Clinical outcomes following proton therapy for adult craniopharyngioma: a single-institution cohort study

The spectrum of radiation therapy options for craniopharyngioma: a systematic review

PURPOSE

Craniopharyngiomas (CPs) are rare, slow-growing brain tumors which originate in the sellar region. CPs may present with symptoms secondary to compression of surrounding structures, particularly the pituitary gland, and surgical removal has traditionally been the mainstay of treatment. However, due to high recurrence rates for CPs, especially when gross total resection is not feasible, radiotherapy has played an increasingly significant role in their management. Here, we review radiation modalities, treatment settings, and future directions in the management of CP. In addition, we outline emerging therapeutic combinations involving targeted therapies.

METHODS

A systematic review was performed in accordance with Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines. A search of the MEDLINE/PubMed, Embase, and Web of Science databases was used for initial identification of articles. Included studies were then grouped into the following treatment modalities: conventional radiotherapy (CRT), intensity-modulated radiotherapy (IMRT), proton therapy, fractionated stereotactic radiotherapy (FSRT) /stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS), and brachytherapy.

RESULTS

A total of 60 studies met inclusion criteria, comprising 3041 patients, with a median sample size of 33 (range: 10-242) and age ranging from 6 to 55. This review included 8, 15, 3, 12, and 29 reports corresponding to brachytherapy, CRT, IMRT, proton therapy, and FSRT/SRS, respectively. Proton therapy and FSRT had the highest median 5-year progression-free survival (PFS), with rates of 92% and 89%, respectively. IMRT and proton therapy were primarily investigated in pediatric patients (median ages of 8.2 and 10.3 years, respectively). By comparison, FSRT and SRS research has mainly been in adult cohorts.

CONCLUSIONS

Precision radiotherapy appears to be associated with high rates of tumor control in CP, suggesting these approaches bear further investigation. Selection of the appropriate radiation modality from those reviewed likely depends on several patient-specific factors. Important considerations include tumor location and volume, patient age, prior treatments for CP, and patient preference.

A case-based review of adult-onset craniopharyngioma

Craniopharyngiomas are histologically benign central nervous system tumors derived from embryonic epithelial cells of Rathke's pouch. The disease demonstrates a bimodal age distribution, occurring most often in patients 5-14 and 50-74 years of age. Common comorbidities include hypopituitarism, hypothalamic obesity, sleep apnea, visual impairment and neurocognitive disturbances. There are several key differences in the presentation, tumor characteristics and clinical outcomes between age groups. Childhood craniopharyngiomas are mostly adamantinomatous and often present as larger tumors with worse functional outcomes such as rates of obesity and neurological deficits. Adults experience similar but slightly adjusted rates of comorbidity with both the adamantinomatous and papillary subtypes. This review presents a case-based discussion of adult craniopharyngiomas, focusing on recent literature regarding their presentation, pathology and pathogenesis, diagnosis, treatment and long-term sequelae.

Papillary Craniopharyngioma: An Integrative and Comprehensive Review

Papillary craniopharyngioma (PCP) is a rare type of tumor, comprising ∼20% of all craniopharyngioma (CP) cases. It is now recognized as a separate pathological entity from the adamantinomatous type. PCPs are benign tumors, classified as World Health Organization grade 1, characterized by nonkeratinizing squamous epithelium. They typically grow as solid and round papillomatous masses or as unilocular cysts with a cauliflower-like excrescence. PCPs primarily occur in adults (95%), with increased frequency in males (60%), and predominantly affect the hypothalamus. Over 80% of these tumors are located in the third ventricle, expanding either above an anatomically intact infundibulum (strictly third ventricle tumors) or within the infundibulo-tuberal region of the third ventricle floor. Clinical manifestations commonly include visual deficits and a wide range of psychiatric disturbances (45% of patients), such as memory deficits and odd behavior. Magnetic resonance imaging can identify up to 50% of PCPs by the presence of a basal duct-like recess. Surgical management is challenging, requiring complex approaches to the third ventricle and posing significant risk of hypothalamic injury. The endoscopic endonasal approach allows radical tumor resection and yields more favorable patient outcomes. Of intriguing pathogenesis, over 90% of PCPs harbor the somatic BRAFV600E mutation, which activates the mitogen-activated protein kinase signaling pathway. A phase 2 clinical trial has demonstrated that PCPs respond well to proto-oncogene B-Raf/MAPK/ERK kinase inhibitors. This comprehensive review synthesizes information from a cohort of 560 well-described PCPs and 99 large CP series including PCP cases published from 1856 to 2023 and represents the most extensive collection of knowledge on PCPs to date.

