Protein Footprinting by Carbenes on a Fast Photochemical Oxidation of Proteins (FPOP) Platform

Mass Spectrometry-Based Protein Footprinting for Protein Structure Characterization

Protein higher-order structure (HOS) is key to biological function because the mechanisms of protein machinery are encoded in protein three-dimensional structures. Mass spectrometry (MS)-based protein footprinting is advancing protein structure characterization by mapping solvent-accessible regions of proteins and changes in H-bonding, thereby providing higher order structural information. Footprinting provides insights into protein dynamics, conformational changes, and interactions, and when conducted in a differential way, can readily reveal those regions that undergo conformational change in response to perturbations such as ligand binding, mutation, thermal stress, or aggregation. Building on firsthand experience in developing and applying protein footprinting, we provide an account of our progress in method development and applications.In the development section, we describe fast footprinting with reactive reagents (free radicals, carbenes, carbocations) with emphasis on fast photochemical oxidation of proteins (FPOP). The rates of the modifying reactions are usually faster than protein folding/unfolding, ensuring that the chemistry captures the change without biasing the structural information. We then describe slow, specific side-chain labeling or slow footprinting and hydrogen-deuterium exchange (HDX) to provide context for fast footprinting and to show that, with validation, these modifications can deliver valid structural information. One advantage of slow footprinting is that usually no special apparatus (e.g., laser, synchrotron) is needed. We acknowledge that no single footprint is sufficient, and complementary approaches are needed for structure comparisons.In the second part, we cover several of our footprinting applications for the study of biotherapeutics, metal-bound proteins, aggregating (amyloid) proteins, and integral membrane proteins (IMPs). Solving structural problems in these four areas is often challenging for other high-resolution approaches, motivating the development of protein footprinting as a complementary approach. For example, obtaining structural data for the bound and unbound forms of a protein requires that both forms are amenable for 3D structure determination. For problems of this type, information on changes in structure often provides an answer. For amyloid proteins, structures of the starting state (monomer) and the final fibril state are obtainable by standard methods, but the important structures causing disease appear to be those of soluble oligomers that are beyond high-resolution approaches because the mix of structures is polydisperse in number and size. Moreover, the relevant structures are those that occur in cell or in vivo, not in vitro, ruling out many current methods that are not up to the demands of working in complex milieu. IMPs are another appropriate target because they are unstable in water (in the absence of membranes, detergents) and may not retain their HOS during the long signal averaging needed for standard tools. Furthermore, the structural changes occurring in membrane transport or induced by drug binding or other interactions, for example, resist high resolution determination.We provide here an account on MS-based footprinting, broadly describing its multifaceted development, applications, and challenges based on our first-hand experience in fast and slow footprinting and in HDX. The Account is intended for investigators contemplating the use of these tools. We hope to catalyze refinements in methods and applications through collaborative, cross-disciplinary research that involves organic and analytical chemists, material scientists, and structural biologists.

Using mass spectrometry-based methods to understand amyloid formation and inhibition of alpha-synuclein and amyloid beta

Amyloid fibrils, insoluble β-sheets structures that arise from protein misfolding, are associated with several neurodegenerative disorders. Many small molecules have been investigated to prevent amyloid fibrils from forming; however, there are currently no therapeutics to combat these diseases. Mass spectrometry (MS) is proving to be effective for studying the high order structure (HOS) of aggregating proteins and for determining structural changes accompanying protein-inhibitor interactions. When combined with native MS (nMS), gas-phase ion mobility, protein footprinting, and chemical cross-linking, MS can afford regional and sometimes amino acid spatial resolution of the aggregating protein. The spatial resolution is greater than typical low-resolution spectroscopic, calorimetric, and the traditional ThT fluorescence methods used in amyloid research today. High-resolution approaches can struggle when investigating protein aggregation, as the proteins exist as complex oligomeric mixtures of many sizes and several conformations or polymorphs. Thus, MS is positioned to complement both high- and low-resolution approaches to studying amyloid fibril formation and protein-inhibitor interactions. This review covers basics in MS paired with ion mobility, continuous hydrogen-deuterium exchange (continuous HDX), pulsed hydrogen-deuterium exchange (pulsed HDX), fast photochemical oxidation of proteins (FPOP) and other irreversible labeling methods, and chemical cross-linking. We then review the applications of these approaches to studying amyloid-prone proteins with a focus on amyloid beta and alpha-synuclein. Another focus is the determination of protein-inhibitor interactions. The expectation is that MS will bring new insights to amyloid formation and thereby play an important role to prevent their formation.

Characterization of Higher Order Structural Changes of a Thermally Stressed Monoclonal Antibody via Mass Spectrometry Footprinting and Other Biophysical Approaches

Characterizing changes in the higher order structure (HOS) of monoclonal antibodies upon stressed conditions is critical to gaining a better understanding of the product and process. One single biophysical approach may not be best suited to assess HOS comprehensively; thus, the synergy from multiple, complementary approaches improves characterization accuracy and resolution. In this study, we employed two mass spectrometry (MS )-based footprinting techniques, namely, fast photochemical oxidation of proteins (FPOP)-MS and hydrogen-deuterium exchange (HDX)-MS, supported by dynamic light scattering (DLS), differential scanning calorimetry (DSC), circular dichroism (CD), and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) to study changes to the HOS of a mAb upon thermal stress. The biophysical techniques report a nuanced characterization of the HOS in which CD detects no changes to the secondary or tertiary structure, yet DLS measurements show an increase in the hydrodynamic radius. DSC indicates that the stability decreases, and chemical or conformational changes accumulate with incubation time according to NMR. Furthermore, whereas HDX-MS does not indicate HOS changes, FPOP-MS footprinting reveals conformational changes at residue resolution for some amino acids. The local phenomena observed with FPOP-MS indicate that several residues show various patterns of degradation during thermal stress: no change, an increase in solvent exposure, and a biphasic response to solvent exposure. All evidences show that FPOP-MS efficiently resolves subtle structural changes and novel degradation pathways upon thermal stress treatment at residue-level resolution.

