Evolution of a Protein-Folding Machine: Genomic and Evolutionary Analyses Reveal Three Lineages of the Archaeal hsp70(dnaK) Gene

Protein Quality Control is a Master Modulator of Molecular Evolution in Bacteria

The bacterial protein quality control (PQC) network comprises a set of genes that promote proteostasis (proteome homeostasis) through proper protein folding and function via chaperones, proteases, and protein translational machinery. It participates in vital cellular processes and influences organismal development and evolution. In this review, we examine the mechanistic bases for how the bacterial PQC network influences molecular evolution. We discuss the relevance of PQC components to contemporary issues in evolutionary biology including epistasis, evolvability, and the navigability of protein space. We examine other areas where proteostasis affects aspects of evolution and physiology, including host-parasite interactions. More generally, we demonstrate that the study of bacterial systems can aid in broader efforts to understand the relationship between genotype and phenotype across the biosphere.

General Structural and Functional Features of Molecular Chaperones

Molecular chaperones are a group of structurally diverse and highly conserved ubiquitous proteins. They play crucial roles in facilitating the correct folding of proteins in vivo by preventing protein aggregation or facilitating the appropriate folding and assembly of proteins. Heat shock proteins form the major class of molecular chaperones that are responsible for protein folding events in the cell. This is achieved by ATP-dependent (folding machines) or ATP-independent mechanisms (holders). Heat shock proteins are induced by a variety of stresses, besides heat shock. The large and varied heat shock protein class is categorised into several subfamilies based on their sizes in kDa namely, small Hsps (HSPB), J domain proteins (Hsp40/DNAJ), Hsp60 (HSPD/E; Chaperonins), Hsp70 (HSPA), Hsp90 (HSPC), and Hsp100. Heat shock proteins are localised to different compartments in the cell to carry out tasks specific to their environment. Most heat shock proteins form large oligomeric structures, and their functions are usually regulated by a variety of cochaperones and cofactors. Heat shock proteins do not function in isolation but are rather part of the chaperone network in the cell. The general structural and functional features of the major heat shock protein families are discussed, including their roles in human disease. Their function is particularly important in disease due to increased stress in the cell. Vector-borne parasites affecting human health encounter stress during transmission between invertebrate vectors and mammalian hosts. Members of the main classes of heat shock proteins are all represented in Plasmodium falciparum, the causative agent of cerebral malaria, and they play specific functions in differentiation, cytoprotection, signal transduction, and virulence.

Complete Genomic Analysis of Enterococcus faecium Heat-Resistant Strain Developed by Two-Step Adaptation Laboratory Evolution Method

Stress resistance is an important trait expected of lactic acid bacteria used in food manufacturing. Among the various sources of stress, high temperature is a key factor that interrupts bacterial growth. In this regards, constant efforts are made for the development of heat-resistant strains, but few studies were done accompanying genomic analysis to identify the causal factors of the resistance mechanisms. Furthermore, it is also thought that tolerance to multiple stresses are equally important. Herein, we isolated one Enterococcus faecium strain named BIOPOP-3 and completed a full-length genome sequence. Using this strain, a two-step adaptive laboratory evolution (ALE) method was applied to obtain a heat-resistant strain, BIOPOP-3 ALE. After sequencing the whole genome, we compared the two full-length sequences and identified one non-synonymous variant and four indel variants that could potentially confer heat resistance, which were technically validated by resequencing. We experimentally verified that the evolved strain was significantly enhanced in not only heat resistance but also acid and bile resistance. We demonstrated that the developed heat-resistant strain can be applied in animal feed manufacturing processes. The multi-stress-resistant BIOPOP-3 ALE strain developed in this study and the two-step ALE method are expected to be widely applied in industrial and academic fields. In addition, we expect that the identified variants which occurred specifically in heat-resistant strain will enhance molecular biological understanding and be broadly applied to the biological engineering field.

