Expression of 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylate (ACC) oxidase genes during the development of vegetative tissues in white clover (Trifolium repens L.) is regulated by ontological cues

Comparative Leaf and Root Transcriptomic Analysis of two Rice Japonica Cultivars Reveals Major Differences in the Root Early Response to Osmotic Stress

BACKGROUND

Rice (Oryza sativa L.) is one of the most important crops cultivated in both tropical and temperate regions and is characterized by a low water-use efficiency and a high sensitivity to a water deficit, with yield reductions occurring at lower stress levels compared to most other crops. To identify genes and pathways involved in the tolerant response to dehydration, a powerful approach consists in the genome-wide analysis of stress-induced expression changes by comparing drought-tolerant and drought-sensitive genotypes.

RESULTS

The physiological response to osmotic stress of 17 japonica rice genotypes was evaluated. A clear differentiation of the most tolerant and the most sensitive phenotypes was evident, especially after 24 and 48 h of treatment. Two genotypes, which were characterized by a contrasting response (tolerance/sensitivity) to the imposed stress, were selected. A parallel transcriptomic analysis was performed on roots and leaves of these two genotypes at 3 and 24 h of stress treatment. RNA-Sequencing data showed that the tolerant genotype Eurosis and the sensitive genotype Loto mainly differed in the early response to osmotic stress in roots. In particular, the tolerant genotype was characterized by a prompt regulation of genes related to chromatin, cytoskeleton and transmembrane transporters. Moreover, a differential expression of transcription factor-encoding genes, genes involved in hormone-mediate signalling and genes involved in the biosynthesis of lignin was observed between the two genotypes.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results provide a transcriptomic characterization of the osmotic stress response in rice and identify several genes that may be important players in the tolerant response.

Phosphate availability regulates ethylene biosynthesis gene expression and protein accumulation in white clover (Trifolium repens L.) roots

The expression and accumulation of members of the 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylate (ACC) synthase (ACS) and ACC oxidase (ACO) gene families was examined in white clover roots grown in either Pi (phosphate) sufficient or Pi-deprived defined media. The accumulation of one ACO isoform, TR-ACO1, was positively influenced after only 1 h of exposure to low Pi, and this was maintained over a 7-day time-course. Up-regulation of TR-ACS1, TR-ACS2 and TR-ACS3 transcript abundance was also observed within 1 h of exposure to low Pi in different tissue regions of the roots, followed by a second increase in abundance of TR-ACS2 after 5-7 days of exposure. An increase in transcript abundance of TR-ACO1 and TR-ACO3, but not TR-ACO2, was observed after 1 h of exposure to low Pi, with a second increase in TR-ACO1 transcripts occurring after 2-5 days. These initial increases of the TR-ACS and TR-ACO transcript abundance occurred before the induction of Trifolium repens PHOSPHATE TRANSPORTER 1 (TR-PT1), and the addition of sodium phosphite did not up-regulate TR-ACS1 expression over 24 h. In situ hybridization revealed some overlap of TR-ACO mRNA accumulation, with TR-ACO1 and TR-ACO2 in the root tip regions, and TR-ACO1 and TR-ACO3 mRNA predominantly in the lateral root primordia. TR-ACO1p-driven GFP expression showed that activation of the TR-ACO1 promoter was initiated within 24 h of exposure to low Pi (as determined by GFP protein accumulation). These results suggest that the regulation of ethylene biosynthesis in white clover roots is biphasic in response to low Pi supply.

1-Aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid as a signalling molecule in plants

This review summarizes and discusses the role of ACC synthase in plants. The classic role of ACC synthase is to act as the key enzyme in the biosynthetic pathway for the plant hormone ethylene. Several recent papers have converged on the notion that ACC, the immediate product of ACC synthase, acts as a novel signaling molecule in plants independent of its conversion to ethylene. The evidence for this hypothesis from these papers and potential roles for ACC is summarized and discussed.

Ethylene influences many aspects of plant growth and development including germination, leaf and floral senescence and abscission, fruit ripening, and the response to abiotic and biotic stress. The pathways involved in the biosynthesis of and response to ethylene have been elucidated. The first committed and generally rate-limiting step in ethylene biosynthesis is the conversion of S-adenosyl-methionine to 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC) by ACC synthase (ACS). This enzyme is encoded by a gene family in most plants and is subject to both transcriptional and post-transcriptional control in response to numerous endogenous and environmental cues. In addition to its well-described function as the immediate precursor of ethylene, recent studies suggest an alternative, non-canonical role for ACC. These studies found that in some contexts, chemical inhibitors of ethylene biosynthesis caused effects on root cell expansion that were not observed when ethylene perception or signalling was disrupted, suggesting that ACC, but not ethylene, played a role in these specific processes. Furthermore, mutation of all eight ACS genes in Arabidopsis was found to result in embryo lethality, in contrast to the relatively modest developmental effects of null mutants in the ethylene signalling components. This divergence suggests that ACC may play a role as a signalling molecule in plants. Here, we first review the ethylene biosynthesis pathway and then discuss these studies suggesting an independent role of ACC as a signalling molecule.