Workflow for Validating Specific Amino Acid Footprinting Reagents for Protein Higher Order Structure Elucidation

Protein footprinting mass spectrometry probes protein higher order structure and dynamics by labeling amino acid side-chains or backbone amides as a function of solvent accessibility. One category of footprinting uses residue-specific, irreversible covalent modifications, affording flexibility of sample processing for bottom-up analysis. Although several specific amino acid footprinting technologies are becoming established in structural proteomics, there remains a need to assess fundamental properties of new reagents before their application. Often, footprinting reagents are applied to complex or novel protein systems soon after their discovery and sometimes without a thorough investigation of potential downsides of the reagent. In this work, we assemble and test a validation workflow that utilizes cyclic peptides and a model protein to characterize benzoyl fluoride, a recently published, next-generation nucleophile footprinter. The workflow includes the characterization of potential side-chain reactive groups, reaction "quench" efficacies, reagent considerations and caveats (e.g., buffer pH), residue-specific kinetics compared to those of established reagents, and protein-wide characterization of modification sites with considerations for proteolysis. The proposed workflow serves as a starting point for improved footprinting reagent discovery, validation, and introduction, the aspects of which we recommend before applying to unknown protein systems.

Advances in Mass Spectrometry on Membrane Proteins

Understanding the higher-order structure of membrane proteins (MPs), which are vital for numerous biological processes, is crucial for comprehending their function. Although several biophysical approaches have been used to study the structure of MPs, limitations exist owing to the proteins' dynamic nature and heterogeneity. Mass spectrometry (MS) is emerging as a powerful tool for investigating membrane protein structure and dynamics. Studying MPs using MS, however, must meet several challenges including the lack of stability and solubility of MPs, the complexity of the protein-membrane system, and the difficulty of digestion and detection. To meet these challenges, recent advances in MS have engendered opportunities in resolving the dynamics and structures of MP. This article reviews achievements over the past few years that enable the study of MPs by MS. We first introduce recent advances in hydrogen deuterium exchange and native mass spectrometry for MPs and then focus on those footprinting methods that report on protein structure.

Structural mass spectrometry approaches to understand multidrug efflux systems

Multidrug efflux pumps are ubiquitous across both eukaryotes and prokaryotes, and have major implications in antimicrobial and multidrug resistance. They reside within cellular membranes and have proven difficult to study owing to their hydrophobic character and relationship with their compositionally complex lipid environment. Advances in structural mass spectrometry (MS) techniques have made it possible to study these systems to elucidate critical information on their structure-function relationships. For example, MS techniques can report on protein structural dynamics, stoichiometry, connectivity, solvent accessibility, and binding interactions with ligands, lipids, and other proteins. This information proving powerful when used in conjunction with complementary structural biology methods and molecular dynamics (MD) simulations. In the present review, aimed at those not experts in MS techniques, we report on the current uses of MS in studying multidrug efflux systems, practical considerations to consider, and the future direction of the field. In the first section, we highlight the importance of studying multidrug efflux proteins, and introduce a range of different MS techniques and explain what information they yield. In the second section, we review recent studies that have utilised MS techniques to study and characterise a range of different multidrug efflux systems.

Residue-Level Characterization of Antibody Binding Epitopes Using Carbene Chemical Footprinting

Characterization of antibody binding epitopes is an important factor in therapeutic drug discovery, as the binding site determines and drives antibody pharmacology and pharmacokinetics. Here, we present a novel application of carbene chemical footprinting with mass spectrometry for identification of antibody binding epitopes at the single-residue level. Two different photoactivated diazirine reagents provide complementary labeling information allowing structural refinement of the antibody binding interface. We applied this technique to map the epitopes of multiple MICA and CTLA-4 antibodies and validated the findings with X-ray crystallography and yeast surface display epitope mapping. The characterized epitopes were used to understand biolayer interferometry-derived competitive binding results at the structural level. We show that carbene footprinting provides fast and high-resolution epitope information critical in the antibody selection process and enables mechanistic understanding of function to accelerate the drug discovery process.

Top-Down Detection of Oxidative Protein Footprinting by Collision-Induced Dissociation, Electron-Transfer Dissociation, and Electron-Capture Dissociation

Fast photochemical oxidation of proteins (FPOP) footprinting is a structural mass spectrometry method that maps proteins by fast and irreversible chemical reactions. The position of oxidative modification reflects solvent accessibility and site reactivity and thus provides information about protein conformation, structural dynamics, and interactions. Bottom-up mass spectrometry is an established standard method to analyze FPOP samples. In the bottom-up approach, all forms of the protein are digested together by a protease of choice, which results in a mixture of peptides from various subpopulations of proteins with varying degrees of photochemical oxidation. Here, we investigate the possibility to analyze a specifically selected population of only singly oxidized proteins. This requires utilization of more specific top-down mass spectrometry approaches. The key element of any top-down experiment is the selection of a suitable method of ion isolation, excitation, and fragmentation. Here, we employ and compare collision-induced dissociation, electron-transfer dissociation, and electron-capture dissociation combined with multi-continuous accumulation of selected ions. A singly oxidized subpopulation of FPOP-labeled ubiquitin was used to optimize the method. The top-down approach in FPOP is limited to smaller proteins, but its usefulness was demonstrated by using it to visualize structural changes induced by co-factor removal from the holo/apo myoglobin system. The top-down data were compared with the literature and with the bottom-up data set obtained on the same samples. The top-down results were found to be in good agreement, which indicates that monitoring a singly oxidized FPOP ion population by the top-down approach is a functional workflow for oxidative protein footprinting.

Advances in mass spectrometry-based footprinting of membrane proteins

Structural biology is entering an exciting time where many new high-resolution structures of large complexes and membrane proteins (MPs) are determined regularly. These advances have been driven by over 15 years of technological improvements, first in macromolecular crystallography, and recently in cryo-electron microscopy. Obtaining information about MP higher order structure and interactions is also a frontier, important but challenging owing to their unique properties and the need to choose suitable detergents/lipids for their study. The development of mass spectrometry (MS), both instruments and methodology in the past 10 years, has also advanced it as a complementary method to study MP structure and interactions. In this review, we discuss advances in MS-based footprinting for MPs and highlight recent methodologies that offer new promise for MP study by chemical footprinting and mass spectrometry.

