinant hHa1 and hHa1-t form identical keratin intermediate filaments when assembled in vitro with a type II hair keratin partner. This finding confirms the view of a noninvolvement of the keratin tail domain in filament assembly and explains the lack of a pathological hair phenotype in hHa1-t positive individuals.