The Effect of Surgical Technique and Spacer Texture on Bone Regeneration: A Caprine Study Using the Masquelet Technique

Modified and alternative bone cements can improve the induced membrane: Critical size bone defect model in rat femur

BACKGROUND

As a two-stage surgical procedure, Masquelet's technique has been used to care for critical-size bone defects (CSD). We aimed to determine the effects of modified and altered bone cement with biological or chemical enriching agents on the progression of Masquelet's induced membrane (IM) applied to a rat femur CSD model, and to compare the histopathological, biochemical, and immunohistochemical findings of these cements to enhance IM capacity.

METHODS

Thirty-five male rats were included in five groups: plain polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA), estrogen-impregnated PMMA (E+PMMA), bone chip added PMMA (BC+PMMA), hydroxyapatite-coated PMMA (HA) and calcium phosphate cement (CPC). The levels of bone alkaline phosphatase (BALP), osteocalcin (OC), and tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-α) were analyzed in intracardiac blood samples collected at the end of 4 weeks of the right femur CSD intervention. All IMs collected were fixed and prepared for histopathological scoring. The tissue levels of rat-specific Transforming Growth Factor-Beta (TGF-β), Runt-related Transcription Factor 2 (Runx2), and Vascular Endothelial Growth Factor (VEGF) were analyzed immunohistochemically.

RESULTS

Serum levels of BALP and OC were significantly higher in E+PMMA and BC+PMMA groups than those of other groups (P = 0.0061 and 0.0019, respectively). In contrast, TNF-α levels of all groups with alternative bone cement significantly decreased compared to bare PMMA (P = 0.0116). Histopathological scores of E+PMMA, BC+PMMA, and CPC groups were 6.86 ± 1.57, 4.71 ± 0.76, and 6.57 ± 1.51, respectively, which were considerably higher than those of PMMA and HA groups (3.14 ± 0.70 and 1.86 ± 0.69, respectively) (P < 0.0001). Significant increases in TGF-β and VEGF expressions were observed in E+PMMA and CPC groups (P = 0.0001 and <0.0001, respectively) whereas Runx2 expression significantly increased only in the HA group compared to other groups (P < 0.0001).

CONCLUSIONS

The modified PMMA with E and BC, and CPC as an alternative spacer resulted in a well-differentiated IM and increased IM progression by elevating BALP and OC levels in serum and by mediating expressions of TGF-β and VEGF at the tissue level. Estrogen-supplemented cement spacer has yielded promising findings between modified and alternative bone cement.

Differences in macrophage expression in induced membranes by fixation method - Masquelet technique using a mouse's femur critical-sized bone defect model

INTRODUCTION

Masquelet's induced membrane technique (MIMT) is an emerging method for reconstructing critical-sized bone defects. However, an incomplete understanding of the underlying biological and physical processes hinders further optimization. This study investigated the effect of different bone-defect fixation methods on macrophage expression in an induced membrane using a novel mouse plate-fixed Masquelet model.

METHODS

Mice were divided into Plate-fixed Masquelet (P-M), Intramedullary-fixed Masquelet (IM-M), Plate-fixed Control (P-C), and Back subfascial (B) groups. In the P-M and IM-M groups, a polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) spacer was implanted into a 3 mm bone defect, while the defect in the P-C group remained unfilled. In group B, a spacer was inserted under the back fascia to examine membrane formation caused by a simple foreign body reaction. Tissues were collected at 1, 2, and 4 weeks postoperatively. Hematoxylin and eosin (H&E) staining and immunohistochemistry (CD68 and CD163: macrophage markers) were performed to assess macrophage expression within the membrane. qPCR was performed to measure the expression of CD68, CD163, and fibroblast growth factor 2 (FGF2).

RESULTS

Four weeks post-operation, the P-M group presented with minimal callus growth, whereas the IM-M group exhibited vigorous growth. The P-M and IM-M groups displayed a tri-layered membrane structure, which is consistent with the results of previous studies. The IM-M group had significantly thicker membranes, whereas the P-M group exhibited higher expression levels of CD68, CD163, and FGF2. Group P-C showed no osteogenesis, whereas group B maintained a thin, cell-dense membrane structure. The P-M group consistently showed higher gene expression levels than the P-C and P-B groups.

CONCLUSION

This study introduced a mouse plate fixation model for MIMT. The induced membranes could be adequately evaluated in this model. Induced membranes are formed by foreign body reactions to PMMA spacers; however, their properties are clearly different from those of simple foreign body reaction capsules and granulation tissues that infiltrate bone defects, suggesting that they are more complex tissues. The characteristics and expression of macrophages within these induced membranes varied according to the bone defect fixation method.