Utilization of Fast Photochemical Oxidation of Proteins and Both Bottom-up and Top-down Mass Spectrometry for Structural Characterization of a Transcription Factor-dsDNA Complex

A combination of covalent labeling techniques and mass spectrometry (MS) is currently a progressive approach for deriving insights related to the mapping of protein surfaces or protein-ligand interactions. In this study, we mapped an interaction interface between the DNA binding domain (DBD) of FOXO4 protein and the DNA binding element (DAF16) using fast photochemical oxidation of proteins (FPOP). Residues involved in protein-DNA interaction were identified using the bottom-up approach. To confirm the findings and avoid a misinterpretation of the obtained data, caused by possible multiple radical oxidations leading to the protein surface alteration and oxidation of deeply buried amino acid residues, a top-down approach was employed for the first time in FPOP analysis. An isolation of singly oxidized ions enabled their gas-phase separation from multiply oxidized species followed by CID and ECD fragmentation. Application of both fragmentation techniques allowed generation of complementary fragment sets, out of which the regions shielded in the presence of DNA were deduced. The findings obtained by bottom-up and top-down approaches were highly consistent. Finally, FPOP results were compared with those of the HDX study of the FOXO4-DBD·DAF16 complex. No contradictions were found between the methods. Moreover, their combination provides complementary information related to the structure and dynamics of the protein-DNA complex. Data are available via ProteomeXchange with identifier PXD027624.

Fast Fluoroalkylation of Proteins Uncovers the Structure and Dynamics of Biological Macromolecules

Covalent labeling of proteins in combination with mass spectrometry has been established as a complementary technique to classical structural methods, such as X-ray, NMR, or cryogenic electron microscopy (Cryo-EM), used for protein structure determination. Although the current covalent labeling techniques enable the protein solvent accessible areas with sufficient spatial resolution to be monitored, there is still high demand for alternative, less complicated, and inexpensive approaches. Here, we introduce a new covalent labeling method based on fast fluoroalkylation of proteins (FFAP). FFAP uses fluoroalkyl radicals formed by reductive decomposition of Togni reagents with ascorbic acid to label proteins on a time scale of seconds. The feasibility of FFAP to effectively label proteins was demonstrated by monitoring the differential amino acids modification of native horse heart apomyoglobin/holomyoglobin and the human haptoglobin-hemoglobin complex. The obtained data confirmed the Togni reagent-mediated FFAP is an advantageous alternative method for covalent labeling in applications such as protein footprinting and epitope mapping of proteins (and their complexes) in general. Data are accessible via the ProteomeXchange server with the data set identifier PXD027310.

Carbocation Footprinting of Soluble and Transmembrane Proteins

Here, we introduce carbocations (R3C+) as laser-initiated footprinting reagents for proteins. We screened seven candidates and selected trifluomethoxy benzyl bromide (TFBB) as an effective precursor for the electrophilic trifluomethoxy benzyl carbocation (TFB+) under laser (248 nm) irradiation on the fast photochemical oxidation of proteins (FPOP) platform. Initial results demonstrate that this electrophilic cation reagent affords residue coverage of nucleophilic amino acids including H, W, M, and S. Further, the addition of TFB+ increases the hydrophobicity of the peptides so that separation of isomeric peptide products by reversed-phase LC is improved, suggesting opportunities for subresidue footprinting. Comparison of apo- and holo-myoglobin footprints shows that the TFB+ footprinting is sensitive to protein conformational change and solvent accessibility. Interestingly, because the TFB+ is amphiphilic, the reagent can potentially footprint membrane proteins as demonstrated for vitamin K epoxide reductase (VKOR) stabilized in a micelle. Not only does footprinting of the extra-membrane domain occur, but also some footprinting of the hydrophobic transmembrane domain is achieved owing to the interaction of TFB+ with the micelle. Carbocation precursors are stable and amenable for tailoring their properties and those of the incipient carbocation, enabling targeting their soluble or membrane-associated or embedded regions and distinguishing between the extra- and trans-membrane domains of membrane proteins.

Flash Oxidation (FOX) System: A Novel Laser-Free Fast Photochemical Oxidation Protein Footprinting Platform

Hydroxyl radical protein footprinting (HRPF) is a powerful and flexible technique for probing changes in protein topography. With the development of the fast photochemical oxidation of proteins (FPOP), it became possible for researchers to perform HRPF in their laboratory on a very short time scale. While FPOP has grown significantly in popularity since its inception, adoption remains limited due to technical and safety issues involved in the operation of a hazardous Class IV UV laser and irreproducibility often caused by improper laser operation and/or differential radical scavenging by various sample components. Here, we present a new integrated FOX (Flash OXidation) Protein Footprinting System. This platform delivers sample via flow injection to a facile and safe-to-use high-pressure flash lamp with a flash duration of 10 μs fwhm. Integrated optics collect the radiant light and focus it into the lumen of a capillary flow cell. An inline radical dosimeter measures the hydroxyl radical dose delivered and allows for real-time compensation for differential radical scavenging. A programmable fraction collector collects and quenches only the sample that received the desired effective hydroxyl radical dose, diverting the carrier liquid and improperly oxidized sample to waste. We demonstrate the utility of the FOX Protein Footprinting System by determining the epitope of TNFα recognized by adalimumab. We successfully identify the surface of the protein that serves as the epitope for adalimumab, identifying four of the five regions previously noted by X-ray crystallography while seeing no changes in peptides not involved in the epitope interface. The FOX Protein Footprinting System allows for FPOP-like experiments with real-time dosimetry in a safe, compact, and integrated benchtop platform.

