Characterization of the humoral immune response of experimentally infected and vaccinated pigs to swine influenza viral proteins

[Challenges in Influenza diagnostics in a swine herd - a case report]

In a gilt producing farm in Lower Austria, respiratory diseases occurred over the previous years in self-reared gilts after being introduced into the sow herd. In addition, fertility disorders in terms of late abortions and re-breeders were observed in the fall of 2019. Nasal swabs of 3 gilts with respiratory signs and fever were tested positive for influenza A virus (IAV) subtype H1avN1 by PCR. However, examination of serum samples from these animals at 2 different time points did not detect antibodies using the standard hemagglutination inhibition (HI) test of the laboratory. Examination of additional age groups likewise failed to detect H1avN1 antibody titers. In consequence to the extension of the diagnostic panel of the HI test by 7 additional H1avN1 test antigens, a clear seroconversion of the PCR positive sows against 2 different H1avN1 isolates could be measured. In addition, high antibody titers against these 2 H1avN1 strains were also detectable in the majority of the remaining age groups tested. Following the administration of the trivalent influenza vaccine, which has been approved throughout Europe, a significant improvement of the clinical presentation in the herd was achieved. The present case report illustrates that direct and indirect pathogen detection should be used in combination for targeted influenza diagnostics. In addition, it was shown that the continuous adaptation of test antigens to the isolates circulating in the field would be extremely crucial for the significance of the HI test.

Experimental H1N1pdm09 infection in pigs mimics human seasonal influenza infections

Pigs are anatomically, genetically and physiologically comparable to humans and represent a natural host for influenza A virus (IAV) infections. Thus, pigs may represent a relevant biomedical model for human IAV infections. We set out to investigate the systemic as well as the local immune response in pigs upon two subsequent intranasal infections with IAV H1N1pdm09. We detected decreasing numbers of peripheral blood lymphocytes after the first infection. The simultaneous increase in the frequencies of proliferating cells correlated with an increase in infiltrating leukocytes in the lung. Enhanced perforin expression in αβ and γδ T cells in the respiratory tract indicated a cytotoxic T cell response restricted to the route of virus entry such as the nose, the lung and the bronchoalveolar lavage. Simultaneously, increasing frequencies of CD8αα expressing αβ T cells were observed rapidly after the first infection, which may have inhibited uncontrolled inflammation in the respiratory tract. Taking together, the results of this study demonstrate that experimental IAV infection in pigs mimics major characteristics of human seasonal IAV infections.

Distinction of subtype-specific antibodies against European porcine influenza viruses by indirect ELISA based on recombinant hemagglutinin protein fragment-1

Background

Serological investigations of swine influenza virus infections and epidemiological conclusions thereof are challenging due to the complex and regionally variable pattern of co-circulating viral subtypes and lineages and varying vaccination regimes. Detection of subtype-specific antibodies currently depends on hemagglutination inhibition (HI) assays which are difficult to standardize and unsuitable for large scale investigations.

Methods

The nucleocapsid protein (NP) and HA1 fragments of the hemagglutinin protein (HA) of five different lineages (H1N1av, H1N1pdm, H1pdmN2, H1N2, H3N2) of swine influenza viruses were bacterially expressed and used as diagnostic antigens in indirect ELISA.

Results

Proteins were co-translationally mono-biotinylated and refolded in vitro into an antigenically authentic conformation. Western blotting and indirect ELISA revealed highly subtype-specific antigenic characteristics of the recombinant HA1 proteins although some cross reactivity especially among antigens of the H1 subtype were evident. Discrimination of antibodies directed against four swine influenza virus subtypes co-circulating in Germany was feasible using the indirect ELISA format.

Conclusions

Bacterially expressed recombinant NP and HA1 swine influenza virus proteins served as antigens in indirect ELISAs and provided an alternative to commercial blocking NP ELISA and HI assays concerning generic (NP-specific) and HA subtype-specific sero-diagnostics, respectively, on a herd basis.