Mechanisms of the Masquelet technique to promote bone defect repair and its influencing factors

The Masquelet technique, also known as the induced membrane technique, is a surgical technique for repairing large bone defects based on the use of a membrane generated by a foreign body reaction for bone grafting. This technique is not only simple to perform, with few complications and quick recovery, but also has excellent clinical results. To better understand the mechanisms by which this technique promotes bone defect repair and the factors that require special attention in practice, we examined and summarized the relevant research advances in this technique by searching, reading, and analysing the literature. Literature show that the Masquelet technique may promote the repair of bone defects through the physical septum and molecular barrier, vascular network, enrichment of mesenchymal stem cells, and high expression of bone-related growth factors, and the repair process is affected by the properties of spacers, the timing of bone graft, mechanical environment, intramembrane filling materials, artificial membrane, and pharmaceutical/biological agents/physical stimulation.

Fibromodulin facilitates the osteogenic effect of Masquelet's induced membrane by inhibiting the TGF-β/SMAD signaling pathway

Masquelet's induced membrane (IM) technique is a promising treatment strategy for the repair of substantial bone defects. The formation of an IM around polymethylmethacrylate bone cement plays a crucial role in this technique. Several studies have indicated that IMs have bioactivity because they contain abundant blood vessels, a variety of cells, and biological factors. The bioactivity of an IM increases during the initial stages of formation, thereby facilitating bone regeneration and remodeling. Nevertheless, the precise mechanisms underlying the enhancement of IM bioactivity and the promotion of bone regeneration necessitate further investigation. In this study, we successfully developed a Masquelet IM model of critical femur defects in rats. By employing proteomics analysis and biological detection techniques, we identified fibromodulin (FMOD) as a pivotal factor contributing to angiogenesis and the enhanced bioactivity of the IM. A significant increase in angiogenesis and the expression of bioactive factors in the IM was also observed with the upregulation of FMOD expression. Furthermore, this effect is mediated through the inhibition of the transforming growth factor beta (TGF-β)/SMAD signaling pathway. We also demonstrated that administering recombinant human FMOD enhanced osteogenesis in rat bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells and angiogenesis in human umbilical vein endothelial cells in vitro. Furthermore, the negative regulatory effect of the TGF-β signaling pathway was verified. In conclusion, this study provides a novel theoretical basis for the application of IMs in bone-defect reconstruction and explores possible new mechanisms that may play an important role in promoting the bioactivity and osteogenic potential of IMs.

Treatment outcome of the Masquelet technique in 195 infected bone defects-A single-center, retrospective case series

BACKGROUND

The Masquelet technique is a surgical procedure for the reconstruction of bone defects. During the first step, an osteosynthetically stabilized defect is filled with a cement spacer. The spacer induces a foreign body membrane, called a Masquelet membrane. In a follow-up procedure, the spacer is replaced by a bone graft, which ossifies in the subsequent phase.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

A total of 171 patients with 195 septic bone defects on the extremities that had been treated with the Masquelet procedure at the BG Klinikum in Hamburg, Germany, from 2011 to 2021 were retrospectively analysed, comparing patients who reached full weight and load bearing on the affected extremity to those who failed to do so. Defect size and configuration, microbiological results and treatment methods as well as comorbidities and epidemiologic data were analysed for factors influencing the treatment outcome.

RESULTS

In all, 113[66%] of the patients were male, and 58[34%] were female, with an age distribution of 52 +/-16 years. Out of 171 patients, 24 patients had two defects. The number of patients that reached full weight bearing was 152[89%], the follow-up period was 2 +/-1 years (median +/- SD). Full weight bearing capability was negatively by the defect size as defects >62 mm tended to be less likely to reach full weight bearing than smaller defects. A secondary stabilization with an internal stabilization was applied in 58[34%] of all patients and positively influenced the attainment of full weight and load bearing.

DISCUSSION

With 171 patients and 195 septic bone defects treated at a single centre with the Masquelet Technique, this study represents a comparably large cohort. Demographics, defect characteristics and treatment outcomes did not differ from those of other cohorts described in the literature. Defects larger than 62 mm showed lower chances to reach full weight bearing and can be defined as "critical defect size" for the Masquelet technique based on our data.

Modern Description of Antibiotic Spacer Options for PJI in Revision Total Knee Arthroplasty: Clinical Outcomes and Infection Eradication Rates

BACKGROUND

As the burden of periprosthetic joint infections (PJI) increases there is growing interest in understanding the efficacy and morbidity reduction of two-stage revision and various antibiotic spacer options. This study aimed to expand the description and evaluation of spacers from solely their articulation status to include their ability to support full (functional) or partial weight-bearing (non-functional).

METHODS

Between 2002 and 2021, 391 patients who had Musculoskeletal Infection Society criteria for PJI with one- or two-stage revision were included. Demographics, functional outcomes, and subsequent revision data was collected. The study population had a mean follow-up of 2.9 years (range, 0.05 to 13.0) with an average age of 67 years (range, 34.7 to 93.4). Spacer failure was defined by surgical intervention following definitive surgery, and infection eradication was defined by the Delphi criteria. Spacers were classified as nonfunctional static, nonfunctional dynamic, functional static, or functional dynamic. Two tailed t-tests were performed.