Protein higher-order-structure determination by fast photochemical oxidation of proteins and mass spectrometry analysis

The higher-order structure (HOS) of proteins plays a critical role in their function; therefore, it is important to our understanding of their function that we have as much information as possible about their three-dimensional structure and how it changes with time. Mass spectrometry (MS) has become an important tool for determining protein HOS owing to its high throughput, mid-to-high spatial resolution, low sample amount requirement and broad compatibility with various protein systems. Modern MS-based protein HOS analysis relies, in part, on footprinting, where a reagent reacts 'to mark' the solvent-accessible surface of the protein, and MS-enabled proteomic analysis locates the modifications to afford a footprint. Fast photochemical oxidation of proteins (FPOP), first introduced in 2005, has become a powerful approach for protein footprinting. Laser-induced hydrogen peroxide photolysis generates hydroxyl radicals that react with solvent-accessible side chains (14 out of 20 amino acid side chains) to fulfill the footprinting. The reaction takes place at sub-milliseconds, faster than most of labeling-induced protein conformational changes, thus enabling a 'snapshot' of protein HOS in solution. As a result, FPOP has been employed in solving several important problems, including mapping epitopes, following protein aggregation, locating small molecule binding, measuring ligand-binding affinity, monitoring protein folding and unfolding and determining hidden conformational changes invisible to other methods. Broader adoption will be promoted by dissemination of the technical details for assembling the FPOP platform and for dealing with the complexities of analyzing FPOP data. In this protocol, we describe the FPOP platform, the conditions for successful footprinting and its examination by mass measurements of the intact protein, the post-labeling sample handling and digestion, the liquid chromatography-tandem MS analysis of the digested sample and the data analysis with Protein Metrics Suite. This protocol is intended not only as a guide for investigators trying to establish an FPOP platform in their own lab but also for those willing to incorporate FPOP as an additional tool in addressing their questions of interest.

Mass Spectrometry-Based Protein Footprinting for Higher-Order Structure Analysis: Fundamentals and Applications

Proteins adopt different higher-order structures (HOS) to enable their unique biological functions. Understanding the complexities of protein higher-order structures and dynamics requires integrated approaches, where mass spectrometry (MS) is now positioned to play a key role. One of those approaches is protein footprinting. Although the initial demonstration of footprinting was for the HOS determination of protein/nucleic acid binding, the concept was later adapted to MS-based protein HOS analysis, through which different covalent labeling approaches "mark" the solvent accessible surface area (SASA) of proteins to reflect protein HOS. Hydrogen-deuterium exchange (HDX), where deuterium in D2O replaces hydrogen of the backbone amides, is the most common example of footprinting. Its advantage is that the footprint reflects SASA and hydrogen bonding, whereas one drawback is the labeling is reversible. Another example of footprinting is slow irreversible labeling of functional groups on amino acid side chains by targeted reagents with high specificity, probing structural changes at selected sites. A third footprinting approach is by reactions with fast, irreversible labeling species that are highly reactive and footprint broadly several amino acid residue side chains on the time scale of submilliseconds. All of these covalent labeling approaches combine to constitute a problem-solving toolbox that enables mass spectrometry as a valuable tool for HOS elucidation. As there has been a growing need for MS-based protein footprinting in both academia and industry owing to its high throughput capability, prompt availability, and high spatial resolution, we present a summary of the history, descriptions, principles, mechanisms, and applications of these covalent labeling approaches. Moreover, their applications are highlighted according to the biological questions they can answer. This review is intended as a tutorial for MS-based protein HOS elucidation and as a reference for investigators seeking a MS-based tool to address structural questions in protein science.

Fast Protein Footprinting by X-ray Mediated Radical Trifluoromethylation

Synchrotron radiolysis generates hydroxyl radicals (^•OH) that are successful footprinting reagents. Here, we describe a new reagent for the synchrotron platform, the trifluoromethyl radical (^•CF₃). The radical is produced by ^•OH displacement of ^•CF₃ from sodium triflinate (Langlois reagent). Upon X-ray beam exposure, the reagent labels proteins extensively without any additional chemicals on a millisecond or shorter time scale. The ^•CF₃ is comparably reactive to ^•OH and produces footprinting information that complements that of ^•OH alone. This reagent in combination with ^•OH should enable novel chemistry for protein footprinting on the synchrotron platform.

Evaluation of NHS-Acetate and DEPC labelling for determination of solvent accessible amino acid residues in protein complexes

The activity of most proteins and protein complexes relies on the formation of defined three-dimensional structures. The analysis of these arrangements is therefore key for understanding their function and regulation in the cell. Besides the traditional structural techniques, structural mass spectrometry delivers insights into the various aspects of protein structure, including stoichiometry, protein-ligand interactions and solvent accessibility. The latter is usually obtained from labelling experiments. In this study, we evaluate two chemical labelling strategies using N-hydroxysuccinimidyl acetate and diethylpyrocarbonate as labelling reagents. We characterised the mass spectra of modified peptides and assessed labelling reactivity of individual amino acid residues in intact proteins. Importantly, we uncovered neutral losses from diethylpyrocarbonate modified amino acids improving the assignments of the peptide fragment spectra. We further established a quantitative labelling workflow to determine labelling percentage and unambiguously distinguish solvent accessible amino acid residues from stochastically labelled residues. Finally, we used ion mobility MS to explore whether labelled proteins maintain their structures and remain stable. We conclude that labelling using N-hydroxysuccinimidyl acetate and diethylpyrocarbonate delivers comparable results, however, N-hydroxysuccinimidyl acetate labelling is compatible with standard proteomic workflows while diethylpyrocarbonate labelling requires specialised experimental conditions and data analysis. SIGNIFICANCE: Covalent labelling is widely used to identify solvent accessible amino acid residues of proteins or protein complexes. However, with increasing sensitivity of available MS instrumentation, a high number of modified residues is usually observed making an unambiguous assignment of solvent accessible residues necessary. In this study, we establish a quantitative labelling workflow for two different labelling strategies to identify accessible amino acid residues. In addition, we characterise observed mass spectra of modified peptides and identified neutral loss of DEPC modified amino acid residues during HCD fragmentation improving their assignments.