Antibodies against conserved antigens provide opportunities for reform in influenza vaccine design

High-performance neutralizing antibody against influenza virus typically recognizes the globular head region of its hemagglutinin (HA) envelope glycoprotein. To-date, approved human vaccination strategies have been designed to induce such antibodies as a sole means of preventing the consequences of this infection. However, frequent amino-acid changes in the HA globular head allow for efficient immune evasion. Consequently, vaccines inducing such neutralizing antibodies need to be annually re-designed and re-administered at a great expense. These vaccines furthermore provide little-to-no immunity against antigenic-shift strains, which arise from complete replacement of HA or of neuraminidase genes, and pose pandemic risks. To address these issues, laboratory research has focused on inducing immunity effective against all strains, regardless of changes in the HA globular head. Despite prior dogma that such cross-protection needs to be induced by cellular immunity alone, several advances in recent years demonstrate that antibodies of other specificities are capable of cross-strain protection in mice. This review discusses the reactivity, induction, efficacy, and mechanisms of antibodies that react with poorly accessible epitopes in the HA stalk, with the matrix 2 membrane ion channel, and even with the internal nucleoprotein. These advances warrant further investigation of the inducibility and efficacy of such revolutionary antibody strategies in humans.

Analysis of different DNA vaccines for protection of experimental influenza A virus infection

Influenza viruses cause acute respiratory infections in humans that result in significant excessive morbidity and mortality rates every year. Current vaccines are limited in several aspects, including laborious manufacturing technology, non-sufficient efficacy, and time-consuming adjustments to new emerging virus variants. An alternative vaccine approach utilizes plasmid DNA encoding influenza virus antigens. Previous experiments have evaluated the protective efficacy of DNA vaccines expressing variable as well as conserved antigens. In this present study, several different combinations of influenza A virus (IAV) HA, NA, M1, M2, NS1, NS2, and NP sequences were cloned into the plasmid pVIVO, which allows the independent expression of two genes separately. These DNA vaccines were administered to induce protection against a lethal IAV infection, and to reduce immunopathology in lung tissue of surviving animals. The highest efficacy was provided by vaccines expressing HA and NA, as well as a mixture of plasmids encoding HA, NA, M1, M2, NS1, NS2, and NP (Mix). Three days post-infection, more than a 99.99% reduction of viral load and no inflammation was achieved in lung tissue of pVIVO/HA-NA-vaccinated mice. Animals vaccinated with pVIVO/HA-NA, pVIVO/HA-M2, or vaccine Mix, survived a lethal challenge with minor or no obvious pathologic abnormities in the lungs. All other surviving mice revealed extensive changes in the lung tissue, indicating possibly an ongoing bronchiolitis obliterans. In addition, pVIVO/HA-NA and the vaccine Mix were also protective against a heterologous IAV infection. Taken together, next to all combinations of different DNA vaccines, the intramuscular application of pVIVO/HA-NA was the most efficient procedure to decrease virus replication and to prevent immunopathology in lung tissue of IAV-infected mice.

Comparison of humoral and cellular immune responses to inactivated swine influenza virus vaccine in weaned pigs

Humoral and cellular immune responses to inactivated swine influenza virus (SIV) vaccine were evaluated and compared. Fifty 3-week-old weaned pigs were randomly divided into the non-vaccinated control group and vaccinated group containing 25 pigs each. Pigs were vaccinated intramuscularly twice with adjuvanted UV-inactivated A/SW/MN/02011/08 (MN/08) H1N2 SIV vaccine at 6 and 9 weeks of age. Whole blood samples for multi-parameter flow cytometry (MP-FCM) and serum samples for hemagglutination inhibition (HI) assay were collected at 23 and 28 days after the second vaccination, respectively. A standard HI assay and MP-FCM were performed against UV-inactivated homologous MN/08 and heterologous pandemic A/CA/04/2009 (CA/09) H1N1 viruses. While the HI assay detected humoral responses only to the MN/08 virus, the MP-FCM detected strong cellular responses against the MN/08 virus and significant heterologous responses to the CA/09 virus, especially in the CD4+CD8+ T cell subset. The cellular heterologous responses to UV-inactivated virus by MP-FCM suggested that the assay was sensitive and potentially detected a wider range of antigens than what was detected by the HI assay. Overall, the adjuvanted UV-inactivated A/SW/MN/02011/08 H1N2 SIV vaccine stimulated both humoral and cellular immune responses including the CD4-CD8+ T cell subset.

