Robust emergence of sharply tuned place-cell responses in hippocampal neurons with structural and biophysical heterogeneities

The Brain's Best Kept Secret Is Its Degenerate Structure

Degeneracy is defined as multiple sets of solutions that can produce very similar system performance. Degeneracy is seen across phylogenetic scales, in all kinds of organisms. In neuroscience, degeneracy can be seen in the constellation of biophysical properties that produce a neuron's characteristic intrinsic properties and/or the constellation of mechanisms that determine circuit outputs or behavior. Here, we present examples of degeneracy at multiple levels of organization, from single-cell behavior, small circuits, large circuits, and, in cognition, drawing conclusions from work ranging from bacteria to human cognition. Degeneracy allows the individual-to-individual variability within a population that creates potential for evolution.

Ion-channel degeneracy and heterogeneities in the emergence of signature physiological characteristics of dentate gyrus granule cells

Complex systems are neither fully determined nor completely random. Biological complex systems, including single neurons, manifest intermediate regimes of randomness that recruit integration of specific combinations of functionally specialized subsystems. Such emergence of biological function provides the substrate for the expression of degeneracy, the ability of disparate combinations of subsystems to yield similar function. Here, we present evidence for the expression of degeneracy in morphologically realistic models of dentate gyrus granule cells (GCs) through functional integration of disparate ion-channel combinations. We performed a 45-parameter randomized search spanning 16 active and passive ion channels, each biophysically constrained by their gating kinetics and localization profiles, to search for valid GC models. Valid models were those that satisfied 17 sub- and suprathreshold cellular-scale electrophysiological measurements from rat GCs. A vast majority (>99%) of the 15,000 random models were not electrophysiologically valid, demonstrating that arbitrarily random ion-channel combinations would not yield GC functions. The 141 valid models (0.94% of 15,000) manifested heterogeneities in and cross-dependencies across local and propagating electrophysiological measurements, which matched with their respective biological counterparts. Importantly, these valid models were widespread throughout the parametric space and manifested weak cross-dependencies across different parameters. These observations together showed that GC physiology could neither be obtained by entirely random ion-channel combinations nor is there an entirely determined single parametric combination that satisfied all constraints. The complexity, the heterogeneities in measurement and parametric spaces, and degeneracy associated with GC physiology should be rigorously accounted for while assessing GCs and their robustness under physiological and pathological conditions.NEW & NOTEWORTHY A recent study from our laboratory had demonstrated pronounced heterogeneities in a set of 17 electrophysiological measurements obtained from a large population of rat hippocampal granule cells. Here, we demonstrate the manifestation of ion-channel degeneracy in a heterogeneous population of morphologically realistic conductance-based granule cell models that were validated against these measurements and their cross-dependencies. Our analyses show that single neurons are complex entities whose functions emerge through intricate interactions among several functionally specialized subsystems.

Heterogeneous off-target impact of ion-channel deletion on intrinsic properties of hippocampal model neurons that self-regulate calcium

How do neurons that implement cell-autonomous self-regulation of calcium react to knockout of individual ion-channel conductances? To address this question, we used a heterogeneous population of 78 conductance-based models of hippocampal pyramidal neurons that maintained cell-autonomous calcium homeostasis while receiving theta-frequency inputs. At calcium steady-state, we individually deleted each of the 11 active ion-channel conductances from each model. We measured the acute impact of deleting each conductance (one at a time) by comparing intrinsic electrophysiological properties before and immediately after channel deletion. The acute impact of deleting individual conductances on physiological properties (including calcium homeostasis) was heterogeneous, depending on the property, the specific model, and the deleted channel. The underlying many-to-many mapping between ion channels and properties pointed to ion-channel degeneracy. Next, we allowed the other conductances (barring the deleted conductance) to evolve towards achieving calcium homeostasis during theta-frequency activity. When calcium homeostasis was perturbed by ion-channel deletion, post-knockout plasticity in other conductances ensured resilience of calcium homeostasis to ion-channel deletion. These results demonstrate degeneracy in calcium homeostasis, as calcium homeostasis in knockout models was implemented in the absence of a channel that was earlier involved in the homeostatic process. Importantly, in reacquiring homeostasis, ion-channel conductances and physiological properties underwent heterogenous plasticity (dependent on the model, the property, and the deleted channel), even introducing changes in properties that were not directly connected to the deleted channel. Together, post-knockout plasticity geared towards maintaining homeostasis introduced heterogenous off-target effects on several channels and properties, suggesting that extreme caution be exercised in interpreting experimental outcomes involving channel knockouts.

