Biomechanical effects of cervical arthroplasty with U-shaped disc implant on segmental range of motion and loading of surrounding soft tissue

Long-term outcomes of anterior cervical dynamic implants: motion-sparing or a delayed fusion?

BACKGROUND CONTEXT

Use of an anterior cervical dynamic implant (ACDI) is generally considered a nonfusion technique for treating cervical degenerative disorders. However, there is limited research focused on evaluating the long-term clinical and radiographic outcomes of ACDI.

PURPOSE

To analyze the long-term clinical and radiographic outcomes of ACDI in the treatment of degenerative cervical disorders.

STUDY DESIGN

A retrospective cohort study.

PATIENTS SAMPLE

Patients with degenerative cervical disorders who underwent anterior cervical discectomy and dynamic cervical implant (DCI) implantation between May 2012 and August 2020 at our institution were included in this study.

OUTCOME MEASURES

Clinical outcomes were assessed using the modified Japanese Orthopedic Association (mJOA), visual analog scale (VAS) scores and patient reported satisfaction rate. Imaging assessment parameters included intervertebral height (IH), intervertebral disc height (IDH), C2-7 range of motion (ROM), segmental ROM, the degree of DCI subsidence and anterior migration, heterotopic ossification (HO) as well as adjacent segment degeneration (ASD).

METHODS

JOA and VAS scores were obtained through questionnaire. The patient reported satisfaction was rated as very satisfied, satisfied, less satisfied and dissatisfied at the final follow-up. The position of the implants, IDH and IH were evaluated on lateral radiographs. ROM at C2-7, ROM at operated level were measured on dynamic radiographs. Cervical 3-dimensional computer tomography (CT) and magnetic resonance image (MRI) images were used to assess the presence of HO and ASD. The clinical and radiologic variables between the preoperative period and different follow-up time point were statistically analyzed by unpaired t-tests or chi-square tests. Statistical significance was defined as p<.05.

RESULTS

A total of 92 patients (51 males and 41 females) were included in this study. Among them, there were 36 cases of cervical spondylotic myelopathy, 26 cases of cervical radiculopathy, and 30 cases of myeloradiculopathy. The mean age was 55.1±12.6 years. The number of operated levels was single level in 57 patients, 2 levels in 31 patients, and 3 levels in 4 patients. The average follow-up period was 81.3 months (range: 35-135 months). The mean JOA scores showed a gradual increase at 1 month, 1 year, and the final follow-up (12.0±0.7,13.5±0.8, and14.4±1.1 respectively) compared to the preoperative score (9.1±0.9, p<.01). VAS scores significantly decreased at 1 month, 1 year, and the final follow-up (4.1±0.7, 2.3±0.9, and 2.0±0.8 respectively) compared to the preoperative score (7.2±l .2, p<.01). At the final follow-up, the patient reported satisfaction was rated as very satisfied, satisfied, less satisfied and dissatisfied (79%, 10%, 10%, 1% respectively). Revision surgery was not required for any of the patients during the follow-up period, either due to instrumentation failure or adjacent segmental diseases. In the radiographic assessment, there was a notable increase in IH and IDH after surgery compared to preoperative values (33.0±4.0 mm vs 30.7±3.0 mm, p<.01 and 6.7±2.4 mm vs 4.6±0.9 mm, p<.01 respectively), which gradually decreased at 1 year and the final follow-up (IH: 32.1±2.5 vs 30.9±3.5 p=.024; IDH: 5.3±1.5 mm vs 4.3±0.6 mm, p=.043 respectively). At the 1-month postoperative follow-up, the segmental ROM exhibited a decrease compared with preoperative values (6.2±1.8° vs 7.5±2.0° p=.044), followed by an increase at the 1-year follow-up (6.2±1.8° vs 6.4±1.5° p=.078), but ultimately decreased at the final follow-up (6.4±1.5° vs 2.9±0.6°, p<.01). HO was observed in approximately 81.5% of cases (75/92), while a great proportion (41.3%) of patients experienced varying degrees of prosthesis subsidence and anterior migration during the follow-up.

CONCLUSIONS

At the long-term follow-up, a high incidence of HO, along with varying degrees of subsidence and migration of the prosthesis, were observed in most patients. As the motion preservation capability of the ACDI gradually diminishes, delayed intervertebral autofusion becomes a more likely outcome compared to motion sparing.

Return-to-Play Outcomes in Elite Athletes After Cervical and Lumbar Motion Preservation Spine Surgery: A Systematic Review

STUDY DESIGN

Systematic review.

OBJECTIVE

The primary purpose of this article was to survey the present literature and report on return-to-play (RTP) outcomes in elite athletes after undergoing motion preservation spinal surgery (MPSS).

BACKGROUND

For elite performance, athletes require adequate mobility throughout the trunk, torso, and spine to achieve maximal force production. Therefore, elite athletes who have failed conservative treatment may seek to undergo motion-preserving surgical options, such as total disc arthroplasty and lumbar microdiscectomy. Individual studies have reported on RTP outcomes following individual motion preservation surgical procedures, but no systematic reviews have formally reported on RTP outcomes, postoperative performance, and reoperation rates on these procedures in elite athletes.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A systematic review was conducted from inception until February 2024 according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines. One reviewer queried PubMed for relevant studies that reported on RTP outcomes in elite athletes after MPSS based on title and abstract (n = 1404). After the original search query, an additional reviewer screened full-length articles. A total of 11 studies met the inclusion criteria. Special consideration was given to RTP rates, postoperative performance, and reoperation rates.

RESULTS

A total of 612 elite athletes from the National Basketball Association, Major League Baseball, National Football League, National Hockey League, and other professional sporting organizations underwent cervical and lumbar MPSS to treat various spinal pathologies. Various motion-sparing techniques were used to treat various pathologies. After undergoing MPSS, RTP rates ranged from 75% to 100% for lumbar cases and 83.3% to 100% for cervical cases. Postoperative performance varied with some athletes performing at the same level before surgery and some performing at a decreased level.

CONCLUSIONS

MPSS is a feasible option when properly indicated. Future studies are needed to compare return to sport rates, postoperative performance, and reoperation rates between MPSS to spinal arthrodesis.

Biomechanical analysis of single and multi-level artificial disc replacement (ADR) in cervical spine using multi-scale loadings: A finite element study

Artificial disc replacement (ADR) is a clinical procedure used to diagnose cervical degenerative disc disease, preserving range of motion (ROM) at the fixation level and preventing adjacent segment degeneration (ASD). This study analyzed the biomechanics of ADR by examining range of motion (ROM), stress levels in bone and implants, and strain in the bone-implant interface using multi-scale loadings. The study focused on single- and double-level patients across various loading scales during physiological motions within the cervical spine. Results showed increased ROM in single-level and double-level fixations during physiological loadings, while ROM decreased at the adjacent level of fixation with the intact cervical spine model. The Prodisc-Implant metal endplate experienced a maximum von Mises stress of 432 MPa during axial rotation, confirming the long durability and biomechanical performance of the bone-implant interface.