RESULTS

There were no significant differences in infection eradication or mechanical outcomes across spacer types; notably, 97.3% of functional dynamic spacers achieved infection eradication. Functional spacers had a longer time to the second stage procedure and a greater number of patients who had not been reimplanted. There was no difference in reoperation rates in nonfunctional versus functional spacers.

CONCLUSION

Within this cohort, infection eradication and spacer exchange rates were non-inferior among spacers. Functional spacers may allow for earlier return to daily living given the weightbearing capability when compared to non-functional, without sacrificing clinical outcome.

The antibiotics supplemented bone cement improved the masquelet's induced membrane in a rat femur critical size defect model

BACKGROUND

Masquelet technique is a two-stage surgical procedure used in the treatment of critical-size bone defects (CSD). Adding antibiotics to polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) is still questionable to create higher quality induced membrane (IM). The aim of the study was to evaluate the effects of three antibiotic-supplemented cement, fusidic acid, teicoplanin, and gentamicin, on osteogenesis and IM progression applied to rat femur CSD model by comparing histopathological, biochemical, and immunohistochemical findings.

METHODS

Twenty-eight male rats were divided into four groups control, gentamicin (G), teicoplanin (T), and fusidic acid (FA). A 10 mm CSD was created in rat femurs. In the postoperative 4th week, intracardiac blood samples were collected for biochemical analysis of bone alkaline phosphatase (BALP), osteocalcin (OC), and tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-α) levels. IMs obtained in secondary operation were fixed and prepared for histopathological scoring of membrane progression and immunohistochemical evaluation of rat-specific Transforming Growth Factor-Beta (TGF-β), Runt-related Transcription Factor 2 (Runx2), and Vascular Endothelial Growth Factor (VEGF) expressions.

RESULTS

Levels of BALP and OC in serum didn't change among groups significantly while serum TNF-α levels significantly decreased in all antibiotic groups compared to the control group (P = 0.017). Histological scores of groups FA and T were significantly higher than those of groups Control and G (P = 0.0007). IMs of groups T and FA showed good progression while those of groups Control and G were also moderately progressed. A significant increase in TGF-β expression was observed in group G and FA (P = 0.001) while a significant increase in the expression of VEGF was observed in groups G and T compared to the control group (P = 0.036).

CONCLUSIONS

The bone cement impregnated with thermostable and safe antibiotics, gentamicin, fusidic acid, and teicoplanin can increase osteogenesis and support IM progression by increasing the expressions of TGF-β and VEGF. Anabolic effects of induced membranes used in the treatment of critical-size bone defects can be enhanced by antibiotic-supplemented PMMAs applied by altering the original technique.

Repair of critical diaphyseal defects of lower limbs by 3D printed porous Ti6Al4V scaffolds without additional bone grafting: a prospective clinical study

The repair of critical diaphyseal defects of lower weight-bearing limbs is an intractable problem in clinical practice. From December 2017, we prospectively applied 3D printed porous Ti6Al4V scaffolds to reconstruct this kind of bone defect. All patients experienced a two-stage surgical process, including thorough debridement and scaffold implantation. With an average follow-up of 23.0 months, ten patients with 11 parts of bone defects were enrolled in this study. The case series included three females and seven males, their defect reasons included seven parts of osteomyelitis and four parts of aseptic nonunion. The bone defects located at femur (five parts) and tibia (six parts), with an average defect distance of 12.2 cm. Serial postoperative radiologic follow-ups displayed a continuous process of new bone growing and remodeling around the scaffold. One patient suffered tibial varus deformity, and he underwent a revision surgery. The other nine patients achieved scaffold stability. No scaffold breakage occurred. In conclusion, the implantation of 3D printed Ti6Al4V scaffold was feasible and effective to reconstruct critical bone defects of lower limbs without additional bone grafting. Graphical abstract.

Masquelet technique in military practice: specificities and future directions for combat-related bone defect reconstruction

Because of its simplicity, reliability, and replicability, the Masquelet induced membrane technique (IMT) has become one of the preferred methods for critical bone defect reconstruction in extremities. Although it is now used worldwide, few studies have been published about IMT in military practice. Bone reconstruction is particularly challenging in this context of care due to extensive soft-tissue injury, early wound infection, and even delayed management in austere conditions. Based on our clinical expertise, recent research, and a literature analysis, this narrative review provides an overview of the IMT application to combat-related bone defects. It presents technical specificities and future developments aiming to optimize IMT outcomes, including for the management of massive multi-tissue defects or bone reconstruction performed in the field with limited resources.