Genetic and pathobiologic characterization of pandemic H1N1 2009 influenza viruses from a naturally infected swine herd

Since its initial identification in Mexico and the United States, concerns have been raised that the novel H1N1 influenza virus might cause a pandemic of severity comparable to that of the 1918 pandemic. In late April 2009, viruses phylogenetically related to pandemic H1N1 influenza virus were isolated from an outbreak on a Canadian pig farm. This outbreak also had epidemiological links to a suspected human case. Experimental infections carried out in pigs using one of the swine isolates from this outbreak and the human isolate A/Mexico/InDRE4487/2009 showed differences in virus recovery from the lower respiratory tract. Virus was consistently isolated from the lungs of pigs infected with A/Mexico/InDRE4487/2009, while only one pig infected with A/swine/Alberta/OTH-33-8/2008 yielded live virus from the lung, despite comparable amounts of viral RNA and antigen in both groups of pigs. Clinical disease resembled other influenza virus infections in swine, albeit with somewhat prolonged virus antigen detection and delayed viral-RNA clearance from the lungs. There was also a noteworthy amount of genotypic variability among the viruses isolated from the pigs on the farm. This, along with the somewhat irregular pathobiological characteristics observed in experimentally infected animals, suggests that although the virus may be of swine origin, significant viral evolution may still be ongoing.

Antibodies to PB1-F2 protein are induced in response to influenza A virus infection

PB1-F2 is a small influenza A virus (IAV) protein encoded by an alternative (+1) reading frame of the PB1 gene. While dispensable for IAV replication in cultured cells, PB1-F2 has been implicated in IAV pathogenicity. To better understand PB1-F2 expression in vivo and its immunogenicity, we analyzed anti-PB1-F2 antibodies (Abs) in sera of mice infected intranasally (i.n.) with A/PR/8/34 (H1N1) virus and human acute and convalescent sera collected from the influenza H3N2 winter 2003-2004 epidemic. We explored a number of methods for detecting anti-PB1-F2 Abs, finding that PB1-F2-specific Abs could clearly be detected via immunoprecipitation or immunofluorescence assays using both immune mouse and human convalescent sera. Importantly, paired human sera exhibited similar increases in HI titers and PB1-F2-specific Abs. This study indicates that PB1-F2 is expressed in sufficient quantities in mice and humans infected with IAV to elicit an Ab response, supporting the biological relevance of this intriguing accessory protein.

Performance of a commercial Swine influenza virus H1N1 and H3N2 antibody enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay in pigs experimentally infected with European influenza viruses

The IDEXX Swine influenza virus H1N1 and H3N2 enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays (ELISAs) are used worldwide, but their capacity to detect antibodies to European Swine influenza viruses (SIVs) has not been documented. A total of 313 well-defined sera from SIV seronegative pigs and pigs experimentally infected with European SIVs were used to compare the performance of both ELISAs and the hemagglutination inhibition (HI) test. The ELISAs largely failed to detect pigs that had been infected with H1N1 (0/42 positive in H1N1 ELISA) or H3N2 only (9/18 positive in H3N2 ELISA; group 1). Higher ELISA detection rates were found after consecutive infection of pigs with either H1N1 or H3N2 and 1 other subtype (7/40 and 11/22 positive in H1N1 and H3N2 ELISA, respectively; group 2). Of 39 pigs that had been vaccinated twice with 1 of 4 commercial SIV vaccines (group 3), 25 tested positive in the H1N1 and 4 in the H3N2 ELISA. Pigs that had received a single vaccination after a prior infection with H1N1 and/or H3N2 (group 4) were more frequently positive than group 1 or 3 pigs (23/24 and 15/24 positive in H1N1 and H3N2 ELISA, respectively). Both the H1N1 and H3N2 ELISA showed a low sensitivity (39% and 35%, respectively) relative to the HI test. Because pigs in the field are frequently infected and/or vaccinated with multiple SIV subtypes and variants, they are more likely to test positive in the ELISAs. However, the interpretation of ELISA results will be difficult, and HI remains the method of choice.

