Temperature Influenced the Comammox Community Composition in Drinking Water and Wastewater Treatment Plants

The vertical distribution and metabolic versatility of complete ammonia oxidizing communities in mangrove sediments

Recently discovered complete ammonia-oxidizing (comammox) microorganisms can completely oxidize ammonia to nitrate and play an important role in the nitrogen (N) cycle across various ecosystems. However, little is known about the vertical distribution and metabolic versatility of comammox communities in mangrove ecosystems. Here we profiled comammox communities from deep sediments (up to 5 m) in a mangrove wetland by combining metagenome sequencing and physicochemical properties analysis. Our results showed that the relative abundance of comammox bacteria (23.2 %) was higher than ammonia-oxidizing bacteria (AOB, 12.0 %), but lower than ammonia-oxidizing archaea (AOA, 64.8 %). The abundance of comammox communities significantly (p < 0.01) decreased with the sediment depth, and dissolved organic carbon and total sulfur appeared to be major environmental factors influencing the nitrifying microbial community structure. We also recovered a high-quality metagenome-assembled genome (MAG) of comammox bacteria (Nitrospira sp. bin2030) affiliated with comammox clade A. Nitrospira sp. bin2030 possessed diverse metabolic processes, not only the key genes for ammonia oxidation and urea utilization in the N cycle, but also key genes involved in carbon and energy metabolisms, sulfur metabolism, and environmental adaptation (e.g., oxidative stress, salinity, temperature, heavy metal tolerance). The findings advance our understanding of vertical distribution and metabolic versatility of comammox communities in mangrove sediments, having important implications for quantifying their contribution to nitrification processes in mangrove ecosystems.

Dynamics of ammonia-oxidizing microorganisms in gradient temperature-regulated reactors under low ammonia loading condition

Ammonia-oxidizing microorganisms (AOMs) play a crucial role in nitrogen removal in engineered systems. However, temperature fluctuations can lead to ammonia oxidation failure. This study investigated the effects of a broad temperature range (10.5, 14, 17.5, 21, 26.4, 35, 38.5, 42, and 45.5 °C) on the distribution of ammonia-oxidizing archaea (AOA), ammonia-oxidizing bacteria (AOB), and comammox together with Nitrospira and Nitrobacter in gradient temperature-regulated reactors operated under low ammonia loading condition. Quantitative PCR and high throughput sequencing revealed that the AOA amoA gene numbers (∼104 copies/ng DNA) were relatively high at 38.5 °C to 42 °C, suggesting AOA favoring higher temperature than lower temperature. The amoA genes of AOA (∼103 - 104 copies/ng DNA) outcompeted those of AOB (∼103 copies/ng DNA) and comammox ( Collapse

Key Words

• AOA
• AOB
• Comammox
• Nitrobacter
• Nitrospira
• Temperature

Collapse

MESH Headings

• Ammonia/metabolism
• Archaea/metabolism
• Bioreactors/microbiology
• Oxidation-Reduction
• Temperature
• Bacteria/metabolism

Collapse

Grants Collapse

Affiliation(s)

Prinpida Sonthiphand Department of Biology, Faculty of Science, Mahidol University, Bangkok, Thailand
Napong Songkriengkrai International Program in Hazardous Substance and Environmental Management, Graduate School, Chulalongkorn University, Bangkok, Thailand
Nampetch Charanaipayuk International Program in Hazardous Substance and Environmental Management, Graduate School, Chulalongkorn University, Bangkok, Thailand
Teerasit Termsaithong Learning Institute, King Mongkut's University of Technology Thonburi, Bangkok, Thailand; Theoretical and Computational Physics (TCP) Group, Center of Excellence in Theoretical and Computational Science (TaCS-CoE), King Mongkut's University of Technology Thonburi, Bangkok, Thailand
Benjaporn Boonchayaanant Suwannasilp Department of Environmental and Sustainable Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, Chulalongkorn University, Bangkok, Thailand; Biotechnology for Wastewater Engineering Research Unit, Chulalongkorn University, Bangkok, Thailand
Wuttichai Mhuantong National Center for Genetic Engineering and Biotechnology (BIOTEC), National Science and Technology Development Agency, Pathumthani, Thailand
Tawan Limpiyakorn Department of Environmental and Sustainable Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, Chulalongkorn University, Bangkok, Thailand; Biotechnology for Wastewater Engineering Research Unit, Chulalongkorn University, Bangkok, Thailand.