Bone defect treatment: does the type and properties of the spacer affect the induction of Masquelet membrane? Evidence today

PURPOSE

High clinical success rates have been reported with the Masquelet technique in the treatment of traumatic bone loss. An increasing number of studies suggest that various factors can influence the properties of induced membranes. Goal of this systematic review is to answer the following questions: (1) which are the ideal spacer properties (material, surface topography, antibiotic supplementation) to booster the quality and osteogenic potential of induced membranes? (2) what is the ideal time to perform the second-stage operation?

METHODS

A systematic search using the keywords "((Masquelet) OR (Induced Periosteum)) AND ((Spacer) OR (Time))" was performed in PubMed, Embase and Cochrane Library according to PRISMA guidelines. Studies published up to the 23rd of February 2022 were included and assessed independently by two reviewers.

RESULTS

Thirteen animal and 1 clinical studies were identified to address the above questions. Spacer materials used were PMMA, silicone, titanium, polypropylene, PVA, PCL and calcium sulfate. With the exception of PVA sponges, all solid materials could induce membranes. Low union rates have been reported with titanium and rough surfaced spacers. Scraping of the inner surface of the IM also increased bony union rates. In terms of the ideal timing to perform the second-stage evidence suggests that membranes older than 8 weeks continue to have regenerative capacities similar to younger ones.

CONCLUSION

Membranes induced by smooth PMMA spacers loaded with low concentrations of antibiotics showed powerful osteogenic properties. Other materials such as Polypropylene or Calcium sulfate can also be used with good results. Despite current recommendation to perform the second stage operation in 4-8 weeks, membranes older than 8 weeks seem to have similar regenerative capacities to younger ones.

The induced membrane technique: Optimization of bone grafting in a rat model of segmental bone defect

INTRODUCTION

The induced membrane technique (IMT) is a two-stage surgical procedure used to treat fracture nonunion and bone defects. Although there is an increasing number of animal studies investigating the IMT, few have examined the outcomes of bone healing after a second stage grafting procedure. This study aimed at comparing two bone grafting procedures, as part of the IMT, in order to establish a rat model providing consistent healing outcomes.

METHODS

In male Fischer 344 rats, we created a 5 mm defect in the right femur, stabilized the bone with a plate and screws, and inserted a polymethylmethacrylate spacer into the defect. Four weeks later, the spacer was removed. Bone graft was harvested from a donor rat and placed into the defect, followed by membrane and wound closure. Experiments were conducted in two groups. In group 1 (n = 11), the bone graft contained a variable amount of cortical and cancellous bone, the time from donor euthanasia to grafting was up to 240 min, and one donor rat provided graft for 5-6 recipients. In group 2 (n = 12), we reduced the contribution of cortical bone to the graft, included bone marrow, and kept donor euthanasia to grafting time under 150 min. One donor was used per 3-4 recipients. The volume of graft per recipient and all other elements of the protocol were the same across groups. Bone healing at 12 weeks post grafting was compared radiographically by two orthopaedic surgeons in a blinded fashion, based on union status and a modified Lane & Sandhu score.

RESULTS

Healing rates improved from 36.4% in Group 1 to 91.6% in Group 2. There was a significant relationship between the methods and resulting union status (p = 0.004). The odds of achieving full union were significantly higher in group 2 compared to group 1 (odds ratio=19.25, 95% confidence interval [1.77-209.55]; p = 0.009). The average radiographic score was also significantly higher in group 2 (p = 0.005).

CONCLUSION

The revised bone grafting method significantly improved the healing outcomes and contributed to establishing a consistent rat model of the IMT. This model can benefit preclinical investigations by allowing for reliable and clinically-relevant comparisons.

Efficacy of total flavonoids of Rhizoma drynariae on the blood vessels and the bone graft in the induced membrane

BACKGROUND

Total flavonoids of Rhizoma drynariae (TFRD), a Chinese medicine, is widely used in the treatment of orthopedic diseases. However, there are few basic and clinical studies on the effect of TFRD on induced membrane technique (Masquelet technique).

PURPOSE

This trial is to explore effects of TFRD on vascularization of the induced membrane, and mineralization of the bone graft in rats with femoral bone defects.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

Forty-eight Sprague-Dawley rats were randomly divided into high dose group (H-TFRD), medium dose group (M-TFRD), low dose group (L-TFRD) and control group (control). The segmental bone defects were established with 12 rats in per group. The polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA) spacer was implanted into the femoral bone defect of rats in the first-stage surgery. About 4 weeks after first-stage surgery, induced membranes of 6 rats in each group were selected. The blood vessels and angiogenesis-related factors in the induced membrane were analyzed by hematoxylin-eosin (HE) and masson staining, western blot, qPCR and immunohistostaining. The remaining rats in per group underwent second-stage surgery (bone grafting). Twelve weeks after the bone grafting, the bone tissues was examined by X-ray, micro-computed tomography (Micro-CT), HE staining and enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) to evaluate the growth of the bone graft. Meanwhile, the TFRD-containing serum was collected from rats to culture osteoblasts in vitro. Cell Counting Kit-8 (CCK-8) method, Alizarin Red S (ARS) staining, western blot and immunofluorescence were used to detect effects of TFRD on the osteoblasts' proliferation and BMP-SMAD signaling pathway.