Internal RNAs overlapping coding sequences can drive the production of alternative proteins in archaea

Prokaryotic genomes show a high level of information compaction often with different molecules transcribed from the same locus. Although antisense RNAs have been relatively well studied, RNAs in the same strand, internal RNAs (intraRNAs), are still poorly understood. The question of how common is the translation of overlapping reading frames remains open. We address this question in the model archaeon Halobacterium salinarum. In the present work we used differential RNA-seq (dRNA-seq) in H. salinarum NRC-1 to locate intraRNA signals in subsets of internal transcription start sites (iTSS) and establish the open reading frames associated to them (intraORFs). Using C-terminally flagged proteins, we experimentally observed isoforms accurately predicted by intraRNA translation for kef1, acs3 and orc4 genes. We also recovered from the literature and mass spectrometry databases several instances of protein isoforms consistent with intraRNA translation such as the gas vesicle protein gene gvpC1. We found evidence for intraRNAs in horizontally transferred genes such as the chaperone dnaK and the aerobic respiration related cydA in both H. salinarum and Escherichia coli. Also, intraRNA translation evidence in H. salinarum, E. coli and yeast of a universal elongation factor (aEF-2, fusA and eEF-2) suggests that this is an ancient phenomenon present in all domains of life.

Concurrent action of purifying selection and gene conversion results in extreme conservation of the major stress-inducible Hsp70 genes in mammals

Several evolutionary mechanisms alter the fate of mutations and genes within populations based on their exhibited functional effects. To understand the underlying mechanisms involved in the evolution of the cellular stress response, a very conserved mechanism in the course of organismal evolution, we studied the patterns of natural genetic variation and functional consequences of polymorphisms of two stress-inducible Hsp70 genes. These genes, HSPA1A and HSPA1B, are major orchestrators of the cellular stress response and are associated with several human diseases. Our phylogenetic analyses revealed that the duplication of HSPA1A and HSPA1B originated in a lineage proceeding to placental mammals, and henceforth they remained in conserved synteny. Additionally, analyses of synonymous and non-synonymous changes suggest that purifying selection shaped the HSPA1 gene diversification, while gene conversion resulted in high sequence conservation within species. In the human HSPA1-cluster, the vast majority of mutations are synonymous and specific genic regions are devoid of mutations. Furthermore, functional characterization of several human polymorphisms revealed subtle differences in HSPA1A stability and intracellular localization. Collectively, the observable patterns of HSPA1A-1B variation describe an evolutionary pattern, in which purifying selection and gene conversion act simultaneously and conserve a major orchestrator of the cellular stress response.

Enhancing stress-resistance for efficient microbial biotransformations by synthetic biology

Chemical conversions mediated by microorganisms, otherwise known as microbial biotransformations, are playing an increasingly important role within the biotechnology industry. Unfortunately, the growth and production of microorganisms are often hampered by a number of stressful conditions emanating from environment fluctuations and/or metabolic imbalances such as high temperature, high salt condition, strongly acidic solution, and presence of toxic metabolites. Therefore, exploring methods to improve the stress tolerance of host organisms could significantly improve the biotransformation process. With the help of synthetic biology, it is now becoming feasible to implement strategies to improve the stress-resistance of the existing hosts. This review summarizes synthetic biology efforts to enhance the efficiency of biotransformations by improving the robustness of microbes. Particular attention will be given to strategies at the cellular and the microbial community levels.

Heat shock proteins: possible biomarkers in pulmonary and extrapulmonary tuberculosis

Tuberculosis (TB) and Tuberculous meningitis (TBM) caused by Mycobacterium tuberculosis (MTB) continue to be a major cause of morbidity and mortality. Therefore there is a need to explore potential biomarkers and heat shock proteins [Hsp(s)] could be one such candidate. We found that host (Hsp 25, Hsp 60, Hsp 70 and Hsp 90) and MTB Hsp(s) (Hsp 16, Hsp 65 and Hsp 71) to be an important feature of the immune response in human clinical samples of pulmonary and extrapulmonary TB patients and in MTB infected monocytes. Notably, the host (Hsp 25, Hsp 70 and Hsp 90) and MTB (Hsp 16, Hsp 65 and Hsp 71) Hsp(s) increases significantly in the clinical samples as well as in cell line model after TB infection. Collectively, results revealed that alteration in immune response leads to a change in the both host and MTB Hsp profile, highlighting them as possible biomarkers for the disease.

Diversity in the origins of proteostasis networks--a driver for protein function in evolution

Although the sequence of a protein largely determines its function, proteins can adopt different folding states in response to changes in the environment, some of which may be deleterious to the organism. All organisms--Bacteria, Archaea and Eukarya--have evolved a protein homeostasis, or proteostasis, network comprising chaperones and folding factors, degradation components, signalling pathways and specialized compartmentalized modules that manage protein folding in response to environmental stimuli and variation. Surveying the origins of proteostasis networks reveals that they have co-evolved with the proteome to regulate the physiological state of the cell, reflecting the unique stresses that different cells or organisms experience, and that they have a key role in driving evolution by closely managing the link between the phenotype and the genotype.