Comparison of biomechanical parameters of two Chinese cervical spine rotation manipulations based on motion capture and finite element analysis

Objective: The purpose of this study was to obtain the stress-strain of the cervical spine structure during the simulated manipulation of the oblique pulling manipulation and the cervical rotation-traction manipulation in order to compare the mechanical mechanism of the two manipulations. Methods: A motion capture system was used to record the key kinematic parameters of operating the two manipulations. At the same time, a three-dimensional finite element model of the C0-T1 full healthy cervical spine was established, and the key kinematic parameters were loaded onto the finite element model in steps to analyze and simulate the detailed process of the operation of the two manipulations. Results: A detailed finite element model of the whole cervical spine including spinal nerve roots was established, and the validity of this 3D finite element model was verified. During the stepwise simulation of the two cervical spine rotation manipulations to the right, the disc (including the annulus fibrosus and nucleus pulposus) and facet joints stresses and displacements were greater in the oblique pulling manipulation group than in the cervical rotation-traction manipulation group, while the spinal cord and nerve root stresses were greater in the cervical rotation-traction manipulation group than in the oblique pulling manipulation group. The spinal cord and nerve root stresses in the cervical rotation-traction manipulation group were mainly concentrated in the C4/5 and C5/6 segments. Conclusion: The oblique pulling manipulation may be more appropriate for the treatment of cervical spondylotic radiculopathy, while cervical rotation-traction manipulation is more appropriate for the treatment of cervical spondylosis of cervical type. Clinicians should select cervical rotation manipulations for different types of cervical spondylosis according to the patient's symptoms and needs.

Effects of cervical rotatory manipulation on the cervical spinal cord complex with ossification of the posterior longitudinal ligament in the vertebral canal: A finite element study

Background: There are few studies focusing on biomechanism of spinal cord injury according to the ossification of the posterior longitudinal ligament (OPLL) during cervical rotatory manipulation (CRM). This study aimed to explore the biomechanical effects of CRM on the spinal cord, dura matter and nerve roots with OPLL in the cervical vertebral canal. Methods: Three validated FE models of the craniocervical spine and spinal cord complex were constructed by adding mild, moderate, and severe OPLL to the healthy FE model, respectively. We simulated the static compression of the spinal cord by OPLL and the dynamic compression during CRM in the flexion position. The stress distribution of the spinal cord complex was investigated. Results: The cervical spinal cord experienced higher von Mises stress under static compression by the severe OPLL. A higher von Mises stress was observed on the spinal cord in the moderate and severe OPLL models during CRM. The dura matter and nerve roots had a higher von Mises stress in all three models during CRM. Conclusion: The results show a high risk in performing CRM in the flexion position on patients with OPLL, in that different occupying ratios in the vertebral canal due to OPLL could significantly increase the stress on the spinal cord complex.

Biomechanical Analysis of Two-Level Novel Cage-Type Implant for Anterior Cervical Discectomy and Fusion: A Finite Element Analysis

One of the standard treatments for spinal diseases is anterior cervical discectomy and fusion (ACDF). ACDF is a secure and successful operation that prevents patients to improve their pain and function. The mechanical goal of the ACDF is to prevent motion between adjoining vertebrae by a novel cage-screw implant. The objective of this study is to analyze the biomechanical flexibility in terms of the range of motion (ROM) of two-level ACDF fixation using the finite element method (FEM). A CT scan-based FEM model of the cervical spine (C2-C7) is used and two-level cage is implanted at C4-C6 segments. A 50-N compressive force and 1-Nm moment are applied on C2 vertebrae and C7 is fixed in all directions. The ROM at two-level fixation (C4-C5-C6) is reduced by 55 to 88% compared with intact spine during all physiological movement. The ROM slightly increase (3-9%) at the adjacent segment. The maximum von Mises stress variations are 25-65 MPa during flexion-extension, lateral bending, and axial rotations under given loading. The maximum von Mises stress found in cage and screw is below the yield stress during all physiological movement.

Effect of cervical spine motion on displacement of posterolateral annulus fibrosus in cervical spondylotic radiculopathy with contained posterolateral disc herniation: a three-dimensional finite element analysis

BACKGROUND

Previous studies on dynamic impingement of nerve root in cervical spondylotic radiculopathy (CSR) have focused on effect of cervical spine motion (CSM) on dimensional changes of intervertebral foramen. However, there are few studies to investigate effect of CSM on displacement of posterolateral intervertebral disc until now. The present study aimed to investigate effect of CSM on displacement of posterolateral annulus fibrosus (AF) in CSR with contained posterolateral disc herniation.

METHODS

A C5-C6 CSR finite element model with unilateral contained posterolateral disc herniation was generated based on validated C5-C6 normal finite element model. Forward and backward displacement distributions of posterolateral AFs in CSR model and normal model were compared. Changes in forward and backward displacement magnitudes of posterolateral AFs of the herniated side and the healthy side in CSR model, with respect to those of the ipsilateral posterolateral AFs in normal model, were compared. The comparisons were performed under flexion, extension, lateral bendings and axial rotations.

RESULTS

There was no difference in deformation trend of posterolateral AF between CSR model and normal model. Bilateral posterolateral AFs mainly moved forward during flexion and backward during extension. Left posterolateral AF mainly moved backward and right posterolateral AF forward during left lateral bending and left axial rotation. Left posterolateral AF mainly moved forward and right posterolateral AF backward during right lateral bending and right axial rotation. However, with respect to forward and backward displacement magnitudes of the ipsilateral posterolateral AFs in normal model, those of the herniated side increased relatively significantly compared with those of the healthy side in CSR model.

CONCLUSIONS

Flexion, lateral bending to the healthy side and axial rotation to the healthy side make posterolateral AF of the herniated side mainly move forward, whereas extension, lateral bending to the herniated side and axial rotation to the herniated side make it mainly move backward. These data may help select CSM or positions to diagnose and treat CSR with contained posterolateral disc herniation. Increase in deformation amplitude of posterolateral AF of the herniated side may also be the reason for dynamic impingement of nerve root in CSR with contained posterolateral disc herniation.

Incorporating strategy in hybrid surgery for continuous two-level cervical spondylosis from a biomechanical perspective

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Hybrid surgery, incorporating cervical disc replacement and anterior cervical discectomy and fusion, has shown good clinical results in the treatment of multilevel cervical spondylosis according to early follow-ups. This study investigated the surgical strategy of hybrid surgery for two-level cervical spondylosis by distinguishing the biomechanical characteristics with different incorporating modes.

METHOD

A finite element model of a healthy cervical spine including C2-T1 was developed, and hybrid surgery was simulated by replacing at one level with Prestige-LP and fusion at another level with the anterior plate in C3-C5 (Hybrid-S1: replaced at C3-C4, Hybrid-S2: replaced at C4-C5), and in C4-C6 (Hybrid-M1: replaced at C4-C5, Hybrid-M2: replaced at C5-C6) and in C5-C7 (Hybrid-U1: replaced at C5-C6, Hybrid-U2: replaced at C6-C7). The motion of C2 vertebrae in flexion, extension, axial rotation, and lateral bending was imposed on all hybrid models following the displacement control testing protocol.

