Arsenic mobility and speciation in contaminated kitchen garden and lawn soils: an evaluation of water for assessment of As phytoavailability

Environmental bioavailability of arsenic, nickel and chromium in soils impacted by high geogenic and anthropogenic background contents

High arsenic, chromium and nickel in soils can pose a hazard to the ecosystem and/or human health. Large areas can be affected by elevated potentially toxic elements (PTE) background contents, entailing a significant effort for managing the potential risk. Assessing the environmental hazard associated to PTE-contaminated soils requires the determination of soil PTE environmental bioavailability, which reflects the capacity of these elements to be transferred to living organisms. Here we assess the environmental bioavailability of As, Cr and Ni in topsoils from the Liège basin and Belgian Lorraine, two areas in Wallonia, Belgium, affected by elevated As, Cr and Ni background contents. The source of soil As, Cr and Ni differs in Liège and Lorraine: anthropogenic in the former location and geogenic in the latter. The environmental bioavailability of PTE was determined using two complementary approaches: (1) by chemical fractionation with the Community Bureau of Reference (BCR) three-step sequential extraction protocol and (2) by estimating the phytoavailability using a plant-based biotest (Lolium multiflorum as plant model). The results show that total As (6-130 mg·kg-1), Cr (15-268 mg·kg-1), and Ni (8-140 mg·kg-1) contents in the Liège and Lorraine soils frequently exceed the soil clean-up standards. However, no positive correlation was found between the total contents and BCR extraction results or rye-grass contents, except for As in Liège soils. Total As, Cr or Ni contents surpassing soil standards do not necessarily result in elevated mobile, potentially mobilizable and phytoavailable contents. In general, environmental bioavailability of As, Cr and Ni is higher in soils from Liège basin compared to those sampled in Belgian Lorraine. The mobile and potentially mobilizable fractions of As, Cr and Ni account for <30 % of their total contents following the BCR extractions. Our study provides valuable information for sustainable management at the regional scale of soils containing high PTE contents.

Investigations of water-extractability of As in excavated urban soils using sequential leaching tests: Effect of testing parameters

Excavated soils with low-level As contamination obtained from construction projects during city development have been of great concern in Japan. Water-extractable As represents the most easily mobilized and ecotoxicologically relevant fraction in the soil environment. In the present study, the water-extractability of As in excavated alkaline urban soils was assessed using sequential leaching tests (SLTs) with a focus on the effects of test parameters. In addition, the potentially water-leachable As over an extremely long period was assessed using the pollution potential leaching index (PPLI), from which one can estimate the number of extractions required to reduce the As in the cumulative leachates to below the Japanese environmental standard (10 μg L^-1). Total As concentrations varied from 6.75 to 79.4 mg kg^-1, and As was continuously detectable among replicate SLT experiments. The water-extractable As obtained in the first step of the SLT accounted for 0.41%-7.60% of total As (average: 2.36%), while the cumulative released As in the SLTs corresponded to 1.30%-21.6% of the total (average: 10.6%). The variability of the water-soluble fractions was sensitive to the test conditions. The shaking time at each SLT step had the largest effect on the As water-extractability; followed by sample storage, shaking speed and shaking interruption. A longer shaking time in the standard leaching test of excavated soils is suggested for regulatory purposes in Japan. The use of the PPLI concept for quick estimation of the potential As leachability from excavated soils was supported by the good reproducibility of PPLI results obtained from SLTs under different test parameters.

Suitability of humic substances recovered from sewage sludge to remedy soils from a former As mining area - a novel approach

Batch washing experiments were performed to evaluate the feasibility of using a solution of humic substances (HS) extracted from municipal sewage sludge as a washing agent to remove As from soils at a former As mining area. Soils (S1, S2, S3) differed in organic matter content, pH and As concentration. At pH 4 and a HS concentration of 4000mgTOCL^-1, As removal efficiency ranged from 18% (S2) to 27% (S3). In all cases, As removal proceeded according to pseudo-second-order kinetics (equilibrium As concentrations ranged from 625mgkg^-1 (S3) to 1250mgkg^-1 (S3); rate constants, from 1.02×10^-5kgmg^-1min^-1 (S1) to 2.05×10^-5kgmg^-1min^-1 (S3). The time needed to reach equilibrium was 12h. With double washing, the efficiency of As removal was 1.5-times higher (on average) than with single washing. Double washing increased As stability, as indicated by the reduced partition index, especially in soils S1 and S3. Moreover, HS effectively decreased the content of the most toxic As(III) (by 95-97%).

Risk assessment from exposure to arsenic, antimony, and selenium in urban gardens (Madrid, Spain)

The authors discuss the geochemical behavior of arsenic (As), antimony (Sb), and selenium (Se) in urban gardens and the human health implications associated with urban agriculture. A total of 42 samples from 7 urban gardens in Madrid, Spain, were collected from the top 20 cm of soil. Concentrations of As, Sb, and Se and the main soil properties (i.e., total iron, pH, texture, calcium carbonate, and organic matter) were determined. A significant correlation was found between As and Sb and calcium carbonate, indicating the possibility of surface adsorption or ligand exchange with the carbonate group. Also, Sb seemed to form stable chelates with soil organic matter. On the other hand, Se showed a significant association with clay and iron content. The concentration of Sb in soil exceeded the recommended value for agricultural use in 70% of the urban gardens. A human health risk assessment resulted in acceptable levels of both noncarcinogenic and carcinogenic risks (although with elevated values of the latter), with As as the main risk driver and soil and food ingestion as the main exposure pathways. The numerical results of the risk assessment should be interpreted with caution given the considerable uncertainties in some exposure variables and the lack of quantitative values for the suspected carcinogenicity of Sb and Se. Environ Toxicol Chem 2017;36:544-550. © 2016 SETAC.