Horizontal gene transfer of a chloroplast DnaJ-Fer protein to Thaumarchaeota and the evolutionary history of the DnaK chaperone system in Archaea

Background

In 2004, we discovered an atypical protein in metagenomic data from marine thaumarchaeotal species. This protein, referred as DnaJ-Fer, is composed of a J domain fused to a Ferredoxin (Fer) domain. Surprisingly, the same protein was also found in Viridiplantae (green algae and land plants). Because J domain-containing proteins are known to interact with the major chaperone DnaK/Hsp70, this suggested that a DnaK protein was present in Thaumarchaeota. DnaK/Hsp70, its co-chaperone DnaJ and the nucleotide exchange factor GrpE are involved, among others, in heat shocks and heavy metal cellular stress responses.

Results

Using phylogenomic approaches we have investigated the evolutionary history of the DnaJ-Fer protein and of interacting proteins DnaK, DnaJ and GrpE in Thaumarchaeota. These proteins have very complex histories, involving several inter-domain horizontal gene transfers (HGTs) to explain the contemporary distribution of these proteins in archaea. These transfers include one from Cyanobacteria to Viridiplantae and one from Viridiplantae to Thaumarchaeota for the DnaJ-Fer protein, as well as independent HGTs from Bacteria to mesophilic archaea for the DnaK/DnaJ/GrpE system, followed by HGTs among mesophilic and thermophilic archaea.

Conclusions

We highlight the chimerical origin of the set of proteins DnaK, DnaJ, GrpE and DnaJ-Fer in Thaumarchaeota and suggest that the HGT of these proteins has played an important role in the adaptation of several archaeal groups to mesophilic and thermophilic environments from hyperthermophilic ancestors. Finally, the evolutionary history of DnaJ-Fer provides information useful for the relative dating of the diversification of Archaeplastida and Thaumarchaeota.

Hsp10, Hsp70, and Hsp90 immunohistochemical levels change in ulcerative colitis after therapy

Ulcerative colitis (UC) is a form of inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) characterized by damage of large bowel mucosa and frequent extra-intestinal autoimmune comorbidities. The role played in IBD pathogenesis by molecular chaperones known to interact with components of the immune system involved in inflammation is unclear. We previously demonstrated that mucosal Hsp60 decreases in UC patients treated with conventional therapies (mesalazine, probiotics), suggesting that this chaperonin could be a reliable biomarker useful for monitoring response to treatment, and that it might play a role in pathogenesis. In the present work we investigated three other heat shock protein/molecular chaperones: Hsp10, Hsp70, and Hsp90. We found that the levels of these proteins are increased in UC patients at the time of diagnosis and decrease after therapy, supporting the notion that these proteins deserve attention in the study of the mechanisms that promote the development and maintenance of IBD, and as biomarkers of this disease (e.g., to monitor response to treatment at the histological level).

The heat shock response: life on the verge of death

Organisms must survive a variety of stressful conditions, including sudden temperature increases that damage important cellular structures and interfere with essential functions. In response to heat stress, cells activate an ancient signaling pathway leading to the transient expression of heat shock or heat stress proteins (Hsps). Hsps exhibit sophisticated protection mechanisms, and the most conserved Hsps are molecular chaperones that prevent the formation of nonspecific protein aggregates and assist proteins in the acquisition of their native structures. In this Review, we summarize the concepts of the protective Hsp network.