RESULTS

The largest range of motion (ROM) in a healthy spine was observed at C5-C6, followed by C3-C4, C4-C5 and C6-C7. On average, the ROM at the replaced segment increased by 175.7%, 202.7%, 176.3%, 117.1%, 139.4%, and 236.0% in Hybrid-S1, Hybrid-S2, Hybrid-M1, Hybrid-M2, Hybrid-U1, and Hybrid-U2, respectively. The facet joint stress at the replaced segment increased by 186.9%, 124.4%, 111.1%, 60.3%, 62.7%, and 144.7%, and the adjacent intradiscal pressure (IDP) increased by 45.2%, 38.7%, 2.7%, 2.1%, 13.9%, and 20.1%.

CONCLUSIONS

Incorporating mode in hybrid surgery affects cervical biomechanics. Hybrid surgery with replacement at a segment with a greater ROM and fusion at a segment with a lower ROM can results in fewer changes in terms of overall cervical stiffness, ROM at the operative level, facet joint stress, and adjacent IDP. In hybrid surgery, it is better to implement disc replacement at a level with a greater ROM and fusion of another segment.

Dynamic Cervical Implants in Patients With Disc Degenerative Disease: A Single-Center Cohort From the Greek Population

Aim

The aim of this study was to review the safety and feasibility, clinical and radiological outcomes, and postoperative complications associated with the use of dynamic cervical implants (DCI).

Patients and methods

A prospective single-cohort study was performed of all consecutive patients who underwent DCI implantation as an adjunct to anterior cervical discectomy. We measured the anterior disc space height (ADH) and posterior disc space height (PDH), as well as the ADH/PDH ratio.

Results

In 11 patients, the ADH/PDH ratio averaged 0.98 (range: 0.7-1.125) postoperatively, from the initial 0.96 (range: 0.72-1.106).

Conclusion

DCI seems to be a viable alternative to anterior cervical discectomy and fusion. However, its role in motion preservation and protection against the degeneration of the adjacent segment is questioned.

Numerical Size Optimization of Cervical Spine Disc Prosthesis Mobi-C Using Design of Experiment Technics

The cervical spine is a structure subject to various vertebral injuries, namely, herniation of intervertebral discs and osteoporosis. Nowadays, several segments of society are vulnerable to these diseases that affect spine motion especially elderly people and women. Hence, various designs of cervical artificial discs are in use or under investigation claiming to restore the normal kinematics of the cervical spine. In this work, it is proposed to minimize the stress level by numerical size optimization in the Mobi-C cervical spine prosthesis to improve their biomechanical performances. For this aim, design of experiment (DoE) is employed as an optimization technique to investigate three geometrical parameters of the prosthesis design. Accordingly, DoE optimization allowed to minimize the equivalent stress value on Mobi-C from 20.3 MPa to 17.856 MPa corresponding to a percentage decrease of 12% from the original geometry. This provides an advantage for the durability of the prosthesis and also for the bone by reducing stress concentration.

A comparative finite element analysis of artificial intervertebral disc replacement and pedicle screw fixation of the lumbar spine

Titanium alloy-based Pedicle screw-rod fusion is a very common technique to provide higher fusion regularity than other methods. In recent times, Carbon-fibre-reinforced (CFR)-PEEK rod is used to better reduce the fusion rate. Alternatively, total disc replacement (TDR) is also very common for the non-fusion treatment method for degenerative disc disease (DDD). This study aims to investigate flexibility (ROM), stability, stress condition in implant, implant adjacent bone of the implanted lumbar spine during different physiological movements and loading environments. The finite element (FE) intact model of the lumbar spine (L2-L5) with two-level pedicle screw-rod fusion at L3-L4-L5 and two-level artificial disc replacement was developed. CFR-PEEK was taken for rod for semi-rigid fusion. UHMWPE was taken as core part of the artificial disc. The FE models were simulated under 6, 8 and 10 Nm moments in left right lateral bending, flexion and extension movements. The total ROM was reduced for two-level pedicle screw fixation and increased for the artificial disc replacement model during flexion extension compared to the intact spine. The total ROM was reduced by around 54% and 25% for two-level fixation and increased by 30% and 19.5% for artificial disc replacement spine, under flexion-extension and left-right lateral bending respectively. For screw fixation, the ROM increased by 15% and 18% reduced by 4.5% and 14% for disc replacement at the adjacent segments for flexion-extension and left-right lateral bending.

Investigation into Cervical Spine Biomechanics Following Single, Multilevel and Hybrid Disc Replacement Surgery with Dynamic Cervical Implant and Fusion: A Finite Element Study

Cervical fusion has been a standard procedure for treating abnormalities associated with the cervical spine. However, the reliability of anterior cervical discectomy and fusion (ACDF) has become arguable due to its adverse effects on the biomechanics of adjacent segments. One of the drawbacks associated with ACDF is adjacent segment degeneration (ASD), which has served as the base for the development of dynamic stabilization systems (DSS) and total disc replacement (TDR) devices for cervical spine. However, the hybrid surgical technique has also gained popularity recently, but its effect on the biomechanics of cervical spine is not well researched. Thus, the objective of this FE study was to draw a comparison among single-level, bi-level, and hybrid surgery with dynamic cervical implants (DCIs) with traditional fusion. Reductions in the range of motion (ROM) for all the implanted models were observed for all the motions except extension, compared to for the intact model. The maximum increase in the ROM of 42% was observed at segments C5–C6 in the hybrid DCI model. The maximum increase in the adjacent segment’s ROM of 8.7% was observed in the multilevel fusion model. The maximum von Mises stress in the implant was highest for the multilevel DCI model. Our study also showed that the shape of the DCI permitted flexion/extension relatively more compared to lateral bending and axial rotation.

Effects of cervical rotatory manipulation on the cervical spinal cord: a finite element study

BACKGROUND

Little information is available concerning the biomechanism involved in the spinal cord injury after cervical rotatory manipulation (CRM). The primary purpose of this study was to explore the biomechanical and kinematic effects of CRM on a healthy spinal cord.

METHODS

A finite element (FE) model of the basilaris cranii, C1-C7 vertebral bodies, nerve root complex and vertebral canal contents was constructed and validated against in vivo and in vitro published data. The FE model simulated CRM in the flexion, extension and neutral positions. The stress distribution, forma and relative position of the spinal cord were observed.

RESULTS

Lower von Mises stress was observed on the spinal cord after CRM in the flexion position. The spinal cord in CRM in the flexion and neutral positions had a lower sagittal diameter and cross-sectional area. In addition, the spinal cord was anteriorly positioned after CRM in the flexion position, while the spinal cord was posteriorly positioned after CRM in the extension and neutral positions.