Collapse

Collaborators Collapse

Advanced Technologies for Nitrogen Removal and Recovery from Municipal and Industrial Wastewater

Nitrogen pollution poses significant environmental challenges, contributing to eutrophication, soil acidification, and greenhouse gas emissions. This study explores advanced methods for nitrogen removal and recovery from municipal and industrial wastewater, with a focus on biological, chemical, and physical processes. Key processes, such as nitrification-denitrification and emerging technologies like shortcut nitrogen pathways, were analyzed for their efficiency, cost-effectiveness, and environmental benefits. This review highlights the integration of innovative techniques, including membrane systems and ammonia stripping, with traditional approaches to enhance nitrogen management. Emphasis is placed on optimizing operational conditions, such as pH, temperature, and carbon-to-nitrogen ratios, to achieve high removal rates while minimizing energy consumption and environmental impact. These findings underline the critical role of interdisciplinary strategies in addressing the challenges of nitrogen pollution and promoting sustainable wastewater management.

Effects of low temperature on the microbial community of MBBR filler biofilm

Moving bed biofilm reactors can purify urban domestic sewage through microbial biodegradation. High-throughput sequencing was used to study the response mechanism of the biofilm microbial community to temperature. The effluent quality of the reactor declined with the decrease in temperature. Proteobacteria, Bacteroidota, and Nitrospirota were the dominant bacteria, accounting for 59.2, 11.9, and 9.4%, respectively. Gammaproteobacteria (38.3%), Alphaproteobacteria (23.2%), and Bacteroidia (12.4%) were the dominant bacteria at the class level. Low temperature had an obvious directional domestication effect on microbial flora, and the composition of the bacterial community was more similar. Pseudomonas was one of the dominant bacterial groups at 5 °C. Nitrospira (p < 0.001) and Trichococcus (p < 0.05) were significantly negatively correlated with effluent ammonia nitrogen and significantly positively correlated with NO3- (p < 0.05) at low temperature. Functional bacteria related to chemoheterotrophy (25.88%) and aerobic_chemoheterotrophy (21.56%) accounted for a relatively high proportion. The bacteria related to nitrate reduction only accounted for 2.62%. Studies have shown that low temperatures can inhibit the growth of nitrogen-cycling bacteria, and few domesticated and selected nitrogen-cycling bacteria play a major role in the removal and transformation of ammonia nitrogen. The degradation of chemical oxygen demand can still be achieved through the adsorption and degradation of dominant functional bacteria.

A critical review of comammox and synergistic nitrogen removal coupling anammox: Mechanisms and regulatory strategies

Nitrification is highly crucial for both anammox systems and the global nitrogen cycle. The discovery of complete ammonia oxidation (comammox) challenges the inherent concept of nitrification as a two-step process. Its wide distribution, adaptability to low substrate environments, low sludge production, and low greenhouse gas emissions may make it a promising new nitrogen removal treatment process. Meanwhile, anammox technology is considered the most suitable process for future wastewater treatment. The diverse metabolic capabilities and similar ecological niches of comammox bacteria and anammox bacteria are expected to achieve synergistic nitrogen removal within a single system. However, previous studies have overlooked the existence of comammox, and it is necessary to re-evaluate the conclusions drawn. This paper outlined the ecophysiological characteristics of comammox bacteria and summarized the environmental factors affecting their growth. Furthermore, it focused on the enrichment, regulatory strategies, and nitrogen removal mechanisms of comammox and anammox, with a comparative analysis of hydroxylamine, a particular intermediate product. Overall, this is the first critical overview of the conclusions drawn from the last few years of research on comammox-anammox, highlighting possible next steps for research.