The Application of Fluorine-Containing Reagents in Structural Proteomics

Structural proteomics refers to large-scale mapping of protein structures in order to understand the relationship between protein sequence, structure, and function. Chemical labeling, in combination with mass-spectrometry (MS) analysis, have emerged as powerful tools to enable a broad range of biological applications in structural proteomics. The key to success is a biocompatible reagent that modifies a protein without affecting its high-order structure. Fluorine, well-known to exert profound effects on the physical and chemical properties of reagents, should have an impact on structural proteomics. In this Minireview, we describe several fluorine-containing reagents that can be applied in structural proteomics. We organize their applications around four MS-based techniques: a) affinity labeling, b) activity-based protein profiling (ABPP), c) protein footprinting, and d) protein cross-linking. Our aim is to provide an overview of the research, development, and application of fluorine-containing reagents in protein structural studies.

Subresidue-Resolution Footprinting of Ligand-Protein Interactions by Carbene Chemistry and Ion Mobility-Mass Spectrometry

The knowledge of ligand-protein interactions is essential for understanding fundamental biological processes and for the rational design of drugs that target such processes. Carbene footprinting efficiently labels proteinaceous residues and has been used with mass spectrometry (MS) to map ligand-protein interactions. Nevertheless, previous footprinting studies are typically performed at the residue level, and therefore, the resolution may not be high enough to couple with conventional crystallography techniques. Herein we developed a subresidue footprinting strategy based on the discovery that carbene labeling produces subresidue peptide isomers and the intensity changes of these isomers in response to ligand binding can be exploited to delineate ligand-protein topography at the subresidue level. The established workflow combines carbene footprinting, extended liquid chromatographic separation, and ion mobility (IM)-MS for efficient separation and identification of subresidue isomers. Analysis of representative subresidue isomers located within the binding cleft of lysozyme and those produced from an amyloid-β segment have both uncovered structural information heretofore unavailable by residue-level footprinting. Lastly, a "real-world" application shows that the reactivity changes of subresidue isomers at Phe399 can identify the interactive nuances between estrogen-related receptor α, a potential drug target for cancer and metabolic diseases, with its three ligands. These findings have significant implications for drug design. Taken together, we envision the subresidue-level resolution enabled by IM-MS-coupled carbene footprinting can bridge the gap between structural MS and the more-established biophysical tools and ultimately facilitate diverse applications for fundamental research and pharmaceutical development.

Composite Conformational Changes of Signaling Proteins upon Ligand Binding Revealed by a Single Approach: Calcium-Calmodulin Study

Signaling proteins exemplified by calmodulin usually bind cooperatively to multiple ligands. Intermediate states and allosteric behavior are difficult to characterize. Here we extend a recently reported mass spectrometry (MS)-based method named LITPOMS (ligand titration, fast photochemical oxidation of proteins and mass spectrometry) that characterizes complex binding systems typically found as signaling proteins. As reported previously, calmodulin's response to binding four Ca²⁺ can be determined by LITPOMS to reveal binding sites, binding order, and most importantly composite binding behavior. Modeling this behavior provides site-specific binding affinities. In this article, we dissect the composite, peptide-level conformational changes at several regions either by digestion with a different protease or by tandem MS of LITPOMS behavior at the amino-acid residue level. Such dissection greatly elevates spatial resolution and increases the confidence of binding-order assignment. These complementary views of complex protein conformational change recapitulate the cumulative understanding via a single approach, providing new insights on poorly understood yet important allostery and underpin an approach applicable for exploring other signaling systems.

Fast photochemical oxidation of proteins (FPOP): A powerful mass spectrometry-based structural proteomics tool

Fast photochemical oxidation of proteins (FPOP) is a MS-based method that has proved useful in studies of protein structures, interactions, conformations, and protein folding. The success of this method relies on the irreversible labeling of solvent-exposed amino acid side chains by hydroxyl radicals. FPOP generates these radicals through laser-induced photolysis of hydrogen peroxide. The data obtained provide residue-level resolution of protein structures and interactions on the microsecond timescale, enabling investigations of fast processes such as protein folding and weak protein-protein interactions. An extensive comparison between FPOP and other footprinting techniques gives insight on their complementarity as well as the robustness of FPOP to provide unique structural information once unattainable. The versatility of this method is evidenced by both the heterogeneity of samples that can be analyzed by FPOP and the myriad of applications for which the method has been successfully used: from proteins of varying size to intact cells. This review discusses the wide applications of this technique and highlights its high potential. Applications including, but not limited to, protein folding, membrane proteins, structure elucidation, and epitope mapping are showcased. Furthermore, the use of FPOP has been extended to probing proteins in cells and in vivo These promising developments are also presented herein.

A Single Approach Reveals the Composite Conformational Changes, Order of Binding, and Affinities for Calcium Binding to Calmodulin

We found that a newly developed method named LITPOMS (ligand titration, fast photochemical oxidation of proteins and mass spectrometry) can characterize section-by-section of a protein the conformational changes induced by metal-ion binding. Peptide-level LITPOMS applied to Ca²⁺ binding to calmodulin reveals binding order and site-specific affinity, providing new insights on the behavior of proteins upon binding Ca²⁺. We established that EF hand-4 (EF-4) binds calcium first, followed by EF-3, EF-2, and EF-1 and determined the four affinity constants by modeling the extent-of-modification curves. We also found positive cooperativity between EF-4, EF-3 and EF-2, EF-1 and allostery involving the four EF-hands. LITPOMS recapitulates via one approach the calcium-calmodulin binding that required decades of sophisticated development to afford versatility, comprehensiveness, and outstanding spatial resolution.

Fast Photochemical Oxidation of Proteins Coupled with Mass Spectrometry

BACKGROUND

Determination of the composition and some structural features of macromolecules can be achieved by using structural proteomics approaches coupled with mass spectrometry (MS). One approach is hydroxyl radical protein footprinting whereby amino-acid side chains are modified with reactive reagents to modify irreversibly a protein side chain. The outcomes, when deciphered with mass-spectrometry-based proteomics, can increase our knowledge of structure, assembly, and conformational dynamics of macromolecules in solution. Generating the hydroxyl radicals by laser irradiation, Hambly and Gross developed the approach of Fast Photochemical Oxidation of Proteins (FPOP), which labels proteins on the sub millisecond time scale and provides, with MS analysis, deeper understanding of protein structure and protein-ligand and protein- protein interactions. This review highlights the fundamentals of FPOP and provides descriptions of hydroxyl-radical and other radical and carbene generation, of the hydroxyl labeling of proteins, and of determination of protein modification sites. We also summarize some recent applications of FPOP coupled with MS in protein footprinting.