Archaeal-like chaperonins in bacteria

Chaperonins (CPN) are ubiquitous oligomeric protein machines that mediate the ATP-dependent folding of polypeptide chains. These chaperones have not only been assigned stress response and normal housekeeping functions but also have a role in certain human disease states. A longstanding convention divides CPNs into two groups that share many conserved sequence motifs but differ in both structure and distribution. Group I complexes are the well known GroEL/ES heat-shock proteins in bacteria, that also occur in some species of mesophilic archaea and in the endosymbiotic organelles of eukaryotes. Group II CPNs are found only in the cytosol of archaea and eukaryotes. Here we report a third, divergent group of CPNs found in several species of bacteria. We propose to name these Group III CPNs because of their distant relatedness to both Group I and II CPNs as well as their unique genomic context, within the hsp70 operon. The prototype Group III CPN, Carboxydothermus hydrogenoformans chaperonin (Ch-CPN), is able to refold denatured proteins in an ATP-dependent manner and is structurally similar to the Group II CPNs, forming a 16-mer with each subunit contributing to a flexible lid domain. The Group III CPN represent a divergent group of bacterial CPNs distinct from the GroEL/ES CPN found in all bacteria. The Group III lineage may represent an ancient horizontal gene transfer from an archaeon into an early Firmicute lineage. An analysis of their functional and structural characteristics may provide important insights into the early history of this ubiquitous family of proteins.

Phylogeny disambiguates the evolution of heat-shock cis-regulatory elements in Drosophila

Heat-shock genes have a well-studied control mechanism for their expression that is mediated through cis-regulatory motifs known as heat-shock elements (HSEs). The evolution of important features of this control mechanism has not been investigated in detail, however. Here we exploit the genome sequencing of multiple Drosophila species, combined with a wealth of available information on the structure and function of HSEs in D. melanogaster, to undertake this investigation. We find that in single-copy heat shock genes, entire HSEs have evolved or disappeared 14 times, and the phylogenetic approach bounds the timing and direction of these evolutionary events in relation to speciation. In contrast, in the multi-copy gene Hsp70, the number of HSEs is nearly constant across species. HSEs evolve in size, position, and sequence within heat-shock promoters. In turn, functional significance of certain features is implicated by preservation despite this evolutionary change; these features include tail-to-tail arrangements of HSEs, gapped HSEs, and the presence or absence of entire HSEs. The variation among Drosophila species indicates that the cis-regulatory encoding of responsiveness to heat and other stresses is diverse. The broad dimensions of variation uncovered are particularly important as they suggest a substantial challenge for functional studies.

Transcriptional analysis of the hsp70 gene in a haloarchaeon Natrinema sp. J7 under heat and cold stress

Although ubiquitous in all haloarchaea, little is known about the transcription and regulation of the haloarchaeal hsp70. The purpose of this study is to investigate the transcription of the haloarchaeal hsp70 gene in Natrinema sp. J7 under the temperature and osmotic stress. The hsp70 gene was found to be both temperature- and osmotic-induced, while the response of hsp70 to cold shock was stronger than that to heat shock. Western blot analysis corroborated the similar results at the level of Hsp70 protein. Northern blot and primer extension analyses indicated that the hsp70 was transcribed into a monocistronic transcript and the thermal stress had no effect on the transcription initiation sites choice. The deletion analyses showed that two putative elements, TATA-box (TTTAAAA) and BRE (AGTAAC) located -27 bp upstream of the transcription initiation site played an essential role for the basal transcription of P( hsp70 ). The results suggested that there are some special regulators of hsp70 gene in Natrinema sp. J7.

Chaperones and protein folding in the archaea

A survey of archaeal genomes for the presence of homologues of bacterial and eukaryotic chaperones reveals several interesting features. All archaea contain chaperonins, also known as Hsp60s (where Hsp is heat-shock protein). These are more similar to the type II chaperonins found in the eukaryotic cytosol than to the type I chaperonins found in bacteria, mitochondria and chloroplasts, although some archaea also contain type I chaperonin homologues, presumably acquired by horizontal gene transfer. Most archaea contain several genes for these proteins. Our studies on the type II chaperonins of the genetically tractable archaeon Haloferax volcanii have shown that only one of the three genes has to be present for the organisms to grow, but that there is some evidence for functional specialization between the different chaperonin proteins. All archaea also possess genes for prefoldin proteins and for small heat-shock proteins, but they generally lack genes for Hsp90 and Hsp100 homologues. Genes for Hsp70 (DnaK) and Hsp40 (DnaJ) homologues are only found in a subset of archaea. Thus chaperone-assisted protein folding in archaea is likely to display some unique features when compared with that in eukaryotes and bacteria, and there may be important differences in the process between euryarchaea and crenarchaea.