Journey of the swift nitrogen transformation: Unveiling comammox from discovery to deep understanding

COMplete AMMonia OXidizer (comammox) refers to microorganisms that have the function of oxidizing NH4+ to NO3- alone. The discovery of comammox overturned the two-step theory of nitrification in the past century and triggered many important scientific questions about the nitrogen cycle in nature. This comprehensive review delves into the origin and discovery of comammox, providing a detailed account of its detection primers, clades metabolic variations, and environmental factors. An in-depth analysis of the ecological niche differentiation among ammonia oxidizers was also discussed. The intricate role of comammox in anammox systems and the relationship between comammox and nitrogen compound emissions are also discussed. Finally, the relationship between comammox and anammox is displayed, and the future research direction of comammox is prospected. This review reveals the metabolic characteristics and distribution patterns of comammox in ecosystems, providing new perspectives for understanding nitrogen cycling and microbial ecology. Additionally, it offers insights into the potential application value and prospects of comammox.

Competition between ammonia-oxidizing archaea and complete ammonia oxidizers from freshwater environments

Aerobic ammonia oxidizers (AOs) are prokaryotic microorganisms that contribute to the global nitrogen cycle by performing the first step of nitrification, the oxidation of ammonium to nitrite and nitrate. While aerobic AOs are found ubiquitously, their distribution is controlled by key environmental conditions such as substrate (ammonium) availability. Ammonia-oxidizing archaea (AOA) and complete ammonia oxidizers (comammox) are generally found in oligotrophic environments with low ammonium availability. However, whether AOA and comammox share these habitats or outcompete each other is not well understood. We assessed the competition for ammonium between an AOA and comammox enriched from the freshwater Lake Burr Oak. The AOA enrichment culture (AOA-BO1) contained Nitrosarchaeum sp. BO1 as the ammonia oxidizer and Nitrospira sp. BO1 as the nitrite oxidizer. The comammox enrichment BO4 (cmx-BO4) contained the comammox strain Nitrospira sp. BO4. The competition experiments were performed either in continuous cultivation with ammonium as a growth-limiting substrate or in batch cultivation with initial ammonium concentrations of 50 and 500 µM. Regardless of the ammonium concentration, Nitrospira sp. BO4 outcompeted Nitrosarchaeum sp. BO1 under all tested conditions. The dominance of Nitrospira sp. BO4 could be explained by the ability of comammox to generate more energy through the complete oxidation of ammonia to nitrate and their more efficient carbon fixation pathway-the reductive tricarboxylic acid cycle. Our results are supported by the higher abundance of comammox compared to AOA in the sediment of Lake Burr Oak.

IMPORTANCE

Nitrification is a key process in the global nitrogen cycle. Aerobic ammonia oxidizers play a central role in the nitrogen cycle by performing the first step of nitrification. Ammonia-oxidizing archaea (AOA) and complete ammonia oxidizers (comammox) are the dominant nitrifiers in environments with low ammonium availability. While AOA have been studied for almost 20 years, comammox were only discovered 8 years ago. Until now, there has been a gap in our understanding of whether AOA and comammox can co-exist or if one strain would be dominant under ammonium-limiting conditions. Here, we present the first study characterizing the competition between freshwater AOA and comammox under varying substrate concentrations. Our results will help in elucidating the niches of two key nitrifiers in freshwater lakes.

Abundance, diversity and physiological preferences of comammox Nitrospira in urban groundwater

Complete ammonia oxidizer (comammox Nitrospira), catalyze complete nitrification process in a single organism, are frequently detected in groundwater ecosystem. However, the ecological niches and environmental driving factors of comammox Nitrospira in urban groundwater are largely unknown. Here we investigated the communities of ammonia oxidizers in urban groundwater located in Shanghai city, China. Quantitative analysis demonstrated the dominance of comammox Nitrospira over classical ammonia oxidizers (ammonia-oxidizing archaea and bacteria, AOA and AOB). Phylogenetic analysis showed clades B and A2 comprise the majority of comammox Nitrospira groups. Temperature was one of the most vital factors affecting comammox Nitrospira community. Furthermore, clade A comammox Nitrospira can be enriched by urea substrate, which was in line with the ability of utilizing urea by the pure clade A comammox culture Nitrospira inopinata. In addition, we observed that relatively low temperature (<20 °C) and high copper levels (>0.04 mg L-1) can stimulate the growth of comammox Nitrospira. Overall, this study revealed the presence, diversity and physiological preferences of comammox Nitrospira in urban groundwater nitrification, shedding insights on the ecological roles of comammox Nitrospira in subsurface environment.