Proton beam therapy for craniopharyngioma: a systematic review and meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

Craniopharyngioma is a rare and slow-growing benign sellar or parasellar epithelial tumor. The number of patients receiving proton beam therapy (PBT) has increased. This study aimed to systematically evaluate and analyze the comprehensive evidence regarding the safety and efficacy of PBT for craniopharyngioma.

METHODS

We searched four databases: the Cochrane Library, PubMed, Embase, and Web of Science. The period was from their inception to February 16, 2024. Two researchers independently screened the literature and extracted data.

RESULTS

Among 486 candidate articles, eight studies were included in our study. Exactly 393 patients with craniopharyngioma underwent PBT in these studies. These studies reported data on survival and toxicity. The median sample size was 42.5 patients. The median age was 9.1-37 years; the female proportion was 48.9%, and the median follow-up time was 29-91.4 months. All patients were treated once daily, five times a week, with a fraction of 1.8 Gy (RBE) per session. The median total dose was 54.0 Gy (RBE). The local control rates at 3 and 5 years in these studies were 99% and 93%, respectively. The overall survival rates at 3 and 5 years in these studies were both 100%. The incidence of acute and late toxicities was mainly grade 1-2. The main late toxicities included vascular and visual toxicities, hypothalamic obesity, endocrinopathy, and panhypopituitarism.

CONCLUSIONS

PBT for craniopharyngioma, especially in children and adolescents, has shown impressive local control and acceptable acute and late toxicities.

Approach to the Patient: New Era Emerges for Craniopharyngioma Management

Papillary craniopharyngioma (PCP) and adamantinomatous craniopharyngioma (ACP) are distinct, slow-growing tumors of the suprasellar region. Their location, composition, and biology have historically evaded successful surgical radiation and medical therapy. Meanwhile compromise of critical structures either by tumor or treatments increase morbidity, impacting patient and carer quality of life. There has been a paradigm shift in the management of PCP, stemming from the discovery of BRAFV600E mutation in its tumorigenesis. Such a treatment breakthrough may soon be the case for ACP, changing the landscape of craniopharyngioma management. We use a case of ACP partially responding to ERK inhibitor therapy to demonstrate chronicity of disease progression and discuss modern management strategies highlighting the importance of access to tumor agnostic clinical trials, and future directions.

Controversies in neuro-oncology: Focal proton versus photon radiation therapy for adult brain tumors

Radiation therapy (RT) plays a fundamental role in the treatment of malignant and benign brain tumors. Current state-of-the-art photon- and proton-based RT combines more conformal dose distribution of target volumes and accurate dose delivery while limiting the adverse radiation effects. PubMed was systematically searched from from 2000 to October 2023 to identify studies reporting outcomes related to treatment of central nervous system (CNS)/skull base tumors with PT in adults. Several studies have demonstrated that proton therapy (PT) provides a reduced dose to healthy brain parenchyma compared with photon-based (xRT) radiation techniques. However, whether dosimetric advantages translate into superior clinical outcomes for different adult brain tumors remains an open question. This review aims at critically reviewing the recent studies on PT in adult patients with brain tumors, including glioma, meningiomas, and chordomas, to explore its potential benefits compared with xRT.

Encouraging Experience with Image-Guided Pencil Beam Scanning Proton Therapy in Craniopharyngioma-First Case Series From India

OBJECTIVE

We report our early clinical experience with image-guided, pencil beam scanning proton beam therapy (PBS-PBT) for residual and recurrent craniopharyngioma.

METHODS

Between September 2019 and January 2023, 19 consecutive patients with residual or recurrent craniopharyngioma, suitable for radiotherapy and treated with image-guided PBS-PBT were analyzed. We documented detailed dosimetric data, acute toxicities, early outcomes, and imaging response on follow-up magnetic resonance imaging scans.