Analysis of the AAA+ chaperone clpB gene and stress-response expression in the halophilic methanogenic archaeon Methanohalophilus portucalensis

ClpB is a member of the protein-disaggregating chaperone machinery belonging to the AAA+ superfamily. This paper describes a new clpB gene from the halophilic methanoarchaeon Methanohalophilus portucalensis, which has not been reported previously in Archaea. The partial sequence of clpB was identified from the investigation of the salt-stress response of Meh. portucalensis by differential-display RT-PCR (DDRT-PCR). Furthermore, the complete clpB sequence (2610 nt) and its upstream genes encoding the type I chaperonin GroEL/ES were obtained through inverse PCR, Southern hybridization and sequencing. The G+C ratio of clpB is 49.6 mol%. The predicted ClpB polypeptide contains 869 aa and possesses a long central domain and a predicted distinctly discontinuous coiled-coil motif separating two nucleotide-binding domains (NBD1 and NBD2). NBD1 has a single Walker A and two Walker B motifs and NBD2 has only one of each Walker motif, a characteristic of HSP100 proteins. Two repeated Clp amino-terminal domain motifs (ClpN) were identified in ClpB. The putative amino acid sequence shared 75.6 % identity with the predicted clpB homologue annotated as ATPase AAA-2 of Methanococcoides burtonii DSM 6242. Preliminary phylogenetic analysis clustered Meh. portucalensis ClpB (MpClpB) with the low G+C Gram-positive bacteria. Stress response analysis of clpB by Northern blotting showed up to 1.5-fold increased transcription levels in response to both salt up-shock (from 2.1 to 3.1 M NaCl) and down-shock (from 2.1 to 0.9 M NaCl). Both clpB and groEL/ES transcript levels increased when the temperature was shifted from 37 degrees C to 55 degrees C. Under heat stress clpB transcription was repressed by the addition of the osmolyte betaine (1 mM). In conclusion, a novel AAA+ chaperone clpB gene from a halophilic methanogen that responded to the fluctuations in temperature, salt concentration and betaine has been identified and analysed for the first time.

Cloning and characterization of a haloarchaeal heat shock protein 70 functionally expressed in Escherichia coli

The Hsp70 molecular chaperone machine is constituted by the 70-kDa heat shock protein Hsp70 (DnaK), cochaperone protein Hsp40 (DnaJ) and a nucleotide-exchange factor GrpE. Although it is one of the best-characterized molecular chaperone machines, little is known about it in archaea. A 5.2-kb region containing the hsp70 (dnaK) gene was cloned from Natrinema sp. J7 strain and sequenced. It contained the Hsp70 chaperone machine gene locus arranged unidirectionally in the order of grpE, hsp70 and hsp40 (dnaJ). The hsp70 gene from Natrinema sp. J7 was overexpressed in Escherichia coli BL21 (DE3). The recombinant Hsp70 protein was in a soluble and active form, and its ATPase activity was optimally active in 2.0 M KCl, whereas NaCl had less effect. In vivo, the haloarchaeal hsp70 gene allowed an E. coli dnak-null mutant to propagate lambda phages and grow at 42 degrees C. The results suggested that haloarchaeal Hsp70 should be beneficial for extreme halophiles survival in low-salt environments.

Chaperonomics, a new tool to study ageing and associated diseases

The participation of molecular chaperones in the process of senescence and in the mechanisms of age-related diseases is currently under investigation in many laboratories. However, accurate, complete information about the number and diversity of chaperone genes in any given genome is scarce. Consequently, the results of efforts aimed at elucidating the role of chaperones in ageing and disease are often confusing and contradictory. To remedy this situation, we have developed chaperonomics, including means to identify and characterize chaperone genes and their families applicable to humans and model organisms. The problem is difficult because in eukaryotic organisms chaperones have evolved into complex multi-gene families. For instance, the occurrence of multiple paralogs in a single genome makes it difficult to interpret results if consideration is not given to the fact that similar but distinct chaperone genes can be differentially expressed in separate cellular compartments, tissues, and developmental stages. The availability of complete genome sequences allows implementation of chaperonomics with the purpose of understanding the composition of chaperone families in all cell compartments, their evolutionary and functional relations and, ultimately, their role in pathogenesis. Here, we present a series of concatenated, complementary procedures for identifying, characterizing, and classifying chaperone genes in genomes and for elucidating evolutionary relations and structural features useful in predicting functional properties. We illustrate the procedures with applications to the complex family of hsp70 genes and show that the kind of data obtained can provide a solid basis for future research.