Mainstream nitrogen removal from low temperature and low ammonium strength municipal wastewater using hydrogel-encapsulated comammox and anammox

Application of partial nitritation (PN)-anammox to mainstream wastewater treatment faces challenges in low water temperature and low ammonium strength. In this study, a continuous flow PN-anammox reactor with hydrogel-encapsulated comammox and anammox was designed and operated for nitrogen removal from mainstream wastewater with low temperature. Long-term operation with synthetic and real wastewater as the feed demonstrated nearly complete ammonium and total inorganic nitrogen (TIN) removal by the reactor at temperatures as low as 10 °C. A significantly decreased nitrogen removal performance and biomass activity was observed in the reactor at 4 °C before a selective heating strategy was employed. A novel heating technology using radiation to heat carbon black co-encapsulated in the hydrogel matrix with biomass was used to selectively heat biomass but not water in the treatment system. This selective heating technology enabled nearly complete ammonium removal and 89.4 ± 4.3 % TIN removal at influent temperature of 4 °C and reactor temperature 5 °C. Activity tests suggested selective heating brought the biomass activity at influent temperatures of 4 °C and reactor temperature 5 °C to a level comparable to that at 10 °C. Comammox and anammox were consistently present in the system and spatially organized in the hydrogel beads as revealed by qPCR and fluorescence in-situ hybridization (FISH). The abundance of comammox largely decreased by 3 orders of magnitude during the operation at 4 °C, and rapidly recovered after the application of selective heating. The anammox-comammox technology tested in this study essentially enabled mainstream shortcut nitrogen removal, and the selective heating ensured good performance of the technology at temperature as low as 5 °C.

Low diversity and microdiversity of comammox bacteria in wastewater systems suggest specific adaptations within the Ca. Nitrospira nitrosa cluster

Studies have found Ca. Nitrospira nitrosa-like bacteria to be the principal or sole comammox bacteria in nitrogen removal systems for wastewater treatment. In contrast, multiple populations of strict ammonia and nitrite oxidizers co-exist in similar systems. This apparent lack of diversity is surprising and could impact the feasibility of leveraging comammox bacteria for nitrogen removal. We used full-length 16S rRNA gene sequencing and genome-resolved metagenomics to compare the species-level diversity of comammox bacteria with that of strict nitrifiers in full-scale wastewater treatment systems and assess whether this comparison is consistent or diverged at the strain-level. Full-length 16S rRNA gene sequencing indicated that Nitrosomonas-like bacteria exhibited higher species-level diversity in comparison with other nitrifying bacteria, while the strain-level diversity (also called microdiversity) of most Nitrospira-like bacteria were higher than Nitrosomonas-like bacteria with few exceptions (one Nitrospira lineage II population). Comammox bacterial metagenome assembled genomes (MAGs) were associated with Ca. Nitrospira nitrosa. The average amino acid identity between principal comammox bacterial MAGs (93% ± 3) across systems was significantly higher than that of the Nitrosomonas-like ammonia oxidizers (73% ± 8), the Nitrospira_A-like nitrite oxidizer (85% ± 4), and the Nitrospira_D-like nitrite oxidizer (83% ± 1). This demonstrated the low species-level diversity of comammox bacteria compared with strict nitrifiers and further suggests that the same comammox population was detected in all systems. Comammox bacteria (Nitrospira lineage II), Nitrosomonas and, Nitrospira_D (Nitrospira lineage II) MAGs were significantly less microdiverse than the Nitrospira_A (lineage I) MAGs. Interestingly, strain-resolved analysis also indicates that different nitrogen removal systems harbor different comammox bacterial strains within the Ca. Nitrospira nitrosa cluster. These results suggest that comammox bacteria associated with Ca. Nitrospira nitrosa have low species- and strain-level diversity in nitrogen removal systems and may thus harbor specific adaptations to the wastewater ecosystem.