RESULTS

Compared with the L-TFRD and control groups, the number of blood vessels and the expression of angiogenesis-related factors (VEGF, TGF-β1, BMP-2, PDGF-BB and CD31) were higher in the H-TFRD and M-TFRD groups. The Lane-Sandhu X-ray score, bone mass and growth rate of the bone graft in the H-TFRD and M-TFRD groups were significantly better than those in the L-TFRD and control groups. In addition, medium and high doses of TFRD significantly increased the expression of BMP-SMAD pathway proteins (BMP-2, SMAD1, SMAD4, SMAD5 and RUNX2) in rat serum and bone graft. In vitro, after osteoblasts were intervened with TFRD-containing serum from the H-TFRD and M-TFRD groups, the cell viability, the number of mineralized nodules and the phosphorylation of BMP-SMAD pathway proteins were markedly increased.

CONCLUSION

TFRD could promote the formation of blood vessels and the expression of angiogenesis-related factors during the formation of the induced membrane. During the growing period of bone graft, it could facilitate the growth and mineralization of bone graft in a dose-dependent manner, which is partly related to the activation and phosphorylation of BMP-SMAD signaling pathway.

Masquelet technique: Effects of vancomycin concentration on quality of the induced membrane

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to determine the effects of polymethylmetnacrylate (PMMA) spacer loaded with different concentrations of vancomycin on the proliferative, osteogenic, and angiogenic capacity of the induced membrane.

METHODS

Varying concentrations of vancomycin (0, 1, 2, 4, 6, 8, and 10 g) were fully mixed with bone cement powder (40 g), resulting in seven experimental groups. Hollow cylindrical PMMA spacers (10 mm height, 3 mm external diameter, and 0.8 mm internal diameter) were formed by a mold and submerged in phosphate-buffered saline for antibiotic release by spectrophotometry. Eighty-four New Zealand white rabbits were evenly randomized into seven groups, and segmental radius shaft defects (10 mm) were created. Defects were filled with cylindrical PMMA spacers containing different vancomycin concentrations, and subsequently underwent intramedullary fixation with a retrograde Kirschner's wire. Tissue toxicity was assessed and the proliferative, osteogenic, and angiogenic capacity of induced membranes were qualitatively analyzed by immunohistochemistry and real-time PCR.

RESULTS

No obvious toxicity was observed in the animal model. Alizarin red s staining and qualitative detection of type I collagen, CD31, Ki67, and STRO-1 by immunohistochemistry revealed an obvious decrease in the percentage of positively stained cells and in osteogenic capacity when the concentration of vancomycin was more than 6 g per cement dose. Quantitation of gene expression related to osteogenesis (Col1a, Alp, and Runx2), vascularization (Vegf, Tgfb1, and vWF), and proliferation (Oct4 and Stro-1) by real-time PCR revealed slight increases in the expression of selected genes at low vancomycin concentrations (1-4 g per cement dose), and relatively lower gene expression when the concentration of vancomycin was more than 6 g per cement dose.

CONCLUSION

PMMA spacers loaded with relatively low concentrations of vancomycin (1-4 g per cement dose) did not interfere with the proliferative, osteogenic, and angiogenic capacity of induced membranes, and even promoted their capacity. In contrast, spacers loaded with relatively high concentrations of vancomycin (6-10 g per cement dose) had negative effects on osteoblast viability, angiogenesis, and proliferation.

The induced membrane technique in animal models: a systematic review

Objectives:

Data Sources:

Study Selection:

Data Extraction:

Data Synthesis:

Conclusions:

The Masquelet Technique: Can Disposable Polypropylene Syringes be an Alternative to Standard PMMA Spacers? A Rat Bone Defect Model

BACKGROUND

Usually, the two-stage Masquelet induced-membrane technique for extremity reconstruction begins with a polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) cement spacer-driven membrane, followed by an autologous cancellous bone graft implanted into the membrane cavity to promote healing of large bone defects. In exceptional cases, spacers made of polypropylene disposable syringes were successfully used instead of the usual PMMA spacers because of a PMMA cement shortage caused by a lack of resources. However, this approach lacks clinical evidence and requires experimental validation before being recommended as an alternative to the conventional technique.

QUESTIONS/PURPOSES

To (1) develop and (2) validate a critical-sized femoral defect model in rats for two stages of the Masquelet technique and to (3) compare the biological and bone healing properties of polypropylene-induced membranes and PMMA-induced membranes in this model.