CONCLUSION

We survey results that show the capability of FPOP for qualitatively measuring protein solvent accessibility on the residue level. To make these approaches more valuable, we describe recent method developments that increase FPOP's quantitative capacity and increase the spatial protein sequence coverage. To improve FPOP further, several new labeling reagents including carbenes and other radicals have been developed. These growing improvements will allow oxidative- footprinting methods coupled with MS to play an increasingly significant role in determining the structure and dynamics of macromolecules and their assemblies.

A Fast Photochemical Oxidation of Proteins (FPOP) platform for free-radical reactions: the carbonate radical anion with peptides and proteins

Fast Photochemical Oxidation of Protein (FPOP), based on a pulsed KrF laser (248 nm) for free-radical generation, is a biophysical method that utilizes hydroxyl radicals to footprint proteins in solution. FPOP has been recognized for structural proteomics investigations, including epitope mapping, protein-aggregation characterization, protein-folding monitoring, and binding-affinity determination. The distinct merits of the platform are: i) the use of a scavenger to control radical lifetime and allow fast ("snapshot") footprinting of solvent-accessible residues in a protein; ii) the employment of a flow system to enable single-shot irradiation of small plugs of the targeted sample; iii) the use of methionine and catalase after radical oxidation chemistry to prevent post-oxidation with residual oxidizing species; and iv) the utilization of mature mass spectrometry-based proteomic methods to afford detailed analysis. In addition to ^•OH, other reactive reagents (e.g., carbenes, iodide, sulfate radical anion, and trifluoromethyl radical) can be implemented on this platform to increase the versatility and scope. In this study, we further elaborate the use of FPOP platform to generate secondary radicals and establish a workflow to answer fundamental questions regarding the intrinsic selectivity and reactivity of radicals that are important in biology. Carbonate radical anion is the example we chose owing to its oxidative character and important putative pathogenic roles in inflammation. This systematic study with model proteins/peptides gives consistent results with a previous study that evaluated reactivity with free amino acids and shows that methionine and tryptophan are the most reactive residues with CO₃^-•. Other aromatic amino acids (i.e., tyrosine, histidine and phenylalanine) exhibit moderate reactivity, whereas, aliphatic amino acids are inert, unlike with ^•OH. The outcome demonstrates this approach to be appropriate for studying the fast reactions of radicals with proteins.

Protein-Ligand Interaction by Ligand Titration, Fast Photochemical Oxidation of Proteins and Mass Spectrometry: LITPOMS

We report a novel method named LITPOMS (ligand titration, fast photochemical oxidation of proteins and mass spectrometry) to characterize protein-ligand binding stoichiometry, binding sites, and site-specific binding constants. The system used to test the method is melittin-calmodulin, in which the peptide melittin binds to calcium-bound calmodulin. Global-level measurements reveal the binding stoichiometry of 1:1 whereas peptide-level data coupled with fitting reveal the binding sites and the site-specific binding affinity. Moreover, we extended the analysis to the residue level and identified six critical binding residues. The results show that melittin binds to the N-terminal, central linker, and C-terminal regions of holo-calmodulin with an affinity of 4.6 nM, in agreement with results of previous studies. LITPOMS, for the first time, brings high residue-level resolution to affinity measurements, providing simultaneously qualitative and quantitative understanding of protein-ligand binding. The approach can be expanded to other binding systems without tagging the protein to give high spatial resolution. Graphical Abstract.

Protein-Metal-Ion Interactions Studied by Mass Spectrometry-Based Footprinting with Isotope-Encoded Benzhydrazide

Metal ions, usually bound by various amino-acid side chains in proteins, play multiple roles in protein folding, conformational change, cellular communication, and catalysis. Ca(II) and Mg(II), abundant among biologically relevant cations, execute their cellular functions associated with the conformational change of bound proteins. They bind with proteins where carboxylic acid residues are dominant ligands. To develop mass spectrometry for mapping protein-binding sites, we implemented a new carboxyl group footprinter, benzhydrazide, and refined it with isotope encoding. The method uses carbodiimide chemistry to footprint carboxylic residues, whereby 1-ethyl-3-(3-(dimethylamino)propyl)carbodiimide activates a carboxyl group followed by nucleophilic attack by benzhydrazide forming a stable labeled product. We tested the effectiveness of isotope-encoded benzhydrazide by studying Ca²⁺ and Mg²⁺ binding of calmodulin, an EF-hand protein. The footprinting results indicate that the four active sites for metal-ion binding (EF hands I, II, III, and IV) and the linker region (peptide 78-86) undergo conformational changes upon Ca(II) and Mg(II) binding, respectively. The outcome is consistent with previously reported results and 3-D structures, thereby validating a new reagent that is more reactive and discriminating for specific amino-acid protein footprinting. This reagent should be important for locating metal-binding sites of other metalloproteins.

Towards high-throughput fast photochemical oxidation of proteins: Quantifying exposure in high fluence microtiter plate photolysis

Protein structural analysis by mass spectrometry has gained significant popularity in recent years, including high-resolution protein topographical mapping by fast photochemical oxidation of proteins (FPOP). The ability to provide protein topographical information at moderate spatial resolution makes FPOP an attractive technology for the protein pharmaceutical discovery and development processes. However, current technology limits the throughput and requires significant manual sample manipulation. Similarly, as FPOP is being used on larger samples, sample flow through the capillary becomes challenging. No systematic comparison of the performance of static flash photolysis with traditional flow FPOP has been reported. Here, we evaluate a 96-well microtiter-based laser flash photolysis method for the topographical probing of proteins, which subsequently could be used to analyze higher order structure of the protein in a high-throughput fashion with minimal manual sample manipulation. We used multiple metrics to compare microtiter FPOP performance with that of traditional flow FPOP: adenine-based hydroxyl radical dosimetry, oxidation efficiency of a model peptide, and hydroxyl radical protein footprint of myoglobin. In all cases, microtiter plate FPOP performed comparably with traditional flow FPOP, requiring a small fraction of the time for exposure. This greatly reduced sample exposure time, coupled with automated sample handling in 96-well microtiter plates, makes microtiter-based FPOP an important step in achieving the throughput required to adapt hydroxyl radical protein footprinting for screening purposes.