Comammox biogeography subject to anthropogenic interferences along a high-altitude river

The recent discovery of comammox Nitrospira performing complete ammonia oxidation to nitrate has overturned the long-held dogma of two-step nitrification on Earth, yet little is known about the effect of urbanization interference on their distribution. Using gene-centric metagenomics, we provided the first blueprints about comammox community, biogeography, and environmental drivers along a high-elevation (> 2000 m) river flowing through the largest city on the vulnerable Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau. Our study confirmed a wide presence and diversity of yet-uncultured comammox clade B across wet and dry seasons, with average 3.0 and 2.0 times as abundant as clade-A amoA genes in water and sediments, respectively. Species identified from freshwater and drinking water treatment plants dominated the comammox guilds (58∼100%), suggesting this plateau river shared a similar comammox assemblage with the above habitat types. Compared with the urban area harboring more abundant canonical Nitrospira identified in wastewater (average 24%), the upstream suburban reach had a smaller human population but larger proportions of comammox in ammonia-oxidizing prokaryotes (24∼72% of abundances) and Nitrospira sublineages I/II. Higher contents of nitrate and nitrite in water, and antibiotics in water and sediments, may restrain comammox niches in nitrifiers over the urban area. Further random forest analysis revealed that lincosamides and quinolones were the most important antibiotic predictors for the niche differentiations between comammox and canonical nitrifiers in water, while macrolides for those in sediments. Finally, by incubation experiments, we demonstrated higher activity contributions of benthic comammox in the suburban area (36.2∼92.8% of potential ammonia-oxidation rates) than in the urban reach, and that the contribution variation had significant negative relations with macrolides and their major components. Overall, this study highlighted that anthropogenic activities hampered the advantage of riverine complete nitrifiers over the canonical two-step ones.

Distinct Nitrification Rates and Nitrifiers in Needleleaf and Evergreen Broadleaf Forest Soils

Research on niche specialization in the microbial communities of ammonia oxidizers is important for assessing the consequences of vegetation shift on nitrogen (N) cycling. In this study, soils were sampled from three tree stands (needleleaf, mixed, and evergreen broadleaf) from the Hannam experimental forest in South Korea in spring (May 2019), summer (August 2019), autumn (November 2019), and winter (January 2020). Quantitative polymerase chain reaction (qPCR) and high-throughput sequencing were used to measure the abundance and community structure of various nitrifiers: ammonia-oxidizing archaea and bacteria (AOA and AOB, respectively) as well as complete ammonia oxidizers (comammox). Nitrification rates and total ammonia oxidizer abundance were significantly higher in needleleaf forest soil than those in other forest stands, and they were lowest in evergreen broadleaf forest soil. Comammox clade B was most abundant in needleleaf and evergreen broadleaf forest soils, while AOA were significantly more abundant in mixed forest soil. The abundances of comammox clade B and AOA were negatively correlated with dissolved organic carbon. Phylogenetic analysis showed that NT-alpha and NS-gamma-2.3.2 were the most abundant AOA lineages in all the samples. The seasonal of AOA, AOB, and comammox varied with the sites, suggesting the need to examine the combinations of environmental factors when considering the effects of seasonal changes in the environment. Overall, the results suggest that potential vegetation shifts in forest ecosystems might affect nitrification activities by regulating the abundance and community structure of ammonia oxidizers.

Abundance and Niche Differentiation of Comammox in the Sludges of Wastewater Treatment Plants That Use the Anaerobic-Anoxic-Aerobic Process