Targeting aberrant dendritic integration to treat cognitive comorbidities of epilepsy

Memory deficits are a debilitating symptom of epilepsy, but little is known about mechanisms underlying cognitive deficits. Here, we describe a Na+ channel-dependent mechanism underlying altered hippocampal dendritic integration, degraded place coding and deficits in spatial memory. Two-photon glutamate uncaging experiments revealed a marked increase in the fraction of hippocampal first-order CA1 pyramidal cell dendrites capable of generating dendritic spikes in the kainate model of chronic epilepsy. Moreover, in epileptic mice dendritic spikes were generated with lower input synchrony, and with a lower threshold. The Nav1.3/1.1 selective Na+ channel blocker ICA-121431 reversed dendritic hyperexcitability in epileptic mice, while the Nav1.2/1.6 preferring anticonvulsant S-Lic did not. We used in vivo two-photon imaging to determine if aberrant dendritic excitability is associated with altered place-related firing of CA1 neurons. We show that ICA-121431 improves degraded hippocampal spatial representations in epileptic mice. Finally, behavioural experiments show that reversing aberrant dendritic excitability with ICA-121431 reverses hippocampal memory deficits. Thus, a dendritic channelopathy may underlie cognitive deficits in epilepsy and targeting it pharmacologically may constitute a new avenue to enhance cognition.

Degeneracy in epilepsy: multiple routes to hyperexcitable brain circuits and their repair

Due to its complex and multifaceted nature, developing effective treatments for epilepsy is still a major challenge. To deal with this complexity we introduce the concept of degeneracy to the field of epilepsy research: the ability of disparate elements to cause an analogous function or malfunction. Here, we review examples of epilepsy-related degeneracy at multiple levels of brain organisation, ranging from the cellular to the network and systems level. Based on these insights, we outline new multiscale and population modelling approaches to disentangle the complex web of interactions underlying epilepsy and to design personalised multitarget therapies.

Efficient information coding and degeneracy in the nervous system

Efficient information coding (EIC) is a universal biological framework rooted in the fundamental principle that system responses should match their natural stimulus statistics for maximizing environmental information. Quantitatively assessed through information theory, such adaptation to the environment occurs at all biological levels and timescales. The context dependence of environmental stimuli and the need for stable adaptations make EIC a daunting task. We argue that biological complexity is the principal architect that subserves deft execution of stable EIC. Complexity in a system is characterized by several functionally segregated subsystems that show a high degree of functional integration when they interact with each other. Complex biological systems manifest heterogeneities and degeneracy, wherein structurally different subsystems could interact to yield the same functional outcome. We argue that complex systems offer several choices that effectively implement EIC and homeostasis for each of the different contexts encountered by the system.

Voltage-Gated Ion Channels and the Variability in Information Transfer

The prerequisites for neurons to function within a circuit and be able to contain and transfer information efficiently and reliably are that they need to be homeostatically stable and fire within a reasonable range, characteristics that are governed, among others, by voltage-gated ion channels (VGICs). Nonetheless, neurons entail large variability in the expression levels of VGICs and their corresponding intrinsic properties, but the role of this variability in information transfer is not fully known. In this study, we aimed to investigate how this variability of VGICs affects information transfer. For this, we used a previously derived population of neuronal model neurons, each with the variable expression of five types of VGICs, fast Na+, delayed rectifier K+, A-type K+, T-type Ca++, and HCN channels. These analyses showed that the model neurons displayed variability in mutual information transfer, measured as the capability of neurons to successfully encode incoming synaptic information in output firing frequencies. Likewise, variability in the expression of VGICs caused variability in EPSPs and IPSPs amplitudes, reflected in the variability of output firing frequencies. Finally, using the virtual knockout methodology, we show that among the ion channels tested, the A-type K+ channel is the major regulator of information processing and transfer.