CONCLUSION

CRM in the flexion position is less likely to injure the spinal cord, but caution is warranted when posterior vertebral osteophytes or disc herniations exist.

Clinical and radiological outcomes of dynamic cervical implant arthroplasty: A 5-year follow-up

BACKGROUND

Dynamic cervical implant (DCI) stabilization has been reported to have satisfactory clinical and radiological results with short- and mid-term follow-up in the treatment of cervical degenerative disc disease. However, few reports about the clinical and radiological outcome with more than 5-year follow-up exist.

AIM

To investigate the long-term clinical and radiological results of DCI arthroplasty.

METHODS

A total of 40 patients who received DCI arthroplasty were consecutively reviewed from May 2010 to August 2015. Visual analogue scale (VAS), neck disability index (NDI) score, Japanese Orthopaedic Association (JOA) score, and SF-36 items were used to assess neural function rehabilitation. Static and dynamic radiographs and 3-dimentional computed tomography were used to evaluate the radiological outcomes.

RESULTS

The scores of neck/arm VAS, NDI, JOA, and 8-dimensions of SF-36 were significantly improved at the 1-mo follow-up (P < 0.05) and maintained until the last follow-up (P < 0.05). The range of motion (ROM) of C2-C7, functional spinal unit (FSU), upper/lower adjacent level, C2-C7 lateral bending, and FSU lateral bending decreased at the 1-mo follow-up (P < 0.05), whereas they increased to the preoperative level at the later follow-up intervals (P > 0.05), except the ROM of FSU lateral bending (P < 0.05). The C2-C7 alignment and FSU angle kept more lordotic at the last follow-up (P < 0.05). The intervertebral height increased significantly at the 1-mo follow-up (P < 0.05) and decreased at later follow-ups (P > 0.05). At the last follow-up, 12 (26.1%) segments developed heterotopic ossification.

CONCLUSION

DCI arthroplasty is a safe and effective non-fusion technique to treat cervical degenerative disc disease in long-term follow-up.

Hybrid implants in anterior cervical decompressive surgery for degenerative disease

Background:

Anterior cervical discectomy and fusion (ACDF) still represent the mainstream surgical approach in the treatment of degenerative cervical Degenerative Disc Disease (DDD), being a loss of mobility at the treated segment and adjacent segment diseases well-known complications. To overcome those complications, hybrid surgery (HS) incorporating ACDF and cervical disk arthroplasty is increasingly performed for DDD.

Methods:

We retrospectively reviewed the clinical, surgical, and outcome data of 62 consecutive patients (male/female, 29/37) harboring cervical disk herniation with or without osteophytes, with radiculopathy with or without myelopathy, who underwent a cervical discectomy on two or more levels with the anterior approach with at least one disk prosthesis along with cage and plate or O Profile screwed plate.

Results:

All the patients improved regardless of the cervical construct used. No significant relationship between different kind of prostheses as well as their surgical level, the number and the site of the cages (screwed and/or plated) was found out concerning immediate stability, dynamic prosthesis effectiveness, and clinical improvement in all the patients up to the maximum follow-up.

Conclusions:

Although the optimal surgical technique for cervical DDD remains controversial, HS represents a safe and effective procedure in selected patients with multilevel cervical DDD, as demonstrated by biomechanical and clinical studies and the present series. Some technical aspects should be considered when dealing with this procedure, like the drilling of the endplate, and some radiological findings have to be detected because potentially predictive of future misplacement.

Parametric study of anterior percutaneous endoscopic cervical discectomy (APECD)

Anterior percutaneous endoscopic cervical discectomy (APECD) is a common treatment for cervical spondylotic radiculopathy (CSR). In this study, the effects of various channel diameters and approach angles on cervical vertebrae on postoperative outcomes in APECD surgery were explored. A finite element model of intact cervical C₃-C₇ was constructed and then modified to obtain six surgical models. Range of motion (ROM) and intradiscal pressure (IDP) were calculated under different conditions of flexion (Fle), extension (Ext), lateral bending, and axial rotation. During Fle and bending to the left (LB), the ROM was closer to the intact model when the angle of approach was 90°. During bending to the left (LB) and rotation to the left (LR), the ROM changed considerably (43.2%, 33.7%, respectively) where the angle of approach was 45°. As the surgical channel diameter increased, the extent of the change in ROM compared with the intact model also increased. IDP decreased by 48% and 49%, respectively, compared with the intact model at the C₅-C₆ segment where the angle of approach was 45° and 60° during Fle, while it changed little at 90°, by less than 10%. The IDP was increased noticeably by 117.6%, 82.1%, and 105.8%, for channel diameters of 2, 3 and 4 mm, respectively. And declined noticeably during LB and LR (LB: 27.1%, 27.1%, 38.5%; LR: 37.4%, 35.5%, 48.7%). The results demonstrated that the shorter the surgical path, the smaller surgical diameter, the less the biomechanical influence on the cervical vertebra.

Total disc arthroplasties alter the characteristics of the instantaneous helical axis of the cervical functional spinal units C3/C4 and C5/C6 during flexion and extension in in vitro conditions

Total disc arthroplasty (TDA) increases the risk of adjacent segment disease (ASD). Kinematic analyses are necessary to compare the intact condition (IC) with alterations after TDA to develop better prostheses. A well-established 6D measuring apparatus (resolution < 2.4 μm; 400 positions/cycle) was used. Kinematics of the flexion and extension of 8 human cervical spine segments (cFSU) C3/C4 and C5/C6 (67.9 ± 13.2 y) were analyzed in the IC and after TDA (Bryan® Cervical Disc [B-TDA], Prestige LP® Cervical Disc [P-TDA]). The migration of the instantaneous helical axis (IHA) and the stiffness of the segments were calculated. Analyses demonstrated a stretched U-curved IHA migration in the sagittal plane. The IHA positions were significantly more cranial in cFSU C5/C6 than in C3/C4 in IC and after either TDA (IC: p < 0.001; B-TDA: p = 0.001; P-TDA: p = 0.045). In cFSU C3/C4 IHA positions shifted anteriocranially after either TDA (p < 0.001). In cFSU C5/C6, the IHA positions were significantly more anterocranial after B-TDA than in IC and after P-TDA (anterior: p < 0.001; cranial: p = 0.005). After B-TDA, the IHA migration path length was significantly longer in cFSU C3/C4 than in C5/C6 (p = 0.007) and longer than in IC in both cFSU (C3/C4: p = 0.047; C5/C6: p < 0.001). Stiffness was increased after both TDA. Various kinematic alterations were observed after both TDA. Increased translation and IHA position shifting after both TDA might indicate abnormal strain and a derogated benefit of TDA. These results imply the most abnormal strain after B-TDA. The lower cFSU might be more susceptible to alterations after TDA than the upper cFSU.