Cloning, identification and expression analysis of ACC oxidase gene involved in ethylene production pathway

1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid oxidase (ACO) enzyme is a member of the Fe II-dependent family of oxidases/oxygenases which require Fe(2+) as a cofactor, ascorbate as a cosubstrate and CO(2) as an activator. This enzyme catalyses the terminal step in the plant signaling of ethylene biosynthetic pathway. A 948 bp fragment of the ACO1 gene cDNA sequence was cloned from tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum) fruit tissues by using reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) with two PCR primers designed according to the sequence of a tomato cDNA clone (X58273). The BLAST search showed a high level of similarity (77-98 %) between ACO1 and ACO genes of other plants. The calculated molecular mass and predicted isoelectric point of LeACO1 were 35.8 kDa and 5.13, respectively. The three-dimensional structure studies illustrated that the LeACO1 protein folds into a compact jelly-roll motif comprised of 8 α-helices, 12 β-strands and several long loops. The cosubstrate was located in a cofactor-binding pocket referred to as a 2-His-1-carboxylate facial triad. Semi-quantitative RT-PCR analysis of gene expression revealed that the LeACO1 was expressed in fruit tissues at different ripening stages.

Changes in 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxlate (ACC) oxidase expression and enzyme activity in response to excess manganese in white clover (Trifolium repens L.)

To examine the effect on Mn treatment on the ACO gene family of white clover [Trifolium repens (L.) cv. Grasslands Challenge], rooted stolon cuttings were maintained in modified Hoaglands medium, at pH 5.4, containing either 5.2 μM Mn or 100 μM Mn over a 9-day time course. A significant uptake of Mn was observed in leaf tissue of plants grown in the 100 μM Mn treatment after 24 h and the content increased in these plants to reach 334 mg/kg DW at the conclusion of the time course. The growth of plants, measured as the petiole extension rate (PER), was significantly less in the 100 μM Mn treatment by day 9, while significantly less accumulation of leaf biomass was observed by day 7. The activity of a cell wall-associated H(2)O(2)-generating NADH peroxidase was shown to be higher in the 100 μM Mn treatment after day 5 of the time course while no significant difference in a H(2)O(2)-consuming guaiacol peroxidase activity was observed between the two Mn treatments. The expression of two leaf-associated ACC oxidase (ACO) genes, TR-ACO2 and TR-ACO3 was examined over the 9-day course but no difference between the two treatments was observed. In contrast, TR-ACO2 enzyme activity was measured and shown to decrease in the 100 μM Mn treatment after day 5 of the time course, with a concomitant decrease in TR-ACO2 accumulation, as determined by western analysis. Using 2DE and western analysis, evidence for post-translational modification of TR-ACO2 was observed.

ACC oxidase (ACO) genes in Trifolium occidentale (L.) and their relationship to ACO genes in white clover (T. repens L.) and T. pallescens (L.)

The identification and expression of two ACC oxidase (ACO) genes during leaf development in Trifolium occidentale (L.), one of the putative ancestral genomes of the allotetraploid, T. repens (L.; white clover), is described. In common with observations made in T. repens, the ACO genes displayed differential expression, with a TR-ACO2-like gene (designated TO-ACO2) confined to developing and early mature-green leaf tissue while expression of a TR-ACO3-like gene (designated TO-ACO3) is highest in leaves at the onset and during senescence. Biochemical analysis of TO-ACO2 revealed that both accumulation of the protein (determined by western analysis with a TR-ACO2 antibody) and enzyme activity matched the transcriptional activity of TO-ACO2. Western analysis also revealed that the Tr-ACO2 antibody recognised a protein of 37 kDa as a putative TP-ACO2 in T. pallescens. The 3'-UTRs of TO-ACO2 and TO-ACO3 were then compared with the 3'-UTRs of a TR-ACO2-like and TR-ACO3-like gene from T. pallescens, the other proposed ancestral genome (or closely related to the ancestor) of T. repens, with identity values of 87.8% for the ACO2-like genes and 94.8% for the ACO3-like genes. Comparison of the 3'-UTRs of TO-ACO2 with a TO-ACO2-like gene in T. repens (designated TR(O)-ACO2) and TP-ACO2 with a TP-ACO2-like gene in T. repens (designated TR(P)-ACO2) revealed identities of 100% and 96.6%, respectively, lending good support to T. occidentale as one of the ancestral genomes of T. repens. A similar comparison of the 3'-UTRs of TO-ACO3 with a TO-ACO3-like gene in T. repens (designated TR(O)-ACO3) and TP-ACO3 with a TP-ACO3-like gene in T. repens (designated TR(P)-ACO3) revealed identities of 99.5% and 97.9%, respectively, again supporting T. occidentale as one of the ancestral genomes. Further, these data confirm that both TO-ACO-like and TP-ACO-like genes are expressed in the allotetraploid T. repens.