Covalent labeling-mass spectrometry with non-specific reagents for studying protein structure and interactions

Using mass spectrometry (MS) to obtain information about a higher order structure of protein requires that a protein's structural properties are encoded into the mass of that protein. Covalent labeling (CL) with reagents that can irreversibly modify solvent accessible amino acid side chains is an effective way to encode structural information into the mass of a protein, as this information can be read-out in a straightforward manner using standard MS-based proteomics techniques. The differential reactivity of proteins under two or more conditions can be used to distinguish protein topologies, conformations, and/or binding sites. CL-MS methods have been effectively used for the structural analysis of proteins and protein complexes, particularly for systems that are difficult to study by other more traditional biochemical techniques. This review provides an overview of the non-specific CL approaches that have been combined with MS with a particular emphasis on the reagents that are commonly used, including hydroxyl radicals, carbenes, and diethylpyrocarbonate. We describe the reagent and protein factors that affect the reactivity of amino acid side chains. We also include details about experimental design and workflow, data analysis, recent applications, and some future prospects of CL-MS methods.

Implementing fast photochemical oxidation of proteins (FPOP) as a footprinting approach to solve diverse problems in structural biology

Fast photochemical oxidation of proteins (FPOP) is a footprinting technique used in mass spectrometry-based structural proteomics. It has been applied to solve a variety of problems in different areas of biology. A FPOP platform requires a laser, optics, and sample flow path properly assembled to enable fast footprinting. Sample preparation, buffer conditions, and reagent concentrations are essential to obtain reasonable oxidations on proteins. FPOP samples can be analyzed by LC-MS methods to measure the modification extent, which is a function of the solvent-accessible surface area of the protein. The platform can be expanded to accommodate several new approaches, including dose-response studies, new footprinting reagents, and two-laser pump-probe experiments. Here, we briefly review FPOP applications and in a detailed manner describe the procedures to set up an FPOP protein footprinting platform.

High-Resolution Hydroxyl Radical Protein Footprinting: Biophysics Tool for Drug Discovery

Hydroxyl radical footprinting (HRF) of proteins with mass spectrometry (MS) is a widespread approach for assessing protein structure. Hydroxyl radicals react with a wide variety of protein side chains, and the ease with which radicals can be generated (by radiolysis or photolysis) has made the approach popular with many laboratories. As some side chains are less reactive and thus cannot be probed, additional specific and nonspecific labeling reagents have been introduced to extend the approach. At the same time, advances in liquid chromatography and MS approaches permit an examination of the labeling of individual residues, transforming the approach to high resolution. Lastly, advances in understanding of the chemistry of the approach have led to the determination of absolute protein topologies from HRF data. Overall, the technology can provide precise and accurate measures of side-chain solvent accessibility in a wide range of interesting and useful contexts for the study of protein structure and dynamics in both academia and industry.

Mass Spectrometry-Based Fast Photochemical Oxidation of Proteins (FPOP) for Higher Order Structure Characterization

Assessment of protein structure and interaction is crucial for understanding protein structure/function relationships. Compared to high-resolution structural tools, including X-ray crystallography, nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR), and cryo-EM, and traditional low-resolution methods, such as circular dichroism, UV-vis, and florescence spectroscopy, mass spectrometry (MS)-based protein footprinting affords medium-to-high resolution (i.e., regional and residue-specific insights) by taking advantage of proteomics methods focused on the primary structure. The methodology relies on "painting" the reactive and solvent-exposed amino acid residues with chemical tags and using the pattern of modifications as footprints from analysis by bottom-up MS-based proteomics to deduce protein higher order structures. The outcome can refer to proteins in solution or even in cells and is complementary to those of X-ray crystallography and NMR. It is particularly useful in mapping protein-ligand interfaces and conformational changes resulting from ligand binding, mutation, and aggregation. Fast photochemical oxidation of proteins (FPOP), in its original conception, is a type of hydroxyl-radical-based protein footprinting that utilizes a pulsed KrF laser (248 nm) to trigger hydrolysis of hydrogen peroxide to produce solution hydroxyl radicals, which subsequently modify the protein in situ. The platform is expanding to adopt other reactive species including carbenes. The reactivity of the probe depends on the intrinsic reactivity of the radical with the residue side chain and the solvent accessibility of the residue as a function of the tertiary/quaternary structures. By introducing an appropriate scavenger to compete with hydroxyl radical self-quenching, the lifetime of the primary radicals is remarkably shortened to approximately microsecond. Thus, the sampling time scale of FPOP is much faster than hydrogen-deuterium exchange and other covalent labeling methods relying on nonradical reactions. The short footprinting time scale of FPOP offers two major advantages for protein structure elucidation: (1) it allows the protein to be interrogated in its native or near-native state with minimum structural perturbation; (2) it exhibits high sensitivity toward alterations in protein higher order structures because its sampling time is short with respect to protein conformational changes and dynamic motion. In addition, the covalent and irreversible oxidation by the hydroxyl radical provides more flexibility in the downstream proteomics workflow and MS analysis, permitting high spatial resolution with residue-specific information. Since its invention in 2005 by Hambly and Gross, FPOP has developed from proof-of-concept to a valuable biophysical tool for interrogating protein structure. In this Account, we summarize the principles and experimental design of FPOP that enable its fast labeling and describe the current and unique capabilities of the technique in protein higher order structure elucidation. Application examples include characterization of amyloid β self-assembly, protein-ligand interactions with a special emphasis on epitope mapping for protein therapeutics (e.g., antibody, Fab, and adnectin), protein folding detailed to residue-specific folding kinetics, and protein flexibility/dynamics. Additionally, the utility of FPOP-based oxidative footprinting should grow with our continuing developments of novel reagents (e.g., sulfate radical anion, carbene diradical, and trifluoromethyl radical). These reactive reagents are compatible with the current FPOP platform and offer different reactivity and selectivity toward various types of amino acid residues, providing complementary insights into protein higher order structures for soluble proteins and ultimately for membrane-bound proteins.