BIOMECHANICAL PERFORMANCE OF A MODIFIED DESIGN OF DYNAMIC CERVICAL IMPLANT COMPARED TO CONVENTIONAL BALL AND SOCKET DESIGN OF AN ARTIFICIAL INTERVERTEBRAL DISC IMPLANT: A FINITE ELEMENT STUDY

Most of the implants used for total disc replacement (TDR) surgery are designed as a ball and socket pair aimed at providing a three-dimensional unconstrained motion. However, one of the major concerns with ball and socket design is the wear of the implant which limits its life. In this study the biomechanical performance of two types of implant designs is compared — a conventional ball and socket type (Prodisc-C) and a modified design of dynamic cervical implant (DCI) using FE analysis. A 3-dimensional geometrical model of cervical spine (C1–T1) was developed using CT scan data of a middle-aged healthy male. Subsequently, using FE analysis, the ROM values were validated with the existing literature using a compressive load in combination with different physiological motions of the neck. Furthermore, FE analysis on the two implants, fitted at C5–C6 segment, showed a significant increase in the ROM of implanted segment using Prodisc and decrease in the ROM of inferior segment, but modified-DCI restored the motion of the implanted and adjacent segments. Analysis of average bone strains adjacent to the implant showed a possibility of stress shielding for Prodisc. However, higher stress distribution on the modified-DCI limited its clinical use.

Biomechanical Effects of Lateral Bending Position on Performing Cervical Spinal Manipulation for Cervical Disc Herniation: A Three-Dimensional Finite Element Analysis

Background

Most studies report that the common position of cervical spinal manipulation (CSM) for treating symptomatic cervical disc herniation (CDH) is lateral bending to the herniated side. However, the rationality of lateral bending position on performing CSM for CDH is still unclear.

Objective

The purpose of this study is to investigate the biomechanical effects of lateral bending position on performing CSM for CDH.

Methods

A finite element (FE) model of CDH (herniated on the left side) was generated in C5-6 segment based on the normal FE model. The FE model performed CSM in left lateral bending position, neutral position, and right lateral bending position, respectively. Cervical disc displacement, annulus fiber stress, and facet joint stress were observed during the simulation of CSM.

Results

The cervical disc displacement on herniated side moved forward during CSM, and the maximum forward displacements were 0.23, 0.36, and 0.45 mm in left lateral bending position, neutral position, and right lateral bending position, respectively. As the same trend of cervical disc displacement, the annulus fiber stresses on herniated side from small to large were 7.40, 16.39, and 22.75 MPa in left lateral bending position, neutral position, and right lateral bending position, respectively. However, the maximum facet stresses at left superior cartilage of C6 in left lateral bending position, neutral position, and right lateral bending position were 6.88, 3.60, and 0.12 MPa, respectively.

Conclusion

Compared with neutral position and right lateral bending position, though the forward displacement of cervical disc on herniated side was smaller in left lateral bending position, the annulus fiber stress on herniated side was declined by sharing load on the left facet joint. The results suggested that lateral bending to the herniated side on performing CSM tends to protect the cervical disc on herniated side. Future clinical studies are needed to verify that.

Clinical and radiographic outcome of dynamic cervical implant (DCI) arthroplasty for degenerative cervical disc disease: a minimal five-year follow-up

Background

To evaluate the mid- to long-term clinical and radiographic outcomes of anterior cervical discectomy and dynamic cervical implant (DCI) arthroplasty for degenerative cervical disc disease.

Methods

From April 2010 to October 2010, 38 patients with single- or double-level cervical disc herniation underwent anterior cervical discectomy and DCI arthroplasty. The clinical results and radiographic outcomes of these 38 patients (42 levels) were retrospectively evaluated. The clinical results included the visual analogue scale, Japanese Orthopaedic Association score, Neck Disability Index score, 36-item short form health survey questionnaire, and incidences of complications and neurological deterioration. Radiographic results including cervical alignment, intervertebral height, cervical range of motion (ROM), ROM of the functional spinal unit, adjacent intervertebral ROM, migration, subsidence, and heterotopic ossification (HO) were assessed on plain radiography, three-dimensional computed tomography, and magnetic resonance imaging.

Results

The mean follow-up period was 72.3 months (range 68–78 months). During follow-up, all patients showed significant improvements in the visual analogue scale score, Japanese Orthopaedic Association score, Neck Disability Index score, 36-item short form health survey physical component summary score and mental component summary score. The ROM of the functional spinal unit was partly reduced. The DCI migrated forward in 10 of 42 (23.8%) cases, and HO was detected in 24 of the 42 (57.1%) DCI segments. Subsidence was observed in 14 of 42 (33.3%) DCI segments. Two patients experienced symptom recurrence, and were treated conservatively.

Conclusions

The clinical efficacy of DCI arthroplasty was maintained during mid- to long-term follow-up. HO formation is a common phenomenon, leading to a substantial decrease in ROM at the index level and recurrence of neurological symptoms. The incidence of implant subsidence and migration is relatively high, leaving a potential risk of symptoms at the index level and adjacent segment degeneration. We consider that the first choice for patients with degenerative cervical disc disease should still be total disc replacement or anterior cervical discectomy and fusion, rather than DCI arthroplasty.

Prosthesis and Hybrid Strategy Consideration for Treating Two-level Cervical Disc Degeneration in Hybrid Surgery

STUDY DESIGN

Biomechanical analysis using a validated nonlinear finite element (FE) model.

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to combine the strategy of two-level hybrid surgery (HS) to explore how prostheses affect cervical biomechanics.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Few FE studies have explored differences in biomechanical behavior between combined and stand-alone structured prostheses with HS. No FE studies have considered whether the prosthesis type and hybrid strategy influence two-level HS.

METHODS

Three prostheses-Prodisc-C, PCM, and DCI-were analyzed in flexion and extension during HS at C4-C6. There were two HS constructs: anterior cervical discectomy and fusion (ACDF) conducted at the C4-C5 levels and anterior cervical disc replacement (ACDR) conducted at C5-C6 levels (ACDF/ACDR); ACDR/ACDF.

RESULTS

Flexion motion at adjacent levels was greater than that of intact spine. A maximum increase of 80% was observed with PCM in the ACDF/ACDR group. Extension motion at adjacent levels for both hybrid strategies with PCM, however, was similar to that of intact spine (<10% change), whereas it increased by 14% to 32% with DCI. The strain energy-storing capability with DCI tended to be similar to that of normal discs. Facet stress at the infra-adjacent level, however, significantly increased with DCI in both groups, whereas it increased with PCM and Prodisc-C only in the ACDR/ACDF group. All prostheses produced overloads on cartilage at the arthroplasty level. Prodisc-C and PCM cores showed stress above the yield stress of ultrahigh-molecular-weight polyethylene.

CONCLUSION

Each prosthesis had advantages and disadvantages. In extension, DCI (vs. Prodisc-C and PCM) exhibited more compensation at adjacent levels in terms of motion, moments, and facet stress. The biomechanical performance of Prodisc-C was easily affected by the hybrid strategy. Thus, if only a combined-structure prosthesis is available for two-level HS (C4-C6 level), the hybrid strategy should be carefully evaluated and the ACDF/ACDR construct is recommended to avoid accelerating degeneration of adjacent segments.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

5.