METHODS

Fifty male Sprague Dawley rats aged 8 weeks old received a 6-mm femur defect, which was stabilized with an external fixator that was converted into an internal device. In the development phase, the defect was filled with PMMA in 16 rats to determine the most favorable timing for bone grafting. Two rats were excluded since they died of anesthetic complications. The other 14 were successively euthanized after 2 weeks (n = 3), 4 weeks (n = 4), 6 weeks (n = 4), and 8 weeks (n = 3) for induced membrane analyses. In the validation phase, 12 rats underwent both stages of the procedure using a PMMA spacer and were randomly assigned to two groups, whether the induced membrane was preserved or removed before grafting. To address our final objective, we implanted either polypropylene or PMMA spacers into the defect (Masquelet technique Stage 1; n = 11 rats per group) for the period established by the development phase. In each group, 6 of 11 rats were euthanized to compare the biological properties of polypropylene-induced membranes and PMMA-induced membranes using histological qualitative analysis, semiquantitative assessment of the bone morphogenic protein-2 content by immunostaining, and qualitative assessment of the mesenchymal stromal cell (MSC; CD31-, CD45-, CD90+, and CD73+ phenotypes) content by flow cytometry. Quantitative measurements from serum bone turnover markers were also performed. The five remaining rats of each group were used for Masquelet technique Stage 2, in which rat bone allografts were implanted in the induced membrane cavity after the polypropylene or PMMA spacers were removed. These rats recovered for 10 weeks before being euthanized for microCT quantitative measurements and bone histology qualitative assessment to evaluate and compare the extent of bone regeneration between groups.

RESULTS

Induced membrane analyses together with serum bone turnover measurements indicated that a 4-week interval time between stages was the most favorable. Removal of the induced membrane before grafting led to almost constant early implant failures with poor bone formation. Four-week-old rats with polypropylene-triggered induced membranes displayed similar histologic organization as rats with PMMA-driven induced membranes, without any difference in the cell density of the extracellular matrix (4933 ± 916 cells per mm2 for polypropylene versus 4923 ± 1284 cells per mm2 for PMMA; p = 0.98). Induced membrane-derived MSCs were found in both groups with no difference (4 of 5 with polypropylene versus 3 of 3 with PMMA; p > 0.99). Induced membrane bone morphogenic protein-2 immunolabeling and serum bone turnover marker levels were comparable between the polypropylene and PMMA groups. MicroCT analysis found that bone regeneration in the polypropylene group seemed comparable with that in the PMMA group (29 ± 26 mm3 for polypropylene versus 24 ± 18 mm3 for PMMA; p > 0.99). Finally, qualitative histological assessment revealed a satisfactory endochondral ossification maturation in both groups.

CONCLUSION

Using a critical-sized femoral defect model in rats, we demonstrated that polypropylene spacers could induce membrane encapsulation with histologic characteristics and bone regenerative capacities that seem like those of PMMA spacers.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

In a same bone site, polymers with close physical properties seem to lead to similar foreign body reactions and induce encapsulating membranes with comparable bone healing properties. Polypropylene spacers made from disposable syringes could be a valuable alternative to PMMA. These results support the possibility of a cementless Masquelet technique in cases of PMMA shortage caused by a lack of resources.

Masquelet's induced membrane technique: Review of current concepts and future directions

Masquelet's induced membrane technique (MIMT) is a relatively new, two-stage surgical procedure to reconstruct segmental bone defects. First performed by Dr. Masquelet in the mid-1980s, MIMT has shown great promise to revolutionize critical-sized bone defect repair and has several advantages over its alternative, distraction osteogenesis (DO). Also, its success in extremely challenging cases (defects > 15 cm) suggests that its study could lead to discovery of novel biological mechanisms that might be at play during segmental defect healing and fracture non-union. MIMT's advantages over DO have led to a world-wide increase in MIMT procedures over the past decades. However, MIMT often needs to be repeated and so the average initial success rate in adults lags significantly behind that of DO (86% vs 95%, respectively). The autologous foreign-body membrane created during the first stage by the immune system's response to a polymethyl methacrylate bone cement spacer is critical to supporting the morselized bone graft implanted in the second stage. However, the biological and/or physical mechanisms by which the membrane supports graft to bone union are unclear. This lack of knowledge makes refining MIMT and improving the success rates through technique improvements and patient selection a significant challenge and hinders wider adoption. In this review, current knowledge from basic, translational, and clinical studies is summarized. The dynamics of both stages under normal conditions as well as with drug or material perturbations is discussed along with perspectives on high-priority future research directions.