Degeneracy in the nervous system: from neuronal excitability to neural coding

Degeneracy is ubiquitous across biological systems where structurally different elements can yield a similar outcome. Degeneracy is of particular interest in neuroscience too. On the one hand, degeneracy confers robustness to the nervous system and facilitates evolvability: Different elements provide a backup plan for the system in response to any perturbation or disturbance. On the other, a difficulty in the treatment of some neurological disorders such as chronic pain is explained in light of different elements all of which contribute to the pathological behavior of the system. Under these circumstances, targeting a specific element is ineffective because other elements can compensate for this modulation. Understanding degeneracy in the physiological context explains its beneficial role in the robustness of neural circuits. Likewise, understanding degeneracy in the pathological context opens new avenues of discovery to find more effective therapies.

Active Dendrites and Local Field Potentials: Biophysical Mechanisms and Computational Explorations

Neurons and glial cells are endowed with membranes that express a rich repertoire of ion channels, transporters, and receptors. The constant flux of ions across the neuronal and glial membranes results in voltage fluctuations that can be recorded from the extracellular matrix. The high frequency components of this voltage signal contain information about the spiking activity, reflecting the output from the neurons surrounding the recording location. The low frequency components of the signal, referred to as the local field potential (LFP), have been traditionally thought to provide information about the synaptic inputs that impinge on the large dendritic trees of various neurons. In this review, we discuss recent computational and experimental studies pointing to a critical role of several active dendritic mechanisms that can influence the genesis and the location-dependent spectro-temporal dynamics of LFPs, spanning different brain regions. We strongly emphasize the need to account for the several fast and slow dendritic events and associated active mechanisms - including gradients in their expression profiles, inter- and intra-cellular spatio-temporal interactions spanning neurons and glia, heterogeneities and degeneracy across scales, neuromodulatory influences, and activitydependent plasticity - towards gaining important insights about the origins of LFP under different behavioral states in health and disease. We provide simple but essential guidelines on how to model LFPs taking into account these dendritic mechanisms, with detailed methodology on how to account for various heterogeneities and electrophysiological properties of neurons and synapses while studying LFPs.

Ion-channel degeneracy: Multiple ion channels heterogeneously regulate intrinsic physiology of rat hippocampal granule cells

Degeneracy, the ability of multiple structural components to elicit the same characteristic functional properties, constitutes an elegant mechanism for achieving biological robustness. In this study, we sought electrophysiological signatures for the expression of ion-channel degeneracy in the emergence of intrinsic properties of rat hippocampal granule cells. We measured the impact of four different ion-channel subtypes-hyperpolarization-activated cyclic-nucleotide-gated (HCN), barium-sensitive inward rectifier potassium (Kir ), tertiapin-Q-sensitive inward rectifier potassium, and persistent sodium (NaP) channels-on 21 functional measurements employing pharmacological agents, and report electrophysiological data on two characteristic signatures for the expression of ion-channel degeneracy in granule cells. First, the blockade of a specific ion-channel subtype altered several, but not all, functional measurements. Furthermore, any given functional measurement was altered by the blockade of many, but not all, ion-channel subtypes. Second, the impact of blocking each ion-channel subtype manifested neuron-to-neuron variability in the quantum of changes in the electrophysiological measurements. Specifically, we found that blocking HCN or Ba-sensitive Kir channels enhanced action potential firing rate, but blockade of NaP channels reduced firing rate of granule cells. Subthreshold measures of granule cell intrinsic excitability (input resistance, temporal summation, and impedance amplitude) were enhanced by blockade of HCN or Ba-sensitive Kir channels, but were not significantly altered by NaP channel blockade. We confirmed that the HCN and Ba-sensitive Kir channels independently altered sub- and suprathreshold properties of granule cells through sequential application of pharmacological agents that blocked these channels. Finally, we found that none of the sub- or suprathreshold measurements of granule cells were significantly altered upon treatment with tertiapin-Q. Together, the heterogeneous many-to-many mapping between ion channels and single-neuron intrinsic properties emphasizes the need to account for ion-channel degeneracy in cellular- and network-scale physiology.