Numerical Shape Optimization of Cervical Spine Disc Prosthesis Prodisc-C

Various ball and socket-type designs of cervical artificial discs are in use or under investigation. All these disc designs claim to restore the normal kinematics of the cervical spine. In this study, we are interested in the cervical prosthesis, which concerns the most sensitive part of the human body, given the movements generated by the head. The goal of this work is to minimize the constraints by numerical shape optimization in the prodisc-C cervical spine prosthesis in order to improve performance and bio-functionality as well as patient relief. Prodisc-C cervical spine prosthesis consists of two cobalt chromium alloy plates and a fixed nucleus. Ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene, on each plate there is a keel to stabilize the prosthesis; this prosthesis allows thee degrees of freedom in rotation. To achieve this goal, a static study was carried out to determine the constraint concentrations on the different components of the prosthesis. Based on the biomechanical behaviour of the spine discs, we totally fixed the lower metal plate; a vertical load of 73.6 N to simulate the weight of the head was applied to the superior metallic endplate. After a static study on this prosthesis, using a finite element model, we noticed that the concentration of the Von-Mises stress is concentrated on the peripheral edge core and the concave articulating surface of the superior metallic endplate the numerical. We use the module optimization for 3D SolidWorks for optimize our design, based on the criteria of minimizing stress value. Shape optimization concluded to minimize the equivalent stress value on both joint surface (concave and convex) from 11.3 MPa to 9.1MPa corresponding to a percentage decrease of 19.4% from the original geometry. We conclude that despite the fact that maximum Von Mises stresses are higher in the case of the dynamic load, remains that they are weak. Which is an advantage for the durability of the prosthesis and-also for the bone, because a low stress concentration on the prosthesis will reduce stress concentration generated by the implant on the bone, therefore its risk of fracture reduces.

Biomechanical Analysis of Two-level Cervical Disc Replacement With a Stand-alone U-shaped Disc Implant

STUDY DESIGN

Biomechanical study using a three-dimensional nonlinear finite element model.

OBJECTIVE

To analyze biomechanical changes with three prostheses based on two-level arthroplasty and to verify the biomechanical efficiency of dynamic cervical implants (DCIs) with a stand-alone U-shaped structure.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Few studies have compared biomechanical behavior of various prostheses as they relate with clinical results after two-level total disc replacement.

METHODS

Three arthroplasty devices Mobi-C, porous coated motion (PCM), and DCI were inserted at the C4-C6 disc space and analyzed. Displacement loading was applied to the center of the endplate at the C3 level to simulate flexion and extension motions.

RESULTS

The motion distributions in extension with DCI and in flexion with DCI and Mobi-C were relatively close to that in the intact model. Mobi-C and PCM obviously increased the combined extension range of motion at the index levels, but both resulted in about 45% decrease in extension moment. DCI showed a trend in strain energy similar to that of healthy discs. PCM exhibited a facet joint stress distribution almost similar to that of the intact model. DCI did not generate significant overloading at cartilage between the index levels, whereas the maximum facet joint stress increased with Mobi-C was about 39%. The maximum stress on a ultrahigh molecular-weight-polyethylene core was above the yield stress (42.43 MPa for Mobi-C and 30.94 MPa for PCM).

CONCLUSION

Each prosthesis shows its biomechanical advantages and disadvantages. However, DCI has the capacity to preserve motion and store energy under external loading, similar to the behavior of normal discs. Compared with Mobi-C, both DCI and PCM showed a lower stress at cartilage between index levels, which may avoid facet joint degeneration to some extent. Such a well-controlled arthroplasty device with a stand-alone structure may be a potential candidate and needs to be investigated in future studies.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

5.

Influence of assigned material combination in a simulated total cervical disc replacement design on kinematics of a model of the full cervical spine: A finite element analysis study

BACKGROUND

Although cervical total disc replacement (TDR) is becoming popular, there are no finite analysis (FEA) studies involving a model of the full spine cervical (C1-C7) and determination of the influence of materials assigned to different parts of a specified TDR design on biomechanics of the model when TDR implantation is simulated.

OBJECTIVE

To determine the influence of assigned material combination, for a given cervical TDR design, on the kinematics of a model of the full cervical spine.

METHODS

A three-dimensional solid model of the full cervical spine was constructed, a finite element mesh was obtained (INT Model), after which FEA was used to determine range of motion (ROM) at each of the intersegmental positions under three clinically-relevant loadings. INT model was then modified by simulated implantation of a notional endplates-and-mobile insert TDR design, at C5-C6 (TDR Model), and six clinically-relevant applied loadings were applied. Four variants of TDR Model were used, the difference between them being in the materials assigned to the endplates and the mobile insert. Under each of the loadings, principal motions at each of the intersegmental positions were determined and compared to counterpart motions when INT Model was used.

RESULTS

Comparison of ROM results of INT Model with relevant experimental results reported in the literature showed that the model was validated. With TDR Model, the smallest overall mean of the absolute values of the % change in principal intersegmental motions (relative to corresponding results in INT Model) was when the material assigned to both the endplates and the mobile insert was poly(ether-ether-ketone).

CONCLUSION

In a simulated implantation of a notional endplates-and-mobile-insert TDR design in a model of the full cervical spine, material combination assigned to the parts of the design exerts a marked influence on the kinematics of the model.

Can an Endplate-conformed Cervical Cage Provide a Better Biomechanical Environment than a Typical Non-conformed Cage?: A Finite Element Model and Cadaver Study

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the biomechanical characteristics of endplate-conformed cervical cages by finite element method (FEM) analysis and cadaver study.

METHODS

Twelve specimens (C2 -C7 ) and a finite element model (C3 -C7 ) were subjected to biomechanical evaluations. In the cadaver study, specimens were randomly assigned to intact (I), endplate-conformed (C) and non-conformed (N) groups with C4-5 discs as the treated segments. The morphologies of the endplate-conformed cages were individualized according to CT images of group C and the cages fabricated with a 3-D printer. The non-conformed cages were wedge-shaped and similar to commercially available grafts. Axial pre-compression loads of 73.6 N and moment of 1.8 Nm were used to simulate flexion (FLE), extension (EXT), lateral bending (LB) and axial rotation (AR). Range of motion (ROM) at C4-5 of each specimen was recorded and film sensors fixed between the cages and C5 superior endplates were used to detect interface stress. A finite element model was built based on the CT data of a healthy male volunteer. The morphologies of the endplate-conformed and wedge-shaped, non-conformed cervical cages were both simulated by a reverse engineering technique and implanted at the segment of C4-5 in the finite element model for biomechanical evaluation. Force loading and grouping were similar to those applied in the cadaver study. ROM of C4-5 in group I were recorded to validate the finite element model. Additionally, maximum cage-endplate interface stresses, stress distribution contours on adjoining endplates, intra-disc stresses and facet loadings at adjacent segments were measured and compared between groups.