RESULTS

A total of 19 patients (11 males and 8 females) with residual or recurrent craniopharyngioma were treated during the study period. The median age of the cohort was 14 years (range, 3-33 years). The histology of most lesions was the adamantinomatous subtype (95%). The most common clinical presentation (before PBT) and most common endocrine deficit was visual disturbance (79%) and hypocortisolism (74%), respectively. Of the 19 patients, 13 had recurrent craniopharyngioma, and 5 had undergone radiotherapy previously. Five patients (26%) had undergone surgery ≥3 times before proton therapy. The median dose delivered was 54 GyE. The most common acute toxicity was grade 1 alopecia (63%). No patient experienced grade ≥3 acute toxicity. With a median follow-up of 18 months (range, 3-40 months), 12 patients showed shrinkage of the residual tumor and/or cyst, and 4 showed a dramatic cyst reduction at 3-9 months of follow-up. Two patients experienced a reduction in both solid and cystic components, with the remaining experiencing a reduction in the cystic component only. The remaining 8 patients had stable disease on magnetic resonance imaging, with 100% disease control and overall survival. Visual function remained stable after treatment.

CONCLUSIONS

Our preliminary experience with modern PBS-PBT and image guidance for craniopharyngioma is encouraging. Proton therapy in our cohort was well tolerated, resulting in limited toxicity and promising early outcomes.

From Genes to Therapy: Pituitary Adenomas in the Era of Precision Medicine

This review presents a comprehensive analysis of pituitary adenomas, a type of brain tumor with diverse behaviors and complexities. We cover various treatment approaches, including surgery, radiotherapy, chemotherapy, and their integration with newer treatments. Key to the discussion is the role of biomarkers in oncology for risk assessment, diagnosis, prognosis, and the monitoring of pituitary adenomas. We highlight advances in genomic, epigenomic, and transcriptomic analyses and their contributions to understanding the pathogenesis and molecular pathology of these tumors. Special attention is given to the molecular mechanisms, including the impact of epigenetic factors like histone modifications, DNA methylation, and transcriptomic changes on different subtypes of pituitary adenomas. The importance of the tumor immune microenvironment in tumor behavior and treatment response is thoroughly analyzed. We highlight potential breakthroughs and innovations for a more effective management and treatment of pituitary adenomas, while shedding light on the ongoing need for research and development in this field to translate scientific knowledge into clinical advancements, aiming to improve patient outcomes.

Proton therapy for adult craniopharyngioma: Experience of a single institution in 91 consecutive patients

BACKGROUND

Craniopharyngioma (CP) in adults is a rare benign tumor associated with many morbidities, with limited contemporary studies to define treatment, and follow-up guidelines.

METHODS

A single-center retrospective study was conducted on patients aged ≥ 18 years from 2006-2018 with CP and who were treated with proton therapy (PT). Late toxicity was defined as a minimum of 18 months from diagnosis. Overall survival (OS), local recurrence-free survival (LRFS), and toxicity were characterized using Kaplan-Meier and Cox regression analyses.

RESULTS

Ninety-one patients met the criteria, with a median age of 37 years (range 18-82 years). PT was conducted after tumor resection in 88 patients (97%), in 64 patients (70.3%) as an adjuvant strategy and in 27 (29.7%) after recurrent disease. Three patients received exclusive PT. A median MRI follow-up of 39 months revealed 35.2% complete response, 49.5% partial response, and 9.9% stable disease. Five patients developed local recurrence (LR). The pattern of failure study showed that these five LR were within the GTV volume. The 5-year LRFS was 92.0% [CI 95% 84.90-99.60]. All the patients were alive at the end of the follow-up. Patients requiring treatment adaptation during PT tend to have a higher risk of LR (P = .084). Endocrinopathy was the most frequent grade ≥ 2 late toxicity. Among patients who were symptom-free before the start of treatment, none developed hearing toxicity but four (9.8%) developed visual disorders and 10 (11.3%) symptomatic memory impairment. Patients with large tumors had a higher risk of developing symptomatic memory impairment (P = .029).

CONCLUSION

Adults with CP treated with PT have favorable survival outcomes, with acceptable late toxicity. Prospective quality-of-life and neurocognitive studies are needed to define late adverse effects better.

