A quantitative analysis of municipal solid waste disposal charges in China

Policy scenario of plastic waste mitigation in Indonesia using system dynamics

Plastic waste has become a major contributor to global environmental pollution. Some of the environmental impacts of plastic waste include littering, the formation of plastic debris in oceans and the contamination of freshwater and terrestrial habitats. Policymakers face great challenges in mitigating plastic waste. Indonesia is considered the second largest contributor of plastic waste in the world. However, existing policies have not addressed this issue. Policies, such as bans on single-use plastic bags and fees on plastic bags, have recently been implemented in some pilot cities, but the results remain unclear. Thus, this study proposes feasible policies to mitigate plastic waste in Indonesia using system dynamics. Specifically, this study seeks to develop a dynamic model of plastic waste mitigation and to propose a policy scenario for plastic waste mitigation. The proposed policies consist of a plastic bag ban, a plastic bag fee, a recycling centre and extended producer responsibility (EPR). The analysis demonstrates that an effective mixed policy instrument for reducing plastic waste depends on the plastic waste type. Regarding plastic bottles, the effective mixed policy is a combination of a recycling centre and EPR. For plastic bags, the effective mixed policies include the following combinations: a plastic bag fee and plastic bag ban, a plastic bag fee and recycling centre and a plastic bag ban and recycling centre.

Public acceptability and its determinants of unit pricing for municipal solid waste disposal: Evidence from a household survey in Beijing

Unit pricing for domestic waste, or pay-as-you-throw (PAYT), affords a promising policy option for waste classification and reduction at source. As an emerging economy, China intends to adopt the sophisticated instrument of unit pricing. The public attitude to this policy is of high relevance for its actual implementation. For the first time in China, this paper quantitatively examined the acceptability of the policy among urban residents by randomly delivering 632 questionnaires by taking Beijing, a megacity expected to introduce the practice, as an example. Based on the ordered logit model, determinants of acceptability were empirically tested including intrinsic, external and demographic factors. The results show that the acceptability rate of PAYT in Beijing is less than half, with the proportion of firm support reaching only 42.6%. The respectively low acceptability rate indicates substantial compliance costs, due to intensive resistance to policy implementation and more resources to be invested to promote acceptability. Empirical analysis further indicates that (1) regarding demographic features, aged or less educated residents tend to accept unit pricing, (2) as for intrinsic factors, a friendly environmental attitude, deeper understanding of charging policy and better social perception can significantly improve the public acceptability of the policy, and (3) in terms of external factors, better property services and transparent funding mechanisms play significant roles in enhancing public acceptability. These findings are further confirmed by replacing the dependent variable with either the willingness to pay for household waste disposal or the acceptability of the operated sewage treatment fee. The status of residents' preference for specific pricing methods is further investigated with underlying reasons being revealed. For developing regions with an urgent demand for waste reduction, it is proposed to install unit pricing in time to avoid possible growing social acceptability costs. Specific measures are proposed including changes in intrinsic factors, paying attention to focus groups, and building social consensus for unit pricing.

The Generation and Effects for Recyclable Waste from Households in a Megapolis: A Case Study in Shanghai

Shanghai is one of the world-leading megapolises facing the challenge of ecological sustainable development. The recyclable waste from households (RWH) generated in Shanghai has increased rapidly since the implementation of garbage classification in 2019. However, there are no rigorous data on the generation and collection of RWH, and the corresponding countermeasures are required to be studied. This paper attempted to investigate RWH generation and identify the effects of RWH recycling in Shanghai. We used questionnaires combined with a field survey to investigate the competent authorities and leading recycling enterprises to analyze the characteristics of RWH generation. We conducted a monthly survey of 52 leading recycling enterprises in 11 typical districts for 2020. We also identified the main influencing factors of RWH generation using a multiple linear regression model. In addition, we popularized the model to estimate Shanghai’s RWH generation rate. Results show that data from leading recycling enterprises surveys were more accurate and reached a maximum of 82,104.77 kg/cap/month in November 2020. Higher RWH generation was found in suburban districts at 36,396.20 kg/cap/month. Shanghai’s RWH generation rate was 6253.60 t/d through model calculation. The educational level of household managers, regional economic condition, resident population, and disposable income impact RWH generation. Based on the abovementioned results, the implications for RWH management were discussed. We propose to promote the combination of theoretical simulation and information data platform construction. Meanwhile, it is also necessary to improve the capacity of the collection and transport system and accelerate the construction of pre-treatment bases in Shanghai.