The antibody responses to swine influenza virus (SIV) recombinant matrix 1 (rM1), matrix 2 (M2), and hemagglutinin (HA) proteins in pigs with different SIV exposure

The influenza invariant matrix 2 (M2) protein is a potential subunit vaccine candidate to induce protective immunity against broader strains of influenza A viruses (IAV). Antibodies to M2 protein have not been well characterized in IAV natural hosts. To characterize M2-specific antibodies in pigs, an ELISA to the extracellular region of the M2 (M2e) protein was developed. Sera from pigs experimentally infected with three different swine influenza virus (SIV) subtypes, immunized with an SIV inactivated vaccine, or positive for SIV maternally derived antibodies (MDA) in the absence of SIV infection were tested in assay. Confirmation of antibody titer status of pigs, was determined using a hemagglutination-inhibition (HI) test and the presence of antibodies to matrix 1 (M1) protein was measured by a recombinant M1 (rM1)-based ELISA. The antibody titers to the HA and M2e proteins but not to the rM1 were directly correlated to the dose of virus used to infect the pigs and the level of antibodies detected by the HI assay varied according to SIV subtype. Pigs experimentally infected with SIV produced low levels of M2e antibodies compared to antibodies detected by the HI and rM1 assays. Vaccination alone followed by infection did not increase the levels of M2e antibodies in contrast to HA and rM1 antibodies. Pigs with MDA had different levels of HA antibodies and were positive to M2e antibodies, but results were not correlated to HA antibodies levels and inconsistently present.

Efficacy of intranasal administration of a truncated NS1 modified live influenza virus vaccine in swine

In the U.S., despite available swine influenza virus (SIV) vaccines, multiple influenza subtypes as well as antigenic and genetic variants within subtypes continue to circulate in the swine population. One of the challenges to control and eliminate SIV is that the currently used inactivated influenza virus vaccines do not provide adequate cross-protection against multiple antigenic variants of SIV in the field. We previously generated a recombinant H3N2 swine influenza virus (SIV) based on the influenza A/SW/TX/4199-2/98 virus (TX98) containing an NS1 gene expressing a truncated NS1 protein of 126 amino acids, TX98-NS1Delta126 virus. This recombinant strain was demonstrated to be highly attenuated in swine and showed potential for use as a modified live-virus vaccine (MLV) after intratracheal application in pigs. However, this route of inoculation is not practical for vaccination in the field. In the present study, we first compared intramuscular and intranasal routes of application of the MLV, and found that the intranasal route was superior in priming the local (mucosal) immune response. Pigs were then vaccinated via the intranasal route and challenged with wild type homologous TX98 H3N2 virus, with a genetic and antigenic variant H3N2 SIV (influenza A/SW/CO/23619/99 virus, CO99) and a heterosubtypic H1N1 SIV (influenza A/SW/IA/00239/2004 virus, IA04). The intranasally vaccinated pigs were completely protected against homologous challenge. In addition, MLV vaccination provided nearly complete protection against the antigenic H3N2 variant CO99 virus. When challenged with the H1N1 IA04 virus, MLV vaccinated animals displayed reduced fever and virus titers despite minimal reduction in lung lesions. In vaccinated pigs, there was no serologic cross-reactivity by HI assays with the heterologous or heterosubtypic viruses. However, there appeared to be substantial cross-reactivity in antibodies at the mucosal level with the CO99 virus in MLV vaccinated pigs.

Failure of protection and enhanced pneumonia with a US H1N2 swine influenza virus in pigs vaccinated with an inactivated classical swine H1N1 vaccine

Two US swine influenza virus (SIV) isolates, A/Swine/Iowa/15/1930 H1N1 (IA30) and A/Swine/Minnesota/00194/2003 H1N2 (MN03), were evaluated in an in vivo vaccination and challenge model. Inactivated vaccines were prepared from each isolate and used to immunize conventional pigs, followed by challenge with homologous or heterologous virus. Both inactivated vaccines provided complete protection against homologous challenge. However, the IA30 vaccine failed to protect against the heterologous MN03 challenge. Three of the nine pigs in this group had substantially greater percentages of lung lesions, suggesting the vaccine potentiated the pneumonia. In contrast, priming with live IA30 virus provided protection from nasal shedding and virus replication in the lung in MN03 challenged pigs. These data indicate that divergent viruses that did not cross-react serologically did not provide complete cross-protection when used in inactivated vaccines against heterologous challenge and may have enhanced disease. In addition, live virus infection conferred protection against heterologous challenge.