Spatial information transfer in hippocampal place cells depends on trial-to-trial variability, symmetry of place-field firing, and biophysical heterogeneities

The relationship between the feature-tuning curve and information transfer profile of individual neurons provides vital insights about neural encoding. However, the relationship between the spatial tuning curve and spatial information transfer of hippocampal place cells remains unexplored. Here, employing a stochastic search procedure spanning thousands of models, we arrived at 127 conductance-based place-cell models that exhibited signature electrophysiological characteristics and sharp spatial tuning, with parametric values that exhibited neither clustering nor strong pairwise correlations. We introduced trial-to-trial variability in responses and computed model tuning curves and information transfer profiles, using stimulus-specific (SSI) and mutual (MI) information metrics, across locations within the place field. We found spatial information transfer to be heterogeneous across models, but to reduce consistently with increasing levels of variability. Importantly, whereas reliable low-variability responses implied that maximal information transfer occurred at high-slope regions of the tuning curve, increase in variability resulted in maximal transfer occurring at the peak-firing location in a subset of models. Moreover, experience-dependent asymmetry in place-field firing introduced asymmetries in the information transfer computed through MI, but not SSI, and the impact of activity-dependent variability on information transfer was minimal compared to activity-independent variability. We unveiled ion-channel degeneracy in the regulation of spatial information transfer, and demonstrated critical roles for N-methyl-d-aspartate receptors, transient potassium and dendritic sodium channels in regulating information transfer. Our results demonstrate that trial-to-trial variability, tuning-curve shape and biological heterogeneities critically regulate the relationship between the spatial tuning curve and spatial information transfer in hippocampal place cells.

Ion-channel regulation of response decorrelation in a heterogeneous multi-scale model of the dentate gyrus

Heterogeneities in biological neural circuits manifest in afferent connectivity as well as in local-circuit components such as neuronal excitability, neural structure and local synaptic strengths. The expression of adult neurogenesis in the dentate gyrus (DG) amplifies local-circuit heterogeneities and guides heterogeneities in afferent connectivity. How do neurons and their networks endowed with these distinct forms of heterogeneities respond to perturbations to individual ion channels, which are known to change under several physiological and pathophysiological conditions? We sequentially traversed the ion channels-neurons-network scales and assessed the impact of eliminating individual ion channels on conductance-based neuronal and network models endowed with disparate local-circuit and afferent heterogeneities. We found that many ion channels differentially contributed to specific neuronal or network measurements, and the elimination of any given ion channel altered several functional measurements. We then quantified the impact of ion-channel elimination on response decorrelation, a well-established metric to assess the ability of neurons in a network to convey complementary information, in DG networks endowed with different forms of heterogeneities. Notably, we found that networks constructed with structurally immature neurons exhibited functional robustness, manifesting as minimal changes in response decorrelation in the face of ion-channel elimination. Importantly, the average change in output correlation was dependent on the eliminated ion channel but invariant to input correlation. Our analyses suggest that neurogenesis-driven structural heterogeneities could assist the DG network in providing functional resilience to molecular perturbations.

•

Perturbations at one scale result in a cascading impact on physiology across scales.

•

Heterogeneous multi-scale models used to assess the impact of ion-channel deletion.

•

Mapping of structural components to functional outcomes is many-to-many.

•

Differential & variable impact of ion channel deletion on response decorrelation.

•

Neurogenesis-induced structural heterogeneity confers resilience to perturbations.