Proton Radiotherapy for Skull-Base Malignancies

Proton therapy (PT) is a form of highly conformal external-beam radiotherapy used to mitigate acute and late effects following radiotherapy. Indications for treatment include both benign and malignant skull-base and central nervous system pathologies. Studies have demonstrated that PT shows promising results in minimizing neurocognitive decline and reducing second malignancies with low rates of central nervous system necrosis. Future directions and advances in biologic optimization may provide additional benefits beyond the physical properties of particle dosimetry.

Risk factors for and predictive nomogram of overall survival in adult patients with craniopharyngiomas: A SEER population-based study

Studies with relatively large sample size as well as long-term follow-up focusing on adult craniopharyngioma (CP) patients are still lacking. We attempted to identify independent prognostic factors and establish a nomogram model to estimate survival rates for adult CP patients. The Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Results database was used to obtain data on patients with CP. Univariable and multivariable Cox analyses were utilized to identify the prognostic factors of adult CP patients. A survival prediction model was constructed and its predictive performance was also assessed. A total of 991 patients (695 in training group and 296 in validation group) were eligible for final inclusion. Multivariate Cox analysis presented that age at diagnosis, marital status, race, tumor size, and surgery type were statistically significant prognostic factors for overall survival (all P < .05). A graphical predicting nomogram model was developed to calculate the predicted patients' survival probabilities at 1, 2, 5, and 10 years. The concordance indexes were 0.708 ± 0.019 and 0.750 ± 0.025 for the training and validation samples, respectively, demonstrating favorable discrimination abilities. Similarly, the time-dependent area under curve also showed overall satisfactory discrimination ability. Favorable consistencies between the predicted and actual survival were presented according to the calibration curves. An easy-to-use nomogram, being proven to be with reliable discrimination ability and accuracy, was established to help predict overall survival for adult patients with CP using the identified significant prognostic factors.

Current Advances in the Management of Adult Craniopharyngiomas

Craniopharyngiomas (CPs) are slow growing, histologically benign intracranial tumors located in the sellar–suprasellar region. Although known to have low mortality, their location and relationship to the adjacent neural structures results in patients having significant neurologic, endocrine, and visual comorbidities. The invasive nature of this tumor makes complete resection a challenge and contributes to its recurrence. Additionally, these tumors are bimodally distributed, being treated with surgery, and are followed by other adjuncts, such as focused radiation therapy, e.g., Gamma knife. Advances in surgical techniques, imaging tools, and instrumentations have resulted in the evolution of surgery using endoscopic techniques, with residual components being treated by radiotherapy to target the residual tumor. Advances in molecular biology have elucidated the main pathways involved in tumor development and recurrence, but presently, no other treatments are offered to patients, besides surgery, radiation, and endocrine management, as the disease and tumor evolve. We review the contemporary management of these tumors, from the evolution of surgical treatments, utilizing standard open microscopic approaches to the more recent endoscopic surgery, and discuss the current recommendations for care of these patients. We discuss the developments in radiation therapy, such as radiosurgery, being used as treatment strategies for craniopharyngioma, highlighting their beneficial effects on tumor resections while decreasing the rates of adverse outcomes. We also outline the recent chemotherapy modalities, which help control tumor growth, and the immune landscape on craniopharyngiomas that allow the development of novel immunotherapies.

Craniopharyngiomas

Craniopharyngiomas are rare epithelial tumours situated primarily in the sellar/parasellar region, occurring along the path of the craniopharyngeal duct. Whilst classed as histologically benign tumours, their unpredictable growth pattern and proximity to vital structures including the optic chiasm, hypothalamus, and pituitary gland renders them a considerable threat, with significant associated morbidity and increase in mortality. Occurring both in child and adulthood, their clinical manifestations are broad, commonly with symptoms/signs secondary to hypothalamic-pituitary dysfunction, raised intracranial pressure and visual compromise. They have two distinct histological subtypes (adamantinomatous and papillary), with unique patterns of age distribution, and genetic and molecular make-up. With increasing understanding of their genetic pathogenesis including BRAF V600E mutations in the papillary subtype, and β-catenin mutations in the adamantinomatous, further research provides hope for the discovery of targeted medical therapy that can exploit molecular changes occurring as a result of such alterations. Until then, primary treatment consists of surgery with or without radiotherapy, with intracystic aspiration, chemotherapy or irradiation being alternative options in selected patients. Long term management by an experienced multidisciplinary team is essential, given the breadth of complications, including hypothalamic morbidity, visual compromise, cognitive and neuropsychological sequelae and impairment to quality of life.