Effects of topical mechanical stability on the formation of Masquelet membrane in a rabbit radial defect model

The exact mechanism of Masquelet technique is unknown. This study intends to explore the effects of topical mechanical stability on the formation of Masquelet membrane. Segmental radius shaft defect was created in all rabbits, which were filled with polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) in Non-fixation group, and with PMMA fixed with plates in Fixation group, and subjected to no disposal in control group. The topical stability of PMMA and plates were monitored via X-ray and mechanical test. And the membranes were excised for further Histological, IHC and Western-Blotting analysis 4 and 6 weeks post-operatively. X-ray revealed no sign of plates loosening, or shift of PMMA. Mechanical tests revealed superior topical stability by plates. Pathological examinations suggested that vascularized and osteogenic membranes were formed around PMMA. IHC and Western-Blotting analysis revealed that both Fixation and Non-fixation group exerted significant effects on the expression of Ki67, COL I, and CD31 positive cells, as well as the protein expression of osteogenic (RUNX2, ALP) and angiogenic (VEGFA, TGF-β1) factors. And compared with membrane in Non-fixation group, Fixing PMMA spacer with plates caused a significant increase in osteogenic and angiogenic expression. This study indicates that rigid fixation provided by plate in Masquelet technique positively alters the quality of membrane formed surrounding PMMA, in terms of significantly osteogenic and angiogenic potential.

A cell-based combination product for the repair of large bone defects

Regenerative cell-based implants using periosteum-derived stem cells were developed for the treatment of large 3 cm fresh and 4.5 centimeter biological compromised bone gaps in a tibial sheep model and compared with an acellular ceramic-collagen void filler. It was hypothesized that the latter is insufficient to heal large skeletal defects due to reduced endogenous biological potency. To this purpose a comparison was made between the ceramic dicalciumphosphate scaffold (CopiOs®) as such, the same ceramic coated with clinical grade Bone Morphogenetic Protein 2 and 6 (BMP) only or a BMP coated cell-seeded combination product. These implants were evaluated in 2 sheep models, a fresh 3 cm critical size tibial defect and a 4.5 cm biologically exhausted tibial defect. For the groups in which growth factors were applied, BMP-6 was chosen at a dose of 344 μg for 3 cm and 1.500 μg or 3.800 μg for 4.5 cm defects. An additional group in the 4.5 cm defect was tested using BMP-2 in a dose of 1.500 μg. For all the cell based implants autologous periosteum-derived cells were used which were cultured in monolayer during 6 weeks. For the fresh defect 408 million cells and for the biologically exhausted tibial defect 612 million cells were drop-seeded on the BMP coated scaffolds. Bone healing was studied during 16 weeks postimplantation, using standard radiographs. While fresh defects responded to all treatments, regardless the use of cells, the biologically hampered defects responded in half of the cases and only if the BMP-cell combination product was used, supporting the concept that cell-based therapies may become attractive in treating defects with a compromised biological status.

The Masquelet technique: Current concepts, animal models, and perspectives

Bone reconstruction within a critical-sized defect remains a real challenge in orthopedic surgery. The Masquelet technique is an innovative, two-step therapeutic approach for bone reconstruction in which the placement of a poly (methylmethacrylate) spacer into the bone defect induces the neo-formation of a tissue called "induced membrane." This surgical technique has many advantages and is often preferred to a vascularized bone flap or Ilizarov's technique. Although the Masquelet technique has achieved high clinical success rates since its development by Alain-Charles Masquelet in the early 2000s, very little is known about how the process works, and few animal models of membrane induction have been developed. Our successful use of this technique in the clinic and our interest in the mechanisms of tissue regeneration (notably bone regeneration) prompted us to develop a surgical model of the Masquelet technique in rats. Here, we provide a comprehensive review of the literature on animal models of membrane induction, encompassing the defect site, the surgical procedure, and the histologic and osteogenic properties of the induced membrane. We also discuss the advantages and disadvantages of those models to facilitate efforts in characterizing the complex biological mechanisms that underlie membrane induction.

A Three-Dimensional Printed Polycaprolactone Scaffold Combined with Co-Axially Electrospun Vancomycin/Ceftazidime/Bone Morphological Protein-2 Sheath-Core Nanofibers for the Repair of Segmental Bone Defects During the Masquelet Procedure

Introduction

Masquelet proposed a new solution for the healing of segmental bone defects, thus minimizing the disadvantages associated with traditional bone grafting. However, a major factor leading to the failure of this technique pertains to be the residual infection. Accordingly, we developed an antibiotic- and osteo-inductive agent-loaded composite scaffold to solve this problem.

Methods

A mesh-like polycaprolactone scaffold was prepared using a lab-exploited solution-type three-dimensional printer, and hybrid sheath-core structured poly(lactic-co-glycolic-acid) nanofibers were fabricated using co-axial electrospinning technology. Vancomycin, ceftazidime, and bone morphological protein (BMP)-2 were employed. The in vitro and in vivo (rabbit fracture model) release patterns of applied agents from the composite scaffold were investigated.