Feasibility study of the unit pricing system for household wastes sorting in the context of China

Although sanitary household waste disposal was achieved in China, an efficient source separation system has not been built yet. The Unit Pricing System has been proved effective for household waste sorting by developed countries and regions, while rare developing countries have successfully introduced the system in their local context. The study, taking an interactive perspective of dominant factors of residents' waste sorting and governments' intervention, combines theoretical analysis with system simulation to dissect the evolution process of residents' waste sorting and local governments' Unit Pricing System policy making, and to provide a Unit Pricing System policy making tool to support policy implementations. The results suggest introducing a Unit Pricing System can significantly push ahead the household waste sorting behaviour for cities with relatively low initial status of environmental awareness, and immediately trigger sorting behaviours for cities with higher initial status of environmental awareness. The study can also benefit other developing countries when imposing waste sorting management instruments.

Unsupervised aided investigation on the associations between municipal solid waste characteristics and socio-economic conditions

Better municipal solid waste (MSW) management can help to address environmental concerns and supports economic and social development. Because MSW characteristics can change over time, management strategies should also evolve and be applied correspondingly. However, many previous studies have focused on MSW characterization or investigated specific management strategies for a target MSW. Few studies have assessed the spatial variations of MSW characteristics and socio-economic (SE) conditions as well as their associations. This study evaluated the feasibility of using an integrated unsupervised method (cluster analysis and cross-tabulation analysis) to explore these topics for MSW management. Results suggest that the integrated method can successfully help to reveal key information. Seven jointed MSW-SE scenarios were investigated based on 259 individual observations of Taiwan. Associations between MSW compositions and SE conditions were identified statistically significant for four MSW-SE scenarios. In general, the general SE type (SE₁) is very likely to generate high food wastes and other combustible, low paper, wood, and rubber wastes (MSW₁). The small island SE type (SE₃) is more likely to produce high paper and low wood, rubber, textile, and other noncombustible wastes (MSW₂). Overall, the method applied in this study could help to reveal statistical associations between MSW and SE, which can help decision-makers comprehend underlying facts and develop effective management strategies.

Dissipation and sorption-desorption of benzisothiazolinone in agricultural soils and identification of its metabolites

Benzisothiazolinone has been widely used to control bacterial and fungal diseases in various agricultural crops by destroying the nuclear structure and interfering with the metabolism of microbial cells. In this study, the dissipation, transformation and sorption-desorption of benzisothiazolinone (BIT) in five soils were investigated to evaluate its environmental fate. Results showed that the degradation of BIT in all the tested soils fitted the first order kinetics and increased with soil organic matter (OM) content. Degradation differences between unsterilized natural and sterilized soils (t 1/2 = 0.09-26.66 and 6.80-86.64 d) suggested that BIT degradation is primarily driven by biological processes and assisted by abiotic degradation. Additionally, BIT dissipated fastest in flooded soils (t 1/2 = 0.20-4.53 d), indicating that anaerobic microorganisms are more likely to degrade BIT compared to aerobic microbes. Also, during the soil degradation process, two metabolites were monitored and identified for the first time. BIT sorption was a spontaneous physical process with no desorption hysteresis effect, which fit the Freundlich model. BIT causes relatively strong sorption (log K OC = 3.76-4.19) and low persistence in soils, thus exhibiting a low potential risk for groundwater contamination.