Laser-Initiated Radical Trifluoromethylation of Peptides and Proteins: Application to Mass-Spectrometry-Based Protein Footprinting

Described is a novel, laser-initiated radical trifluoromethylation for protein footprinting and its broad residue coverage. ^. CF₃ reacts with 18 of the 20 common amino acids, including Gly, Ala, Ser, Thr, Asp, and Glu, which are relatively silent with regard to ^. OH. This new approach to footprinting is a bridge between trifluoromethylation in materials and medicinal chemistry and structural biology and biotechnology. Its application to a membrane protein and to myoglobin show that the approach is sensitive to protein conformational change and solvent accessibility.

Amino Acid Insertion Frequencies Arising from Photoproducts Generated Using Aliphatic Diazirines

Mapping proteins with chemical reagents and mass spectrometry can generate a measure of accessible surface area, which in turn can be used to support the modeling and refinement of protein structures. Photolytically generated carbenes are a promising class of reagent for this purpose. Substituent effects appear to influence surface mapping properties, allowing for a useful measure of design control. However, to use carbene labeling data in a quantitative manner for modeling activities, we require a better understanding of their inherent amino acid reactivity, so that incorporation data can be normalized. The current study presents an analysis of the amino acid insertion frequency of aliphatic carbenes generated by the photolysis of three different diazirines: 3,3'-azibutyl-1-ammonium, 3,3'-azibutan-1-ol, and 4,4'-azipentan-1-oate. Leveraging an improved photolysis system for single-shot labeling of sub-microliter frozen samples, we used EThCD to localize insertion products in a large population of labeled peptides. Counting statistics were drawn from data-dependent LC-MS² experiments and used to estimate the frequencies of insertion as a function of amino acid. We observed labeling of all 20 amino acids over a remarkably narrow range of insertion frequencies. However, the nature of the substituent could influence relative insertion frequencies, within a general preference for larger polar amino acids. We confirm a large (6-fold) increase in labeling yield when carbenes were photogenerated in the solid phase (77 K) relative to the liquid phase (293 K), and we suggest that carbene labeling should always be conducted in the frozen state to avoid information loss in surface mapping experiments. Graphical Abstract ᅟ.

Topological Dissection of the Membrane Transport Protein Mhp1 Derived from Cysteine Accessibility and Mass Spectrometry

Cys accessibility and quantitative intact mass spectrometry (MS) analyses have been devised to study the topological transitions of Mhp1, the membrane protein for sodium-linked transport of hydantoins from Microbacterium liquefaciens. Mhp1 has been crystallized in three forms (outward-facing open, outward-facing occluded with substrate bound, and inward-facing open). We show that one natural cysteine residue, Cys327, out of three, has an enhanced solvent accessibility in the inward-facing (relative to the outward-facing) form. Reaction of the purified protein, in detergent, with the thiol-reactive N-ethylmalemide (NEM), results in modification of Cys327, suggesting that Mhp1 adopts predominantly inward-facing conformations. Addition of either sodium ions or the substrate 5-benzyl-l-hydantoin (L-BH) does not shift this conformational equilibrium, but systematic co-addition of the two results in an attenuation of labeling, indicating a shift toward outward-facing conformations that can be interpreted using conventional enzyme kinetic analyses. Such measurements can afford the Km for each ligand as well as the stoichiometry of ion-substrate-coupled conformational changes. Mutations that perturb the substrate binding site either result in the protein being unable to adopt outward-facing conformations or in a global destabilization of structure. The methodology combines covalent labeling, mass spectrometry, and kinetic analyses in a straightforward workflow applicable to a range of systems, enabling the interrogation of changes in a protein's conformation required for function at varied concentrations of substrates, and the consequences of mutations on these conformational transitions.

Protein Footprinting Comes of Age: Mass Spectrometry for Biophysical Structure Assessment

Protein footprinting mediated by mass spectrometry has evolved over the last 30 years from proof of concept to commonplace biophysics tool, with unique capabilities for assessing structure and dynamics of purified proteins in physiological states in solution. This review outlines the history and current capabilities of two major methods of protein footprinting: reversible hydrogen-deuterium exchange (HDX) and hydroxyl radical footprinting (HRF), an irreversible covalent labeling approach. Technological advances in both approaches now permit high-resolution assessments of protein structure including secondary and tertiary structure stability mediated by backbone interactions (measured via HDX) and solvent accessibility of side chains (measured via HRF). Applications across many academic fields and in biotechnology drug development are illustrated including: detection of protein interfaces, identification of ligand/drug binding sites, and monitoring dynamics of protein conformational changes along with future prospects for advancement of protein footprinting in structural biology and biophysics research.

Carbene footprinting accurately maps binding sites in protein-ligand and protein-protein interactions

Specific interactions between proteins and their binding partners are fundamental to life processes. The ability to detect protein complexes, and map their sites of binding, is crucial to understanding basic biology at the molecular level. Methods that employ sensitive analytical techniques such as mass spectrometry have the potential to provide valuable insights with very little material and on short time scales. Here we present a differential protein footprinting technique employing an efficient photo-activated probe for use with mass spectrometry. Using this methodology the location of a carbohydrate substrate was accurately mapped to the binding cleft of lysozyme, and in a more complex example, the interactions between a 100 kDa, multi-domain deubiquitinating enzyme, USP5 and a diubiquitin substrate were located to different functional domains. The much improved properties of this probe make carbene footprinting a viable method for rapid and accurate identification of protein binding sites utilizing benign, near-UV photoactivation.

Mapping protein-ligand interactions is fundamental to advance the understanding of cellular processes and to develop drug discovery strategies. Here, the authors present a photo-activated probe that allows highly efficient labelling and identification of protein binding sites using mass spectrometry.