Results

The results revealed that the drug-eluting composite scaffold enabled the sustainable release of the medications for at least 30 days in vitro. Animal tests demonstrated that a high concentration of medications was maintained. Abundant growth factors were induced within the bioactive membrane stimulated by the applied scaffold. Finally, satisfactory bone healing potential was observed on radiological examination and biomechanical evaluation.

Discussion

The developed composite scaffold may facilitate bone healing by inducing bioactive membrane formation and yielding high concentrations of antibiotics and BMP-2 during the Masquelet procedure.

Masquelet Technique: Effects of Spacer Material and Micro-topography on Factor Expression and Bone Regeneration

We and others have shown that changing surface characteristics of the spacer implanted during the first Masquelet stage alters some aspects of membrane development. Previously we demonstrated that titanium (TI) spacers create membranes that are better barriers to movement of solutes > 70 kDa in size than polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA) induced-membranes, and roughening creates more mechanically compliant membranes. However, it is unclear if these alterations affect the membrane's biochemical environment or bone regeneration during the second stage. Ten-week-old, male Sprague-Dawley rats underwent an initial surgery to create an externally stabilized 6 mm femoral defect. PMMA or TI spacers with smooth (~ 1 μm) or roughened (~ 8 μm) surfaces were implanted. Four weeks later, rats were either euthanized for membrane harvest or underwent the second Masquelet surgery. TI spacers induced thicker membranes that were similar in structure and biochemical expression. All membranes were bilayered with the inner layer having increased factor expression [bone morphogenetic protein 2 (BMP2), transforming growth factor beta (TGFβ), interleukin 6 (IL6), and vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF)]. Roughening increased overall IL6 levels. Ten-weeks post-engraftment, PMMA-smooth induced membranes better supported bone regeneration (60% union). The other groups only had 1 or 2 that united (9-22%). There were no significant differences in any micro computed tomography or dynamic histology outcome. In conclusion, this study suggests that the membrane's important function in the Masquelet technique is not simply as a barrier. There is likely a critical biochemical, cellular, or vascular component as well.

Masquelet technique: The effect of altering implant material and topography on membrane matrix composition, mechanical and barrier properties in a rat defect model

The Masquelet technique is a surgical procedure to regenerate segmental bone defects. The two-phase treatment relies on the production of a vascularized foreign-body membrane to support bone grafts over three times larger than the traditional maximum. Historically, the procedure has always utilized a bone cement spacer to evoke membrane production. However, membrane formation can easily be effected by implant surface properties such as material and topology. This study sought to determine if the membrane's mechanical or barrier properties are affected by changing the spacer material to titanium or roughening the surface finish. Ten-week-old, male Sprague Dawley rats were given an externally stabilized, 6 mm femur defect which was filled with a pre-made spacer of bone cement (PMMA) or titanium (TI) with a smooth (∼1 μm) or roughened (∼8 μm) finish. After 4 weeks of implantation, the membranes were harvested, and the matrix composition, tensile mechanics, shrinkage, and barrier function was assessed. Roughening the spacers resulted in significantly more compliant membranes. TI spacers created membranes that inhibited solute transport more. There were no differences between groups in collagen or elastin distribution. This suggests that different membrane characteristics can be created by altering the spacer surface properties. Surgeons may unknowingly effecting membrane formation via bone cement preparation techniques.

Altering spacer material affects bone regeneration in the Masquelet technique in a rat femoral defect

The Masquelet technique depends on pre-development of a foreign-body membrane to support bone regeneration with grafts over three times larger than the traditional maximum. To date, the procedure has always used spacers made of bone cement, which is the polymer polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA), to induce the foreign-body membrane. This study sought to compare (i) morphology, factor expression, and cellularity in membranes formed by PMMA, titanium, and polyvinyl alcohol sponge (PVA) spacers in the Masquelet milieu and (ii) subsequent bone regeneration in the same groups. Ten-week-old, male Sprague-Dawley rats were given an externally stabilized, 6 mm femur defect, and a pre-made spacer of PMMA, titanium, or PVA was implanted. All animals were given 4 weeks to form a membrane, and those receiving an isograft were given 10 weeks post-implantation to union. All samples were scanned with microCT to measure phase 1 and phase 2 bone formation. Membrane samples were processed for histology to measure membrane morphology, cellularity, and expression of the factors BMP2, TGFβ, VEGF, and IL6. PMMA and titanium spacers created almost identical membranes and phase 1 bone. PVA spacers were uniformly infiltrated with tissue and cells and did not form a distinct membrane. There were no quantitative differences in phase 2 bone formation. However, PMMA induced membranes supported functional union in 6 of 7 samples while a majority of titanium and PVA groups failed to achieve the same. Spacer material can alter the membrane enough to disrupt phase 2 bone formation. The membrane's role in bone regeneration is likely more than just as a physical barrier. © 2018 Orthopaedic Research Society. Published by Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Orthop Res.