A stochastic frontier analysis of the efficiency of municipal solid waste collection services in China

Governments in many developing countries, such as China, are investing a lot of human, financial and material resources to ensure that as much of municipal solid waste (MSW) as possible is collected for centralized harmless treatment and disposal. This is regarded as an effective way to alleviate the "waste siege" problem in governance caused by the continuous enormous increase in MSW quantity. Therefore, how to improve the efficiency of MSW collection service system is an important governance issue because the inputs that can be utilized to manage MSW problem are limited due to budget and resource constraints. However, studies on MSW collection efficiency in developing countries like China are under-represented in the existing literature. This paper applies a stochastic frontier analysis (SFA) approach to evaluate the efficiency of MSW collection services in 30 provinces of China from 2008 to 2017, and explore the relative importance of several factors that might influence collection efficiency. The results indicate that there exists considerable room (62.8%) to enhance efficiency since its current efficiency value is merely 0.372. With regard to influencing factors, the proportion of population aged 15-64 appears to have the greatest positive impact on efficiency, along with per capita GDP, added value of tertiary industry and education level. This paper also explores spatial variations of MSW collection efficiency across the eastern, central and western regions. These findings have policy implications and can inform the related government departments how to formulate proper policies to improve collection efficiency.

Analysis of residents' choice of waste charge methods and willingness to pay amount for solid waste management in Hong Kong

Among various waste charging methods, the quantity-based method will most likely be adopted by the government of Hong Kong because of its effectiveness in reducing waste, as demonstrated in a few major cities. Several quantity-based methods exist. A large sample questionnaire survey was conducted in this study to examine residents' choice among three quantity-based waste charging methods, willingness to pay (WTP) amount, and the factors that influence these choices. Results revealed that residents prefer the household volume charging method and the average WTP amount for waste disposal should be HKD 38.4 per month. Multinomial logit model results indicated that five key factors affect the choice of waste charging method, whereas the Tobit model results suggested that seven factors significantly affect the WTP amount. Among the factors, the perceived fairness and effectiveness of the quantity-based waste charging methods affected the choice of waste charging method and the WTP amount, apart from demographic characteristics, knowledge, and attitudes toward the government's waste management proposals. Results may be useful for concerned groups in designing and implementing waste charge policies.

Charging for municipal solid waste disposal in Beijing

Considering the various ways of Municipal Solid Waste (MSW) disposal that are currently in practice, this paper proposes a bundle pricing model of MSW disposal in Beijing, China. The bundle pricing model is set according to per capita annual disposable income, per capita annual consumption expenditure and MSW disposal cost based on the cost reimbursement principle and complementarity principle. This paper first estimates the unit costs of landfill and incineration respectively, and then designs three bundling packages according to three different income levels of households in Beijing (low-income households, middle-income households and high-income households). Specifically, based on our bundle pricing model, we propose to charge low-income households (of the average size of 3 persons) MSW fees 5.64 RMB per month, middle-income households 10.16 RMB, and high-income households 20.70 RMB per month. We also discuss and explain how the proposed mechanism can be expected to not only mitigate the capital shortage problem, but also reduce MSW quantity and improve the MSW incineration disposal technology.

An exploration into municipal waste charges for environmental management at local level: The case of Spain

Municipal waste charges have been widely acknowledged as a crucial tool for waste management at the local level. This is because they contribute to financing the costly provision of waste collection and treatment services and they can be designed to provide an economic stimulus to encourage citizens and local businesses to improve separate collection and recycling. This work presents a methodology to evaluate a sample of 125 municipal waste charges in Spain for the year 2015, covering 33.91% of the Spanish population. The qualitative benchmarking of municipal waste charges shows that flat fees are frequent, whereas variable fees are set according to criteria that are weakly related to waste generation. The average fee per household is €82.2 per year, which does not provide full cost recovery. The current configuration of municipal waste charges penalises taxpayers contributing to source separation of waste, while subsidising less environmentally friendly behaviours. In this sense, municipal waste charges in Spain are far from applying the polluter pays principle. Furthermore, it is argued that municipal waste charges are ineffective for promoting the proper application of the so-called 'waste hierarchy'.