RESULTS

In the cadaver study, Group C showed a much lower interface stress in all directions of motion (all P < 0.05) and the ROM of C4-5 was smaller in FLE-EXT (P = 0.001) but larger in AR (P = 0.017). FEM analysis produced similar results: the model implanted with an endplate-conformed cage presented a lower interface stress with a more uniform stress distribution than that implanted with a non-conformed cage. Additionally, intra-disc stress and facet loading at the adjacent segments were obviously increased in both groups C and N, especially those at the supra-jacent segments. However, stress increase was milder in group C than in group N for all directions of motion.

CONCLUSIONS

Endplate-conformed cages can decrease cage-endplate interface stress in all directions of motion and increase cervical stability in FLE-EXT. Additionally, adjacent segments are possibly protected because intra-disc stress and facet loading are smaller after endplate-conformed cage implantation. However, axial stability was reduced in group C, indicating that endplate-conformed cage should not be used alone and an anterior plate system is still important in anterior cervical discectomy and fusion.

Biomechanical consideration of prosthesis selection in hybrid surgery for bi-level cervical disc degenerative diseases

PURPOSE

Hybrid surgery (HS) coupling total disc replacement and fusion has been increasingly applied for multilevel cervical disc diseases (CDD). However, selection of the optimal disc prosthesis for HS in an individual patient has not been investigated. This study aimed to distinguish the biomechanical performances of five widely used prostheses (Bryan, ProDisc-C, PCM, Mobi-C, and Discover) in HS for the treatment of bi-level CDD.

METHODS

A finite element model of healthy cervical spine (C3-C7) was developed, and five HS models using different disc prostheses were constructed by arthrodesis at C4-C5 and by arthroplasty at C5-C6. First, the rotational displacements in flexion (Fl), extension, axial rotation, and lateral bending in the healthy model under 1.0 Nm moments combined with 73.6 N follower load were achieved, and then the maximum rotations in each direction combined with the same follower load were applied in the surgical models following displacement control testing protocols.

RESULTS

The range of motion (ROM) of the entire operative and adjacent levels was close to that of the healthy spine for ball-in-socket prostheses, that is, ProDisc-C, Mobi-C, and Discover, in Fl. For Bryan and PCM, the ROM of the operative levels was less than that of the healthy spine in Fl and resulted in the increase in ROMs at the adjacent levels. Ball-in-socket prostheses produced similar reaction moments (92-99 %) in Fl, which were close to that of the healthy spine. Meanwhile, Bryan and PCM required greater moments (>130 %). The adjacent intradiscal pressures (IDPs) in the models of ball-in-socket prostheses were close to that of the healthy spine. Meanwhile, in the models of Bryan and PCM, the adjacent IDPs were 25 % higher than that of the ball-in-socket models. The maximum facet stress in the model of Mobi-C was the greatest among all prostheses, which was approximately two times that of the healthy spine. Moreover, Bryan produced the largest stress on the bone-implant interface, followed by PCM, Mobi-C, ProDisc-C, and Discover.

CONCLUSION

Each disc prosthesis has its biomechanical advantages and disadvantages in HS and should be selected on an individual patient basis. In general, ProDisc-C, Mobi-C, and Discover produced similar performances in terms of spinal motions, adjacent IDPs, and driving moments, whereas Bryan and PCM produced similar biomechanical performances. Therefore, HS with Discover, Bryan, and PCM may be suitable for patients with potential risk of facet joint degeneration, whereas HS with ProDisc-C, Mobi-C, and Discover may be suitable for patients with potential risk of vertebral osteoporosis.

Effect of pillow height on the biomechanics of the head-neck complex: investigation of the cranio-cervical pressure and cervical spine alignment

BACKGROUND

While appropriate pillow height is crucial to maintaining the quality of sleep and overall health, there are no universal, evidence-based guidelines for pillow design or selection. We aimed to evaluate the effect of pillow height on cranio-cervical pressure and cervical spine alignment.

METHODS

Ten healthy subjects (five males) aged 26 ± 3.6 years were recruited. The average height, weight, and neck length were 167 ± 9.3 cm, 59.6 ± 11.9 kg, and 12.9 ± 1.2 cm respectively. The subjects lay on pillows of four different heights (H0, 110 mm; H1, 130 mm; H2, 150 mm; and H3, 170 mm). The cranio-cervical pressure distribution over the pillow was recorded; the peak and average pressures for each pillow height were compared by one-way ANOVA with repeated measures. Cervical spine alignment was studied using a finite element model constructed based on data from the Visible Human Project. The coordinate of the center of each cervical vertebra were predicted for each pillow height. Three spine alignment parameters (cervical angle, lordosis distance and kyphosis distance) were identified.

RESULTS

The average cranial pressure at pillow height H3 was approximately 30% higher than that at H0, and significantly different from those at H1 and H2 (p < 0.05). The average cervical pressure at pillow height H0 was 65% lower than that at H3, and significantly different from those at H1 and H2 (p < 0.05). The peak cervical pressures at pillow heights H2 and H3 were significantly different from that at H0 (p < 0.05). With respect to cervical spine alignment, raising pillow height from H0 to H3 caused an increase of 66.4% and 25.1% in cervical angle and lordosis distance, respectively, and a reduction of 43.4% in kyphosis distance.

DISCUSSION

Pillow height elevation significantly increased the average and peak pressures of the cranial and cervical regions, and increased the extension and lordosis of the cervical spine. The cranio-cervical pressures and cervical spine alignment were height-specific, and they were believed to reflect quality of sleep. Our results provide a quantitative and objective evaluation of the effect of pillow height on the biomechanics of the head-neck complex, and have application in pillow design and selection.

A comparative study on dynamic stiffness in typical finite element model and multi-body model of C6-C7 cervical spine segment

In contrast to numerous researches on static or quasi-static stiffness of cervical spine segments, very few investigations on their dynamic stiffness were published. Currently, scale factors and estimated coefficients were usually used in multi-body models for including viscoelastic properties and damping effects, meanwhile viscoelastic properties of some tissues were unavailable for establishing finite element models. Because dynamic stiffness of cervical spine segments in these models were difficult to validate because of lacking in experimental data, we tried to gain some insights on current modeling methods through studying dynamic stiffness differences between these models. A finite element model and a multi-body model of C6-C7 segment were developed through using available material data and typical modeling technologies. These two models were validated with quasi-static response data of the C6-C7 cervical spine segment. Dynamic stiffness differences were investigated through controlling motions of C6 vertebrae at different rates and then comparing their reaction forces or moments. Validation results showed that both the finite element model and the multi-body model could generate reasonable responses under quasi-static loads, but the finite element segment model exhibited more nonlinear characters. Dynamic response investigations indicated that dynamic stiffness of this finite element model might be underestimated because of the absence of dynamic stiffen effect and damping effects of annulus fibrous, while representation of these effects also need to be improved in current multi-body model. Copyright © 2015 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

In vitro investigation of a new dynamic cervical implant: comparison to spinal fusion and total disc replacement

PURPOSE AND METHODS

For the treatment of degenerative disc diseases of the cervical spine, anterior cervical discectomy and fusion (ACDF) still represents the standard procedure. However, long term clinical studies have shown a higher incidence of pathologies in the adjacent segments. As an alternative to spinal fusion, cervical total disc replacement (cTDR) or dynamically implants were increasingly used. This in vitro study analyzed the kinematics and intradiscal pressures in seven multi-segmental human cervical spine using hybrid multidirectional test method. The aim of our study was to compare the intact condition with a single-level dynamic stabilization with DCI(®), with cTDR (activC(®)) and with simulated ACDF (CeSPACE(®) cage and CASPAR plate).