Complete ammonia oxidizers (comammox), which directly oxidize ammonia to nitrate, were recently identified and found to be ubiquitous in artificial systems. Research on the abundance and niche differentiation of comammox in the sludges of wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) would be useful for improving the nitrogen removal efficiency of WWTPs. Here, we investigated the relative abundance and diversity of comammox in fifteen sludges of five WWTPs that use the anaerobic−anoxic−aerobic process in Jinan, China, via quantitative polymerase chain reaction and high-throughput sequencing of the 16S rRNA gene and ammonia monooxygenase gene. In the activated sludges in the WWTPs, comammox clade A.1 was widely distributed and mostly comprised Candidatus Nitrospira nitrosa-like comammox (>98% of all comammox). The proportion of this clade was negatively correlated (p < 0.01) with the dissolved oxygen (DO) level (1.7−8 mg/L), and slight pH changes (7.20−7.70) affected the structure of the comammox populations. Nitrospira lineage I frequently coexisted with Nitrosomonas, which generally had a significant positive correlation (p < 0.05) with the DO level. Our study provided an insight into the structure of comammox and other nitrifier populations in WWTPs that use the anaerobic−anoxic−aerobic process, broadening the knowledge about the effects of DO on comammox and other nitrifiers.

The Coupling Response between Different Bacterial Metabolic Functions in Water and Sediment Improve the Ability to Mitigate Climate Change

Extreme climatic events, such as heat wave and large temperature fluctuations, are predicted to increase in frequency and intensity during the next hundred years, which may rapidly alter the composition and function of lake bacterial communities. Here, we conducted a year-long experiment to explore the effect of warming on bacterial metabolic function of lake water and sediment. Predictions of the metabolic capabilities of these communities were performed with FAPROTAX using 16S rRNA sequencing data. The results indicated that the increase in temperature changed the structure of bacterial metabolic functional groups in water and sediment. During periods of low temperature, the carbon degradation pathway decreased, and the synthesis pathway increased, under the stimulation of warming, especially under the conditions temperature fluctuation. We also observed that nitrogen fixation ability was especially important in the warming treatments during the summer season. However, an elevated temperature significantly led to reduced nitrogen fixation abilities in winter. Compared with the water column, the most predominant functional groups of nitrogen cycle in sediment were nitrite oxidation and nitrification. Variable warming significantly promoted nitrite oxidation and nitrification function in winter, and constant warming was significantly inhibited in spring, with control in sediments. Co-occurrence network results showed that warming, especially variable warming, made microbial co-occurrence networks larger, more connected and less modular, and eventually functional groups in the water column and sediment cooperated to resist warming. We concluded that warming changed bacterial functional potentials important to the biogeochemical cycling in the experimental mesocosms in winter and spring with low temperature. The effect of different bacteria metabolism functions in water column and sediment may change the carbon and nitrogen fluxes in aquatic ecosystems. In conclusion, the coupling response between different bacterial metabolic functions in water and sediment may improve the ability to mitigate climate change.

Insights into Nitrous Oxide Mitigation Strategies in Wastewater Treatment and Challenges for Wider Implementation

Nitrous oxide (N₂O) emissions account for the majority of the carbon footprint of wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs). Many N₂O mitigation strategies have since been developed while a holistic view is still missing. This article reviews the state-of-the-art of N₂O mitigation studies in wastewater treatment. Through analyzing existing studies, this article presents the essential knowledge to guide N₂O mitigations, and the logics behind mitigation strategies. In practice, mitigations are mainly carried out by aeration control, feed scheme optimization, and process optimization. Despite increasingly more studies, real implementation remains rare, which is a combined result of unclear climate change policies/incentives, as well as technical challenges. Five critical technical challenges, as well as opportunities, of N₂O mitigations were identified. It is proposed that (i) quantification methods for overall N₂O emissions and pathway contributions need improvement; (ii) a reliable while straightforward mathematical model is required to quantify benefits and compare mitigation strategies; (iii) tailored risk assessment needs to be conducted for WWTPs, in which more long-term full-scale trials of N₂O mitigation are urgently needed to enable robust assessments of the resulting operational costs and impact on nutrient removal performance; (iv) current mitigation strategies focus on centralized WWTPs, more investigations are warranted for decentralised systems, especially decentralized activated sludge WWTPs; and (v) N₂O may be mitigated by adopting novel strategies promoting N₂O reduction denitrification or microorganisms that emit less N₂O. Overall, we conclude N₂O mitigation research is reaching a maturity while challenges still exist for a wider implementation, especially in relation to the reliability of N₂O mitigation strategies and potential risks to nutrient removal performances of WWTPs.