Nomograms for Predicting Overall Survival Among Patients with Craniopharyngiomas at Initial Diagnosis: A SEER Population-Based Analysis

Background

Craniopharyngiomas (CPs) are relatively rare benign tumor located in the central nervous system (CNS). This study investigates the related risk factors of survival of craniopharyngiomas and develops a simple but detailed method predicting prognosis based on the Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Results (SEER) database in order to improve the clinic management of CPs.

Methods

Between 2004 and 2017, 1213 patients diagnosed with craniopharyngiomas registered at the program and were included in the SEER-21 registry database. Overall survival (OS) curves were plotted with the Kaplan–Meier method and significance was determined by Log rank test. Single- and multiple-factor regression analyses were made using Cox proportional hazards model to identify independent predictors related to OS. Subsequently, we developed a nomogram with those factors to predict 3-, 5- and 10-year OS of craniopharyngiomas patients.

Results

We identified 1213 patients with craniopharyngioma. The OS rates at 3, 5, and 10 years after diagnosis were 89.1%, 86.2%, and 83%. Age, ethnicity, tumor size and radiation therapy were confirmed to be predictors correlating with OS at initial diagnosis. In multivariate analysis, we found that younger age (P<0.001), smaller tumor size (P<0.001), white ethnicity (P<0.001) and radiation therapy (P=0.004) were the factors that remained significantly associated with better survival. A nomogram was successfully constructed and validated by ROC, calibration plots and C-index of 0.773 (95% CI, 0.708–0.838).

Conclusion

The well-calibrated nomogram is the first clinical prediction model for predicting the prognosis for patients with craniopharyngiomas at initial diagnosis. Our study indicates that the surgical effect is not clear. Younger white patients with radiotherapy have a better prognosis, and the gross total resection (GTR) was not effective in prolonging the OS of a patient compared to no surgery and subtotal resection (STR).

[New indications of protontherapy for adults intracranial tumours]

Considering intracranial tumours, only few indications of protontherapy, such as chordoma, chondrosarcoma or uveal melanoma, are uniformly approved in the world. Other indications, excluding paediatric pathologies, are still debated. The aim of this article is to describe the rationale for the use of protonbeam irradiation for meningioma, pituitary adenoma, craniopharyngioma, paraganglioma, glioma, and schwannoma, and to inform the radiation oncologists if prospective studies or randomized studies are opened for inclusions. This article deals only with indications for adults.

Craniopharyngioma treatment: an updated summary of important clinicopathological concepts

INTRODUCTION

Craniopharyngiomas (CPs) are benign histological tumors that may develop at different positions along the hypothalamic-pituitary axis. Their close, heterogenous relationship to the hypothalamus makes surgical removal challenging even though this remains the primary treatment strategy.

AREAS COVERED

This article presents a critical overview of the pathological and clinical concepts regarding CPs that should be considered when planning treatment. Thus, we have performed a comprehensive review of detailed CP reports published between 1839 and 2020.

EXPERT OPINION

CP surgery should pursue maximal tumor resection while minimizing the risk of injuring the hypothalamus. Therefore, surgical strategies should be individualized for each patient. Accurate assessment of presenting symptoms and preoperative MRI has proven useful to predict the type of CP-hypothalamus relationship that will be found during surgery. CPs with dense and extensive adhesions to the hypothalamus should be highly suspected when MRI shows the hypothalamus positioned around the mid-third of the tumor and an amputated upper portion of the pituitary stalk. Symptoms related to functional impairment of the infundibulo-tuberal area of the third ventricle floor, such as obesity/hyperphagia, Fröhlich's syndrome, diabetes insipidus, and/or somnolence, also indicate risky CP-hypothalamic adhesions. In these cases, limited tumor removal is strongly advocated followed by radiation therapy.