RESULTS

No significant changes in the kinematics and pressures were observed in all segments after arthroplasty. The DCI(®) significantly decreased the motion of the treated segment in flexion/extension and lateral bending with some remaining residual mobility. Thereby the motion of the upper segment was increased significantly in flexion/extension. No significant changes of the intradiscal pressures were observed. With simulated fusion the motion of the indexed level was significantly decreased in flexion/extension and axial rotation with the greatest changes in the adjacent levels and the highest pressures.

CONCLUSION

Based on our biomechanical study the DCI(®) can pose an alternative to fusion, which has a lesser effect on adjacent levels. This might reduce the risk of long-term degeneration in those levels. In particular, the facet joint arthritis and kyphotic deformity, as a contraindication to the arthroplasty, could be a clinical application of the dynamic implant.

Finite Element Analysis of a New Pedicle Screw-Plate System for Minimally Invasive Transforaminal Lumbar Interbody Fusion

PURPOSE

Minimally invasive transforaminal lumbar interbody fusion (MI-TLIF) is increasingly popular for the surgical treatment of degenerative lumbar disc diseases. The constructs intended for segmental stability are varied in MI-TLIF. We adopted finite element (FE) analysis to compare the stability after different construct fixations using interbody cage with posterior pedicle screw-rod or pedicle screw-plate instrumentation system.

METHODS

A L3-S1 FE model was modified to simulate decompression and fusion at L4-L5 segment. Fixation modes included unilateral plate (UP), unilateral rod (UR), bilateral plate (BP), bilateral rod (BR) and UP+UR fixation. The inferior surface of the S1 vertebra remained immobilized throughout the load simulation, and a bending moment of 7.5 Nm with 400N pre-load was applied on the L3 vertebra to recreate flexion, extension, lateral bending, and axial rotation. Range of motion (ROM) and Von Mises stress were evaluated for intact and instrumentation models in all loading planes.

RESULTS

All reconstructive conditions displayed decreased motion at L4-L5. The pedicle screw-plate system offered equal ROM to pedicle screw-rod system in unilateral or bilateral fixation modes respectively. Pedicle screw stresses for plate system were 2.2 times greater than those for rod system in left lateral bending under unilateral fixation. Stresses for plate were 3.1 times greater than those for rod in right axial rotation under bilateral fixation. Stresses on intervertebral graft for plate system were similar to rod system in unilateral and bilateral fixation modes respectively. Increased ROM and posterior instrumentation stresses were observed in all loading modes with unilateral fixation compared with bilateral fixation in both systems.

CONCLUSIONS

Transforaminal lumbar interbody fusion augmentation with pedicle screw-plate system fixation increases fusion construct stability equally to the pedicle screw-rod system. Increased posterior instrumentation stresses are observed in all loading modes with plate fixation, and bilateral fixation could reduce stress concentration.

BIOMECHANICAL ANALYSIS OF DIFFERENT PRODISC-C ARTHROPLASTY DESIGNS AFTER IMPLANTATION: A NUMERICAL SENSITIVITY STUDY

Ball-and-socket disc prostheses are the leading type of artificial disc replacement (ADR) and are typically used to treat degenerative cervical spine instability. Previous publications focused on the influence of different ProDisc-C design parameters in view of biomechanics. However, more beneficial data could be gathered if the implant was implanted prior to testing. Therefore, this study aimed to estimate the effect of different ProDisc-C arthroplasty designs and alignments when implanted at the C5-6 segment. This research can provide advice on the design of artificial discs as well as optimal placement. The geometry of the vertebrae was developed based on computed tomography (CT) images of a 32-year-old healthy male (170 cm height and 68 kg weight) with a slice thickness of 0.625 mm. A finite element (FE) model of intact C5–C6 segments including vertebrae and disc was developed and validated. A ball-and-socket artificial disc prosthesis model (ProDisc-C, Synthes) was implanted into the validated FE model. The curvature of the ProDisc-C prosthesis as well as the implanted position was varied. All models were loaded with a 74 N compressive force and pure moments of 1.8 Nm in flexion-extension, bilateral bending and axial torsion. The radius of the artificial disc influenced the ROM, facet joint force and capsule ligament tension only in flexion, while the position influenced these aspects in all loading conditions. The disc with a 6 mm radius had a greater ROM in flexion, and lower stress on the polyethylene (PE) insert without apparent stress concentrations, but it had a greater facet joint force and ligament tension compared to other radii. For all the designs, the implant position in the anterior–posterior direction had a significant influence on the disc biomechanics. Disc design and surgical procedure, such as implantation position, are important factors in postoperative rehabilitation, especially regarding the ROM in flexion/extension and implant stress. Thus, a suitable disc design should consider preserving an adequate range of motion (ROM) as well as a moderate facet joint force or stress, and proper implant positioning along the anterior–posterior direction should be monitored.

Hybrid surgery for multilevel cervical degenerative disc diseases: a systematic review of biomechanical and clinical evidence

PURPOSE

The optimal surgical technique for multilevel cervical degenerative disc diseases (DDD) remains controversial. Hybrid surgery (HS) incorporating anterior cervical discectomy and fusion (ACDF) and cervical disc replacement (CDR) is increasingly performed for cervical DDD. This study aims to evaluate the biomechanical and clinical evidence available for HS and to provide a systematic review of current understanding of HS.

METHODS

This systematic review was undertaken by following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses Statement. Multiple databases and online registers of clinical trials were searched up to February 2014. The biomechanical and clinical studies on HS for cervical DDD written in English were included. Two authors independently assessed methodological quality and extracted data.

RESULTS

Fifteen studies including eight biomechanical studies and seven clinical studies were indentified. The biomechanical studies showed that HS was benefit to motion preservation of the operative levels and revealed less adverse effect on adjacent segments. All clinical studies demonstrated improvement in validated functional scores after HS. Segment motion and immobilization were achieved at the arthroplasty level and arthrodesis level, respectively. Postoperative assessments and complication rate were similar or in favor of HS when comparing with ACDF or CDR. However, the overall quality of evidence for HS was low to very low.

CONCLUSIONS

There is a paucity of high quality evidence for HS. HS may be a safe and efficacious technique to benefit a select group of multilevel cervical DDD, which is needed to be confirmed by further prospective, randomized controlled trials.