Differential responses of the promoters from nearly identical paralogs of loblolly pine (Pinus taeda L.) ACC oxidase to biotic and abiotic stresses in transgenic Arabidopsis thaliana

Promoters from an ACC oxidase gene (PtACO1) and its nearly identical paralog (NIP) (PtACO2) of loblolly pine (Pinus taeda L.) were recovered from genomic DNA using PCR amplification. Transgenic Arabidopsis plants harboring genetic constructs from which beta-glucuronidase (GUS) expression was driven by the full-length (pACO1:GUS, pACO2:GUS) or truncated (pACO1-1.2:GUS, pACO2-1.2:GUS) loblolly pine ACC oxidase gene promoters displayed distinctive patterns of expression for the different promoter constructs. Both full-length promoter constructs, but not those using truncated promoters, responded to indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) and wounding. Both pACO1:GUS and pACO1-1.2:GUS responded to pathogen attack, while neither version of the pACO2 promoter responded to infection. In the inflorescence stalks, the full-length pACO1 promoter construct, but not the truncated pACO1-1.2:GUS or either pACO2 construct, responded to bending stress. When flowering transgenic Arabidopsis plants were placed in a horizontal position for 48 h, expression from pACO2:GUS, but not the other constructs, was induced on the underside of shoots undergoing gravitropic reorientation. The expression pattern for the pACO2:GUS construct in transgenic Arabidopsis was consistent with what might be expected for a gene promoter involved in the compression wood response in loblolly pine. Although near complete sequence identity between PtACO1 and PtACO2 transcripts prevented quantitation of specific gene products, the promoter expression analyses presented in this study provide strong evidence that the two ACC oxidase genes are likely differentially expressed and responded to different external stimuli in pine. These results are discussed with respect to the potential functional differences between these two genes in loblolly pine.

Characterization of the 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC) oxidase multigene family of Malus domestica Borkh

Two 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC) oxidase (ACO) genes have been cloned from RNA isolated from leaf tissue of apple (Malus domestica cv. Royal Gala). The genes, designated MD-ACO2 (with an ORF of 990bp) and MD-ACO3 (966bp) have been compared with a previously cloned gene of apple, MD-ACO1 (with an ORF of 942bp). MD-ACO1 and MD-ACO2 share a close nucleotide sequence identity of 93.9% in the ORF but diverge in the 3' untranslated regions (3'-UTR) (69.5%). In contrast, MD-ACO3 shares a lower sequence identity with both MD-ACO1 (78.5%) and MD-ACO2 (77.8%) in the ORF, and 68.4% (MD-ACO1) and 71% (MD-ACO2) in the 3'-UTR. Southern analysis confirmed that MD-ACO3 is encoded by a distinct gene, but the distinction between MD-ACO1 and MD-ACO2 is not as definitive. Gene expression analysis has shown that MD-ACO1 is restricted to fruit tissues, with optimal expression in ripening fruit, MD-ACO2 expression occurs more predominantly in younger fruit tissue, with some expression in young leaf tissue, while MD-ACO3 is expressed predominantly in young and mature leaf tissue, with less expression in young fruit tissue and least expression in ripening fruit. Protein accumulation studies using western analysis with specific antibodies raised to recombinant MD-ACO1 and MD-ACO3 produced in E. coli confirmed the accumulation of MD-ACO1 in mature fruit, and an absence of accumulation in leaf tissue. In contrast, MD-ACO3 accumulation occurred in younger leaf tissue, and in younger fruit tissue. Further, the expression of MD-ACO3 and accumulation of MD-ACO3 in leaf tissue is linked to fruit longevity. Analysis of the kinetic properties of the three apple ACOs using recombinant enzymes produced in E. coli revealed apparent Michaelis constants (K(m)) of 89.39 microM (MD-ACO1), 401.03 microM (MD-ACO2) and 244.5 microM (MD-ACO3) for the substrate ACC, catalytic constants (K(cat)) of 6.6x10(-2) (MD-ACO1), 3.44x10(-2) (Md-ACO2) and 9.14x10(-2) (MD-ACO3) and K(cat)/K(m) (microMs(-1)) values of 7.38x10(-4) microMs(-1) (MD-ACO1), 0.86x10(-4)Ms(-1) (MD-ACO2) and 3.8x10(-4) microMs(-1) (MD-ACO3). These results show that MD-ACO1, MD-ACO2 and MD-ACO3 are differentially expressed in apple fruit and leaf tissue, an expression pattern that is supported by some variation in kinetic properties.